1: \documentclass[twocolumn,showpacs,bibnotes]{revtex4}
2: \usepackage{graphicx,epsfig}
3: \usepackage{dcolumn}
4:
5: \begin{document}
6:
7: \title{Forcing and Velocity Correlations in a Vibrated
8: Granular Monolayer}
9:
10: \author{Alexis Prevost}
11: \email[Email: ]{prevost@physics.georgetown.edu}
12: \author{David A. Egolf}
13: \altaffiliation{Also, Center for Nonlinear Studies, Los Alamos
14: National Laboratory, Los Alamos, NM 87545}
15: \author{Jeffrey S. Urbach}
16:
17: \affiliation{Department of Physics, Georgetown University,
18: Washington D.C., 20057}
19: \date{\today}
20:
21: \begin{abstract}
22: The role of forcing on the dynamics of a vertically shaken
23: granular monolayer is investigated. Using a flat plate, surprising
24: negative velocity correlations are measured. A mechanism for this
25: anti-correlation is proposed with support from both experimental
26: results and molecular dynamics simulations. Using a rough plate,
27: velocity correlations are positive, and the velocity distribution
28: evolves from a gaussian at very low densities to a broader
29: distribution at high densities. These results are interpreted as a
30: balance between stochastic forcing, interparticle collisions, and
31: friction with the plate.
32: \end{abstract}
33:
34: \pacs{45.70.Mg,05.20.Dd,05.20.Jj,83.10.Rs}
35:
36: \maketitle
37:
38: Granular gases, systems of large numbers of macroscopic grains in
39: rapid motion and interacting through dissipative collisions,
40: appear in a wide range of industrial applications and natural
41: phenomena. Energy must be supplied externally to compensate for
42: the inelastic collisions, so granular gases are necessarily
43: systems out of equilibrium. As a result, they may display dramatic
44: non-equilibrium effects such as non-gaussian velocity
45: distributions
46: \cite{OlafsenUrbach,Losert99,Rouyer00,VanNoije98,ChrisBizon,NieBenNaimChen}
47: and long-range spatial velocity correlations
48: \cite{VanNoije99,Pagonabarraga01,MoonShattuckSwiftPRE2001,BlairKudrolliRPRE2001}.
49: Non-gaussian velocity distributions are a direct demonstration of
50: the inapplicability of the Gibbs distribution, and significant
51: velocity correlations indicate the absence of `molecular chaos',
52: which is a crucial approximation normally used to solve the
53: Boltzmann equation and to calculate other fundamental quantities
54: in kinetic theory. Recent theoretical work has focused on the
55: non-equilibrium steady state obtained when the energy supplied by
56: spatially homogeneous random external forcing is balanced by the
57: dissipation due to the collisions such that the average energy of
58: the system remains constant
59: \cite{VanNoije98,VanNoije99,Pagonabarraga01}. Non-gaussian
60: velocity distributions and algebraically decaying velocity
61: correlations arise as a direct consequence of the energy
62: injection. Non-gaussian velocity distributions and velocity
63: correlations have been observed in a number of experiments
64: \cite{OlafsenUrbach,Losert99,Rouyer00,BlairKudrolliRPRE2001}, but
65: in each case the forcing is sufficiently different from that of
66: the theoretical models that a direct comparison is difficult. In
67: this Letter, we provide a direct demonstration of the determining
68: role that the forcing plays on the spatial velocity correlations
69: in a homogeneously forced granular gas. We will also show how the
70: framework of kinetic theory can provide a coherent description of
71: the origin of the observed velocity distributions and
72: correlations.
73:
74: We have investigated a quasi-2D granular system consisting of a
75: layer of a large number of spherical particles partially covering
76: a vertically driven horizontal plate. Two plates with different
77: surface properties were used in the experiments: a smooth circular
78: plate (20 cm in diameter) made of black anodized aluminum, and a
79: rough hexagonally shaped plate (30 cm between opposite corners).
80: The roughness of the latter is provided by a close-packed lattice
81: of blackened steel balls (1.19 mm diameter) glued to a flat plate.
82: The granular gas is made of uniform stainless steel spheres with
83: diameter $\sigma=1.59$\,mm (smooth plate), or $\sigma=3.97$ mm
84: (rough plate). On the smooth plate, the layer is constrained from
85: above by an anti-static coated plexiglas lid, 1.7 $\sigma$ above
86: the plate. Using an electromagnetic shaker, the plate is driven
87: sinusoidally, and the granular layer is brought to a
88: non-equilibrium steady state. The strength of the shaking $\Gamma
89: = A \omega^2/g$ is directly measured with a fast response
90: accelerometer ($A$ is the amplitude and $\omega$ the frequency of
91: the plate oscillation, and $g$ the acceleration due to gravity).
92:
93: A high resolution camera (Pulnix TM1040) placed above the plate
94: records the bright spots on the tops of the balls produced by a
95: stroboscopic LED array. Instantaneous horizontal velocities ${\bf
96: v}_i$ are obtained from the displacements between strobe pulses.
97: The strobe is synchronized with the camera so that the first pulse
98: occurs at the end of the exposure of one frame, and the next pulse
99: occurs at the beginning of the subsequent frame. The time interval
100: between pulses ($\sim$ 1 ms) is chosen to be significantly smaller
101: than the mean collision time. The width of both pulses is
102: typically less than 0.05 ms. Displacements of the centers of the
103: bright spots are measured with 0.1 pixel accuracy. To eliminate
104: systematic errors in the velocity correlations, snapshots are
105: taken at a fixed phase relative to the driving signal
106: corresponding to the maximum average position of the layer.
107:
108: The general behavior of the granular layer on the smooth plate has
109: been reported previously \cite{OlafsenUrbach} and a rich phase
110: diagram depending on both $\Gamma$ and $\omega$ was found. Here we
111: focus mainly on the fluidized regime, obtained for $\Gamma\geq 1$.
112: All results presented in this Letter were obtained with
113: $\Gamma=1.5$ and $\omega/2\pi=60$ Hz.
114:
115: The longitudinal and transverse velocity correlations, $C_{||}$
116: and $C_{\bot}$, respectively, are calculated by
117: \begin{eqnarray}\label{velocitycorrdef}
118: C_{||,\bot}(r)= \sum_{i\neq j}^{N_r} v_i^{||,\bot}
119: v_j^{||,\bot}/N_r, \nonumber
120: \end{eqnarray}
121: where the sum runs over the $N_r$ pairs of particles separated by
122: a distance $r$, $v_i^{||}$ is the projection of ${\bf
123: v}_i$ along the line connecting the centers of particles $i$ and
124: $j$, and $v_i^{\bot}$ is the projection perpendicular to that
125: line.
126:
127: \begin{figure}
128: \centerline{\epsfig{file=Figure1.eps,width=8.6cm}}
129: \caption{Longitudinal velocity correlations normalized by the
130: granular temperature $T$ on the smooth plate: $\Gamma=1.5$,
131: $\rho=0.4\,(\bullet)$ and $\rho=0.5\,(\circ)$. Inset: transverse
132: velocity correlations. Data represent averages over approximately
133: 8000 pairs of images with about 180 balls per
134: image.}\label{fig:figure1}
135: \end{figure}
136:
137: Figure \ref{fig:figure1} shows $C_{||}$ (inset: $C_{\bot}$)
138: normalized by the granular temperature $T=\langle{\bf
139: v}_i^2\rangle$ obtained on the smooth plate for $\rho=0.4$ and
140: 0.5, and $\Gamma=1.5$ \cite{coverage}. Surprisingly, the
141: longitudinal velocity correlations are strongly negative for all
142: $r$ and all accessible densities: the velocities are
143: anti-correlated. $C_{||}$ decays slower than exponentially, and in
144: the range $r=[2\sigma,16\sigma]$ can be reasonably well described
145: by $C_{||}(r)\propto r^{-2}$. The structure visible between
146: $1\sigma$ and $2\sigma$ is stronger at high density, and its
147: origin is not understood. The transverse component $C_{\bot}$ is
148: much smaller and has a shorter range than $C_{||}$ (note the
149: difference in vertical scale). Nearly identical correlations were
150: observed without the lid in place. We have performed molecular
151: dynamics simulations that closely match the conditions of the
152: experiment \cite{computer} and find qualitatively similar
153: correlations.
154:
155: The existence of long-range velocity correlations in a randomly
156: forced granular gas has been explained theoretically using a
157: hydrodynamic approach \cite{VanNoije99}. The velocity
158: correlations result from the balance between the excitation of
159: hydrodynamic modes by the random external forcing and their
160: dissipation through diffusion. At shorter range, velocity
161: correlations arise from an increased probability of re-collision
162: due to the forcing \cite{Pagonabarraga01}. This suggests that the
163: correlations could be quite sensitive to the particular mechanism
164: of energy injection, and we believe that this is the origin of the
165: dramatic difference between the negative correlations observed in
166: our experiment and the positive correlations observed in the
167: randomly forced model systems
168: \cite{VanNoije98,VanNoije99,Pagonabarraga01,MoonShattuckSwiftPRE2001}.
169: In those systems, energy is injected through white noise forcing
170: of each particle independently, while on the smooth plate energy
171: is injected only into the vertical motion of the spheres and is
172: then transferred to the horizontal motion through inter-particle
173: collisions. As a result of this transfer, collisions will result,
174: on average, in an increase in the magnitude of the relative
175: horizontal velocities ${\bf v}_r$ of pairs of particles. This
176: effect can be measured directly in the molecular dynamics
177: simulations, and at $\rho=0.5$ we find that the average value of
178: $\langle {\bf v}_r^2 \rangle$ for pairs of particles leaving a
179: collision is 13\% higher than for pairs entering a collision.
180: Experimental support for this scenario can be found in Fig.\
181: \ref{fig:figure2}, which shows a calculation of $\langle{\bf
182: v}(0)\cdot{\bf v}(r)\rangle$, where the average includes only
183: particles restricted to a narrow band along the direction of
184: motion of the particle at the origin, either ahead (for positive
185: $r$) or behind (for negative $r$). There is a clear asymmetry with
186: respect to zero, showing that balls moving away from each other
187: contribute significantly more to the velocity anti-correlation
188: than do particles moving towards each other. The velocity
189: anti-correlations would presumably dissipate through diffusion as
190: the momentum gets transferred to surrounding particles through
191: collisions, thus it is not surprising that the observed
192: correlations extend over several mean free paths. This mechanism
193: for the generation of anti-correlated velocities may also operate
194: in inhomogeneously forced granular media when the average kinetic
195: energy of the grains is anisotropic.
196:
197: \begin{figure}
198: \centerline{\epsfig{file=Figure2.eps,width=8.6cm}} \caption{
199: $\langle{\bf v}(0)\cdot{\bf v}(r)\rangle$ (as described in the
200: text) normalized by $T$ for $\Gamma=1.5$ and $\rho=0.4$
201: ($\bullet$), $\rho=0.5$ ($\circ$).}\label{fig:figure2}
202: \end{figure}
203:
204: To test our hypothesis about the origin of the correlations, we
205: have changed the forcing by using a rough surface, so that the
206: vibrating plate also injects energy directly into the horizontal
207: motion of the spheres. This energy input mechanism is closer to
208: the white noise forcing of Ref.\ \cite{VanNoije99}, and allows for
209: a more direct comparison between experiment and theory
210: \cite{chaotic}.
211:
212: The velocity correlations measured on the rough plate are shown on
213: Fig.\ \ref{fig:figure3} for $\Gamma=1.5$ \cite{Cluster}, and two
214: extremal densities. We find that both $C_{||}$ and $C_{\bot}$ are
215: positive for all measured $\rho$. $\langle{\bf v}(0)\cdot{\bf
216: v}(r)\rangle$, calculated as described above, is positive
217: everywhere and is roughly symmetric about zero. Molecular dynamics
218: simulations of the layer on the rough plate \cite{computer} show
219: similar correlations, and the effect of the collisions is to
220: decrease the average value of $\langle {\bf v}_r^2 \rangle$ by
221: 3.7\% at $\rho = 0.5$. Thus in the absence of large vertical to
222: horizontal collisional energy transfer, the velocity
223: anti-correlations are replaced by positive velocity correlations,
224: presumably arising from the random forcing as described in Refs.
225: \cite{VanNoije99,Pagonabarraga01}. The dramatic difference in the
226: correlations between the smooth and rough plates is a clear
227: indication that the forcing, rather than the inelastic
228: interparticle collisions, determines the velocity correlations.
229:
230: \begin{figure}
231: \centerline{\epsfig{file=Figure3.eps,width=8.6cm}}\caption{Longitudinal
232: velocity correlations normalized by the granular temperature on
233: the rough plate: $\Gamma=1.5$, and $\rho=0.125\,(\bullet)$,
234: $\rho=0.6\,(\circ)$. Inset: transverse velocity correlations. Data
235: are averaged over 16000 pairs of images ($\sim$ 80 balls per
236: image) for $\rho=0.125$, and 8000 pairs ($\sim$ 420 balls) for
237: $\rho=0.6$. }\label{fig:figure3}
238: \end{figure}
239:
240: \begin{figure}
241: \centerline{\epsfig{file=Figure4.eps,width=8.6cm}}\caption{Scaled
242: longitudinal and transverse velocity correlations normalized by
243: $T$. $C_{||}/(\alpha T)$ (symbols with solid lines) and
244: $C_{\bot}/(\alpha T)$ (symbols with dashed lines) for
245: $\Gamma=1.5$, $\rho=0.125$ ($\circ$), $\rho=0.5$ ($\times$), and
246: $\rho=0.6$ ($\bullet$). Inset: Log-linear plot of the scaled
247: velocity correlations (the straight lines are exponentials with
248: decay lengths of $2\sigma$ and $0.6\sigma$.)}\label{fig:figure4}
249: \end{figure}
250:
251: Interestingly, we find that $C_{||}$ and $C_{\bot}$ can be roughly
252: scaled on two different curves of the form $C_{||,\bot} = T
253: \alpha(\rho) f_{||,\bot}(r)$ (Fig.\ \ref{fig:figure4}). The
254: functions $f_{||}$ and $f_{\bot}$ have different $r$ dependence,
255: but the function $\alpha(\rho)$ is the same for both $C_{||}$ and
256: $C_{\bot}$. $f_{||}$ and $f_{\bot}$ are reasonably well described
257: by $f(r) \propto e^{-r/r_o}$, with $r_o=2\sigma$ for $f_{||}$ and
258: $0.6\sigma$ for $f_{\bot}$. It is surprising that this decay
259: length has little density dependence, despite the fact that the
260: mean free path estimated from Enskog-Boltzmann kinetic theory
261: varies from 2.3$\sigma$ for $\rho=0.125$ to 0.16$\sigma$ for
262: $\rho=0.6$. A similar scaling relation is predicted in the
263: randomly forced model at large $r$ \cite{VanNoije99}, but the
264: scaling is the same for both $C_{||}$ and $C_{\bot}$, and $f(r)$
265: decays algebraically.
266:
267: An important difference between our experiment and the randomly
268: forced model is revealed by the velocity distributions $P(v)$ of
269: the balls on the rough plate. Figure \ref{fig:figure5} shows the
270: normalized $P(v_x)$ obtained for $\Gamma=1.5$, and $\rho$ ranging
271: from $0.014$ to $0.6$. At the lowest density, $P(v_x)$ is well
272: described by a gaussian. As $\rho$ increases, the tails of the
273: distribution rise significantly above a gaussian. At high density,
274: the velocity distribution resembles those reported previously on
275: flat plates \cite{OlafsenUrbach,Losert99}. To better understand
276: the effect of density on $P(v)$, we have followed the trajectories
277: of individual balls using a fast camera (838 frames/s,
278: \cite{OlafsenUrbach}), and measured the time-dependent velocity
279: autocorrelation function $C_{v}(t)=\langle{\bf v}(0)\cdot {\bf
280: v}(t)\rangle$ and find that $C_v(t)\approx e^{-t/ \tau(\rho)}$ at
281: all densities. The scattering length defined by
282: $l\equiv\sqrt{T}\tau(\rho)$ varies from about 0.5$\sigma$ at
283: $\rho=0.6$ to about 2.5$\sigma$ at $\rho=0.014$. At the lowest
284: density, $l$ is much smaller than the mean free path for ball-ball
285: scattering ($\sim$ 20 $\sigma$) obtained from kinetic theory. This
286: suggests that it is ball-plate scattering that is responsible for
287: the decay of the velocity auto-correlation function, and that the
288: scattering must therefore have a viscous component. The evolution
289: of $P(v)$ for a single ball on the rough plate can thus be very
290: likely modelled with an equation including only random white noise
291: forcing and a viscous term, such as the Fokker-Plank equation for
292: Brownian motion, which produces a gaussian $P(v)$. When the random
293: forcing is instead balanced by ball-ball scattering in a modified
294: Boltzmann equation, there is an over-population of the tails of
295: the distributions, $P(v) \sim \exp(-|v|^{3/2})$ \cite{VanNoije98}.
296: This is consistent with the experimentally measured $P(v)$ at high
297: densities, where the scattering is dominated by ball-ball
298: collisions. At intermediate densities both scattering processes
299: contribute and the evolution of $P(v)$ with density can likely be
300: described with a Boltzmann equation consisting of random white
301: noise forcing, collisional scattering, and a density independent
302: viscous drag. This model has been recently investigated
303: \cite{Puglisi99}, although primarily at higher inelasticities,
304: where significant clustering is observed.
305:
306: \begin{figure}
307: \centerline{\epsfig{file=Figure5.eps,width=8.6cm}}\caption{Normalized
308: velocity distributions $P(v_x)$, on the rough plate for
309: $\Gamma=1.5$ and $\rho=0.014$\,$(\triangle)$,
310: $\rho=0.125\,(\circ)$, $\rho=0.6\,(\bullet)$. The solid line is a
311: gaussian. (Results for $P(v_y)$ are identical).
312: }\label{fig:figure5}
313: \end{figure}
314:
315: The ball-plate scattering may also explain the lack of significant
316: density dependence of the decay length of the velocity
317: correlations. We speculate that the density independent scattering
318: with the plate, which unlike ball-ball collisions does not
319: conserve momentum, is more effective at destroying the long-range
320: velocity correlations, and therefore controls the observed decay.
321: Support for this scenario is provided by the fact that the decay
322: length for the exponentially decaying $C_{||}(r)$ at {\em all}
323: measured densities is close to the ball-plate scattering length
324: deduced from the individual trajectories at very low densities
325: (2$\sigma$ versus $2.5\sigma$). However, a full quantitative
326: understanding of the velocity correlations observed on the rough
327: plate will require a theoretical analysis along the lines of Ref.\
328: \cite{VanNoije99}, including the effect of viscous drag. Our
329: results provide a clear experimental demonstration that the
330: velocity distribution and correlations in a granular gas are not
331: determined exclusively by internal dynamics (inelastic ball-ball
332: collisions) but by a balance between internal dynamics and
333: external forcing.
334:
335: The authors gratefully acknowledge Mickey Moore for providing us
336: with the rough plate. This work was supported by grants from the
337: Research Corporation, the Petroleum Research fund, DOE, and Grant
338: No. DMR-9875529 from the NSF. J.S.U. acknowledges support from the
339: Sloan foundation.
340:
341: \begin{thebibliography}{14}
342: \bibitem{OlafsenUrbach} J.S. Olafsen and J.S. Urbach, Phys. Rev. Lett.
343: {\bf 81}, 4369 (1998); J.S. Olafsen and J.S. Urbach, Phys. Rev. E
344: {\bf 60}, R2468 (1999).
345: \bibitem{Losert99} W. Losert, D.G.W. Cooper, J. Delour, A.
346: Kudrolli and J.P. Gollub, Chaos {\bf 9}, 682 (1999).
347: \bibitem{Rouyer00} F. Rouyer and N. Menon, Phys. Rev. Lett. {\bf
348: 85}, 3676 (2000).
349: \bibitem{VanNoije98} T.P.C. van Noije and M.H. Ernst, Granular Matter
350: {\bf 1}, 57 (1998).
351: \bibitem{ChrisBizon} C. Bizon, M.D. Shattuck, J.B. Swift, and H.L.
352: Swinney, Phys. Rev. E {\bf 60}, 4340 (1999).
353: \bibitem{NieBenNaimChen} X. Nie, E. Ben-Naim, and S.Y. Chen,
354: Europhys. Lett. {\bf 51}, 679 (2000).
355: \bibitem{VanNoije99} T.P.C. van Noije, M.H. Ernst, E. Trizac and I.
356: Pagonabarraga, Phys. Rev. E {\bf 59}, 4326 (1999).
357: \bibitem{Pagonabarraga01} I. Pagonabarraga, E. Trizac, T.P.C van
358: Noije and M.H. Ernst, Phys. Rev. E {\bf 65}, 011303 (2002).
359: \bibitem{MoonShattuckSwiftPRE2001} S.J. Moon, M.D. Shattuck,
360: and J.B. Swift, Phys. Rev. E {\bf 64}, 031303 (2001).
361: \bibitem{BlairKudrolliRPRE2001} D.L. Blair and A. Kudrolli,
362: Phys. Rev. E {\bf 64}, 050301(R) (2001).
363: \bibitem{coverage} $\rho=N/N_{c}$, $N$ is the number of balls and
364: $N_{c}$ the number in a full close-packed monolayer.
365: \bibitem{computer} The interaction rules and parameters for the
366: molecular dynamics simulation were taken from Ref.
367: \cite{NieBenNaimChen}. The roughness was simulated by adding a
368: layer of close-packed spheres rigidly attached to the plate. The
369: values for $\sigma$, $\omega$ and $A$ are taken from the
370: experiment.
371: \bibitem{Cluster} At $\Gamma=1.5$, the layer is fully fluidized.
372: Clustering, due to trapping of the balls by the lattice, is
373: present for values of $\Gamma$ below 1.2.
374: \bibitem{chaotic} Although the roughness of the plate is periodic, its wavelength is considerably
375: less than the measured scattering length, and the motion of the
376: balls on the surface is presumably chaotic, so stochastic forcing
377: and scattering is likely to be a good approximation.
378: \bibitem{Puglisi99} A. Puglisi, V. Loreto, U. Marini Bettolo Marconi, and A. Vulpiani, Phys. Rev. E {\bf 59}, 5582 (1999).
379: \end{thebibliography}
380: \end{document}
381: