1:
2: %%
3: %% Beginning of file 'revised93420.tex'
4: %%
5: %% Modified 20 Dec 03
6: %%
7:
8: %\documentclass[12pt,preprint]{aastex}
9: \documentclass{emulateapj}
10:
11: %% manuscript produces a one-column, double-spaced document:
12:
13: % \documentclass[manuscript]{aastex}
14:
15: %% preprint2 produces a double-column, single-spaced document:
16:
17: % \documentclass[preprint2]{aastex}
18:
19: %% If you want to create your own macros, you can do so
20: %% using \newcommand. Your macros should appear before
21: %% the \begin{document} command.
22: %%
23:
24: \newcommand{\vdag}{(v)^\dagger}
25: \newcommand{\myemail}{kalas@astron.berkeley.edu}
26:
27: %% You can insert a short comment on the title page using the command below.
28:
29: \slugcomment{accepted November 7, 2005, for publication in ApJ Letters}
30: \shorttitle{Dust surrounding HD 32297}
31: \shortauthors{P. Kalas}
32:
33: %% This is the end of the preamble. Indicate the beginning of the
34: %% paper itself with \begin{document}.
35:
36: \begin{document}
37:
38: %% LaTeX will automatically break titles if they run longer than
39: %% one line. However, you may use \\ to force a line break if
40: %% you desire.
41:
42: \title{First optical images of circumstellar dust surrounding the debris disk candidate HD 32297}
43:
44: \author{Paul Kalas\altaffilmark{1,2}}
45: \affil{Astronomy Department,
46: University of California, Berkeley, CA 94720}
47: \email{kalas@astron.berkeley.edu}
48:
49: \altaffiltext{1}{Astronomy Department,
50: University of California, Berkeley, CA 94720}
51: \altaffiltext{2}{National Science Foundation Center for Adaptive Optics, University of California, Santa Cruz, CA 95064}
52:
53:
54: \begin{abstract}
55: Near-infrared imaging with the {\it Hubble Space Telescope} recently revealed a
56: circumstellar dust disk around the A star HD 32297. Dust scattered
57: light is detected as far as 400 AU radius and the linear morphology is consistent with
58: a disk $\sim$10$\degr$ away from an edge-on orientation. Here we present the first optical
59: images that show the dust scattered light morphology from 560 to 1680 AU radius. The position angle of the
60: putative disk midplane diverges by $\sim$31$\degr$ and
61: the color of dust scattering is most likely blue. We associate
62: HD 32297 with a wall of interstellar gas and the enigmatic region south of the Taurus molecular cloud.
63: We propose that the extreme asymmetries and
64: blue disk color originate
65: from a collision with a clump of interstellar material as HD 32297 moves southward, and
66: discuss evidence consistent with an age of 30 Myr or younger.
67: \end{abstract}
68: \keywords{stars: individual(\objectname{HD 32297}) - circumstellar matter},
69:
70: \section{Introduction}
71: Debris disks are the exosolar analogs of our Zodiacal light and Kuiper Belt and
72: each new discovery represents an opportunity to understand how planetary
73: systems form and evolve around other stars.
74: Schneider, Silverstone \& Hines (2005) recently showed
75: that HD 32297, an A star at $\sim$112$^{+15}_{-12}$ pc, illuminates
76: a dusty nebulosity resembling the edge-on debris
77: disks around $\beta$ Pic \citep{smith84} and AU Mic \citep{kal04}.
78: HD 32297 was one of 26 stars that they identified as
79: debris disk candidates for coronagraphic imaging with the
80: NICMOS camera aboard the {\it Hubble Space Telescope}.
81: Using the F110W filter ($\lambda_c$= 1104 nm,
82: $\Delta\lambda$ = 592 nm), the HD 32297 disk was found to be extended by at least 400 AU (3.3$\arcsec$)
83: to the northeast with PA = 47.6$\pm1\degr$ (G. Schneider, 2005, private communication),
84: and at least 250 AU to the southwest. The hundreds of AU extent
85: of the disk, and the significant asymmetry, are indeed comparable to
86: those of $\beta$ Pic \citep{kal95}.
87: Here we present new $R$-band observations of HD 32297 using a ground-based
88: coronagraphic camera that reveal a larger and more asymmetric circumstellar nebulosity than
89: shown by the HST data.
90:
91: \section{Observations \& Data Analysis}
92:
93: We artificially eclipsed HD 32297 using
94: an optical stellar coronagraph at the University of Hawaii 2.2-m
95: telescope on Mauna Kea, Hawaii \citep{kal96a}.
96: Data were acquired with a Tek
97: 2048$\times$2048 CCD with a scale of 0.407$\arcsec$/pixel and through
98: a standard broadband $R$ filter ($\lambda_c$=647 nm,
99: $\Delta\lambda$ = 125 nm).
100: Observations were made on 28 September, 2005, with a 6.5$\arcsec$ diameter occulting spot
101: and 1320 seconds effective integration time.
102: Measurements of photometric standard stars showed photometric condition, with image quality, as measured by the full-width at half-maximum (FWHM)
103: of field stars, equal to $\sim$1.2$\arcsec$. A series of short, unocculted integrations
104: yielded $R = 7.9 \pm 0.1$ mag for HD 32297.
105: We also observed three other bright stars with the coronagraph to
106: check for spurious features such as diffraction spikes and internal reflections.
107:
108:
109: After the data were bias subtracted, flat-fielded
110: and sky-subtracted, we subtracted the stellar
111: point spread function (PSF) to remove
112: excess stellar light from around the occulting spot. We used the real PSF's
113: from other stars observed throughout each night, as well as artificial PSF's.
114: Artificial PSF subtraction is effective for HD 32297 because the circumstellar disk is close to
115: edge-on. We extracted the stellar PSF for each image of HD 32297
116: by sampling the image radially in
117: a direction perpendicular to the PA of the disk.
118: We then fit a polynomial to the data and generated an
119: artificial PSF that is a figure of rotation of the polynomial. The PSF's were then scaled
120: and registered to each data frame such that subtraction minimized
121: the residual light in directions perpendicular to the disk beyond the edge of the
122: occulting spot.
123:
124: \section{Results}
125:
126: Figure 1 presents our $R$-band image of nebulosity surrounding HD 32297. The inner detection
127: limit is 5.0$\arcsec$ and the nebulosity is detected as far as 15$\arcsec$ (1680 AU) radius. On these
128: spatial scales the two ansae taken together do not resemble a circumstellar disk because the apparent
129: midplanes diverge in position angle. Instead the curved morphology resembles that of pre-main sequence
130: stars such as SU Aur and Z CMa \citep{nakajima95}. The northeast side is a relatively narrow structure
131: resembling the near edge-on disk described by \citet{ssh05}, but with PA = 34$\pm$1$\degr$ that is
132: 13.6$\degr$ smaller than that measured in the HST NICMOS data. The southwest side of the nebulosity
133: is a broader structure that curves westward with radius. We adopt PA = $245\pm2\degr$, which is 18$\degr$ away
134: from the midplane PA measured by \citet{ssh05}, and forms a 31$\degr$ angle with the northeast midplane in our data.
135: The FWHM of the disk perpendicular to the midplane at $8\arcsec$ radius is $3.7\arcsec$ and $5.0\arcsec$ for
136: the NE and SW sides, respectively.
137:
138: The midplane radial surface brightness profiles for the SW side is $0.3-0.5$ mag arcsec$^{-2}$ brighter than
139: the NE side between 5$\arcsec - 10\arcsec$ radius, and approximately equal further out (Fig. 2).
140: PSF subtraction dominates the uncertainty in the absolute flux measurements, but the relative flux measurements
141: between the NE and SW sides remain constant between different PSF subtractions.
142: The cumulative magnitudes for the NE and SW extensions are equal to within a
143: tenth of a magnitude, with $R$=$20.0\pm0.5$ mag for each side. Again the uncertainty
144: depends on the PSF subtraction and scales upward or downward uniformly for both
145: sides of the disk. To first order, both extensions have the same scattering cross-section of dust, even though the spatial
146: distribution is significantly different, similar to the findings for the $\beta$ Pic disk \citep{kal95}.
147:
148:
149: Between 5$\arcsec - 15\arcsec$ radius the two midplane profiles can be described by power-laws
150: with indices $-2.7\pm0.2$ and $-3.1\pm0.2$ for the NE and SW sides, respectively (Fig. 2).
151: These indices are comparable to the $F110W$ surface brightness profile of the NE midplane
152: between 1.6$\arcsec$ and 3.3$\arcsec$ radius \citep{ssh05}.
153: The similarity supports extrapolating the $R$-band surface brightness profile inward
154: to estimate the $R - F110W$ disk color within 3.3$\arcsec$ radius (Fig. 2). We find $R - F110W \approx -1$ mag for the
155: NE extension and $-2$ mag for the SW extension, whereas
156: the intrinsic stellar color is $R - F110W$ = +0.21 mag. The blue scattered light color is consistent with sub-micron
157: Raleigh scattering grains found in the interstellar medium \citep{draine03}, as well as the
158: outer region of the AU Mic debris disk \citep{metchev05}. If HD 32297 is comparable in spectral
159: type to $\beta$ Pic (A5V), then grains with radii smaller than $\sim$5 $\mu$m will be blown
160: out of the system on one dynamical timescale ($\sim$10$^3$ yr; Artymowicz \& Clampin 1997).
161: Below we discuss how the presence of small grains ($\sim$0.1 $\mu$m) leads to several
162: plausible scenarios for the origin of the nebulosity and the age of the system.
163:
164: \section{Discussion}
165:
166: The asymmetric, large-scale morphology and the blue color of nebulosity surrounding HD 32297 indicate
167: that a population of dust grains may be primordial originating from the interstellar medium. Interstellar
168: grains have a size distribution that peaks at $0.1-0.2$ $\mu$m \citep{kim94, mathis96} and many
169: reflection nebulosities have a blue color \citep{witt86}.
170: However, the morphology of the HD 32297 nebulosity
171: between 0.5$\arcsec$ and 1.7$\arcsec$ radius satisfies
172: four criteria for the imaging detection of a circumstellar disk \citep{kal96b}.
173: In this inner region the disk is relatively symmetric and a power-law fit to the surface
174: brightness profile has index -3.6 \citep{ssh05}, which
175: is comparable to the outer disk regions of $\beta$ Pic and
176: AU Mic \citep{kal04}. The steepness of this surface brightness profile is consistent with models of an
177: outward propagation of grains from an interior source region due to radiation pressure \citep{aug01}.
178: Beyond 1.7$\arcsec$ (190 AU) radius the disk may overlap with an interstellar nebulosity
179: or it is influenced by forces that are otherwise insignificant in the inner disk.
180:
181: If the large-scale nebulosity is produced by
182: a random encounter between an A star and a clump of interstellar gas and dust, then the resulting morphology
183: should demonstrate the signature linear filamentary features of the Pleiades Phenomenon \citep{kal02}.
184: We do not detect Pleiades-like nebulosity, though
185: interaction with the ISM is nevertheless plausible as the galactic location of HD 32297 ($l$=192.83$\degr$, $b$=-20.17$\degr$)
186: coincides with a ridge of relatively high density gas
187: outside of our local bubble (Fig 3; Kalas et al. 2002). This ridge also contains two
188: stars surrounded by optical nebulosity that are members of the Pleiades open cluster
189: (M45; d = $118\pm4$ pc; van Leeuwen 1999).
190: The proper motion vector of HD 32297
191: ($\mu_{\alpha}=7$ mas/yr, $\mu_{\delta}=-20$ mas/yr) points to the south-southeast, with a sky-plane motion
192: corresponding to 13.4 km s$^{-1}$ at 112 pc distance. Therefore the southern side of the
193: disk will suffer enhanced erosion that would result in both a brighter nebulosity and diminished
194: disk mass, compared to the northern side of the disk. \citet{liss89} refer to this process
195: as ISM sandblasting, and \citet{art97} show that stellar radiation pressure would protect the circumstellar
196: disk from the ISM up to a few hundred AU radius from the star. The ISM avoidance radius is a
197: function of several factors, such as ISM density, relative velocity, and encounter geometry.
198: A more detailed model applied specifically to HD 32297 is required to understand if the observed
199: disk asymmetries are consistent with ISM sandblasting. However, \citet{art97} cautioned
200: that ISM grains do not have sufficient mass
201: to perturb grains vertically away from a disk midplane. If this is valid, then other processes
202: could create the observed $R$-band asymmetries,
203: such as the entrainment of small grains by the ISM gas that should be associated with the ISM dust, or
204: dynamical perturbations from the two stars, HD 32304 (G5, $d= 134_{-15}^{+18}$ pc)
205: and BD +7 777s, south-southeast of HD 32297 (Figs. 1 \& 4).
206:
207: In the ISM sandblasting scenario, HD 32297 could be a main sequence star presently
208: undergoing a random encounter with a clump of ISM. An alternate hypothesis is that HD 32297 is very young,
209: and the nebulosity resembles that of SU Aur and Z CMa because the dust is the remnant
210: of an outflow cavity, or more generally represents pristine matter from the natal cloud. The position angle
211: discrepancies could arise because HST NICMOS is sensitive to the circumstellar disk at $<$200 AU radius with
212: PA $\approx48\degr$, whereas
213: our $R$ band data observe the top (out of the sky-plane) of an outflow cavity associated with this inner disk.
214: However, the lack of reddening ($V - K$ = 0.54 mag, $J - H$ = 0.06, $H - K$ = 0.03) generally argues
215: against a massive obscuring dust disk, such as that discovered around the Herbig Ae/Be
216: Star PDS 144N \citep{perrin05}.
217: Examination of several degrees of sky surrounding HD 32297 in the Digitized Sky Survey
218: reveals filamentary nebulosities to the southeast and southwest, apparently
219: associated with the $\lambda$ Orionis molecular ring (SH 2-264) to the east (Fig. 4).
220: $\lambda$ Orionis is in the background at $\sim$400 pc, and its diameter is no
221: greater than 20 pc in radius \citep{madd87, dolan02}. Therefore, HD 32297 must
222: originate from a different star forming region.
223: Taurus-Aurigae, $\sim$10$\degr$ to the north of HD 32297 and with heliocentric distance $140\pm20$ pc \citep{elias78},
224: may be a possibility. The proper motion of HD 32297 is comparable to
225: T Tauri stars in this region \citep{frink97}, but it does not have a relative excess southward
226: that would flag HD 32297 as a runaway star. Therefore, if HD 32297 is indeed a pre-main sequence
227: star, then it formed in relative isolation from Taurus-Aurigae within an outlying clump of the
228: main molecular cloud.
229:
230: The discovery of young stars south of Taurus led \citet{neu97} through
231: a similar considerations when discussing the
232: origin of their lithium-rich targets. In addition, they proposed two alternatives
233: that may be applicable to HD 32297. First, they noted that the midplane
234: of the Gould Belt, with age $\sim$30 Myr, passes south of
235: Taurus. In fact, HD 32297 is located within the Gould Belt midplane.
236: Second, star formation in Taurus-Aurigae may have
237: been triggered 30 Myr ago when a high-velocity cloud passed northward
238: through the galactic plane \citep{lepine94}. The first generation of stars formed
239: at this earlier epoch
240: within the molecular cloud, which eventually passed again southward through the
241: galactic plane. The second passage formed a new generation of stars observed
242: today in Taurus-Aurigae, with the first generation separating from the natal material
243: when the latter decelerated as it encountered denser ISM in the galactic plane. The first-generation stars
244: are currently found south of Taurus (both in galactic latitude and declination).
245: Therefore, whether associated with the Gould Belt or with Taurus-Aurigae,
246: the young stars presently located south of the Taurus molecular cloud have age $\sim$30 Myr.
247: HD 32297 may be a member of either group given that the relatively large dust disk
248: surrounding it may be adopted as a proxy for spectroscopic youth indicators.
249:
250: \section{Conclusions and Future Work}
251:
252: Coronagraphic $R$-band data reveal that the circumstellar nebulosity surrounding HD 32297
253: is significantly distorted relative to the near edge-on disk observed within 400 AU with
254: HST NICMOS. We detect nebulosity as far as 1680 AU radius, with long axes that deviate
255: from the NICMOS position angles by $\sim$15$\degr$ for each midplane. The southwest midplane
256: is warped and vertically distended. We invoke the possibility of ISM sandblasting, which is consistent
257: with the southward proper motion of HD 32297. We examine several scenarios relating
258: to the age and origin of HD 32297. Association with either the Gould Belt or Taurus-Aurigae
259: would give age $\sim$30 Myr, similar to that of $\beta$ Pic. A younger age is also possible if
260: HD 32297 formed in an isolated, outlying cloud of Taurus-Aurigae.
261:
262: If the ISM sandblasting scenario is correct, then future multi-color imaging should
263: reveal significant color differences between the northeast and southwest sides
264: of the disk. The southwest side may also show significant color structure perpendicular
265: to disk midplane if the apparent distortions in the disk are due to small grains swept
266: northward. Dynamical perturbations are possible if either HD 32304 or BD +7 777s to
267: the southeast are physically associated with HD 32297.
268: Future spectroscopic observations of HD 32297 should also include these two stars to constrain
269: their spectral types, relative motions, and ages. If the radial velocities support a physical
270: association, then either HD 32304 or BD +7 777s may demonstrate additional age
271: indicators that would constrain the evolutionary status of HD 32297. Moreover, if HD 32297
272: is a $\beta$ Pic analog, then multi-epoch spectroscopy should test for the variable, transient
273: redshifted features thought to arise from cometary activity under the dynamical
274: influence of planets \citep{beust00}.
275:
276: \acknowledgements
277: {\bf Acknowledgements:} This work was supported in part by NASA grants
278: to P.K, and by the NSF Center for Adaptive Optics, managed
279: by the University of California, Santa Cruz, under cooperative
280: agreement AST 98-76783.
281: We thank Michael Ratner (SAO/Harvard) for supporting the observing campaigns
282: at the University of Hawaii 2.2-m telescope.
283:
284: \begin{thebibliography}{}
285:
286: \bibitem[Artymowicz \& Clampin(1997)]{art97}
287: Artymowicz, P. \& Clampin, M. 1997, \apj, 490, 863
288:
289: \bibitem[Augereau et al.(2001)]{aug01}
290: Augereau, J. C., Nelson, R. P., Lagrange, A. M., Papaloizou, J.C.B. \& Mouillet, D. \aap, 370, 447
291:
292: \bibitem[Aumann(1985)]{aum85}
293: Aumann, H.H. 1985, \pasp, 97, 885
294:
295: \bibitem[Backman \& Paresce(1993)]{bap93}
296: Backman, D. E. \& Paresce, F. 1993, in {\it Protostars and Planets III},
297: eds. E. H. Levy \& J. I. Lunine, (Univ. Arizona Press, Tucson), p. 1253
298:
299: \bibitem[Beust \& Morbidelli(2000)]{beust00}
300: Beust, H. \& Morbidelli, A. 2000, Icarus, 143, 170
301:
302: \bibitem[Dolan \& Mathieu(2002)]{dolan02}
303: Dolan, C. J. \& Mathieu, R. D. 2002, \apj, 123, 387
304:
305: \bibitem[Draine(2003)]{draine03}
306: Draine, B. T. 2003, \araa, 41, 241
307:
308: \bibitem[Elias(1978)]{elias78}
309: Elias, J. H. 1978, \apj, 224, 857
310:
311: \bibitem[Frink et al. (1997)]{frink97}
312: Frink, S., Roser, S., Neuhauser, R. \& Sterzik, M. F. 1997, \aap, 325, 613
313:
314: \bibitem[Kalas et al.(2004)]{kal04}
315: Kalas, P., Liu, M.C. \& Matthews, B.C., 2004, Science, 303, 1990
316:
317: \bibitem[Kalas et al.(2002)]{kal02}
318: Kalas, P., Graham, J.R., Beckwith, S.V.W., Jewitt, D., and Lloyd, J.P.
319: 2002, \apj, 567, 999
320:
321: \bibitem[Kalas \& Jewitt(1996a)]{kal96a}
322: Kalas, P.\& Jewitt, D. 1996a, \aj, 110, 794
323:
324: \bibitem[Kalas \& Jewitt(1996b)]{kal96b}
325: Kalas, P.\& Jewitt, D. 1996b, Nature, 386, 52
326:
327: \bibitem[Kalas \& Jewitt(1995)]{kal95}
328: Kalas, P.\& Jewitt, D. 1995, \aj, 110, 794
329:
330: \bibitem[Kim et al.(1994)]{kim94}
331: Kim, S.-H., Martin, P. G. \& Hendry, P. D. 1994, \apj, 422, 164
332:
333: \bibitem[van Leeuwen(1999)]{vanlee99}
334: van Leeuwen, F. 1999, \aap, 341, L71
335:
336: \bibitem[Lepine \& Duvert(1994)]{lepine94}
337: Lepine, J. R. D. \& Duvert, G. 1994, \aap, 286, 60
338:
339: \bibitem[Lissauer \& Griffith(1989)]{liss89}
340: Lissauer, J. J. \& Griffith, C. A. 1989, \apj, 340, 468
341:
342: \bibitem[Maddalena \& Morris(1987)]{madd87}
343: Maddalena, R.J. \& Morris, M. 1987, \apj, 323, 179
344:
345: \bibitem[Mathis(1996)]{mathis96}
346: Mathis, J. S. 1996, \apj, 472, 643
347:
348: \bibitem[Metchev et al.(2005)]{metchev05}
349: Metchev, S. A., Eisner, J. A., Hillenbrand, L. A. \& Wolf, S. 2005, \apj, 622, 451
350:
351: \bibitem[Nakajima \& Golimowski(1995)]{nakajima95}
352: Nakajima, T. \& Golimowski, D. A. 1995, \aj, 109, 1181
353:
354: \bibitem[Neuhauser et al.(1997)]{neu97}
355: Neuhauser, R., Torres, G., Sterzik, M.F. \& Randich, S. 1997, \aap, 325, 647
356:
357: \bibitem[Perrin et al.(2005)]{perrin05}
358: Perrin, M. D.,Kalas, P., Duchene, J. R. \& Graham 2005, \apj, submitted.
359:
360: \bibitem[Schneider et al.(2005)]{ssh05}
361: Schneider, G., Silverstone, M.D., \& Hines, D.C., \apjl, 629, L117
362:
363: \bibitem[Sfeir et al.(1999)]{sfe99}
364: Sfeir, D.M., Lallement, R., Crifo, F. \& Welsh, B.Y. 1999, \aap, 346, 785
365:
366: \bibitem[Smith \& Terrile(1984)]{smith84}
367: Smith, B. A. \& Terrile, R. J., Science, 226, 1421
368:
369: \bibitem[Witt \& Schild(1986)]{witt86}
370: Witt, A. N. \& Schild, R. E. 1986, \apjs, 62, 839
371:
372:
373: \end{thebibliography}
374:
375:
376:
377: \clearpage
378:
379: %% Use the figure environment and \plotone or \plottwo to include
380: %% figures and captions in your electronic submission.
381:
382: \begin{figure}
383: \epsscale{0.7}
384: \plotone{f1.eps}
385: \caption{
386: Coronagraphic R-band image of HD 32297 after PSF subtraction.
387: Intensity is displayed on a logarithmic scale with false colors. Contours are spaced at
388: intervals of 0.5 mag arcsec$^{-2}$, and the outer contour represents
389: 23.5 mag arcsec$^{-2}$. North is up, east is left, and the field shown is 40$\arcsec\times40\arcsec$.
390: The bright column from the lower left is a saturation column on the CCD from the star
391: BD +7 777s ($V$=10.2, 47.9$\arcsec$ east and 78.6$\arcsec$ south of HD 32297).
392: The dominant sources of instrumental scattered light is from the bright star
393: HD 32304 ($V$=6.9, 61$\arcsec$ east and 134$\arcsec$ south of HD 32297).
394: \label{fig1}}
395: \end{figure}
396:
397: %\clearpage
398:
399: \begin{figure}
400: \epsscale{1.0}
401: \plotone{f2.eps}
402: \caption{
403: Midplane surface brightness as a function of radius for the northeast and southwest extension of HD 32297. LEFT: $R$-band
404: surface brightness profile of a midplane cut with width 1.2$\arcsec$. Error bars indicate uncertainty from the subtraction of the PSF.
405: The surface brightness profiles may be fit by power-laws as described in the text.
406: RIGHT: Inward extrapolation of the $R$-band surface brightness profile represented by the power-law fits for
407: comparison to the HST NICMOS $F110W$ data. The $R$-band SW disk midplane (dash-dot)
408: and the NE disk midplane (dot) are both brighter than the $F110W$ midplanes detected by
409: Schneider et al. 2005 (solid line is the NE extension, dashed line
410: is the SW extension), consistent with a blue color for the nebulosity.
411: \label{fig2}}
412: \end{figure}
413:
414: \clearpage
415:
416: \begin{figure}
417: \epsscale{0.7}
418: \plotone{f3.eps}
419: \caption{
420: Association of HD 32297 with interstellar gas beyond the local bubble.
421: HD 32297 is plotted with a solid square (lower left quadrant) in this figure adapted from \citet{kal02}
422: showing the spatial relationship
423: between infrared excess stars and interstellar gas. This is the meridian plane of the galaxy, containing both
424: galactic poles and the galactic center to the right. Thin and thick contours represent neutral gas mapped
425: by \citet{sfe99} using the Na I D-line doublet. Other symbols on the map represent the location
426: of stars that possess the far infrared signature of debris disks. Stars are mapped here if they
427: have $l$=0$\degr\pm$18$\degr$ or $l$=180$\degr\pm$18$\degr$. HD 32297 is therefore
428: included in this plot and appears superimposed on a wall or ridge of relatively
429: dense interstellar gas ($>50$ m$\AA$ D2-line equivalent width). Thick crosses mark five more stars that appear to trace the
430: boundary of the wall, though the uncertainties in the $Hipparcos$ parallaxes effectively
431: place them at the same heliocentric distance.
432: To the left of HD 32297 is HD 28149, and
433: just below HD 32297 are 18 Tau (HD 23324) and 21 Tau (HD 23432), members of the Pleiades open cluster.
434: Two more debris disk candidate stars along the bottom portion of this ridge are HD 28978 and HD 28375
435: \citep{bap93}. They lie closest to HD 32297 in galactic latitude.
436: \label{fig3}}
437: \end{figure}
438:
439: %\clearpage
440:
441: \begin{figure}
442: \epsscale{0.5}
443: \plotone{f4.eps}
444: \caption{
445: Digitized Sky Survey image of the region around HD 32297 (marked between diagonal lines) shows significant
446: nebulosity in the large-scale environment (north is up, east is left). Filamentary H$\alpha$ nebulosities on scales of
447: tens of arcminutes (rectangles), are
448: evident to the southeast (Sh 2-262) and southwest (Sh 2-260) of HD 32297. They are most likely
449: associated with $\lambda$ Orionis molecular ring (Sh 2-264) to the east. The age
450: and origin of HD 32297 are enigmatic due to the superposition of objects in its environment
451: that could be associated with $\lambda$ Orionis,
452: the Gould Belt, or the Taurus molecular cloud.
453: \label{fig3}}
454: \end{figure}
455:
456:
457: %
458:
459: \end{document}
460: