1: %%
2: %% Beginning of file 'ms.tex'
3: %%
4: %% Draft version: Avishay, Aug. 8, 2003
5: %%
6: %% This is a manuscript marked up using the
7: %% AASTeX v5.x LaTeX 2e macros.
8:
9: %% The command below calls the preprint style
10: %% which will produce a one-column, single-spaced document.
11: %% Examples of commands for other substyles follow. Use
12: %% whichever is most appropriate for your purposes.
13:
14: %\documentclass{aastex}
15: %\documentstyle[emulateapj]{article}
16:
17: %\usepackage{emulateapj5}
18: %\usepackage{apjfonts}
19: %\usepackage{natbib}
20:
21: %\documentclass[12pt,preprint]{aastex}
22:
23: %% manuscript produces a one-column, double-spaced document:
24:
25: \documentclass[manuscript]{aastex}
26:
27: %% preprint2 produces a double-column, single-spaced document:
28:
29: %\documentclass[preprint2]{aastex}
30:
31: %% If you want to create your own macros, you can do so
32: %% using \newcommand. Your macros should appear before
33: %% the \begin{document} command.
34: %%
35: %% If you are submitting to a journal that translates manuscripts
36: %% into SGML, you need to follow certain guidelines when preparing
37: %% your macros. See the AASTeX v5.x Author Guide
38: %% for information.
39:
40: \newcommand{\vdag}{(v)^\dagger}
41: \newcommand{\myemail}{skywalker@galaxy.far.far.away}
42: \def\gtorder{\mathrel{\raise.3ex\hbox{$>$}\mkern-14mu
43: \lower0.6ex\hbox{$\sim$}}}
44:
45: % Define "less than or approximately" symbol.
46: \def\ltsima{$\; \buildrel < \over \sim \;$}
47: \def\simlt{\lower.5ex\hbox{\ltsima}}
48: % Define "greater than or approximately" symbol.
49: \def\gtsima{$\; \buildrel > \over \sim \;$}
50: \def\simgt{\lower.5ex\hbox{\gtsima}}
51:
52: %% You can insert a short comment on the title page using the command below.
53:
54: %\slugcomment{Not to appear in Nonlearned J., 45.}
55:
56: %% If you wish, you may supply running head information, although
57: %% this information may be modified by the editorial offices.
58: %% The left head contains a list of authors,
59: %% usually a maximum of three (otherwise use et al.). The right
60: %% head is a modified title of up to roughly 44 characters. Running heads
61: %% will not print in the manuscript style.
62:
63: %\shorttitle{Collapsed Cores in Globular Clusters}
64: %\shortauthors{Djorgovski et al.}
65:
66: %% This is the end of the preamble. Indicate the beginning of the
67: %% paper itself with \begin{document}.
68:
69: \begin{document}
70:
71: %% LaTeX will automatically break titles if they run longer than
72: %% one line. However, you may use \\ to force a line break if
73: %% you desire.
74:
75: \title{Photometric Identification of Young Stripped-Core
76: Supernovae}
77:
78: %% Use \author, \affil, and the \and command to format
79: %% author and affiliation information.
80: %% Note that \email has replaced the old \authoremail command
81: %% from AASTeX v4.0. You can use \email to mark an email address
82: %% anywhere in the paper, not just in the front matter.
83: %% As in the title, you can use \\ to force line breaks.
84:
85: \author{Avishay Gal-Yam\altaffilmark{1}}
86: \affil{Astronomy Department, California Institute of Technology,
87: Pasadena, CA 91125}
88: \email{avishay@astro.caltech.edu}
89: \author{Dovi Poznanski, Dan Maoz}
90: \affil{School of Physics \& Astronomy, Tel-Aviv University, Tel-Aviv
91: 69978, Israel}
92: \email{dovip@wise.tau.ac.il, dani@wise.tau.ac.il}
93: \and
94: \author{Alexei V. Filippenko, Ryan J. Foley}
95: \affil{Deaprtment of Astronomy, 601 Campbell Hall, University of California, Berkeley, CA 94720-3411}
96: \email{alex@astro.berkeley.edu, rfoley@astro.berkeley.edu}
97:
98: %% Notice that each of these authors has alternate affiliations, which
99: %% are identified by the \altaffilmark after each name. Specify alternate
100: %% affiliation information with \altaffiltext, with one command per each
101: %% affiliation.
102:
103: \altaffiltext{1}{Hubble Fellow.}
104:
105: %% Mark off your abstract in the ``abstract'' environment. In the manuscript
106: %% style, abstract will output a Received/Accepted line after the
107: %% title and affiliation information. No date will appear since the author
108: %% does not have this information. The dates will be filled in by the
109: %% editorial office after submission.
110:
111: \begin{abstract}
112:
113: We present a method designed to identify the spectral type of young
114: (less than $\sim30$ days after explosion) and nearby
115: ($z \simlt 0.05$) supernovae (SNe) using their broad-band
116: colors. In particular, we show that stripped-core SNe (i.e.,
117: hydrogen deficient core-collapse events, spectroscopically
118: defined as SNe~Ib and SNe~Ic, including broad-lined
119: SN 1998bw-like events) can be clearly distinguished
120: from other types of SNe. Using the full census of nearby
121: SNe discovered during the year 2002, we estimate the impact
122: that prompt multi-band photometry, obtained by $1$~m class
123: telescopes, would have on the early identification of
124: stripped-core events. Combining this new approach with
125: ongoing spectroscopic follow-up programs, one can expect
126: $\sim 20$ nearby, stripped-core events to be identified, each year,
127: around, or before, maximum light. Follow-up studies, including
128: prompt, multi-epoch optical spectroscopy and spectropolarimetry, as well
129: as radio and X-ray observations, could greatly increase our understanding
130: of these events, and shed new light on their
131: association with cosmological gamma-ray bursts.
132:
133: \end{abstract}
134:
135: %% Keywords should appear after the \end{abstract} command. The uncommented
136: %% example has been keyed in ApJ style. See the instructions to authors
137: %% for the journal to which you are submitting your paper to determine
138: %% what keyword punctuation is appropriate.
139:
140: \keywords{supernovae: general}
141:
142: %% From the front matter, we move on to the body of the paper.
143: %% In the first two sections, notice the use of the natbib \citep
144: %% and \citet commands to identify citations. The citations are
145: %% tied to the reference list via symbolic KEYs. The KEY corresponds
146: %% to the KEY in the \bibitem in the reference list below. We have
147: %% chosen the first three characters of the first author's name plus
148: %% the last two numeral of the year of publication as our KEY for
149: %% each reference.
150:
151: \section{Introduction}
152:
153: Several types of supernovae (SNe) are recognized, and are
154: most commonly determined by the attributes of the SN
155: optical spectra. The most basic division is between
156: hydrogen-rich (type II) SNe, and hydrogen deficient
157: (type I) SNe (Minkowski 1941). Type I events are
158: further divided into SNe Ia, which usually show
159: the prominent Si II absorption trough near $6150$~\AA,
160: SNe Ib, which lack this feature but show prominent
161: He lines, and SNe Ic, whose spectra show neither
162: (see Filippenko 1997 for a review).
163:
164: Direct detection of the progenitor stars on pre-explosion
165: images has established that type II SNe result from the
166: explosion of massive stars, presumably following the
167: gravitational collapse of the stellar core (SN 1987A, White \& Malin 1987;
168: SN 1993J, Aldering et al. 1994; SN 2003gd, Van Dyk, Li, \&
169: Filippenko 2003, Smartt et al. 2004). The existence
170: of transition objects, which appear to be SNe II in spectra
171: obtained shortly after explosion, but later evolve and become
172: very similar to SNe Ib and SNe Ic (SNe IIb; e.g., Filippenko 1997),
173: as well as the apparent association of SNe Ib and Ic with young stellar
174: populations (e.g., Van Dyk, Hamuy, \& Filippenko 1996), suggest that these events also result
175: from the core collapse of massive stars. These stars are assumed to have
176: lost most (in the case of SNe IIb) or all (in SNe Ib and Ic) of their hydrogen
177: envelope, as well as, in the case of SN Ic progenitors, most of their
178: helium, either through stellar winds or due to binary interaction.
179: In contrast, SNe Ia are frequently found among old stellar populations, e.g., in
180: elliptical galaxies, and are unlikely to be associated with very young
181: progenitor stars. These events are commonly assumed to be the result of
182: a thermonuclear runaway explosion of a white-dwarf star, which reaches
183: the Chandrasekhar mass either through accretion from, or a merger with,
184: a binary companion.
185:
186: Of all the various types of SNe, the ones that are probably the least
187: studied are SNe Ib and Ic, which will be referred to henceforth as
188: stripped-core events. Contributing factors probably include the intrinsic
189: rareness, relatively low luminosity, and heterogeneity of these events,
190: along with the absence of a high-profile science driver for such work,
191: as provided, for example, by cosmological distance estimation for studies
192: of SNe Ia. Most of the progress in this field was due to the (rare)
193: occurrence of bright stripped-core events in nearby galaxies, e.g., SN 1994I
194: in M51. The only recent comprehensive study of stripped-core events was
195: conducted by Matheson et al. (2001).
196:
197: This situation is perhaps about to change, following the emerging connection
198: between stripped-core SNe and long-duration gamma-ray bursts, and in particular, the associations between
199: GRB 980425 and SN 1998bw (Galama et al. 1998) and GRB 030329 and SN 2003dh
200: (Stanek et al. 2003; Hjorth et al. 2003; Matheson et al. 2003) -- see Lipkin et al. (2003)
201: for a recent review. The amount of overlap between GRBs and stripped-core SNe
202: is intriguing. Are all GRBs associated with a SN? Are
203: all stripped-core SN explosions triggered by, or associated with,
204: a GRB or GRB-like mechanism (i.e., a non-isotropic, jetted explosion;
205: Khokhlov et al. 1999) ?
206: Early-time studies of stripped-core SNe may provide the answer to this
207: last quesion.
208:
209: \section{The Importance of Early-Time Identification
210: of Stripped-Core SNe}
211:
212: A key to understanding the connection between stripped-core
213: SNe and GRBs is whether ``ordinary'' SNe Ib and Ic (such as SN 1994I)
214: and SN 1998bw-like events, associated with GRBs, are bridged by a
215: continuum of SNe with intermediate properties. Alternatively,
216: are there two distinct populations of SNe -- those associated
217: with GRB-like explosions, and ``ordinary'' stripped-core events. The existence
218: of a continuum would support theories in which GRB-like phenomena
219: (i.e., highly aspherical explosions) occur in all stripped-core
220: events, with the observed variety driven by geometrical (orientation)
221: effects, or variations in the intrinsic energy of the central GRB
222: engine, in which case ordinary SNe are ``failed GRBs.'' A bi-modal
223: distribution would suggest that the (mostly spherical) core-collapse
224: and the (highly aspherical) GRB are two unrelated physical processes that
225: occur simultaneously in some cases (e.g., Soderberg, Frail, \& Weiringa 2004).
226:
227: Since the spectral distinction between SN 1998bw-like events and
228: normal SNe Ic becomes less pronounced with age, it is quite possible
229: that the fact that most stripped-core events are spectroscopically
230: observed at or after maximum brightness causes us not to detect
231: intermediate events, which resemble SN 1998bw early on, but are already
232: ordinary-looking when we observe them. Thus, early-time identification of
233: stripped-core events is crucial in order to trigger
234: spectroscopic studies of these events, as well as spectropolarimetric
235: observations, the most sensitive tracers for explosion asphericity.
236:
237: The collapsar model predicts an association between long-soft GRBs and stripped-core
238: SNe (Woosley 1993, MacFadyen \& Woosley 1999). The progenitor stars are required
239: to have lost their extended hydrogen-rich envelopes before collapse,
240: either to a binary companion or through mass loss by stellar winds. This is necessary for
241: a relativistic jet to escape the surface of the star on a collapse timescale for the
242: helium core ($\sim10$~s).
243: The SNe Ic associated observationally with GRBs (SN 1998bw
244: and SN 2003dh) are luminous, with models indicating large explosion energies ($\sim10^{52}$ erg)
245: and the production of large masses of radioactive Ni ($\sim0.2-0.5 M_{\odot}$) (Iwamoto
246: et al. 1998; Woosley, Eastman, \& Schmidt 1999; Mazzali et al. 2003; Woosley \& Heger 2003).
247: Collapsars can produce large amounts of Ni by expelling hot material
248: from a poorly cooled accretion disk (MacFadyen 2003)
249: around the central accreting black hole powering the GRB.
250: Current models incorporate asymmetry in the explosion to explain the fast rise in the light
251: curve of SN 2003dh (Woosley \& Heger 2003). Thus,
252: early photometric observations of stripped-core SNe on the rise to maximum
253: will better constrain the degree of asymmetry in stripped-core SNe, and,
254: in combination with early spectra, also the
255: explosion energy and nickel masses. These quantities are critical to understanding
256: the mechanism responsible for exploding the star and, sometimes, producing a GRB.
257:
258: SN 1998bw was uniquely radio luminous. In spite of recent and ongoing
259: intensive efforts (Berger et al. 2003; Soderberg et al. 2004) no
260: similar events were discovered among $\sim 60$ stripped-core SNe observed
261: so far (1999--2004). On the other hand, the late
262: initiation of many of the radio searches may have contributed to this null
263: result. In particular, the radio light curve of SN 1998bw
264: peaked early, $\sim~5$ days {\it prior} to optical maximum.
265: Another SN 1998bw-like event, SN 2002ap,
266: one of the only other detections, also peaked early
267: in the radio band. However, with a radio luminosity $10^4$
268: times below that of SN~1998bw, this event was only detected
269: since it is the nearest SN in the sample ($\sim 7$ Mpc) and
270: was observed $\ge 10$ days before optical maximum.
271: Thus, early identification of stripped-core events would be highly
272: valuable for radio studies of these SNe. The same is true in the case of
273: space-based searches for the rapidly decaying X-ray emission from these
274: events.
275:
276: To conclude, early identification of stripped-core events, providing
277: a trigger for detailed follow-up observations, would be very helpful
278: in characterizing the little-known properties of the stripped-core
279: SN population, as well as in searching for transition objects between GRB-associated SN 1998bw-like
280: events and more ordinary stripped-core SNe. Such studies would further
281: our understanding of stripped-core SN physics, and provide an important
282: insight into the GRB-SN connection.
283:
284: \section{Color Classification of Young Supernovae}
285:
286: In Poznanski et al. (2002) we describe a method to classify
287: SNe based on their broad-band colors. The method is based on
288: a large number of high-quality optical SN spectra we have assembled (Table 1).
289: This database includes observations of the prototypical members of
290: every well-defined SN subclass, at various ages.
291: By redshifting the spectra and convolving them with the appropriate
292: filter throughput curves, we derive synthetic photometry of SNe
293: of all types at a given redshift, which can then be compared to
294: available measurements, in order to determine, or constrain,
295: the possible type of an observed SN. The tools we developed
296: are quite general, and can be used to classify SNe of
297: all the well-defined spectroscopic subclasses at arbitrary
298: redshifts. Observations in optical bands may be used to classify
299: SNe up to a redshift of $z=0.75$, while infrared observation
300: are required at higher redshifts.
301:
302: In view of the growing interest in broad-lined
303: SN 1998bw-like events, following their established
304: association with GRBs, we have added the spectra of the two
305: best-observed examples, SN 1998bw (Patat et al. 2001)
306: and SN 2002ap (Gal-Yam, Ofek, \& Shemmer 2002; Foley
307: et al. 2003) to our spectroscopic database (Table 1)\footnotemark.
308: \footnotetext{An updated version of our web-based
309: SN-typing tool, incorporating these additional spectra,
310: is now available at \url{http://wise-obs.tau.ac.il/$\sim$dovip/typing}}
311: We then
312: proceed to study in detail the case of nearby ($z \simlt 0.05$)
313: and young (less then $\sim$30 days after explosion)
314: SNe. As we show below, young stripped-core SNe
315: (Ib and Ic, including the SN1998bw-like events) can
316: be clearly distinguished from all other types of SNe.
317:
318: The broad-band colors of SNe are determined by their
319: spectral energy distribution, dominated by the continuum
320: shape. There are many spectroscopically defined
321: subtypes of SNe. However, some of
322: the more subtle spectroscopic divisions are erased when
323: we examine only the continuum shape. Considering only
324: SNe near peak brightness, we find that all subtypes
325: of hydrogen-rich SNe (types II-P, IIn, and IIb) have similar
326: spectra, rising steadily toward the blue all the way
327: down to the atmospheric cutoff at $\sim3000$~\AA.
328: Type Ia SNe are generally bluer than SNe~II at wavelengths
329: longer than $4000$~\AA, beyond which a UV cutoff, attributed to
330: line-blanketing by iron-group elements, strongly
331: suppresses the flux (see Riess et al. 2004 for a relevant
332: discussion). Type Ib and Ic SNe near maximum have spectra
333: similar to each other,
334: typically redder than both SNe~Ia and SNe~II, and showing a
335: flux deficit blueward of $\sim5500$~\AA.
336:
337: One of the peculiarities of SN 1998bw was the relatively blue
338: spectrum observed at early times, significantly bluer than
339: most other SNe~Ic. This is demonstrated
340: in Figure 1, showing the rest-frame spectra of SN 1998bw compared
341: with three other nearby SNe observed close to peak brightness.
342: Other SN 1998bw-like events, such as SN 2002ap,
343: also have somewhat bluer continua, intermediate between those
344: of SN 1998bw and those of ``normal'' SNe Ic and SNe Ib.
345:
346: Inspecting Figure 1 we can see that young SNe of all types
347: have similar continuum shapes redward of $\sim5500$~\AA.
348: We are thus led to focus on bluer bands in our search for
349: broad-band classification schemes for young SNe. Experimenting
350: with various choices of bands, we find that $B-g$ vs. $V-R$\footnotemark
351: \footnotetext{Throughout, we note the Johnson-Cousins
352: and SDSS filter systems by $UBVRI$ and $ugriz$, respectively; see Poznanski
353: et al. 2002 and references therein for exact details.}
354: plots proves the most informative. The enhanced sensitivity
355: one would expect to gain by analyzing also
356: $U$-band data is in fact hindered by poor existing spectroscopic
357: coverage of young SNe, resulting in sparse sampling of
358: the relevant color spaces by our spectral database. The
359: observational difficulties expected in performing accurate
360: $U$-band photometry are likely to further impede the
361: utility of such data. We therefore consider below mainly
362: $B-g$ vs. $V-R$ plots.
363:
364: \begin{figure*}
365: \includegraphics[width=17cm]{figure1.eps}
366: \caption{Spectra of SNe near maximum light. For clarity,
367: we show only spectra of the prototypical SN~Ia 1999ee
368: (blue; Hamuy et al. 2002), SN~Ic 1994I (Magenta; from Filippenko et al. 1995), SN II-P
369: 1999em (black; Hamuy et al. 2001),
370: and SN 1998bw (red; Patat et al. 2001), with ages in days
371: with respect to $B$-band maximum marked. All spectra have been
372: normalized to have the same flux around $6000$~\AA. Spectra of other
373: types of SNe~II (e.g., SN IIb 1993J or SN IIn 1998S) are similar
374: to that of SN II-P 1999em, while those of SNe~Ib are similar
375: to those of the SN Ic 1994I. SN 2002ap is intermediate between
376: SN Ic 1994I and SN 1998bw.
377: Note how all SNe have similar spectral shape redward of
378: $5500$~\AA, thus making bands redder than $V$ less useful for
379: classification of young SNe.}
380: \end{figure*}
381:
382: Figure 2(a) shows the $B-g$ vs. $V-R$ color-color diagram
383: for SNe of all types up to $\sim1$ week after peak brightness.
384: This and following figures were produced using the
385: methods discussed in detail by Poznanski et al. (2002).
386: A color cut at $B-g=0.24$ mag separates stripped-core SNe
387: from other SNe (SNe~Ia and SNe~II). Considering only events with
388: $B-g>0.24$ mag, stripped-core SNe form a sequence
389: in $V-R$ colors, going from the bluest SN 1998bw, through
390: SN 2002ap and SNe~Ic, with SNe~Ib being the reddest.
391: Similar analysis can be carried out for SNe at
392: higher redshifts. Figure 2(b) shows that for SNe
393: at $z=0.05$, the $g-V$ vs. $V-R$ color-color plot can be
394: used for classification with similar efficacy.
395:
396: Note that the use of these plots requires colors measured with a
397: photometric accuracy of $\sim0.05$ mag, or better. As we further discuss below,
398: for nearby, $z\le0.05$ stripped-core SNe, this level of accuracy can
399: be easily obtained with $1$~m class telescopes. The plots also show the
400: possible effects of dust reddening. For example, examining Fig. 2(a), we
401: see that young SNe of any type are unlikely to be confused with SN 1998bw
402: or SN 2002ap-like events, even when strongly affected by dust. Some reddened
403: SNe II may be confused with young SNe Ib or Ic, though. Another encouraging
404: fact is that SNe Ia, which, being the most luminous type of SNe, usually dominate
405: flux-limited SN surveys, are unlikely to appear similar to stripped-core events,
406: even if highly extinguished ($A_V > 1$ mag).
407:
408: \begin{figure*}
409: \includegraphics[width=7cm]{figure2.eps}
410: \caption{{\bf (a)}~$B-g$ vs. $V-R$ colors for SNe of
411: all types, up to $\sim1$ week past maximum
412: light. SN ages (in days) with respect to $B$-band maximum
413: light are marked. A color-cut at $B-g=0.24$ mag separates
414: stripped-core SNe from all other SNe. The error bars
415: represent extrapolation uncertainties introduced when
416: spectra do not cover the entire wavelength range
417: of a given filter. The arrow shows the reddening effect
418: corresponding to $A_V=1$ mag of dust extinction.
419: See Poznanski et al. (2002) for a full discussion.
420: {\bf (b)}~$g-V$ vs. $V-R$ colors for SNe up to $\sim1$ week
421: past maximum light, but for SNe at $z=0.05$.
422: A color-cut at $g-V\sim0.16$ mag separates stripped-core SNe
423: from most other events. {\bf (c)}~$B-g$ vs. $V-R$ colors for SNe of
424: all types, up to $\approx$ two weeks past maximum
425: light. Note that SNe of type II-P, IIb, Ic and Ib
426: attain approximately the same colors $\approx2$ weeks
427: after maximum.}
428: \end{figure*}
429:
430: %\begin{figure*}
431: %\includegraphics[width=17cm]{figure3.eps}
432: %\caption{$g-V$ vs. $V-R$ colors for SNe up to $\sim1$ week
433: %past maximum light, but for SNe at $z=0.05$.
434: %A color-cut at $g-V\sim0.16$ mag separates stripped-core SNe
435: %from most other events.}
436: %\end{figure*}
437:
438: Classification of SNe becomes harder as they become
439: older. Figure 2(c) shows $B-g$ vs. $V-R$
440: color curves computed for SNe of all types, at $z=0$,
441: up to $\sim2$ weeks past maximum light. We can see
442: that SN 1998bw can still be easily distinguished from all
443: other types of SNe. While SNe~Ia, between $10 - 14$ days
444: past maximum, have similar colors to those of SN 1998bw
445: before maximum light, elementary photometric information
446: (i.e., if the SN is rising or declining in brightness)
447: will differentiate between these two options. We note that
448: highly reddened SNe Ia (with $A_V > 1$ mag),
449: around two weeks after peak brightness,
450: could perfectly mimic SN 1998bw, both in color and in
451: photometric behavior. However, SNe Ia are usually detected
452: in relatively dust-poor environments, so such events are
453: very rare. Type II-P and IIb
454: SNe during their second week past maximum have similar
455: colors to SNe~Ib and Ic and also to those of SN 2002ap
456: at similar ages ($B-g \approx V-R \approx 0.4$ mag).
457: Thus, these types cannot be disentangled using these colors alone.
458:
459: %\begin{figure*}
460: %\includegraphics[width=17cm]{figure4.eps}
461: %\caption{$B-g$ vs. $V-R$ colors for SNe of
462: %all types, up to $\approx$ two weeks past maximum
463: %light. Note that SNe of type II-P, IIb, Ic and Ib
464: %attain approximately the same colors $\approx2$ weeks
465: %after maximum.}
466: %\end{figure*}
467:
468: \section{Young, Nearby SNe -- Current Status and
469: Potential Improvement}
470:
471: In order to utilize the method described above for prompt
472: identification of stripped-core SNe, one needs to secure
473: accurate, multi-band photometry of each new nearby SN,
474: as soon as possible after discovery. Stripped-core SNe of
475: all kinds, close to peak brightness, are expected
476: to be brighter than $\sim16$ mag ($\sim20$ mag) at $z=0.01$ ($z=0.05$)
477: in the $B$, $g$, $V$ and $R$ bands.
478: Using the web exposure-time calculator for the $1.54$m Danish
479: telescope at ESO as an example, we find that a four-band
480: photometry sequence for a $20$ mag source could be obtained
481: in less than $10$ minutes ($35$ minutes) with $S/N$ of $20$ ($50$).
482: Thus, photometry at the required level of accuracy, as
483: specified above, could be easily obtained with a $1$~m class
484: telescope. Since less than a single suitable young SN per day is
485: currently discovered, an early photometric classification
486: program could be maintained at such a facility using only a small
487: fraction of the available telescope time.
488:
489: To assess the possible impact of such a prompt
490: color-classification program, we inspect a SN sample
491: comprised of all nearby ($z \simlt 0.05$) SNe detected
492: and reported in the IAU Circulars during the year 2002. We
493: further limit our sample to SNe for which
494: the reported photometry can be used to constrain the
495: date of explosion. Specifically, we have compiled all those events
496: for which the age at discovery could be constrained by
497: pre-explosion images to be less than $\sim1$ month.
498: Considering SN rise times (i.e., the time between
499: explosion and peak brightness, typically between
500: one and three weeks) and the fact that most of these
501: SNe exploded some time after the reported non-detections,
502: we estimate that this sample is comprised mostly of SNe
503: that are within one week from peak brightness. We have
504: to select young SNe using an upper limit on the time since
505: explosion, instead of their age relative to peak brightness
506: (as done in the previous section), since the peak date is usually not reported
507: in the IAU Circulars, and is often unknown or poorly constrained.
508:
509: In Figure 3 we plot, for the SN sample described above (blue) and
510: for stripped-core events only (red), the distribution
511: of delay times between SN discovery and the date of the first
512: spectroscopic observation. As this histogram shows, spectra of only about
513: half of the SNe are obtained promptly (within $\sim5$ days).
514: Spectroscopic observations of the rest of these ``young'' SNe (i.e., which were
515: discovered at an early age) are unfortunately secured only at much later dates.
516: Comparing the blue and red histograms, we see that the distribution
517: of delays between SN discovery and
518: spectroscopic follow-up for stripped-core events is the same as
519: the distribution found for the general SN population, as can be expected
520: in the case where no priors are used in the selection of events for
521: spectroscopic follow-up. Similar results were found in an analysis
522: of SNe reported in IAU circulars in the last 5 years (1998-2002) by
523: E. Cappellaro (2004, private communication).
524: It should be noted that the delay times
525: shown in Fig. 3 are between the date of discovery and the date the
526: first spectrum was obtained. In reality, further delay (of typically a few days)
527: in the study of interesting events is caused by the time required to analyze
528: the spectra, report them to the IAU, and for the IAU to distribute
529: this information.
530:
531: This analysis demonstrates the potential contribution of early
532: photometric identification to the studies of SNe in general, and
533: stripped-core SNe in particular. Of the $19$ stripped-core events
534: discovered probably within 7 days from peak magnitude during the year
535: 2002, only $11$ were identified as such within 5 days from discovery,
536: using the combined spectroscopic resources of the entire SN-research
537: community, which are unlikely to be significantly expanded in the coming
538: few years. Thus, studies such as the ones described in $\S~2$ were
539: limited to only $58\%$ of those stripped-core SNe which happened to be
540: discovered early. Implementing the photometric identification
541: procedures outlined in $\S~3$ using a $1$~m class telescope could have
542: practically doubled the sample of objects available for this type of research.
543:
544: \begin{figure*}
545: \includegraphics[width=17cm]{figure3.eps}
546: \caption{The distribution of delay times (in days) between the
547: SN discovery and the date of the first spectroscopic observation,
548: for all ``young'' SNe (see text) discovered during 2002 (blue)
549: and for the subset of stripped-core SNe (red).}
550: \end{figure*}
551:
552: \section{Conclusions}
553:
554: The emerging connection between stripped-core SNe and GRBs
555: is likely to revitalize the study of this class of SNe. The
556: rareness and relative faintness of these events has so far
557: held back advancements in systematic studies of their
558: properties, which would probably help
559: understanding their relation to GRBs and the underlying
560: physics. In particular, studies possible only
561: while these SNe are young (i.e., at, or preferably before,
562: maximum light) have been hindered by frequent delays
563: between the discovery, spectroscopic type determination, and
564: the announcement of the type in IAU circulars.
565:
566: To facilitate prompt classification of young stripped-core SN candidates using
567: broad-band colors, we have added the spectra
568: of SN 1998bw, associated with GRB 980425, and the similar SN 1998bw-like
569: SN 2002ap, to the spectroscopic data base of Poznanski et al. (2002).
570: We have applied the methods of these authors to this expanded data base,
571: and have studied in detail methods to classify young (around peak, or before)
572: and nearby ($z\le0.05$) SNe. We have shown that stripped-core events
573: can be efficiently selected using four-band photometry focused
574: on the bluer bands. We have also demonstrated that the required photometric accuracy
575: can be obtained with a $1$~m class telescope, and that reddening effects
576: do not significantly compromise our analysis. Application
577: of this method to the SN population discovered by current SN surveys will probably
578: double the number of young stripped-core SNe identified at or before
579: peak magnitude, and, combined with current SN spectroscopy programs,
580: will supply about $20$ new targets each year for
581: detailed follow-up studies in radio, optical, and X-ray bands.
582:
583: \section*{Acknowledgments}
584:
585: D. Fox, A. MacFadyen, F. Patat and A. Soderberg
586: are thanked for help, advice, and data used in this work.
587: A.G. acknowledges support by NASA through Hubble Fellowship grant
588: \#HST-HF-01158.01-A awarded by STScI, which is operated by AURA, Inc.,
589: for NASA, under contract NAS 5-26555. D.M. acknowledges support by the
590: Israel Science Foundation --- the Jack Adler Foundation for Space Research,
591: grant 63/01-1. A.V.F. is grateful for the financial support of NSF grants
592: AST 94-17213 and AST 99-87438, as well as of the Guggenheim
593: Foundation.
594:
595: %% If you wish to include an acknowledgments section in your paper,
596: %% separate it off from the body of the text using the \acknowledgments
597: %% command.
598:
599: %% Included in this acknowledgments section are examples of the
600: %% AASTeX hypertext markup commands. Use \url without the optional [HREF]
601: %% argument when you want to print the url directly in the text. Otherwise,
602: %% use either \url or \anchor, with the HREF as the first argument and the
603: %% text to be printed in the second.
604:
605: %% The reference list follows the main body and any appendices.
606: %% Use LaTeX's thebibliography environment to mark up your reference list.
607: %% Note \begin{thebibliography} is followed by an empty set of
608: %% curly braces. If you forget this, LaTeX will generate the error
609: %% "Perhaps a missing \item?".
610: %%
611: %% thebibliography produces citations in the text using \bibitem-\cite
612: %% cross-referencing. Each reference is preceded by a
613: %% \bibitem command that defines in curly braces the KEY that corresponds
614: %% to the KEY in the \cite commands (see the first section above).
615: %% Make sure that you provide a unique KEY for every \bibitem or else the
616: %% paper will not LaTeX. The square brackets should contain
617: %% the citation text that LaTeX will insert in
618: %% place of the \cite commands.
619:
620: %% We have used macros to produce journal name abbreviations.
621: %% AASTeX provides a number of these for the more frequently-cited journals.
622: %% See the Author Guide for a list of them.
623:
624: %% Note that the style of the \bibitem labels (in []) is slightly
625: %% different from previous examples. The natbib system solves a host
626: %% of citation expression problems, but it is necessary to clearly
627: %% delimit the year from the author name used in the citation.
628: %% See the natbib documentation for more details and options.
629:
630: \begin{thebibliography}{}
631:
632: \bibitem{} Aldering, G., Humphreys, R.~M., \& Richmond, M.\ 1994, \aj, 107, 662
633: \bibitem{} Berger, E., Kulkarni, S.~R., Frail, D.~A., \& Soderberg, A.~M.\ 2003, \apj, 599, 408
634: \bibitem{} Fassia, A., et al.\ 2001, \mnras, 325, 907
635: \bibitem{} Filippenko, A.~V.,~et al.\ 1995, \apjl, 450, L11
636: \bibitem{} Filippenko, A.~V.\ 1997, \araa, 35, 309
637: \bibitem{} Foley, R.~J.,~et al.\ 2003, \pasp, 115, 1220
638: \bibitem{} Galama, T.~J.,~et al.\ 1998, \nat, 395, 670
639: \bibitem{} Gal-Yam, A., Ofek, E.~O., \& Shemmer, O.\ 2002, \mnras, 332, L73
640: \bibitem{} Gal-Yam, A., \& Shemmer, O.\ 2001, \iaucirc, 7602
641: \bibitem{} Hamuy, M.,~et al.\ 2001, \apj, 558, 615
642: \bibitem{} Hamuy, M.,~et al.\ 2002, \aj, 124, 417
643: \bibitem{} Hjorth, J.,~et al.\ 2003, \nat, 423, 847
644: \bibitem{} Iwamoto, K.,~et al.\ 1998, \nat, 395, 672
645: \bibitem{} Khokhlov, A.~M., H{\" o}flich, P.~A., Oran, E.~S., Wheeler, J.~C., Wang, L., \& Chtchelkanova, A.~Y.\ 1999, \apjl, 524, L107
646: \bibitem{} Leonard, D.~C., et al.\ 2002, \pasp, 114, 35
647: \bibitem{} Leonard, D.~C., Filippenko, A.~V., Barth, A.~J., \& Matheson, T.\ 2000, \apj, 536, 239
648: \bibitem{} Lipkin, Y.~M.~et al.\ 2003, ApJ, in press, ArXiv Astrophysics e-prints, astro-ph/0312594
649: \bibitem{} MacFadyen, A.~I.,~\& Woosley, S.~E.\ 1999, \apj, 524, 262
650: \bibitem{} MacFadyen, A.~I.\ 2003, From Twilight to Highlight: The Physics of Supernovae, p. 97, Eds.
651: Hillenbrandt \& Leibundgut, Springer, astro-ph/0301425
652: \bibitem{} Matheson, T., Filippenko, A.~V., Li, W., Leonard, D.~C., \& Shields, J.~C.\ 2001, \aj, 121, 1648
653: \bibitem{} Matheson, T.,~et al.\ 2003, \apj, 599, 394
654: \bibitem{} Mazzali, P.~A.,~et al. 2003, \apjl, 599, L95
655: \bibitem{} Minkowski, R.\ 1941, \pasp, 53, 224
656: \bibitem{} Patat, F.,~et al.\ 2001, \apj, 555, 900
657: \bibitem{} Poznanski, D., Gal-Yam, A., Maoz, D., Filippenko, A.~V., Leonard, D.~C., \& Matheson, T.\ 2002, \pasp, 114, 833
658: \bibitem{} Qiu, Y., Li, W., Qiao, Q., \& Hu, J.\ 1999, \aj, 117, 736
659: \bibitem{} Riess, A.~G.,~et al.\ 2004, \apjl, 600, L163
660: \bibitem{} Smartt, S.~J., Maund, J.~R., Hendry, M.~A., Tout, C.~A., Gilmore, G.~F., Mattila, S., \& Benn, C.~R.\ 2004, Science, 303, 499
661: \bibitem{} Soderberg, A.~M., Frail, D.~A., \& Wieringa, M.~H.\ 2004, ArXiv Astrophysics e-prints, astro-ph/0402163
662: \bibitem{} Soderberg, A.~M.,~et al.\ 2004, in preparation
663: \bibitem{} Stanek, K.~Z.,~et al.\ 2003, \apjl, 591, L17
664: \bibitem{} Takada-Hidai, M., Aoki, W., \& Zhao, G.\ 2002, \pasj, 54, 899
665: \bibitem{} Van Dyk, S.~D., Hamuy, M., \& Filippenko, A.~V.\ 1996, \aj, 111, 2017
666: \bibitem{} Van Dyk, S.~D., Li, W., \& Filippenko, A.~V.\ 2003, \pasp, 115, 1289
667: \bibitem{} White, G.~L.,~\& Malin, D.~F.\ 1987, \nat, 327, 36
668: \bibitem{} Woosley, S.~E.\ 1993, \apj, 405, 273
669: \bibitem{} Woosley, S.~E., Eastman, R.~G., \& Schmidt, B.~P.\ 1999, \apj, 516, 788
670: \bibitem{} Woosley, S.~E.~\& Heger, A.\ 2003, ApJ, submitted, ArXiv Astrophysics e-prints, astro-ph/0309165
671:
672:
673:
674:
675: \end{thebibliography}
676:
677: \clearpage
678: \begin{deluxetable}{clccc}
679: \tabletypesize{\scriptsize}
680: \tablecaption{SN Spectral Database \label{database table}}
681: \tablewidth{17cm}
682: \tablehead{
683: \colhead{Type} & \colhead{SNe} & \colhead{Epochs} & \colhead{Redshift}&
684: \colhead{References\tablenotemark{a}}
685: }
686: \startdata
687: Ia & 1994D & 22 & 0.0015 & 1,2 \\
688: & 1987L & 2 & 0.0074 & 1\\
689: & 1995D & 4 & 0.0066 & 2\\
690: & 1999dk & 5 & 0.0150 & 2\\
691: & 1999ee & 12 & 0.0114 & 3\\
692: Ib & 1984L & 12 & 0.0051& 1,2 \\
693: & 1991ar & 1 & 0.0152 & 4 \\
694: & 1998dt & 2 & 0.0150 & 4 \\
695: & 1999di & 1 & 0.0164 & 4 \\
696: & 1999dn & 3 & 0.0093 & 4 \\
697: Ic & 1994I & 14 & 0.0015 & 1,5 \\
698: & 1990U & 8 & 0.0079 & 4 \\
699: & 1990B & 4 & 0.0075 & 4 \\
700: II-P & 1999em & 27 & 0.0024 & 6\\
701: & 1992H & 13 & 0.0060 & 1,2\\
702: & 2001X & 12 & 0.0049 & 2,7\\
703: IIn & 1998S & 13 & 0.0030 & 8,9\\
704: & 1994Y & 1 & 0.0080 & 1 \\
705: & 1994ak & 1 & 0.0085 & 1 \\
706: IIb & 1993J & 12 & 0 & 1 \\
707: & 1996cb & 3 & 0.0024 & 10 \\
708: \tableline
709: Ic (98bw-like)& 1998bw & 25 & 0.0085 & 11\\
710: & 2002ap & 19 & 0.0022 & 12,13\\
711: \tableline
712: Total & & 216 &&\\
713: \enddata
714: \tablecomments{Data from Poznanski et al. (2002) listed in the
715: upper part of the table.
716: Spectra of SN 1998bw and SN 2002ap added in work study are listed
717: below. No extinction corrections were applied.
718: SNe studied by Poznanski et al. (2002) were selected to avoid
719: highly extinguished events. Low extinction values are also
720: reported for SN 1998bw ($A_V\le0.2$; Patat et al. 2001)
721: and for SN 2002ap ($A_V\le0.1$; Takada-Hidai, Aoki, \& Zhao, 2002).}
722: \tablenotetext{a}{
723: (1) Filippenko 1997; (2) Unpublished spectra by Filippenko and collaborators,
724: obtained and reduced as those presented in (1), (4)--(6) and (8);
725: (3) Hamuy et al. 2002; (4) Matheson et al. 2001; (5) Filippenko et al. 1995b;
726: (6) Leonard et al. 2002; (7) Gal-Yam \& Shemmer
727: 2001; (8) Leonard et al. 2000; (9) Fassia et al. 2001; (10) Qiu et al. 1999;
728: (11) Patat et al. 2001; (12) Gal-Yam, Ofek, \& Shemmer 2002; (13)
729: Foley et al. 2003.\\}
730: \end{deluxetable}
731:
732: %% Use the figure environment and \plotone or \plottwo to include
733: %% figures and captions in your electronic submission.
734:
735: \end{document}
736:
737:
738:
739:
740: