1: %Nov 29, 2001, revised version
2: %Sept 24, 2001(final longer version)
3: %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%% file template.tex %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%
4: %
5: % This is a template file for The European Physical Journal
6: %
7: % Copy it to a new file with a new name and use it as the basis
8: % for your article
9: %
10: %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%% Springer-Verlag %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%
11: \begin{filecontents}{g.eps}
12: %!PS-Adobe-2.0 EPSF-2.0
13: %%CreationDate: Mon Jul 13 16:51:17 1992
14: %%DocumentFonts: (atend)
15: %%Pages: 0 1
16: %%BoundingBox: 72 31 601 342
17: %%EndComments
18:
19: gsave
20: 72 31 moveto
21: 72 342 lineto
22: 601 342 lineto
23: 601 31 lineto
24: 72 31 lineto
25: showpage
26: grestore
27: %%Trailer
28: %%DocumentFonts: Helvetica
29: \end{filecontents}
30: %
31: %\documentclass[epj,referee]{svjour}
32: \documentclass[epj]{svjour}
33: % Remove option referee for final version
34: \usepackage{graphics}
35: % etc
36: %
37: \begin{document}
38: \title{ Localization, Dirac Fermions and Onsager Universality}
39: \author{Indubala I. Satija\cite{www}}
40: \institute{
41: Department of Physics, George Mason University,
42: Fairfax, VA 22030}
43: \date{Received: date / Revised version: date}
44: \abstract{
45: Disordered systems exhibiting exponential localization are mapped to anisotropic spin chains
46: with localization length being related to the anisotropy of the spin model.
47: This relates localization phenomenon in fermions to the rotational symmetry breaking
48: in the critical spin chains.
49: One of the intriguing consequence is that the statement of Onsager universality
50: in spin chains implies universality of the localized fermions where the fluctuations
51: in localized wave functions are universal.
52: We further show that the fluctuations about localized nonrelativistic fermions describe relativistic fermions.
53: This provides a new approach to understand the absence of localization in
54: disordered Dirac fermions.
55: We investigate how disorder affects well known universality
56: of the spin chains by examining the multifractal exponents. Finally, we examine the effects
57: of correlations on the localization characteristics of relativistic fermions.
58: \PACS{
59: {PACS-key}{Harper equation, localization} \and
60: {PACS-key}{Dirac fermions}
61: } % end of PACS codes
62: } %end of abstract
63: %
64: \authorrunning
65: \titlerunning
66: \maketitle
67: %
68: Two-dimensional Ising model is one of the few examples of exactly solvable many body systems.\cite{book}
69: The model exhibits a phase transition at finite temperature characterized by universal exponents defining
70: a universality class, the Onsager universality which describes the phase transitions for anisotropic XY models.
71: Interestingly, the Onsager universality
72: also describes a quantum phase transition at zero temperature, driven by quantum fluctuations,
73: of one-dimensional quantum anisotropic XY spin chains in a transverse field.\cite{Lieb}
74: These quantum models belong to a small family of integrable Hamiltonians that have attracted both
75: theoreticians as well as experimentalists.
76: Heart of integrability of these many body quantum spin problem is a mapping between spin and fermions
77: which relates interacting XY spin chain with $O(1)$ symmetry to the fermion Hamiltonian that
78: are quadratic in fermions. The
79: spin-fermion correspondence has proven to be extremely important also for the case of disordered magnetic field
80: as the quadratic fermion Hamiltonian can be numerically diagonalized with extreme precision.\cite{IIS}
81: Recent studies have shown that the a large variety of disordered quantum chains with $O(1)$ spin symmetry
82: are still described by the Onsager
83: universality.\cite{Luck,IIS}
84:
85: In this paper, we show a new type of spin-fermion mapping where
86: disordered fermions exhibiting
87: exponential localization are shown to be related to anisotropic spin chain
88: in a disordered magnetic field at the onset to long range order(LRO).
89: This correspondence, valid exclusively for exponentially localized systems,
90: provides new insight into various issues relevant
91: to disordered fermion as well as spin models. In particular we exploit well established universality
92: hypothesis of spin systems to make important statements about fermion problems.
93: Firstly, the root of recently observed universality in localized fermions\cite{KSprl,andy}
94: is traced to the Onsager universality of the spin systems.
95: Another interesting result is a correspondence between the relativistic and the
96: nonrelativistic fermions in the presence of disorder.
97: It is shown that the relativistic fermions can be viewed as
98: the fluctuations in the exponentially localized solutions of the
99: nonrelativistic fermions. This provides a new approach for understanding
100: the absence of localization in disordered Dirac fermions
101: which has been the subject of various recent studies.\cite{Dirac}
102: We argue that the long range magnetic correlations provide mechanism for delocalization of relativistic fermions
103: thus obtaining a deeper understanding of the absence of localization.
104: In addition to obtaining intuitively appealing picture
105: of some surprising results of disordered fermions, we also obtain a generalization of universality
106: statement of the critical exponents for disordered spin models.
107: Finally, we examine how the correlations affect the localization characteristics
108: and show the possibility of delocalization of relativistic fermions analogous to the corresponding
109: nonrelativistic case.
110:
111: Although the setting we describe is quite general in the context of disordered systems,
112: for concreteness we will consider
113: quasiperiodic disorder where the lattice problem for nonrelativistic fermion is described by the
114: Harper equation,\cite{Harper}
115: \begin{equation}
116: \psi_{n-1}+\psi_{n+1}+2 \lambda V_n \psi_n = E \psi_n.
117: \end{equation}
118: Here $V_n = cos(\theta_n)$ where $\theta_n= (2 \pi \sigma_g n +\phi)$. The $\sigma_g$ is an irrational number
119: describing competing length scales in the problem and $\phi$ is a constant phase factor.
120: Harper equation, in one-band approximation describes
121: Bloch electrons in a magnetic field. This problem frequently arises in many different physical contexts,
122: every time emerging with a new face to describe another physical application.
123: The problem is solvable by Bethe-ansatz\cite{BA}: there is an algebraic Bethe-ansatz equation for the spectrum.
124: It was shown that at some special points in the spectrum, e.g at the mid-band points,
125: the Hamiltonian in certain gauge can be written as a linear combination of generators of a
126: quantum group called $U_q(sl_2)$. It also describes
127: some properties of the integer quantum Hall effect: it showed that Kubo-Greenwood
128: formula for the conductance of any filled isolated band is an expression for a topological
129: invariant, and is an integer multiple of $e^2/h$.
130: It was further shown by Avron et al\cite{Chern} that it is a topological invariant that defines the first
131: Chern class of the mapping of the Brillouin zone( a two-dimensional torus)
132: onto a complex projective space of the wave functions.
133:
134: In contrast to usual Anderson problem describing localized particle in a random potential, the Harper equation
135: exhibits localization-delocalization transition provided $\sigma_g$ is an irrational number
136: with good Diophantine properties (ie. badly approximated by rational numbers).
137: This transition at $\lambda=1$ has been characterized with
138: singular continuous states and spectra. Richness and complexity of the critical point
139: describing localization transition has been studied in great detail by various renormalization
140: group approaches.\cite{Ostlund,KSrg} Recently, it was shown that multifractal characteristics
141: continue to exist beyond the critical point\cite{KSprl} throughout the localized phase.
142: This hidden complexity of the localized phase is brought to light after one factors out the
143: exponentially decaying envelope.
144: The localized wave functions with inverse
145: localization length $\xi^{-1}=log(\lambda)$ is rewritten as,\cite{KSprl}
146: \begin{equation}
147: \psi_n = e^{ -\gamma |n|} \eta_n
148: \end{equation}
149: where $\gamma=\xi^{-1}$.
150: The tight binding model(tbm) describing the fluctuations $\eta_n$ in the exponentially decaying
151: envelope is given by the following pair of equations,
152: \begin{eqnarray}
153: e^{-\gamma} \eta^r_{n+1} + e^{\gamma} \eta^r_{n-1} + 2 \lambda V_n
154: \eta^r_n &=& E \eta^r_n \nonumber\\
155: e^{\gamma} \eta^l_{n+1} + e^{-\gamma} \eta^l_{n-1} + 2 \lambda V_n
156: \eta^l_n &= &E \eta^l_n
157: \end{eqnarray}
158: Here $\eta^r$ and $\eta^l$ respectively describe the fluctuations
159: to the right and to the left of the localization
160: center. An exact renormalization
161: scheme\cite{KSprl} showed that these fluctuations exhibit universal features(see Fig. 1)
162: described by the strong coupling fixed point. Hence, localized phase is characterized by
163: universal fractal characteristics described by $\lambda \to \infty$ limit of the equation.
164: These results were further confirmed by rigorous mathematical analysis.\cite{andy}
165: Hence the strength of the disorder which determines the localization length can be factored out making
166: universal aspects transparent.
167: \begin{figure}
168: \resizebox{0.5\textwidth}{!}{%
169: \includegraphics{fig1.eps}
170: }
171: \caption{Absolute value of the fluctuations for Harper equation for $E=0$ states with $\phi=.25$
172: and $\sigma_g=(\sqrt(5)-1)/2$. At the Fibonacci sites,
173: we see period-$6$ behavior(period-$3$ in absolute value): $|\eta_{F_m}|=|\eta_{F_{m+3}}|$ which
174: is independent of $\lambda$.}
175: \label{fig:1}
176: \end{figure}
177:
178: A new revelation that provides intuitive understanding of
179: the strong coupling fixed point of Harper is obtained
180: by relating the fluctuations described by (3) to the anisotropic spin chain at the onset to LRO.
181: It turns out that the equations (3) for $E=0$ describe quasiparticle excitations of a
182: $critical$ anisotropic XY spin-$1/2$ chain in a transverse magnetic field, given by the following spin
183: Hamiltonian.
184: \begin{equation} \label{spin}
185: H=-\sum [e^{-\gamma} \sigma^x_n \sigma^x_{n+1}+ e^{\gamma}\sigma^y_n \sigma^y_{n+1} + 2\lambda V_n \sigma^z_n].
186: \end{equation}
187: The $\sigma_k$, $k=x,y$ are the Pauli matrices.
188: The $e^{-\gamma}$ and $e^{\gamma}$ respectively describe the exchange interactions along the
189: $x$ and the $y$ directions in spin space.
190: Using Jordan-Wigner transformation,
191: the interacting spin problem can be mapped to non-interacting
192: spinless fermion problem\cite{Lieb} where fermions are the quasiparticle
193: excitations of the spin chain obeying the following coupled equations,
194:
195: \begin{eqnarray}\label{fermion}
196: e^{-\gamma} \eta^1_{l+1}+e^{\gamma} \eta^1_{l-1}+2\lambda V_l \eta^1_l &=& E \eta^2_l \nonumber\\
197: e^{\gamma} \eta^2_{l+1}+e^{-\gamma} \eta^2_{l-1}+2\lambda V_l \eta^2_l &=& E \eta^1_l
198: \end{eqnarray}
199: At the onset to LRO, the excitation spectrum becomes gap-less and hence for the
200: $E=0$, the massless mode, the above two equations are degenerate
201: coinciding with the equation (3). Therefore, the massless excitations
202: of the critical anisotropic spin chain describe the
203: fluctuations in the exponentially localized excitations of the isotropic chain where the anisotropy
204: parameter is related to the localization length.
205:
206: Therefore, the localization length like the anisotropy parameter is an irrelevant variable
207: and hence the statement of strong coupling universality of the Harper equation is synonymous with
208: the statement that anisotropic spin chain is in the universality class of the Onsager universality.
209: In short, we establish an equivalence between Ising fixed point of the anisotropic spin chain and the strong
210: coupling fixed point of the Harper equation
211: and thus provide a simple interpretation of the strong coupling universality of the Harper equation.
212: Furthermore, by relating anisotropy to the localization length, we obtain a new picture of the localized
213: phase: the role of the strength of the disorder is similar to that of the strength of the anisotropy,
214: which is an irrelevant parameter for renormalization flow.
215: It should be noted that the spin-fermion mapping provides a new method to determine the localization length of
216: the tbms in the presence of disorder.
217: The expression for the localization length, $\gamma=log(\lambda)$
218: can be viewed as the relation describing the
219: critical point of the spin chain in a
220: disordered field.
221:
222: We next show that the fluctuation $\eta_n$ obey Dirac equation
223: for zero energy states.
224: In the long wave length limit, the equations(3) reduce to the Dirac equation.
225: We replace $n$ by $x$ and write
226: $\eta_{n\pm 1} = e^{\pm ip} \eta(x)$, where $p$ is the momentum canonically conjugate to $x$.
227: The equation (4) for the fluctuations for $E=0$ state can be described by the following non-Hermitian Hamiltonian $H_{fluc}$
228: and its adjoint,
229: $H_{fluc} = e^{-\gamma} e^{i p} + e^{\gamma} e^{-i p} + 2\lambda V(x)$.
230: In the limit ($p \rightarrow 0$),
231: the system for $E=0$ reduces to the Dirac equation,
232: \begin{equation}
233: [g \sigma_x p -i(2\lambda V(x)+2 cosh(\gamma) )\sigma_y]\eta(x) = 0
234: \end{equation}
235: where $\eta(x)$ is a two-dimensional spinor
236: $\eta(x)=(\eta^l(x),\eta^r(x))$.
237: It is interesting that the two-component structure of Dirac spinor arises naturally when we consider
238: fluctuations about exponentially
239: localized wave functions.
240: Here $g \equiv 2sinh(\gamma)$ is the velocity of the Dirac fermions while the mass of the Dirac fermions
241: $m(x) = 2((\lambda V(x)+ cosh(\gamma))$.
242: Therefore, on a lattice, the Dirac fermions
243: with disordered mass are the fluctuations of the nonrelativistic localized fermions.
244: This would imply the absence of exponential localization for relativistic fermions.
245: The defiance of localization by relativistic fermions has been the subject of various studies
246: and our analysis provides a simple way to understand this intriguing result.
247:
248: Next, we address the question whether the strong coupling fixed point which describes localized
249: phase of Harper equation, the critical Ising model and the Dirac fermions with quasiperiodic disorder, implies universal
250: multifractal exponents.
251: We compute the $f(\alpha)$ curve( Fig.2) describing the multifractal spectrum
252: associated with the self-similar wave function or
253: the inverse participation ratios ${\bf P}$,
254: ${\bf P}(q,N) = \frac{\sum |\eta_n|^{2q}}{\sum |\eta_n|^2} \sim N^{-\tau(q)}$,
255: $\alpha = \frac{d\tau}{dq}$ and
256: $f(\alpha) = \alpha q-\tau(q)$
257: The free energy function $\tau(q)$ and
258: its Legendre transform $f(\alpha)$ were found to be $\lambda$ independent only for {\it for positive values of $q$}
259: and hence only left half of the $f(\alpha)$ curve is universal.
260: Therefore, for quasiperiodic spin chains at the onset to LRO, scaling exponents for {\it only
261: positive moments} of the participation ratio are universal.
262: This can be viewed as a generalization of the universality statements of periodic spin chains
263: to disordered spins.
264: \begin{figure}
265: \resizebox{0.5\textwidth}{!}{%
266: \includegraphics{fig2.eps}
267: }
268: \caption{Numerically obtained $f(\alpha)$ curves for $\lambda \rightarrow \infty$( solid curve) and
269: $\lambda=1.5$ (lines with crosses).}
270: \label{fig:2}
271: \end{figure}
272:
273: Finally we investigate the role on correlations on the localization characteristics of massless
274: spin excitations which obey Dirac equation. The fact that correlations would result in delocalization
275: as originally shown by a random-dimer model\cite{pp}
276: is an important result in localization theory.\cite{pp}
277: For quasiperiodic disorder, dimer-type correlations can be introduced by
278: replacing $\theta_n=2\pi\sigma_g n$ in $V(\theta_n)$ by the iterates of the $supercritical$
279: standard map, describing
280: Hamiltonian systems with two degrees of freedom.\cite{dimerlong}
281: \begin{equation}
282: \theta_{n+1}+\theta_{n-1}-2\theta_n = - {K\over 2\pi } \sin( 2 \pi \theta_n) .\label{SM}
283: \end{equation}
284: We use iterates that describe golden-mean cantorus(the remanent of the KAM torus beyond the onset to global stochasticity)
285: which has been shown to exhibit dimer-type correlations, and leads to
286: Bloch-type states for the nonrelativistic fermions.\cite{dimerlong}
287: Here, we will confine to the Ising limit( can be obtained from (5) using $\gamma \to \infty$ and rescaling the parameters), described by,
288: \begin{eqnarray}
289: \eta^1_{n+1}+2\lambda cos(2\pi\theta_n)\eta^1_n&=& E \eta^2_n\nonumber\\
290: \eta^2_{n-1}+2\lambda cos(2\pi\theta_n)\eta^2_n&=& E \eta^1_n
291: \end{eqnarray}
292: We determine the critical $\lambda$ ( the threshold for the onset to magnetic transition)
293: as a function of $K$, the nonlinearity parameter of the two-dimensional map.\cite{Lieb}
294: The localization characteristics of the massless mode of the Ising model are studied using
295: an exact RG methodology\cite{KSrg}. In this approach, quasiperiodic models such as eqn (7) with
296: golden-mean incommensurability are decimated
297: to a renormalized model defined only at the Fibonacci sites. Renormalization flow describing
298: renormalized couplings at the Fibonacci sites provides an extremely accurate tool to distinguish
299: extended, localized and critical states. Trivial fixed points of the RG describe extended states while
300: critical states correspond to nontrivial fixed points. As shown in Fig. 3, nontrivial $6$-cycle
301: ( which also corresponds to six-cycle of the wave function $\eta_n$ as shown in
302: Fig. 1) degenerates to trivial fixed points
303: at certain special parameter values.
304: The origin of these trivial fixed points, has been traced to
305: a {\it hidden dimer} in the quasiperiodic iterates describing the golden-cantorus.\cite{dimerlong}
306: At these points, the relativistic massless mode of the Ising model is ballistic.
307: Therefore, relativistic fermions may become delocalized analogous to the nonrelativistic case
308: due to dimer-type correlations.
309:
310: The Fig. 3 shows an interesting interplay between the magnetic transition and the
311: ballistic transition due to dimer-type correlations: the ballistic transitions where the relativistic
312: mode is propagating seems to be sandwiched between two peaks corresponding to strong enhancement
313: of ( possibility divergent ) strength of the inhomogeneous field needed for the onset to LRO.
314: This phenomena again confirms the view that spin-fermion relationship may be an extremely
315: useful means to understand the richness and complexity underlying a variety of new phenomena in
316: disordered systems.
317: \begin{figure}
318: \resizebox{0.5\textwidth}{!}{%
319: \includegraphics{fig3.eps}
320: }
321: \caption{(a)Critical $\lambda$ as a function of $K$ for the Ising model.
322: (b) RG $6$-cycle showing the variation in the renormalized coupling at Fibonacci iteration of the RG flow for $E=0$.}
323: \label{fig:3}
324: \end{figure}
325:
326: One-dimensional quantum spin chain in a transverse field at the onset to LRO
327: describes two-dimensional layered Ising model.
328: Therefore, our study relates universal aspects, described by Onsager universality,
329: of two-dimensional Ising model to the universal
330: aspects of the two-dimensional
331: Bloch electron problem described by the Harper equation.
332: This paper establishes a relationship between two important systems where geometry and integrability
333: are of central importance.
334: We believe that our results are valid for a variety of disorders including
335: a large class of pseudorandom as well as random cases.
336:
337: Finally, it should be noted that spin-fermion correspondence is also valid for time-dependent models.
338: Kicked Harper model that has been extensively studied in quantum chaos literature\cite{Dima,PSS}
339: also describes XY spin chain in a periodically kicked inhomogeneous magnetic field.\cite{PS}
340: By exploiting the spin-fermion correspondence,
341: various new results in the kicked Harper model can provide a new way to understand
342: many surprising results.\cite{SP}
343: One of the interesting results is the independence of the critical exponents with respect to the discommensuration
344: parameter $\sigma_g$ in the limit $\sigma_g \to 0$. This defines a new aspect of the usual universality
345: statements for the spin systems at the onset to magnetic transition and hence
346: broadens the concept of universality to include disorder as well as time dependence.
347:
348: This research is supported by a grant from National Science Foundation,
349: DMR-0072813. I would like to thank Alain Comtet for bringing to my attention the problem
350: of disordered Dirac fermions.
351: \begin{thebibliography}{}
352: \bibitem{www} Web address: physics.gmu.edu~isatija
353: \bibitem{book} L. Onsager, Phys Rev 65, 117 (1944). Also see H. E. Stanley, " Introduction to Phase Transitions and Critical Phenomenon",
354: McGraw-Hill, 1978.
355: \bibitem{Lieb}E. Lieb, T. Schultz, and D. Mattis, Ann Phys. (N.Y) 16,
356: 407 (1961).
357: \bibitem{Luck}J. M. Luck, J . Stat. Phys 72 (1993) 417; Eurpphys Lett. 24 (1993) 359.
358: \bibitem{IIS} I.I. Satija, Phys Rev B49, 3391 (1994).
359: \bibitem{BA}P.B. Wiegmann and A.V. Zabrodin, Phys Rev Lett 72, 1890 (1994).
360: \bibitem{Chern}J.E.Avron, R. Seiler and B. Simon, Phys.~Rev.~Lett.,{\bf 51}, 1983.
361: \bibitem{Ostlund} S. Ostlund and R. Pandit, Phys. Rev. B 29, 1394
362: (1984); S. Ostlund, R. Pandit, D. Rand, H. J. Schellnhuber,
363: and E. D. Siggia, Phys. Rev. Lett. 50, 1873 (1983).
364: \bibitem{KSrg}J. A. Ketoja and I. I. Satija, Phys. Lett. A 194, 64
365: (1994), Physica A, 219, 212, (1995).
366: \bibitem{KSprl} J. A. Ketoja and I. I. Satija, Phys. Rev. Lett. 75,
367: 2762 (1995);
368: \bibitem{andy}B.Mestel,A.Osbaldestin and B. Winn;"Golden mean renormalization
369: for the Harper equation:the
370: strong coupling fixed point",preprint.
371: \bibitem{Dirac} L. Balents and M. Fisher, Phys Rev B, 56, 12970 (1997).
372: Castillo, C. Chamon, E. Fradkin, P. Goldbart and C. Mudry,
373: Phys Rev B, 56, (1997) 10668;
374: \bibitem{Harper} P. G. Harper, Proc. Phys. Soc. London A 68, 874 (1955);
375: B. Simon,
376: Adv. Appl. Math. 3, 463 (1982);
377: \bibitem{pp}H-L. Wu, W. Golf and P. W. Phillips, Phys Rev B 45 (1992) 1623.
378: \bibitem{dimerlong} J. Ketoja and I. Satija, Phys Rev B, 59, 9174 (1999);
379: \bibitem{Dima} P.~Leboeuf, J.~Kurchan, M.~Feingold and D.~P.~Arovas,
380: Phys.Rev.Lett {\bf 65}, 3076 (1990).
381: \bibitem{PSS} T.~Prosen, I.~I.~Satija and N.~Shah, Phys.~Rev.~Lett., {\bf 87}, 066601-1 (2001)
382: \bibitem{PS} T Prosen and I Satija (unpublished).
383: \bibitem{SP} "$\hbar \to 0$ in kicked Harper": Reassurances and Surprises" , I Satija and T Prosen ( preprint).
384: \end{thebibliography}
385: \end{document}
386:
387: