1: %\documentclass[12pt,preprint]{aastex}
2: \documentclass{emulateapj}
3:
4: %% manuscript produces a one-column, double-spaced document:
5:
6: %% \documentclass[manuscript]{aastex}
7:
8: %% preprint2 produces a double-column, single-spaced document:
9:
10: %% \documentclass[preprint2]{aastex}
11:
12: %% Sometimes a paper's abstract is too long to fit on the
13: %% title page in preprint2 mode. When that is the case,
14: %% use the longabstract style option.
15:
16: %% \documentclass[preprint2,longabstract]{aastex}
17:
18: %% If you want to create your own macros, you can do so
19: %% using \newcommand. Your macros should appear before
20: %% the \begin{document} command.
21: %%
22: %% If you are submitting to a journal that translates manuscripts
23: %% into SGML, you need to follow certain guidelines when preparing
24: %% your macros. See the AASTeX v5.x Author Guide
25: %% for information.
26:
27: \newcommand{\vdag}{(v)^\dagger}
28: \newcommand{\myemail}{rsl@phyast.pitt.edu}
29:
30: %% You can insert a short comment on the title page using the command below.
31:
32: \slugcomment{To appear in ApJL., ???}
33:
34: %% If you wish, you may supply running head information, although
35: %% this information may be modified by the editorial offices.
36: %% The left head contains a list of authors,
37: %% usually a maximum of three (otherwise use et al.). The right
38: %% head is a modified title of up to roughly 44 characters.
39: %% Running heads will not print in the manuscript style.
40:
41: \shorttitle{SBS~1543+593}
42: \shortauthors{Schulte-Ladbeck et al.}
43:
44: \begin{document}
45:
46: %% LaTeX will automatically break titles if they run longer than
47: %% one line. However, you may use \\ to force a line break if
48: %% you desire.
49:
50: \title{Emission-line spectroscopy of Damped Lyman Alpha Systems: The case of SBS~1543+593/HS~1543+5921}
51:
52: \author{Regina E. Schulte-Ladbeck\altaffilmark{1},
53: Brigitte K\"onig\altaffilmark{1},
54: Christopher J. Miller\altaffilmark{2},
55: Andrew M. Hopkins\altaffilmark{1},
56: Igor O. Drozdovsky\altaffilmark{3},
57: David A. Turnshek\altaffilmark{1},
58: and Ulrich Hopp\altaffilmark{4}
59: }
60:
61:
62: \email{rsl@phyast.pitt.edu, bkoenig@phyast.pitt.edu,
63: cmiller@noao.edu, ahopkins@anu.phyast.pitt.edu, dio@ipac.calthech.edu,
64: turnshek@quasar.phyast.pitt.edu, hopp@usm.uni-muenchen.de}
65: \altaffiltext{1}{Physics \& Astronomy Department, University of
66: Pittsburgh, Pittsburgh, PA 15260, USA} \altaffiltext{2}{Cerro Tololo
67: Inter-American Observatory, Chile} \altaffiltext{3}{Spitzer Science
68: Center, California Institute of Technology, Pasadena, CA 91125, USA}
69: \altaffiltext{4}{Universit\"atssternwarte M\"unchen, Scheinerstr. 1,
70: D-81679 M\"unchen, Germany}
71:
72:
73: \begin{abstract}
74: We report HST/STIS spectroscopy and Gemini/GMOS-N imaging of the
75: Damped Lyman Alpha (DLA) system toward HS~1543+5921 caused by the host
76: star-forming galaxy (SFG) SBS~1543+593. The Gemini image shows new
77: morphological details of this well resolved DLA galaxy. In combination
78: with previous optical spectra, the new UV spectra enable us to compare
79: for the first time, ionized and neutral gas-phase alpha-element abundances
80: derived from emission- and absorption-line spectroscopy, in a bona fide DLA
81: galaxy. The abundances we determine using emission-line diagnostics agree
82: with those from absorption-line diagnostics. We present our results on
83: a metallicity versus redshift diagram that combines local HII regions
84: and SFGs with high-redshift DLAs, and discuss implications for the chemical
85: evolution of galaxies.
86: \end{abstract}
87:
88: \keywords{galaxies:individual:SBS 1543+593---quasars:individual: HS 1543+5921---galaxies:abundances---galaxies:quasars:absorption lines }
89:
90: \section{Introduction}
91:
92: Damped Lyman Alpha systems on the sightlines to background quasars
93: exhibit high neutral hydrogen column densities and are thought to
94: arise in early disk galaxies capable to sustain star formation
95: \citep{wolfe1990}. But over the last decade, only about a dozen DLA
96: {\it~galaxies} have been identified and imaged \cite[e.g.][]{turn2002,
97: chen2005}.
98:
99: The chance projection of the galaxy SBS~1543+593 (z=0.0096) and the
100: background QSO HS~1543+5921 (z=0.807) 2.4'' away from the center of
101: the galaxy (Fig.~\ref{fig:sbs}) was discovered by \citet{reimers1998}.
102: \citet{bowen2001} and \citet{bowen2001b} noticed that the galaxy gives
103: rise to a DLA system in the spectrum of the QSO. \citet{sl2004a}
104: studied SBS~1543+593 using HST imaging and ground based
105: spectroscopy. They classified it an Sm dwarf galaxy with properties
106: that are entirely in line with those of other local dwarf
107: galaxies. Several of 33 HST-discovered HII regions were analyzed with
108: emission-line diagnostics. For the brightest region (\#5) all emission
109: lines necessary to derive the O and N abundances were detected.
110:
111: SBS~1543+593 offers an excellent opportunity to directly compare
112: element abundances inferred from cool interstellar gas (DLAs) and
113: ionized gas (SFGs). None of the previously imaged DLA galaxies
114: resolves to show individual HII regions. In none of them, does the
115: sightline to the QSO intercept the disk of the galaxy well within its
116: optical radius, let alone, close to its center, thus eliminating concerns
117: over metallicity gradients. SBS~1543+593 facilitates
118: an important inquiry into the behavior of galaxy metallicities with
119: redshift, because almost all available abundances at high redshifts
120: are determined from QSO absorption line studies and refer to iron-peak
121: elements such as Zn and Cr \citep{pettini2004}, whereas at low
122: redshifts, derivations of chemical abundances are based on nebular
123: emission-line studies in star-forming regions, and are primarily,
124: based on the alpha-capture element oxygen
125: \citep[e.g.][]{garnett2004}. \cite{chen2005} recently derived O
126: abundances from emission-lines in one DLA and one sub-DLA galaxy; the
127: QSOs' spectra allowed them to determine absorption-line abundances of
128: Fe. These data are not suited to the comparison we are interested in
129: here, because Fe is a highly depleted element; we do not know the
130: $\alpha$/Fe ratio; and their QSOs have impact parameters larger than
131: the optical disks of the galaxies. SBS~1543+593 is unique, since it
132: enables a direct comparison between the emission- and absorption-line
133: techniques, and allows alpha element abundances of a DLA and its host
134: galaxy to be contrasted in a low-redshift QSO-galaxy pair.
135:
136:
137: \section{Observations}
138: %\subsection{HST-STIS spectra}
139:
140: Two sets of HST/STIS observations of the QSO HS~1543+5921 were
141: performed (ID 9784, PI Bowen) using grating G140M with a
142: dispersion of 0.05\,\AA/pix and centered on 1222.0\,\AA~and on
143: 1272.0\,\AA. We averaged the five exposures per configuration to one
144: single spectrum in order to increase the signal-to-noise ratio.
145:
146: The spectrum centered on 1222.0\,\AA\ covers the NI(1199.5\,\AA,
147: 1200.2\,\AA, 1200.7\,\AA) triplet. The continuum is very noisy; and
148: the lines are located in the blue wing of the Galactic Lyman $\alpha$
149: line. For each line, we measure a lower and upper limit to its EW, by
150: varying the continuum placement. This results in 6 EW values, each of
151: which has a large uncertainty. The range a EWs will be translated into
152: an abundance range below.
153:
154: \begin{table}
155: \begin{center}
156: \caption{Column densities derived from SII lines.\label{tab:SII}}
157: \begin{tabular}{cccccc}
158: \\
159: \colrule\colrule
160: Rest-frame & observed & EW & REW & $f$ & $N$ \\
161:
162: [\AA] & [\AA] & [\AA] & [\AA] & [cm] & [$10^{15}{\rm cm}^{-2}$] \\
163: \colrule
164: 1250.58 & 1262.54 & $0.061\pm0.023$ & 0.060 & 0.00545 & $0.80\pm0.30$ \\
165: 1253.81 & 1265.85 & $0.173\pm0.034$ & 0.171 & 0.01088 & $1.13\pm0.23$ \\
166: 1259.52 & 1271.61 & $0.243\pm0.050$ & 0.241 & 0.01624 & $1.06\pm0.21$ \\
167: \colrule
168: \end{tabular}
169: %\vspace{-0.8cm}
170: %\tablenotetext{a}{$f$~values from \citet{morton1991}. These values are
171: %also used by \citet{prochaska2003b}.}
172: %see kingpin.ucsd.edu/~hiresdla/atomic.dat
173: \end{center}
174: \end{table}
175:
176:
177: The spectrum centered on 1272.0\AA\ (see Fig.~\ref{fig:SII}) is used
178: to measure the individual lines of the SII triplet. The continuum
179: level of SII($\lambda_{\rm obs}= 1262.54$\,\AA) is difficult to
180: determine and therefore uncertain; we consider this measurement as a
181: lower limit. SII($\lambda_{\rm obs}=1265.85$\,\AA) is unblended and
182: the continuum level is well determined. SII($\lambda_{\rm
183: obs}=1271.61$\,\AA) is blended with a nearby SiII line. We used two
184: Gaussian profiles to deblend the two lines. For an overview of the
185: measured values see Tab.~\ref{tab:SII}.
186:
187: %\subsection{GMOS-N imaging}
188:
189: \begin{figure}
190: \epsscale{1.10}
191: \plotone{f1.ps}
192: \caption{GMOS-N observations of SBS~1543+593 using the r\_G0303
193: filter. To facilitate comparison with Fig.~1 of \citet{sl2004a}, we
194: marked the position of the QSO which is located in the background of
195: the galaxy, and a foreground star. Notice the extended spiral-arm
196: system of the galaxy that is not visible on the HST images of
197: \citet{sl2004a}.
198: \label{fig:sbs}}
199: \vspace{-0.5cm}
200: \end{figure}
201:
202: We performed deep optical imaging using GMOS-N (see
203: Fig.~\ref{fig:sbs}) equipped with the r\_G0303 filter, a broad band
204: filter (5620 - 6980\,\AA) with an effective wavelength of 6300\,\AA. A
205: total of six dithered 300\,sec exposures were taken. After pipeline
206: calibration the images were averaged to increase the signal-to-noise
207: ratio.
208:
209: The HST image published by \citet{sl2004a} showed only the inner
210: saturated region of the new GMOS-N image. We now detect extended
211: spiral arms with associated HII regions. Note also the two features to
212: the NE which are only revealed in this deep image. The image suggests
213: a morphology which is still consistent with the previous
214: classification of SBS~1543+593 as an Sm galaxy.
215: Photometry of 193 regions within the image which are more extended
216: than the stellar point-spread function was performed using the IRAF
217: task DAOPHOT. Up to 140 could be HII regions, based on the fact that
218: they lie within the disk of the galaxy. Spectroscopy is needed to
219: confirm their nature and to measure their chemical abundances.
220:
221: \section{Abundance analysis - neutral gas}
222: \begin{figure}
223: %\epsscale{1.20}
224: \plotone{f2.ps}
225: \caption{HST/STIS spectrum centered on 1272.0\,\AA\ showing the SII
226: triplet. The spectrum was smoothed with a boxcar of 3 pixel.
227: \label{fig:SII}}
228: \vspace{-0.6cm}
229: \end{figure}
230:
231: The abundances of sulfur and nitrogen are derived using the
232: measurements of the EWs and calculating the rest-equivalent width
233: ($REW$) using the redshift of the galaxy. Together with
234: the oscillator strengths or $f$ values of \citet{morton1991} we derive
235: column densities ($N$) from eq.~8 of \citep{petitjean1998}. This
236: expression is only applicable to optically thin absorption lines on
237: the linear part of the curve of growth. Table~\ref{tab:SII} shows
238: that the equivalent widths of the three S lines used, are in the same
239: ratio as their $f$ values (within the errors), so assuming the
240: optically thin case appears to be valid. However, we must be concerned
241: that the spectral resolution is insufficient to discern if there are
242: any narrow saturated components contributing to the absorption
243: lines. If such components are present, we may have underestimated the
244: column density of S (but this would not invalidate the main result of
245: the paper).
246:
247: In the following we will introduce a new nomenclature\footnote{${\rm
248: [Y/X]} = \log (Y/X) - \log (Y/X)_\odot$}. ${\rm [Y/X]_{\rm I}}$\
249: refers to the element abundance of element Y with respect to element X
250: in the neutral gas measured using absorption line diagnostics while
251: ${\rm [Y/X]_{\rm II}}$\ refers to it measured in HII regions by
252: emission line diagnostics.
253:
254: %\subsection{The nitrogen abundance in the neutral gas}
255: Each of the 6 nitrogen $REW$s is converted to a column
256: density. Considering the above-mentioned measurement uncertainties, we
257: give a range, ($0.12$ -- $1.80$)\,$10^{14}$\,cm$^{-2}$, rather than a
258: mean value for the column density. Consequently, we derive $-2.6
259: \lesssim {\rm [N/H]_I} \lesssim -2.0$, and adopting the solar nitrogen
260: abundance of $7.931\pm0.111$ from \cite{holweger2001}.
261:
262: %\subsection{The SII abundance in the neutral gas}
263: We use a solar sulfur abundance of 7.20 \citep{grevesse1998}. This is
264: consistent with \citet{prochaska2003b}. Note that \citet{holweger2001}
265: does not provide a sulfur abundance for the Sun. The REWs
266: ($\lambda\lambda = 1254,\ 1259$) listed in Tab.~\ref{tab:SII}, were
267: used to calculate $N({\rm SII}) = (1.10\pm0.31)\ 10^{15}$\,cm$^{-2}$\
268: or ${\rm [SII/H]_I} = -0.50\pm0.33$.
269:
270:
271: %\subsubsection{Corrections for SI and SIII in the neutral gas}
272: The ionization energies for sulfur are SI: 10.36\,eV and for SII:
273: 23.33\,eV. Abundance corrections in DLAs for ionization energies higher
274: than $h \nu > 13.6$\,eV are not necessary because these absorbers are
275: optically thick to such radiation. We therefore do not apply a
276: correction for SIII. For photons with energies $h\nu < 13.6$\,eV the
277: HI gas is transparent and thus $N({\rm SII})=N({\rm S})$.
278:
279: Assuming that DLAs arise in a neutral plus a mildly ionized region,
280: \citet{vladilo2001} model ionization correction terms for
281: sulfur. Depending on the ionization parameter U (the surface flux of
282: ionizing photons divided by the hydrogen particle density) the
283: correction would be between $0.15\geq \log(C{\rm [S/H]_I}) \geq
284: -0.20$\ for $\log N(H)= 20.34$ (their Fig.~9). We consider this range
285: of correction terms as an indication for the size of possible
286: systematic errors in our abundance determination.
287:
288: Thus we derive a sulfur abundance of ${\rm [S/H]_I} = -0.50\pm0.33$,
289: or $0.29$\ solar.
290:
291: \section{Abundance analysis - ionized gas}
292: %\subsection{The SII abundance in the ionized gas}
293: We use [SII] fluxes from region \#5
294: \citep{sl2004a}. The rest-frame fluxes are
295: $F_{6717} = (0.61\pm0.09) 10^{-16}$\,erg\,s$^{-1}$\,cm$^{-2}$,
296: $F_{6731} = (0.46\pm0.09) 10^{-16}$\,erg\,s$^{-1}$\,cm$^{-2}$, $F_{\rm
297: H \beta} = (2.13\pm0.43) 10^{-16}$\,erg\,s$^{-1}$\,cm$^{-2}$. The
298: electron temperature is $T_{\rm e} = 11300^{+2100}_{-1500}$\,K; and
299: the electron density is $n_{\rm e} \approx 80$\,cm$^{-3}$.
300:
301: We use IONIC \citep{shaw1995} to derive abundances from the line-flux
302: measurements. This results in ${\rm [SII/H]_{II}}=-1.25\pm0.30$\ for
303: the HII region. Errors are estimated by exploring the effects on the
304: outcome of the model when varying the input values with their errors.
305: As a consistency check, we also calculate the abundance of SII/H by
306: applying Eq.~11 of \citet{pagel1992}. This gives ${\rm
307: [SII/H]_{II}}=-1.31\pm0.45$. The errors are calculated by error
308: propagation. In the further text we will refer to the value derived
309: by using IONIC.
310:
311: %\subsubsection{Correction for higher ionization states}
312: Note that the spectra of \citet{sl2004a} do not cover the strong
313: [SIII] lines at 9069\,\AA, 9532\,\AA. The weak [SIII] line at
314: 6312.06\,\AA\ was covered by the WHT ISIS R600R/TEK4 spectrum
315: observed on 25 April 2000. We measure a rest-frame flux of $F_{\rm
316: 6312} = (0.11\pm0.09)\ 10^{-16}$\,erg\,s$^{-1}$\,cm$^{-2}$\ in HII
317: region \#5. This leads to ${\rm [SIII/H]_{II}}=-0.32\pm0.30$. To
318: estimate the error we again explored the outcome of IONIC by varying
319: the input values with their errors. Thus we derive ${\rm [S/H]}_{\rm
320: II} = {\rm [SII+SIII/H]}_{\rm II} = -0.27\pm0.30$\ for the total
321: sulfur abundance.
322: %Equation~12 of \citet{pagel1992} can be used as a consistency
323: %check.
324: We calculate ${\rm[SIII/H]}_{\rm II}=-0.36\pm0.40$ using eq.~12 of
325: \citet{pagel1992} as a consistency check, thus ${\rm
326: [S/H]_{II}}=-0.31\pm0.30$. As another check we apply a correction
327: factor from photoionization models to the measured SII abundance to
328: account for SIII in the HII region. \citet{garnett1989} intensively
329: studied sulfur in extragalactic HII regions. Typically one observes
330: two major ionization states: SII and SIII. \citet{sl2004a} measured
331: $({\rm OII}/{\rm OI})_{\rm II} = 0.41$. With this oxygen ratio we can
332: correct for the unseen SIII. Using Fig.~4 from \citet{garnett1989}
333: leads to a correction factor of $\log ({\rm SII}/{\rm SIII})_{\rm
334: II}=-1.0\pm0.2$; and we derive ${\rm [S/H]_{II}} = -0.21\pm
335: 0.30$. Whereas SIV becomes important in highly ionized nebulae, or if
336: $({\rm OII}/{\rm OI})_{\rm II} < 0.3$, the measured $({\rm OII}/{\rm
337: OI})_{\rm II}$ ratio suggests that this ion does not make an important
338: contribution in our case.
339:
340:
341: \section{Results}
342:
343: \begin{figure}
344: %\epsscale{.80}
345: %\plotone{sbsfat.ps}
346: %\includegraphics[width=\textwidth]{sbste.ps}
347: \includegraphics[width=0.45\textwidth]{f3.ps}
348: %\includegraphics[width=0.51\textwidth]{sbsfat.ps}
349: \caption{Metallicity as a function of redshift. The dashed lines
350: indicate the minimum and maximum local-universe values of ${\rm
351: [O/H]}_{\rm II}$ (see text). The bright circles are
352: values of ${\rm [O/H]}_{\rm II}$\ for HII regions and SFGs from the
353: SDSS. The black squares are values of ${\rm [O,S,Si/H]}_{\rm I}$\ from
354: the compilation of \citet{prochaska2003d}. The neutral ([S/H]$_{\rm
355: I}$) and ionized ([O/H]$_{\rm II}$) gas phase abundances of
356: SBS~1543+593 are overlayed. Their agreement indicates that the
357: metallicities of SFGs and DLAs can be interpreted within the same
358: framework.
359: \label{fig:sbsvsz}}
360: \vspace{-0.6cm}
361: \end{figure}
362: The measured sulfur column density in the neutral gas, $N({\rm SII}) =
363: 1.10\ 10^{15}$\,cm$^{-2}$, is consistent with the prediction of
364: \citeauthor{sl2004a}, $N({\rm SII}) = 1.15\ 10^{15}$\,cm$^{-2}$.
365:
366: They used three methods to determine ${\rm [O/H]}_{\rm II}
367: = -0.54\pm0.20$. HST/FOS data revealed ${\rm
368: [O/H]}_{\rm I}>-2.14$. Here we find ${\rm [S/H]}_{\rm II} =
369: -0.27\pm0.30$, and ${\rm [S/H]_I} = -0.50\pm0.33$. Within the
370: errors these four values are the same.
371: \citeauthor{sl2004a} derived log ${\rm (N/O)}_{\rm II} =
372: -1.40^{+0.20}_{-0.30}$. Here, we calculate a range of $-2.0 \lesssim
373: \log {\rm(N/S)_I} \lesssim -0.8$. Again, we find agreement.
374:
375: \section{Discussion}
376:
377: Figure~\ref{fig:sbsvsz} offers a comparison between the metallicities
378: ([O/H]$_{\rm II}$) of local SFGs and the metallicities ([O, S,
379: Si/H]$_{\rm I}$) of high redshift DLAs. Synthesized in massive stars,
380: O and Si are both made by alpha capture, while S originates from the
381: explosive burning of O \citep{Woos2002}. \citet{Nissen2002} recently
382: studied S in Galactic halo stars, and showed empirically that S
383: behaves like an alpha-capture element. Thus we use it as a proxy for
384: O. Note that the gas-phase Si abundances may be slightly
385: underestimated in DLAs since Si depletes onto dust grains.
386:
387: In the local universe, accurate oxygen abundances are determined using
388: the direct, or $T_{\rm e}$ method. I~Zw~18 is the local galaxy with
389: the lowest oxygen abundance on record, $-1.56\pm0.01$
390: \citep{IT1999}. Even the analysis of a large sample of Sloan Digital
391: Sky Survey (SDSS) spectra using the $T_{\rm e}$ method
392: \citep{Kniazev2004} has not turned up a galaxy with a lower oxygen
393: abundance. Neither has a lower abundance been found in the outskirts
394: of local spirals \citep{Zee1998}. The local HII region with the
395: highest known oxygen abundance, $0.2\pm0.2$, resides in NGC~1232
396: \citep{Cast2002}. These minimum and maximum values are indicated in
397: Fig.~\ref{fig:sbsvsz} by dashed lines.
398:
399: To illustrate the oxygen abundances at low redshifts, we plot on
400: Fig.~\ref{fig:sbsvsz}, oxygen abundances for local HII regions and
401: SFGs from the SDSS, using the selection criteria described in
402: \citet{sl2004b} and applying the O3N2 strong-line indices of
403: \citet{PP04} after adding 1.3\,\AA\ to the rest equivalent widths of
404: H$\alpha$\ and H$\beta$ to account for underlying stellar Balmer
405: absorption \citep{hop03}. The median error based on line fluxes is
406: 0.05; and following Pettini \& Pagel, the systematic errors are 0.14
407: (their eq.~3) and 0.18 (their eq.~2). Our illustrative [O/H] values
408: for the redshift range from 0 to 0.3, span the range from $-1.2$ to
409: 0.2, and represent well, local $T_{\rm e}$-based values. Note that our
410: median metallicities are systematically lower than those derived by
411: \citet{Tremonti} for SDSS SFGs; this is presumably due to different
412: methodologies. Adopting their [O/H] ratios would exacerbate the
413: difference between SFG and DLA metallicities.
414:
415: For the DLAs, we plot on Fig.~\ref{fig:sbsvsz} the ${\rm [O/H]}_{\rm
416: I}$, ${\rm [S/H]}_{\rm I}$, and ${\rm [Si/H]}_{\rm I}$ ratios from the
417: compilation of \citet{prochaska2003d}. The median [$\alpha$/H] error in
418: this sample is 0.1.
419:
420: Our main observations are the following: ${\rm [O,S,Si/H]}_{\rm I}$ of
421: high-redshift DLAs, go down to $-2.6$. Such low metallicities are
422: unobserved in the local universe! DLA metallicities reach as high as
423: ${\rm[O,S,Si/H]}_{\rm I}$ of $-0.4$, but never once do they attain
424: super-solar values, observed in local galaxies. Are these two
425: populations at all comparable?
426:
427: We enter on Fig.~\ref{fig:sbsvsz} the values for SBS1543+593 as
428: follows. For the neutral-gas abundance, we show ${\rm [S/H]_I}$, and
429: for the ionized-gas abundance, we show ${\rm [O/H]}_{\rm II}$. Here
430: is one DLA for which we can demonstrate that in principle, emission-
431: and absorption-line techniques give the same results when chemical
432: elements with similar nucleosynthetic origins are compared at similar
433: locations within a DLA galaxy.
434:
435: There have long been discussions about whether or not emission- and
436: absorption-line diagnostics yield the same chemical abundances in SFGs
437: when one uses the internal star-forming regions rather than a QSO as
438: the background light source for the absorption experiment
439: \cite[e.g.][]{pettini1995, pettini2002, aloisi2003,
440: lecavelier2004}. There is as yet no agreement on the issue. A few
441: recent studies have addressed chemical abundances in (sub-)DLAs; but
442: these works do not compare the same elements in absorption and in
443: emission \cite[e.g.][]{christensen2005, ellison2005, chen2005}. The
444: case we have here doesn't suffer from any of these
445: uncertainties. Furthermore, in other DLA galaxies, the QSO intercepts
446: the galaxy's disks at much larger impact parameter, so internal
447: metallicity gradients have to be accounted for. Therefore, our's is
448: the cleanest comparison made to date between emission- and
449: absorption-line abundances in a DLA/SFG.
450:
451: The agreement between the metallicity in the neutral and the ionized
452: gas phase of SBS~1543+593 validates in principle, the comparisons between
453: the two types of objects, SFGs and DLAs, on the metallicity versus redshift
454: diagram. SBS~1543+593 thus makes the case that metal enrichment has taken place
455: in the gas-rich, star-forming galaxy population between redshifts of 5 and 0.
456:
457: In practice, galaxy metallicity gradients must be important for a
458: detailed comparison between SFG and DLA metallicities. DLAs are
459: merely defined by a neutral H column density threshold; yet we do not
460: know where a given DLA line is produced within a high-redshift
461: galaxy's disk. Galaxy metallicity gradients have been investigated
462: for local disk galaxies; but it remains to be seen how they behave as
463: a function of redshift. First insights on this issue are provided by
464: the work of \cite{chen2005}.
465:
466:
467: \section{Conclusions}
468: We investigated O/H, S/H and N/O ratios in the ionized gas of the DLA
469: galaxy SBS~1543+593, and compared it with O/H, S/H, and N/S ratios in
470: its neutral gas. We find that the metallicities in the ionized and
471: neutral gas agree within the errors. The experiment allows us to
472: interpret DLA metallicities as an extension of SFG metallicities to
473: high redshift, suggesting that gas-rich galaxies had lower
474: metallicities at higher redshifts, when they were younger.
475:
476: \acknowledgments
477:
478: This paper is based in part on HST archival data. We thank David Bowen
479: for communicating his preliminary [S/H] results while the data were
480: still proprietary. RS-L and AMH gratefully acknowledge support awarded
481: by the Space Telescope Science Institute, which is operated by the
482: Association of Universities for Research in Astronomy, Inc., for NASA,
483: under contract NAS 5-26555. Max Pettini and Sandhya Rao are thanked
484: for useful discussions of the paper. Please note that
485: \cite{prochaska2003d} contains a long list of original references
486: which we did not repeat here in the interest of brevity.
487: %Funding for
488: %the creation and distribution of the SDSS Archive has been provided by
489: %the Alfred P. Sloan Foundation, the Participating Institutions, the
490: %National Aeronautics and Space Administration, the National Science
491: %Foundation, the U.S. Department of Energy, the Japanese
492: %Monbukagakusho, and the Max Planck Society.
493: We acknowledge the use of the SDSS archive.
494: The SDSS Web site is http://www.sdss.org/ and lists all partners.
495: %The SDSS is managed by the Astrophysical
496: %Research Consortium (ARC) for the Participating Institutions. The
497: %Participating Institutions are The University of Chicago, Fermilab,
498: %the Institute for Advanced Study, the Japan Participation Group, The
499: %Johns Hopkins University, the Korean Scientist Group, Los Alamos
500: %National Laboratory, the Max-Planck-Institute for Astronomy (MPIA),
501: %the Max-Planck-Institute for Astrophysics (MPA), New Mexico State
502: %University, University of Pittsburgh, Princeton University, the United
503: %States Naval Observatory, and the University of Washington.
504: Based on
505: observations (GN-2004A-Q-82) obtained at the Gemini Observatory.
506: %, which
507: %is operated by the Association of Universities for Research in
508: %Astronomy, Inc., under a cooperative agreement with the NSF on behalf
509: %of the Gemini partnership: the National Science Foundation (United
510: %States), the Particle Physics and Astronomy Research Council (United
511: %Kingdom), the National Research Council (Canada), CONICYT (Chile), the
512: %Australian Research Council (Australia), CNPq (Brazil) and CONICET
513: %(Argentina).
514: We thank Marcel Bergmann for assistance with the Gemini observations.
515:
516: %Facilities: \facility{HST(STIS)}.
517:
518: \begin{thebibliography}{}
519: \bibitem[Aloisi et al. (2003)]{aloisi2003} Aloisi, A., Savaglio, S.,
520: Heckman, T.~M., Hoopes, C.~G., Leitherer, C., \& Sembach, K.~R. 2003,
521: \apj, 595, 760
522: \bibitem[Bowen et al.(2001)]{bowen2001b} Bowen, D.~V., Huchtmeier, W.,
523: Brinks, E., Tripp, T.~M., \& Jenkins, E.~B.\ 2001, \aap, 372, 820
524: \bibitem[Bowen, Tripp, \& Jenkins (2001)]{bowen2001} Bowen, D.~V.,
525: Tripp, T.~M., \& Jenkins, E.~B.\ 2001, \aj, 121, 1456
526: \bibitem[Castellanos, D\'iaz \& Terlevich (2002)]{Cast2002}
527: Castellanos, M., D\'iaz, A.~I., \& Terlevich, E. 2002, MNRAS, 329, 315
528: \bibitem[Chen et al. (2005)]{chen2005} Chen H.-W., Kennicutt Jr R.C. ,
529: Rauch M.\ 2005, astro-ph/0411006
530: \bibitem[Christensen et al. (2005)]{christensen2005} Christensen,
531: L., Schulte-Ladbeck, R.~E., S\'anchez, S.~F., Becker, T., Jahnke,
532: K., Kelz, A., Roth, M.~M., \& Wisotzki, L.\ 2005, \aap, 429, 477
533: \bibitem[Ellison et al. (2005)]{ellison2005} Ellison, S.~L., Kewley,
534: L.~J., \& Mall\'en-Ornelas, G.\ 2005, \mnras, 33
535: \bibitem[Garnett(1989)]{garnett1989} Garnett, D.~R.\ 1989, \apj,
536: 345, 282
537: \bibitem[Garnett (2004)]{garnett2004} Garnett, D.~R.\ 2004,
538: Cosmochemistry.~The melting pot of the elements, 171
539: \bibitem[Grevesse \& Sauval (1998)]{grevesse1998} Grevesse, N.~\&
540: Sauval, A.~J.\ 1998, Space Science Reviews, 85, 161
541: \bibitem[Holweger (2001)]{holweger2001} Holweger, H.\ 2001, AIP
542: Conf.~Proc.~598: Joint SOHO/ACE workshop "Solar and Galactic Composition",
543: 598, 23
544: \bibitem[Hopkins et al.(2003)]{hop03} Hopkins, A.~M., et al.\ 2003,
545: \apj, 599, 971
546: \bibitem[Izotov \& Tuan (1999)]{IT1999}Izotov, Y.~I., Thuan, T.~X. 1999, ApJ, 511, 639
547: %\bibitem[Kunth~\& Sargent (1986)]{kunth1986} Kunth, D., \& Sargent,
548: % W.~L.~W.\ 1986, \apj, 300, 496
549: \bibitem[Kniazev et al. (2004)]{Kniazev2004}Kniazev, A.~Y., Pustilnik, S.~A., Grebel,
550: E.~K., Lee, H., Pramskij, A.~G. 2004, ApJS, 153, 429
551: \bibitem[Lecavalier des Etangs et al. (2004)]{lecavelier2004}
552: Lecavalier des Etangs, A., D{\' e}sert, J.-M., Kunth, D.,
553: Vidal-Madjar, A., Callejo, G., Ferlet, R., H{\' e}brard, G., \&
554: Lebouteiller, V. 2004, \aap, 412, L131
555: \bibitem[Morton (1991)]{morton1991} Morton, D.~C.\ 1991, \apjs, 77, 119
556: \bibitem[Nissen et al. (2004)]{Nissen2002} Nissen, P.~E., Chen, Y.~Q., Asplund, M.,
557: Pettini, M. 2004, A\&A, 415, 993
558: \bibitem[Pagel et al. (1992)]{pagel1992} Pagel, B.~E.~J., Simonson,
559: E.~A., Terlevich, R.~J., \& Edmunds, M.~G.\ 1992, \mnras, 255, 325
560: \bibitem[Petitjean (1998)]{petitjean1998} Petitjean P.,
561: astro-ph/9810418
562: \bibitem[Pettini \& Lipman (1995)]{pettini1995} Pettini M. \& Lipman,
563: K.\ 1995, \aap, 297L, 63
564: %\bibitem[Pettini, Lipman, \& Hunstead (1995b)]{pettini1995b} Pettini,
565: %M., Lipman, K., \& Hunstead, R.~W.\ 1995b, \apj, 451, 100
566: \bibitem[Pettini et al. (2002)]{pettini2002} Pettini, M., Rix, S. A.,
567: Steidel, C.C., Adelberger, K. L., Hunt, M.P., \& Shapley, A.E. 2002,
568: \apj, 569, 742
569: \bibitem[Pettini (2004)]{pettini2004} Pettini, M.\ 2004,
570: Cosmochemistry.~The melting pot of the elements, 257
571: \bibitem[Pettini \& Pagel (2004)]{PP04} Pettini, M.~\& Pagel,
572: B.~E.~J.\ 2004, \mnras, 348, L59
573: \bibitem[Prochaska et al.(2003a)]{prochaska2003d} Prochaska, J.~X.,
574: Gawiser, E., Wolfe, A.~M., Castro, S., \& Djorgovski, S.~G.\ 2003a,
575: \apjl, 595, L9
576: \bibitem[Prochaska et al.(2003b)]{prochaska2003b} Prochaska, J.~X.,
577: Gawiser, E., Wolfe, A.~M., Cooke, J., \& Gelino, D.\ 2003b, \apjs, 147,
578: 227
579: \bibitem[Reimers \& Hagen (1998)]{reimers1998} Reimers, D.~\& Hagen,
580: H.-J.\ 1998, \aap, 329, L25
581: \bibitem[Schulte-Ladbeck et al.(2004a)]{sl2004a} Schulte-Ladbeck,
582: R.~E., Rao, S.~M., Drozdovsky, I.~O., Turnshek, D.~A., Nestor, D.~B.,
583: \& Pettini, M.\ 2004a, \apj, 600, 613
584: \bibitem[Schulte-Ladbeck et al. (2004b)]{sl2004b} Schulte-Ladbeck,
585: R. E., Miller, C. J., Hopp, U., Hopkins, A., Nichol, R. C., Voges,
586: W., \& Fang, T., 2004b, astro-ph/0312069
587: \bibitem[Shaw \& Dufour (1995)]{shaw1995} Shaw, R.~A.~\& Dufour,
588: R.~J.\ 1995, \pasp, 107, 896
589: \bibitem[Tremonti et al.(2004)]{Tremonti} Tremonti, C.~A., et
590: al.\ 2004, \apj, 613, 898
591: \bibitem[Turnshek, Rao \& Nestor (2002)]{turn2002} Turnshek, D.~A., Rao, S.~M. \&
592: Nestor, D.~B. 2002, ASPC, 254, 42
593: \bibitem[van Zee et al. (1998)]{Zee1998} van Zee, L., Salzer, J.~J., Haynes, M.~P.,
594: O'Donoghue, A.~A.; Balonek, T.~J. 1998, AJ, 116, 2805
595: \bibitem[Vladilo et al.(2001)]{vladilo2001}
596: Vladilo, G., Centuri{\' o}n, M., Bonifacio, P., \& Howk, J.~C.\
597: 2001, \apj, 557, 1007
598: \bibitem[Wolfe (1990)]{wolfe1990} Wolfe, A.M., in "The interstellar
599: medium in galaxies", Proceedings of the 2nd Teton Conference, Grand
600: Teton National Park, WY, July 3-7, 1989. Dordrecht, Netherlands,
601: Kluwer Academic Publishers, 1990, 387
602: \bibitem[Woosley, Heger \& Weaver (1990)]{Woos2002}Woosley, S.~E.,
603: Heger, A., \& Weaver, T.~A. 2002, RvMP, 74, 1015
604:
605: \end{thebibliography}
606:
607: %\clearpage
608:
609: %\clearpage
610:
611: %\clearpage
612:
613:
614: %\clearpage
615:
616:
617: %\clearpage
618:
619: \end{document}
620: