1: %%
2: %% Beginning of file 'ms.tex' D. Batcheldor et al. 2006
3: %%
4: %% Modified 30 Jan 07
5:
6: %% The first piece of markup in an AASTeX v5.x document
7: %% is the \documentclass command. LaTeX will ignore
8: %% any data that comes before this command.
9:
10: %% The command below calls the preprint style
11: %% which will produce a one-column, single-spaced document.
12: %% Examples of commands for other substyles follow. Use
13: %% whichever is most appropriate for your purposes.
14:
15: %\documentclass[12pt,preprint]{aastex}
16:
17: %% manuscript produces a one-column, double-spaced document:
18:
19: %\documentclass[manuscript]{aastex}
20:
21: %% preprint2 produces a double-column, single-spaced document:
22:
23: %\documentclass[preprint2]{aastex}
24:
25: \documentclass[apj]{emulateapj}
26:
27: %% If you want to create your own macros, you can do so
28: %% using \newcommand. Your macros should appear before
29: %% the \begin{document} command.
30: %%
31: %% If you are submitting to a journal that translates manuscripts
32: %% into SGML, you need to follow certain guidelines when preparing
33: %% your macros. See the AASTeX v5.x Author Guide
34: %% for information.
35:
36: \newcommand{\vdag}{(v)^\dagger}
37: \newcommand{\myemail}{dpbpci@astro.rit.edu}
38:
39: %% You can insert a short comment on the title page using the command below.
40:
41: % \slugcomment{Not to appear in Nonlearned J., 45.}
42:
43: %% If you wish, you may supply running head information, although
44: %% this information may be modified by the editorial offices.
45: %% The left head contains a list of authors,
46: %% usually a maximum of three (otherwise use et al.). The right
47: %% head is a modified title of up to roughly 44 characters. Running heads
48: %% will not print in the manuscript style.
49:
50: \shorttitle{Outflow Mechanisms in Powerful Radio Galaxies}
51: \shortauthors{Batcheldor et al.}
52:
53: %% This is the end of the preamble. Indicate the beginning of the
54: %% paper itself with \begin{document}.
55:
56: \begin{document}
57:
58: %% LaTeX will automatically break titles if they run longer than
59: %% one line. However, you may use \\ to force a line break if
60: %% you desire.
61:
62: \title{Dominant Nuclear Outflow Driving Mechanisms in Powerful Radio Galaxies\altaffilmark{1}}
63: %% Use \author, \affil, and the \and command to format
64: %% author and affiliation information.
65: %% Note that \email has replaced the old \authoremail command
66: %% from AASTeX v4.0. You can use \email to mark an email address
67: %% anywhere in the paper, not just in the front matter.
68: %% As in the title, you can use \\ to force line breaks.
69:
70: \author{Dan Batcheldor\altaffilmark{2}, Clive Tadhunter\altaffilmark{3}, Joanna Holt\altaffilmark{3}, Raffaella Morganti\altaffilmark{4},
71: Christopher P. O'Dea\altaffilmark{5},\\ David J. Axon\altaffilmark{6} \& Anton Koekemoer\altaffilmark{7}}
72:
73: %% Notice that each of these authors has alternate affiliations, which
74: %% are identified by the \altaffilmark after each name. Specify alternate
75: %% affiliation information with \altaffiltext, with one command per each
76: %% affiliation.
77:
78: \altaffiltext{1}{Based on observations made with the NASA/ESA {\it Hubble Space Telescope} obtained at the Space Telescope Science Institute, which
79: is operated by the Association of Universities for Research in Astronomy, Incorporated, under NASA contract NAS 5-26555. These
80: observations are associated with programme 10206.}
81: \altaffiltext{2}{Assistant Research Scientist, Center for Imaging Science, Rochester Institute of Technology, 54 Lomb Memorial Drive,
82: Rochester, NY 14623 \email{dpbpci@astro.rit.edu}}
83: \altaffiltext{3}{Department of Physics \& Astronomy, University of Sheffield, Sheffield, S3 7RH, UK}
84: \altaffiltext{4}{ASTRON, Postbus 2, 7900AA Dwingeloo, The Netherlands}
85: \altaffiltext{5}{Department of Physics, Rochester Institute of Technology, Rochester, NY 14623}
86: \altaffiltext{6}{Space Telescope Science Institute, 3700 San Martin Drive, Baltimore, MD 21218}
87:
88:
89:
90: %% Mark off your abstract in the ``abstract'' environment. In the manuscript
91: %% style, abstract will output a Received/Accepted line after the
92: %% title and affiliation information. No date will appear since the author
93: %% does not have this information. The dates will be filled in by the
94: %% editorial office after submission.
95:
96: \begin{abstract}
97: In order to identify the dominant nuclear outflow mechanisms in Active Galactic Nuclei, we have undertaken deep, high resolution
98: observations of two compact radio sources (PKS 1549-79 and PKS 1345+12) with the Advanced Camera for Surveys (ACS) aboard the
99: {\it Hubble Space Telescope}. Not only are these targets known to have powerful emission line outflows, but they also contain all the
100: potential drivers for the outflows: relativistic jets, quasar nuclei and starbursts. ACS allows the compact nature ($<$0\farcs15) of
101: these radio sources to be optically resolved for the first time. Through comparison with existing radio maps we have seen consistency in
102: the nuclear position angles of both the optical emission line and radio data. There is no evidence for bi-conical emission line features
103: on the large-scale and there is a divergance in the relative position angles of the optical and radio structure. This enables us to
104: exclude starburst driven outflows. However, we are unable to clearly distinguish between radiative AGN wind driven outflows and outflows
105: powered by relativistic radio jets. The small scale bi-conical features, indicative of such mechanisms could be below the resolution
106: limit of ACS, especially if aligned close to the line of sight. In addition, there may be offsets between the radio and optical nuclei
107: induced by heavy dust obscuration, nebular continuum or scattered light from the AGN.
108: \end{abstract}
109:
110: %% Keywords should appear after the \end{abstract} command. The uncommented
111: %% example has been keyed in ApJ style. See the instructions to authors
112: %% for the journal to which you are submitting your paper to determine
113: %% what keyword punctuation is appropriate.
114:
115: \keywords{quasars: emission lines - quasars: general - galaxies: active - galaxies: jets - galaxies: starburst - galaxies: individual
116: (PKS 1549-79, PKS 1345+12)}
117:
118: %% From the front matter, we move on to the body of the paper.
119: %% In the first two sections, notice the use of the natbib \citep
120: %% and \citet commands to identify citations. The citations are
121: %% tied to the reference list via symbolic KEYs. The KEY corresponds
122: %% to the KEY in the \bibitem in the reference list below. We have
123: %% chosen the first three characters of the first author's name plus
124: %% the last two numeral of the year of publication as our KEY for
125: %% each reference.
126:
127: \section{Introduction}
128:
129: Gaseous nuclear outflows are known to be present in many Active Galactic Nuclei (AGN). Indeed, these high velocity phenomena have been
130: noted in a broad range of objects, including Seyferts, starbursts, quasars and radio galaxies \citep{cren00,kron03,veil04,morg05}. In
131: addition, it has been suggested that these outflows can (a) have a significant impact on the surrounding warm inter-stellar
132: medium (ISM), which may in turn influence the evolution of the host galaxies, and can (b) limit the growth of the supermassive black
133: holes and the rate of star formation \citep{sandr98,wandl03}. As these factors link nuclear activity with the surrounding host galaxy and
134: the process of galactic evolution, feedback effects associated with these outflows may be directly responsible for the observed tight
135: relations between black hole mass and bulge properties \citep{fandf05}. However, there is a deficiency in our current understanding of
136: AGN-induced feedback mechanisms. While the primary source for the large-scale X-ray halos surrounding radio sources, in addition to the
137: kilo-parsec-scale radio structures, is seen to be the AGN-induced radio jet in many cases \citep[e.g.,][]{car94,nul02,fab03,gal06}, the
138: dominant driving device for these nuclear ($\le 1$ kpc) outflows is still unclear.
139:
140: As radio-emitting jets can couple with the ISM more strongly than AGN photons, radio galaxies and radio-loud quasars offer the
141: chance to scrutinize the role of nuclear activity on the host galaxies of powerful AGN. In addition, since the light from bright quasar
142: nuclei is extinguished along our line of sight by circumnuclear material, we can directly investigate the structure and spatial extent of
143: the nuclear outflow regions. Gaseous outflows in powerful radio galaxies are also expected to be important for several reasons. Firstly,
144: nuclear activity triggers, i.e., mergers or cooling flows \citep{heck86,bfandc97}, are likely to leave debris which is dissipated as the
145: radio source evolves. Such nuclear debris has been implied by the greater number of absorption line systems in young, compact quasars
146: than in quasars with extended, evolved radio morphologies \citep{bak02}. Secondly, NICMOS observations of Cygnus A have provided evidence
147: of outflow induced despoliation in the form of hollowed out bi-conical structures \citep{tad99}. Finally, it is likely that all the
148: suggested drivers of the outflows are present to varying degree in radio galaxies.
149:
150: \begin{deluxetable}{ccccccccc}
151: \tabletypesize{\footnotesize}
152: \tablecaption{Summary of Observations \label{tab:obs}}
153: \tablewidth{0pt}
154: \tablehead{
155: \colhead{Target} &\colhead{Instru.} &\colhead{Filter} & \colhead{Central $\lambda$} & \colhead{Exposures} \\
156: \colhead{} &\colhead{} &\colhead{} & \colhead{${\rm\AA}$} & \colhead{No. x T(s)} \\
157: }
158: \startdata
159: PKS 1549-79 & WFC1 & FR647M & 6798 & 4x250 \\
160: & & & 7560 & 4x250 \\
161: & HRC & FR459M & 5234 & 4x730 \\
162: & & F550M & 5580 & 4x700 \\
163: & & & & \\
164: PKS 1345+12 & WFC1 & FR647M & 6618 & 4x200 \\
165: & & & 7361 & 4x200 \\
166: & HRC & FR459M & 5093 & 4x640 \\
167: & & F550M & 5580 & 4x620 \\
168: \enddata
169: \tablecomments{Exposures are giving in terms of total number, and length (in seconds), of each drizzle.
170: }
171: \end{deluxetable}
172:
173: There are several potential sources for the observed nuclear outflows: radiative winds from highly luminous quasar nuclei \citep{bk93};
174: starburst driven winds \citep{ham90}; powerful relativistic jets \citep{bdo97}; cloud interaction with expanding radio lobes
175: \citep{ode02}. Each of these mechanisms will leave an imprint on the nuclear morphology of the host.
176:
177: The main observational difference between AGN and starburst driven outflows will be in the size of the region from where the process
178: originates. Starburst winds will have an origin which is roughly the size of the starburst region, i.e., 100 -- 2000 pc \citep{ham90},
179: whereas the AGN wind driven outflows will have an origin which is inside the torus \citep[e.g.,][]{kandb86}. Therefore, collimated
180: outflows on scales of $<100$ pc would indicate that the outflow is AGN driven. A secondary diagnostic is the alignment of the outflow with
181: the minor axis of the galaxy. Since starburst driven winds are collimated by the galaxy pressure gradient, they should align with the
182: minor axis. However, the torus that defines the AGN driven outflows does not necessarily have to be aligned with the galaxy minor axis as
183: Seyfert radio sources show a roughly random distribution of orientation with respect to the minor axis \citep[e.g.,][]{kin00}.
184:
185: In jet driven outflows the emission line structure will have similar features and scales to the radio structure. However,
186: in lobe driven outflows, where the expanding radio lobe bow shock runs over ambient clouds giving them a kick outward, the cloud
187: velocities are much smaller than the radio source bow shock expansion velocity. Therefore, the outflow region will be smaller than the
188: total radio source extent.
189:
190: The following analysis is designed to determine the dominant mechanism driving nuclear outflows through the study of two compact radio
191: sources. For an extended review of such objects see \citet{odea98}. Firstly, the nearby compact flat-spectrum radio source PKS 1549-79
192: (z=0.152). Secondly, the nearby Gigahertz Peaked Spectrum (GPS) radio source PKS 1345+12 (z=0.122). Both these sources are hosted by
193: ultra-luminous infra-red galaxies (URLIGS), with on-going star formation, and are well known powerful radio galaxies in which outflows
194: have been unequivocally detected in the near nuclear narrow-line region, i.e., \citet[][hereafter HTM03]{htandm03} and
195: \citet[][hereafter H06]{hol06}. In addition, these previous spectroscopic observations indicate that the [OIII] emission in the nuclear
196: regions is dominated by broad, outflowing emission line gas. Therefore, despite accepting all [OIII] emission from the nuclear regions,
197: suitable filters will avoid any ambiguities associated with possible contamination by non-outflowing, narrower emission line components
198: in the nuclear regions.
199:
200: Important information on the outflow driving mechanism could be gained through further consideration of the internal nuclear kinematics
201: and also from studying the possible ionization mechanisms. The relative velocities and FWHM of the kinematical components in both
202: PKS 1549-79 and PKS 1345+12 are consistent with shocks, however, the same cannot be said about the ionization mechanism. In the case of
203: PKS 1549-79, the line ratios are consistent with AGN photoionization; there is no evidence for shock ionization. In PKS 1345+12, the
204: nature of the outflow components change between different lines making it impossible to investigate the ionisation mechanisms using the
205: standard line ratios and diagnostic diagrams.
206:
207: \begin{figure*}[t]
208: \plotone{f1.eps}
209: \caption[PKS 1549-79 ACS Data]{
210: PKS 1549-79. [{\it Top Row}] WFC1 ACS Observations. (a) FR647M at $7560{\rm\AA}$ (H$\alpha$). (b) FR647M at $6798{\rm\AA}$ (Continuum).
211: (c) Continuum subtracted H$\alpha$. [{\it Bottom Row}] HRC ACS Observations. (d) FR550M at $5580{\rm\AA}$ ([OIII]). (e) FR459 at
212: $5234{\rm\AA}$ (Continuum). (f) Continuum subtracted [OIII].}\label{fig:1549acs}
213: \end{figure*}
214:
215: \begin{figure}[t]
216: \plotone{f2.eps}
217: \caption[PKS 1549-79: Large scale structure]{
218: PKS 1549-79. The larger structure (FR647M at $6798{\rm\AA}$) showing extended diffuse with potential star clusters and foreground stars.
219: }\label{fig:1549ls}
220: \end{figure}
221:
222: We introduce high resolution emission line maps obtained with the Advanced Camera for Surveys (ACS) aboard the {\it Hubble Space
223: Telescope} ({\it HST}). The superior spatial resolution of ACS allows the compact nature of these sources ($\sim$0\farcs15) to be resolved
224: for the first time. These new data make it possible to distinguish the main outflow driving mechanism through morphological comparison
225: with existing radio data.
226:
227: In \S~\ref{obs+dr} we detail the {\it HST} observations and the data reduction steps. The new ACS data are presented in \S~\ref{1549} and
228: \S~\ref{1345}. These observations, in conjunction with VLBI data, allow us to attempt to identify the mechanisms dominating the nuclear
229: outflows in \S~\ref{dommech}. Our findings are discussed in \S~\ref{discussion} and concluded in \S~\ref{cons}.
230:
231: \section{Observations and Data Reduction}\label{obs+dr}
232:
233: PKS 1549-79 and PKS 1345+12 were observed by ACS on the $4^{\rm th}$ and $5^{\rm th}$ August 2004 as part of Cycle 13 \#10206
234: PI: Tadhunter. Two exposures of PKS 1549-79, each of 4x250s, were made using chip 1 of the Wide Field Channel (WFC1, pixel scale
235: $\approx0\farcs05$ -- the spatial scale at the distance of these targets is $\sim~3{\rm~kpc/arcsec}$)\footnote{We adopt a value of
236: $\rm H_0~=~70~km~s^{-1} Mpc^{-1}$ throughout}. The IRAMP (FR647M, $\delta\lambda=9\%$) ramp filter was adjusted to cover two central
237: wavelengths, $7560{\rm\AA}$ for the H$\alpha$ emission line and $6798{\rm\AA}$ for the continuum map. To avoid overfilling the {\it HST}
238: storage buffer only a 1024x1024 sub-array of the WFC1 was read out. Two more exposures of PKS 1549-79 were also made using the High
239: Resolution Channel (HRC, pixel scale $\approx0\farcs027$). The first focused on the [OIII] emission line (F550M,
240: $\delta\lambda=547{\rm\AA}$, 4x700s) and the second focused on the continuum (FR459M - $5234{\rm\AA}, \delta\lambda=9\%$, 4x730s). This
241: strategy was repeated for PKS 1345+12 where the central wavelength of the FR647M ramp filter was adjusted to $7361{\rm\AA}$ and
242: $6618{\rm\AA}$ (4x200s each), and $5093{\rm\AA}$ for the FR459M ramp filter (4x640s). A summary of these observations is presented in
243: Table~\ref{tab:obs}.
244:
245: \begin{figure*}[t]
246: \plotone{f3.eps}
247: \caption[PKS 1345+12 ACS Data]{
248: PKS 1345+12. [{\it Top Row}] WFC1 ACS Observations. (a) FR647M at $7361{\rm\AA}$ (H$\alpha$). (b) FR647M at $6618{\rm\AA}$ (Continuum).
249: (c) Continuum subtracted H$\alpha$. [{\it Bottom Row}] HRC ACS Observations. (d) FR550M at $5580{\rm\AA}$ ([OIII]). (e) FR459 at
250: $5093{\rm\AA}$ (Continuum). (f) Continuum subtracted [OIII].}\label{fig:1345acs}
251: \end{figure*}
252:
253: \begin{figure}[t]
254: \plotone{f4.eps}
255: \caption[PKS 1345+12: Large scale structure]{
256: PKS 1345+12: The larger scale structure (FR647M at $6618{\rm\AA}$) showing the distorted morphology.
257: }\label{fig:1345ls}
258: \end{figure}
259:
260: The data were passed through the ACS reduction pipeline, using the latest reference files, in order to remove instrumental residuals.
261: Cosmic-ray removal was facilitated through the use of the Multi-drizzle script \citep{koek02}. Detailed examinations of the distortion
262: corrected data were performed, given that only subsets of the data were read out. The ellipticity of isophotes fitted to 10 stellar
263: objects across each field never exceeded 0.08 and averaged 0.03. As a final step, the on and off line images were scaled and subtracted
264: from each other in order to produce emission line maps.
265:
266: \section{PKS 1549-79}\label{1549}
267:
268: The radio source PKS 1549-79 has had much previous work carried out on it. A brief outline of its main properties will be given before
269: the new data are presented. Readers interested in more thorough reviews are directed toward \citet{morg01}, \citet{tad01} and H06.
270:
271: VLBI observations reveal PK1549-79 to have a relatively small ($\sim$150 mas) one-sided distorted jet structure bending through 60\degr
272: \citep{king94}. Lower resolution maps show no evidence of large scale structures. The radio jet has a steep radio spectrum and originates
273: from an unresolved flat spectrum radio core. Although the jet is likely close to our line of sight this source shows no evidence for broad
274: emission-line features, contrary to the standard orientation based unification schemes. A model describing a cocooned (obscured) quasar,
275: where a young radio jet is carving a path through a dense nuclear region, has been proposed by \citet{tad01}. A narrow HI absorption line
276: gives a redshift of 0.152 \citep[][H06]{morg01}. \citet{pandp83} were first to associate the radio source with what has been classified
277: as an 18.5(V) magnitude Seyfert 2.
278:
279: Signs of star formation are provided by abnormally strong far-infrared (FIR) emissions, i.e., ULIRG, and an optical continuum that is
280: dominated by a population of early type stars \citep{randn97,dick97}. Based on spectral synthesis modeling, H06 have shown this young
281: stellar population to account for 1-30\% of the total stellar mass, and be between 50 and 250 Myrs old. In addition, the modeling of H06
282: has shown that the reddened quasar, which has been directly detected in the K-band \citep{bell03}, makes a small but significant
283: contribution to the continuum around the wavelength of H$\alpha$. This has also been suggested by the detection of a very broad component
284: to the H$\alpha$. Further spectral analyses \citep[][H06]{tad01} have shown the outflow to have an extremely broad high ionization [OIII]
285: line (FWHM$\sim$1280${\rm~km~s^{-1}}$), and a lower ionization [OII] line (FWHM$\approx$380${\rm~km~s^{-1}}$). The outflow, which is
286: blue-shifted by $680{\rm~km~s^{-1}}$ with respect to the rest frame, is detected in all of the ionization lines. However, the outflow
287: is strongest (and dominated by) the high ionization lines. In comparison, the low ionisation lines are dominated by quiescent gas.
288:
289: In summary, H06, using ground-based optical, infrared (IR) and radio observations, have confirmed that PK1549-79 constitutes a young
290: luminous narrow-line (obscured) quasar, the activity of which has been triggered by a gas rich major merger.
291:
292: \begin{deluxetable}{lccc}
293: \tabletypesize{\footnotesize}
294: \tablecaption{Astrometric Details\label{tab:astro}}
295: \tablewidth{0pt}
296: \tablehead{
297: \colhead{} &\colhead{PKS 1549-79} &\multicolumn{2}{c}{PKS 1345+12} \\
298: \colhead{} &\colhead{} &\colhead{(East)} &\colhead{(West)}
299: }
300: \startdata
301: {\it HST} RA: & $15^{\rm h}56^{\rm m}58\fs96$ & $13^{\rm h}47^{\rm m}33\fs51$ & $13^{\rm h}47^{\rm m}33\fs37$ \\
302: {\it HST} DEC: & $-79\degr14\arcmin04\farcs16$ & $+12\degr17\arcmin22\farcs99$ & $+12\degr17\arcmin23\farcs44$ \\
303: Radio RA: & $15^{\rm h}56^{\rm m}58\fs87^{1}$ & \multicolumn{2}{c}{$15^{\rm h}56^{\rm m}58\fs87^{2}$} \\
304: Radio DEC: & $-79\degr14\arcmin04\farcs28^{1}$ & \multicolumn{2}{c}{$-79\degr14\arcmin04\farcs28^{2}$} \\
305: $\Delta$RA: & $1\farcs35$ & $2\farcs25$ & $0\farcs15$ \\
306: $\Delta$DEC: & $0\farcs12$ & $1\farcs27$ & $0\farcs82$ \\
307: \enddata
308: \tablecomments{All co-ordinates are in J2000. (1) Radio data from \citet{john95}. (2) Radio data from \citet{stang01}.
309: }
310: \end{deluxetable}
311:
312: In Figure~\ref{fig:1549acs} we present the new ACS data for PKS 1549-79. In both the H$\alpha$ and [OIII] line and continuum images
313: we find a prominent nucleus with an offshoot extending to the north. The radio and {\it HST} astrometry is listed in
314: Table~\ref{tab:astro}. The offshoot, which is significantly less prominent in the [OIII] emission, appears to have several distinct
315: components, the furthest of which lies along a position angle (PA) of 0 and at a distance of $1\farcs6$ ($\sim5$ kpc) from the
316: nucleus. The sharpness of the features in this northern offshoot, and the block-like appearance of the isophotes to the south-east
317: (PA$\approx15\degr$) of the nucleus provide evidence for a dust lane with a PA similar to the PA of the nuclear emission line and
318: continuum structures (e.g. Figure~\ref{fig:1549acs}d).
319:
320: On the large scale (Figure~\ref{fig:1549ls}) we can see extremely faint, diffuse emission that extends for $\sim6\farcs5$ (20 kpc) in
321: the east-west direction. The north-south extension, as noted by \citet{pandp83}, can be seen. This Figure shares similar features to the
322: deep Very Large Telescope Gunn $r$ image of H06 (their Figure~1). The authors note that the north-south extended features appear to
323: contain knots of emission. Here we can see point-like sources in similar positions to these knots, which could be foreground stars but may
324: also be super star clusters associated with the tidal tails of PKS1549-79.
325:
326: \section{PKS 1345+12}\label{1345}
327:
328: The radio source PKS 1345+12 has also had much previous work carried out on it. Again, a brief outline of its main properties will be
329: given before the new data are presented. Readers interested in a more thorough review are directed toward HTM03.
330:
331: PKS 1345+12 (4C 12.50) is one of the closest GPS sources. This allows the compact double jet and core structure, noted from VLBI (2cm)
332: and VLBA (6cm) radio observations, to present proportions of $\sim0\farcs15$. The more prominent S-shaped jet component extends to the
333: south-east before bending and expanding into a diffuse lobe. Protruding to the north-west of the core (the core being identified from the
334: relative flatness of the radio spectrum) weak radio emission is detected. On larger scales, diffuse radio emission is detected extending
335: 35\farcs0 ($\sim$80 kpc) to the north, and 25\farcs0 ($\sim$55 kpc) to the south \citep{stang05}.
336:
337: Optically, PKS 1345+12 shows a complex morphology characterized by two nuclei, the western most of which, identified as a 17.5(V)
338: magnitude elliptical, possessing an extended curved tail. Previous {\it HST} studies, which are unable to resolve structure down to the
339: scale of the radio morphology, have shown the western nucleus to be associated with the radio source \citep{axon00}. From the ACS data
340: presented here we find optical -- radio offsets (Table~\ref{tab:astro}) similar to those found by \citet{axon00}, which confirms the
341: western nucleus as the host of the radio source. The double nucleus and distorted appearance of PKS 1345+12 shows that a merger event is
342: taking place. As with the other source in this study, PKS 1345+12 shows a young stellar population \citep{tad05}, a FIR excess (ULIRG) and
343: near-UV emission \citep[][Labiano et al., in prep]{evans99}, indicating the presence of considerable star formation. Using optical
344: spectroscopy, HTM03 have observed 3 distinct nuclear kinematical components in PKS 1345+12, the narrowest of which
345: (FWHM$\approx340{\rm~km~s^{-1}}$) is interpreted as the systemic velocity. The two other components, designated ``intermediate'' and
346: ``broad'', show FWHM of $\sim1250{\rm~km~s^{-1}}$ and $\sim1950{\rm~km~s^{-1}}$ respectively, with corresponding blue-shifts of
347: $\sim400{\rm~km~s^{-1}}$ and $\sim1980{\rm~km~s^{-1}}$ with respect to the rest frame. Due to the reddening observed in each component,
348: it is proposed that the broad component originates from the inner most regions closest to the obscured quasar, whilst the narrow component
349: represents a quiescent halo.
350:
351: In Figure~\ref{fig:1345acs} we present the new ACS data for PKS 1345+12. In both the H$\alpha$ and [OIII] line and continuum images we
352: find the two separate nuclei clearly visible within an extended diffuse envelope. The $2\farcs0$ ($\sim5$ kpc) separation of the two
353: nuclei measured here is $\sim0\farcs1$ greater than the separation reported by \citet{heck86} and \citet{gands86}. The continuum
354: subtracted emission line images (Figures~\ref{fig:1345acs}c and f) show that an insignificant amount of line emission emanates from the
355: eastern component when compared to the western nucleus. To the north-west of this western nucleus there is an extended emission line
356: filament (e.g., Figures~\ref{fig:1345acs}a, c, d and f). Immediately north-east of the main nuclear structure there is a separate island
357: of [OIII] emission (see Figure~\ref{fig:1345acs}e) and a ``mushroom'' like morphology to the H$\alpha$ continuum (see
358: Figure~\ref{fig:1345acs}b); this is clear evidence of a dust lane running approximately south-east to north-west. On the larger scale we
359: can again compare this data to the findings of \citet{heck86}. Figure~\ref{fig:1345ls} highlights the distorted morphology and hints at
360: some of the south-west curved tail extensions mentioned by \citet{heck86}. We also see that the halo of PKS 1345+12 contains similar point
361: like sources (to the south of the eastern nucleus) to the foreground stars or possible star cluster seen around PKS 1549-79. Further study
362: has shown these sources to be super star cluster with young stellar populations \citep{rod06}.
363:
364: \section{Investigating the Dominant Mechanism}\label{dommech}
365:
366: In this section we closely examine the inner structures of the observed nuclei and determine the most likely position of the AGN in
367: the ACS emission line images (and therefore the likely position of the radio cores). Bi-conical structures will suggest that the outflows
368: are wind driven, whereas structures similar to the radio morphologies will suggest that the outflows are driven by the radio jets.
369: However, first we examine the relative astrometry in the ACS data in order to estimate the uncertainties in derived positions.
370:
371: \subsection{Relative Astrometry and Alignments}
372:
373: There are two elements that could contribute to differences between the spatial offsets of objects measured on the WFC1 and HRC
374: frames: the errors in measuring the positions themselves, i.e., true positions as related to measured positions, and the residual
375: errors in the correction of the spatial distortion by the pipeline reduction. By quantifying these errors we can estimate the astrometric
376: uncertainties present in the ACS images. An estimate of the residual distortion error can be gained from the relative positions of stellar
377: like objects present in both the WFC1 and HRC data. The errors in measuring the positions themselves can be minimized by averaging the
378: differences across as many objects as possible. We identified 7 stellar like objects common to the PKS 1549-79 data (the PKS 1345+12 field
379: is relatively empty) and centroided their positions. Each stellar object was then paired with the remaining six objects, and the offset
380: between the pairs were recorded (21 total offsets). The dispersion in the relative offsets between these objects in the WFC1 and HRC
381: images, which we adopt as our astrometric uncertainty, was found to be $\sim0\farcs03$.
382:
383: \begin{figure*}[t]
384: \plotone{f5.eps}
385: \caption[PKS 1549-79: Comparing with the radio morphology]{
386: PKS 1549-79: Comparing the ACS data with the radio morphology. On the left is the HRC continuum subtracted [OIII] emission line map with
387: a logarithmic stretch showing the very high surface brightness features. An ``X'' marks the position of the H$\alpha$ core and dotted lines
388: show the estimated astrometric error box. On the right we see an expanded view of the [OIII] emission (smoothed thick contours) overlaid
389: with the 2.3 GHz radio map (thin contours at 10, 20, 40, 80, 160, 320, 640 and 1280 mJy Beam$^{-1}$).
390: }\label{fig:1549rad}
391: \end{figure*}
392:
393: \begin{figure}[t]
394: \plotone{f6.eps}
395: \caption[PKS 1549-79: Comparing optical and radio position angles]{
396: PKS 1549-79: Comparing continuum subtracted [OIII] and radio position angles. In the top panel, positions of knots in the radio emission,
397: with respect to the radio core, are plotted as crosses and joined with a dashed line, while the PAs of ellipses fitted to the
398: [OIII] continuum subtracted emission are joined with a solid line. The PAs of the [OIII] continuum are plotted with open squares and
399: joined with a dotted line, the errors are omitted for clarity but are at the same level as for the [OIII] emission. The lower panel
400: shows the ellipticities of the [OIII] continuum subtracted emission line data.
401: }\label{fig:1549pas}
402: \end{figure}
403:
404: In addition to the astrometric uncertainties, the obscured nature of the central engines can be an added source of error for the relative
405: alignments of the AGN and radio cores; the measured peak in emission line flux may not correspond to the position of the AGN. In the
406: following two sections we will attempt to minimize this effect, however, for this process to be a significant source of error it must act
407: at a distance of $>0\farcs03$ (100 pc) from the estimated position of the central AGN.
408:
409: \subsection{PKS 1549-79}\label{sub1549}
410:
411: The very central region (1\farcs0) of PKS 1549-79 ([OIII] emission line) is presented in Figure~\ref{fig:1549rad}(a). We see a relatively
412: high surface brightness concentration to the north-east, with a lower surface brightness fan of emission extending toward the south-west.
413: Based on existing optical and near-IR spectra we do not expect to be able to detect the reddened AGN in the HRC [OIII] images. However,
414: we know from the modeling presented by H06 that the quasar nucleus should be detected in the H$\alpha$ continuum image. Therefore, we
415: have assumed that the centroid of the concentration of pixels at the center of the WFC1 H$\alpha$ continuum image gives the true quasar
416: position relative to the reference stars common to both the WFC1 and HRC fields. When translated to the HRC images the WFC1 position is
417: found to lie at the point marked with an ``X'' in Figure~\ref{fig:1549rad}(a). It is with this point that we align the radio core. The
418: estimated astrometric uncertainty is outlined with dotted lines ($\pm0\farcs03$).
419:
420: The radio map in panel (b) of Figure~\ref{fig:1549rad} (thin contours) is that presented by H06. The data were collected in 1988 at
421: $\sim3$ GHz using a the Southern Hemisphere VLBI Experiment, SHEVE \citep{pre84}. The beam size is $7.3\times2.7$ mas at a PA of 4.7\degr.
422: The western-most knot shows a flat spectrum across 2.3-8.4 GHz and is considered the core. The H$\alpha$ AGN position has subsequently
423: been aligned with this. A steep spectrum jet is seen to extend to the east at a PA of $\sim90\degr$. The jet bends through approximately
424: 60\degr, indicative of orientation change, and exhibits a gap which may be attributed to cyclic emission processes. H06 estimate an upper
425: limit of $i<55\degr$ for the inclination, with respect to the line of sight, for this jet.
426:
427: \begin{figure*}[t]
428: \plotone{f7.eps}
429: \caption[PKS 1345+12: Comparing with the radio morphology]{
430: PKS 1345+12: Comparing the ACS data with the radio morphology. On the left is the HRC continuum subtracted [OIII] emission line map with
431: a logarithmic stretch showing the very high surface brightness features. An ``X'' marks the position of the NIR core and dotted lines show
432: the estimated astrometric error box. On the right we see an expanded view of the [OIII] emission (smoothed thick contours) overlaid with the
433: 1.3 GHz radio map (thin contours at 7, 10, 16, 25, 37, 42 ... 766 mJy Beam$^{-1}$).
434: }\label{fig:1345rad}
435: \end{figure*}
436:
437: \begin{figure}[t]
438: \plotone{f8.eps}
439: \caption[PKS 1345+12: Comparing optical and radio position angles]{
440: PKS 1345+12: Comparing continuum subtracted [OIII], [OIII] continuum and radio position angles. As Figure~\ref{fig:1549pas} but for
441: PKS 1345+12.
442: }\label{fig:1345pas}
443: \end{figure}
444:
445: Figure~\ref{fig:1549rad}(b) also demonstrates the comparative morphologies between the radio structure (thin contours) and the [OIII]
446: emission (thick lines). The emission line map shows no evidence for bi-conical features. Ellipse fitting to the [OIII] data is presented
447: in Figure~\ref{fig:1549pas}, where the PAs of knots along the jet, with respect to the radio core, are also plotted. We see excellent
448: agreement between the [OIII] continuum and [OIII] emission line PAs. Similarity in the emission line and continuum morphology could be
449: attributed to dust obscuration, scattered AGN light \citep{tad92}, nebular continuum \citep{dic95}, or a mixture of all three.
450: In addition to the optical emission-continuum alignment, there is an overlap in the very inner regions between the radio structure and
451: the [OIII] emission. However, this radio-optical agreement deteriorates as the jet curves around. The jet also extends past the highest
452: surface brightness region of the [OIII] emission.
453:
454: \subsection{PKS 1345+12}\label{sub1345}
455:
456: The very central region of the western nucleus in PKS 1345+12 ([OIII] emission line) is presented in Figure~\ref{fig:1345rad}(a). A
457: north-west to south-east elongation is clearly apparent. As in the case of PKS 1549-79, we do not expect to be able to directly detect the
458: AGN in the [OIII] images, nor at optical wavelengths. However, we can assume that the quasar nucleus will be detected in the K-band.
459: Therefore, we have retrieved a NICMOS F222M image for this source from the {\it HST}
460: archive\footnote{\tt http://archive.stsci.edu/hst/search.php}. It was taken as part of programme \#7219 PI: Scoville, the finer details of
461: which are presented in \citet{scov00}. By determining the relative offset of the eastern nucleus with that of the western nucleus in both
462: the emission line images and the NIR, we can place a better constraint on the position of the radio core. Following this we have indicated
463: in Figure~\ref{fig:1345rad}(a) the position of the NIR peak with respect to the eastern nucleus on the HRC emission line map. It is here
464: we assume the radio core to fall.
465:
466: The radio map in panel (b) of Figure~\ref{fig:1345rad} (thin contours) is a 1.3 GHz map obtained from a global VLBI (HI) experiment
467: \citep{mor04} overlaid onto the smoothed contours of the HRC emission line map (thick lines). The radio data were collected in 2001 where
468: the beam size was $6.6\times1.2$ mas at a PA of -11\degr. The radio core has been identified at 5 GHz by \citet{stang97} from the
469: relatively flat spectrum. However, similar to the findings of \citet{xia02}, this core is not clearly defined in the 1.3 GHz map, and is
470: likely self absorbed. Therefore, in order to register the 1.3 GHz map (which shows more extended, lower surface brightness features than
471: the 5 GHz map) against the optical emission line images, we have aligned the 5 GHz map with the 1.3 GHz map based on the positions of the
472: southern components of the jet -- where optical depth effects are likely to be less of an issue. Then, knowing the true position of the
473: radio core in the 1.3 GHz map, we can place it onto the emission line image.
474:
475: Ellipse fitting to the [OIII] data is shown in Figure~\ref{fig:1345pas}. As radio emission is detected either side of the nucleus, we have
476: presented the PA of both the northern and southern jets with respect to the radio core, using knots in both the 1.3 and 5 GHz maps. We can
477: see that there is excellent agreement with the radio and [OIII] across a range of radii, but there is significant divergence as the jet
478: extends past the high surface brightness regions and begins to bend. As with PKS 1549-79, we can also see the excellent agreement between
479: the morphologies of the [OIII] continuum and emission line structures.
480:
481: \section{Discussions}\label{discussion}
482:
483: There are several features of these high resolution data that are common to both objects. In the first instance, there are strikingly
484: detailed similarities in the morphologies of the continuum and emission lines detected in the nuclear regions. For example, in both
485: objects the [OIII] continuum images are very similar to the detailed morphologies of the the [OIII] emission in terms of both alignment
486: and scale. This is particularly evident from Figures~\ref{fig:1549pas} and \ref{fig:1345pas}. Secondly, in both objects the relative
487: alignments in the PAs of the optical morphologies and radio knots follow the same pattern; close alignments in the inner regions and
488: increasing disparities at larger radii. In PKS 1549-79 the observed radio core is not exactly aligned with the [OIII] emission, it is
489: offset to the south-east. However, considering the estimated positional accuracy, this offset is not significant. We can see from
490: Figure~\ref{fig:1549pas} that the nuclear PAs of both the radio and optical data are consistent. In addition, the PAs fitted to the
491: nuclear isophotes of PKS 1345+12 compare remarkably well with PAs of the radio jet knots for a radius $<0\farcs04$
492: (Figure~\ref{fig:1345pas}). The isophotes also tentatively follow some of the radio structure, i.e., PAs change in tandem with the jet. In
493: both cases, nevertheless, the optical morphologies do not resemble the nature of the jet on larger scales ($>$0\farcs15). This is
494: consistent with the idea that the jets are being deflected at the location of the high surface brightness [OIII] emission.
495:
496: From inspection of Figures~\ref{fig:1549rad} and \ref{fig:1345rad} we find no evidence of bi-conical structures extending beyond the
497: radio jets. The ellipticities of isophotes fitted to the extended emission line data are low ($\sim$0.05). On the smallest scales
498: ($\sim0\farcs07$) there is also no evidence for bi-cones. Adding this observation to the de-coupling of the radio and optical
499: morphologies at radii greater than $\sim130$ pc means that we can rule out starburst wind driven outflows; the expected extent of
500: starburst winds \citep{ham90} are greater than the scales seen here.
501:
502: The close alignment of PAs between the radio and optical, in the inner regions, provides clear evidence for the relativistic radio jet
503: driven outflow mechanism. This would be consistent with the mechanism powering kilo-parsec and halo scale structures. However, the radio
504: structure does extend beyond main [OIII] structure and alignments are not exact on the larger scale. In addition, as mentioned above,
505: the continuum and emission lines show similar structures close to the nucleus. Coincident features such as these may be giving
506: us supplementary clues about the nuclear outflow mechanisms. If we first naively assume that the continuum is dominated by stars and the
507: emission lines are due mostly to gas, then it tells us the gas dynamics are currently consistent with the gravitational potential defined
508: by the stars. However, if the extended nuclear continuum is not stellar, but instead represents AGN-related continuum from the emission
509: line regions, then we may be observing nebular continuum or scattered AGN light. Finally, the nuclear morphologies of the continuum and
510: emission lines may be determined by uneven dust obscuration rather than AGN-related processes. This last case is considerably strong
511: considering the evidence for clear dust lanes in both PKS 1549-79 and PKS 1345+12.
512:
513: Unfortunately, in the light of this, it is difficult to unambiguously determine whether radiative winds from the AGN, or outflows induced
514: via the radio structures, dominate the driving mechanism. Further factors compound this problem. Even with the high spatial resolution of
515: ACS, there is the fact that the resolution is unfavorable for clearly seeing detailed associations between radio and optical features. The
516: problem is more acute if we consider the possible orientations of the small-scale bi-conical structures indicative of nuclear winds. There
517: is some debate as to the relative alignment to the line of sight for the jet in PKS 1345+12, however, an orientation close to end on is
518: favored for PKS 1549-79. In that case, the projection of the bi-cone would make resolving the feature especially difficult.
519:
520: \section{Conclusions}\label{cons}
521:
522: We have resolved the emission line outflow regions in two compact radio sources (PKS 1549-79 and PKS 1345+12) using the high resolution
523: channel of ACS. Through morphological comparisons with existing radio data we have investigated the possible driving mechanisms for the
524: observed nuclear outflows. These sources are ideal for this study as they are well known radio galaxies in which nuclear outflows have
525: been unequivocally detected. They also contain all of the possible driving mechanisms (jets, quasars and starbursts).
526:
527: In both cases we see good agreement with the radio and optical PAs and no evidence for the large scale bi-conical features
528: indicative of starburst driven winds; the emission line morphology shows similar structure and scales to that of the radio. We are thus
529: left with the conclusion that the outflows are most likely not driven by starburst winds. However, these ACS observations are unable to
530: clearly resolve the scales over which a compact nuclear structures may exist, especially if orientations to the line-of-sight are
531: considered. There is also an excellent agreement between the emission line and continuum morphology, which could be attributed to patchy
532: dust obscuration. In addition, while the kinematics do advocate shocks, the ionization mechanism is difficult to couple with shock
533: ionization. Radio jets and radiative AGN winds cannot be unambiguously distinguished as the dominant outflow mechanism.
534:
535: \acknowledgments
536:
537: We extend our thanks to Carlo Stanghellini, Istituto di Radioastronomia del C.N.R, Bologna, Italy, for supplying the 5 GHz radio data
538: for PKS 1345+12, and to Tasso Tzioumis, CSIRO Radiophysics Laboratory, Pembroke and Vimiera Rds, Marsfield, NSW, Australia, for
539: retrieving the radio data for PKS 1549-79 from Edward King's thesis. We also thank the anonymous referee for their useful comments.
540:
541: Support for Proposal number HST-GO-09401.10A was provided by NASA through a grant from the Space Telescope Science Institute, which is
542: operated by the Association of Universities for Research in Astronomy, Incorporated, under NASA contract NAS5-26555.
543:
544: \begin{thebibliography}{}
545:
546: \bibitem[Axon et al.(2000)]{axon00} Axon, D.~J., Capetti, A., Fanti, R., Morganti, R., Robinson, A., \& Spencer, R.\ 2000, \aj, 120, 2284
547: \bibitem[Baker et al.(2002)]{bak02} Baker, J.~C., Hunstead, R.~W., Athreya, R.~M., Barthel, P.~D., de Silva, E., Lehnert, M.~D., \&
548: Saunders, R.~D.~E.\ 2002, \apj, 568, 592
549: \bibitem[Balsara \& Krolik(1993)]{bk93} Balsara, D.~S., \& Krolik, J.~H.\ 1993, \apj, 402, 109
550: \bibitem[Bellamy et al.(2003)]{bell03} Bellamy, M.~J., Tadhunter, C.~N., Morganti, R., Wills, K.~A., Holt, J., Taylor, M.~D., \&
551: Watson, C.~A.\ 2003, \mnras, 344, L80
552: \bibitem[Bicknell, Dopita \& O'dea(1997)]{bdo97} Bicknell, G.~V., Dopita, M.~A., \& O'Dea, C.~P.~O.\ 1997, \apj, 485, 112
553: \bibitem[Bremer, Fabian \& Crawford(1997)]{bfandc97} Bremer, M.~N., Fabian, A.~C., \& Crawford, C.~S.\ 1997, \mnras, 284, 213
554: \bibitem[Carilli et al.(1994)]{car94} Carilli, C.~L., Perley, R.~A., \& Harris, D.~E.\ 1994, \mnras, 270, 173
555: \bibitem[Crenshaw et al.(2000)]{cren00} Crenshaw, D.~M., et al.\ 2000, \aj, 120, 1731
556: \bibitem[Dickson et al.(1995)]{dic95} Dickson, R., Tadhunter, C., Shaw, M., Clark, N., \& Morganti, R.\ 1995, \mnras, 273, L29
557: \bibitem[Dickson(1997)]{dick97} Dickson, R.\ 1997, Ph.D.~Thesis, University of Sheffield.
558: \bibitem[Evans et al.(1999)]{evans99} Evans, A.~S., Kim, D.~C., Mazzarella, J.~M., Scoville, N.~Z., \& Sanders, D.~B.\ 1999,
559: \apjl, 521, L107
560: \bibitem[Fabian et al.(2003)]{fab03} Fabian, A.~C., Sanders, J.~S., Allen, S.~W., Crawford, C.~S., Iwasawa, K., Johnstone, R.~M.,
561: Schmidt, R.~W., \& Taylor, G.~B.\ 2003, \mnras, 344, L43
562: \bibitem[Ferrarese \& Ford(2005)]{fandf05} Ferrarese, L., \& Ford, H.\ 2005, Space Science Reviews, 116, 523
563: \bibitem[Gallimore et al.(2006)]{gal06} Gallimore, J.~F., Axon, D.~J., O'Dea, C.~P., Baum, S.~A., \& Pedlar, A.\ 2006, \aj, 132, 546
564: \bibitem[Gilmore \& Shaw(1986)]{gands86} Gilmore, G., \& Shaw, M.~A. 1986, \nat, 321, 750
565: \bibitem[Heckman et al.(1986)]{heck86} Heckman, T.~M., Smith, E.~P., Baum, S.~A., van Breugel, W.~J.~M., Miley, G.~K., Illingworth,
566: G.~D., Bothun, G.~D., \& Balick, B. 1986, \apj, 311, 526
567: \bibitem[Heckman, Armus \& Miley(1990)]{ham90} Heckman, T.~M., Armus, L., \& Miley, G.~K.\ 1990, \apjs, 74, 833
568: \bibitem[Holt, Tadhunter \& Morganti(2003)]{htandm03} Holt, J., Tadhunter, C.~N., \& Morganti, R. 2003, \mnras, 342, 227
569: \bibitem[Holt et al.(2006)]{hol06} Holt, J., Tadhunter, C., Morganti, R., Bellamy, M., Gonz{\'a}lez Delgado, R.~M., Tzioumis, A.,
570: \& Inskip, K.~J.\ 2006, \mnras, 370, 1633
571: \bibitem[Johnston et al.(1995)]{john95} Johnston, K.~J., et al. 1995, \aj, 110, 880
572: \bibitem[King(1994)]{king94} King, E.~A. 1994, Ph.D.~Thesis, University of Tasmania.
573: \bibitem[Kinney et al.(2000)]{kin00} Kinney, A.~L., Schmitt, H.~R., Clarke, C.~J., Pringle, J.~E., Ulvestad, J.~S., \&
574: Antonucci, R.~R.~J.\ 2000, \apj, 537, 152
575: \bibitem[Koekemoer et al.(2002)]{koek02} Koekemoer, A.~M., Fruchter, A.~S., Hook, R.~N., \& Hack, W.\ 2002, The 2002 HST Calibration
576: Workshop, Proceedings of a STScI Workshop, 2002, p.339. eds. Arribas, Koekemoer and Whitmore.
577: \bibitem[Krolik \& Begelman(1986)]{kandb86} Krolik, J.~H., \& Begelman, M.~C.\ 1986, \apjl, 308, L55
578: \bibitem[Krongold et al.(2003)]{kron03} Krongold, Y., Nicastro, F., Brickhouse, N.~S., Elvis, M., Liedahl, D.~A., \& Mathur, S.
579: 2003, \apj, 597, 832
580: \bibitem[Lister et al.(2003)]{list03} Lister, M.~L., Kellermann, K.~I., Vermeulen, R.~C., Cohen, M.~H., Zensus, J.~A., \& Ros, E.
581: 2003, \apj, 584, 135
582: \bibitem[Morganti et al.(2001)]{morg01} Morganti, R., Oosterloo, T.~A., Tadhunter, C.~N., van Moorsel, G., Killeen, N., \&
583: Wills, K.~A.\ 2001, \mnras, 323, 331
584: \bibitem[Morganti et al.(2004)]{mor04} Morganti, R., Oosterloo, T.~A., Tadhunter, C.~N., Vermeulen, R., Pihlstr{\"o}m, Y.~M.,
585: van Moorsel, G., \& Wills, K.~A.\ 2004, \aap, 424, 119
586: \bibitem[Morganti, Tadhunter \& Oosterloo(2005)]{morg05} Morganti, R., Tadhunter, C.~N., \& Oosterloo, T.~A.\ 2005, \aap, 444, L9
587: \bibitem[Nulsen et al.(2002)]{nul02} Nulsen, P.~E.~J., David, L.~P., McNamara, B.~R., Jones, C., Forman, W.~R., \& Wise, M.\ 2002,
588: \apj, 568, 163
589: \bibitem[O'Dea(1998)]{odea98} O'Dea, C.~P.\ 1998, \pasp, 110, 493
590: \bibitem[O'Dea et al.(2002)]{ode02} O'Dea, C.~P., et al.\ 2002, \aj, 123, 2333
591: \bibitem[Prestage \& Peacock(1983)]{pandp83} Prestage, R.~M., \& Peacock, J.~A. 1983, \mnras, 204, 355
592: \bibitem[Preston et al.(1984)]{pre84} Preston, R.~A., et al.\ 1984, IAU Symp.~110: VLBI and Compact Radio Sources, 110, 67
593: \bibitem[Rodriguez Zaurin et al.(2006)]{rod06} Rodriguez Zaurin, J., Holt, J., Tadhunter, C.~N., \& Gonzalez Delgado, R.~M.\ 2006,
594: ArXiv Astrophysics e-prints, arXiv:astro-ph/0612578
595: \bibitem[Roy \& Norris(1997)]{randn97} Roy, A.~L., \& Norris, R.~P. 1997, \mnras, 289, 824
596: \bibitem[Scoville et al.(2000)]{scov00} Scoville, N.~Z., et al. 2000, \aj, 119, 991
597: \bibitem[Silk \& Rees(1998)]{sandr98} Silk, J., \& Rees, M.~J. 1998, \aap, 331, L1
598: \bibitem[Stanghellini et al.(1993)]{stang93} Stanghellini, C., O'Dea, C.~P., Baum, S.~A., \& Laurikainen, E. 1993, \apjs, 88, 1
599: \bibitem[Stanghellini et al.(1997)]{stang97} Stanghellini, C., O'Dea, C.~P., Baum, S.~A., Dallacasa, D., Fanti, R., \& Fanti, C.
600: 1997, \aap, 325, 943
601: \bibitem[Stanghellini et al.(2001)]{stang01} Stanghellini, C., Dallacasa, D., O'Dea, C.~P., Baum, S.~A., Fanti, R., \& Fanti, C.
602: 2001, \aap, 377, 377
603: \bibitem[Stanghellini et al.(2005)]{stang05} Stanghellini, C., O'Dea, C.~P., Dallacasa, D., Cassaro, P., Baum, S.~A., Fanti, R.,
604: \& Fanti, C.\ 2005, \aap, 443, 891
605: \bibitem[Tadhunter et al.(1992)]{tad92} Tadhunter, C.~N., Scarrott, S.~M., Draper, P., \& Rolph, C.\ 1992, \mnras, 256, 53P
606: \bibitem[Tadhunter et al.(1999)]{tad99} Tadhunter, C.~N., Packham, C., Axon, D.~J., Jackson, N.~J., Hough, J.~H., Robinson, A.,
607: Young, S., \& Sparks, W. 1999, \apjl, 512, L91
608: \bibitem[Tadhunter et al.(2001)]{tad01} Tadhunter, C., Wills, K., Morganti, R., Oosterloo, T., \& Dickson, R. 2001, \mnras, 327, 227
609: \bibitem[Tadhunter et al.(2005)]{tad05} Tadhunter, C., Robinson, T.~G., Gonz{\'a}lez Delgado, R.~M., Wills, K., \& Morganti, R.\
610: 2005, \mnras, 356, 480
611: \bibitem[Veilleux(2004)]{veil04} Veilleux, S. 2004, Astronomical Society of the Pacific Conference Series, 320, 277, eds.
612: Aalto et al.
613: \bibitem[Wyithe \& Loeb(2003)]{wandl03} Wyithe, J.~S.~B., \& Loeb, A. 2003, \apj, 595, 614
614: \bibitem[Xiang et al.(2002)]{xia02} Xiang, L., Stanghellini, C., Dallacasa, D., \& Haiyan, Z.\ 2002, \aap, 385, 768
615: \end{thebibliography}
616:
617: \end{document}
618:
619: %%
620: %% End of file `ms.tex'.
621: