1: \begin{abstract}

2: We prove that the Boltzmann-Grad limit of the Lo- rentz gas with periodic distribution of scatterers

3: cannot be described with a linear Boltzmann equation. This is at variance with the case of a Poisson

4: distribution of scatterers, for which the convergence to the linear Boltzmann equation was proved

5: by Gallavotti [{\it Phys. Rev. (2)} {\bf 185}, 308 (1969)]. The arguments presented here complete

6: the analysis in [Golse-Wennberg, {\it M2AN Mod\'el. Math. et Anal. Num\'er.} {\bf 34}, 1151 (2000)],

7: where the impossibility of a kinetic description was established only in the case of absorbing

8: obstacles. The proof is based on estimates on the distribution of free-path lengths established in

9: [Golse-Wennberg {\it loc.cit.}] and in [Bourgain-Golse-Wennberg, {\it Commun. Math. Phys.} {\bf 190},

10: 491 (1998)], and on a classical result on the spectrum of the linear Boltzmann equation which can be

11: found in [Ukai-Point-Ghidouche, {\it J. Math. Pures Appl. (9)} {\bf 57}, 203 (1978)].

12: \end{abstract}

13: