1: \documentclass[11pt,twoside]{article}

2: 

3: %%% PREAMBLE MATTER

4: 

5: \usepackage{asp2006}

6: \usepackage{fancyhdr,graphicx,caption,rotating,multirow,lscape}

7: \DeclareGraphicsExtensions{.eps,.eps.gz,.ps,.jpg,.tiff}

8: %\usepackage{epsf}

9: %\usepackage{psfig}

10: %\usepackage{lscape}

11: 

12: \markboth{Pepper}{Transit Search}

13: 

14: \pagestyle{myheadings}

15: 

16: %%% To ensure any equations, figures, footnotes, section numbers and tables

17: %%% are correctly numbered from ``1'' upwards. DO NOT ALTER!!!

18: \setcounter{equation}{0}

19: \setcounter{figure}{0}

20: \setcounter{footnote}{0}

21: \setcounter{section}{0}

22: \setcounter{table}{0}

23: 

24: \begin{document}

25: 

26: \title{Early Results from the KELT Transit Survey}  

27: 

28: \author{Joshua Pepper, Richard Pogge, D.~L. DePoy, J.~L. Marshall, Kris Stanek}

29: \affil{Department of Astronomy, The Ohio State University, 140 West 18th Avenue, Columbus, OH, 43210-1173}

30: \author{Amelia Stutz}  

31: \affil{Department of Astronomy, Univeristy of Arizona, 933 N Cherry Ave, Tucson AZ 85721-0065}

32: \author{Mark Trueblood, Pat Trueblood}  

33: \affil{Winer Observatory, P.\ O.\ Box 797, Sonoita, AZ 85637-0797}    

34: 

35: 

36: \begin{abstract}

37: The Kilodegree Extremely Little Telescope (KELT) project is a small-aperture transit

38: survey of bright stars. The project has completed commissioning runs searching for transits in the

39: Hyades and Praesepe, and is well into a multi-year survey of a large portion of the Northern 

40: Hemisphere.  Here we describe the setup of the telescope and discuss the early data.

41: \end{abstract}

42: 

43: 

44: There is great scientific potential in the discovery of transiting planets with 

45: bright host stars.  Follow-up observation of such systems can determine  

46: properties of the planets that are not measurable in non-transiting systems, or 

47: in transiting systems where the host stars are too faint.  The Kilodegree Extremely Little 

48: Telescope (KELT) project is a wide field, small-aperture survey for such 

49: transits, based on a theoretical optimization of all-sky transit 

50: searches \citep{pep03}.  It is similar to the other small-telescope transit surveys with wide 

51: fields \citep{alonso04,mc06,bakos04,acc06}, but it surveys a larger area of sky 

52: than the other surveys.  KELT is designed to target stars with 

53: magnitudes $8 < V < 10$; a range fainter than the stars observed in radial-velocity 

54: surveys but brighter than those targeted by most existing transit surveys.  KELT

55: consists of a single automated telescope located at the remote telescope hosting 

56: site Winer Observatory in Sonoita, AZ.  The primary KELT mission is a survey of a 

57: strip of sky 26 degrees wide at $\delta = +32^\circ$, broken 

58: into 13 equally-spaced fields.  The telescope began operations in October 2004, and 

59: spent two commissioning runs observing the open clusters Praesepe and the 

60: Hyades.  We then began observing the 13 survey fields, which together cover 

61: about 25\% of the Northern sky.

62: 

63: We have been gathering data for the past two years, with gaps due to the need 

64: to shut down during the summer monsoons, and also due to periodic equipment 

65: problems.  The telescope is currently operating well, and returning data 

66: regularly.  In this proceeding, we briefly describe the telescope instrumentation, 

67: the survey area and observing strategy, and we discuss the telescope performance 

68: and show sample lightcurves. 

69: 

70: \section{Instrumentation} 

71: 

72: KELT employs an Apogee AP16E thermoelectrically cooled CCD camera.  This 

73: camera uses the Kodak KAF-16801E front-side illuminated CCD 

74: with $4096 \times 4096$ $9\mu m$ pixels (36.88 $\times$ 36.88\,mm detector 

75: area).  We use two different lenses with KELT.  For the wide-angle survey mode,

76: we use a Mamiya 645 80\,mm f/1.9 medium-format manual-focus lens with a

77: 42\,mm aperture.  This lens provides a roughly 23\arcsec\,pix$^{-1}$ image scale 

78: and a $26^\circ \times 26^\circ$ field of view, with vignetting at the corners, so 

79: the effective clear field of view is circular.  Figure \ref{fig:m31} shows a sample 

80: image of a survey field.  We selected the field with galaxy M31 to give perspective 

81: on the size of our fields.  To provide a narrow-angle campaign mode used for the 

82: Hyades and Praesepe observations, we use a Mamiya 645 200\,mm f/2.8 APO manual-focus 

83: telephoto lens with a 71\,mm aperture.  This provides a roughly 9.5\arcsec\,pix$^{-1}$ image 

84: scale and effective 10\fdg8$\times$10\fdg8 field of view.

85: 

86: To reject the mostly-blue background sky without greatly diminishing the

87: sensitivity to stars (which are mostly redder than the night sky), we

88: use a Kodak Wratten \#8 red-pass filter with a 50\% transmission point

89: at $\sim$490\,nm (the filter looks yellow to the eye).  The filter is

90: mounted in front of the KELT lens during operations.  

91: 

92: The optical assembly (camera+lens+filter) is mounted on a Paramount ME

93: Robotic Telescope Mount manufactured by Software

94: Bisque.  The Paramount is a research-grade German Equatorial Mount designed 

95: specifically for robotic operation with integrated telescope and camera 

96: control.  The CCD camera and mount are controlled by a PC computer located 

97: at the observing site that runs Windows XP Pro and the Bisque Observatory 

98: Software Suite from Software Bisque.  

99: 

100: \section{Survey Area and Strategy}

101: 

102: The main targets for KELT are a series of fields, all at $\delta = +32^\circ$, the 

103: latitude of Winer Observatory.  The fields are 

104: spaced equally in Right Ascension, and we tile between two fields at any given 

105: time, observing each once before slewing to the next field, yielding a cadence 

106: on a single field of about six minutes, with an exposure time of 2.5 minutes 

107: and 40 seconds for readout and slewing.  Over the course of a year, we take 

108: about the same number of images from each field.  Since beginning operations, we 

109: have taken over 40,000 images of our 13 survey fields.  We are still building 

110: the software pipeline for the data and gathering images from certain fields.  By 

111: spring 2007, we expect to begin searching our data for transits.

112: 

113: Each survey field is about $500^2$ degrees, and together they fill about 25\% of 

114: the Northern sky.  This amount of coverage and the magnitude range of our target 

115: stars set KELT apart from similar wide-angle surveys.  This setup allows KELT to

116:  search for the most scientifically interesting transits over the largest part of 

117: the sky.  Based on estimates from \citet{pep03}, we expect to find $\sim 4$ 

118: transiting planets in these fields.

119: 

120: \section{Performance}

121: 

122: The critical threshold for sensitivity to transits is generally taken to be an RMS 

123: of less than 1\%, which corresponds to the transit by a Jupiter-sized planet of 

124: a solar-type star.  In order to achieve this level of precision, we employ image 

125: subtraction using the ISIS package \citep{alard00}.  Difference imaging is often 

126: difficult to implement in general, and is especially prone to complications with very 

127: large fields of view.  After overcoming various problems, we were able to successfully 

128: implement ISIS.  Among transit surveys, KELT has the largest field of view for which image subtraction has 

129: been successfully employed.

130: 

131: Figure \ref{fig:rms} shows the RMS for one of our survey fields 

132: from one night of observing.  There are over 6000 stars in the field showing sub-1\% 

133: variation, which would make it possible to detect transits in their lightcurves.  A more robust 

134: measure of transit sensitivity would require computing RMS over the entire course of 

135: observations of the field, but would also require the application of a detrending 

136: algorithm, such as SYSREM \citep{tamuz05}, that would remove nightly atmospheric 

137: and airmass variations.  We are still testing detrending algorithms with our data, 

138: and thus do not yet have a complete analysis for our long-term RMS sensitivity.  However, 

139: the quality of the single-night lightcurves demonstrate the potential of the data.  A full 

140: description of the performance of the telescope will appear in an upcoming paper, which 

141: will also provide a detailed discussion of the telescope instrumentation and control and 

142: data handling procedures \citep{pepper06}.

143: 

144: \section{Example Lightcurves}

145: 

146: Along with the survey data taken to date, we have been analyzing the commissioning 

147: data on Praesepe, which consists of over 3,000 observations taken on 34 nights over the course of 74 

148: days, using the 200\,mm lens with the 10\fdg8$\times$10\fdg8 fields of view.  We have found 

149: a large number of variable stars, of which we show three examples 

150: in Figure \ref{fig:vars}.  We have also begun searching the Praesepe data for transits.  We 

151: are still sorting through the data, but we have found two-transit-like curves, shown 

152: in Figure \ref{fig:dips}.  These signals are probably not planetary transits, based on their 

153: depths and periods, but they demonstrate our ability to detect transits with the KELT data.  We 

154: will be publishing an upcoming paper describing the analysis of the Praesepe data for 

155: variable stars and transits \citep{pepper07}. 

156: 

157: \begin{figure}[!ht]

158: \centering

159: \includegraphics[angle=0,width=12cm]{f1.ps}

160: \vspace{-1in}

161: \caption{Image of one $26^{\circ} \times 26^{\circ}$ survey field from the

162: KELT camera.  The extended object at the upper right is M31. \label{fig:m31}}

163: \vspace{1in}

164: \end{figure}

165: 

166: \begin{figure}[!ht]

167: \centering

168: \includegraphics[angle=270,width=15cm]{f2.ps}

169: \caption{RMS magnitude scatter of a time-series of magnitude measurements of one of the survey fields.  This plot shows the RMS for 33 images of 73,000 stars over one night of observing, with no detrending applied.\label{fig:rms}}

170: \end{figure}

171: 

172: \begin{figure}[!ht]

173: \centering

174: \includegraphics[angle=0,width=9cm]{f3.ps}

175: \vspace{-0.2in}

176: \caption{Examples of newly discovered variable stars in Praesepe.  Each light curve contains over 3000 points. \label{fig:vars}}

177: \end{figure}

178: 

179: \vspace{0.2in}

180: 

181: \begin{figure}[!ht]

182: \centering

183: \includegraphics[angle=0,width=9cm]{f4.ps}%{dips2l.ps}

184: \vspace{-0.1in}

185: \caption{Transit-like light curves from KELT observations of Praesepe.  These objects are probably not planets, but demonstrate the ability of KELT to detect transits.\label{fig:dips}}

186: \end{figure}

187: 

188: 

189: \vspace{0.5in}

190: \acknowledgements %%% Text of acknowledgments runs on after this command.

191: Thanks to Scott Gaudi for helpful comments.  Thanks also to the Local Organizing Committee of 

192: this Workshop, Cristina Afonso, David Weldrake, and Maria Janssen-Bennynck.  This 

193: work was supported by the National Aeronautics and Space Administration under Grant No. NNG04GO70G issued 

194: through the Origins of Solar Systems program.

195: 

196: 

197: \begin{thebibliography}{}

198: 

199: \bibitem[Alard(2000)]{alard00} Alard, C. 2000, \aap, 144, 363

200: 

201: \bibitem[Alonso et al.(2004)]{alonso04} Alonso, R., et al. 2004, \apj, 613, L153

202: 

203: \bibitem[Bakos et al.(2004)]{bakos04} Bakos, G., et al. 2004, \pasp, 116, 266

204: 

205: \bibitem[Cameron et al.(2006)]{acc06} Cameron, A. C., et al. 2006, to appear in \mnras, astro-ph/0609688

206: 

207: \bibitem[McCullough et al.(2006)]{mc06} McCullough, P. R., et al. 2006, \apj, 648, 1228

208: 

209: \bibitem[Pepper, Gould, \& DePoy(2003)]{pep03} Pepper, J., Gould, A., \& DePoy, D.~L.,\ 2003, Acta Astron, 53, 213 

210: 

211: \bibitem[Pepper et al.(2006)]{pepper06} Pepper, J., et al. 2006, in preparation

212: 

213: \bibitem[Pepper et al.(2007)]{pepper07} Pepper, J., et al. 2007, in preparation

214: 

215: \bibitem[Tamuz, Mazeh, \& Zucker(2005)]{tamuz05} Tamuz, O.,  Mazeh, T., \& Zucker, S. 2005, \mnras, 356, 1466

216: 

217: \end{thebibliography}

218: 

219: \end{document}

220: 

221: % LocalWords:  alonso mc bakos acc Sonoita KAF Wratten XP SYSREM tamuz Pogge ph

222: % LocalWords:  Stanek Siverd Trueblood NNG Mazeh Zucker DePoy Stutz Univeristy

223: % LocalWords:  alard Afonso Weldrake Janssen Bennynck Astron

224: