1: %&tex
2: \input magic
3: \input epsf
4: \let\label=\autoeqno
5: \let\ref=\eqref
6:
7: \def\fig#1{\epsfxsize=0.49\hsize \epsfbox{#1.eps}}
8: \def\bfig#1{\epsfysize=0.355\vsize \epsfbox{#1.eps}}
9: \def\textbf#1{{\bf#1}}
10: \def\texttt#1{{\tt#1}}
11: \def\mbox#1{\hbox{#1}}
12:
13: \hyphenation{an-a-lyse be-hav-iour}
14: \def\Ne{N_{\rm e}}
15: \def\Nmin{N_{\rm min}}
16: %--------------------------------------------------------------------------
17: \input refs
18: \preprint{astro-ph/0610944}
19:
20: \title{Search for Sources of Cosmic Rays in the Region of the Knee.~II}
21:
22: \author{G. V. Kulikov, M. Yu.\ Zotov}
23: \address{
24: D. V. Skobeltsyn Institute of Nuclear Physics\\
25: Moscow State University, Moscow 119992, Russia\\
26: \tt $\{$kulikov,zotov$\}$@eas.sinp.msu.ru}
27:
28: \date{October 31, 2006}
29:
30: \bigskip
31: \centerline{\bf Abstract}
32: {\narrower\noindent
33: New results of an analysis of arrival directions of extensive air showers
34: registered with the EAS--1000 Prototype array from August 1997 till
35: February 1999 are presented. The method of Alexandreas et al., which has
36: been used for analysis of data registered with CYGNUS, Milagrito, HEGRA
37: AIROBICC, KASCADE and a number of other experiments, is employed. The
38: existence of zones of excessive flux of cosmic rays with energies in the
39: region of the knee is confirmed, as well as closeness of the zones to
40: coordinates of possible astrophysical cosmic ray sources.
41:
42: }
43:
44: %--------------------------------------------------------------------------
45: \section{Introduction}{sec:intro}
46: We have already studied arrival directions of extensive air showers
47: (EAS) with energies of primary particles of the order of
48: $10^{14}$--$10^{15}$~eV registered with the EAS--1000 Prototype
49: array~[\cref{we1},~\cref{we2}].
50: In these works, the analysis was performed with the help of a special
51: procedure of filtering experimental data which allowed us to obtain a
52: set of data such that at some scale, the showers were distributed
53: uniformly wrt.\ sidereal time and the azimuth angle.
54: In this method, filtering of data was done in a (pseudo-)random way.
55: Thus, in what follows, we shall call this procedure as a method of
56: random filtering~(MRF).
57: A detailed description of the MRF can be found in~[\cref{we1},~\cref{we2}].
58:
59: The MRF applied to our data set resulted in the selection of 37~zones
60: of excessive flux (ZEFs) of EAS.
61: Location of the majority of the ZEFs was found to be close to
62: the coordinates of possible astrophysical sources of cosmic rays (CRs)
63: with energies in the region of the knee in the energy spectrum
64: at around 3~PeV~\cite{knee}.
65: The fact that application of the MRF to the available data set
66: led to exclusion of about~17\% of the initial number of EAS with
67: known arrival directions, motivated us to perform a similar
68: analysis basing on the method of Alexandreas et al.~\cite{Al}.
69: This method utilizes the full amount of available data.
70: It has been successfully employed earlier in a number of investigations,
71: see, e.g., reports on the analysis of data obtained with the
72: CYGNUS~\cite{Al}, Milagrito~\cite{Milagrito}, Milagro~\cite{Milagro},
73: HEGRA AIROBICC~\cite{HEGRA}, and KASCADE~\cite{KASCADE} experiments.
74: Below we present the results of our investigation.
75:
76: %--------------------------------------------------------------------------
77: \section{Experimental Data}{sec:data}
78: The data set under consideration includes 1,668,489 EAS registered
79: during 203 days of operation of the EAS--1000 Prototype Array in the
80: period from August~30, 1997, till February~1, 1999.
81: The array consisted of eight detectors
82: located in the central part of the EAS MSU array along longer sides
83: of the $64\,{\rm m}\times22\,{\rm m}$ rectangle~\cite{Fomin}.
84: The geographical coordinates of the array were
85: $37^\circ32.5'$E, $55^\circ41.9'$N.
86:
87: Arrival directions were determined for 1,366,010 EAS.
88: A number~$\Ne$ of charged particles (electrons) was found for 826,921
89: EAS.
90: The mean value $\bar\Ne=1.20\times10^5$ corresponds to the energy
91: of a primary proton $E\approx10^{15}$~eV.
92: There are only 11262 EAS with $\Ne>10^6$ but they give a noticeable
93: contribution in the value of~$\bar\Ne$.
94: With the above energetic EAS excluded, $\bar\Ne=7.65\times10^4$
95: and the median value equals $3.62\times10^4$.
96: Thus, the majority of showers in the data set under consideration
97: had primary particles with energies slightly below the knee.
98:
99:
100: %--------------------------------------------------------------------------
101: \section{Method of Investigation}{sec:method}
102: The main idea of the method of Alexandreas et al.~\cite{Al}
103: is the following.
104: A search for ZEFs is based on the comparison of real experimental data
105: set with a ``background'' set that would be registered with the same
106: installation and during the same period of observation in the
107: assumption of a uniform distribution of arrival directions of EAS over
108: the celestial sphere.
109: The background data set is obtained by a simple procedure of
110: randomization.
111: First, for every shower with an arrival direction $(\theta,\varphi)$
112: an arrival time~$t'$ of another
113: shower is chosen randomly from the rest of the experimental data set.
114: Next, arrival directions of all showers in the equatorial coordinates
115: $(\alpha,\delta)$ are calculated basing on the respective triplets
116: $(t',\theta,\varphi)$.
117: In the resulting set, the distribution of EAS wrt.~$\delta$ is exactly
118: the same as in the original data set.
119:
120: Randomization is performed multiple times in order to avoid
121: a dependency of the distribution wrt.~$\alpha$ on the concrete
122: choice of~$t'$.
123: After this, one creates an averaged ``background'' map by
124: calculating the mean number of EAS located in cells of a
125: fixed size $\Delta\alpha\times\Delta\delta$ in all obtained maps.
126: It is believed that the background map has most of the
127: properties of an isotropic background~\cite{KASCADE}.
128: A search for ZEFs is performed by comparing the number of EAS
129: in a region in the original (``real'') experimental map
130: with the same region in the background map.
131: The measure of deviation is the significance
132: $S=(N_{\rm real} - N_{\rm bg})/\sqrt{N_{\rm bg}}$, where
133: $N_{\rm real}$ and $N_{\rm bg}$ are the numbers of EAS in
134: the same region of the ``real'' experimental map and the
135: background maps respectively.
136:
137: For the purposes of this investigation, the background map
138: was obtained by averaging the number of showers binned in
139: $\Delta\alpha\times\Delta\delta=1^\circ\times1^\circ$ cells.
140: An analysis of the background maps revealed that two
141: maps obtained consecutively differ by at most~1\% of the number
142: of EAS in the respective cells after around~50 cycles of
143: randomization, and by~0.5\% after~90 cycles.
144: Thus we chose to perform 100 cycles of randomization
145: to obtain the final background map.
146:
147: To look for ZEFs, we followed the same procedure as we used
148: in~[\cref{we1}, \cref{we2}]. Namely, the field of observation was
149: divided into strips of width $\Delta\delta=3^\circ\dots30^\circ$,
150: with the boundaries of the strips of equal width shifted by~$1^\circ$
151: wrt.\ each other.
152: Each strip was then divided into cells of equal width~$\Delta\alpha$.
153: In the main part of the investigation, for any fixed width~$\Delta\delta$
154: of a strip, $\Delta\alpha$ was chosen to be equal to a rounded value
155: (expressed in degrees) of $\Delta\delta/\cos\bar{\delta}$, where~$\bar{\delta}$
156: is the mean value of the declination for the strip.
157: This guarantees that cells with the same~$\Delta\delta$ but located
158: at different declination, have an approximately equal area.
159: Similar to~[\cref{we1}, \cref{we2}], such cells will be called `regular'.
160: It is important to take into account that neither the method
161: of Alexandreas et al., nor the method of random filtering put
162: a restriction on the way one chooses regions to be compared.
163: One may perform a search for ZEFs with an arbitrary relation
164: of~$\Delta\alpha$ and~$\Delta\delta$, as well as ZEFs of an
165: arbitrary shape.
166:
167:
168: %--------------------------------------------------------------------------
169: \section{Main Results}{sec:main}
170: Application of the method of Alexandreas et al. to the available data
171: set resulted in the discovery of~561 regular cells with $S>3.0$.
172: For 364 of these cells, significance $S>3.1$.
173: For the sake of convenience, the cells were joined into 27 zones
174: such that each zone is a connected domain.
175: In order to perform an accurate comparison of the results of the two
176: methods, we added five zones made of ``irregular'' cells, i.e., cells
177: with an arbitrary relation of~$\Delta\alpha$ and~$\Delta\delta$.
178: The resulting ZEFs are shown in Fig.~1 in red.
179: The most of partially overlapping cells of excessive flux
180: are not shown for the sake of visual clarity.
181: Their joint exterior boundaries are shown instead.
182: Blue lines show the boundaries of the ZEFs presented
183: in~[\cref{we1}, \cref{we2}]. Recall that all of these 37 ZEFs
184: but zones No.~4, 5, 6, 20, and~21, and bigger cells in ZEFs
185: No.~3, 27, 29, 33, and~36 are composed of regular cells.
186: A number of the zones found by the MRF coincide with those
187: found by the method of Alexandreas et al.\ and thus their
188: boundaries are not visible in the figure.
189:
190: %--------------------------------------------------------------------------
191: \figure{fig:zefs}{Red lines show the boundaries of ZEFs found by the
192: method of Alexandreas et al. Blue lines show the boundaries of ZEFs
193: found by the method of random filtering. Numbers in the field of the
194: figure show the numbers of ZEFs assigned to them in~[\cref{we1},
195: \cref{we2}]. The (magenta) arcs show the Galactic plane. The $\cap$-like
196: curve shows the Supergalactic plane.}{\bfig{zefs}}
197: %--------------------------------------------------------------------------
198:
199: As is clear from Fig.~1, the results obtained by two different methods
200: are quite close, though the MRF seems to be more selective in the
201: sense that the total area of ZEFs found by this method is less than
202: that of the zones found by the method of Alexandreas et al.\
203: (``A-zones''). In sum, 20 ZEFs found by the MRF lie {\it inside\/}
204: A-zones. These are zones No.~1--9, 12, 14, 15, 18, 22, 25--28, 31,
205: and~36. Zone No.~30 also lies inside the corresponding A-zone
206: excluding a small area
207: $\Delta\alpha\times\Delta\delta=3^\circ\times1^\circ$. A major part
208: of ZEF No.~32 also lies within the corresponding A-zone. Zones No.~11,
209: 17, and~21 exactly coincide with A-zones, while zones No.~13 and
210: 33--35 coincide with A-zones up to~$1^\circ$. In fact, there are
211: multiple coincidences with deviation of at most~$1^\circ$ of separate
212: cells found my the two methods in all cases when a ``composite'' ZEF
213: found by the MRF is embedded into a zone found by the method of
214: Alexandreas et~al.
215:
216: Let us mention the existence of pairs for the central cell in ZEF
217: No.~16, which has the M33 galaxy located inside, and for ZEF No.~7,
218: which contains the famous C2 triplet of ultra-high energy cosmic rays,
219: registered with the AGASA array~\cite{AGASA}. Recall that the
220: observation of the latter coincidence was one of the motivations for
221: the analysis of coordinates of extra-galactic cosmic ray sources
222: performed in~\cite{we2}.
223:
224: An embedding of A-zones into the ZEFs found by the MRF can be seen in
225: a few cases. Namely, ZEF No.~10, 23, 24, and~29 contain the
226: corresponding A-zones inside. Only three of 37 ZEFs found by the MRF
227: do not have close counterparts among A-zones. These are the irregular
228: ZEF No.~20, the irregular (exterior) cell of ZEF No.~29, and ZEF
229: No.~37. In the latter case, there are a number of irregular A-zones
230: that intersect the ZEF. They are shown in the figure.
231:
232: Finally, notice seven A-zones (made of regular cells) that do not
233: have any close counterparts among the ZEFs found by the MRF.
234: These are a zone located around $\alpha=20^\circ,\,\delta=75^\circ$,
235: two big A-zones in the vicinity of $\delta=70^\circ$,
236: a zone near $\alpha=330^\circ,\,\delta=73^\circ$,
237: a zone around $\alpha=290^\circ,\,\delta=60^\circ$,
238: and two zones near $\delta=10^\circ$ ($\alpha=25\dots29^\circ$ and
239: $\alpha=224\dots229^\circ$ respectively).
240:
241: %--------------------------------------------------------------------------
242: \section{Discussion}{sec:disc}
243: In our opinion, there is a qualitative agreement between the results
244: of the analyses of arrival directions of cosmic rays registered with
245: the EAS--1000 Prototype Array performed by two different methods.
246: The agreement confirms one of the main conclusions
247: of~[\cref{we1}, \cref{we2}] that there are zones of excessive flux
248: of EAS in the available data set.
249: We find it remarkable that mutual coincidences or embeddings are
250: observed for all zones located in the vicinity of the Galactic
251: and Supergalactic planes.
252:
253: %--------------------------------------------------------------------------
254: \figure{fig:objects}{Zones of excessive flux found by the
255: method of Alexandreas et~al.~\cite{Al} that have counterparts
256: among the ZEFs found in~[\cref{we1}, \cref{we2}].
257: Different symbols show coordinates of some astrophysical objects
258: that have coordinates within angular distance $\le3^\circ$
259: from the ZEFs. These are galactic supernova remnants~$(\bullet)$,
260: pulsars (filled blue triangles), active galactic nuclei and
261: interacting galaxies at red shifts $z\le0.01$~($\triangle$).
262: Also shown are the coordinates of the C2 triplet registered
263: with the AGASA array~($*$)~\cite{AGASA} and the M33
264: galaxy (the red box).}{\bfig{objects}}
265: %--------------------------------------------------------------------------
266:
267: Let us now consider correlations between positions of the ZEFs
268: and coordinates of possible astrophysical sources of cosmic rays
269: with energies near the knee.
270: Figure~2 shows A-zones that have close counterparts among the ZEFs
271: presented in~[\cref{we1}, \cref{we2}] and coordinates of galactic
272: supernova remnants (SNRs)~\cite{Green}, pulsars~\cite{ATNF}
273: (as of the state on June~19, 2006), and active galactic nuclei (AGN)
274: and interacting galaxies at red shifts $z\le0.01$~\cite{Simbad}.
275: All shown astrophysical objects have coordinates at angular
276: distances~$\le3^\circ$ from the closest A-zone.
277: This criterion selected 18 of 110 SNRs at $\delta>-16^\circ$
278: with 15 of them lying inside A-zones and two of them lying
279: at angular distances~$\le1.5^\circ$,
280: 154 of 694 pulsars, and 139 of 317 AGN and interacting galaxies.
281: In particular, the selected objects include the famous SNRs
282: SN1181, 3C461 (Cas~A), SN1572 (Tycho), and the Crab Nebula,
283: a number of pulsars located at distances~$<0.5$~kpc from the Solar
284: system, as well as the active galactic nuclei
285: NGC 3718, NGC 2681, NGC 4278, Mrk 1307, M105, M64, M65, M66, etc.,
286: which have red shifts $z\le0.0033$.
287: Notice that the Virgo cluster of galaxies lies inside a huge A-zone
288: located along the Supergalactic plane
289: ($\alpha\approx170^\circ\dots200^\circ$).
290: It is evident that there are numerous coincidences between
291: coordinates of possible astrophysical sources of cosmic rays
292: with energies near the knee and positions of zones located
293: in the vicinity of the Galactic and Supergalactic planes.
294:
295: %--------------------------------------------------------------------------
296: \asection{Acknowledgments}
297: Only free, open source software was used for the investigation.
298: In particular, all calculations were performed with
299: GNU Octave~\cite{Octave} running in Slackware Linux.
300: The research was partially supported by the Federal Program
301: ``Priority Investigations in Science and Technology'' for
302: 2002--2006, contract No.~02.452.11.7053, and the Russian
303: Foundation for Fundamental Research grant No.~05-02-16401.
304:
305:
306:
307: \listrefs
308: \bye
309: %--------------------------------------------------------------------------
310:
311:
312: