1: %\documentclass{aastex}
2: \documentclass[12pt,preprint]{aastex}
3:
4: \newcommand{\etal}{{et al.}\ }
5: \newcommand{\eg}{{e.g.,}\ }
6: \newcommand{\ie}{{i.e.,}\ }
7: %\usepackage[]{color}
8:
9: \shorttitle{Ca Variations in G29-38}
10: \shortauthors{von Hippel \& Thompson}
11:
12: \begin{document}
13:
14: \title{Discovery of Photospheric Calcium Line Strength Variations in the
15: DAZd White Dwarf G29-38}
16:
17: \author{Ted von Hippel\altaffilmark{1,2} and Susan E. Thompson\altaffilmark{3}}
18:
19: \altaffiltext{1}{Department of Astronomy, University of Texas at Austin, 1
20: University Station C1400, Austin, TX 78712-0259, USA;
21: ted@astro.as.utexas.edu}
22: \altaffiltext{2}{Visiting Scientist, Southwest Research Institute,
23: 1050 Walnut St., Suite 400 Boulder, CO 80302}
24: \altaffiltext{3}{The Colorado College, 14 E. Cache La Poudre, Colorado
25: Springs, CO 80903}
26:
27: \begin{abstract}
28:
29: Metals in the photospheres of white dwarfs with $T_{\rm eff}$ between
30: 12,000 and 25,000 K should gravitationally settle out of these atmospheres
31: in 1--2 weeks. Temporal variations in the line strengths of these
32: metals could provide a direct measurement of episodic metal accretion.
33: Using archival VLT and Keck spectroscopy, we find evidence that the
34: DAZd white dwarf G29-38 shows significant changes in its Ca II K line
35: strength. At the two best-observed epochs, we find that the Ca line
36: equivalent width (EW) = 165 $\pm$ 4 m\AA\ (in 1996.885) and 280 $\pm$
37: 8 m\AA\ (in 1999.653), which is an increase of 70\%. We consider the
38: effect that pulsation has on the Ca EWs for this known variable star,
39: and find that it adds an error of $<$ 1 m\AA\ to these measurements.
40: Calcium line strengths at other observational epochs support variations
41: with timescales as short as two weeks. These Ca EW variations indicate
42: that the metal accretion process in G29-38, presumably from its debris
43: disk, is episodic on timescales of a few weeks or less, and thus the
44: accretion is not dominated by Poynting-Robertson drag from an optically
45: thin, continuous disk, which has a timescale of $\sim1$ year.
46:
47: \end{abstract}
48:
49: \keywords{accretion, accretion disks --- stars: individual (G29-39) --- white dwarfs}
50:
51: \section{Introduction}
52:
53: The presence of Ca, Mg, Fe, or other heavy elements in the photospheres
54: of hydrogen-dominated (DA) white dwarfs (WDs) poses a long-standing
55: problem. The high surface gravities of WDs cause their atmospheres to
56: become highly stratified and theory predicts that these heavy elements
57: will settle on timescales of $10^{-2}$ to $10^6$ years \citep{DFP92,
58: KW06}, depending on the mass and surface temperature of the white dwarf.
59: Yet most WDs are old, and almost every known DAZ, as these stars are now
60: called \citep{SGL83}, has been cooling as a WD for at least $10^8$ years,
61: and usually $10^9$ years or more. The timescale problem is less extreme
62: for metals in the rarer helium-dominated (DB) white dwarfs, since the
63: depletion of metals due to diffusion at the bottom of the He-convection
64: zone is slower than at the bottom of the H-convection zone and since the
65: higher transparency of helium atmospheres makes lower metal abundances
66: more visible.
67:
68: Heavy elements have been known in WD atmospheres for almost 50
69: years \citep[in the DB vMa 2;][]{W58}, though the first convincing
70: demonstration of metals in a DA was not until \cite{LWF83}. It took
71: another 14 years to find the second and third DAZs \citep{KPS97, HBG97}.
72: The DAZ sample then began to grow with the breakthrough survey of
73: \cite{ZR98}, which yielded seven to nine new DAZs. Subsequent modern
74: surveys \citep[\eg][]{ZKR03} have shown that $\sim$25\% of all single DAs
75: possess metals in their photospheres. On the theoretical side, early work
76: focused on understanding how WDs might accrete sufficient material from
77: the interstellar medium (ISM) to maintain metals in their atmospheres.
78: Some researchers \citep{DFW93, KW06} concluded that ISM accretion
79: is the source of the photospheric metals, while other researchers
80: \citep{AKH93, ZR98, ZKR03, KR07} concluded that ISM accretion is
81: insufficient. An alternative hypothesis, that DAZs accrete their metals
82: from circumstellar material, has gone from an intriguing possibility
83: based on just one DAZ with a debris disk \citep[G29-38,][]{ZB87}, to a
84: compelling scenario, especially now that five debris disk white dwarfs
85: are known, all of which happen to be DAZs \citep{BFJ05, KvHL05, KvHL06,
86: vHKK07, KR07}. These DAZs with debris disks are now known as DAZd white
87: dwarfs \citep{vHKK07}. The newly discovered debris disk WDs, the high
88: relative frequency of DAZs and their plausible connection to circumstellar
89: debris \citep[\eg][]{J03}, as well as new catalogs of DAZs \citep{ZKR03,
90: KRN05}, have created new opportunities to understand the origin of DAZs
91: and their accretion processes.
92:
93: In this paper we study archival time-series spectroscopy from multiple
94: epochs of the luminosity variable DAZ white dwarf G29-38 (=WD2326+049).
95: The case for Ca line strength variations in G29-38 is complicated since
96: this star is a pulsating WD. The parameters for G29-38 are $T_{\rm eff}$
97: = 12100, log(g) = 7.9, log(Ca/H) = $-6.8$ \citep{KRN05}, distance =
98: 19 pc \citep{HD80}, or log(g) = 8.14 \citep{BWL95}. The timescale for
99: gravitational settling in this star is 7 days according to \cite{KW06},
100: shorter for the higher log(g) of \cite{BWL95}, and therefore Ca line
101: strength variations are plausible. After accounting for the effects of
102: pulsation, we find clear evidence that the Ca II K line strength varies
103: in this star. Metal line strength variability is a new tool for the
104: study of accretion onto WDs and it may eventually help us unravel the
105: source(s) of metals found in DAZ atmospheres.
106:
107:
108: \section{Observations}
109:
110: Both \cite{vKCW00} and \cite{TvKC07} published time-series spectroscopy
111: of G29-38 in order to measure the spherical degree of pulsation modes
112: via line shape variations of the Balmer series. We use these spectra to
113: measure the Ca II K line strength present in this star. On November 19,
114: 1996, \cite{vKCW00} obtained 4.72 hours of continuous (no readout gaps)
115: 12s exposures of G29-38 with the Low Resolution Imaging Spectrometer on
116: the Keck II Telescope. The resolution was set by the seeing to be $\sim7$
117: \AA, and the average spectrum has a signal-to-noise of 1000 measured
118: at the continuum near 5000 \AA. For the same purposes, on August 27,
119: 1999, \cite{TvKC07} obtained 6.14 hours of continuous spectroscopy with
120: the FORS1 spectrograph on the VLT \citep[see also][]{T06}. Each of the
121: 604 spectra has an exposure time of 16~s and a resolution of $\sim8$
122: \AA. The average spectrum has a signal-to-noise of 500 measured at
123: the continuum near 5000 \AA. \cite{T06} and \cite{TvKC07} performed
124: standard reductions on both sets of data, except that flat fields and
125: traditional flux calibrations were not possible for either dataset.
126: In both cases the average spectra are visibly smooth near 4000 \AA, and
127: we have determined that the lack of flat-fields has a negligible effect
128: on our EW measurements. In both datasets, the Ca II 3933 \AA\ line is
129: clearly visible, a fact that we utilize to demonstrate EW variations
130: between these two observations.
131:
132: \section{Calcium Equivalent Width Measurements}
133:
134: In Figure 1 we present the average Ca II K line region of G29-38 at
135: two epochs, 1996.885 and 1999.653. The average spectrum taken with the
136: Keck telescope in 1996 shows an obvious Ca II K line with EW = 165 $\pm$
137: 4 m\AA. The average spectrum taken with the VLT in 1999 shows a deeper
138: Ca line with EW = 280 $\pm$ 8 m\AA, an increase of 70\%. Formally, these
139: two observations differ by 12.9 $\sigma$. Each are measured by fitting
140: a Gaussian to the spectral line and the errors are those associated with
141: that fit.
142:
143: We need to ensure that the pulsations of G29-38, which produce brightness
144: variations as high as 3\% for a single pulsation, are not responsible for
145: the changes in Ca line strength. The pulsating modes cause changes in
146: surface temperature and radial velocity fields, both of which can alter
147: the measured absorption lines. Since the 1996 and 1999 data sets are
148: time series of spectra, we measure how the EW changes over the pulsation
149: cycle and how this change is reduced by integrating over the extended
150: periods of the Keck and VLT observations. Using these measurements,
151: we demonstrate (see below) that the pulsations have a negligible effect
152: compared to the observed 70\% change in EW of the average spectra.
153:
154: We measured the equivalent width for each spectrum of both the Keck and
155: VLT data sets by fitting a Gaussian to the calcium line after normalizing
156: the spectra. We fit an 8th-order polynomial across 20 \AA\ on each side
157: of the Ca II K line of the average spectrum. We removed the curvature
158: induced by the broad hydrogen lines on either side of the Ca line by
159: dividing each spectrum by this fit to the average. These flattened
160: spectra were normalized as we fit the Gaussian function by allowing the
161: overall flux of the spectrum to vary during the fit. During the fit,
162: the area and FWHM of the Gaussian were allowed to vary.
163:
164: We performed a Fourier Transform (FT) on the time-series Ca EW
165: measurements (Figure 2). These FTs provide a clear indication of how
166: much the line strength can change during a single observing run due to
167: pulsation effects. The EW FTs clearly show that the pulsations are
168: stronger during the Keck epoch. The flux amplitude of the largest
169: observed pulsation (measured at 615s) in the VLT data is 2.7\%
170: \citep{TvKC07} while the largest mode (measured at 614s) in the Keck
171: data is 3.17\% \citep{vKCW00}. Therefore, one would expect the Keck
172: observations to exhibit larger variations in Ca equivalent width.
173: The equivalent width amplitude of these largest flux modes are 7.1\%
174: and 13.8\%, with the Keck amplitude being 1.9 times larger than the
175: VLT amplitude. See Table 1 for the amplitude of the EW variations
176: measured at the dominant modes in each data set. Finally, we calculate
177: the average value of the measured equivalent widths, weighted by the
178: errors established from fitting the Gaussian. The values 167 $\pm$
179: 1.7 m\AA\ for the Keck epoch and 272 $\pm$ 1.9 m\AA\ for the VLT epoch
180: (an increase in 63\%) are in close agreement with the equivalent width
181: of the unweighted average spectrum.
182:
183: The pulsations cause deviations from the average equivalent width.
184: Observing an incomplete cycle of a dominant pulsation can result in an
185: abnormally high or low measurement of the average EW. To determine how
186: large this effect could be, we calculated a worst case for this star.
187: This worst case provides an outer bounds for our data set (useful for our
188: error analyses, below) and should help future observers who wish to repeat
189: this experiment with G29-38, possibly with long exposures that do not
190: resolve the pulsation modes. We combined six modes with semi-amplitude
191: (mean to maximum) EW variations of 8, 12, and 15\% (2 each) and we
192: chose periods from 1150 to 600 seconds based on previous observations
193: (see Figure 3 for the specific modes). Since the modes of G29-38 vary in
194: strength with time, this allows for maximal pulsations (which are larger
195: amplitude modes than we actually observed in the Keck and VLT data).
196: This approach also encompasses the possibility of observing a few large
197: amplitude modes along with a few moderate amplitude modes. Figure 3
198: shows the possible range of EW values in percentage terms ((max EW - min
199: EW) / mean EW) due to only partial averaging over pulsation modes, as a
200: function of cumulative exposure times. For an extremely short exposure
201: time, we could observe an EW difference as large as $\sim$100\% given the
202: semi-amplitudes of the modes introduced in this example. After one hour
203: of cumulative exposure, the maximum expected EW difference due to the
204: pulsation modes of this star drop to 5\%. After 3.5 hours this effect
205: is $<$ 1.5\%.
206:
207: Since the VLT and Keck spectra are time series, we know the size of the Ca
208: EW variations and can better estimate the error associated with partial
209: averaging. Including only the three largest pulsations of the Keck data
210: and averaging over a total of 4.7 hours spaced in 24s intervals (identical
211: to the Keck observations), we find a deviation of less than 0.3\% in
212: the EW. This translates to at most an additional error of 0.5 m\AA\
213: and 0.8 m\AA\ for the Keck and VLT measurements, respectively. This is
214: equivalent to one third of the error in the weighted average and one
215: tenth of the error from fitting the average spectrum. We conclude that
216: partial averaging over the pulsations cannot account for the observed 70\%
217: variation between the measured Ca EW in 1996 at Keck and 1999 at the VLT.
218:
219: In summary, we find that the EW of Ca increased by 63-70\% between
220: 1996.885 and 1999.653. The difference between these two estimates
221: is likely dominated by subtle differences in how we measure EWs, and
222: this range is a useful estimate of the accuracy in the measured change
223: in Ca EWs. Only a negligible amount of this 63-70\% change is due to
224: residual, unaccounted-for pulsation effects.
225:
226: Besides these two epochs with time-series spectroscopy, we were able to
227: derive Ca EWs for nine additional spectra of G29-38, kindly provided to
228: us by D. Koester. Two spectra of 30 minute duration each were observed
229: with the Calar Alto 2.2m Cassegrain spectrograph on September 18 and 20,
230: 1995. These spectra were the source of the discovery by \cite{KPS97}
231: that G29-38 is a DAZ. Due to the temporal proximity of the Calar Alto
232: observations, we averaged together the spectra before measuring the
233: Ca EW. This averaging also decreased the spectral noise and reduced the
234: pulsation error. Five spectra of 30 minute duration each were observed
235: with Keck, one on the night of July 7, 1997, one on the night of December
236: 10, 1998, and three on the night of August 12, 1999. To increase the
237: signal-to-noise for August 12, 1999, we averaged together the spectra
238: from this night before measuring the Ca EW. Two additional spectra of
239: 5 minute duration were obtained at VLT/UVES on the nights of August 6,
240: 2000 and September 17, 2000. Further details on the observations and data
241: quality for these spectra can be found in \cite{KNC01}, \cite{KRN05},
242: and \cite{ZKR03}. From these nine additional spectra we derive Ca
243: EWs at six additional epochs. All of these measured Ca EWs, as well
244: as the two derived from the time-series spectroscopy discussed above,
245: are presented in Figure 4. The error bars represent the 1 $\sigma$
246: quadrature combination of the Ca EW measurement uncertainty and the
247: expected EW variation caused by sampling over partial luminosity periods.
248: Figure 3 represents the maximum observed error from partial averaging
249: and thus we use these values as a 3$\sigma$ estimate for this error for
250: all epochs except the two discussed above, where we directly measure
251: the amplitude of the pulsation modes.
252:
253: \section{The Source of Calcium Line Strength Variations}
254:
255: Since G29-38 has a debris disk known to be rich in refractory elements
256: \citep{RKvH05}, it is natural to assume that the Ca variations we see
257: are due to time-variable accretion from the disk. There is, however,
258: another possibility worth considering---that this object has a large
259: star spot that covers more or less of the observed face of G29-38 at the
260: different observational epochs. Such star spots models have been proposed
261: before to explain variations in He line strength in three WDs with mixed
262: H/He atmospheres, G104-27 \citep{KHB92}, PG1210+533 \citep{BWB94}, and
263: HS0209+0832 \citep{HNL97}. For a model of G29-38 with steady-state
264: accretion and a magnetically constrained star spot, the spot could either
265: be enriched in Ca with respect to the rest of the star if accretion
266: occurs within the spot, or it could be depleted in Ca if accretion occurs
267: elsewhere. Since the variation in Ca EW is nearly a factor of two (Fig.\
268: 4), even in a model with dramatically different Ca abundances within
269: and outside the spot, the spot would have to cover nearly half of a WD
270: hemisphere. It seems unlikely that such a spot could persist for years,
271: particularly for this pulsating WD with pulsations sloshing across the
272: surface every few minutes. A prediction of the star spot model is that
273: the Ca EW should be modulated on the timescale of the rotation period.
274: This effect would be particularly apparent with observations covering two
275: or more rotation periods. G29-38 appears to be rotating with v sin(i) =
276: 11--28 km s$^{-1}$ \citep{BKN05}, or a period of $\leq$ 900--2400 s or
277: 2000--5000 s, assuming a radius consistent with log(g) = 8.14 or 7.9,
278: respectively. Our VLT and Keck time-series observations cover 4.72 and
279: 6.14 hours, so if the star spot model were correct, the rotation period
280: would have to be meaningfully longer than 6 hours, which is inconsistent
281: with the measured rotation velocity. In summary, we consider the star
282: spot scenario highly unlikely, yet future observations with better
283: temporal sampling will be needed to convincingly rule it out.
284:
285: The history of Ca EWs in G29-38 presented in Figure 4 shows that the
286: Ca line strength varies by at least a factor of two, that significant
287: variations occur on timescales as short as 15 days (August 12, 1999 to
288: August 27, 1999), and possibly that there is a typical Ca EW $\approx$
289: 230 m\AA\ with periods of both higher and lower Ca line strength.
290: Assuming that the Ca EW variations are caused by time-variable accretion
291: from G29-38's debris disk, the low Ca EW in late 1996 indicates
292: that accretion decreased dramatically for at least one settling time
293: \citep[expected to be $\sim$ 7 days;][]{KW06}. The variations in August
294: 1999 similarly indicate an increased accretion rate with a timescale of
295: $\sim$ 2 settling times. Further observations and analysis are required
296: for this star in order to determine the minimum timescale and range for
297: accretion events, as well as to observationally test the theoretical
298: gravitational settling time.
299:
300: We note also that D. Koester kindly searched through multiple spectra of
301: 24 DAZs from the SPY survey \citep{NCD01, KRN05} for us in order to search
302: for other WDs with varying Ca EWs. He found no other convincing cases.
303: Perhaps a larger sample of stars or more spectra per star are needed.
304: In any case, further examples besides G29-38 would help clarify whether
305: episodic accretion is a function of other system parameters and would
306: help test the theoretically determined residence timescale for metals
307: in DAZ atmospheres.
308:
309: \section{Conclusions}
310:
311: We find that the Ca II K line in G29-38 varies from EW = 165 $\pm$ 4
312: m\AA\ in 1996.885 to EW = 280 $\pm$ 8 m\AA\ in 1999.653, or a factor
313: of $\sim 1.7 \times$ between these two epochs. Fully taking into
314: account variations in G29-38's EW due to sampling effects over its
315: multi-period pulsations, we find that the EW variations are essentially
316: unaffected over these 4.72 hour and 6.14 hour time-series observations.
317: We also measure Ca EWs in this star for a further six epochs and find
318: convincing evidence that the Ca line changes on timescales as short as
319: 15 days. These Ca line-strength variations indicate that the source
320: of the variations, presumably metal accretion from the debris disk,
321: is not a steady-state process and varies on timescales of a few weeks.
322: Observations with greater temporal sampling are required to determine
323: the timescale range of G29-38's episodic accretion.
324:
325: Our Ca EW measurements may already provide insight into the physics
326: governing accretion onto this star. For instance, if accretion is
327: dominated by Poynting-Robertson (P-R) drag from the known debris disk,
328: then the dust accretion timescale is $4 r^2 a$ years \citep{RKvH05},
329: where $r$ is the particle distance in solar radii and $a$ is the particle
330: radius in microns. Spitzer mid-IR spectroscopy \citep{RKvH05} indicates
331: sub-micron silicate particles. With an inner debris disk edge at $\leq$
332: 0.15 $R_{\sun}$ \citep{vHKK07}, the P-R timescale at the inner disk edge
333: is $\leq$ 33 days, consistent with the Ca EW variations, especially if
334: whatever process feeds dust to the inner disk edge is discontinuous.
335: This scenario argues against an optically thin (in the radial direction)
336: debris disk extending continuously to 1 $R_{\sun}$ or beyond. Comparing
337: these timescales indicates that G29-38's debris disk is likely to be
338: optically thick with collisional processes or dust delivery radially
339: through an optically thick disk setting the accretion timescale.
340:
341: Due to the short settling times of metals in their atmospheres, warm
342: ($T_{\rm eff}$ = 12,000--25,000~K) DAZs are an excellent place to look
343: for Ca (or other metal) line strength variations. Will other DAZs that
344: harbor debris disks show Ca line strength variations? And if so, will
345: the timescale or range of these variations be correlated with any of
346: the debris disk properties? Will DAZs without detectable debris disks
347: show Ca line strength variations? Answers to these questions will help
348: us understand the accretion process operating in these systems and
349: possibly give us clues to the origins of white dwarf surface metals.
350: Additionally, the timescale of metal line strength variations as
351: a function of stellar effective temperature would provide the first
352: observational test of the theoretically determined residence timescale
353: for metals in DAZ atmospheres.
354:
355: \acknowledgments
356: We thank Detlev Koester for his many excellent spectra of G29-38, and for
357: considerable consultation on WD models and this paper. We thank Marten
358: van Kerkwijk for his reductions of the Keck data and Mike Montgomery
359: for helpful discussions. We thank our referee, Ralf Napiwotzki, for his
360: insights and for comments that improved the presentation. TvH gratefully
361: acknowledges support as a visiting scientist from the Southwest Research
362: Institute. This material is based upon work supported by the National
363: Aeronautics and Space Administration under Grant No.\ NAG5-13070 issued
364: through the Office of Space Science.
365:
366: \bibliography{apjmnemonic,references}
367: \bibliographystyle{apj}
368:
369: \clearpage
370:
371: %Table 1
372: \begin{deluxetable}{lcc}
373: \tablewidth{0pt}
374: \tablecaption{EW Variations for Different Periods in the Keck and VLT Data.}
375: \tablehead{
376: \colhead{period} & \colhead{Amp (m\AA)} & \colhead{Amp (\%)} \\
377: \phantom{123} (1) & \phantom{1} (2) & (3) }
378: %
379: \startdata
380: %
381: Keck (1996.885) &&\\
382: 614.25 & 23 $\pm$ 3 & 13.81 $\pm$ 1.8 \\
383: 817.66 & 18 $\pm$ 3 & 10.03 $\pm$ 1.8 \\
384: 653.08 & 5 $\pm$ 3 & 2.95 $\pm$ 1.8 \\
385: 775.97 & 10 $\pm$ 3 & 5.24 $\pm$ 1.8 \\
386: VLT (1999.653) &&\\
387: 615.371 & 20 $\pm$ 4 & 7.1 $\pm$ 1.4 \\
388: 810.759 & 20 $\pm$ 4 & 7.4 $\pm$ 1.4 \\
389: 835.283 & 17 $\pm$ 4 & 6.2 $\pm$ 1.4 \\
390: 353.469 & 1 $\pm$ 4 & 0.4 $\pm$ 1.4 \\
391: %
392: \enddata
393: \tablerefs{We fit the series of EW measurements with periods found by
394: \cite{vKCW00} and by \cite{TvKC07} for the Keck and VLT observations,
395: respectively. We present the amplitude of the changing EWs in
396: milli-{\AA}ngstroms and in percentages. The errors represent the formal
397: errors from the fits.}
398: \end{deluxetable}
399:
400: \clearpage
401:
402: % Figure 1
403: \begin{figure}[!t]
404: \plotone{f1.eps} %= plotone{avespec.ps}
405: \figcaption{The Ca line region in G29-38 at two different epochs,
406: 1996.885 and 1999.653. The data are the averaged, normalized spectra.}
407: \end{figure}
408:
409: % Figure 2
410: \begin{figure}[!t]
411: \plotone{f2.eps} %= \plotone{fts.ps}
412: \figcaption{Fourier Transforms of the Ca EWs from the 1996.885 Keck
413: spectroscopy and the 1999.653 VLT spectroscopy.}
414: \end{figure}
415:
416: % Figure 3
417: \begin{figure}[!t]
418: \plotone{f3.eps} %= \plotone{maxdifftime.ps}
419: \figcaption{The maximum expected contribution of pulsations to EW
420: variations for G29-38 as a function of the cumulative exposure time.}
421: \end{figure}
422:
423: % Figure 4
424: \begin{figure}[!t]
425: \vspace*{-12mm}
426: \plotone{f4.eps}
427: \figcaption{Calcium EW measurements for G29-38 at eight epochs over a
428: five year period from three telescopes. The error bars are a quadrature
429: addition of the uncertainty in the EW measurement and the expected
430: variation due to sampling effects. Both error contributions decrease
431: with longer exposures.}
432: \end{figure}
433:
434: \end{document}
435: