1: \begin{abstract}

2: Recently the Casimir self-entropy of an electromagnetic $\delta$-function 

3: shell was considered by two different groups, with apparently discordant 

4: conclusions, although

5: both had concluded that a region of negative entropy existed for sufficiently

6: weak coupling.  We had found that the entropy contained an infrared divergence,

7:  which we argued should be discarded on physical grounds.  On the contrary, 

8: Bordag and Kirsten recently found a completely finite self-entropy, although 

9: they, in fact, have to remove an infrared divergence.  Apart from this, the

10: high- and low-temperature results for finite coupling agree precisely for 

11: the transverse electric mode, but there are significant discrepancies in the 

12: transverse magnetic  mode.  We resolve those 

13: discrepancies here.  In particular, it is shown that coupling-independent terms

14: do not occur  in  a consistent regulated calculation, 

15: they likely being an artefact of the omission of pole terms.

16: %frequency, unregulated treatment. 

17: The results of our previous analysis, especially, the existence of a negative 

18: entropy region for sufficiently weak coupling,  are therefore confirmed.  

19: Finally, we offer some analogous remarks concerning the Casimir entropy of a 

20: thin electromagnetic sheet, where the total entropy is always positive.

21:  In that case, the origin of the analogous discrepancy can

22: be explicitly isolated.

23: \end{abstract}

24: