1: %%
2:
3:
4: %% Beginning of file 'sample.tex'
5: %%
6: %% Modified 03 Jan 01
7: %%
8: %% This is a sample manuscript marked up using the
9: %% AASTeX v5.x LaTeX 2e macros.
10:
11: %% The first piece of markup in an AASTeX v5.x document
12: %% is the \documentclass command. LaTeX will ignore
13: %% any data that comes before this command.
14:
15: %% The command below calls the preprint style
16: %% which will produce a one-column, single-spaced document.
17: %% Examples of commands for other substyles follow. Use
18: %% whichever is most appropriate for your purposes.
19:
20: \documentclass[12pt,preprint]{aastex}
21: %%\documentclass{emulateapj}
22:
23: %% manuscript produces a one-column, double-spaced document:
24: % \documentclass[manuscript]{aastex}
25: %% preprint2 produces a double-column, single-spaced document:
26: % \documentclass[preprint2]{aastex}
27:
28:
29: %% If you want to create your own macros, you can do so
30: %% using \newcommand. Your macros should appear before
31: %% the \begin{document} command.
32: %%
33: %% If you are submitting to a journal that translates manuscripts
34:
35:
36: %% into SGML, you need to follow certain guidelines when preparing
37: %% your macros. See the AASTeX v5.x Author Guide
38: %% for information.
39:
40: %%\usepackage{pjournal}
41: \usepackage{natbib}
42: \newcommand{\idn}{ads/sa.spitzer\#0007427328}
43:
44: %% You can insert a short comment on the title page using the command below.
45:
46: \slugcomment{}%
47:
48: %% If you wish, you may supply running head information, although
49: %% this information may be modified by the editorial offices.
50: %% The left head contains a list of authors,
51: %% usually a maximum of three (otherwise use et al.). The right
52: %% head is a modified title of up to roughly 44 characters. Running heads
53: %% will not print in the manuscript style.
54:
55:
56:
57: %% This is the end of the preamble. Indicate the beginning of the
58: %% paper itself with \begin{document}.
59:
60: \begin{document}
61:
62: %% LaTeX will automatically break titles if they run longer than
63: %% one line. However, you may use \\ to force a line break if
64: %% you desire.
65: \shorttitle{Excesses in M47}
66: \shortauthors{N. Gorlova et al.}
67:
68: %________________________________________________________________
69: \title{New debris disk candidates:\\
70: 24$\micron$ stellar excesses at 100 Myr}
71:
72: %% Use \author, \affil, and the \and command to format
73: %% author and affiliation information.
74: %% Note that \email has replaced the old \authoremail command
75: %% from AASTeX v4.0. You can use \email to mark an email address
76: %% anywhere in the paper, not just in the front matter.
77: %% As in the title, use \\ to force line breaks.
78:
79: \author{Nadya Gorlova$^1$, Deborah L. Padgett$^2$, George H. Rieke$^1$, James Muzerolle$^1$, Jane E. Morrison$^1$,
80: Karl D. Gordon$^1$, Chad W. Engelbracht$^1$, Dean C. Hines$^{1, 3}$, Joannah C. Hinz$^1$, Alberto Noriega-Crespo$^2$, Luisa Rebull$^2$,
81: John A. Stansberry$^1$, Karl R. Stapelfeldt$^4$, Kate Y. L. Su$^1$, Erick T. Young$^1$ }
82:
83:
84: \affil{$^1$Steward Observatory, University of Arizona, Tucson, AZ 85721}
85: \email {ngorlova@as.arizona.edu}
86: \affil{$^2$Spitzer Science Center, California Institute of Technology, Pasadena,CA 91125}
87: \affil{$^3$Space Science Institute, Boulder, Colorado 80301}
88: \affil{$^4$Jet Propulsion Laboratory, California Institute of Technology, Pasadena, CA 91109.}
89:
90:
91: %% Notice that each of these authors has alternate affiliations, which
92: %% are identified by the \altaffilmark after each name. Specify alternate
93: %% affiliation information with \altaffiltext, with one command per each
94: %% affiliation.
95:
96:
97: %% Mark off your abstract in the ``abstract'' environment. In the manuscript
98: %% style, abstract will output a Received/Accepted line after the
99: %% title and affiliation information. No date will appear since the author
100: %% does not have this information. The dates will be filled in by the
101: %% editorial office after submission.
102:
103: \begin{abstract}
104: Sixty three members of the 100 Myr old open cluster M47 (NGC 2422) have been
105: detected
106: at 24$\micron$ with {\it Spitzer}.
107: The Be star V 378 Pup shows an excess both in the near-infrared and at 24$\mu$m ($K-[24] =
108: 2.4$ mag),
109: probably due to free-free emission from the gaseous envelope. Seven other early-type
110: stars show smaller excesses, $K-[24] = 0.6-0.9$.
111:
112:
113: Among late-type stars, two show large excesses: P922 -- a K1V star with $K-[24]
114: = 1.08 \pm 0.11$ and
115: P1121 -- an F9V star with $K-[24] = 3.72 \pm 0.02$.
116: P1121 is the first known main-sequence star showing an excess comparable to
117: that of $\beta$ Pic, which may indicate
118: the presence of an exceptionally massive debris disk. It is possible that a
119: major
120: planetesimal collision has occurred in this system, consistent with the few
121: hundred Myr time scales
122: estimated for the clearing of the Solar System.
123: \end{abstract}
124:
125: %% Keywords should appear after the \end{abstract} command. The uncommented
126: %% example has been keyed in ApJ style. See the instructions to authors
127: %% for the journal to which you are submitting your paper to determine
128: %% what keyword punctuation is appropriate.
129:
130: %% Authors who wish to have the most important objects in their paper
131: %% linked in the electronic edition to a data center may do so in the
132: %% subject header. Objects should be in the appropriate "individual"
133: %% headers (e.g. quasars: individual, stars: individual, etc.) with the
134: %% additional provision that the total number of headers, including each
135: %% individual object, not exceed six. The \objectname{} macro, and its
136: %% alias \object{}, is used to mark each object. The macro takes the object
137: %% name as its primary argument. This name will appear in the paper
138: %% and serve as the link's anchor in the electronic edition if the name
139: %% is recognized by the data centers. The macro also takes an optional
140: %% argument in parentheses in cases where the data center identification
141: %% differs from what is to be printed in the paper.
142:
143: \keywords{infrared: stars --- planetary systems: protoplanetary disks --- open
144: clusters and associations: individual: M47}
145:
146: %% \keywords{globular clusters: general ---
147: %% globular clusters: individual(\objectname{NGC 6397},
148: %% \object{NGC 6624}, \objectname[M 15]{NGC 7078},
149: %% \object[Cl 1938-341]{Terzan 8})}
150:
151: %% From the front matter, we move on to the body of the paper.
152: %% In the first two sections, notice the use of the natbib \citep
153: %% and \citet commands to identify citations. The citations are
154: %% tied to the reference list via symbolic KEYs. The KEY corresponds
155: %% to the KEY in the \bibitem in the reference list below. We have
156: %% chosen the first three characters of the first author's name plus
157: %% the last two numeral of the year of publication as our KEY for
158: %% each reference.
159:
160: \section{Introduction}
161:
162: A knowledge of circumstellar disk evolution is crucial to
163: understanding the planet formation process. The current paradigm
164: predicts that optically thick accretion disks
165: left over from star formation should dissipate as material is accreted,
166: photoevaporated, or driven out of the system, leaving a remnant or debris disk formed by collisions
167: between large bodies in a nascent planetary system \citep{Hollenbach2000,Wyatt2002}.
168: Studies of how these circumstellar debris disks
169: evolve in the planet-forming zone from 1 to 10 AU, where the
170: disk emission emerges in the mid- and far-infrared, have been limited
171: by the sensitivity of the previous space-based infrared missions, IRAS and ISO.
172: The small number of F and A stars within
173: their reach has undermined attempts to
174: determine the frequency of excess emission. Claims of
175: decreasing amounts of excess emission with
176: age \citep{Spangler2001} or an upper limit to the age of stars
177: with debris disks \citep{Habing2001} have been disputed by
178: others who question the S/N of the excesses in question and/or
179: the reliability of age estimates for nearby field stars \citep{Decin2003}.
180:
181: The solution to this problem is to survey for debris disks
182: around stars in young clusters of reliable and disparate ages.
183: The high sensitivity of the {\it Spitzer} MIPS instrument at last puts
184: this goal within reach for nearby young clusters. The use
185: of M47, a young Galactic open cluster, as a calibration target during the {\it
186: Spitzer}
187: in-orbit checkout has provided an early opportunity to perform
188: such a survey.
189:
190:
191: Messier 47 (NGC 2422) is a reasonably compact (core radius 30 arcmin,
192: \citet{Barbera2002})
193: cluster of several hundred stars \citep{Ishmukhamedov1967,Mermilliod1986,
194: Prisinzano2003}
195: at galactic latitude 3$\degr $ and distance
196: around 450pc (see discussion in Sec \ref{memb}). Its age of
197: $80 \pm 20 $ Myr \citep*{RojoArellano1997, vanRensbergen1978},
198: is approximately the same as that of the Pleiades. Stromgren photometry of M47 indicates that
199: its metallicity is also similar to that of the Pleiades and $\alpha$ Per
200: clusters \citep{Nissen1988}. Despite its
201: proximity to the galactic plane, M47 has a small measured reddening of
202: $E(B-V) = 0.05 - 0.07$ \citep{Shobbrook1984, Nissen1988}.
203:
204:
205:
206: \section{New Observations}
207:
208: \subsection{Spitzer Measurements}
209:
210: A region around M47 was observed with MIPS \citep{Rieke2004}
211: as a verification
212: of the scan map parameters during the in-orbit checkout period (\idn).
213: The sky coverage is non-uniform: the effective
214: exposure time varies over the combined $20' \times 60'$ map, from a minimum
215: of 100 seconds at the edges to a maximum of about 600 seconds
216: in the central $\sim5' \times 60'$ strip.
217: The data were reduced using the instrument team Data Analysis
218: Tool \citep{Gordon2004}.
219: The 24$\micron$ mosaic is shown in Fig. \ref{fig1}. It
220: is oversampled by a factor of two, i.e., the pixel size is 1.27$''$. The sky coverage was
221: not optimized for the 70$\micron$ array, and only a few (possibly extragalactic)
222: sources were detected at this wavelength. Thus, all our analysis
223: has focused on the 24$\micron$ data.
224:
225:
226: Aperture photometry was performed using the DAOPHOT package \citep{Stetson1987}.
227: The signal aperture radius and inner and outer sky radii
228: were set at 3.5, 9 and 18 pixels (4.5$''$, 11.5$''$, and 23$''$), respectively.
229: A 0.73 mag aperture correction was applied to the measured values after
230: examining
231: the trend of the signal with aperture size on well isolated stars and
232: in synthetic images. Final magnitudes were put on a scale where zero magnitude
233: at 24$\micron$
234: is at 7.3 Jy.
235: A total of 1093 objects was detected with $[24] < 12.0 $ (0.12mJy) and S/N$ > 5$.
236:
237: \subsection {Optical Spectroscopy}
238:
239: For the three possible M47 members with largest $K-[24]$ excesses
240: (P1121, P369 and P922, Sec \ref{lt}), optical spectra were obtained for
241: us by J. Liebert
242: in February 2004 using the blue channel of the 6.5-m Multiple Mirror Telescope
243: spectrograph.
244: With the 1$\arcsec$ slit, the resolution was 3.6 \AA$ $ and
245: the wavelength coverage was 3640 -- 6790 \AA.
246: Exposure times were 4, 4 and 5 min for
247: P1121 (V=12.7), P922 (V=14.5) and P369 (V=16.2) respectively,
248: at airmass 1.8.
249:
250:
251: \section{Cluster Membership and Spitzer Detections}\label{memb}
252:
253: To interpret our results, we need to determine which 24$\mu$m sources are members of the cluster.
254: Our first test for membership is the color-magnitude diagram.
255: To construct such a diagram, we need to
256: determine the cluster distance. A distance of 497 $^{+135}_{-88}$ pc
257: is indicated by four B stars with Hipparcos
258: parallaxes \citep{Robichon1999}.
259: \citet{Prisinzano2003} showed that the $V$ vs. $V-I$
260: diagram is consistent with this distance and an age of 100 Myr.
261: Estimates from Stromgren photometry include:
262: \citet{Shobbrook1984}: $400 \pm 10$ pc (28 B-A stars);
263: \citet{Nissen1988}: 425 pc (11 F stars);
264: \citet{RojoArellano1997}: $470 \pm 5$ pc (average) and $400 \pm 100$ pc (median)
265: (36 B-F stars).
266: We adopt a distance of 450 pc and $E(B-V) = 0.07$. Because the Prisinzano et al. list of
267: cluster members is incomplete above 3.5M$_\odot$, we added 11 bright stars near the cluster turn-off,
268: taken from \citet{Robichon1999} and \citet{RojoArellano1997}.
269: Our photometrically selected sample of M47 members detected at 24$\mu$m then consists
270: of 66 objects (Fig. \ref{fig1}).
271:
272:
273: We confirmed probable membership for 63 of these 66 stars by proper motion analysis.
274: The UCAC2 \citep{ucac2}, ACT \citep{act}, ACC \citep{allsky}, and Tycho \citep{tyc} catalogs
275: provided data for all the possible cluster members except P369 (which is relatively faint).
276: Only P1218 is ruled out as a probable member, but P1078 has large errors in its
277: proper motion and its status is unclear. All the remaining stars have appropriate
278: proper motions for cluster membership:
279: $<\mu_\alpha cos\delta>=-7.5 \pm 3.4$ mas/yr, $<\mu_\delta>=1.9 \pm 2.3$ mas/yr.
280:
281: We detected at 24$\micron$ all M47 members lying within the boundaries
282: of our mosaic and brighter than $V=12$ mag (Spectral Type $\sim$F5, 1.5M$_\odot$)
283: and a few as late as $\sim$K. Accurate astrometry for the cluster members is
284: available both from \citet{Prisinzano2003}, who quote errors of $0.24''$,
285: and 2MASS, with typical errors $<$ $0.1''$. At 24$\mu$m, {\it Spitzer}
286: positions are accurate to $\sim$ $1''$, but the dominant term is
287: an offset in the scan direction that remains fixed for a campaign.
288: It we take this offset out, the positional agreement between
289: cluster members and 24$\mu$m counterparts is better than $0.5''$.
290: The total probability of even one chance coincidence between random 24$\mu$m
291: source and any cluster member whose photospheric flux is above our detection limit (0.12mJy)
292: is about $P = \frac{\pi(0.5'')^{2}}{20' \times 60' \times (60 '')^{2}} \times 1093\times 63 = 1.3\%$. For objects
293: brighter than 1mJy at 24$\mu$m, the probability of
294: such a coincidence is $<$ 0.25\% (take 195 instead of 1093). Thus, it is unlikely that there
295: are any chance identifications for the brighter sources.
296: Fig. \ref{fig2} shows $J-H$ vs. $K-[24]$ for these stars.
297:
298:
299: \section{Discussion}
300:
301: The histogram of $K-[24]$ colors for the majority of M47 stars can be described by a Gaussian
302: centered at $K-[24] = 0.11$ mag and with FWHM 0.26 mag ($\sigma = 0.11$ mag).
303: At these long wavelengths, for pure photospheric emission one
304: expects $K-[24] = 0$ virtually independent of spectral type.
305: Our distribution is shifted by $+$ 0.11 mag relative to this value;
306: however, the offset is within the systematic error of our photometry
307: ($\sim$ 0.10 mag, arising from uncertainties in absolute calibration
308: (up to 10\%) and in the aperture correction),
309: and the scatter is of the order of the random error of our photometry
310: (0.03-0.08 mag). We therefore define excess stars as those lying redwards
311: of $(K-[24])_{excess} = 0.11 + 3\sigma = 0.44$ mag.
312: The majority of M47 stars (55 out of 66) have 24$\micron$ fluxes consistent
313: with a pure photospheric origin or at most a small excess.
314: The remaining stars form two groups: early-type stars
315: with 0.6 $<$ $K-[24]$ $<$ 2.5 and three late-type stars with extreme excesses
316: $K-[24]$ $>$ 1.
317:
318: \subsection{Early type stars}
319:
320: Table \ref{table1} lists parameters of 8 M47 hot stars with 24$\micron$ excess
321: (out of 33 total having $J-H < 0.1$, which is characteristic of A-B stars ).
322: The most extreme one -- V378 Pup (= HIP 36981) -- is a blue straggler and emission-line star,
323: the only star in our sample that also shows a NIR excess (Dougherty \& Taylor 1994). The incidence
324: of substantial 24$\mu$m excesses is large:
325: 24\% of the early-type stars have excesses $>$ 0.4 magnitudes.
326: All of these stars are brighter than 1mJy, so the possibility of a chance
327: coincidence with another source is very small.
328:
329: It has been known since IRAS (\citet*{Waters87}, \citet{Cohen87}) that the fraction of stars
330: with infrared excesses in the field is the highest among B and M stars. This result is consistent
331: with the high incidence of excesses among the early-type stars in M47.
332: In the case of emission-line stars, the excess is explained by free-free processes
333: in the extended gaseous envelopes/disks \citep{Chokshi1987,Yudin2001}.
334: The nature of the excess in non-emission-line stars is not well established:
335: dust condensed after mass-loss episodes, dust from interstellar
336: cirrus, and dust from circumstellar disks may all contribute
337: \citep{Kalas2002}.
338:
339: The Pleiades provide a natural comparison with M47. We identified probable Pleiades members
340: by searching for stars within 1.5 degrees of RA 03:47:00 and DEC +24:07:00 (2000) and
341: with proper motions within 7mas/yr of 17.9, -43.2 mas/yr respectively in RA and DEC.
342: We used the IRAS FSC and PSC
343: to identify infrared excesses in these stars.
344: Our preliminary analysis of Pleiades \textit{Spitzer} data
345: shows that all the possible excess stars we found in this manner
346: are surrounded by 0.$\arcmin$5-1$\arcmin$ extended halos that
347: contaminate the IRAS measurements.
348: Since the surface brightness from the cirrus
349: between M47 stars is an order of magnitude less than in the Pleiades,
350: we doubt that such halos exist around M47 stars.
351: In addition, at the distance of M47 such halos would be resolved
352: by the MIPS 6$\arcsec$ beam -- contrary to our observations (see Fig. \ref{fig1}).
353: This shows the importance of M47 as a 100 Myr benchmark in disk evolution,
354: since interpretation of Pleiades FIR data
355: may be severely complicated by cirrus emission.
356:
357:
358: \subsection{Late type stars}\label{lt}
359:
360: As one moves to later spectral types, the Vega phenomenon becomes very rare
361: at wavelengths of 25$\mu$m and shorter.
362: For example, \citet{Oudmaijer1992} list 462 stars with possible excesses in
363: the IRAS catalog. If we take dwarf stars later than F3 and earlier than K7,
364: brighter than V = 8, and at absolute Galactic latitude $>$ 10$\degr $ (to avoid confusion
365: with Galactic emission), then there are no stars with candidate excesses
366: greater than 1.5 magnitudes at 25$\mu$m. \citet{Mannings98} report a similar
367: study, with similar results. These studies searched to the full depth of
368: the SAO star catalog, making chance associations a possibility. As a
369: more stringent test, we took a complete sample
370: of F and G dwarfs selected to have V magnitudes that would
371: predict photospheric fluxes of 0.5 Jy or brighter at 25$\mu$m (and thus likely
372: to be measured well by IRAS). This limit was set at V = 4 for F0 to F4, V = 4.5 for F5 to F8,
373: and V = 5 for F9 to G8. For these stars, we searched the IRAS PSC for high quality measurements,
374: and if no detection was reported there, checked if the star was listed in the FSC. Of a
375: total of 59 stars with good IRAS measurements, none had an excess greater than
376: 0.3 magnitudes in [12] - [25]. Similarly, \citet{backman93} found only two F or G dwarfs
377: in the Bright Star Catalog (which goes to $V \sim$ 6.5) with moderate ($\sim$ 0.5 mag)
378: 25$\mu$m excesses (HR 506 and HR 818), and most recently, \citet{Laureijs2002}
379: found one K dwarf (HD191408) with excess of 0.5 mag in their 25pc volume limited survey.
380:
381: Therefore our discovery of three late type M47 stars with
382: excesses $K-[24] = 1-4$ mag -- P1121, P922, P369 -- is very surprising.
383: To clarify their nature, we obtained the optical spectra of these stars shown in Fig. \ref{fig3}.
384: We used spectral standards from the NStars database\footnote{http://stellar.phys.appstate.edu} to
385: classify our spectra.
386: P369 turned out to be a reddened (A$_V \approx 1.0$ mag) K0 III-IV slightly metal poor star,
387: with radial velocity $\sim+100$ km/s. It is also the only member candidate without a
388: confirming proper motion measurement. Thus, we believe it is a background
389: giant. On the other hand, P922 and P1121 have radial velocities consistent with
390: cluster membership. Their spectral types are K1.5 V and F9 IV-V respectively,
391: as expected from their positions on the cluster color-magnitude diagram.
392: Both show signs of moderate chromospheric activity
393: in CaII K and H lines (level ''k'' on scale of \citet{Gray2003}), which is a bit higher than observed in
394: 800 Myr old Hyades stars (R. O. Gray 2004, private communication). No emission is seen in H$\alpha$
395: but slight infilling is present in H$\beta$ for P1121.
396: In conclusion, P922 and P1121 have spectral signatures of young main
397: sequence stars consistent with being M47 members (in addition to their
398: proper motions and photometric characteristics).
399:
400:
401: P922 is close to the 24$\mu$m detection limit and its photosphere would
402: be below that limit, so the probability of
403: a chance coincidence of an unrelated source with some cluster member
404: to produce a similar "system" is $\sim$ 8\%. Although P922 is only
405: slightly below the photospheric detection limit, in this calculation
406: we have included all known cluster members within the {\it Spitzer} image ($\sim$380).
407: Therefore, a chance
408: coincidence is possible but not highly likely.
409: P922 possesses an excess at 24$\micron$ similar to the extreme
410: debris disk stars such as $\zeta$ Lep (A2 Vann, 370 Myr).
411:
412: P1121 is an exceptionally interesting object. All the indicators
413: (photometry, spectral type, proper motion, radial velocity) place
414: it within the cluster. Its image (Fig.\ref{fig1}) is point-like with
415: no indication of extended emission in its vicinity.
416: It is 7mJy at 24$\mu$m and it is above our photospheric detection
417: limit, so the probability of
418: any chance association of a source this bright (25 out of 1093 total) with a cluster member
419: is only $\sim$0.03\%.
420: If it is bright at longer wavelengths, it might have a disk
421: as massive as seen in $\beta$ Pic !
422: It is also possible that it is surrounded by a less-massive disk lying
423: much closer to the star than is typical. At the age of P1121,
424: Poynting-Robertson drag should have cleared
425: out most of a thick, primordial disk. It is more likely the
426: disk has been renewed by planetesimal collisions. This possibility is
427: particularly interesting given the
428: arguments that the solar system went through a phase of disk
429: clearing, planet building, and violent planetesimal collisons
430: for its first few hundred Myr \citep{Hartmann2000}.
431:
432:
433: \section{Conclusions}
434:
435: We find substantial infrared excesses at 24$\mu$m in 10 stars that are members of
436: the 100 Myr old cluster M47. The most interesting example is P1121, which is of
437: spectral type F9 IV-V, yet has $K - [24]$ $\sim$ 3.7. If this excess is due to
438: a debris disk, it likely has a large mass and is a very rare object judging from
439: IRAS and ISO observations of the debris-disk phenomenon.
440:
441:
442: \acknowledgments
443:
444: We are grateful to Jim Liebert and Curtis Williams for obtaining spectra
445: of the IR-excess stars, Richard Gray and Chris Corbally for help with spectral classification,
446: and Eric Mamajek for useful discussions.
447: This work is based on observations made with the Spitzer Observatory,
448: which is operated by the Jet Propulsion Laboratory, California Institute of Technology
449: under NASA contract 1407. Support for this work was provided by NASA through
450: Contract Number 960785 issued by JPL/Caltech.
451:
452:
453: \begin{thebibliography}{}
454: \bibitem[Barbera et al.(2002)]{Barbera2002} Barbera, M., Bocchino, F., Damiani, F.,
455: Micela, G., Sciortino, S., Favata, F., \& Harnden, F. R., Jr. 2002, \apj, 387, 463
456: \bibitem[Backman \& Paresce(1993)]{backman93} Backman, D. E. \& Paresce, F. 1993, Protostars and Planets III, eds. E. H. Levy \& J. I. Lunine, Univ. Arizona Press, Tucson
457: \bibitem[Chokshi \& Cohen(1987)]{Chokshi1987} Chokshi, A. \& Cohen, M. 1987, \aj, 94, 123
458: \bibitem[Cohen et al.(1987)]{Cohen87} Cohen, M., Schwartz, D. E., Chokshi, A., \& Walker, R. G. 1987, \aj, 93, 1199
459: \bibitem[Decin et al.(2003)]{Decin2003} Decin, G., Dominik, C., Waters, L. B. F. M.,
460: \& Waelkens, C. 2003, \apj, 598, 636
461: \bibitem[Dougherty \& Taylor (1994)]{Dougherty} Dougherty, S. M., \& Taylor, A. R. 1994, \mnras, 269, 1123
462: \bibitem[Ducati (2002)]{Ducati2002} Ducati, J. R. 2002, Stellar Photometry in Johnson's 11-color system (VizieR on-line catalog II/237)
463: \bibitem[Dworetsky(1975)]{Dworetsky} Dworetsky, M. M. 1975, \aj, 80, 131
464: \bibitem[Gordon et al.(2004)]{Gordon2004} Gordon, K. et al. 2004, \pasp, submitted
465: \bibitem[Gray et al.(2003)]{Gray2003} Gray, R. O., Corbally, C. J., Garrison, R. F.,
466: McFadden, M. T., \& Robinson, P. E 2003, \aj, 126, 2048
467: \bibitem[Habing et al.(2001)]{Habing2001} Habing, H. J., Dominik, C., Jourdain de Muizon, M.,
468: Laureijs, R. J., Kessler, M. F., Leech, K., Metcalfe, L., Salama, A., Siebenmorgen, R.,
469: Trams, N., \& Bouchet, P. 2001, \aap, 365, 545
470: \bibitem[Hartmann et al.(2000)]{Hartmann2000} Hartmann, W. K., Ryder, G., Dones, L., \& Grinspoon, D. 2000,
471: Origin of the earth and moon, eds. R. M. Canup \& K. Righter, Univ. Arizona Press, Tucson
472: \bibitem[Hartoog(1976)]{Hartoog} Hartoog, M. R. 1976, \apj, 205, 807
473: \bibitem[Hog et al.(2000)]{tyc} Hog E., Fabricius C., Makarov V.V., Urban S., Corbin T.,
474: Wycoff G., Bastian U., Schwekendiek P., \& Wicenec A. 2000, The Tycho-2 Catalogue of the 2.5 Million Brightest
475: Stars (VizieR on-line catalog I/259)
476: \bibitem[Hollenbach, Yorke, \& Johnstone(2000)]{Hollenbach2000} Hollenbach, D. J., Yorke, H. W., \& Johnstone D. 2000,
477: Protostars and Planets IV, eds. V. Mannings, A. P. Boss \& S. S. Russell, Univ. Arizona Press, Tucson
478: \bibitem[Ishmukhamedov (1967)]{Ishmukhamedov1967} Ishmukhamedov1, K. 1967, Tsirk. Tashkent. Astr. Obs., 346, 1
479: \bibitem[Kalas et al.(2002)]{Kalas2002} Kalas, P., Graham, J. R., Beckwith, S. V. W., Jewitt, D. C., \& Lloyd, J. P.
480: 2002,\apj, 567, 999
481: \bibitem[Kenyon \& Hartmann(1995)]{kh95} Kenyon, S. J. \& Hartmann, L. 1995, \apjs, 101, 117
482: \bibitem[Kharchenko (2001)]{allsky} Kharchenko N.V. 2001, All-sky Compiled Catalogue of 2.5 million stars (VizieR on-line catalog I/280)
483: \bibitem[Laureijs et al.(2002)]{Laureijs2002} Laureijs, R. J., Jourdain de Muizon, M., Leech, K.,
484: Siebenmorgen, R., Dominik, C., Habing, H. J., Trams, N., \& Kessler, M. F. 2002, \aap, 387, 285
485: \bibitem[Li \& Greenberg(1998)]{Li1998} Li, A. \& Greenberg, J. M. 1998, \aap, 331, 291
486: \bibitem[Mannings \& Barlow (1998)]{Mannings98} Mannings, V. \& Barlow, M. J. 1998, \apj, 497, 330
487: \bibitem[Mermilliod (1986)]{Mermilliod1986} Mermilliod J.C. 1986, \aaps, 63, 293
488: \bibitem[Mermilliod (2004)]{WEBDA} Mermilliod J.-C., On-line open cluster archive (http://obswww.unige.ch/webda/)
489: \bibitem[Montes et al.(2001)]{Montes2001} Montes, D., Lopez-Santiago J., Galvez M. C., Fernandez-Figueroa M. J.,
490: De Castro E., \& Cornide M. 2001, \mnras, 328, 45
491: \bibitem[Nissen (1988)]{Nissen1988} Nissen, P. E 1988, \aap, 199, 146
492: \bibitem[Oudmaijer et al.(1992)]{Oudmaijer1992} Oudmaijer, R. D., van der Veen, W. E. C. J.,
493: Waters, L. B. F. M., Trams, N. R., Waelkens, C., \& Engelsman, E. 1992, \aaps, 96, 625
494: \bibitem[Prisinzano et al.(2003)]{Prisinzano2003} Prisinzano, L., Micela, G., Sciortino, S., Favata, F.,
495: 2003, \aap, 404, 927
496: \bibitem[Rieke at al.(2004)]{Rieke2004} Rieke, G. H., et al. 2004, \apjs, this issue
497: \bibitem[Robichon et al.(1999)]{Robichon1999} Robichon, N., Arenou, F., Mermilliod, J.-C.,
498: \& Turon, C. 1999, \aap, 345, 471
499: \bibitem[Rojo Arellano et al.(1997)Rojo Arellano, Pena, \& Gonzalez]{RojoArellano1997} Rojo Arellano, E.,
500: Pena, J. H., \& Gonzalez, D. 1997, \aaps, 123, 25
501: \bibitem[Shobbrook (1984)]{Shobbrook1984} Shobbrook, R. R. 1984, \mnras, 211, 659
502: \bibitem[Spangler et al.(2001)]{Spangler2001} Spangler, C., Sargent, A. I., Silverstone,
503: M. D., Becklin, E. E., \& Zuckerman, B. 2001, \apj, 555, 932
504: \bibitem[Stetson (1987)]{Stetson1987} Stetson, P. B. 1987, \pasp, 99, 191
505: \bibitem[Urban et al.(1997)]{act} Urban S. E., Corbin T. E., \& Wycoff G. L. 1997, The ACT Reference Catalog (VizieR on-line catalog I/246)
506: \bibitem[van Rensbergen (1987)]{vanRensbergen1978} van Rensbergen, W., Hammerschlag-Hensberge, G., van den Heuvel, E. P. J.
507: 1978, \aap, 64, 131
508: \bibitem[Waters et al.(1987)Waters, Co\'{t}e, \& Aumann]{Waters87} Waters, L. B. F. M., Co\'{t}e, J, \& Aumann, H. H. 1987, \aap, 172, 225
509: \bibitem[Wyatt \& Dent(2002)]{Wyatt2002} Wyatt, M. C. \& Dent W. R. F., 2002, \mnras, 334, 589
510: \bibitem[Yudin(2001)]{Yudin2001} Yudin, R.V. 2001, \aap, 368, 912
511: \bibitem[Zacharius et al.(2003)]{ucac2} Zacharias N., Urban S. E., Zacharias M. I., Wycoff G. L., Hall D. M.,
512: Germain M. E., Holdenried E.R., \& Winter L. 2003, The Second U.S. Naval Observatory CCD
513: Astrograph Catalog (VizieR on-line catalog I/289)
514: \end{thebibliography}
515:
516: \clearpage
517: \begin{deluxetable}{lllrrrrlllrrr}
518: \tablecolumns{7}
519: \tablewidth{0pt}
520: \tabletypesize{\small}
521: \tablecaption{24{\micron} excess stars in M47\label{table1}}
522: \tablehead{
523: \colhead{P.N} & \colhead{Name} & \colhead {SpT} & \colhead {M$_{V}$} &
524: \colhead {J-H} & \colhead {K-[24]} & \colhead {F$_{24}$ (mJy)} }
525: \startdata
526: \\
527: \nodata & HIP 36981 & B2-B5 Ven & -2.61 & 0.02 & 2.42 & 558.89 $\pm$ 0.51 \\
528: \nodata & HIP 36967 & B5-B9 Vn & -0.33 & -0.05 & 0.71 & 8.86 $\pm$ 0.05 \\
529: \nodata & HD 60995 & B8-B9 V & 0.38 & -0.03 & 0.72 & 5.19 $\pm$ 0.05 \\
530: 1152 & 2MASS 07371449-1425179 & \nodata & 1.73 & 0.00 & 0.62 & 1.58 $\pm$ 0.03 \\
531: 1155 & BD -1402028 & A2p & 2.07 & 0.01 & 0.92 & 1.67 $\pm$ 0.02 \\
532: 1173 & 2MASS 07362205-1430283 & \nodata & 2.13 & -0.00 & 0.86 & 1.55 $\pm$ 0.02 \\
533: 1172 & 2MASS 07365524-1433176 & \nodata & 2.42 & 0.05 & 0.68 & 1.13 $\pm$ 0.03\\
534: 1182 & 2MASS 07370687-1431348 & \nodata & 2.75 & 0.05 & 0.74 & 1.14 $\pm$ 0.03\\
535: \\
536: 1121 & 2MASS 07354269-1450422 & F9 IV/V & 4.40 & 0.28 & 3.72 & 7.31 $\pm$ 0.03\\
537: 922 & 2MASS 07364576-1434348 & K1 V & 6.27 & 0.45 & 1.08 & 0.23 $\pm$ 0.02 \\
538: 369\tablenotemark{a} & 2MASS 07372200-1424262 & K0 III/IV & \nodata & 0.66 & 3.01 & 0.94 $\pm$ 0.03 \\
539: \\
540: \enddata
541: \tablenotetext{a}{Our spectrum indicates it is not a cluster member.}
542: \tablecomments{P.N -- numbering sequence from Table 4 of \citet{Prisinzano2003}; SpT -- from the literature \citep[VizieR;][]{WEBDA,Hartoog,Dworetsky}, except for late types (this work); M$_{V}$ -- assuming distance 450pc}
543: \end{deluxetable}
544:
545: \clearpage
546:
547: \begin{figure}
548: \plotone{f1.eps}
549: \caption{Left panel -- M47 mosaic.
550: Central panel -- sources detected at 24$\mu$m,
551: red circles represent 24$\mu$m excess in M47 members (size $\sim K-[24]$). Right panel -- magnified images
552: of some excess stars (left column, arrows pointing to the position on the map),
553: compared to similar magnitude $V$, $B-V$ non-excess stars (right column).}\label{fig1}
554: \end{figure}
555:
556:
557: \clearpage
558: \begin{figure}
559: \plotone{f2.eps}
560: \caption{IR color-color diagram of M47 in comparison with Pleiades and field debris disk stars. Solid circles: M47 members; squares:
561: membership uncertain due to lack of proper motion information; asterisks: Pleiades stars detected by IRAS; 1: HR 4796A (A0V 10Myr), 2: $\beta$ Pic (A3V 12Myr), 3: Fomalhaut (A3V 220Myr), 4: $\beta$ Leo (A3V 240Myr), 5: $\epsilon$ Eri (K2V 330Myr), 6: Vega (A0V 350Myr), 7: $\zeta$ Lep (A2nn 370Myr). Dashed line: locus of main sequence stars converted from $K-[12]$ colors in \citet{kh95} by assuming $[24]=[12]+0.08$, where 0.08 arises because of IRAS color corrections. Dotted lines: adopted 3$\sigma$ boundaries on non-excess stars. The crosses on the left represent
562: typical errorbars on M47 photometry as a function of J--H (, or brightness for MS stars).
563: Sources of photometry: JHK -- 2MASS and \citet{Ducati2002},
564: [24] -- MIPS for M47 and IRAS $[25]$ for the rest stars.}\label{fig2}
565: \end{figure}
566:
567: \clearpage
568: \begin{figure}
569: \plotone{f3.eps}
570: \caption{Portions of MMT spectra of P1121 and P922 in comparison with spectral standards
571: (taken from
572: NStars database). Sr II, as well as CN depression, is stronger compared to the neighbouring
573: Fe I line in giants and weaker in dwarfs. Weak
574: emission in the cores of Ca II lines is seen in P1121 and P922 confirming a young
575: age for these stars.}\label{fig3}
576: \end{figure}
577:
578: \end{document}
579:
580:
581:
582:
583: