1: %\documentclass{aastex}
2: \documentclass[12pt,preprint]{aastex}
3: %\documentclass[12pt,manuscript]{aastex}
4: \usepackage{graphicx}
5: \begin{document}
6: \def\la{\mathrel{\hbox{\rlap{\hbox{\lower4pt\hbox{$\sim$}}}\hbox{$<$}}}}
7: \def\ga{\mathrel{\hbox{\rlap{\hbox{\lower4pt\hbox{$\sim$}}}\hbox{$>$}}}}
8: \def\lam{$\lambda$}
9: \def\kms{km~s$^{-1}$}
10: \def\vphot{$v_{\rm phot}$}
11: \def\ang{~\AA}
12: \def\syn{{\bf Synow}}
13: \def\tex{$T_{\rm exc}$}
14: \def\ve{$v_{\rm e}$}
15: \def\halpha{H$\alpha$}
16: \def\6200{the 6200\ang\ absorption}
17: \def\5700{the 5700\ang\ absorption}
18:
19: \title {HYDROGEN IN TYPE~Ic SUPERNOVAE?}
20:
21: \author {David Branch\altaffilmark{1},
22: David~J. Jeffery\altaffilmark{1}, Timothy R. Young\altaffilmark{2}, \&
23: E.~Baron\altaffilmark{1}}
24:
25: \altaffiltext{1} {Homer L. Dodge Department of Physics and Astronomy,
26: University of Oklahoma, Norman,~OK 73019; e-mail: branch@nhn.ou.edu}
27:
28: \altaffiltext{2} {Department of Physics, University of North Dakota,
29: Grand Forks, ND, 58202}
30:
31: \begin{abstract}
32:
33: By definition, a Type~Ic supernova (SN~Ic) does not have conspicuous
34: lines of hydrogen or helium in its optical spectrum. SNe~Ic usually
35: are modelled in terms of the gravitational collapse of bare
36: carbon--oxygen cores. We consider the possibility that the spectra of
37: ordinary (SN~1994I--like) SNe~Ic have been misinterpreted, and that
38: SNe~Ic eject hydrogen. An absorption feature usually attributed to a
39: blend of Si~II \lam6355 and C~II \lam6580 may be produced by
40: H$\alpha$. If SN~1994I--like SNe~Ic eject hydrogen, the possibility
41: that hypernova (SN~1998bw--like) SNe~Ic, some of which are associated
42: with gamma--ray bursts, also eject hydrogen should be considered. The
43: implications of hydrogen for SN~Ic progenitors and explosion models
44: are briefly discussed.
45:
46: \end{abstract}
47:
48: \keywords{supernovae: general --- supernovae: individual (SN 1994I, SN
49: 1999ex)}
50:
51: \section{INTRODUCTION}
52:
53: A Type~II supernova (SN~II) has conspicuous hydrogen lines in its
54: optical spectrum. A Type~Ib supernova lacks conspicuous hydrogen
55: lines but does have conspicuous He~I lines. A Type~Ic supernova has
56: conspicuous lines of neither hydrogen nor He~I. For a review of
57: supernova spectral classification see Filippenko (1997).
58:
59: Supernovae of these types are thought to result from core--collapse in
60: massive stars. A SN~Ib is hydrogen--deficient in its outer layers,
61: and displays He~I lines owing to nonthermal excitation by the decay
62: products of radioactive $^{56}$Ni and $^{56}$Co (Lucy 1991). In
63: recent years it has becomes clear that at least some SNe~Ib are not
64: completely hydrogen--free; in fact, it is likely that most or even all
65: SNe~Ib eject a small amount of hydrogen at high velocities (Deng et
66: al. 2000; Branch et~al. 2002; Elmhamdi et~al. 2006). If some of the
67: events classified as Type~Ib had been observed earlier, hydrogen lines
68: might have been conspicuous, in which case they would be classified as
69: Type~IIb --- the designation used for events such as SN~1993J that
70: looked like a Type~II at early times but later looked like a Type~Ib
71: (Filippenko, Matheson, \& Ho 1993).
72:
73: A SN~Ic either is helium--deficient in its outer layers or fails to
74: nonthermally excite its helium (Woosley \& Eastman 1997). It has
75: become common practice to model SNe~Ic in terms of core collapse in
76: bare (or nearly bare) carbon--oxygen cores (Iwamoto et~al. 1994; Foley
77: et~al. 2003; Mazzali et~al. 2004).
78:
79: Supernova spectral features are P--Cygni features characterized by
80: line--centered emission components and blueshifted absorption
81: components, with the absorptions frequently being more identifiable.
82: Spectral features usually are blended owing to the huge Doppler
83: broadening. Nevertheless, some identifications of spectral lines are
84: definite. For example, blends of Fe~II lines and features produced by
85: Ca~II H\&K and the Ca~II infrared triplet appear in all types of
86: supernovae as long as the temperature is sufficiently low. However,
87: there also are some serious identification ambiguities. The most well
88: known involves the Na~I D--line doublet at mean wavelength \lam5892
89: and the strongest optical line of He~I, \lam5876, which are separated
90: by only about 800 \kms. If the corresponding observed feature is
91: strong and other He~I lines are not present, the feature is produced
92: at least mainly by Na~I, while if other He~I lines are clearly present
93: then the feature is at least partly due to He~I. But if the observed
94: feature is not strong, it can be difficult to choose between Na~I and
95: He~I.
96:
97: When SNe~Ic are interpreted in terms of bare carbon--oxygen cores, an
98: absorption feature usually near 6200\ang, which we will refer to as
99: \6200, is attributed to the strongest optical line of Si~II, \lam6355
100: (the transition definitely responsible for the similarly located deep
101: absorption in Type~Ia supernovae), perhaps blended with the strongest
102: optical line of C~II, \lam6580, forming in higher--velocity ejecta
103: than Si~II. Local--thermodynamic--equilibrium (LTE) calculations of
104: Sobolev line optical depths for a composition dominated by carbon and
105: oxygen (with hydrogen and helium burned to carbon and oxygen, and
106: solar mass fractions of heavier elements) show that within certain
107: intervals of temperature Si~II \lam6355 and C~II \lam6580 are expected
108: to have significant optical depths (Hatano et~al. 1999).
109: Nevertheless, the identification of \6200\ is plagued by ambiguities.
110: The strongest line of Ne~I, \lam6402, is about 2200 \kms\ to the red
111: of Si~II \lam6355, and \halpha\ \lam6563 is only about 800 \kms\ to
112: the blue of C~II \lam6580. Because these four ions, each of which
113: could appear in supernova spectra (although Ne~I probably would
114: require nonthermal excitation), have their strongest optical lines to
115: the red, but not too far to the red, of \6200, the ambiguity is
116: difficult to resolve when the observed feature is weak and other lines
117: of these ions do not produce identifiable features.
118:
119: In this paper we are primarily concerned with the possible presence of
120: hydrogen in SNe~Ic. This issue (and that of helium in SNe~Ic) has
121: been addressed in the literature before; for summaries see Filippenko
122: (1997); Matheson et~al. (2001); and Branch (2002). The presence of
123: hydrogen has been suggested, for example, by Filippenko (1988, 1992);
124: Filippenko, Porter, \& Sargent (1990); Jeffery et al. (1991); and
125: Branch (2002). The currently prevailing view, however, is that
126: hydrogen is absent and \6200\ is produced by Si~II and/or C~II
127: (Wheeler et~al. 1994; Millard et~al. 1999). In \S2, based on a
128: comparison of spectra of the Type~Ib or Type~Ib/c SN~1999ex, which we
129: believe to contain hydrogen, and the Type~Ic SN~1994I, we raise the
130: question of whether hydrogen also is present in SN~1994I. In \S3,
131: comparisons of spectra of SN~1999ex and SN~1994I with synthetic
132: spectra generated with the parameterized resonant--scattering code
133: {\bf Synow} are presented and discussed. In \S4, the implications of
134: the presence of hydrogen in ordinary (SN~1994I--like), and possibly
135: even in hypernova (SN~1998bw--like; Foley et~al. 2003) SNe~Ic, are
136: briefly considered.
137:
138: \section{COMPARISON OF SN~1999ex AND SN~1994I}
139:
140: SN~1999ex was initially classified as Type~Ic based on a resemblance
141: of its early spectrum to SN~1994I (Hamuy \& Phillips 1999), but
142: because it later developed He~I lines Hamuy et~al. (2002) revised the
143: classification to intermediate Type~Ib/c. Although the He~I lines
144: were not as deep as in most events that have been classified as
145: Type~Ib, their presence was definite, so Branch (2002) referred to
146: SN~1999ex as a ``shallow--helium'' Type~Ib. Hamuy et~al. (2002)
147: labelled \6200\ as Si~II, but Branch (2002) argued that the correct
148: identification is \halpha, consistent with the presence of \halpha\ in
149: most if not all other SNe~Ib. Recently Elmhamdi et~al. (2006) have
150: reinforced the conclusion that SNe~Ib, including SN~1999ex and another
151: transition Type~Ib/c event, SN~1996aq, eject hydrogen. (The
152: overluminous Type~Ib SN~1991D (Benetti et~al. 2002) could be an
153: exception.)
154:
155: The spectra of SN~1999ex and the Type~Ic SN~1994I shown in Figures 1
156: to 3 are from Hamuy et~al. (2002) and Filippenko et~al. (1995),
157: respectively. The horizontal scale on all figures in this paper is
158: logarithmic wavelength, which allows the widths of Doppler--broadened
159: features to be compared on an equal basis across the whole spectrum.
160: The spectra are ``tilted'' by multiplying by \lam$^\alpha$, with
161: $\alpha$ chosen to make the flux peaks near 4600\ang\ and 6300\ang\
162: about equally high. The tilting makes it easier to compare spectral
163: features. When comparing SN~1999ex and SN~1994I spectra we
164: artificially blueshift those of SN~1999ex in order to compensate for
165: the different photospheric velocities and roughly align the absorption
166: features.
167:
168: In Figure~1 a spectrum of SN~1994I obtained 2 days before the time of
169: maximum light in the $B$ band (day~$-2$) is compared with a day~$-1$
170: spectrum of SN~1999ex that has been blueshifted by 4000~\kms.
171: Figure~2 is like Figure~1, but for day~+4 spectra of SN~1994I and
172: SN~1999ex, with the latter blueshifted by 2000~\kms. Figure~3 is for
173: a day~+10 spectrum of SN~1994I and a day~+13 spectrum of SN~1999ex,
174: with the latter blueshifted by 2000~\kms. In all three figures the
175: spectra are similar in many respects, although the features are more
176: washed out in SN~1994I because of its higher photospheric velocity at
177: each epoch (hence the necessity to blueshift SN~1999ex to illustrate
178: the similarities). Otherwise the main differences are that He~I
179: \lam6678 and \lam7065, although weak, are clearly present in SN~1999ex
180: (making it a Type~Ib or at least a Type~Ib/c), but they are not
181: clearly present in SN~1994I (making it a Type~Ic). However, it is not
182: possible on the basis of Figures 1 to 3 to exclude the presence of
183: weak He~I features in SN~1994I. Given the similarities in these
184: figures --- and they are rather striking --- the question becomes: are
185: the Na~I and Si~II/C~II identifications correct for SN~1994I? If so,
186: then the resemblance of the SN~1999ex and SN~1994I spectra from about
187: 5500\ang\ to 6300\ang\ is coincidental.
188:
189: \section{COMPARISONS WITH SYNTHETIC SPECTRA}
190:
191: To further investigate the possibility of hydrogen (and He~I) in
192: SN~1994I we have used the parameterized resonant--scattering {\bf
193: Synow} code (Branch et~al. 2002) to generate synthetic spectra for
194: comparison with spectra of SN~1999ex and SN~1994I.
195:
196: \subsection{SN 1999ex}
197:
198: In Figure~4 the day~+4 spectrum of SN~1999ex is compared with a
199: synthetic spectrum in which \6200\ is produced by \halpha. In the
200: synthetic spectrum the velocity at the photosphere is 8000 \kms.
201: Hydrogen is detached from the photosphere at 13,000 \kms\ where
202: \halpha\ has an optical depth of 0.5. Hydrogen--line optical depths
203: decrease outward exponentially but very slowly, with e--folding
204: velocity $v_e$ = 20,000 \kms, to an imposed maximum velocity of 20,000
205: \kms. Given the closeness of the fit to \6200, we know that with fine
206: adjustments of the optical--depth profile we could refine the fit to
207: be practically perfect. Thus at the \syn\ level of analysis, \halpha\
208: is completely adequate and we would not prefer a different
209: identification without other evidence. For all ions used in Figure~4,
210: reference--line optical depths and $v_e$ values (in units of 1000
211: \kms) are given in Table~1.
212:
213: Elmhamdi et~al. (2006) show that Si~II \lam6355 cannot account for
214: \6200\ of SN~1999ex on its own because even when it is undetached from
215: the photosphere, its synthetic absorption feature is too blue. It is
216: unlikely that \6200\ is due mainly to Ne~I \lam6402 because the
217: observed feature is strong enough that when it is fitted with Ne~I
218: \lam6402 other Ne~I lines appear in the synthetic spectrum and the fit
219: deteriorates. This conclusion is based on LTE excitation and must be
220: tested against detailed non-LTE calculations that take nonthermal
221: excitation into account.
222:
223: Hamuy et~al. (2002) also obtained a day~+4 spectrum of SN~1999ex that
224: extends to nearly 2.5 microns. {\bf Synow} fitting parameters used to
225: fit the optical He~I lines also give satisfactory fits to features
226: attributed to He~I \lam10830 and He~I \lam20851 (Branch 2002; Elmhamdi
227: et~al. 2006), but the infrared spectrum does not provide a useful
228: constraint on the presence of hydrogen.
229:
230: \subsection{SN 1994I}
231:
232: {\bf Synow} fits to spectra of SN~1994I in which \6200\ is attributed
233: to Si~II and/or detached high--velocity C~II are shown in Millard
234: et~al. (1999) and Elmhamdi et~al. (2006). For this paper we began
235: trying to fit the day~+4 spectrum of SN~1994I by varying the input
236: parameters that were used for the synthetic spectrum shown in Figure~4
237: for SN~1999ex, i.e., we assumed the presence of hydrogen and He~I
238: lines. Figure~5 for SN~1994I is like Figure~4 for SN~1999ex. The
239: synthetic spectrum has a velocity at the photosphere of 11,000 \kms\
240: (compared with 8000 \kms\ for SN~1999ex). Hydrogen lines are detached
241: from the photosphere at 15,000 \kms\ where \halpha\ has an optical
242: depth of 0.4. Hydrogen--line optical depths decrease outward
243: exponentially with e--folding velocity $v_e$ = 20,000 \kms\ to an
244: imposed maximum velocity of 22,000 \kms. This hydrogen optical--depth
245: profile is quite similar to that used for SN~1999ex in Figure~4, and
246: in Figure~5 \6200\ is fit nicely. The 5700~\AA\ absorption also is
247: fit nicely by He~I \lam5876. In the synthetic spectrum He~I \lam6678
248: and \lam7065 are weak and rather washed out owing to the high
249: photospheric velocity, but they do more good than harm and their
250: presence in the observed spectrum cannot be excluded. (However,
251: regarding the strong observed absorption near one micron, the
252: situation remains as illustrated and discussed in Millard
253: et~al. (1999); the synthetic He~I \lam10830 absorption is too weak and
254: narrow to account entirely for the observed absorption.)
255: Reference--line optical depths and $v_e$ values for Figure~5 are given
256: in Table~1.
257:
258: The synthetic spectrum in Figure~6 is like that of Figure~5 except
259: that it includes Si~II lines instead of hydrogen lines. The figure
260: illustrates that in SN~1994I, as well as in SN~1999ex, Si~II \lam6355
261: is too blue to account for \6200\ on its own (flux differences between
262: observed and \syn\ spectra are to be expected, but differences in
263: wavelengths of absorption features are regarded as serious
264: disrepancies), although it is possible to obtain a fit by invoking
265: detached high--velocity C~II. Because \6200\ is less deep in SN~1994I
266: than in SN~1999ex, and the SN~1994I features are more smeared out by
267: the higher photospheric velocity, it also is difficult to exclude Ne~I
268: \lam6402 in SN~1994I.
269:
270: \section{DISCUSSION}
271:
272: \subsection{Spectroscopy}
273:
274: We have discussed the possibility of \halpha\ in absorption, in the
275: spectrum of the Type~Ic SN~1994I. As shown in Figure~7, this is an
276: issue for SNe~Ic in general; the spectra within the wavelength
277: interval emphasized in this paper have strong similarities. Other
278: evidence for hydrogen in SNe~Ic was emphasized by Filippenko
279: (1988\footnote{Filippenko (1988) referred to the events suggested to
280: have hydrogen as Type~Ib because the Type~Ic classification (Wheeler
281: \& Harkness 1986) was not yet commonly used, but these events are now
282: classified Type~Ic.}; 1992): the apparent presence of broad \halpha\
283: emission in near--maximum--light spectra. This feature can be seen in
284: the day~$-2$ spectrum of SN~1994I in Figure~1 (beneath a narrow
285: \halpha\ emission due to an H~II region). In order to produce a
286: peaked rather than a flat \halpha\ emission component the hydrogen
287: would have to be present down to the photosphere, rather than being
288: confined to a detached high--velocity shell such as we have invoked
289: for the absorption component. In this regard it is interesting to
290: note that in Figures~1 to 3 the red edges of the putative \halpha\ and
291: He~I \lam5876 absorptions in SN~1994I are less sharp than in
292: SN~1999ex; a detached shell produces sharp red edges. A continuous
293: \halpha\ optical--depth distribution that peaks at 15,000 \kms\ but
294: extends down to the photosphere might suffice to produce a peaked
295: \halpha\ emission. This can only be tested by non-LTE calculations
296: because the resonance--scattering approximation on which \syn\ is
297: based is known to be a poor approximation for \halpha\ in SNe~II. It
298: is not clear that a large hydrogen mass would be required because the
299: appearance of hydrogen and He~I lines depends on the radial
300: optical--depth profiles (Branch et~al. 2002) and on the distribution
301: of $^{56}$Ni (Woosley \& Eastman 1997).
302:
303: At present it is difficult to establish the presence or absence of
304: hydrogen in SN~1994I--like SNe~Ic, but the issue should be considered
305: further. A large--scale comparative study of observed spectra, like
306: that of Elmhamdi et~al. (2006) but including SNe~Ic as well as SNe~Ib,
307: probably would yield clues. In addition, detailed non-LTE spectrum
308: calculations for a grid of explosion models are needed. Such
309: calculations, even based on parameterized explosion models rather than
310: full hydrodynamical calculations, could probe several issues: e.g., is
311: Ne~I \lam6402 really a candidate to produce \6200, and under what
312: circumstances can peaked \halpha\ emission be produced? In the only
313: full non-LTE calculations for SNe~Ic published so far (Baron
314: et~al. 1999), synthetic spectra for models containing no hydrogen did
315: not provide good fits to \6200\ in SN~1994I.
316:
317: An interesting recent case is that of SN~2005bf (Anupama et~al. 2005;
318: Tominaga et~al. 2005; Folatelli et~al. 2006), which like SN~1999ex was
319: initially classifed as Type~Ic but later developed definite He~I
320: lines, making it either Type~Ib or Type~Ib/c (or Type~Icb?). In each
321: of these three papers the 6200~\AA\ absorption was attributed to
322: \halpha. Strong support for the identification was provided by the
323: presence in early spectra of Ca~II and Fe~II at the same high velocity
324: (15,000 \kms) as the \halpha\ absorption (Folatelli et~al. 2006). The
325: very long rise time to maximum light of 40~days indicates that the
326: progenitor was massive. In addition, SN~2005bf showed evidence for
327: high--velocity polar ejection, reminiscent of SN~1998bw--like
328: explosions of massive stars, some of which produce gamma--ray--bursts
329: (GRBs). In view of the high ejected mass and the polar ejection,
330: Folatelli et~al. suggested that SN~2005bf may have been a transition
331: event between ordinary SNe~Ib/c and hypernovae. Therefore if
332: SN~2005bf ejected hydrogen we should consider the possibility that
333: SN~1998bw--like SNe~Ic also do.
334:
335: In SN~1998bw--like spectra \5700\ and \6200\ are assumed to be Na~I
336: and Si~II, respectively. These identifications initially were adopted
337: (Iwamoto et~al. 1998; Branch 2001) partly because they were assumed to
338: be correct for SN~1994I, and SN~1998bw--like spectra were and still
339: are regarded to be Doppler--broadened versions of SN~1994I--like
340: spectra, and partly because Monte Carlo spectrum calculations for bare
341: carbon--oxygen cores do provide reasonable fits to SN~1998bw--like
342: spectra (e.g., Mazzali, Iwamoto, \& Nomoto 2000, Mazzali et~al. 2002)
343: with Si~II and/or C~II producing \6200. Thus, even if \6200\ in
344: SN~1994I--like SNe~Ic is produced by \halpha, it may still turn out to
345: be produced by Si~II in SN~1998bw--likes. Nevertheless, the
346: possibility that even in SN~1998bw--likes the correct identification
347: is \halpha\ rather than Si~II (and perhaps He~I rather than Na~I)
348: should be considered. Full non--LTE spectrum caclulations for
349: comparison with SN~1998bw--like spectra are in their initial stages
350: (E.~Baron \& M.~Troxel, in preparation).
351:
352: \subsection{Implications for Progenitors and Explosion Models}
353:
354: Ideas concerning the progenitors of SNe~Ib and SN~1994I--like SNe~Ic
355: have been reviewed by Podsiadlowski (1996), who concluded that most of
356: the progenitors are stars of main--sequence masses $\la$20 solar
357: masses that lose their envelopes by means of binary interactions. In
358: standard binary evolutionary scenarios, if all or even just a
359: substantial fraction the helium envelope must be lost, all of the
360: hydrogen is lost. For example, Nomoto et~al. (1994) favored a
361: scenario involving two common--envelope episodes that results in a
362: carbon--oxygen core containing little or no helium and no hydrogen.
363: However, as emphasized by Podsiadlowski, there are many unresolved
364: questions in binary stellar evolution. If SN~1994I--like SNe~Ic eject
365: hydrogen (and therefore also, of course, helium), some modification of
366: the standard evolutionary scenarios, perhaps involving substantial
367: mixing of hydrogen prior to and/or during the explosion, will be
368: needed.
369:
370: SN~1998bw--like SNe~Ic, including those that produce GRBs, are usually
371: regarded to come from stars of sufficiently high main--sequence mass
372: that they can lose their envelopes by means of single--star winds.
373: Those that produce GRBs may have to be in binaries in order to have
374: sufficient angular momentum at the time of core--collapse for the
375: collapsar model (McFadyen \& Woosley 1999) to be viable (Fryer \&
376: Heger 2005; Petrovic et~al. 2005). The uncertainities involved in the
377: evolutionary scenarios for SN~1998bw--likes are even greater than for
378: SN~1994I--likes, and if SN~1998bw--likes eject hydrogen, current
379: scenarios will require revision. Particularly interesting in this
380: regard are recent results on chemically homogeneous evolution of
381: rapidly rotating massive stars (Yoon \& Langer 2005; Woosley \& Heger
382: 2006). Some of these GRB--candidate models contain hydrogen at the
383: time of core collapse.
384:
385: We are grateful to Mario Hamuy, Alex Filippenko, and Tom Matheson for
386: providing spectra, to Filippenko, Alicia Soderberg, and the anonymous
387: referee for helpful comments on the manuscript, and to Norbert Langer
388: for calling our attention to recent results on quasi--homogeneous
389: evolution of rapidly rotating massive stars. This work has been
390: supported by NSF grants AST-0204771 and AST-0506028, NASA LTSA
391: grant NNG04GD36G, and NASA ADP grant NAG5-3505.
392:
393: \clearpage
394:
395: \begin{references}
396:
397: \reference{} Anupama, G. C., Sahu, D. K., Deng, J., Nomoto, K.,
398: Tominaga,~N., Tanaka,~M., Mazzali,~P.~A., \& Prabhu,~T.P. 2005, ApJ,
399: 631, L125
400:
401: \reference{} Baron, E., Branch, D., Hauschildt, P. H,
402: Filippenko,~A.~V., \& Kirshner,~R.~P. 1999, ApJ, 527, 739
403:
404: \reference{} Benetti, S., et~al. 2002, MNRAS, 336, 91
405:
406: \reference{} Branch, D. 2001, in Supernovae and Gamma--Ray Bursts: The
407: Largest Explosions in the Universe, ed. M.~Livio (Cambridge: Cambridge
408: Univ. Press), 96
409:
410: \reference{} Branch, D. 2002, in A Massive Star Odyssey: from Main
411: Sequence to Supernova, Proc. IAU Symposium No. 212, ed. K.~A.~van der
412: Hucht, A.~Herraro, \& C.~Esteban (San Francisco: ASP), 346
413:
414: \reference{} Branch, D., et~al. 2002, ApJ, 566, 1005
415:
416: \reference{} Deng, J. S., Qiu, Y. L., Hu, J. Y., Hatano, K., \&
417: Branch, D. 2000, ApJ, 540, 452
418:
419: \reference{} Elmhamdi, A., Danziger, I. J., Branch, D., Leibundgut,
420: B., Baron,~E., \& Kirshner,~R.~P. 2006, A\&A, in press
421:
422: \reference{} Filippenko, A. V. 1988, AJ, 96, 1941
423:
424: \reference{} Filippenko, A. V. 1992, ApJ, 384, L37
425:
426: \reference{} Filippenko, A. V. 1997, ARAA, 35, 309
427:
428: \reference{} Filippenko, A. V., Matheson, T., \& Ho, L. C. 1993, ApJ,
429: 415, L103
430:
431: \reference{} Filippenko, A. V., Porter, A., \& Sargent, W. L. W. 1990,
432: AJ, 100, 1575
433:
434: \reference{} Filippenko, A. V., et~al. 1995, ApJ, 450, L11
435:
436: \reference{} Folatelli, et~al. 2006, ApJ, in press
437:
438: \reference{} Foley, R. J., et~al. 2003, PASP, 115, 1220
439:
440: \reference{} Fryer, C. L., \& Heger, A. 2005, ApJ, 623, 302
441:
442: \reference{} Hamuy, M., et al. 2002, AJ, 124, 417
443:
444: \reference{} Hamuy, M., \& Phillips, M. M. 1999, IAU Circ. 7310
445:
446: \reference{} Hatano, K., Branch, D., Fisher, A., Millard,~J., \&
447: Baron,~E. 1999, ApJS, 121, 233
448:
449: \reference{} Iwamoto, K., Nomoto, K., H\"oflich, P., Yamaoka,~H.,
450: Kumagai,~S., \& Shigeyama,~T. 1994, ApJ, 437, L115
451:
452: \reference{} Iwamoto, K., et~al. 1998, Nature, 395, 672
453:
454: \reference{} Jeffery, D. J., Branch, D., Filippenko, A. V., \&
455: Nomoto,~K. 1991, ApJ, 317, 717
456:
457: \reference{} Lucy, L. B. 1991, ApJ, 383, 308
458:
459: \reference{} Matheson, T., Filippenko, A. V., Li, W., Leonard,~W.~C.,
460: \& Shields,~J.~C. 2001, AJ, 121, 1648
461:
462: \reference{} McFadyen, A. I., \& Woosley, S. E. 1999, ApJ, 524, 262
463:
464: \reference{} Mazzali, P. A., Iwamoto, K., \& Nomoto, K. 2000, ApJ,
465: 545, 407
466:
467: \reference{} Mazzali, P. A., et~al. 2002, ApJ, 572, 61
468:
469: \reference{} Mazzali, P. A., Deng, J., Maeda, K., Nomoto, K.,
470: Filippenko,~A.~V., \& Matheson, T. 2004, ApJ, 614, 858
471:
472: \reference{} Millard, J., et~al. 1999, ApJ, 527, 746
473:
474: \reference{} Nomoto, K., Yamaoka, H., Pols, O. R., van den
475: Heuvul,~E.~P.~J., Iwamoto,~K., Kumagai,~S., \& Shigeyama,~T. 1994,
476: Nature, 371, 227
477:
478: \reference{} Petrovic, J., Langer, L., Yoon, S.-C., \& Heger,~A. 2005,
479: A\&A, 435, 247
480:
481: \reference{} Podsiadlowski, P. 1996, in Hydrogen Deficient Stars,
482: ed. C.~S.~Jeffery \& U.~Heber (San Francisco: ASP), 419
483:
484: \reference{} Tominaga, N., et al. 2005, ApJ, 633, 97
485:
486: \reference{} Wheeler, J. C., \& Harkness, R. P. 1986, in Galaxy
487: Distances and Daviations from Universal Expansion, ed. B.~F.~Madore,
488: R.~B.~Tully (Dordrecht: Reidel), 45
489:
490: \reference{} Wheeler, J. C., Harkness, R. P., Clocchiatti, A.,
491: Benetti,~S., Brotherton,~M.~S., Depoy,~D.~L., \& Elias,~J. 1994, ApJ,
492: 436, L135
493:
494: \reference{} Woosley, S. E., \& Eastman, R. G. 1997, in Thermonuclear
495: Supernovae, ed. P~Ruiz--LaPuente, R.~Canal, \& J.~Isern (Dordrecht:
496: Kluwer), 821
497:
498: \reference{} Woosley, S. E., \& Heger, A. 2006, ApJ, 637, 914
499:
500: \reference{} Yoon, S.--C., \& Langer, N. 2005, A\&A, 443, 643
501:
502: \end{references}
503:
504: \clearpage
505:
506: \begin{figure}
507: \includegraphics[width=.8\textwidth,angle=270]{f1.eps}
508: \caption{A day~$-2$ spectrum of the Type~Ic SN~1994I is compared with
509: a day~$-1$ spectrum of the Type~Ib or TypeIb/c SN~1999ex. The latter
510: is blueshifted by 4000 \kms\ to align the absorption features. The
511: flux scale is arbitrary and the spectra have been tilted to
512: facilitate the comparison of spectral features. The narrow
513: absorptions near 5900\ang\ in SN~1994I and 5800\ang\ in SN~1999ex are
514: interstellar Na~I in the host galaxies and the narrow absorptions
515: near 6700\ang\ and 7400\ang\ in SN~1999ex are telluric.}
516: \end{figure}
517:
518: \begin{figure}
519: \includegraphics[width=.8\textwidth,angle=270]{f2.eps}
520: \caption{Like Figure~1 but for day~+4 spectra of both SN~1994I and
521: SN~1999ex. The latter is blueshifted by 2000
522: \kms.}
523: \end{figure}
524:
525: \begin{figure}
526: \includegraphics[width=.8\textwidth,angle=270]{f3.eps}
527: \caption{Like Figure~1 but for a day~+10 spectrum of SN~1994I
528: and a day~+13 spectrum of SN~1999ex. The latter
529: is blueshifted by 2000 \kms. }
530: \end{figure}
531:
532: \begin{figure}
533: \includegraphics[width=.8\textwidth,angle=270]{f4.eps}
534: \caption{The day~+4 spectrum of SN~1999ex ({\sl solid line}) is compared
535: to a {\bf Synow} synthetic spectrum ({\sl dashed line}) that has
536: \vphot = 8000 \kms\ and includes lines of hydrogen, He~I, O~I, Mg~II,
537: Ca~II, and Fe~II. }
538: \end{figure}
539:
540: \begin{figure}
541: \includegraphics[width=.8\textwidth,angle=270]{f5.eps}
542: \caption{ The day~+4 spectrum of SN~1994I ({\sl solid line}) is
543: compared to a {\bf Synow} synthetic spectrum ({\sl dashed line}) that
544: has \vphot = 11,000 \kms\ and includes lines of hydrogen, He~I, O~I,
545: Mg~II, Ca~II, Fe~II, and Ti~II. }
546: \end{figure}
547:
548: \begin{figure}
549: \includegraphics[width=.8\textwidth,angle=270]{f6.eps}
550: \caption{Like Figure~5 except that the synthetic spectrum includes
551: lines of Si~II instead of hydrogen. }
552: \end{figure}
553:
554: \begin{figure}
555: \includegraphics[width=.8\textwidth,angle=0]{f7.eps}
556: \caption{A day~+10 spectrum of SN~1994I is compared with spectra of
557: four other SNe~Ic (from Matheson et~al. 2001). The flux scale is
558: arbitrary and the spectra have been tilted to facilitate the
559: comparison of spectral features. The spectrum of SN~1990B was
560: obtained on day~+5. The spectra of SN~1988L, SN~1995F, and SN~1997ei
561: were obtained 11, 10, and 6 days after discovery, respectively; the
562: dates of $B$ maximum are unknown.}
563: \end{figure}
564:
565: \clearpage
566:
567: \begin{deluxetable}{lccccc}
568: %\tabletypesize{\scriptsize}
569: %\rotate
570: \tablenum{1}
571: %\tablewidth{1000pt}
572: \setlength{\tabcolsep}{4pt}
573:
574: \tablecaption{{\bf Synow} Fitting Parameters for Figures 4 and 5}
575:
576: \tablehead{ \colhead{ } & \colhead{\lam$_{\rm ref}$} & \colhead{$\tau$} &
577: \colhead{$v_e$} & \colhead{$\tau$} & \colhead{$v_e$}\\
578:
579: \colhead{ } & \colhead{ } & \colhead{Fig.~4} & \colhead{Fig.~4} &
580: \colhead{Fig.~5} & \colhead{Fig.~5} }
581:
582: \startdata
583:
584: \halpha & \lam6563 & 0.5 & 20 & 0.4 & 20\\
585:
586: He~I & \lam5876 & 2.5 & 1 & 1.2 & 1\\
587:
588: O I & \lam7773 & 1 & 1 & 2 & 1\\
589:
590: Mg~II & \lam4481 & 2 & 1 & 2 & 1\\
591:
592: Ca~II & \lam3934 & 80 & 4 & 80 & 4\\
593:
594: Ti~II & \lam4550 & 0 & & 5 & 1\\
595:
596: Fe~II & \lam5018 & 15 & 2 & 4 & 2\\
597:
598: \enddata
599: \end{deluxetable}
600:
601: \end{document}