1:
2:
3: %\documentclass[referee]{aa} % for a referee version
4: \documentclass{aa}
5:
6: \usepackage{epsfig}
7: %\usepackage{graphicx}
8:
9: \usepackage{txfonts}
10:
11: \begin{document}
12:
13: \title{An optical absorption study of the Helix Planetary
14: Nebula}
15: \subtitle{Na\,{\sc i} and Ca\,{\sc ii} lines, and a search for diffuse bands}
16: \author{N. Mauron\inst{1} \and T.R. Kendall\inst{2} }
17: \offprints{N.Mauron}
18:
19: \institute{ Groupe d'Astrophysique, UMR 5024 CNRS, Case CC72, Place Bataillon,
20: F-34095 Montpellier Cedex 05, France\\
21: \email{mauron@graal.univ-montp2.fr}
22: \and
23: Laboratoire d'Astrophysique, Observatoire de Grenoble,
24: Universit\'{e} Joseph Fourier, BP 53, F-38041 Grenoble Cedex 09, France
25: \email{tkendall@obs.ujf-grenoble.fr}
26: \thanks{Based on observations carried out with the European
27: Southern Observatory VLT/UVES, program 70.C-0100}}
28:
29: \date{Received xxx; accepted xxx}
30:
31:
32: \abstract {We present the first results of an optical absorption study
33: of NGC\,7293, the Helix planetary nebula (PN), designed to search definitively
34: for diffuse band (DIB) absorptions perhaps arising in the carbon-rich
35: circumstellar matter of the PN. We used the VLT-UVES spectrograph to achieve
36: high resolution (R=50000) spectra of 8 stars located angularly close to and
37: behind the Helix. These targets were selected through their photometric UBV
38: or 2MASS properties, permitting derivation of spectral types (mainly F-G dwarfs)
39: and distance that place several of them far (700--1500\,pc) beyond the Helix
40: (210\,pc). Through a detailed analysis of the Na\,{\sc i} and Ca\,{\sc ii}
41: lines to the 8 targets, we find that two lines of sight situated close to
42: the nebula as mapped in CO and H\,{\sc i} exhibit very strong Na\,{\sc i}
43: absorption. This absorption is unlikely to arise in the foreground or background
44: interstellar medium which has a relatively low column density, because the
45: Helix is at high galactic latitude $b = -57^{\circ}$. It is much more probable
46: that it is due to the PN neutral or molecular material. This circumstellar origin
47: is reinforced by the fact that no corresponding Ca\,{\sc ii} line is observed
48: (as it would usually be from the ISM), which is in agreement with the very high
49: Ca depletion often observed in PNs. No trace of any DIB
50: features was found in these two circumstellar lines of sight, nor to the other
51: targets. The two circumstellar sightlines discovered in this work open the way to search
52: for molecular species such as C$_2$ which are not observable at radio wavelengths,
53: and to obtain more information on the rich neutral and molecular content of the Helix.
54: \keywords{Stars; individual: NGC\,7293 -- stars: planetary nebulae --
55: stars: circumstellar matter -- ISM: lines and bands --
56: ISM: molecules}
57: }
58: \titlerunning{Optical absorption line spectroscopy of the Helix PN}
59:
60: \maketitle
61: %
62: %________________________________________________________________
63:
64: \section{Introduction}
65:
66: The identification of the carriers of the diffuse interstellar bands (DIBs)
67: has proved one of the most difficult problems in observational molecular
68: astrophysics (see Herbig \cite{her95}, hereafter H95, for a review).
69: DIBs have been widely
70: observed throughout the interstellar medium (ISM) for nearly a century, but
71: no convincing identification of a carrier has yet been forthcoming. In addition,
72: the origin of the carrier(s) remains unknown. Numerous studies have suggested
73: that DIB carriers are not present in the circumstellar matter of evolved cool
74: O-rich or C-rich stars that inject various dust or molecular compounds into the
75: ISM (Snow \cite{sno73}; Snow \& Wallerstein \cite{snw72}; Zacs et al. \cite{zac03}).
76: However, there are a few exceptions that would certainly deserve further
77: attention, e.g. the unusual 6177\,\AA~ band seen in some evolved objects by
78: Le Bertre \& Lequeux (\cite{leb93}), or the case
79: of DIBs possibly observed against the A-type companion of the carbon star CS\,776
80: (Le Bertre \cite{leb90}; for this object, see also comments in H95 and in Kendall et al.
81: \cite{ken02}).
82:
83: The initial findings of Scarrott et al. (\cite{sca92}) and Sarre et al. (\cite{sar95})
84: connecting the optical emission
85: bands in the Red Rectangle (RR) with a subset of well-known DIBs have been qualified
86: recently by Van Winckel et al. (\cite{vwi02}) and Glinski \& Anderson (\cite{gli02}) on
87: the basis of e.g. a 2\,\AA~wavelength
88: mismatch between the $\lambda$5797 DIB in the ISM and the nearby $\sim$5800\,\AA\,\,
89: RR\,\,emission band. This mismatch remains at the largest observed distances from the central
90: star, leading both authors to conclude that the carriers of the DIB and the RR band
91: are not identical. However, Van Winckel et al. (\cite{vwi02}) also note five further possible
92: matches between DIB wavelengths and RR features, and there certainly exist in
93: the RR molecules closely related to the likely DIB carriers.
94:
95: A hitherto undisputed fact is that a subset of diffuse bands are also clearly seen
96: in emission in the circumstellar layers of the unusual, carbon rich, R\,CrB-type
97: variable V854\,Cen (Rao \& Lambert \cite{rao93}). DIB carriers perhaps exist also
98: in the envelopes of
99: rare, hotter C-rich post-AGB objects (Zacs et al. \cite{zac99}; Klochkova et al.
100: \cite{klo99}; Klochkova et al. \cite{klo00}; Klochkova et al.
101: \cite{klo01}), although this is not certain. A clear-cut case concerning
102: a post-AGB object is HR\,4049,
103: which has a carbon-rich envelope; no diffuse band of circumstellar origin
104: could be found in the spectrum of the central hot star (Waters et al. \cite{wat89}).
105: Because it is often thought that large carbon bearing molecules might be the
106: (or one of the) DIB carriers (e.g. H95, Duley \cite{dul98}), every effort is desirable to
107: test this hypothesis by seeking DIBs at carbon-rich sites of origin
108: where these molecules may be abundant.
109:
110: In a recent paper (Kendall et al. \cite{ken02}), we have pioneered a new
111: observational method using optical absorption spectroscopy of background objects to
112: probe the spatially extended circumstellar envelope (CSE) of the archetypal
113: extreme mass-losing carbon star IRC\,+10$^{\circ}$\,216. By searching for absorptions
114: against the relatively smooth continua of thick-disk background targets, the method
115: alleviated confusion with photospheric features in the highly complex spectrum of
116: the central, cool, evolved object. These observations showed that DIB carriers are
117: of very low abundance, or non-existent, around IRC\,+10$^{\circ}$\,216, and we
118: suggested that the DIB carriers might be sought in compact, UV-rich regions where ionised
119: and neutral molecular material interact. Such sites are the circumstellar shells of
120: planetary nebulae (PN), and this paper reports our first attempts to detect DIBs in
121: the Helix PN.
122:
123: In fact, DIB carriers have already been sought in a few other carbon-rich PN, most
124: notably NGC\,7027~(Le Bertre \& Lequeux \cite{leb92}) and no circumstellar diffuse
125: bands have been detected. However, it is justified to apply our method of background
126: target spectroscopy to PN and especially to use several lines of sight.
127: This is an important point, since the clear clumpiness and inhomogeneity
128: of typical PN shells means that DIB carriers, and other species, may not be distributed
129: uniformly throughout such shells. Indeed, in cases where only
130: the central star is observed through relatively low density material, the column density
131: may be insufficient for observable absorptions to arise.
132:
133: Therefore, in this paper, we report the first results of a
134: similar absorption spectroscopy experiment performed using 8 targets seen through, or
135: located angularly very close to, the Helix. As explained below in more detail (Sect. 2), this
136: PN was selected primarily because of its proximity, its high galactic
137: latitude, and its wealth in ionized, neutral and molecular content.
138:
139: %%%==================================== TABLE OF TARGETS ===================================
140: \begin{table*}
141: \caption[]{Background targets beyond the Helix Nebula, with basic and derived data.
142: For clarity, we will use the identification given in the second column when referring
143: to individual targets.
144: The column t$_{\rm exp}$ gives for each target
145: the total exposure time; for objects 1, 3, 4, and 8, two spectra of
146: half this time were exposed. $d$ is the estimated distance in pc.
147: The final column states whether a target is directly behind the nebula (on-PN)
148: or a control object (off-PN). Targets 7 and 8 are HD\,213056 and HD\,213069,
149: respectively, with spectral types from Simbad.}
150: \begin{center}
151:
152: \begin{tabular}{crccrrrrrcr}
153: \noalign{\smallskip}
154: \hline
155: \hline
156: \noalign{\smallskip}
157: IAU &Id. & $\alpha$\,\, $\delta$ & $V$ & $B-V$ & $V-J$ & t$_{\rm exp}$ &Sp.& $d$ &
158: Notes \\
159: name & & (J2000) & (mag)&(mag)&(mag) & (min) & & (pc) &\\
160:
161: \noalign{\smallskip}
162: \hline
163: \noalign{\smallskip}
164: USNO-B1.0 0691-0897349& 1 & 22 29 47.3 $-$20 50 31 & 13.17 & 0.51 & 1.02 & 66.2 & F8V & 680 & on PN\\
165: USNO-B1.0 0691-0897340& 2 & 22 29 38.6 $-$20 50 14 & 13.54 &$-$0.39& -\,\,& 46.1 &-\,\,& 210 & nucleus\\
166: USNO-B1.0 0692-0882100& 3 & 22 29 33.5 $-$20 46 18 & 12.04 & 0.64 & 1.08 & 22.7 & G2V & 290 & on-PN\\
167: USNO-B1.0 0691-0897309& 4 & 22 29 19.0 $-$20 48 48 & 13.94 & -\,\, & 0.75 & 66.7 & F2V & 1500& on-PN\\
168: USNO-B1.0 0690-0897407& 5 & 22 29 46.5 $-$20 56 33 & 13.57 & -\,\, & 0.68 & 47.4 & F0V & 1500& on-PN\\
169: USNO-B1.0 0691-0897499& 6 & 22 30 28.0 $-$20 48 31 & 12.31 & 0.59 & 1.16 & 14.6 & G1V & 380 & off-PN\\
170: USNO-B1.0 0692-0882044& 7 & 22 29 09.4 $-$20 46 07 & 10.02 & 0.89 & 1.88 & 01.7 &K1III& 760 & on-PN\\
171: USNO-B1.0 0690-0897288& 8 & 22 29 13.1 $-$20 57 49 & 10.36 & 0.73 & -\,\,& 05.2 & F5V & 240 & off-PN\\
172: \noalign{\smallskip}
173: \hline
174: \end{tabular}
175: \end{center}
176: \end{table*}
177: %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%++=======================================================================================
178:
179:
180: %=========================== figure showing Helix; graph bidon pour ArXiv
181: \begin{figure}
182: \centering
183: \resizebox{\hsize}{!}{
184: {\rotatebox{-90} {\includegraphics{za-helix-bidon.ps}} }
185: }
186: \caption{Observed targets labelled on the $R$-band POSS-2 image.
187: The field is 25$^{\prime}$ $\times$ 25$^{\prime}$, centered on
188: the nucleus (\#2). North at top, East to the left.}
189: \label{f1}
190: \end{figure}
191: %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%====================================================================
192:
193: \section{The Helix Nebula and the background stars used for absorption spectroscopy}
194:
195: The Helix Nebula is undoubtedly the best target of its kind for this study, being
196: close ($d$\,=\,$210\pm30$\,pc, from parallax $4.70\pm0.75$\,mas; Young et al. \cite{you99}),
197: as well as rich in carbon, dust and being irradiated by a strong central UV source.
198: Its high galactic latitude ($b=-57^{\circ}$)
199: minimises confusion with the foreground or background ISM: the maps of
200: Burnstein \& Heiles (\cite{bur82}) and Schlegel et al. (\cite{sch98})
201: show a very low interstellar (IS) reddening of
202: $E_{\rm B-V}$\,$\sim$\,0.03\,mag. The nebula has been detected in the lines of
203: H\,{\sc i}, H$_2$ and CO, together with other species (CN, HCN, HNC, HCO$^+$
204: and C\,{\sc i}) which strongly indicate a carbon-rich medium (Young et al. \cite{you99};
205: Speck et al. \cite{spe02}).
206: While the H\,{\sc i} and CO\,(2--1) maps (Rodriguez et al. \cite{rod02};
207: Young et al. \cite{you99}, respectively)
208: roughly outline the main body of the optical PN, i.e. as traced by ionised species,
209: these maps reveal strong inhomogeneity in the form of a marked ``knotty'' structure.
210: This is fully consistent with the presence of the well known numerous
211: dust globules seen in optical images. Also, the radio maps show that the global PN
212: geometry is not spherical, but approximately disk-like and seen nearly pole-on. This
213: complex structure makes obvious the necessity of considering as many background
214: stars as possible. Finally, because the neutral phase of the PN contains $\sim$\,3
215: to 6 times more mass than the molecular phase (Rodriguez et al. \cite{rod02};
216: Young et al. \cite{you99}), it can
217: be expected that essentially the neutral material, but perhaps also some molecular
218: knots, may be probed by observing background stars.
219:
220: Optical images (Fig.\,\ref{f1}) show a large number of potential targets within or
221: near the PN shell which might function as sightlines to probe the nebula and the ISM
222: in angularly nearby sightlines. Targets were first selected using homogeneous, accurate
223: $JHK$ photometry from 2MASS.
224: For some of them, a $V$ magnitude is available in Simbad.
225: By comparing the $J$$-$$K$ and/or $V$$-$$J$ colours of our targets to
226: template Population\,I dwarfs, an approximate spectral type could be inferred.
227: Then, absolute magnitudes and therefore distances were derived. Where independent
228: $U$$-$$B$, $B$$-$$V$ colours are available in Simbad, we find excellent agreement with
229: the predictions of the $J$$-$$K$ or $V$$-$$J$ colours.
230: Only about half of the targets which were
231: bright enough to obtain high signal-to-noise ($S/N$) spectra could eventually be observed,
232: owing to poor weather.
233:
234: The derived types and distances for these 8 observed targets are given in Table\,1.
235: The targets have $V$\,$\sim$\,10--14 and are located directly behind, or
236: close to, the shell. With the exception of the nucleus, target \#2,
237: the sightlines probed have spectral types F or G. The uncertainties on distances are
238: of the order of 20\%. Distances would be 30\% smaller (or less) if we had adopted
239: the luminosity of low-metallicity subdwarfs, but they would be considerably larger
240: if we had adopted the luminosity of giants. In the end, several targets are clearly much more
241: distant ($>$\,400\,pc) than the Helix. As we shall see below, all these targets provide
242: a very usable continuum for absorption spectroscopy
243: despite their photospheric lines. Moreover, for each target,
244: the precise velocity of the photospheric Na\,{\sc i} D lines could be easily predicted
245: through consideration of
246: $\sim$20 prominent unblended Fe\,{\sc i} lines available in our spectra
247: (vertical bars in Fig.\,\ref{f2}).
248:
249: \section{Observations and data reduction}
250:
251: Observations were performed on 2002 October 11--12 using the Very Large
252: Telescope with the Ultraviolet and Visual Echelle
253: Spectrograph (UVES) at the European Southern Observatory, Cerro Paranal, Chile.
254: Total integration times of up to $\sim$\,one hour were achieved, depending on the
255: target magnitude. Using the 0.8\arcsec~slit (R\,=\,50000) with both red
256: and blue dichroics, spectra were obtained over three wavelength ranges,
257: $\sim$\,3500--4520\,\AA, 4630--5600\,\AA~ and 5670--6650\,\AA.
258: These ranges include in particular the strongest DIBs at 5780, 5797, 6283
259: and 6614\,\AA, the Na\,{\sc i} D and Ca\,{\sc ii} H \& K lines.
260: The target signal-to-noise ratio of $\sim$\,70 (per 0.017\AA\,bin) was achieved
261: over the most part of these ranges, except in the blue region
262: comprising the Ca\,{\sc ii} lines where $S/N$ is generally poor because
263: the target is not hot enough (with the exception of the nucleus).
264: The data analysis was carried out by using the
265: reduced spectra that are provided by the ESO/UVES reduction pipeline, and by
266: using the ESO MIDAS and the NOAO IRAF packages.
267:
268: %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%% TABLE ON 3 FIELD HOT STARS =================================
269: \begin{table*}
270: \caption[]{Literature data for 3 bright stars located at 2.8--5.4\degr\,
271: from the Helix. $\theta$ is the angular distance of each star
272: to the Helix nucleus. W$_{\lambda}$(D1) \& W$_{\lambda}$(D2) are the observed
273: equivalent widths in the IS Na\,{\sc i} D1 5895\,\AA\, and D2 5890\,\AA\,
274: lines, and W$_{\lambda}$(K) is that for the Ca\,{\sc ii} K 3933\,\AA\, line, all
275: expressed in m\AA. Relative uncertainties on
276: W$_{\lambda}$ values are $\sim$ a few percent.}
277: \begin{center}
278: \begin{tabular}{lcrlrrrrl}
279: \noalign{\smallskip}
280: \hline
281: \hline
282: \noalign{\smallskip}
283:
284: Star & $\theta$ & V\,\,\,\,\, & Sp.&dist. &W$_{\lambda}$(D1)& W$_{\lambda}$(D2)&
285: W$_{\lambda}$(K) & Notes\\
286: name & (deg) & (mag)& & (pc) &(mA) & (mA) & (mA) & \\
287: \noalign{\smallskip}
288: \hline
289: \noalign{\smallskip}
290: PHL\,346 & 2.86 &11.47 & B1 &10000 & -\,\, & -\,\, & 199 & (1)(4)\\
291:
292: HD\,214080 & 4.70 & 6.83 & B1Ib & 3000 & 171 & 207 & 149 & (2)\\
293:
294: HD\,210191 & 5.38 & 5.81 & B2.5IV& 460 & 90 & 164 & 285 & (2)(3)\\
295: \noalign{\smallskip}
296: \hline
297: \end{tabular}
298: \end{center}
299:
300: Notes: (1) Data from Keenan et al. (\cite{kee88}); (2) Data from Albert (\cite{alb83});
301: (3) Also known as 35 Aqr; (4) for PHL\,346, no Na\,{\sc i} data could be found
302: in the literature.
303: \end{table*}
304: %%%====================================================================================
305:
306: \section{The interstellar medium in the direction of the Helix Nebula}
307:
308: Before interpreting the spectra of our program stars, e.g.
309: the Na\,{\sc i} and Ca\,{\sc ii} profiles,
310: one has to estimate the effect of the foreground and background
311: ISM, deriving, at least approximately, the expected strength of the IS lines.
312: One source of information is the $E_{\rm B-V}$ maps derived
313: by Schlegel et al. (\cite{sch98}). By considering a zone of
314: 3\degr$\times$\,3\degr~centred on the Helix (the nucleus is at $l$\,=\,36\fdg2,
315: $b$\,=\,$-57$\fdg1) but excluding a central region of
316: 1\degr$\times$\,1\degr~to avoid the nebula itself,
317: we find that $E_{\rm B-V}$ would be on average $\approx$ 0.035 mag.
318: with $\sigma$\,=\,0.005, as derived from 20 independent positions.
319: One has to note that the $\sigma$ above only represents the local
320: scatter of $E_{\rm B-V}$ as given by the Schlegel et al. maps which have an
321: angular resolution of 6\arcmin. This does not exclude
322: moderately larger deviations from this mean when one considers the very narrow
323: pencil-like sightlines to background stars.
324:
325: Based on this estimate of $E_{\rm B-V}$, one can derive
326: the expected column density of Na\,{\sc i}. From Bohlin et al. (\cite{boh78}),
327: the hydrogen (H\,{\sc i} + 2H$_2$) column density is obtainable with
328: $N$(H)/$E_{\rm B-V}$ = 5.8\,$\times$\,10$^{+21}$ cm$^{-2}$, with
329: deviations from this mean generally less than a factor 1.5. Consequently,
330: we obtain $N$(H)\,=\,2.0\,$\times$\,10$^{+20}$ cm$^{-2}$. For this column
331: density, the correlation found by Ferlet et al. (\cite{fer85}) with $N$(Na\,{\sc i})
332: suggest that $N$(Na\,{\sc i})\,=\,1.0\,$\times$\,10$^{+12}$ cm$^{-2}$ with
333: a scatter of about a factor 3 (see their Fig.\,1). This Na\,{\sc i} column density
334: is relatively small but is already in the non linear regime of the curve of
335: growth for typical IS sightlines. It corresponds to a typical
336: equivalent width (W$_{\lambda}$) in the Na\,{\sc i} D2 (5890\,\AA) line
337: W$_{\lambda}$(D2)\,$\sim$\,200\,m\AA. Consequently, we expect that
338: W$_{\lambda}$(D2) observed towards our targets be close to 200\,m\AA.
339:
340:
341: Another source of information concerning the ISM in the direction of the Helix
342: is obtained by considering available observations of Na\,{\sc i} or other
343: atoms for stars angularly close to the Helix. By interrogating the catalogue of
344: Garcia (\cite{gar91}), we find 3 stars with IS information available
345: and located at less than 6\degr~from the Helix centre. The data, taken
346: from Albert (\cite{alb83}) and Keenan et al. (\cite{kee88}), are listed in Table 2, and
347: the values of W$_{\lambda}$(D2) are found to be also $\sim$\,200\,m\AA\, in
348: excellent agreement with estimations made above. It is interesting also to note
349: that Albert (\cite{alb83}) gives for HD\,214080 $E_{\rm B-V}$\,=\,0.05 in very
350: good agreement with $E_{\rm B-V}$\,=\,0.047 provided by the Schegel et al. maps
351: in the direction of this star. In contrast, for HD\,210191, Albert (\cite{alb83}) gives
352: $E_{\rm B-V}$\,=\,0.07 whereas the maps of Schlegel et al. give
353: $E_{\rm B-V}$\,=\,0.025. It is possible that Albert (\cite{alb83}) overestimates the
354: extinction because the intrinsic colour $(B-V)_{0}$ of HD\,210191 has
355: to be derived from its spectral classification and may have been
356: incorrectly taken as too blue.
357:
358: An equally important point to consider is the expected range of heliocentric
359: velocities for IS lines. By considering Fig.\,2 of Albert (\cite{alb83}), it is clear that
360: the H\,{\sc i} (21\,cm) line, the Na\,{\sc i} and the Ca\,{\sc ii} lines toward
361: HD\,214080 and HD\,210191 are all consistently
362: found within the velocity interval $v_{\rm LSR}$\,=\,$-$25 km\,s$^{-1}$
363: to +20\,km\,s$^{-1}$,
364: which corresponds to $v_{\rm helio}$\,=\,$-$28 to +17\,km\,s$^{-1}$
365: (for the direction of the Helix $v_{\rm helio}$\,=\,$v_{\rm LSR}$\,--3, in km\,s$^{-1}$).
366: Concerning PHL\,346, Keenan et al. (\cite{kee88}) find the Ca\,{\sc ii} K IS line
367: at $v_{\rm LSR}$\,=\,+21\,km\,s$^{-1}$, or $v_{\rm helio}$\,=\,+18\,km\,s$^{-1}$,
368: in good agreement with the other two bright stars.
369:
370: To conclude, the above considerations suggest that IS lines in our target
371: sightlines should display typical W$_{\lambda}$ of 200\,m\AA~ for Na\,{\sc i} D2, and
372: about the same for the Ca\,{\sc ii} K line (see Table 2). We expect
373: the IS lines to have $v_{\rm helio}$ within the interval
374: from $-$28 to +17\,km\,s$^{-1}$, although a velocity slightly outside of this expected
375: range is not excluded, because it is based on 3 sightlines which
376: are not exactly toward the Helix, but angularly shifted by a few degrees.
377:
378: %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%% figure 2 showing NAI and Ca\,{\sc ii} profiles ===========
379: \begin{figure*}
380:
381: \resizebox{\hsize}{!}{
382: {\rotatebox{-90}{\includegraphics{zzp000.ps}}}
383: {\rotatebox{-90}{\includegraphics{zzp013.ps}}} }
384:
385: \resizebox{\hsize}{!}{
386: {\rotatebox{-90}{\includegraphics{zzp046.ps}}}
387: {\rotatebox{-90}{\includegraphics{zzp213.ps}}} }
388:
389: \resizebox{\hsize}{!}{
390: {\rotatebox{-90}{\includegraphics{zzp166.ps}}}
391: {\rotatebox{-90}{\includegraphics{zzp085.ps}}} }
392:
393: \resizebox{\hsize}{!}{
394: {\rotatebox{-90}{\includegraphics{zzp185.ps}}}
395: {\rotatebox{-90}{\includegraphics{zzp091.ps}}} }
396:
397: \caption[]{Na\,{\sc i} D1 (5896\AA) and D2 (5890\AA) profiles (upper plots)
398: and Ca\,{\sc ii} H (3968\AA) and K (3933\AA) profiles for all eight targets.
399: For Na, D2 is the solid line and D1 the dotted. For Ca, the solid line
400: is K, the dotted H. The velocity of photospheric Na \& Ca lines is
401: shown by a vertical bar. In the left-hand four panels, we show targets \#1,
402: \#3, \#6 and \#7 for which we suspect there is no circumstellar Na D component.
403: The same is true of the nucleus (\#2, upper right) where we see
404: a pure IS spectrum because of the lack of photospheric contamination.
405: For \#8, the photosphere is well separated, at $\sim$\,+76\,km\,s$^{-1}$.
406: For \#4, the component at $-$25\,km\,s$^{-1}$ is most likely nebular, as
407: is most of the Na\,{\sc i} line for \#5 (see text).}
408: \label{f2}
409: \end{figure*}
410: %%%%==============================================================================
411:
412: \section{Results and analysis}
413:
414: \subsection{Characterising the nebular absorption using Na\,{\sc i} D profiles}
415:
416: Figure\,\ref{f2}
417: displays the Na\,{\sc i} D1 and D2 line profiles for all eight targets.
418: It is important to realize first that, for a given target, any detail seen in
419: {\it both} D1 and D2 profiles should be the signature of the same IS (or possibly
420: circumstellar) component, and one can indeed see in these spectra many
421: components with corresponding fully consistent D1 and D2 features.
422: This compensates for one of the difficulties of our experiment:
423: one has to be careful about the fact that the stellar continua of our targets
424: are not flat, as they would be for OB type stars. Consequently,
425: depending on the radial velocity of the targets, the Na\,{\sc i}
426: IS (or circumstellar) lines may
427: be blended with photospheric Na\,{\sc i} lines in the target stars themselves,
428: or, possibly, with a different photospheric feature.
429: Finally, since Na\,{\sc i} has now been detected in a number of PNs
430: (Dinerstein \& Sneden \cite{din88}; Dinerstein et al. \cite{din95}),
431: one can expect some circumstellar contribution, that could well be
432: significant.
433:
434: In Fig.\,\ref{f2}, the approximate range of velocities for IS components
435: (discussed above) is indicated by a horizontal dashed line labelled ``IS''.
436: Concerning the velocities of possible circumstellar components, we have
437: plotted with a horizontal solid line labelled ``PN'' the $v_{\rm helio}$ range
438: of the Helix gas: this range is from $-$55 to +2\,km\,s$^{-1}$, as derived
439: from CO and H\,{\sc i} line profiles (integrated over the PN).
440: In principle, in order to predict at which
441: velocity one could expect a circumstellar component, one might consider the
442: CO or H\,{\sc i} maps and look at the profiles at the exact position of each
443: target. In practice, this provides little information: none of the 8 targets are
444: covered by the H\,{\sc i} map of Rodriguez et al. (\cite{rod02}; their Fig.~4),
445: and CO is detected only to target \#3, after a careful examination of Fig.~1 of
446: Young et al. (\cite{you99});
447: the case of target \#3 is discussed below. Therefore, we adopt the view that
448: circumstellar Na\,{\sc i} components may occur anywhere within the CO or H\,{\sc i}
449: velocity range.
450:
451: \subsubsection{Targets 1, 3, 6 and 7 (Fig.\ref{f2}, left panels)}
452:
453: The case of blending with photospheric Na is obviously present
454: for targets \#1, \#3, \#6 and \#7. In the light of the
455: above comments, these four targets
456: show nothing exceptional which is not explained by photospheric
457: {\it plus} IS contributions.
458: We note one component at $v_{\rm helio} \approx +25$\,km\,s$^{-1}$
459: for \#1 and \#6. This is +7\,km\,s$^{-1}$ outside
460: the expected velocity range of IS lines, and not near the $v_{\rm helio}$
461: of the Helix itself or that of the target photospheres. It may be a local
462: feature of the ISM affecting only these lines of sight.
463:
464: There is also a distinct component at
465: $v_{\rm helio}$\,$\approx$\, $-10$\,km\,s$^{-1}$
466: for \#3 and \#7, and this might {\it a priori} be assigned to
467: IS matter in these lines of sight, since their W$_{\lambda}$(D2) are
468: $\sim$\,100 and 230\,m\AA~for \#3 and \#7 respectively, and because
469: this velocity falls in the expected range for IS absorptions. The relatively small
470: value for \#3 (suggesting a lack of a circumstellar contribution)
471: is surprising in view of the location of this target within the CO isophotes
472: (see Fig.~1 of Young et al. \cite{you99}).This line of sight should trace
473: neutral/molecular nebular material, but this is not apparent in Na\,{\sc i} and
474: it may be that the Helix is located beyond this star, which is the nearest of
475: all the targets.
476: In any case, the component is not at the observed CO velocity
477: in this region, between $-$30 and $-$50 \,km\,s$^{-1}$, see Fig.~3 of
478: Young et al. (\cite{you99}).
479: For target \#7, well off the PN and CO contours, the strength
480: of this particular component is typical of the ISM in the direction of the Helix.
481:
482: \subsubsection{ Targets 2, 8 (Fig.\,\ref{f2}, upper right panels)}
483:
484: One can pursue this analysis further by considering target \#2 (the PN nucleus)
485: and target \#8, for which no blending with photospheric lines
486: exists. For the nucleus, this is because no photospheric Na\,{\sc i} line is expected,
487: given its likely very hot $T_{\rm eff}$. Target \#8 is cooler with an
488: estimated F5V spectral type, but its $v_{\rm helio}$ is such
489: (+76\,km\,s$^{-1}$) that the Na\,{\sc i} components are unaffected by any
490: photospheric Na line, or indeed any other line, since the D1 and D2
491: profiles resemble each other accurately.
492: The distances of these two stars are $\sim$\,210--240 pc.
493: For \#2, W$_{\lambda}$(D2) is found to be $\sim$\,150\,m\AA, and we
494: do not expect any circumstellar absorption, because of the PN geometry,
495: or photospheric absorption, so by definition this is the ISM probed towards the nucleus
496: itself, at its fairly well-known distance.
497:
498: For target \#8, well off the PN, the
499: photospheric and (presumably) IS components are well separated (as mentioned above)
500: and we can measure the photospheric (D2) strength as $\sim$\,250\,m\AA~(seemingly
501: typical of all our F--G type targets). The IS component is surprisingly strong at
502: 410\,m\AA. Because the absorption velocities in both \#2 and \#8 are
503: at $\sim$\,+15 km\,s$^{-1}$, not within the Helix $v_{\rm helio}$ range,
504: the simplest interpretation is that we are again tracing the foreground ISM, although
505: one cannot entirely rule out a nebular contribution.
506:
507: \subsubsection{ Targets 4 and 5 (Fig.\,\ref{f2}, lower right panels)}
508:
509: Finally, targets \#4 and \#5 are particularly interesting for our
510: purposes because they are distant ($\sim$\,1500\,pc), and because they
511: are located close to the edge or angularly slightly
512: outside the bulk of the ionized PN gas. They are close to
513: the lowest contours of the available H\,{\sc i} and CO maps. Therefore,
514: one can expect that these line of sight probe some neutral PN gas. Examination
515: of the data indeed suggest this is the case.
516:
517: Given the strength of the Na\,{\sc i} absorptions towards \#5, and that
518: their velocity range lie largely within the PN CO velocity range, we are led to
519: attribute at least a significant part of the absorption to circumstellar
520: material. The case of \#4 is perhaps even more clear cut; there is a strong,
521: well-resolved component centred very closely
522: on the $v_{\rm helio}$ of the Helix which lies at the (negative) velocity limit
523: of where IS absorptions are expected. This component is at
524: $\sim$$-$25\,km\,s$^{-1}$; the equivalent width of the individual component
525: in D2 is 350\,m\AA, exceeding the canonical ISM expectation by nearly a factor of 2.
526: Similarly, we note that \#5 has by far the greatest total Na\,{\sc i} equivalent
527: width, in both D1 and D2, of all the targets, certainly where the photosphere
528: is well removed in velocity (\#7 has comparable absorption strength
529: but includes a significant photospheric component). This in itself lends support to
530: the thesis that we are probing nebular Na\,{\sc i} towards \#4 and \#5.
531:
532: The surprising strength of the Na\,{\sc i} lines to
533: target \#5 suggests a further favourable argument; summing over the three components,
534: one finds W$_{\lambda}$(D2) $\approx$\,1000\,m\AA, much stronger than the
535: expected level from the ISM. Moreover, the individual D1 and D2 components,
536: which are only partially resolved our velocity resolution (6\,km\,s$^{-1}$),
537: are in fact probably saturated, and the ratio W$_{\lambda}$(D2)/W$_{\lambda}$(D1) is
538: found to be 980/740\,$\sim$\,1.3, significantly less than a factor of 2, indicating that
539: the lines are not formed in the linear regime of the curve of growth. A much better
540: resolution ($\sim$\,1\,km\,s$^{-1}$) would be necessary to accurately derive
541: column densities, and assess, e.g. the importance of blending, saturation
542: and wing shapes. However, one can obtain a rough estimate by comparing
543: the data to IS cases described in previous studies of IS Na\,{\sc i} lines.
544: By considering the IS Na\,{\sc i} survey of Hobbs (\cite{hob78}), a
545: W$_{\lambda}$(D2) value of $\approx$\,1000\,m\AA\,\, is enormous compared
546: to usual IS lines of sight, especially when one considers the Helix
547: high galactic latitude. In Hobbs' survey, the largest D2 Na\,{\sc i} widths are at
548: 500, 520 and 530 m\AA, and the corresponding $N$(Na\,{\sc i}) are 3.1, 1.3 and 7.8
549: $\times$ 10$^{+13}$\,cm$^{-2}$. In view of these numbers,
550: one can reasonably estimate that to \#5 the column density
551: $N$(Na\,{\sc i}) is of the order of at least $\sim$\,4\,$\times$\,10$^{+13}$\,cm$^{-2}$,
552: or $\sim$\,\,20 or 40 times stronger than the expectation from the galactic layer
553: ($\sim$ 1--2\,$\times$\,10$^{+12}$\,cm$^{-2}$, Sect.~4).
554:
555: To conclude, we strongly favour
556: a circumstellar origin for the Na\,{\sc i} components described above.
557: Finding some Na\,{\sc i} in the neutral gas of the Helix is also consistent with
558: other observations on several PNs (Dinerstein \& Sneden \cite{din88},
559: Dinerstein et al. \cite{din95}).
560: In addition, we shall see in the following that further evidence for a circumstellar
561: origin is carried by the Ca\,{\sc ii} lines analysed below.
562:
563:
564: \subsection{Analysis of the Ca\,{\sc ii} lines}
565:
566: In Fig.\,\ref{f2} are displayed the Ca\,{\sc ii} regions for all targets. Except for
567: the nucleus (\#2) that provides a generous, flat continuum, all other targets show
568: broad, deep Ca\,{\sc ii} photospheric lines, implying unfortunately low $S/N$ ratios.
569: Note that with the exception of \#7, the spectra have been normalised to the highest point
570: in the displayed range so as to best display the details, since the IS or circumstellar
571: features must be sought against the local continuum noise. For \#7, the signal is much too
572: faint and the $S/N$ too poor for showing any detection, because the velocity range falls
573: in the very deep core of the Ca\,{\sc ii} lines (\#7 a K giant). For this star,
574: the line profile have been shifted up by 0.2 for clarity.
575:
576: The IS Ca\,{\sc ii} line is clearly seen to target \#2, with a strength in
577: very good agreement with those of the neighbouring stars of Table 2. This IS component at
578: $v_{\rm helio}$\,$\sim$\,+10 km\,s$^{-1}$ is also seen, more or less clearly, to
579: \#1, \#8, \#4 and \#5. For \#3, \#6 and \#7, the noise is too large.
580:
581: It is therefore quite surprising to notice that, for \#4, absolutely no trace
582: of a Ca\,{\sc ii} line is seen for the strong, double component at $\sim -20$\,km\,s$^{-1}$.
583: Similarly, it is even more striking that, to \#5,
584: the components at $v$\,$<$\,$-5$\,km\,s$^{-1}$ , being nearly saturated in Na D, have no
585: Ca\,{\sc ii} counterparts. The contrast with the case of \#2 is obvious.
586:
587: This lack of Ca\,{\sc ii} components can be easily understood in the case
588: of absorption by circumstellar matter. There have been already a number of studies
589: concerning abundances in the gas phase of PN that showed that Ca is
590: very depleted in the ionized phase, otherwise e.g. the [Ca\,{\sc ii}] 7291\,\AA\, and
591: 7323\,\AA\, forbidden lines would be of great strength, whereas they are generally absent.
592: The commonly accepted explanation is that, even in the ionized phase,
593: Ca is almost completely
594: locked in very robust grains that resist the effects of the hard UV radiation or
595: interaction with the PN plasma (see for example Shields \cite{shi83};
596: Ferland \cite{fer93}; Volk et al. \cite{vol97}; Dopita et al. \cite{dop94};
597: Dopita et al. \cite{dop00}).
598: These grains are not easily directly observed (or/and their abundance measured),
599: but they are necessary to explain the
600: strong depletion of various refractories. This extreme Ca
601: depletion in PNs is quite general and occurs in both O-rich or C-rich PNs.
602: It seems to us natural to deduce that since Ca is depleted in PNs,
603: e.g. {\it their ionized phase}, Ca is also very depleted in the neutral phase
604: that we are probing with Na\,{\sc i} (Na is
605: not a refractory species and is not, or only very lightly, depleted).
606: Our interpretation is the Ca atoms reside in
607: the hard cores, condensed at high temperature, of the heterogeneous grains that
608: form in the cool AGB winds and that eventually lose their more fragile
609: envelope during the PN formation.
610:
611: \subsection{A search for circumstellar diffuse bands}
612:
613: %%%%=====================================================================================
614: \begin{figure}
615: \resizebox{\hsize}{!}{\rotatebox{-90}{\includegraphics{zz-plotz-6614-t85.ps}}}
616: \resizebox{\hsize}{!}{\rotatebox{-90}{\includegraphics{zz-plotz-6614-t91.ps}}}
617: \resizebox{\hsize}{!}{\rotatebox{-90}{\includegraphics{zz-plotz-5780-t91.ps}}}
618: \caption[]{{\it Upper panel}: Spectrum of \#4 in the region of the 6614\,\AA\,
619: DIB (``Data''). The overplotted dotted line is the expected
620: 6614\,\AA\, feature for an equivalent width of 50\,m\AA\, and no noise.
621: The lower curve (``Simul.'') is the same DIB simulated after adding noise
622: similar to the data noise.
623: {\it Middle panel}: Same for \#5, for which the data $S/N$ is significantly better.
624: If present, a 6614\,\AA\, DIB of 50\,m\AA\, would be very clearly seen to \#5.
625: {\it Lower panel}: Spectrum of \#5 near the 5780 DIB.
626: A DIB at 5780\,\AA\, of 100\,m\AA\, is shown and would be fairly well detected.}
627: \label{f3}
628: \end{figure}
629: %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%==============================================
630:
631: We searched for DIBs in all the targets spectra, and found none. For targets
632: probing the ISM (see above), this lack of DIBs is fully expected, because the
633: IS excess is only $E_{\rm B-V}$\,$\sim$\,0.03, and the $S/N$ of our spectra is limited,
634: despite $\sim$\,1\,hr exposure times with VLT-UVES.
635: For example, from the work of Kumar (\cite{kum86}) on low colour excess stars (see his Table 1),
636: one finds that, for $E_{\rm B-V}$\,=\,0.10\,$\pm$\,0.01, the 6614\,\AA~ DIB equivalent
637: width (noted $W_{\lambda}$)
638: is $W_{\lambda}$(6614)\,=\,20\,m\AA\, (4 stars, $\sigma$\,=\,2\,m\AA);
639: for $E_{\rm B-V}$\,=\,0.075\,$\pm$\,0.005, $W_{\lambda}$(6614)\,=\,5\,m\AA\,
640: (8\,\,stars, $\sigma$\,=\,4\,m\AA).
641: Alternatively, Galazutdinov et al. (\cite{gal98}) show for the $\lambda$5780 DIB that
642: equivalent widths of the order of 30--40\,m\AA\, are observed for their lowest colour excess
643: sightlines ($E_{\rm B-V}$\,=\,0.05\,$\pm$\,0.01, comparable to those discussed above).
644: The DIB strengths due to the ISM in the
645: direction of the Helix are thus quite small (perhaps as low as
646: $\sim$\,5\,m\AA\, but possibly up to 30\,m\AA) and
647: simulations presented below show that our experiments cannot detect such weak
648: DIB signals. However, our experiment may only be perhaps
649: a factor 2--3 insufficiently sensitive to detect the ISM in the strongest DIBs.
650:
651:
652: Figure \ref{f3} shows the observed spectra of targets \#4 and \#5 in the region
653: of the 6614\,\AA~ DIB (labelled ``Data''). For
654: both objects, we also show the DIB profiles that would be seen if their equivalent
655: width were 50\,m\AA\, either with an infinite $S/N$ (overplotted dotted line), or
656: with an added noise similar to the data (lower curve). The DIB profile
657: was approximated by a Gaussian with FWHM\,1.0\,\AA\, (Walker et al. \cite{wal00}).
658: The DIB central wavelength is the rest value,
659: 6613.56\,\AA, as given by Galazutdinov et al. (\cite{gal00}), with uncertainty $\sim$ 0.1\,\AA.
660: No velocity shift was applied since the Earth velocity shift of +20\,km\,s$^{-1}$
661: and the average heliocentric velocity of the Helix ($-28$\,km\,s$^{-1}$) almost cancel.
662: One can see that for \#4, a 50\,m\AA\, 6614\,\AA~ DIB would be fairly
663: detectable, and for \#5 where the $S/N$ is better, it would be very clearly seen.
664: On the basis of these plots, a 3\,$\sigma$ upper limit to
665: $W_{\lambda}$(6614) for target \#5 is taken as $\sim$\,25\,m\AA.
666:
667: The limits for other DIBs, e.g. at 5780\,\AA , are not better (see Fig.\,\ref{f3}).
668: The 5780\,\AA\, DIB is generally stronger in equivalent width
669: than $\lambda$6614, but it is also
670: twice wider; $\sim$\,2.0\,\AA\, FWHM, as observed by Galazutdinov et al. (\cite{gal98}).
671: In our spectra, its detection is not easier than for $\lambda$6614,
672: especially because of faint photospheric lines lying in this
673: region. In the end, for $W_{\lambda}$(5780), we derive an
674: upper limit of $\sim$\,70\,m\AA.
675:
676: Instead of comparing the data with simulations,
677: one might derive 3\,$\sigma$ upper limits with the usual formula, as given by,
678: e.g.,\, Cowie \& Songaila (\cite{cow86}): for a line that falls over
679: $m$ resolution elements, the $3\sigma$ detectable equivalent width is
680: $W(3\sigma)$\,=\,3\,$\lambda$\,$m^{1/2}$\,$R^{-1}$\,$(S/N)^{-1}$,
681: where $S/N$ is the signal-to-noise ratio in each resolution element.
682: For the $\lambda$6614 DIB, one finds with our data $W(3\sigma)$\,$\sim$\,10\,m\AA.
683: However, the above formula, while taking into account the observed $S/N$, assumes an absence of
684: other (photospheric) lines,
685: which may not be the case (see Fig.\,\ref{f3}).
686: Therefore, we believe that the limits derived from simulations are more
687: appropriate.
688:
689: \section{Discussion}
690:
691: The primary goal of this work was to search for circumstellar diffuse bands: none
692: were found, but we discovered two targets, \#4 and \#5, whose lines of sight indeed probe
693: some neutral PN gas, with such a strong Na\,{\sc i} absorption, and strong Ca
694: depletion, that the two together cannot possibly be due to the foreground or
695: background ISM.
696:
697: A further indication that the sightline to \#5 is far from typically interstellar is obtained by
698: plotting $W_{\lambda}$(5780) $versus$ $W_{\lambda}$(D2) (Fig.\,\ref{f4}). The data for IS
699: lines were taken from the compilation of Herbig (\cite{her93}) and involves sightlines with
700: $E_{\rm B-V}$ between 0 and 1.5. We see a clear increase of $W_{\lambda}$(5780)
701: with increasing D2 equivalent width. The representative point
702: of sightline \#5 is the full black square. Not only $W_{\lambda}$(D2) appears
703: huge compared to other sightlines, especially when one realizes that \#5 is
704: at high galactic latitude, but this plot suggests that if {\em only} IS matter were
705: probed, then we would see $W_{\lambda}$(5780)$\ga$\,400\,m\AA,
706: which is definitely not the case. Therefore, the material seen in the line of sight to
707: \#5 must be overwhelmingly of circumstellar origin.
708:
709:
710: The fact that no DIBs have been seen is consistent with their absence in several other
711: archetypal sources with carbon-rich circumstellar material. For example, in the case of
712: IRC\,+10$^{\circ}$\,216 which is very rich in molecules, including carbon chains,
713: no DIB was detected on a sightline for which the Na\,{\sc i} absorption lines were
714: heavily saturated, the K\,{\sc i} lines were very strong with
715: $W_{\lambda}$\,$\sim$\,500\,m\AA~ (Kendall et al. \cite{ken02}),
716: and the C$_2$ molecule was detected (Kendall et al. \cite{ken04}).
717: In the case of the post-AGB star HR\,4049, Waters et al. (\cite{wat89}) showed that the
718: circumstellar dust is carbon-rich and displays the emission features at 7, 9 and 11.3
719: $\mu$m attributed to PAHs, but no DIB was detected. Waters et al. (\cite{wat89})
720: obtained a stringent
721: limit on the DIB abundance, with $W_{\lambda}(6614) < 4.2$ m\AA\, despite
722: a large circumstellar reddening, $E_{\rm B-V}$ being between 0.19 and 0.29.
723: Compared to these two objects, the Helix is a third interesting case; its nucleus is much
724: hotter than HR\,4049, but the PN also still contains much circumstellar
725: molecular and dusty material left by the AGB progenitor wind. A peculiarity
726: of the Helix is that there are no PAH mid-infrared features, interpreted by Cox et al.
727: (\cite{cox98})
728: as due to a destruction of small grains by the hard radiation field of the nucleus in the
729: early PN phase.
730:
731: Finding no DIBs in these three typical but quite different
732: objects suggests that DIBs are not fabricated in AGB envelopes or PNs. However,
733: it will now become even more necessary to $i$.) fully explain the origin of the
734: emission bands in the Red Rectangle and their possible relation to DIBs;
735: and $ii$.) further examine the few cases
736: of carbon stars and post-AGB objects mentioned in Sect.~1 for which evidence for
737: circumstellar diffuse bands have been put forward.
738:
739: It will also be interesting to perform specific observations of targets \#4 and \#5
740: with a higher spectral resolution and/or a better signal-to-noise ratio in order to detect
741: other species, e.g. K\,{\sc i}, C$_{2}$ or CN, to establish whether
742: these circumstellar lines of sight probe any molecular matter, to infer
743: the total hydrogen column density and obtain a more quantitative upper limit to the
744: DIB abundance.
745:
746: %=========================== figure showing $W_{\lambda}$(5780) versus $W_{\lambda}$(NaI 5890)
747: \begin{figure}
748: \centering
749: \resizebox{\hsize}{!}{
750: {\rotatebox{-90} {\includegraphics{zzz-plot-na-5780.ps}} }
751: }
752: \caption{Plot of the equivalent widths of the 5780\,\AA~DIB {\it versus} the
753: Na\,{\sc i} D2 5890\,\AA\, equivalent widths (open circles), for interstellar
754: data of Herbig (\cite{her93}). The solid square at lower right
755: represents the upper limit of $\lambda$5780 for target \#5,
756: which has $W_{\lambda}$(Na\,{\sc i} D2) $\sim$ 1000\,m\AA. This plot
757: illustrates the deficiency of $\lambda$5780,
758: further supporting the {\it circumstellar}
759: nature of the matter probed by this target.}
760: \label{f4}
761: \end{figure}
762: %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%====================================================================
763:
764:
765:
766: \section{Summary and conclusions}
767:
768: 1.-- With the goal of studying the neutral gas
769: of the Helix PN and the presence of circumstellar
770: diffuse bands, VLT/UVES spectroscopy was achieved
771: on 8 targets lying within
772: $\sim$\,13\arcmin~ of the PN centre, including its nucleus.
773: Using available 2MASS and UBV photometry, the spectral
774: types of the targets could be estimated. This allowed the
775: derivation of distances, which are found to be in the
776: range $\sim$ 200\,pc to 1500\,pc. Thus, several targets
777: are located far beyond the Helix and can be used as background
778: sources, angularly placed on or off the visible nebula.
779:
780: 2.-- Of the 8 targets, four (including the nucleus)
781: can particularly be exploited because they show little
782: blending between the interstellar/circumstellar Na\,{\sc i} lines
783: and the photospheric lines of the background target itself,
784: which are either absent, favorably shifted by the stellar radial
785: velocity, or/and broadened by stellar rotation.
786:
787: 3.-- By analysing the extinction maps around the Helix, and IS
788: lines observed towards 3 bright stars in a $\sim$\,5\degr~zone around the Helix,
789: we could estimate the expected contribution
790: of the foreground and background ISM, in terms of equivalent
791: width of the Na\,{\sc i} lines (W$_{\lambda}$(D2) $\sim$\,200m\AA),
792: and the expected range of heliocentric velocities for IS lines.
793:
794: 4.-- It appears that many of the Na\,{\sc i} components observed in the target
795: spectra are probably of IS origin. However, for two targets (\# 4 and \#5),
796: our analysis shows that {\it circumstellar} Na\,{\sc i} is observed in absorption.
797: For \#5, a very strong Na\,{\sc i} column density is derived, at least
798: 20 times larger than the expected IS contribution.
799: The circumstellar origin is also supported by the fact that no corresponding
800: absorption Ca\,{\sc ii} K line is detected, in contrast to IS lines. This fact
801: is well understood: since Ca is always very depleted in the ionized phases of
802: planetary nebulae, it is probably depleted as well and locked
803: in the circumstellar grains of the cool neutral phase, where dust has not yet been
804: subject to strong UV radiation and plasma interaction.
805:
806: 5.-- No diffuse bands were detected. The expected bands from the foreground
807: and background ISM are not strong enough ($W_{\lambda}$(6614)\,$\sim$\,5 to 20\,m\AA) to
808: be seen in our spectra. Nor do the circumstellar lines of sight to \#4 and \#5
809: show any bands.
810: Qualitatively, our data do not favour abundant fabrication of diffuse band
811: carriers in the Helix.
812:
813:
814: \begin{acknowledgements}
815: The authors warmly thank Claudio Melo, Jonathan Smoker, and the ESO staff,
816: for their assistance during observations. Thanks also to Christophe Mercier
817: at Montpellier for his help in making Figure 1. We also thank the anonymous referee
818: for comments that helped to improve the paper. N.M. acknowledges support from the
819: French CNRS Program {\it Physico-chimie du Milieu Interstellaire}. T.R.K.
820: acknowledges support from the French {\it Minist\`{e}re de la Recherche}. The publication
821: makes use of data products from 2MASS, which is a joint project of the
822: Univ. of Massachusetts and the Infrared Analysis and Processing Centre, California
823: Institute of Technology, funded by NASA and NSF.
824: This research has also made use of the ESO MIDAS data analysis
825: software, the NOAO IRAF software and the SIMBAD database, operated
826: at CDS, Strasbourg, France.
827: \end{acknowledgements}
828:
829: \begin{thebibliography}{}
830:
831: \bibitem[1983]{alb83} Albert, C.E. 1983, ApJ, 272, 509
832:
833: \bibitem[1978]{boh78} Bohlin, R.C., Savage, B.D.,
834: \& Drake, J.F. 1978, ApJ, 224, 132
835:
836: \bibitem[1986]{cow86} Cowie, L.L., \& Songaila, A., 1986,
837: ARA\&A, 24, 499
838:
839: \bibitem[1998]{cox98} Cox, P., Boulanger, F., Huggins, P.J., et al. 1998,
840: ApJ, 495, L23
841:
842: \bibitem[1982]{bur82} Burnstein, D.,
843: \& Heiles, C. 1982, AJ, 87, 1165
844:
845: \bibitem[1988]{din88} Dinerstein, H.L.,
846: \& Sneden, C. 1988, ApJL, 335, L23
847:
848: \bibitem[1995]{din95} Dinerstein, H.L., Sneden, C., \&
849: Uglum, J. 1995, ApJ, 447, 262
850:
851: \bibitem[1994]{dop94} Dopita, M.A., Vassiliadis, E.,
852: Meatheringham, S.J., Ford, H.C., et al. 1994, ApJ, 426, 150
853:
854: \bibitem[2000]{dop00} Dopita, M.A., \& Sutherland, R.S.
855: 2000, ApJ, 539, 742
856:
857: \bibitem[1998]{dul98} Duley, W.W. 1998, MNRAS, 301,955
858:
859: \bibitem[1993]{fer93} Ferland, G.J. 1993, in Planetary Nebulae,
860: ed. R. Weinberger \& A. Acker (Dordrecht, Reidel), 123
861:
862: \bibitem[1985]{fer85} Ferlet, R., Vidal-Madjar, A.,
863: \& Gry, C. 1985, ApJ, 298, 838
864:
865: \bibitem[1991]{gar91} Garcia, B. 1991, A\&AS, 89, 469
866:
867: \bibitem[1998]{gal98} Galazutdinov, G.A.,
868: Krelowski, J., Moutou, C., \& Musaev, F.A. 1998, MNRAS, 295, 437
869:
870: \bibitem[2000]{gal00} Galazutdinov, G.A.,
871: Musaev, F.A., Krelowski, J., \& Walker, G.A.H. 2000, PASP, 112, 648
872:
873: \bibitem[2002]{gli02} Glinski, R.J., \& Anderson,
874: C.M. 2002, MNRAS, 332, L17
875:
876: \bibitem[1993]{her93} Herbig, G.H. 1993, ApJ, 407, 142
877:
878: \bibitem[1995]{her95} Herbig, G.H. 1995, ARA\&A, 33, 19
879:
880: \bibitem[1978]{hob78} Hobbs, L.M. 1978, ApJSS, 38, 129
881:
882: \bibitem[1999]{hug99} Huggins, P.J., Cox, P., Forveille, T.,
883: Bachiller, R., \& Young, K. 1999, in IAU Symposium 191,
884: Asymptotic Giant Branch Stars, ed. T. Le Bertre,
885: A. Lebre \& C. Waelkens (Astronomical Society of the Pacific), 425
886:
887: \bibitem[1988]{kee88} Keenan, F.P., Conlon, E.S.,
888: Brown, P.J.F., \& Dufton, P.L. 1988, A\&A, 192, 295
889:
890: \bibitem[2002]{ken02} Kendall, T.R., Mauron, N., McCombie, J.,
891: \& Sarre, P.J. 2002, A\&A, 387, 624
892:
893: \bibitem[2004]{ken04} Kendall, T.R., Mauron, N., McCombie, J.,
894: \& Sarre, P.J. 2004, Ap\&SS, 289, 203
895:
896: \bibitem[1999]{klo99} Klochkova, V.G., Szczerba, R.,
897: Panchuk, V.E., \& Volk, K. 1999, A\&A, 354, 905
898:
899: \bibitem[2000]{klo00} Klochkova, V.G., Szczerba, R.,
900: \& Panchuk, V.E. 2000, Astr. Lett., 26, 88
901:
902: \bibitem[2001]{klo01} Klochkova, V.G., Panchuk, V.E.,
903: \& Szczerba, R. 2001, in Post-AGB objects
904: as a Phase of Stellar Evolution, ed. R. Szczerba \& S.K. Gorny
905: (Kluwer Academic Publishers), 265
906:
907: \bibitem[1986]{kum86} Kumar, C.K. 1986, ApJ, 306, 38
908:
909: \bibitem[1990]{leb90} Le Bertre, T. 1990, A\&A, 236, 472
910:
911: \bibitem[1992]{leb92} Le Bertre, T., \& Lequeux, J.
912: 1992, A\&A, 255, 288
913:
914: \bibitem[1993]{leb93} Le Bertre, T., \& Lequeux, J.
915: 1993, A\&A, 274, 909
916:
917: \bibitem[1993]{rao93} Rao, N.K., \& Lambert, D.L.
918: 1993, MNRAS, 263, L27
919:
920: \bibitem[2002]{rod02} Rodriguez, L.F., Goss, W.M., \&
921: Williams, R. 2002, ApJ, 574, 179
922:
923: \bibitem[1995]{sar95} Sarre, P.J., Miles, J.R.,
924: \& Scarrott, S.M. 1995, Science, 269, 674
925:
926: \bibitem[1992]{sca92} Scarrott, S.M., Watkin, S., Miles, J.R., \& Sarre, P.J. 1992,
927: MNRAS, 255, 11
928:
929: \bibitem[1998]{sch98} Schlegel, D.J., Finkbeiner, D.P.,
930: \& Davis, M. 1998, ApJ, 500, 525.
931:
932: \bibitem[1983]{shi83} Shields, G.A. 1983, in Planetary Nebulae,
933: ed. D.R. Flower (IAU), 259
934:
935: \bibitem[2002]{spe02} Speck, A.K., Meixner, M., Fong, D., McCullough,
936: P.R., Moser, D.E., \& Ueta, T. 2002, AJ, 123, 346
937:
938: \bibitem[1973]{sno73} Snow, T.P. 1973, PASP, 85, 590
939:
940: \bibitem[1972]{snw72} Snow, T.P., Wallerstein, G. 1972, PASP, 84, 492
941:
942: \bibitem[2002]{vwi02} Van Winckel, H., Cohen, M.,
943: \& Gull, T.R. 2002, A\&A, 390, 147
944:
945: \bibitem[1997]{vol97} Volk, K., Dinerstein, H., \& Sneden, C.1997, in
946: IAU Symposium 180, Planetary Nebulae, ed. H.J. Habing \& H.J.G.L.M.
947: Lamers (Kluwer Academic, Publishers, Dordrecht), 284
948:
949: \bibitem[2000]{wal00} Walker, G.A.H., Bohlender, D.A.,
950: \& Krelowski, J. 2000, ApJ, 530, 362
951:
952: \bibitem[1989]{wat89} Waters, L.B.F.M., Lamers, H.J.G.L.M., Snow, T.P.,
953: et al. 1989, A\&A, 211,208
954:
955: \bibitem[1997]{you97} Young, K., Cox, P., Huggins, P.J., Forveille, Y.,
956: \& Bachiller, R. 1997, ApJ, 482, L101
957:
958: \bibitem[1999]{you99} Young, K., Cox, P., Huggins, P.J., Forveille, T.,
959: \& Bachiller, R. 1999, ApJ, 522, 837
960:
961: \bibitem[1999]{zac99} Zacs, L., Schmidt, M.R., \& Szczerba, R. 1999,
962: MNRAS, 306, 903
963:
964: \bibitem[2003]{zac03} Zacs, L., Spelmanis, R.,
965: Musaev, F.A., \& Galazutdinov, G.A. 2003, MNRAS, 339, 460
966:
967: \end{thebibliography}
968: \end{document}
969: %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%
970:
971:
972:
973:
974:
975:
976:
977: