1: % resubmit PRB Lee
2: % Apr. 2002
3: % Dear Editor,
4: % I want to resubmit a manuscript, whose title is
5: % " Non-Fermi liquid behavior and scaling of low-frequency suppression in
6: % optical conductivity spectra of CaRuO$_3$" for the Rapid communication section in Phys. Rev. B.
7: % This file contains a text including 3 figures. If you have any questions or requests,
8: % please let me know
9: % promptly. My address is as follows;
10: % Prof. T. W. Noh
11: % School of Physics
12: % Seoul National University
13: % Seoul, 151-747, Korea
14: % (Phone) 82-2-883-1385
15: % (FAX) 82-2-875-1222
16: % (email) twnoh@phya.snu.ac.kr
17: % Thanks a lot for your attention.
18: % Sincerely yours,
19: % Tae W. Noh
20: % towcolumn enforce 2 column output
21: % deactivate 1 line below for two column output
22: %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%% activate 3 lines below for two column output
23:
24: \documentstyle[prb,aps,twocolumn,epsfig]{revtex}
25: %\documentstyle[preprint,prb,aps,]{revtex}
26: %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%
27: \begin{document}
28: \draft
29: \twocolumn[\hsize\textwidth\columnwidth\hsize\csname @twocolumnfalse\endcsname\title{Temperature-dependent Raman spectroscopy in BaRuO$_3$ systems}
30: \title{Non-Fermi liquid behavior and scaling of low frequency suppression in
31: optical conductivity spectra of CaRuO$_3$}
32: \author{Y. S. Lee and Jaejun Yu}
33: \address{School of Physics and Center for Strongly Correlated Materials Research,\\
34: Seoul National University, Seoul 151-747, Korea}
35: \author{J. S. Lee and T. W. Noh}
36: \address{School of Physics and Research Center for Oxide Electronics, Seoul\\
37: National University, Seoul 151-747, Korea}
38: \author{T.-H. Gimm and Han-Yong Choi}
39: \address{School of Physics and Institute for Basic Science Research, Sung Kyun\\
40: Kwan University, Suwon 440-746, Korea}
41: \author{C. B. Eom}
42: \address{Department of Material Science and Engineering, University of\\
43: Wisconsin-Madison, Madison, Wisconsin 53706.}
44: \date{\today }
45: \maketitle
46:
47: \begin{abstract}
48: Optical conductivity spectra $\sigma _1(\omega )$ of paramagnetic CaRuO$_3$
49: are investigated at various temperatures. At $T=10$ K, it shows a non-Fermi
50: liquid behavior of $\sigma _1(\omega )\sim 1/{\omega }^{\frac 12}$, similar
51: to the case of a ferromagnet SrRuO$_3$. As the temperature ($T$) is
52: increased, on the other hand, $\sigma _1(\omega )$ in the low frequency
53: region is progressively suppressed, deviating from the $1/{\omega }^{\frac 12%
54: }$-dependence. Interestingly, the suppression of $\sigma _1(\omega )$ is
55: found to scale with $\omega /T$ at all temperatures. The origin of the $%
56: \omega /T$ scaling behavior coupled with the non-Fermi liquid behavior is
57: discussed.
58: \end{abstract}
59:
60: \pacs{PACS number : 78.20.-e, 78.30.-j, 78.66.-w}
61:
62: \vskip1pc] \newpage
63: %\newpage
64:
65: The Fermi liquid model has provided a fundamental concept in understanding
66: metals.\cite{FL87} However, in some strongly correlated systems, non-Fermi
67: liquid (NFL) behaviors have been often observed, where the Fermi liquid
68: picture fails. In the normal state of high $T_c$ superconductors (HTS),
69: evidences of NFL behaviors were reported in many experiments involving
70: photoemission, transport, and optical measurements.\cite{orenstein00} In
71: particular, their optical conductivity spectra $\sigma _1(\omega )$ show $%
72: 1/\omega $-dependence in contrast to the usual Drude form of $\sim 1/\omega
73: ^2$, and their scattering rates show linear temperature- ($T$-) and $\omega $%
74: -dependences up to the mid-infrared (IR) region. Such unusual behaviors have
75: been explained in terms of the marginal Fermi liquid.\cite{Varma89}
76:
77: Recently, perovskite ruthenates have attracted much attention as another
78: class of materials exhibiting NFL behavior. The ruthenates belong to 4$d$
79: transition metal oxides, and the electron correlation effects are believed
80: to play a crucial role in determining their physical properties.\cite{lee01}
81: Together with their intriguing transport properties,\cite{Allen96,Klein99}
82: the optical spectra show a distinct NFL behavior.\cite{schlesinger98,dodge00}
83: For an itinerant ferromagnet SrRuO$_3$ (a ferromagnetic transition
84: temperature $T_c$ = 165 K), Kostic {\it et al}.\cite{schlesinger98} reported
85: that its $\sigma _1(\omega )$ at low $T$ follow a $1/\omega ^{\frac 12}$%
86: -dependence, indicating a NFL behavior stronger than that of HTS. Recently,
87: Dodge {\it et al}.\cite{dodge00} fitted the $\sigma _1(\omega )$ of SrRuO$_3$
88: with $\sigma _\alpha (\omega )\sim (\tau ^{-1}-i\omega )^{-\alpha }$ with $%
89: \alpha \sim 0.4$ down to a very low energy region of $\sim 0.001$ eV.
90: Although the NFL behavior in the ruthenate has been widely accepted, its
91: origin is not clearly understood. In addition, an unusual suppression of $%
92: \sigma _1(\omega )$ in the low energy region occurs in the paramagnetic (PM)
93: state, but is absent in the ferromagnetic (FM) state.\cite{dodge00} However,
94: this intriguing phenomenon, which might be coupled with a NFL behavior, has
95: not been addressed properly.
96:
97: While CaRuO$_3$ has the electronic structure similar to that of SrRuO$_3$,
98: this material does not show any magnetic ordering down to a very low $T$.%
99: \cite{Cao97} CaRuO$_3$ can provide a relatively wide $T$ window for
100: investigating the interesting PM state as well as another example for
101: understanding the NFL behavior. In this paper, we investigated the
102: electrodynamic responses of CaRuO$_3$. It was found that $\sigma _1(\omega )$
103: at 10 K follows $\sim 1/\omega ^{\frac 12}$, indicating a NFL behavior. With
104: increasing $T$, the suppression of $\sigma _1(\omega )$ near $\omega \simeq
105: 0 $ develops below the characteristic energy $\omega _c$, which corresponds
106: to a peak structure in $\sigma _1(\omega )$ and shifts to higher frequencies
107: as $T$ increases. It is remarkable that the low frequency optical spectra in
108: a function of $\sigma _1(\omega )/\omega ^{-\frac 12}$ show a $\omega /T$
109: scaling behavior in a very wide $T$ range. While there have been similar
110: scaling behavior reported in some physical properties of other NFL systems,%
111: \cite{aronson95,Schroder98} the $\omega /T$ scaling behavior in ruthenates
112: is the first observation in optical spectra. This scaling indicates that the
113: only characteristic energy scale should be set by $T$ in the PM state of the
114: perovskite ruthenates.
115:
116: \begin{figure}[tbp]
117: \epsfig{file=Fig1.eps,width=3.0in,clip=}
118: \vspace{2mm}
119: \caption{$T$-dependent $\rho (T)$ curves of a CaRuO$_3$ film (open circle)
120: and a SrRuO$_3$ single crystal (open triangle). The data of SrRuO$_3$ are
121: quoted from Ref. [5].}
122: \label{reflectivity}
123: \end{figure}
124:
125: Several CaRuO$_3$ epitaxial films on (100) SrTiO$_3$ substrates were
126: fabricated using 90$^{\text{o}}$ off-axis sputtering techniques.\cite{Eom1}
127: Their thicknesses were about 5000 \AA . To obtain high crystalline quality
128: films with little strain effect, we used vicinal substrates with large
129: miscut angles (4 and 7$^{\text{o}}$). The $dc$ resistivity $\rho (T)$ was
130: measured up to 500 K using the standard four probe method. Figure 1 shows
131: the $\rho (T)$ curve of a film, which is nearly the same as that of a bulk
132: single crystal, including a crossover near around 50 K below which the $T$%
133: -dependence changes from $T^{\frac 12}$ to $T^{\frac 32}$.\cite{Cao97} The
134: 300 K resistivity value of the film is $\sim $ 270 $\mu \Omega $cm,
135: comparable to that of the bulk single crystal value of resistivity $\sim $
136: 200 $\mu \Omega $cm.\cite{Cao97} The resistivity ratio $\rho (300$ K)/$\rho
137: (10$ K) is about 9, indicating the high quality of our film. It is
138: interesting that the $\rho (T)$ in the PM state of the perovskite ruthenates
139: follows a $T^{\frac 12}$-dependence. The $\rho (T)$ of CaRuO$_3$ increases
140: continuously up to 500 K with no saturation, and $\rho (T)$ $\sim T^{\frac 12%
141: }$ above 50 K.\cite{Klein99} Note that, as displayed in Fig. 1, the reported
142: $\rho $ values of a single crystal SrRuO$_3$ in the PM state also show the $%
143: T^{\frac 12}$-dependence.\cite{Allen96} The $T^{\frac 12}$-dependence of $%
144: \rho (T)$ in the perovskite ruthenates is another anomalous feature,
145: distinguished from the linear $T$-dependence of $\rho (T)$ in the normal
146: state of HTS.
147:
148: Near normal incident reflectivity spectra $R(\omega )$ were measured in a
149: wide photon energy region of 5 meV $\sim $ 30 eV. The Kramers-Kronig (K-K)
150: analysis was used to calculate $\sigma _1(\omega )$ from the measured $%
151: R(\omega )$. For K-K transformation, $R(\omega )$ in the low frequency
152: region were extrapolated with the Hagen-Rubens relation. $T$-dependent $%
153: R(\omega )$ were measured in a photon energy region below 6 eV. Above 6 eV,
154: the room temperature $R(\omega )$ was used for high frequency extrapolation.
155: The overall features of the measured $R(\omega )$ were similar to those in
156: SrRuO$_3$ reported by Kostic {\it et al}..\cite{schlesinger98} The
157: calculated $\sigma _1(\omega )$ from the K-K analysis agreed with the
158: experimental $\sigma _1(\omega )$ independently obtained by spectroscopic
159: ellipsometry in the visible region, which demonstrates the validity of our
160: K-K analysis.\cite{yslee01} A high frequency region of $\sigma _1(\omega )$
161: in CaRuO$_3$ were described in our published paper.\cite{lee01} In the
162: paper, we focus on the far-IR region.
163:
164: Figure 2 shows $T$-dependent $\sigma _1(\omega )$ in the far-IR region. The
165: peak at $\sim $ 570 cm$^{-1}$ is due to a transverse optic phonon mode,
166: whose $T$-dependence is rather weak. Interestingly, $\sigma _1(\omega )$ at
167: 10 K shows a clear NFL behavior, deviating from that of conventional metals.
168: As shown in the inset of Fig. 2, $\sigma _1(\omega )$ at 10 K is
169: proportional to 1/$\omega ^{\frac 12}$,\cite{footnote1} which is much slower
170: than the frequency dependence of a Fermi liquid of 1/$\omega ^2$. Even at a
171: higher $T$, the 1/$\omega ^{\frac 12}$-dependence in $\sigma _1(\omega )$ is
172: retained in the high frequency region, which might be correlated with the $%
173: T^{\frac 12}$-dependence of $\rho (T)$ at high temperatures. A similar NFL
174: behavior was also observed in SrRuO$_3$.\cite{schlesinger98} It is
175: interesting that the 1/$\omega ^{\frac 12}$-dependence in $\sigma _1(\omega
176: ) $ can be observed in perovskite ruthenates with different magnetic ground
177: states.
178:
179: \begin{figure}[tbp]
180: \epsfig{file=Fig2.eps,width=3.0in,clip=}
181: \vspace{2mm}
182: \caption{$T$-dependenct $\sigma _1(\omega )$ of CaRuO$_3$ below 1500 cm$%
183: ^{-1} $. The solid circle symbols represent $\omega _c$. The solid triangle,
184: the solid square, and the solid circle symbols on the $y$-axis represent the
185: $dc$ value of $\sigma (T)$ at 100, 300, and 500 K, respectively. The dotted
186: lines are $\sigma _1(\omega )$ obtained from the Hagen-Rubens
187: extrapolations. In the inset, $\sigma _1(\omega )$ at 10, 200, 500 K follow
188: 1/$\omega ^{\frac 12}$ above $\omega _c$. For clarity, the $\sigma _1(\omega
189: )$ at 200 K and 500 K are multiplied by a factor of 0.85 and 0.7,
190: respectively. The dotted lines are guidelines for 1/$\omega ^{\frac 12}$%
191: -dependence.}
192: \label{conductivity1}
193: \end{figure}
194:
195: The suppression in $\sigma _1(\omega )$ is observed near $\omega \simeq 0$
196: at higher $T$. As $\omega $ decreases from the high frequency side, $\sigma
197: _1(\omega )$ increase initially but decrease below the peak frequency $%
198: \omega _c$, approaching smoothly to the measured {\it dc} conductivity
199: values. This feature is clear even at 100 K, where the {\it dc} conductivity
200: value is rather high by $\sim $ 7000 $\Omega ^{-1}$cm$^{-1}$. It is noted
201: that in the case of SrRuO$_3$, the low frequency suppression occurs only in
202: its PM state, not in its FM state.\cite{dodge00} Together with the $T^{\frac
203: 12}$-dependence of $\rho (T)$, the low-energy suppression in $\sigma
204: _1(\omega )$ can be regarded as a generic feature of the PM state of the
205: perovskite ruthenates.
206:
207: Note that the low-energy suppression of $\sigma _1(\omega )$ shows an
208: interesting $T$-dependent evolution. As $T$ increases, the suppression
209: feature becomes clear and $\omega _c$ shifts to a higher frequency linearly
210: with $T$. It is evident that the peak structure does not arise from
211: electronic transitions or disorder effects. The values of $\omega _c$ are
212: comparable with a thermal energy, $k_BT$. This energy scale is too low for a
213: typical interband transition.\cite{lee01} A similar suppression in $\sigma
214: _1(\omega )$ near $\omega \simeq 0$ has been often observed in highly
215: disordered systems, but their characteristic energy scale is expected to
216: decrease with increasing $T$,\cite{basov98} which is the opposite to our
217: case. Therefore, a thermal energy scale of a pseudogap-like feature observed
218: in CaRuO$_3$ is quite unique.
219:
220: The pseudogap-like feature could be closely related to nearly ferromagnetic
221: characteristics of CaRuO$_3$. Several experimental and theoretical evidences
222: suggest that CaRuO$_3$ should be nearly ferromagnetic.\cite
223: {Yoshimura99,cava01,Mazin97} A strong FM fluctuation was also observed in
224: the PM state of SrRuO$_3$.\cite{Yoshimura99} Especially, local density
225: functional calculations on (Ca,Sr)RuO$_3$ showed that the lattice
226: distortions associated with different ionic sizes are crucial in determining
227: the magnetic properties.\cite{Mazin97} Further, phonon anomalies at $T_c$
228: were observed in SrRuO$_3$, indicating the strong spin-lattice interaction.%
229: \cite{Iliev99} These imply that the lattice degree of freedom is strongly
230: coupled to the magnetic ordering so that the excitation of a relevant phonon
231: mode can be responsible for the local magnetic fluctuation in the nearly FM
232: system. From the spin fluctuation theory of nearly ferromagnetic materials,%
233: \cite{moriya} it is known that the mean-square amplitude of spin-fluctuation
234: increases linearly in proportion to $T$. Thus, one may expect the low-energy
235: quasiparticle excitations to be strongly renormalized by the thermally
236: induced spin-fluctuations with spin-lattice coupling, where such $T$%
237: -dependent renormalization might be relevant to the suppression of $\sigma
238: _1(\omega )$ in the low frequency region. It is noted that the
239: pseudogap-like feature in $\sigma _1(\omega )$ of CaRuO$_3$ and its
240: proximity to the FM instability is quite analogous to the situation in HTS,
241: which is close to the antiferromagnetic instability.\cite{Manske01}
242:
243: Now, we show that from the systematic $T$-dependent evolution of the low
244: frequency suppression in $\sigma _1(\omega )$, an interesting $\omega /T$
245: scaling behavior can occur in the perovskite ruthenates. The low frequency
246: suppression in $\sigma _1(\omega )$ can be expressed as a deviation from the
247: 1/$\omega ^{\frac 12}$-dependence. As shown in the inset of Fig. 2, the
248: deviation region of $\sigma _1(\omega )$ from 1/$\omega ^{\frac 12}$%
249: -dependence becomes wider with increasing $T$, consistent with the shift of $%
250: \omega _c$ to higher frequency. To check the possibility of scaling
251: behavior, we plotted $\sigma _1(\omega )/a\omega ^{-\frac 12}$ vs. $\omega
252: /T $. With the value of the coefficient $a$ adopted for the scaling, the $%
253: \sigma _1(\omega )$ at 10 K was reproduced. As shown in Fig. 3, all of the
254: normalized conductivity spectra collapse onto a single line.\cite{footnote3}
255: It is noted that this scaling behavior persists up to a rather high
256: temperature, 500 K. The $\omega /T$ scaling behavior means that the $T$%
257: -dependent suppression behavior could be determined only by $T$, indicating
258:
259: \begin{equation}
260: \sigma _1(\omega )\sim 1/\omega ^{\frac 12}\cdot Z(\omega /T)\text{,}
261: \end{equation}
262: or
263: \begin{equation}
264: \sigma _1(\omega )T^{\frac 12}\sim (T/\omega )^{\frac 12}\cdot Z(\omega /T)%
265: \text{,}
266: \end{equation}
267: The scaling function $Z(\omega /T)$ is fitted quite well with $Z(\omega
268: /T)=\tanh (\beta \omega /T)$, with $\beta =1.6$. Clearly, Eq. (1) and (2)
269: are closely related to the characteristic properties in the PM states, such
270: as $\rho (T)\sim T^{\frac 12}$ and $\sigma _1(\omega )\sim 1/\omega ^{\frac 1%
271: 2}$ at high frequencies. We also plotted the SrRuO$_3$ $\sigma _1(\omega )$
272: data in the PM region (i.e., at 185 K, 225 K, and 250 K) reported by Kostic
273: {\it et al}..\cite{schlesinger98} Interestingly, the normalized spectra of
274: SrRuO$_3$ fall on the scaling curve. This indicates that the scaling
275: function shown in Fig. 3 could be applied to other perovskite ruthenates.
276:
277: \begin{figure}[tbp]
278: \epsfig{file=Fig3.eps,width=3.0in,clip=}
279: \vspace{2mm}
280: \caption{$T$-dependent $\sigma _1(\omega )/a\omega ^{-\frac 12}$ with $%
281: \omega /T$ as the abscissa. The open circle, open trigonal, and cross
282: symbols are for the 185 K, 225 K, and 250 K spectra of SrRuO$_3$,
283: respectively, quoted from Ref. [7]. For SrRuO$_3$, the value of $a$ was
284: adopted to reproduce the 40 K $\sigma _1(\omega )$. The solid line
285: represents $Z(\omega /T) = \tanh(1.6\omega/T)$. }
286: \label{scaling behavior}
287: \end{figure}
288:
289: While the $\omega /T$ scaling behavior in $\sigma _1(\omega )$ of the
290: perovskite ruthenates is quite unique, it is noted that similar
291: scale-invariance has also been observed in some physical properties of other
292: NFL systems, such as some $f$-electron compounds\cite{aronson95} and HTS.%
293: \cite{Schroder98} The scaling behaviors in these NFL systems indicate that
294: the only characteristic energy scale is determined by $T$, a possible origin
295: of which was suggested to be the quantum critical fluctuation associated
296: with the zero temperature phase transition.\cite{Sachdev99} Similar to other
297: NFL\ systems, our $\omega /T$ scaling behavior in $\sigma _1(\omega )$ may
298: suggest a quantum critical point between the ferromagnetic and paramagnetic
299: phases in the perovskite ruthnates: The ferromagnetic transition temperature
300: $T_c$ is decreased as $x$ is increased in Sr$_{1-x}$Ca$_x$RuO$_3$ and is
301: completely suppressed in CaRuO$_3$, and a quantum critical point is expected
302: at an appropriate value of $x=x_c$.\cite{Cao97,Fukunaga94} We note that,
303: consistent with the magnetic quantum phase transition, the previous low $T$
304: transport measurements hinted a phase transition from a Fermi liquid
305: behavior for SrRuO$_3$ to a NFL behavior for CaRuO$_3$.\cite
306: {Fukunaga94,Capogna02} Motivated by our observation, understanding the
307: origin of the NFL behavior associated with the $\omega /T$ scaling in $%
308: \sigma _1(\omega )$ and its possible relation with the quantum criticality
309: is a challenging issue in the future study of perovskite ruthenates.
310:
311: In summary, the optical spectra of the nearly ferromagnetic CaRuO$_3$ shows
312: non-Fermi liquid behavior and a scaling in the low frequency suppression.
313: Its $\sigma _1(\omega )$ follow the $1/\omega ^{\frac 12}$-dependence,
314: similar to the case of SrRuO$_3$. From the $T$-dependent evolution of the
315: low frequency suppression, it is observed that the $\sigma _1(\omega )$
316: normalized by the $1/\omega ^{\frac 12}$ can be scaled with $\omega /T$ at
317: all temperatures, indicating that only characteristic energy scale is
318: determined by $T$. The $\omega /T$ scaling coupled with the non-Fermi liquid
319: behavior is expected to provide further insights into understanding the
320: unusual electrodynamics of the ruthenates.
321:
322: We thank Yunkyu Bang, J. E. Han, In-Sang Yang, Philip B. Allen, J. H. Kim,
323: and K. H. Kim for helpful discussions. We also thank PAL and NCIRF for
324: allowing us to use some of their facilities. This work was supported by
325: Ministry of Science and Technology through the Creative Research Initiative
326: program, and by KOSEF through CSCMR. THG and HYC acknowledge the support
327: from KOSEF through Grant No.\ 1999-2-11400-005-5.
328:
329: \begin{references}
330: \bibitem{FL87} D. Pines and P. Nozieres, {\it The Theory of Quantum Liquid,
331: Vol 1: Normal Fermi liquids} (Addison-Wesley, Reading, MA, 1987).
332:
333: \bibitem{orenstein00} J. Orenstein and A. J. Millis, Science {\bf 288}, 468
334: (2000).
335:
336: \bibitem{Varma89} C. M. Varma, P. B. Littlewood, S. Schmitt-Rink, E.
337: Abrahams, and A. E. Ruckenstein, Phys. Rev. Lett. {\bf 63}, 1996 (1989).
338:
339: \bibitem{lee01} J. S. Lee, Y. S. Lee, T. W. Noh, K. Char, J. Park, S. J.
340: Oh, J. H. Park, C. B. Eom, T. Takeda, and R. Kanno, Phys. Rev. B {\bf 64},
341: 245107 (2001), and the references therein.
342:
343: \bibitem{Allen96} P. B. Allen, H. Berger, O. Chauvet, L. Forro, T.
344: Jarlborg, A. Junod, B. Revaz, and G. Santi, Phys. Rev. B {\bf 53}, 4393
345: (1996).
346:
347: \bibitem{Klein99} L. Klein, L. Antognazza, T. H. Geballe, M. R. Beasley,
348: and A. Kapitulnik, Phys. Rev. B {\bf 60}, 1448 (1999).
349:
350: \bibitem{schlesinger98} P. Kostic, Y. Okada, N. C. Collins, Z. Schlesinger,
351: J. W. Reiner, L. Klein, A. Kapitulnik, T. H. Geballe, and M. R. Beasley,
352: Phys. Rev. Lett. {\bf 81}, 2498 (1998).
353:
354: \bibitem{dodge00} J. S. Dodge, C. P. Weber, J. Corson, J. Orenstein, Z.
355: Schlesinger, J. W. Reiner, and M. R. Beasley, Phys. Rev. Lett. {\bf 85},
356: 4932 (2000).
357:
358: \bibitem{Cao97} G. Cao, S. McCall, M. Shepard, J. E. Crow, and R. P.
359: Guertin, Phys. Rev. B {\bf 56}, 321 (1997).
360:
361: \bibitem{aronson95} M. C. Aronson, R. Osborn, R. A. Robinson, J. W. Lynn,
362: R.Chau, C. L. Seaman, and M. B. Maple, Phys. Rev. Lett. {\bf 75}, 725 (1995).
363:
364: \bibitem{Schroder98} A. Schr\"{o}der, G. Aeppli, E. Bucher, R.
365: Ramazashvili, and P. Coleman, Phys. Rev. Lett. {\bf 80}, 5623 (1998). T.
366: Valla, A. V. Fedorov, P. D. Johnson, B. O. Wells, S. L. Hulbert, Q. Li, G.
367: D. Gu, and N. Koshizuka, Science {\bf 285}, 2110 (1999).
368:
369: \bibitem{Eom1} C. B. Eom, R. J. Cava, R. M. Fleming, J. M. Phillips, R. B.
370: van Dover, J. H. Marshall, J. W. P. Hsu, J. J. Krajewski, and W. F. Peck,
371: Jr., Science {\bf 258}, 1766 (1992). R. A. Rao, Q. Gan, C. B. Eom, R. J.
372: Cava, Y. Suzuki, J. J, Krajewski, S. C. Gausepohl, and M. Lee, Appl. Phys.
373: Lett. {\bf 70}, 3035 (1997).
374:
375: \bibitem{yslee01} Y. S. Lee, J. S. Lee, K. W. Kim, T. W. Noh, J. Yu, Y.
376: Bang, M. K. Lee, and C. B. Eom, Phys. Rev. B {\bf 64}, 165109 (2001).
377:
378: \bibitem{footnote1} From the extended Drude model analysis, it is found
379: that the frequency-dependent scattering rate at 10 K follows the $\omega ^{%
380: \frac 12}$-dependence with the correlation to the $1/\omega ^{\frac 12}$%
381: -dependence in $\sigma _1(\omega )$.
382:
383: \bibitem{basov98} D. N. Basov, B. Dabrowski, and T. Timusk, Phys. Rev.
384: Lett. {\bf 81}, 2132 (1998). A. Gold, S. J. Allen, B. A. Wilson, and D. C.
385: Tsui, Phys. Rev. B {\bf 25}, 3519 (1982).
386:
387: \bibitem{Yoshimura99} K. Yoshimura, T. Imai, T. Kiyama, K. R. Thurber, A.
388: W. Hunt, and K. Kosuge, Phys. Rev. Lett. {\bf 83}, 4397 (1999).
389:
390: \bibitem{cava01} T. He and R. J. Cava, Phys. Rev. B {\bf 63}, 172403 (2001).
391:
392: \bibitem{Mazin97} I. I. Mazin and D. J. Singh, Phys. Rev. B {\bf 56}, 2556
393: (1997).
394:
395: \bibitem{Iliev99} M. N. Iliev, A. P. Litvinchuk, H.-G. Lee, C. L. Chen, M.
396: L. Dezaneti, C. W. Chu, V. G. Ivanov, M. V. Abrashev, and V. N. Popov, Phys.
397: Rev. B {\bf 59}, 364 (1999).
398:
399: \bibitem{moriya} T. Morya, {\it Spin Fluctuations in Itinerant Electron
400: Magnetism}~(Springer-Verlag, New York, 1985).
401:
402: \bibitem{Manske01} D. Manske, I. Eremin, and K. H. Bennemann, Phys. Rev.
403: Lett. {\bf 87}, 177005 (2001).
404:
405: \bibitem{footnote3} It is not clear that even the 10 K $\sigma _1(\omega )$
406: follows the scaling behavior. If so, this might be observed below 20 cm$^{-1}
407: $, where is beyond the experimental region.
408:
409: \bibitem{Sachdev99} S. Sachdev, {\it Quantum Phase Transition} (Cambridge
410: Univ. Press, Cambridge, 1999).
411:
412: \bibitem{Fukunaga94} F. Fukunaga and N. Tsuda, J. Phy. Soc. Jpn {\bf 63},
413: 3798 (1994).
414:
415: \bibitem{Capogna02} L. Capogna, A. P. Mackenzie, R. S. Perry, S. A.
416: Grigera, L. M. Galvin, P. Raychaudhuri, A. J. Schofield, C. S. Alexander, G.
417: Cao, S. R. Jullian, and Y. Maeno, Phy. Rev. Lett. {\bf 88}, 76602 (2002).
418: \end{references}
419:
420: \end{document}
421: