1: \documentstyle[preprint,aps]{revtex}
2:
3: \begin{document}
4: \title
5: {The Ising Transition in the double-frequency sine-Gordon model}
6: \author{Fei Ye\hspace{1.0cm}Guo-Hui Ding\hspace{1.0cm}Bo-Wei Xu}
7: \address
8: {Department of Physics, Shanghai Jiao Tong University, Shanghai 200030,China} \date{\today}
9: \draft
10: \maketitle
11: \begin{abstract}
12: In the present paper we utilize the renormalization group(RG) technique to analyse the
13: Ising critical behavior in the double frequency sine-Gordon model. The one-loop RG equations
14: obtained show unambiguously that there exist two Ising critical points besides the trivial
15: Gaussian fixed point. The topology of the RG flows is obtained as well.
16: \end{abstract}
17:
18: \newpage
19: \narrowtext
20: The sine-Gordon(SG) model plays an important role in the condensed matter physics
21: since many one-dimensional physical system can be mapping onto it. The SG hamiltonian
22: can be written as a Gaussian model of a scalar field $\phi$ perturbed by a vertex
23: operator $\cos\beta\phi$, which has the form
24: \begin{equation}
25: {\cal H}_{SG}={\cal H}_{Gauss}+g'\cos\beta\phi\;\label{SG}
26: \end{equation}
27: \begin{equation}
28: {\cal H}_{Gauss}={1\over 2}\pi^2+{1\over 2}(\partial_x\phi)^2\;\label{Gauss}
29: \end{equation}
30: with coupling constant $g'$. As well known, for $\beta^2>8\pi$, the perturbation is
31: irrelevant and the system is gapless, and for $0<\beta^2<8\pi$, the vertex operator
32: becomes relevant and drive the system to a strong-coupling massive phase with a
33: mass gap $m\sim g^{4\pi/(8\pi-\beta^2)}$\cite{Tsvelik}.
34:
35: Recently, the double-frequency sine-Gordon(DSG) model has received much attention
36: which is the SG model subjected to another vertex operator
37: \begin{equation}
38: {\cal H}_{DSG}={\cal H}_{Gauss}+g'\cos\beta\phi+\lambda'\cos{\beta\over 2}\phi\;\label{DSG}.
39: \end{equation}
40: This model was found to display an Ising criticality with central charge $c=1/2$ on a quantum
41: critical line $\lambda'=\lambda'_c(g)$(quasi-classically $\lambda'_c(g)=4g'$) by Delfino and
42: Mussardo\cite{Delfino}. They also argued that this Ising transition is a universal property
43: of the DSG model\cite{Delfino} as long as $\beta^2<8\pi$. Fabrizio ${\it et.al}$ investigated
44: in detail the critical properties of this transition by mapping the DSG model onto the deformed
45: quantum Ashkin-Teller(DAT) model. Under a new representation of the DAT model, they succeeded
46: in identifying those degrees of freedom that become critical, and they also discussed the
47: application of the Ising transition in some physical realization of the DSG model.
48:
49: In this letter, we shall give the renormalization group(RG) analysis of the Ising criticality
50: in the DSG model. In the following, we assume that $32\pi/9<\beta^2<8\pi$, so that both the
51: vertex operators in Eq.(\ref{DSG}) are relevant and no other relevant operators are generated
52: upon renormalization. It is clear that both these two vertex operators will make the theory
53: fully massive, if acting alone. However if they coexist, it will become gapless on some critical
54: line. The RG equations obtained explore this feature in an explicit way
55: and give the RG flows in the coupling parameters plane, in which
56: there exist three fixed points to the RG equations including
57: the trivial Gaussian fixed point and two non-trivial Ising fixed points.
58:
59: To construct the one loop RG equations, we employ the formalism in Refs.\cite{Cardy1,Cardy2}
60: which is based on the operator product expansion(OPE) in real space.
61: Firstly, we replace the coupling constants $g'$ and $\lambda'$ by
62: the dimensionless bare coupling constants $g=a^{\Delta_g-2}g'$ and $\lambda=a^{\Delta_\lambda
63: -2}\lambda'$ with $\Delta_g=4\Delta_\lambda=\beta^2/(4\pi)$ and $a$ being the microscopic
64: short distance cut-off.
65: In our case, the coefficients of the following OPEs are needed to construct the RG
66: equations
67: \begin{eqnarray}
68: :\cos{\beta\over 2}\phi(z,{\bar z})::\cos{\beta\over 2}\phi(w,{\bar w}):&\sim&
69: {1\over 2}|z-w|^{\beta^2\over 8\pi}:\cos\beta\phi(w,{\bar w}):-{\beta^2\over 8}|z-w|^{2-{\beta^2
70: \over 8\pi}}:\partial_w\phi\partial_{\bar w}\phi:+\cdots\;,\label{ope1}\\
71: :\cos\beta\phi(z,{\bar z})::\cos\beta\phi(w,{\bar w}):&\sim&
72: {1\over 2}|z-w|^{\beta^2\over 2\pi}:\cos 2\beta\phi(w,{\bar w}):-{\beta^2\over 2}
73: |z-w|^{2-{\beta^2
74: \over 2\pi}}:\partial_w\phi\partial_{\bar w}\phi:+\cdots\;,\label{ope3}\\
75: :\cos\beta\phi(z,{\bar z})::\cos{\beta\over 2}\phi(w,{\bar w}):&\sim&{1\over 2}
76: |z-w|^{-{\beta^2\over 4\pi}}:\cos{\beta\over 2}\phi(w,{\bar w}):+\cdots\;.\label{ope2}
77: \end{eqnarray}
78: It should be noted that in Eqs.(\ref{ope1},\ref{ope3},\ref{ope2}) we only pick up the operators
79: which have contribution to the RG equation.
80:
81:
82: Through Eqs.(\ref{ope1},\ref{ope2}) one can obtain the one-loop RG equations\cite{Cardy1,Cardy2}
83: \begin{eqnarray}
84: &&{dg\over d\ln l}=(2-\Delta_g)g-{\pi\over 2}\lambda^2\label{RGE1}\\
85: &&{d\lambda\over d\ln l}=(2-\Delta_\lambda)\lambda-\pi g\lambda\label{RGE2}
86: \end{eqnarray}
87: under the scaling transformation $a\sim e^l a$.
88: The second term in Eqs.(\ref{ope1},\ref{ope3}) leads to the renormalization of $\beta^2$
89: \begin{equation}
90: {d\beta^2\over d\ln l}=-{\pi\over 4}\beta^4(g^2+{\lambda^2\over 4})\;,\label{beta}
91: \end{equation}
92: which results in the modification of $\Delta_g$ and $\Delta_\lambda$ in Eqs.(
93: \ref{RGE1},\ref{RGE2}). However, this higher order correction can be neglected since it
94: will not change our conclusion qualitatively for small $g$ and $\lambda$.
95:
96: The zeros of the RG equations (\ref{RGE1},\ref{RGE2}) give the fixed points of the system,
97: which include two Ising critical points $(g_c,\pm\lambda_c)$ with
98: \begin{eqnarray}
99: &&g_c={1\over\pi}(2-\Delta_\lambda)\;\\
100: &&\lambda_c={1\over\pi}\sqrt{2(2-\Delta_g)(2-\Delta_\lambda)}\;
101: \end{eqnarray}
102: and the trivial Gaussian fixed point $g=\lambda=0$.
103: The topology of the RG flows implied by Eqs.(\ref{RGE1},\ref{RGE2}) is plotted in Fig.(1).
104:
105: In the vicinity of the Gaussian fixed point which is unstable with respect to the parameters
106: $g$ and $\lambda$, the RG trajectories have the form
107: $\lambda\sim g^\mu$ with $\mu=(2-\Delta_\lambda)/(2-\Delta_g)$ and flow outward.
108:
109: In order to extract the asymptotic behavior of the RG flows near the Ising critical
110: points, one can substitute $g=g_c+\tilde{g}$ and $\lambda=\lambda_c+\tilde{\lambda}$ into
111: the RG equations and neglect the quadratic terms of $\tilde{g}$ and $\tilde{\lambda}$,
112: which leads to
113: \begin{eqnarray}
114: &&{d\tilde{g}\over d\ln l}={\pi\lambda^2_c\over 2g_c}\tilde{g}-\pi\lambda_c\tilde{\lambda}\;,
115: \label{icp1}\\
116: &&{d\tilde{\lambda}\over d\ln l}=-\pi\lambda_c\tilde{g}\;.\label{icp2}
117: \end{eqnarray}
118: These two equations (\ref{icp1},\ref{icp2}) can be rewritten in a decoupled form with the
119: new variables $\xi_\pm=\tilde{g}+a_\pm\tilde{\lambda}$ as
120: \begin{equation}
121: {d\xi_\pm\over d\ln l}=\pi\lambda_c a_\mp \xi_\pm\;,\label{ddd}
122: \end{equation}
123: where $a_\pm=(\lambda_c/g_c\pm\sqrt{16+\lambda^2_c/g^2_c})/4$.
124:
125: Clearly Eq.(\ref{ddd}) implies that $\xi_-$ is relevant and will opens a mass gap proportional
126: to $\xi_-^{1/\pi\lambda_c a_+}$ and $\xi_+$ is irrelevant.
127: As seen from Fig.(1), the Ising fixed point $(g_c,\lambda_c)$ is unstable with respect to
128: $\xi_-$ and stable with respect to $\xi_+$. The lines $\xi_+=0$ and $\xi_-=0$ act as separatrix
129: dividing the region around the Ising fixed point into four parts. Fig.(1) also indicates
130: there exist a critical line connecting the Gaussian fixed point and the Ising fixed point, any
131: point on which will flow toward the Ising fixed point and the central charge of the system
132: changes from $c=1$ to $c=1/2$
133: according to the Zamolodchikov's C-theorem\cite{Cardy1,Cardy2,Zamolodchikov}.
134: Thus, all the initial hamiltonian on this line are in the same university class.
135: This critical trajectory has the form $\lambda=\zeta g^\mu$ with some fixed parameter
136: $\zeta>0$ near the Gaussian fixed point and has a linear asymtotic form $\xi_-=0$, namely,
137: \begin{equation}
138: g+a_-\lambda-g_c-a_+\lambda_c=0
139: \end {equation}
140: around the Ising fixed point $(g_c,\lambda_c)$.
141:
142: As for the other Ising fixed point $(g_c,-\lambda_c)$, the similar analysis gives that this
143: fixed point is unstable with respect to $\xi_+$ and stable with respect to $\xi_-$.
144: The critical line connecting this Ising fixed point and the Gaussian fixed point also has the
145: form $\lambda=\zeta g^\mu$ but the parameter $\zeta<0$ near the Gaussian fixed point, and in the vicinity of the
146: fixed point $(g_c,-\lambda_c)$ it becomes $\xi_+=0$, namely
147: \begin{equation}
148: g+a_+\lambda-g_c+a_+\lambda_c=0\;.
149: \end{equation}
150:
151: As a conclusion, we employ the RG approach to study the Ising criticality occurring in the
152: DSG model which finds some interesting applications in the 1D strongly correlated electron
153: systems. Two Ising fixed points are found besides the trivial Gaussian fixed point. The quantum
154: critical line $\lambda=\lambda_c(g)$, on which the system displays Ising criticality with
155: central charge $c=1/2$, is obtained near the fixed points together with the RG flows.
156:
157: The project is supported by the National Natural Science Foundation of China(Grant No.19975031)
158: and the RFDP(Grant No.199024833).
159: \begin{references}
160: \bibitem{Tsvelik} A.O.Gogolin, A.A.Nersesyan and A.M.Tsvelik 1998 {\it Bosonization and
161: Strongly Correlated Systems} (Cambridge University Press)
162: \bibitem{Delfino} G.Delfino and G.Mussardo 1998 {\it Nucl. Phys.} B {\bf 516} 675
163: \bibitem{Fabrizio} M.Fabrizio, A.O.Gogolin and A.A.Nersesyan 2000 {\it Nucl. Phys.} B {\bf 580} 647
164: \bibitem{Cardy1} J.L.Cardy 1996 {\it Scaling and Renormalization in Statistical Physics} (Cambridge
165: University Press)
166: \bibitem{Cardy2} J.L.Cardy 1988 {\it Lectures delivered at Les Houches Summer School on Fields, Strings and Statistical Mechanics}
167: \bibitem{Zamolodchikov} A.B.Zamolodchikov 1986 {\it JETP. Lett.} {\bf 43} 730
168: \end{references}
169: \end{document}
170:
171: \begin{figure}
172: \caption{The RG trajectories $\lambda\sim g$.}
173: \end{figure}
174:
175: