1: %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%
2: %% ws-procs9x6.tex : 10 October 2003
3: %% Text file to use with ws-procs9x6.cls written in Latex2E.
4: %% The content, structure, format and layout of this style file is the
5: %% property of World Scientific Publishing Co. Pte. Ltd.
6: %% Copyright 1995, 2002 by World Scientific Publishing Co.
7: %% All rights are reserved.
8: %%
9: %% Proceedings Trim Size: 9in x 6in
10: %% Text Area: 7.35in (include runningheads) x 4.5in
11: %% Main Text is 10/13pt
12: %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%
13:
14: %\documentclass[draft]{ws-procs9x6}
15: \documentclass{ws-procs9x6}
16:
17: %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%
18: % My Definitions
19: \newcommand{\ltsima}{$\; \buildrel < \over \sim \;$}
20: \newcommand{\simlt}{\lower.5ex\hbox{\ltsima}}
21: \newcommand{\gtsima}{$\; \buildrel > \over \sim \;$}
22: \newcommand{\simgt}{\lower.5ex\hbox{\gtsima}}
23: \newcommand{\ls}{{_<\atop^{\sim}}}
24: \newcommand{\lax}{{_<\atop^{\sim}}}
25: \newcommand{\gs}{{_>\atop^{\sim}}}
26: \newcommand{\gax}{{_>\atop^{\sim}}}
27: \newcommand{\cgs}{ ${\rm erg~cm}^{-2}~{\rm s}^{-1}$}
28: \newcommand{\lum}{\rm erg~s$^{-1}$}
29: %\newcommand{\ion}{\rm erg~cm~s$^{-1}$}
30: \newcommand{\pn}{\par\noindent}
31: \newcommand{\bs}{\bigskip}
32: \newcommand{\ms}{\medskip}
33: \newcommand{\ssk}{\smallskip}
34: \def\sun{\hbox{$\odot$}}
35: \def\earth{\hbox{$\oplus$}}
36: \def\lesssim{\mathrel{\hbox{\rlap{\hbox{\lower4pt\hbox{$\sim$}}}\hbox{$<$}}}}
37: \def\gtrsim{\mathrel{\hbox{\rlap{\hbox{\lower4pt\hbox{$\sim$}}}\hbox{$>$}}}}
38: \def\sq{\hbox{\rlap{$\sqcap$}$\sqcup$}}
39: \def\arcdeg{\hbox{$^\circ$}}
40: \def\arcmin{\hbox{$^\prime$}}
41: \def\arcsec{\hbox{$^{\prime\prime}$}}
42: \def\micron{\hbox{$\mu$m}}
43: \def\ubvr{\hbox{$U\!BV\!R$}}
44: \def\ub{\hbox{$U\!-\!B$}}
45: \def\bv{\hbox{$B\!-\!V$}}
46: \def\vr{\hbox{$V\!-\!R$}}
47: \def\ur{\hbox{$U\!-\!R$}}
48: \def\aox{$\alpha_{\rm ox}$}
49: \def\lo{$\log~L_{\rm O}$}
50: \def\loo{{\rm $l_{o}$}}
51: \def\lx{$\log~L_{\rm X}$}
52: \def\lxx{{\rm $l_{x}$}}
53: \def\lumh{\rm erg s$^{-1}$ Hz$^{-1}$}
54: \def\ab1450{$AB_{1450(1+z)}$}
55: \def\todo{{\LARGE $\bullet$}}
56: \def\xray{\hbox{X-ray}}
57: \def\feka{Fe\ K$\alpha$}
58: \def\oviii{\hbox{O\ {\sc viii}}}
59: \def\ovii{\hbox{O\ {\sc vii}}}
60: %\def\fs{$F_{\rm 0.5-2\ keV}$}
61: %\def\fh{$F_{\rm 2-10\ keV}$}
62: \def\mb{$M_{\rm B}$~}
63: \def\today{\ifcase\month\or January\or February\or March\or April\or May\or
64: June\or July\or August\or September\or October\or November\or December\fi
65: \space\number\day, \number\year}
66: %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%
67: % Missions definitions
68: %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%
69: \def\asca{{\it ASCA\/}}
70: \def\chandra{{\it Chandra\/}}
71: \def\conx{{\it Constellation-X\/}}
72: \def\genx{{\it Generation-X\/}}
73: \def\euve{{\it {\it EUVE}\/}}
74: \def\fuse{{\it {\it FUSE}\/}}
75: \def\einstein{{\it Einstein\/}}
76: \def\exosat{{\it EXOSAT\/}}
77: \def\ginga{{\it Ginga\/}}
78: \def\heao1{{\it HEAO-1\/}}
79: \def\hst{{\it {\it HST}\/}}
80: \def\iras{{\it IRAS\/}}
81: \def\iue{{\it IUE\/}}
82: \def\rosat{{\it ROSAT\/}}
83: \def\rxte{{\it RXTE\/}}
84: \def\sax{{\it BeppoSAX\/}}
85: \def\xeus{{\it XEUS\/}}
86: \def\xmm{{XMM-{\it Newton\/}}}
87: \def\xte{{\it XTE\/}}
88: %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%
89: %Journal Definitions
90: \def\apj{{\it ApJ}}
91: \def\apjs{{\it ApJS}}
92: \def\aap{{\it A\&A}}
93: \def\aj{{\it AJ}}
94: \def\mnras{{\it MNRAS}}
95: \def\nat{{\it Nature}}
96: \def\apjl{{\it ApJL}}
97: \def\aaps{{\it A\&AS}}
98: \def\araa{{\it Ann. Rev. Astron. Astroph.}}
99: \def\pasp{{\it PASP}}
100: \def\pasj{{\it PASJ}}
101: \def\newastr{{\it New Astr.}}
102: \def\etal{{\it et al.}}
103: %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%
104: \hyphenation{in-cre-di-ble}
105: %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%
106:
107: \begin{document}
108:
109: %\title{X-ray emission from high-redshift quasars: a \chandra\ and \xmm\
110: %update}
111: \title{
112: %News from outer space: \\
113: The \boldmath$z>4$ quasar population observed by Chandra and XMM-Newton}
114:
115: \author{C. VIGNALI\footnote{\uppercase{W}ork partially supported by the
116: \uppercase{I}talian \uppercase{S}pace \uppercase{A}gency under the contract
117: \uppercase{ASI} \uppercase{I/R}/057/02 \uppercase{(CV)}
118: and by the \uppercase{C}handra \uppercase{X}-ray
119: \uppercase{C}enter grant \uppercase{GO}2-3134\uppercase{X} \uppercase{(WNB)}.}}
120:
121: \address{INAF--Osservatorio Astronomico di Bologna, \\
122: Via Ranzani, 1 -- I-40127 Bologna, Italy \\
123: %E-mail: l\_vignali@bo.astro.it}
124: E-mail: cristian.vignali@bo.astro.it}
125:
126: \author{W.N. BRANDT and D.P. SCHNEIDER}
127:
128: \address{Department of Astronomy \& Astrophysics, \\
129: The Pennsylvania State University, \\
130: 525 Davey Lab, University Park, PA 16802, USA \\
131: E-mail: niel,dps@astro.psu.edu}
132:
133:
134: %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%
135: % You may repeat \author \address as often as necessary %
136: %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%
137:
138: \maketitle
139:
140: \abstracts{
141: The current status of our \chandra\ and \xmm\ project on
142: high-redshift ($z\simgt4$) quasars is briefly reviewed.
143: We report the main results obtained in the last
144: few years for the \xray\ detected quasars, along with
145: a few ($\approx$~10\%) intriguing cases where no
146: detection has been obtained with \chandra\ snapshot observations.
147: }
148:
149: \section{Introduction}
150: Quasars at $z\simgt4$ provide direct information on the first massive
151: structures to form in the Universe. The last few years have evidenced
152: incredible progress in the study of the high-redshift
153: Universe, largely thanks to ground-based optical surveys.
154: In particular, the Sloan Digital Sky Survey (SDSS\cite{y00})
155: has discovered large numbers of high-redshift quasars, increasing the
156: number of known quasars at $z\simgt4$ to $>500$,\cite{f04}
157: and many more are expected to be discovered
158: before the survey ends (see [3]
159: %will come to an end\cite{ab04}
160: for the recent advances provided by the SDSS).
161: Many of the high-redshift quasars discovered by recent optical surveys
162: are suitable for follow-up \xray\ investigations. Here we review \xray\
163: studies of the highest redshift quasars, focusing on recent advances enabled
164: largely by the imaging and spectroscopic capabilities of \chandra\ and \xmm.
165:
166:
167: %\section{X-ray results}
168: \section{X-ray detections at $z\simgt4$}
169: Our knowledge of the \xray\ properties of $z\simgt4$ quasars has advanced
170: rapidly over the last few years. Since the pioneering work based on the
171: systematic analysis of archival \rosat\ data\cite{kbs00}, where the number
172: of \xray\ detected quasars at $z>4$ doubled, the progress made in this field
173: has been substantial (see Fig.~1).
174: At present, more than 90 quasars at $z\simgt4$ have \xray\
175: detections;\footnote{See
176: http://www.astro.psu.edu/users/niel/papers/highz-xray-detected.dat for a
177: regularly updated listing of \xray\ detections and sensitive upper limits
178: at $z\simgt4$.} while in most cases \chandra\ snapshot
179: (typically \hbox{4--6~ks}) observations have allowed derivation of
180: basic \xray\ information (\xray\ fluxes and
181: luminosities),\cite{b01,v01,b02,sil02,be03,v03a,v03b,cas03,tre03}
182: for a few \xray\ luminous objects medium-quality \xray\ spectra
183: have also been obtained\cite{fb03,gr04} thanks to the large collecting area
184: of \xmm.
185: %
186: %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%
187: % Figure 1 - two panels: (a) Fx vs. AB1450(1+z) just after KBS00 work
188: % (b) Fx vs. AB1450(1+z): present situation
189: \begin{figure}[t]
190: \parbox{0.48\textwidth}
191: {\psfig{figure=fxab_kbs00.eps,width=14pc,angle=0}}
192: \hglue-0.8cm
193: % \hglue=-0.8cm if width=14pc and fxab_now_nolabel.eps is used
194: % otherwise: USE no space, width=13pc, and fxab_now,eps
195: \parbox{0.48\textwidth}
196: {\psfig{figure=fxab_now_nolabel.eps,width=14pc,angle=0}}
197: \caption{Observed-frame, Galactic absorption-corrected 0.5--2~keV flux versus
198: \ab1450\ magnitude for $z\simgt4$ AGN found in optical (triangles) and
199: \xray\ (squares) surveys. The rapid increase in the number of \xray\
200: detected AGN at $z\simgt4$ is evident when the two panels (i.e., the
201: situation in year 2000 vs. the current one) are compared.
202: Most of the upper limits have
203: been obtained from archival \rosat\ observations.}%\cite{kbs00,v01,v03a}
204: \label{fig1}
205: \end{figure}
206: %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%
207: %
208: From a general perspective, the most important results from \xray\
209: analyses of high-redshift quasars are the following:
210: %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%
211: % Summary of main X-ray results on high-z QSOs
212: %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%
213: \pn
214: $\diamond$ The \xray\ properties of $z\simgt4$ quasars are similar to
215: those of local quasars. Joint \xray\ spectral fitting of optically
216: luminous quasars at $z\simgt4$ selected from the Palomar Digital Sky Survey
217: (DPOSS\cite{dj98}) and the SDSS has shown\cite{v03a,v03b} that
218: quasar \xray\ continuum shapes
219: do not show evidence for significant spectral evolution over cosmic time.
220: This has found further support recently via joint spectral fitting of a
221: sample of 46 radio-quiet quasars (RQQs) with \chandra\ detections
222: in the redshift range 4.0--6.3 ($\approx$~750 source counts;
223: \hbox{$\Gamma=1.9\pm{0.1}$})\cite{vbs04} and by direct
224: \xray\ spectral analyses of a few objects observed by \xmm.\cite{fb03,gr04}
225: No evidence for widespread \xray\ absorption has been found,
226: although some quasars (see discussion below) are likely to be obscured.
227: \pn
228: $\diamond$ The optical-to-\xray\ properties of high-redshift
229: quasars and those of local quasars have been found similar, once
230: luminosity effects and selection biases are taken
231: into account properly.\cite{vbs03}
232: %%
233: %Significant differences between the high-redshift
234: %quasar population and the local one have been found in their broad-band
235: %properties using the SDSS Early Data Release quasar catalog;\cite{dps02}
236: %detailed investigations on a well-selected and homogeneous sample
237: %have confirmed previous results indicating that
238: %these difference are due to luminosity effects.\cite{vbs03}
239: %%
240: %\pn
241: %$\diamond$ \xray\ spectral studies do not show hints for different accretion
242: %and growth mechanisms, such as accretion-disk instabilities
243: %and trapping-radius effects.
244: %\pn
245: Overall, the emerging picture is that the small-scale \xray\ emission
246: regions of quasars appear relatively insensitive to large-scale environmental
247: differences at $z\approx$~6.
248: \pn
249: $\diamond$ Moderately deep \chandra\ observations and the ultra-deep (2~Ms)
250: survey in the \chandra\ Deep Field-North (CDF-N)\cite{ale03} have
251: allowed \xray\ studies of moderate-luminosity AGN at $z>4$;
252: this population of AGN is more numerous and thus more
253: representative than the rare, highly luminous quasars.\cite{v02}
254: \pn
255: $\diamond$ Similarly to the results obtained for the RQQs, neither the
256: \xray\ spectral slope ($\Gamma=1.65\pm{0.15}$) nor the jet emission
257: of the radio-loud quasar population seems to evolve with
258: cosmic time.\cite{bas04}
259: No evidence for significant \xray\ brightening ascribed to
260: inverse Compton scattering of energetic electrons
261: with Cosmic Microwave Background photons
262: has been revealed by snapshot observations with \chandra.\cite{bas04}
263:
264:
265: \section{X-ray non-detections: space oddities at high redshift?}
266: At present, the fraction of \xray\ upper limits among the sensitive \chandra\
267: and \xmm\ observations of high-redshift quasars is low ($\approx$~10\%).
268: About half of the \xray\ undetected quasars are broad
269: absorption-line quasars (BALQSOs), which are known to be absorbed
270: in the \xray\ band;\cite{blw00} one quasar shows narrow absorption
271: features from N\,{\sc v} and Ly$\alpha$ at approximately the
272: source redshift.\cite{v03b}
273: For most of these objects the lack of \xray\ detections at the flux
274: limits reached by \chandra\ with snapshot observations is likely due to
275: absorption by column densities larger\cite{v01,v03b}
276: than $\approx$~10$^{23}$~cm$^{-2}$
277: (assuming reasonable values for the optical-to-\xray\ spectral energy
278: distribution and \xray\ photon index).
279: It is possible that the remaining \xray\ undetected high-redshift quasars
280: are characterized by absorption features not recognized in low-resolution
281: optical spectra. Recently, it has been shown that
282: near-infrared spectroscopy can be highly effective\cite{ma04}
283: in detecting absorption features in high-redshift objects
284: previously classified as ``normal'' quasars.
285: Clearly, minority AGN populations at $z>4$ need to be investigated better
286: in the \xray\ regime. These include
287: %moderate-luminosity AGN,
288: BALQSOs (whose number is still too limited to derive statistically
289: reliable average properties) and the population of quasars
290: lacking emission lines.\cite{fan99,v01}
291: Follow-up observations of quasars without optical emission lines
292: with \chandra\ are on-going and the results will be presented in a
293: forthcoming paper.\cite{br04}
294:
295: \begin{thebibliography}{0}
296: %%%
297: \bibitem{y00}
298: D.G. York \etal, \aj\ {\bf 120}, 1579 (2000).
299: %
300: \bibitem{f04}
301: X. Fan, private communication (2004).
302: %
303: \bibitem{ab04}
304: K. Abazajian \etal, \aj, in press, astro-ph/0403325 (2004).
305: %
306: \bibitem{kbs00}
307: S. Kaspi, W.N. Brandt and D.P. Schneider, \aj\ {\bf 119}, 2031 (2000; KBS00).
308: %
309: \bibitem{b01}
310: %W.N. Brandt, M. Guainazzi, S. Kaspi, X. Fan, D.P. Schneider,
311: %M.A. Strauss, J. Clavel and J.E. Gunn, \aj\ {\bf 121}, 591 (2001).
312: W.N. Brandt \etal, \aj\ {\bf 121}, 591 (2001).
313: %
314: \bibitem{v01}
315: C. Vignali, W.N. Brandt, X. Fan, J.E. Gunn, S. Kaspi, D.P. Schneider and
316: M.A. Strauss, \aj\ {\bf 122}, 2143 (2001).
317: %
318: \bibitem{b02}
319: W.N. Brandt \etal, \apj\ {\bf 569}, L5 (2002).
320: %
321: \bibitem{sil02}
322: J.D. Silverman \etal, \apj\ {\bf 569}, L1 (2002).
323: %
324: \bibitem{be03}
325: J. Bechtold \etal, \apj\ {\bf 588}, 119 (2003).
326: %
327: \bibitem{v03a}
328: C. Vignali, W.N. Brandt, D.P. Schneider, G.P. Garmire and S. Kaspi,
329: \aj\ {\bf 125}, 418 (2003).
330: %
331: \bibitem{v03b}
332: C. Vignali \etal, \aj\ {\bf 125}, 2876 (2003).
333: %
334: \bibitem{cas03}
335: F.J. Castander, E. Treister, T.J. Maccarone, P.S. Coppi,
336: J. Maza, S.E. Zepf and R. Guzman, \aj\ {\bf 125}, 1689 (2003).
337: %
338: \bibitem{tre03}
339: E. Treister, F.J. Castander, T.J. Maccarone, D. Herrera, E. Gawiser, J. Maza
340: and P.S. Coppi, \apj\ {\bf 603}, 36 (2004).
341: %
342: \bibitem{fb03}
343: E. Ferrero and W. Brinkmann, \aap\ {\bf 402}, 465 (2003).
344: %
345: \bibitem{gr04}
346: D. Grupe, S. Mathur, B.J. Wilkes and M. Elvis, \aj\ {\bf 127}, 1 (2004).
347: %
348: \bibitem{dj98}
349: S.G. Djorgovski \etal, in Proceedings of ``Wide Field Surveys in Cosmology'',
350: %ed. S. Colombi, \& Y. Mellier (Paris: Editions Frontieres),
351: 89 (1998).
352: %
353: \bibitem{vbs04}
354: C. Vignali, W.N. Brandt and D.P. Schneider, in Proceedings of
355: ``AGN Physics with the Sloan Digital Sky Survey'', in press,
356: astro-ph/0310659 (2004).
357: %
358: \bibitem{vbs03}
359: C. Vignali, W.N. Brandt and D.P. Schneider, \aj\ {\bf 125}, 433 (2003).
360: %
361: \bibitem{ale03}
362: D.M. Alexander \etal, \aj\ {\bf 126}, 539 (2003).
363: %
364: \bibitem{v02}
365: C. Vignali, F.E. Bauer, D.M. Alexander, W.N. Brandt, A.E. Hornschemeier,
366: D.P. Schneider and G.P. Garmire, \apj\ {\bf 580}, L105 (2002).
367: %
368: %\bibitem{dps02}D.P. Schneider \etal, \aj\ {\bf 123}, 567 (2002).
369: %
370: \bibitem{bas04}
371: L.C. Bassett, W.N. Brandt, D.P. Schneider, C. Vignali and G.P. Garmire,
372: \aj, in press, astro-ph/0404543 (2004).
373: %
374: \bibitem{blw00}
375: W.N. Brandt, A. Laor and B.J. Wills, \apj\ {\bf 528}, 637 (2000).
376: %
377: \bibitem{ma04}
378: R. Maiolino, E. Oliva, F. Ghinassi, M. Pedani, F. Mannucci, R. Mujica and
379: Y. Juarez, \aap, in press, astro-ph/0312402 (2004).
380: %
381: %\bibitem{and01} S.F. Anderson \etal, \aj\ {\bf 122}, 503.
382: \bibitem{fan99}
383: X. Fan \etal, \apj\ {\bf 526}, L57 (1999).
384: %
385: \bibitem{br04}
386: W.N. Brandt \etal, in preparation.
387: %%%
388: \end{thebibliography}
389:
390: \end{document}
391: