1: %\documentclass{aastex}
2:
3: %% preprint produces a one-column, single-spaced document:
4: %% preprint2 produces a double-column, single-spaced document:
5:
6: %\documentclass[preprint]{aastex}
7: \documentclass[preprint2]{aastex}
8: %\documentclass[referee]{aastex}
9:
10: \newcommand{\vdag}{(v)^\dagger}
11: \newcommand{\myemail}{skywalker@galaxy.far.far.away}
12:
13: %% You can insert a short comment on the title page using the command below.
14:
15: \slugcomment{To appear in Astrophys. Journal}
16:
17: \shorttitle{H$\alpha$ Velocity Mapping of the Stephan's Quintet}
18: \shortauthors{C. M. Gutierrez et al.}
19:
20:
21: %% This is the end of the preamble. Indicate the beginning of the
22: %% paper itself with \begin{document}.
23:
24: \begin{document}
25:
26: \title{New light and shadows on Stephan's Quintet}
27:
28: \author{C. M. Guti\'errez}
29: \affil{Instituto de Astrof\'{\i}sica de Canarias, E-38205 La Laguna, Tenerife, Spain}
30: \email{cgc@ll.iac.es}
31: \author{M. L\'opez-Corredoira}
32: \affil{Instituto de Astrof\'{\i}sica de Canarias, E-38205 La Laguna, Tenerife,
33: Spain\\
34: Astronomisches Institut der Universit\"at Basel, Venusstrasse 7, CH-4102
35: Binningen, Switzerland}
36: \author{F. Prada}
37: \affil{Centro Astron\'omico Hispano-Alem\'an, Apdo. 511, E-04080 Almer\'\i
38: a, Spain}
39: \and
40: \author{M. C. Eliche}
41: \affil{Instituto de Astrof\'{\i}sica de Canarias, E-38205 La Laguna, Tenerife, Spain}
42: %% Notice that each of these authors has alternate affiliations, which
43: %% are identified by the \altaffilmark after each name. Specify alternate
44: %% affiliation information with \altaffiltext, with one command per each
45: %% affiliation.
46:
47: \begin{abstract}
48:
49: We present deep broad-band $R$ and narrow-band H$\alpha$ images of
50: Stephan's Quintet. The observations in the $R$ band show that the
51: diffuse halo of the Stephan's Quintet is larger than previously thought
52: and extends out to NGC~7320C. However, we have not found emission
53: connecting NGC~7331 and NGC~7320 to $R\sim 26.7 $ mag/arcsec$^2$ (at
54: more than 3-$\sigma$ level), so there is no direct evidence up to this
55: limiting magnitude of a relation between the peculiar kinematical
56: structure found in NGC~7331 and an ongoing or past interaction between
57: this galaxy and NGC~7320. The H$\alpha$ emission at high-velocity
58: (6000--7000 km s$^{-1}$) is distributed in a diffuse structure running
59: NS between NGC~7319 and NGC~7318B and in some other more concentrated
60: features. Some of these are located in the tidal tails produced by the
61: interaction between the galaxies of the group. With the H$\alpha$
62: images we have made a two-dimensional velocity map which helps to
63: identify the origin of each structure detected. This map does not show
64: features at intermediate velocities between the high- and low-redshift
65: members of the group. This is in agreement with the standard scenario
66: in which the apparent proximity of NGC~7320 to the rest of the
67: galaxies of the Quintet is merely a projection effect. The only point
68: which is unclear in this interpretation, is an H$\alpha$ filament which
69: is seen extending throughout NGC 7320 with velocity at 6500 km/s
70: instead of the 800 km/s expected for this galaxy.
71:
72:
73: \end{abstract}
74:
75: %% Keywords should appear after the \end{abstract} command. The uncommented
76: %% example has been keyed in ApJ style. See the instructions to authors
77: %% for the journal to which you are submitting your paper to determine
78: %% what keyword punctuation is appropriate.
79:
80: \keywords{galaxies: individual (NGC~7317, NGC~7318A, NGC~7318B,
81: NGC~7319, NGC~7320, NGC~7320C, NGC~7331), Galaxies: Interactions.}
82:
83: \section{Introduction}
84:
85: Stephan's Quintet (SQ) was discovered in 1877 and is one of the most
86: popular and studied groups of galaxies. It is classified as a compact
87: group (HCG 92) in the Hickson (1982) catalog. The core of the group is
88: formed by three galaxies (NGC~7319, NGC~7318A, and NGC~7317), which
89: have recessional velocities $\sim$ 6600 km s$^{-1}$ with very low
90: velocity dispersions. The other members of the group are NGC~7318B, at
91: $\sim$ 5700 km s$^{-1}$, and NGC~7320 at $\sim$800 km s$^{-1}$.
92: According to the orthodox view, NGC~7320 is a foreground galaxy, while
93: NGC~7318B which has a difference in velocity of $\sim$1000 km s$^{-1}$
94: with respect to the core of the group, shows clear signs of strong
95: distortions which indicate ongoing interaction with the group. Two
96: other galaxies NGC~7320C ($\sim$ 6000 km s$^{-1}$) and NGC~7331 ($\sim$
97: 800 km s$^{-1}$) are not considered in the Hickson scheme as members of
98: the group, but their apparent proximity and several reasons that we
99: will discuss in this paper make it convenient to consider them here. A
100: diagram showing the relative positions of the galaxies in the SQ and
101: NGC~7331 can be found in Moles, Sulentic, \& Marquez (1997).
102:
103: In spite of the large observational effort dedicated to the study of SQ
104: from the radio to the X ray continuum, there are many points which yet
105: require further attention. In particular, in this paper we address the
106: following specific questions: {\it i\/}) whether the apparent
107: proximity of NGC~7320 to the other members of SQ is merely a
108: projection effect; {\it ii\/}) whether there is any evidence of
109: interaction between SQ (specifically NGC~7320) and NGC~7331 that could
110: explain the particular kinematics of this galaxy (Prada et al. 1996);
111: and {\it iii\/}) whether the core of SQ (NGC~7318A, NGC~7318B and
112: NGC~7319) is connected with NGC~7320C. We have tried to answer these
113: questions by conducting an observational program of broad- and
114: narrow-band imaging. The narrow-band H$\alpha$ images analyzed in this
115: paper cover velocities in the range 0--8000 km s$^{-1}$, while the
116: broad-band $R$ observations correspond to two different regions: the
117: south part of NGC7331 and SQ respectively, covering a total area
118: $\sim$650 square arcminutes. With the $R$ images we have investigated
119: the possible presence of bridges between NGC~7331 and SQ, and with the
120: narrow-band observations we have mapped the H$\alpha$ and derived a
121: map with the velocity field of this emission in SQ.
122:
123: Section~2 of this paper summarizes our present knowledge and previous
124: observations of SQ. Section~3 presents the observations and data
125: processing. In Sections~4 and 5 we analyze the broad- and narrow-band
126: images, respectively. Section~6 discusses our results in the context of
127: earlier observations. Our conclusions are given in Section 7.
128:
129: \section{Present status of observations of Stephan's Quintet}
130:
131: \subsection{\small Optical and near IR}
132:
133: Recent studies have been conducted in the optical and near infrared
134: from ground-based telescopes and from {\it ISO} and the {\it Hubble Space
135: Telescope} ({\it HST\/}). From {\it HST} broad-band images, Gallagher
136: et al. (2001) have recently claimed the discovery of a large number of
137: young star clusters at distances up to 20 kpc from the galactic center
138: in the tidal debris of NGC~7319. This is in agreement with the standard
139: dynamical picture (Moles, Marquez, \& Sulentic 1998), in which the ongoing
140: interaction with NGC~7319 is older than that occurring now between
141: NGC~7318A and NGC~7318B.
142:
143: Ohyama et al. (1998) have discovered two emission-line regions in the
144: tidal arm of NGC~7318B in a position which coincides with previously
145: discovered radio continuum emission. The lines in these two region are
146: at 6560 and 6720 km s$^{-1}$, respectively, and much wider (900 km
147: s$^{-1}$) than the normal H~{\scshape ii} regions in NGC 7318B and NGC
148: 7319. From this, and from the the ratio between the S~{\scshape ii} and
149: the H$\alpha$ emission, they conclude that the emission is the remnant
150: of a large number of recent supernovae. Plana et al. (1999) have
151: presented H$\alpha$ observations in SQ with a Fabry--Perot
152: interferometer. From these, they have detected and derived the
153: velocities for 23 H$\alpha$ regions with velocities in the range
154: 5540--6700 km s$^{-1}$. Mendes de Oliveira et al. (2001) and
155: Iglesias-P\'aramo \& V\'\i lchez (2001) have recently presented
156: evidence that some of this emission corresponds to dwarf galaxies
157: located within tidal tails in the SQ.
158:
159: %Molecular gas
160:
161: Yun et al. (1997) have demonstrated that SQ is deficient in molecular gas. CO emission is detected only in NGC 7319 and is concentrated mostly in
162: a region 8 kpc north of the center of the galaxy. This asymmetry could
163: be produced by recent tidal disruptions. However Gao \& Xu (2000),
164: using BIMA, have detected a larger abundance of CO in NGC 7319, and
165: also in NGC 7318B and the intergroup starburst region. Finally, Smith \& Struck
166: (2001) have detected CO in a tail located to the north of SQ at 6000
167: and 6700 km s$^{-1}$. This emission has H~{\scshape i} and H$\alpha$
168: counterparts, and the velocities suggest that this gas corresponds to
169: material removed from NGC 7318B and NGC 7319.
170:
171: The IRAS data (Yun et al. 1997) show that the far-infrared emission in
172: SQ is more extended than in other groups and is remarkably similar to
173: the X-ray emission (see below). This could indicate the presence of
174: warm dust in the intragroupo gas.
175:
176: %**********
177: \subsection{\small Radio}
178:
179: Kaftan-Kassim \& Sulentic (1974) observed the radio continuum at 318, 430,
180: and 606 MHz and built a map of the emission which shows a connection
181: between NGC~7331 and the source 4C33.56 across SQ. However von
182: Kap-Herr, Haslam, \& Wielebinski
183: (1977) observed the same region at 2695 MHz and
184: found no evidence of such a connection.
185:
186: Allen \& Sullivan (1980) observed in the SQ region the 21 cm
187: H~{\scshape i} at 750 km s$^{-1}$ and 6700 km s$^{-1}$ and concluded
188: that the low redshift H~{\scshape i} is entirely associated with
189: NGC~7320, and that the high-redshift H~{\scshape i} is concentrated in
190: the range 6570--6630 km s$^{-1}$. However, Sulentic \& Arp (1983) have
191: measured the neutral hydrogen at low velocity ($v \le2200$ km s$^{-1}$)
192: and found that it is displaced from the optical position of NGC~7320;
193: they argued that this has been produced by interaction between NGC~7320
194: and the other members of SQ. Peterson \& Shostak (1980) have observed
195: several positions of the 21 cm line in the inner and outer parts of SQ
196: and found three extended systems at velocities 5700, 6000, and 6600 km
197: s$^{-1}$. The galaxies are enveloped by a cloud of H~{\scshape i} with
198: a size of $\sim$ 100 kpc (Sullivan 1980; Peterson \& Shostak 1980).
199: Shostak, Sullivan \& Allen (1984) mapped the H~{\scshape i} line in the
200: region of SQ with a resolution of 35$^{\prime\prime}$. They built a
201: map of the gas with resolution of 50 km s$^{-1}$ and confirmed the
202: existence of three systems at velocities 5700, 6000, and 6600 km
203: s$^{-1}$. Most of the emission comes from the outer parts of the
204: galaxies. The authors argued that the stripping of gas from the disks
205: is due to a tidal encounter in the past and a present collision.
206: Gillespie (1974, 1977) have found several radio sources $\sim$ 15
207: arcminutes to the north of SQ. However, the most probable
208: interpretation is a group of radio sources at $z\sim$ 0.5 without any
209: relation with SQ.
210:
211: %************
212: \subsection{\small X-Ray}
213:
214: X-ray emission in SQ was detected (Bahcall, Harris, \& Rood 1984) by
215: the {\it Einstein Observatory}. Other more recent observations have
216: been obtained with {\it ROSAT} (Sulentic, Pietsch, \& Arp 1995; Pietsch
217: et al. 1997), and {\it ASCA} (Awaki et al. 1997). Pietsch et al. (1997)
218: obtained high spatial resolution X-ray images of SQ with the {\it
219: ROSAT} HRI detector. This tidal emission amounts to $\sim 5 \times
220: 10^{41}$ erg s$^{-1}$ and is distributed among the following
221: components: $a$) the galaxies NGC 7319 and NGC 7318A, $b$) the
222: intergalactic feature between NGC 7319 and NGC 7318B, $c$) a region
223: situated $\sim 1^{\prime \prime}$ to the north of NGC~7318A,B, and $d$)
224: diffuse hot gas (amounting to one third of the total emission).
225:
226: %************
227: \subsection{\small Physical picture}
228:
229: The discrepant redshift of NGC~7320 has received special attention in
230: the past. In the orthodox view, this is just a chance projection
231: similar to those found in a large numbers of Hickson compact groups.
232: However, some authors (Arp 1973; Burbidge \& Burbidge 1961; Sulentic
233: \& Arp 1983) have claimed the existence of a physical connection
234: between the low- and high-redshift galaxies of SQ. This claim is based
235: on statistical arguments or on the numerous signs of distortions found
236: in optical, IR and radio images of SQ. Recently, the {\it Hubble
237: Space Telescope} has obtained images of SQ with high resolution (see
238: http://spaceflightnow.com/news/n0010/26hststephen). It has been
239: claimed (Moles 2001) that these images have definitely solved the
240: question of the redshift discrepancy of NGC~7320 because it is possible
241: to resolve individual stars in this galaxy, showing that it is closer
242: than the rest of the galaxies of the group. However, Arp (2001)
243: (private comm.), in strong disagreement with this, claims that in these
244: images it is also possible to resolve individual stars in the
245: high-redshift members of the group. Furthermore, using the luminosity
246: of the H~{\scshape ii} region as a distance indicator, Arp (2001)
247: (private comm.) points out that the low- and high-redshift galaxies of
248: SQ should be at the same distance.
249:
250: The other relevant fact in the discussion on SQ is the large
251: difference in velocity ($\sim 1000$ km s$^{-1}$) between NGC~7318B and
252: the rest of the high-$z$ members of SQ. Moles et al. (1998) argue
253: that NGC~7318B is crossing the group now; as this galaxy has kept its
254: gas, this current crossing should be occurring for the first time. As a
255: consequence of this encounter, the interstellar medium of NGC~7318B is
256: shocking the intragroup medium, especially in the Northern Starburst
257: Forming (NSF) region (Gallagher et al. 2001) and in the tidal tail of
258: NGC~7319. As is expected from numerical simulations and as an
259: increasing number of observations show, this interaction is producing
260: intense starbursts in several regions of the group. There are several
261: features indicating that this interaction is in fact in progress; for
262: instance: {\it i\/}) optically, NGC~7318A and NGC~7318B look like a
263: typical pair merging, {\it ii\/}) there is radio emission associated
264: with the interaction between NGC~7319 and NGC~7318B, and {\it iii\/}) a
265: large number of knots has been observed in the arms of NGC~7318B.
266: However, Arp (1973) has suggested that with this difference in
267: velocities the group would dissipate over a very short timescale so
268: that it would be very unlikely to see them together.
269:
270: In the standard picture (Moles et al. 1998), NGC~7320C crossed the
271: group 10$^8$ years ago producing considerable disruptions; for
272: instance, it removed the H~{\scshape i} in NGC~7319 creating a visible
273: tail seen today in this galaxy, with part of the gas being deposited in
274: a region northeast of NGC~7319. The interaction was also probably
275: responsible for the Seyfert 2-type nuclear activity of NGC~7319. In
276: this paper, we will show more evidence of the connection between
277: NGC~7320C and the other galaxies in SQ.
278:
279: \section{Observations and data reduction}
280:
281: \begin{table}[htb]
282: \caption{Summary of the observations}
283: \begin{center}
284: \begin{tabular}{ccccc}
285: $\lambda_{\rm cent}$ (\AA) & FWHM (\AA) & Tel. &$T_{\rm exp}$ (s) \\
286: \hline
287: \\
288: 6611 & 50 & IAC 80 & 11700 \\
289: 6687 & 50 & IAC 80 & 5400 \\
290: 6724 & 50 & IAC 80 & 4800 \\
291: 6569 & 113 & Calar 2.2 m & 1000 \\
292: 6667 & 76 & Calar 2.2 m & 1000 \\
293: 6737 & 66 & Calar 2.2 m & 1000 \\
294: % 6568 & 95 & INT & \\
295: $R$& &INT & 2200 \\
296: $R$& & IAC~80 & 4800\\
297: \\
298: \end{tabular}
299: \end{center}
300: \end{table}
301:
302: The observations analyzed in this paper were obtained during several
303: runs between 1997 and 2000 on the 0.8 m IAC 80 telescope at Teide
304: Observatory\footnote{The IAC 80 is operated by the Instituto de
305: Astrof\'\i sica de Canarias at Teide Observatory on the island of
306: Tenerife (Spain).}, the 2.2 m telescope at Calar Alto\footnote{The
307: German--Spanish Astronomical Centre, Calar Alto, is operated jointly by
308: the Max-Planck-Institute for Astronomy, Heidelberg, and Spain's
309: National Commission for Astronomy.}, and the 2.5 m Isaac Newton
310: Telescope (INT) at Roque de los Muchachos Observatory on La Palma
311: (Spain)\footnote{The INT is operated by the Isaac Newton Group.}. The
312: observations taken with the IAC~80 and the 2.2 m telescope, we
313: concentrated specifically on the H$\alpha$ emission in SQ (the $R$
314: images taken with the IAC 80 were used only for continuum subtraction
315: of the H$\alpha$ images). The south of NGC~7331 and SQ were observed in
316: the $R$-band with the wider field of the WFC on the INT, with a total
317: exposure time $\sim 2000$ s each. Typical seeing was $\sim $ 2 arcsec
318: in the narrow band images, and $\sim 1$ arcsec for the $R$-band
319: observations. Table 1 summarizes the observations. The spectral
320: response of the narrow-band filters can be found at
321: http://\-www.iac.es/\-telescopes/\-ten.html and
322: http://\-www.caha.es/\-CAHA/\-Instruments/\-filterlist.html. We
323: performed standard data reduction: bias subtraction, flat-field
324: correction, coaddition of images for the same filter, and sky
325: subtraction. Only the observations at the INT have been photometrically
326: calibrated, using stars from the catalog of Landolt et al. (1992). For
327: the observations in the H$\alpha$ narrow bands we subtracted the
328: continuum using the images in $R$ taken with the IAC 80 or in a
329: different redshifted H$\alpha$, scaling according to the flux measured
330: in field stars.
331:
332: \section{Broad-band imaging}
333:
334: Images in the $R$ band were taken with the Wide Field Camera at the 2.5
335: m INT at Roque de los Muchachos Observatory in 1997 August. The
336: observations covered $\sim$ 1800 square arcminutes from which we have
337: selected $\sim 650$ square arcminutes corresponding to the SQ region
338: and the southern part of the galaxy NGC~7331. We had two objectives:
339: the first was to delineate the halo of SQ, and the second was to search
340: for possible evidence of interaction between NGC~7331 and the other SQ
341: galaxies. The limiting 3$\sigma$ magnitude per 0.37 square arcsecond
342: pixels was $\sim$ 25.2 mag/arcsec$^2$. However, the structures that we
343: wanted to map were diffuse and spatially very extended, so we binned
344: the images to a resolution $\sim$ 2.5 arcsecs, this permits an
345: enhancement of the signal-to-noise ratio by a factor $\sim$7, that is,
346: we go almost two magnitudes deeper, being now the 3-$\sigma$ limiting
347: magnitude 27.3 mag/arcsec$^2$. Figures 1$a,b$ present the gray-scale
348: and isophotal map obtained around SQ and in the southern part of
349: NGC~7331 respectively. Figure 1$a$ shows that the halo is considerable
350: more extended that it was revealed in the observations by Moles et al.
351: (1998). For the first time, we have found evidence of a clear
352: connection in the form of diffuse light between SQ and the galaxy
353: NGC~7320C. In particular the SW tail which emerges from SQ seems to
354: extend to this galaxy. We think that this supports the previously
355: suspected connection between SQ and NGC~7320C. We have traced the
356: emission up to the isophote at 26.7 mag/arcsec$^2$ and 25.5
357: mag/arcsec$^2$ around the SQ and NGC~7331 respectively. The 25.5
358: mag/arcsec$^2$ isophote surrounds and seems to enclose NGC~7331. These
359: numbers are conservative with respect to the sensitivity of the image
360: and take into account the uncertainties in the estimation of the sky
361: level, particularly difficult in the observations of the region around
362: NGC~7331.
363:
364: There are no signs of past or present interaction in the form of tails,
365: bridges, etc., between SQ and NGC~7331. We would remark that the last
366: isophote surrounding SQ is not associated with any individual galaxy,
367: but instead corresponds to the diffuse halo of the group, while the
368: last isophote detected around NGC~7331 is more regular, roughly
369: following the shape of the galaxy, and seems to be associated with the
370: disk (and halo) of this galaxy.
371:
372: \section{H$\alpha$ maps and velocity field}
373:
374: To differentiate the emission coming from the low-z (at the systemic
375: velocity of NGC~7320) and high-z (the other galaxies of SQ)
376: respectively, we decided to take H$\alpha$ images redshifted at the
377: velocities of both components (see Section~3). Figure~2 presents the
378: $R$ band (gray-scale) and the total H$\alpha$ (contours). The
379: H$\alpha$ maps presented here are a combination of the emission
380: associated with the low- and high-$z$ components. To enhance the
381: signal with respect to the noise we binned the data to a common pixel
382: size of 1.06 arcsec; this produces a slight degradation in resolution.
383: There are many spurious H$\alpha$ features associated with residuals
384: due to imperfect continuum subtraction in the stars of the field. In
385: general, there is no ambiguity in distinguishing between these
386: residuals and real H$\alpha$ emission because the latter is
387: specifically associated with several extended features that we discuss
388: below. Figure 3 presents the images in the narrow filters observed
389: combining the H$\alpha$ low-$z$ (contours) and high-$z$ (gray-scale)
390: filters, respectively. The size of the images is $\sim 6 \times 6$
391: arcmin$^2$. From these images, it is clear that the low-$z$ emission is
392: associated with NGC~7320. The high-$z$ emission is concentrated in
393: three well differentiated structures: $i$) the center of NGC~7319,
394: $ii$) an intergroup feature in the NS direction between NGC~7318B and
395: NGC~7319, and $iii$) a structure to the north of the aforementioned
396: feature, which corresponds to features previously identified by Xu,
397: Sulentic, \& Tuffs (1999) and Gallagher et al. (2001). Apart from these
398: components, there are several other high-$z$ H$\alpha$ features in the
399: tidal tails produced by the strong interaction within the group. From
400: Fig.~3, we see that the low- and high-$z$ emission are associated with
401: different spatial regions, and that there are no regions in which both
402: types of emission overlap. Although our spatial resolution is poor and
403: the H$\alpha$ emission is diffuse, using the algorithm SExtractor
404: (Bertin \& Arnouts 1996) and eliminating the spurious detections
405: associated with star residuals, we identified about 20 and 30 separated
406: regions in the low- and high-$z$ maps, respectively. The low-$z$
407: structures are symmetrically distributed in the disk of NGC~7320 (see
408: however Section~6.1) and tend to be isolated and compact. The high-$z$
409: emission tends to be more diffuse than the low-$z$ component. This is
410: in agreement with the standard picture in which components $ii$ and
411: $iii$ (see above) of the high-$z$ emission are associated with the
412: intergroup medium formed by material stripped by recent and ongoing
413: strong interaction involving the galaxies NGC~7318A, NGC~7318B,
414: NGC~7319, and NGC~7320C.
415:
416: We may consider the set of H$\alpha$ images as a two-dimensional
417: spectrum with very low resolution. It then makes sense to compute the
418: centroid and dispersion of a given feature. From this, it is
419: straightforward to produce a two-dimensional velocity map. We proceed
420: as follows. A single wavelength, $\lambda _i$, was assigned to the
421: $i$th pixel of the image:
422:
423: \begin{equation}
424: \lambda _i=\frac{\sum _j F_{ij} \times \lambda _{j}}{\sum _j F_{ij}}
425: \end{equation}
426:
427: \noindent where $F_{ij}$ the flux in pixel $i$ and filter $j$, and
428: $\lambda _{j}$ is the central wavelength in pixel $i$. To eliminate
429: most of the residuals due to stars, only fluxes at a level above
430: 2$\sigma$ were considered. From this, we computed the associated
431: velocity as $v_i=(\lambda_i-\lambda_0)/\lambda_0$ ($\lambda_0=6562$
432: \AA). Figures~4$a$ and $b$ show the velocity and the associated error
433: map, respectively. Overplotted in Fig.~4$a$ is the ellipse which fits
434: the outer isophote of NGC~7320 in the $R$-band. An important result is
435: that the velocities derived are in two well separated ranges: one from
436: 5500 to 7500 km s$^{-1}$, and the other from 700 to 1000 km s$^{-1}$.
437: No features at intermediate velocities that could suggest a Doppler
438: redshift as the origin of the difference in velocities between
439: NGC~7320 and the rest of the SQ have been detected. However, some
440: points concerning the relationship between these two features are
441: unexplained and are discussed in next section.
442:
443: \section{Discussion}
444:
445: The relation between NGC~7331 and NGC~7320 is clear according to their
446: relative positions and systemic velocities. From the H~{\scshape i}
447: line the difference in velocities between both galaxies is $\sim 45$ km
448: s$^{-1}$ (de Vaucouleurs et al. 1991). Their projected separation is
449: $\sim 100$ kpc, and the magnitudes in the $B$ band are 9.38 and 13.56
450: for NGC~7331 and NGC~7320, respectively. These allow us to classify
451: NGC~7320 as a satellite of NGC~7331 according to the criteria defined
452: by Zaritsky et al. (1997). We have searched the NED for objects at
453: less than 500 kpc from NGC~7331 and with recessional velocities similar
454: to that of this galaxy and found another two galaxies besides NGC
455: 7320. These galaxies seem to constitute one of the loose groups
456: identified by Trasarti-Battistoni (1998). At angular distances $\le 1$
457: degree ($\le 2$ Mpc) from SQ, there are about ten other galaxies with
458: measured redshifts and with recessional velocities in the range
459: 5500--7500 km s$^{-1}$; they form another loose group with
460: 9 members identified by Trasarti-Battistoni (1998); a subgroup of such
461: galaxies (NGC7335, NGC7337, and NGC7340) at the East of NGC7331 has
462: been classified as a poor cluster by White et al. (1999).
463:
464: One of the mechanisms proposed to explain the counter-rotating core
465: found in NGC~7331 (Prada et al. 1996) is the interaction of this galaxy
466: with a small satellite. Although this could really be the origin of
467: such kinematics, in our deep $R$ images we have found no evidence
468: (bridges, tails, etc.) to $R \sim 26.7$ mag/arcsec$^2$ supporting such
469: an interaction between NGC~7331 and NGC~7320.
470:
471: We have carried out a comparative study between the features detected
472: in our velocity map and the results by Plana et al. (1999). The
473: position of these common H$\alpha$ regions is indicated in Fig. 3. We
474: have indicated also in the figure two features in one of the tails connecting
475: NGC~7320c with the rest of SQ. The comparison with the
476: results by Plana et al. (1999) shows that we have detected and
477: estimated the velocities of the regions detected by these authors (the
478: detection of region number 23 it is not completely clear in our data),
479: although we have found a systematic difference of $\sim +300$ km
480: s$^{-1}$ in the estimated velocities. This is consistent with the
481: uncertainties expected from the typical width of the H$\alpha$ filters
482: used in our analysis. In Table~2 we present our estimate of the
483: velocities of H$\alpha$ regions detected by Plana et al. (1999) (we
484: have adopted the notation used by these authors). This uncertainty is
485: too large to distinguish between the components associated with
486: NGC~7319 and the other three galaxies (NGC~7318A, NGC~7318B, and
487: NGC~7317), but is small enough to distinguish between emission
488: associated with the above four galaxies and NGC~7320. Due to the
489: technique used, in some cases Plana et al. (1999) were not able to
490: measured unambiguously the velocities, so our observations represent
491: the first determination of such velocities. Our analysis allows us to
492: distinguish only one component in velocity in each position. If there
493: were more than one, this should reveal itself in our velocity map as an
494: increase in the pixel-to-pixel rms according to the importance of one
495: or other component. This seems to be the case for region 13 (in the
496: notation of Plana et al. 1999) in which these authors detected two
497: different components, and which shows up in our map as a large
498: variation in velocity from pixel to pixel.
499:
500: \begin{table}
501: \caption{Recessional velocities (in km s$^{-1}$) of the H$\alpha$
502: regions in common with Plana et al. (1999).}
503: \begin{center}
504: \begin{tabular}{cccccccc}
505: \hline
506: Region &1 & 2 & 3 & 4 & 5 & 6 \\
507:
508: Velocity & 6300 & 6000 & 6300 & 6300 & 6300 & 7200 \\
509: \hline
510:
511:
512: Region &7 &8 & 9 & 10 & 11 & 12 \\
513: Velocity & 6900 & 6400 & 6900 & 6300 & 6250 & 6400 \\
514: \hline
515:
516: Region & 13 & 14 &15 & 16 & 17 & 18 \\
517: Velocity & 6100 & 6100 & 5500 & 5950 & 5750 & 6100 \\
518: \hline
519: Region & 19 & 20 & 21&22 & 23 \\
520: Velocity & 6000 & 6200 & 5800 & 5750 & 6100?\\
521: \end{tabular}
522: \end{center}
523: \end{table}
524:
525: Some of these features are in the tidal tails resulting from the strong
526: interaction within the group. This is in perfect agreement with the
527: results of Iglesias-P\'aramo \& V\'\i lchez (2001), who identified these
528: features as dwarf galaxies. The above results are also in agreement
529: with the predictions from numerical simulations (Barnes 1988) in which
530: dwarf galaxies can form in tidal tails resulting from the
531: interaction of two disk galaxies.
532:
533: Our broad-band observations reveal a bigger halo that was previously
534: observed. As pointed out by Moles et al. (1998), this light is not
535: associated with the individual galaxies, but is instead diffuse light
536: associated with present and past interactions within the group. In
537: particular it indicates large transversal motions of NGC~7317 and
538: NGC~7320C. The interaction with this galaxy seems to be responsible
539: for the diffuse light observed to the north of SQ. The extension of
540: the SW tail to NGC~7320C strongly supports the standard scenario
541: proposed by Moles et al. (1998), in which the galaxy crossed SQ and
542: created this tail, which runs in parallel to a second tail which
543: emerges from one of the arms of NGC~7319. This second tail is brighter
544: as it would be expected if it corresponds to a past encounter with the
545: core from which most of the gas associated with NGC~7319 (and partially
546: with NGC~7320C) was stripped.
547:
548: \subsection{{\bf A remark on some odd coincidences}}
549:
550: Apart from all the positive facts which suggest that NGC 7320 is
551: unrelated to the rest of the components of SQ, as we have argued above,
552: there is one further observational aspect whose interpretation is not
553: clear in the light of the orthodox view: there is an H$\alpha $ bridge
554: (see Figs. 3, 4$a$ and 4$c$) which is a continuation of the
555: intergalactic gas of the high-redshift galaxies of SQ pointing to
556: NGC~7320 and extending throughout this galaxy. In particular, we would
557: like to remark:
558:
559: \begin{itemize}
560:
561: \item The emission of H$\alpha $ at 6500 km/s is in a region of NGC7320
562: where there is no emission of H$\alpha $ at 800 km/s. Assuming
563: elliptical symmetry for NGC 7320 (such symmetry exists in the
564: $R$-band), we would expect to observe H$\alpha $ emission with both
565: velocities (6500 km s$^{-1}$ and 800 km s$^{-1}$) superposed in the
566: region of the bridge. Instead of that, we observe a gap in the
567: H${\alpha}$ emission at 800 km/s precisely where the bridge at 6500
568: km/s is present.
569:
570: \item Exactly in the point where the bridge of 6500 km/s finishes, HII
571: regions at 800 km/s begin. We might think that the opacity of these
572: HII regions does not allow to see what is behind. However, it is not
573: only in the position of the HII regions at 800 km/s, but also in the
574: gaps between them, where we do not find any emission at 6500 km/s.
575:
576: \end{itemize}
577:
578: These coincidences could be explained naturally if a bridge at 6500
579: km/s were in front of the galaxy at 800 km/s. Although the evidence is
580: not conclusive, and difficult to fit in an ortodox view, we think that
581: this is a new and interesting observational fact to consider in future
582: studies of SQ.
583:
584: \section{Conclusions}
585:
586: 1) We have obtained deep $R$ images in the region from SQ
587: to the southern edge of the giant spiral NGC~7331. We have found no
588: evidence of an optical connection in the form of tails, bridges, etc.,
589: between SQ and NGC 7331 above magnitudes $\sim 26.7$ mag/arcssec$^2$.
590:
591: 2) We have delineated the halo of SQ up to the above magnitude showing
592: that it extends to and contains the galaxy NGC~7320C. Additionally, in
593: the $R$-band image, a tail connecting the core of SQ and NGC~7320C is
594: seen. This is interpreted as a tidal tail produced by a past encounter
595: between NGC~7320C and the core of the group.
596:
597: 3) With narrow-band images in the range 0--8000 km s$^{-1}$, we have
598: delineated the H$\alpha$ emission. We see that this is concentrated in
599: a feature in the NS direction situated between NGC~7318B and NGC~7319,
600: a region $\sim 1$ arcminute to the north of NGC~7318B and the nucleus
601: of NGC~7319.
602:
603: 4) With the H$\alpha$ images, we have obtained a low-resolution velocity
604: map of the SQ region. The H$\alpha$ images and the velocity map show
605: evidence of emission in the tidal tail that is the result of the
606: strong interaction within the group.
607:
608: 5) The velocity map derived from the H$\alpha$ images does not show
609: features at intermediate velocities between the low- and the high-$z$
610: components.
611:
612: 6) A filament in H$\alpha$ at $\sim 6500$ km s$^{-1}$ apparently
613: connecting NGC~7320 (at $\sim 800$ km s$^{-1}$) and the rest of SQ is
614: seen. We think that this fact leaves the point of the possible relation
615: between NGC~7320 and the rest of SQ still open and will require further
616: attention.
617:
618: \acknowledgments
619:
620: We wish to thank J. Iglesias-P\'aramo, who kindly provided the
621: H$\alpha$ images taken at the 2.2 m telescope in Calar Alto.
622:
623: \begin{thebibliography}{}
624: \bibitem[]{} Allen, R. J., \& Sullivan, W. T., III 1980, A\&A, 84, 181
625: \bibitem[]{} Arp, H. 1973, ApJ, 183, 411
626: %\bibitem[]{} Arp, H. 2001, Troth, 5(1) (http://www.kronia.com/thoth/thothV01.txt)
627: \bibitem[]{} Awaki, H., Koyama, K., Matsumoto, H., Tomida, H., Tsuru, T., \& Ueno, S. 1997, PASP, 49, 445
628: \bibitem[]{} Bahcall, N. A., Harris, D. E., \& Rood, H. J. 1984, ApJ, 284, L29
629: \bibitem[]{} Barnes, J. E. 1988, ApJ, 331, 699
630: \bibitem[]{} Bertin, E., \& Arnouts, S. 1996, AAS, 117, 393
631: \bibitem[]{} Burbidge, E. M., \& Burbidge, G. R. 1961, ApJ, 134, 244
632: \bibitem[]{} de Vaucouleurs, G., de Vaucouleurs, A., Corwin, JR, H. G., Buta, R. J., Paturel, G., \& Fouque, P. 1991, Third Reference Catalogue of Bright Galaxies. Springer-Verlag. N.Y.
633: \bibitem[]{} Gallagher, S. C., Charlton, J. C., Hunsberger, S. D., Zaritsky, D., \& Whitmore, B. C. et al. 2001, AJ, 122, 163
634: \bibitem[]{} Gao, Y. \& Xu, C. 2000, ApJ, 542, L83
635: \bibitem[]{} Gillespie, A. R. 1974, MNRAS, 166, 11
636: \bibitem[]{} Gillespie, A. R. 1977, MNRAS, 181, 149
637: \bibitem[]{} Hickson, P. 1982, ApJ, 255, 382
638: \bibitem[]{} Iglesias-P\'aramo, J., \& V\'\i lchez, J. M. 2001, ApJ, 550, 204
639: \bibitem[]{} Kaftan-Kassim, M. A. \& Sulentic, J. W. 1974, A\&A, 33, 343
640: \bibitem[]{} Landolt, A. U. 1992, A\&A, 104, 340
641: \bibitem[]{} Mendes de Oliveira, C., Plana, H., Amram, P., Balkowski, C., \& Bolte, M. 2001, AJ, 121, 2524
642: \bibitem[]{} Moles, M. 2001 http://spaceflightnow.com/news/ \\ n0010/26hststephen
643: \bibitem[]{} Moles, M. Marquez, I., \& Sulentic, J. W. 1998, A\&A, 334, 473
644: \bibitem[]{} Moles, M., Sulentic, J. W., \& Marquez, I. 1997, ApJ, 485, L69
645: \bibitem[]{} Ohyama, Y., Nishiura, S., Murayama, T., \& Taniguchi, Y. 1998, ApJ, 492, L25
646: \bibitem[]{} Peterson, S. D. \& Shostak, G. S. 1980, ApJ, 241, L1
647: \bibitem[]{} Pietsch, W., Trinchieri, G., Arp, H., \& Sulentic, J. W. 1997, A\&A, 322, 89
648: \bibitem[]{} Plana, H., Mendes de Oliveira, C., Amram, P., Bolte, M., Balkowski, C., \& Boulesteix, J. 1999, ApJ, 516, L69
649: \bibitem[]{} Prada, F., Guti\'errez, C. M., Peletier, R. F., \& McKeith, C. D. 1996, ApJ, 463, L9
650: \bibitem[]{} Shostak, G. S., Sullivan, W. T. III, \& Allen, R. J. 1984, A\&A, 139, 15
651: \bibitem[]{} Smith, B. J. \& Struck, C. 2001, AJ, 121, 710
652: \bibitem[]{} Sulentic, J. W., \& Arp. H. 1983, AJ, 88, 267
653: \bibitem[]{} Sulentic, J. W., Pietsch, W., \& Arp, H. 1995, ApJ, 445, 85
654: \bibitem[]{} Sullivan, W. T. III 1980, A\&A, 89, L3
655: \bibitem[]{} Trasarti-Battistoni R. 1998, AAS, 130, 341
656: \bibitem[]{} von Kap-Herr, A., Haslam, C. G. T., \& Wielebinski, R. 1977, A\&A, 57, 337
657: \bibitem[]{} White, R. A., Bliton, M., Bhavsar, S. P., Bornmann, P., Burns, J. O., Ledlow, M. J., \& Loken, C. 1999, AJ, 118, 2014
658: \bibitem[]{} Xu, C., Sulentic, J. W., \& Tuffs, R. 1999, ApJ, 512, 178
659: \bibitem[]{} Yun, M. S., \& Verdes-Montenegro, L., del Olmo, A., \& Perea, J. 1997, ApJ, 475, L21
660: \bibitem[]{}Zaritsky, D., Smith, R., Frenk, C., \& White, S. D. M. 1997, ApJ, 478, 39
661:
662: \end{thebibliography}
663:
664: \clearpage
665:
666: \section*{Figures}
667:
668: \figcaption[]{Gray-level and contour $R$ map in the region of Stephan's Quintet and in the southern part of NGC~7331. The lowest isophotes are 26.7 and 25.5 mag/arcsec$^2$, respectively.}
669:
670: \figcaption[]{Broad-band $R$ filter (gray-scale) and H$\alpha$ emission (contours) of Stephan's Quintet.}
671:
672: \figcaption[]{Low-$z$ (contours) and high-$z$ (gray-scale) H$\alpha$ maps in the region of Stephan's Quintet.}
673:
674: \figcaption[]{$(a)$ Velocity and $(b)$ error maps in Stephan's Quintet region obtained from the low-$z$ and high-$z$ H$\alpha$ images. $(c)$ An expanded view of the velocity map centered on the region of abrupt transition from the low to the high-$z$ emission.}
675:
676:
677: \end{document}
678: