1: \documentclass[12pt]{iopart}
2:
3: \usepackage{graphicx}
4: \usepackage{verbatim}
5: \usepackage{color}
6: \usepackage{subfigure}
7: \usepackage{dcolumn}
8: \usepackage{bm}
9: \usepackage[dvips]{epsfig}
10: \usepackage{bbm}
11:
12:
13: \begin{document}
14:
15: \title[Collective dynamics in crystalline polymorphs of ZnCl$_{2}$...]{Collective dynamics in crystalline polymorphs of ZnCl$_{2}$: potential modelling and inelastic neutron scattering study}
16:
17: \author{A Sen\footnote[1]{Present address: Department of Physics, Indian Institute of Technology, Kanpur 208016, India}
18: \footnote[2]{Email: asen@iitk.ac.in}, Mala N. Rao, R Mittal and S. L. Chaplot\footnote[3]{Email: chaplot@magnum.barc.ernet.in}}
19:
20: \address{Solid State Physics Division, Bhabha Atomic Research Centre,
21: Trombay, Mumbai 400085, India}
22:
23: \begin{abstract}
24: We report a phonon density of states measurement of $\alpha$-ZnCl$_{2}$
25: using the coherent inelastic neutron scattering technique and a lattice
26: dynamical calculation in four crystalline phases of ZnCl$_{2}$ using a
27: transferable interatomic potential. The model calculations agree
28: reasonably well with the available experimental data on the structures,
29: specific heat, Raman frequencies and their pressure variation in various
30: crystalline phases. The calculated results have been able to provide a
31: fair description of the vibrational as well as the thermodynamic
32: properties of ZnCl$_{2}$ in all its four phases.
33: \end{abstract}
34:
35: \pacs{63.20.Dj, 78.70.Nx, 64.30.+t, 65.40.De}
36:
37:
38: \section{Introduction}
39: Among the metal halides of form MX$_{2}$ (M: metal, X: halide),
40: ZnCl$_{2}$ continues to draw attention in current research for several
41: reasons. Firstly, the crystalline ZnCl$_{2}$ has four structurally
42: determined polymorphs\cite{breh,bryn} at the ambient pressure, viz.
43: $\alpha$-ZnCl$_{2}$ ($I\bar{4}2d$, Z=4], $\beta$-ZnCl$_{2}$ ($P2_{1}/n$,
44: Z=12), $\gamma$-ZnCl$_{2}$ ($P4_{2}/nmc$, Z=2), and $\delta$-ZnCl$_{2}$
45: ($Pna2_{1}$, Z=4) in which the Zn atom is tetrahedrally coordinated with
46: Cl atoms. Secondly, ZnCl$_{2}$ displays unique phase transitions upon
47: compression as well as pressure release.
48: For instance, the four-coordinated $\alpha$-ZnCl$_{2}$ transforms into a
49: six-coordinated CdCl$_{2}$-like phase at 2.1 GPa, which further
50: converts into four-coordinated $\gamma$-ZnCl$_{2}$ upon decompression\cite{saka}.
51: Thirdly, molten ZnCl$_{2}$, which is commercially used as a solvent and
52: catalyst in the hydro cracking of coal slurries and heavy
53: crude oil fractions\cite{gard}, typifies high viscosity\cite{mcke,grub,wood}, low
54: ionic diffusivities\cite{bock}, and very low electric
55: conductivity\cite{duke} due mainly to its non-uniform polymeric network
56: linkage.\cite{ribe1} Further, liquid ZnCl$_{2}$ has the ability to
57: supercool into a glass\cite{smith} at a relatively low glass transition
58: temperature (T$_{g}$ = 375 K). Finally, ZnCl$_{2}$ glass, which is
59: intermediate between strong (e.g. SiO$_{2}$) and fragile (e.g. CKN)
60: glasses, finds its potential use as a low-loss optical transmission
61: medium in the near infrared region.\cite{bryan}
62:
63: \vspace{0.2cm}
64: \parindent 0.8cm
65: All the crystalline phases of ZnCl$_{2}$ at ambient pressure are formed
66: by the network of ZnCl$_{4}$ tetrahedra sharing their corners. But this
67: network is rather soft (unlike SiO$_{2}$ or BeF$_{2}$) resulting in a
68: strongly hybridized character for the normal modes of
69: vibration.\cite{smith} Further, in the low frequency range ($<$ 20
70: cm$^{-1}$), where the collective acoustic modes are expected to dominate
71: the vibrational density of states, liquid ZnCl$_{2}$ exhibits a
72: prominent boson peak\cite{lebon,kart} reflecting its more complex
73: microstructure. Ribero et al.\cite{ribe2} examined the nature of
74: instantaneous normal modes in the atomic motion of liquid ZnCl$_{2}$,
75: which involve the coupled vibration of several quasi-molecular
76: ZnCl$_{4}$ units of the network and has the local torsional character.
77: \vspace{0.2cm}
78: \parindent 0.8cm
79: Although molecular dynamics (MD) and Monte Carlo (MC) simulations have
80: been reported for glassy as well as molten ZnCl$_{2}$, the need for a
81: realistic interatomic potential has remained unfulfilled.\cite{yann} The
82: present work is primarily intended to make an attempt in formulating an
83: effective transferable interatomic potential that can be applied to any
84: of the polymorphs of ZnCl$_{2}$ with equal ease. Angell et
85: al.\cite{ang1} had already suggested that there is little distinction
86: between the glassy and the crystalline behavior of ZnCl$_{2}$ so far as
87: the dynamics is concerned. They further opined that the short time
88: dynamics of liquid ZnCl$_{2}$ near its melting point (T$_{m}$ = 593 K)
89: might be regarded as solid-like in character. Later on, X-ray
90: diffraction measurements of molten ZnCl$_{2}$ by Triolo and
91: Narten\cite{trio} favored this argument strongly. Anomalously low
92: enthalpy and volume changes on fusion are supposed to be behind the
93: resemblance of ZnCl$_{2}$ melt with the crystalline
94: structure.\cite{gard} An extensive neutron diffraction study by Desa et
95: al.\cite{erw} further showed that vitreous ZnCl$_{2}$ has a distorted
96: closed packed array of Cl atoms in which Zn atoms are randomly
97: distributed in the tetrahedral sites. Numerous such studies undoubtedly
98: imply that if we are able to understand the dynamical properties of
99: crystalline polymorphs of ZnCl$_{2}$, microscopic interpretation for
100: glassy and molten phases will also be robust. In the present work we
101: have also determined the phonon density of states in the $\alpha$-phase
102: by coherent inelastic neutron scattering. The potential model
103: calculation is found to be in fair agreement with the neutron data.
104:
105: \section{Crystal structure}
106: Till 1961, it was commonly believed that the ambient stable phase of
107: ZnCl$_{2}$ had a layered structure in which each Zn atom was coordinated
108: to six Cl atoms to form regular octahedra with van der Waals bonding
109: between the layers.\cite{paul} Later investigations proved that
110: ZnCl$_{2}$ has bonding based on a tetrahedral framework. Initially three
111: solid phases of ZnCl$_{2}$ were known crystallographically. These were
112: $\alpha$, $\beta$ and $\gamma$ polymorphs of ZnCl$_{2}$ belonging to
113: monoclinic and tetragonal crystal classes (Table~\ref{tab1}). While
114: $\alpha$ and $\beta$ phases have cristobalite type three dimensional
115: networks of corner linked tetrahedra\cite{breh}, $\gamma$-ZnCl$_{2}$
116: crystallizes to a layered structure of cross linking tetrahedra as in
117: case of red HgI$_{2}$.\cite{osw} However, in 1978, Brynestad and
118: Yakel\cite{bryn,yak} pointed out that all three modifications are rather
119: the result of water contamination and that purely anhydrous ZnCl$_{2}$
120: has an orthorhombic unit cell containing corner linked ZnCl$_{4}$
121: tetrahedra. This orthorhombic phase has been referred to as
122: $\delta$-ZnCl$_{2}$ in various papers.\cite{saka,erw} Fig.~\ref{fig1}
123: suggests that the close packed layers in $\delta$-ZnCl$_{2}$ are
124: horizontal. Further, temperature has a significant impact\cite{ang2} on
125: the structure of ZnCl$_{2}$. While rapid cooling of the melt (or
126: devitrification of the glass) produces the $\alpha$-phase, slow cooling
127: of the melt favors the formation of $\beta$-ZnCl$_{2}$. On the other
128: hand, concentrated solution yields the $\gamma$-phase upon
129: crystallization.
130:
131: \section{Experiments and data analysis}
132: Experimental studies involving crystalline ZnCl$_{2}$ encounter
133: difficulties because of its extreme hygroscopicity. The reagent grade
134: chemical ZnCl$_{2}$ (purity 98\%), purchased from Merck Chemical Co.
135: (Germany), was dried for a period of 8 hours. It was then exposed into
136: the glove box under dry argon atmosphere for transferring into different
137: containers. About 30 g of the polycrystalline ZnCl$_{2}$ sample so
138: obtained was placed in a thin walled aluminum sample holder of circular
139: shape for the inelastic neutron scattering (INS) studies. Another
140: cylindrical vanadium can was made use of for taking the neutron
141: diffraction pattern of the same sample. Neutron powder diffraction
142: confirmed that the sample belongs to the $\alpha$-phase. The structural
143: refinements of the powder data were carried out using the Rietveld
144: profile refinement method with the program DBWS 9411.\cite{young} The
145: cell constants and atomic coordinates refined from the data recorded at
146: 300 K are in close agreement with the reported data.\cite{breh}
147:
148: \vspace{0.2cm}
149: \parindent 0.8cm
150: Inelastic neutron scattering measurements were carried out at 300 K
151: using a medium resolution triple-axis spectrometer\cite{chap3} at the
152: Dhruva Reactor, Trombay. The instrument used a monochromated beam of
153: neutrons produced by diffraction from the (111) planes of a copper
154: crystal. Neutrons scattered inelastically by the sample were again
155: diffracted by a pyrolytic graphite (002) analyzer and subsequently
156: detected in a $^{10}BF_{3}$ proportional counter. All the measurements
157: were made in the energy loss mode with constant momentum transfer ($\bf{Q}$).
158: The elastic energy resolution was about 15\% of the initial energy.
159: Several scans were performed with the final energy
160: ($E_{f}$) values of 30 meV and $\bf{Q}$ values of
161: 5 to 6 \AA$^{-1}$ that are much larger than the size of the Brillouin zone (about 1 \AA$^{-1}$). Additional
162: measurements of the neutron background were made by
163: detuning the analyzer crystal from the position by
164: $\pm 5^{o}$ and repeating the scan for the same
165: sample.
166:
167: \vspace{0.2cm}
168: \parindent 0.8cm
169: The neutron weighted phonon density of states, $g^{n}(E)$, are obtained
170: from the measured scattering function $S(\bf{Q},E)$ through the
171: following relation\cite{price}
172: \begin{eqnarray}
173: g^{n}(E) = A \left\langle {e^{2W(Q)} \over Q^2} {E\over n(E,T) + 1} S(\bf{Q}, E) \right\rangle \\
174: \approx B \sum_{p} {{4\pi b_{p}^2}\over M_{p}}g_{p}(E)
175: \label{eq5}
176: \end{eqnarray}
177: where $n(E,T)$ = $[exp(E/KT)-1]^{-1}$; $A$, $B$ are normalization
178: constants; $2W(Q)$ is the Debye-Waller factor; $b_{p}$, $M_{p}$, and
179: $g_{p}(E)$ refer respectively to the neutron scattering length, mass and
180: partial phonon density of states of the $p^{th}$ atom in the unit cell.
181: The quantity within $\left\langle...\right\rangle$ represents the
182: average over all $\bf{Q}$ values. The factor ${4\pi b_{p}^2}\over M_{p}$
183: turns out to be 0.063 and 0.474 barn/a.m.u. for Zn and Cl atoms
184: respectively.
185:
186:
187: \section{Model interatomic potential}
188: As previously stated, there is a need to formulate a
189: realistic potential model that can effectively model the structure
190: and dynamics in various polymorphs of ZnCl$_{2}$. In the present
191: model, Born-Mayer repulsive and attractive van der Waals
192: interactions among different pairs of atoms have been
193: incorporated. Because of the covalent nature of the Zn-Cl
194: bond, a stretching term has to be included further in the
195: potential model. The model thus turns out to be
196: \begin{equation}
197: V(r) = A\hspace{0.1cm} exp\left[ -\frac{B\hspace{0.1cm}r}{R(k)+R(k')}
198: \right] - \frac{C_{kk'}}{r^6} - D\hspace{0.1cm} exp\left[
199: -{n{(r-r_{0})^2}\over 2r} \right] \label{eq1}
200: \end{equation}
201: where $A$ (=1822 eV) and $B$ (=12.364) are two constants, used
202: extensively in several previous works.\cite{chap1,mala,mittal}; $R(k)$
203: and $R(k')$ refer to effective radius parameters for Zn and Cl atoms.
204: $C_{kk'}$ accounts for van der Waals terms between Zn-Zn, Zn-Cl and
205: Cl-Cl atoms; $r_{0}$ is the equilibrium Zn-Cl bond length; $D$ and $n$
206: are two adjustable parameters.
207: At the observed lattice constants and atomic
208: positions in the unit cell, the parameters were so adjusted as to give nearly
209: a zero internal stress and net force on each individual atom. Once the structural constraints are
210: met, the potential parameters were further adjusted
211: so that the calculated eigen frequencies are real
212: for all the wave vectors in the entire Brillouin zone. The
213: group theoretical analysis provides the symmetry
214: vectors necessary for block diagonalization of the
215: dynamical matrix. Table~\ref{tab2} lists the final values
216: of the optimized parameters. All the necessary calculations were made
217: using DISPR\cite{chap2} developed at Trombay. Lattice parameters and atomic
218: coordinates obtained as a result of the potential minimization for various polymorphs
219: of ZnCl$_{2}$ are displayed in Tables{~\ref{tab3a},~\ref{tab3b},~\ref{tab3c} \& ~\ref{tab3d}}.
220: At high pressures, the equilibrium crystal structures were obtained
221: from the free energy minimization.
222:
223: \section{Vibrational modes: Raman and infrared active}
224: A group theoretical classification of various zone-center phonon modes
225: for each of the crystalline modifications in ZnCl$_{2}$ is given in
226: Table~\ref{tab1}. Experimental mode assignments are available for only
227: two polymorphs of ZnCl$_{2}$ (viz. $\alpha$-ZnCl$_{2}$ and
228: $\gamma$-ZnCl$_{2}$). Measured optical phonon
229: data\cite{saka,yann,ang2,james} are found to be in good agreement with
230: our calculated results (Tables{~\ref{tab4a},~\ref{tab4b},~\ref{tab4c} \&
231: ~\ref{tab4d}}). It may be noted that the lowest frequency mode in the
232: $\gamma$-phase (36 cm$^{-1}$) is almost half the frequency of that in
233: the $\alpha$-phase (80 cm$^{-1}$). Further the pressure dependence of
234: Raman modes in $\alpha$, $\gamma$ and $\delta$ forms of ZnCl$_{2}$ are
235: calculated. Except for the $\alpha$-phase, in all the others, the
236: calculated pressure dependence compares well with the available
237: measured\cite{saka,pols} data (see Fig.~\ref{fig2}). Since
238: $\beta$-ZnCl$_{2}$ has as many as 108 phonon modes, pressure dependence
239: of these modes is not shown here.
240:
241: \section{Phonon dispersion relations and phonon density of states in $\alpha$-ZnCl$_{2}$ }
242:
243: As Table~\ref{tab1} suggests, there is a total of 18 degrees of
244: freedom in $\alpha$-ZnCl$_{2}$, giving rise to 18 phonon
245: frequencies. Following are the representations of normal modes
246: along the three high symmetry directions (viz. $\Sigma$, $\Lambda$
247: and $\Delta$).
248: \begin{center}
249: $\Sigma(100)$: 8$\Sigma_{1}$ + 10$\Sigma_{2}$\\
250: $\Lambda(001)$: 4$\Lambda_{1}$ + 4$\Lambda_{2}$ + 5$\Lambda_{3}$ ($\Lambda_{3}$ being doubly degenerate)\\
251: $\Delta(110)$: 9$\Delta_{1}$ + 9$\Delta_{2}$\\
252: \end{center}
253: Fig.~\ref{fig3} displays the calculated phonon dispersion relations in
254: $\alpha$-ZnCl$_{2}$. Considerable dispersion and anti-crossing are found
255: for the branch in all the three symmetry directions which indicate
256: strong hybridization. There are no indications of any phonon softening
257: in the calculations in any of the four polymorphs at ambient pressure.
258:
259: \vspace{0.2cm}
260: \parindent 0.8cm
261: We have plotted the measured phonon density of states along with
262: the calculated spectrum in Fig.~\ref{fig4}. The experimental one-phonon spectra are
263: obtained by subtracting the multiphonon contribution from the
264: experimental data. The multiphonon contribution is obtained using the
265: Sjolander formalism.\cite{sjol} The experimental data (Fig.~\ref{fig4})
266: confirm two broad structures with a band gap around 25 meV. The measured
267: neutron data\cite{gal} for vitreous ZnCl$_{2}$ and the Raman density of
268: states data\cite{alio} for molten ZnCl$_{2}$ are qualitatively similar
269: to the present neutron data on crystalline $\alpha$-ZnCl$_{2}$.
270: \vspace{0.2cm}
271: \parindent 0.8cm
272: The computed partial phonon density of states is shown in Fig 5(a). This
273: indicates that the Zn ions contribute significantly at energies below 10 meV
274: while from 10 meV to 19 meV, the vibrations of Cl ions dominate.
275: However, in the higher energy region, contributions from both the ions
276: remain more or less similar. A comparison of the calculated phonon
277: density of states for all the crystalline polymorphs is shown in Fig.
278: 5(b). Two band gaps (a broad one around 23 meV and a very narrow one
279: around 36 meV) are observed in each of the phases, though of slightly
280: varying degree. For these calculations, all the phonon modes are
281: integrated at each wave vector within the irreducible Brillouin zone on
282: a $10\times10\times10$ mesh with an energy resolution of 1.0 meV.
283:
284: \section{Thermodynamic properties}
285:
286: \subsection{Heat capacity and Debye temperature}
287: As Fig.~\ref{fig6}(a) suggests, there is a fairly good agreement
288: between the calculated and the experimental data\cite{ang3} on the molar heat capacity.
289: As the inset shows, there is vary small variation among heat capacities of various polymorphs, which reflects
290: the small variation in the respective phonon density of states. In particular, the spike in $\Delta C_{p}$ at about
291: 50 K in the inset of Fig.~\ref{fig6}(a) arises due to the different phonon density of states of the $\alpha$-phase
292: at low energy in Fig.~\ref{fig5}(b). Fig.~\ref{fig6}(b) displays the Debye temperature ($\theta_{D}$) plot
293: for different crystalline modifications in ZnCl$_{2}$. The characteristic Debye temperature in the present model turns out to be 375 K, while the experimental value is 340 K\cite{ang3}.
294:
295:
296: \subsection{Mode Gr\"uneisen parameters and thermal expansion}
297: The mode Gr\"uneisen parameters are important indicators of the
298: anharmonicity of phonon modes and their role in determining the thermal
299: expansion. For the i$^{th}$ mode the Gr\"uneisen parameter is given by
300:
301: \begin{equation}
302: \gamma_{i} = - {\partial ln~\omega_{i}\over\partial ln~V}
303: \label{eq3}
304: \end{equation}
305:
306: In the quasiharmonic approximation, the ${\it i}$th phonon mode contributes ($1
307: \over BV$)$\gamma_{i}$C$_{Vi}$ to the volume thermal expansion
308: ($\alpha_{V}$), where $C_{Vi}$ denotes the contribution of the $i^{th}$
309: mode to the volume heat capacity. As heat capacity and bulk modulus
310: values remain similar for each of the polymorphs, it is obviously the
311: mode Gr\"uneisen parameter which dominates in the determination of
312: $\alpha_{V}$. Fig.~\ref{fig7} displays averaged $\gamma_{i}$ as a
313: function of phonon energy for different crystalline polymorphs in
314: ZnCl$_{2}$. One may notice that while for $\alpha$, $\beta$ and $\delta$
315: phases, 18 meV phonons have maximum variations with volume,
316: $\gamma$-ZnCl$_{2}$ behaves slightly differently. This is further
317: reflected in the subsequent thermal expansion calculation (see
318: Fig.~\ref{fig7}).
319:
320: \subsection{Equation of state}
321: The crystal structure parameters as a function of pressure (at T=0 K)
322: are calculated corresponding to the minimum of Gibbs free energy.
323: Fig.~\ref{fig8} shows how the cell dimensions belonging to different
324: crystalline polymorphs of ZnCl$_{2}$ vary with pressure. It is observed
325: that the compressibility is anisotropic. While $\bf{c}$ axis is the most
326: compressible in $\beta$ and $\gamma$ forms of ZnCl$_{2}$, it is the
327: least compressible in $\alpha$-ZnCl$_{2}$. In $\delta$-ZnCl$_{2}$,
328: $\bf{b}$ axis is found to be the most compressible. However, the volume
329: derivative with pressure in all the phases looks a bit alike, as their
330: bulk moduli are similar.
331:
332: \section{Conclusions}
333: We have developed an interatomic potential model for ZnCl$_{2}$ that
334: mimicks the vibrational and thermodynamic properties of the polymorphs
335: of crystalline ZnCl$_{2}$ and reproduces fairly well the inelastic
336: neutron scattering data for the $\alpha$-phase. The fact that the $\gamma$-phase
337: shows differences in Gr\"uneisen parameters and
338: lattice expansion is essentially due to its layered structure, which is
339: very different from other corner-shared polymorphs. This transferable
340: potential model may be exploited further to investigate the properties
341: of the glassy and the liquid phases of ZnCl$_{2}$.
342:
343: \ack
344: A. S. expresses his gratitude to the Council of Scientific and
345: Industrial Research (CSIR, New Delhi), India, for rendering the
346: financial assistance and acknowledges as well the encouragement and care
347: taken by Dr. M. Ramanadham and Dr. V. C. Sahni. We thank Dr. S. N.
348: Achary for his kind cooperation in making the commercial polycrystalline
349: ZnCl$_{2}$ sample suitable for the inelastic neutron scattering
350: experiments. We are also thankful to the referees for their valuable suggestions.
351:
352:
353: \section*{References}
354: \begin{thebibliography}{<num>}
355: \bibitem{breh}Brehler B 1961 {\it Z. Kristalogr.} {\bf 115} 373.
356: \bibitem{bryn}Brynestad J and Yakel H L 1978 {\it Inorg. Chem.} {\bf 17} 1376.
357: \bibitem{saka}Sakai M, Kuroda N and Nishina Y 1985 {\it J. Phys. Soc. Jpn.} {\bf 54} 4081.
358: \bibitem{gard}Gardner P J and Heyes D M 1985 {\it Physica B} {\bf 131} 227.
359: \bibitem{mcke}McKenzie J D and Murphy W K 1960 {\it J. Chem. Phys.} {\bf 33} 366.
360: \bibitem{grub}Gruber G J and Litovitz T A 1964 {\it J. Chem. Phys.} {\bf 40} 13.
361: \bibitem{wood}Woodcock L V, Angell C A and Cheeseman P 1976 {\it J. Chem. Phys.} {\bf 65} 1565.
362: \bibitem{bock}Bockris J O' M, Richards S R and Nanis I 1965 {\it J. Phys. Chem.} {\bf 69} 1627.
363: \bibitem{duke}Duke F R and Fleming R A 1957 {\it J. Electrochem. Soc.} {\bf 104} 251.
364: \bibitem{ribe1}Ribero M C C, Wilson M and Madden P A 1999 {\it J. Chem. Phys.} {\bf 110} 4803.
365: \bibitem{smith}Smith G P and Triolo R 1981 {\it J. Chem. Phys.} {\bf 75} 613.
366: \bibitem{bryan}O'Bryan Jr. H M, Van Uitert L G, Guggenheim H J and Grodkiewicz W H 1979 {\it Bull. Am. Ceram. Soc.} {\bf 58} 1098.
367: \bibitem{lebon}Lebon M J, Drefus C, Li G, Housadi A, Cummins H Z and Pick R M 1995 {\it Phy. Rev. E} {\bf 51} 4357.
368: \bibitem{kart}Kartini E, Collins M F, Mezei F, and Svensson E C 1997 {\it Physica} {\bf 234} 399.
369: \bibitem{ribe2}Ribero M C C, Wilson M and Madden P A 1998 {\it J. Chem. Phys.} {\bf 109} 9859.
370: \bibitem{yann}Yannopoulos S N, Kalampounias A G, Chrissanthopoulos A, and Papatheodorou G N 2003 {\it J. Chem. Phys.} {\bf 118} 3197.
371: \bibitem{ang1}Angell C A, Wegdam G and van der Elsken J 1974 {\it Spectrochim. Acta} {\bf 30A} 665.
372: \bibitem{trio}Triolo R and Narten A H 1981 {\it J. Chem. Phys.} {\bf 74} 703.
373: \bibitem{erw}Erwin Desa J A, Wright A C, Wong J and Sinclair R N 1982 {\it J. Non. Crys. Sol.} {\bf 51} 57.
374: \bibitem{paul}Pauling L 1929 {\it Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA} {\bf 15} 709.
375: \bibitem{osw}Oswald H R and Jaggi H 1960 {\it Helv. Chim. Acta} {\bf 43} 72.
376: \bibitem{yak}Yakel H L, and Brynestad J 1978 {\it Inorg. Chem.} {\bf 17} 3294.
377: \bibitem{ang2}Angell C A and Wong J 1970 {\it J. Chem. Phys.} {\bf 53} 2053.
378: \bibitem{young}Young R A, Sakthivel A, Moss T S and Paiva-Santos C O 1995 {\it J. Appl. Cryst.} {\bf 28} 366.
379: \bibitem{chap3}Chaplot S L, Mukhopadhyay R, Vijayaraghavan P R, Deshpande A S and Rao K R 1989 {\it Pramana-J.Phys.} {\bf 33} 595.
380: \bibitem{price}Price D L and Skold K 1986 in {\it Neutron Scattering: Vol A}, edited by Skold K and Price D L (Orlando: Academic Press); Carpenter J M and Price D L 1985 {\it Phy. Rev. Lett.} {\bf 54} 441; Taraskin S N and Elliott S R 1997 {\it Phy. Rev. B} {\bf 55} 117.
381: \bibitem{chap1}Chaplot S L 1992 {\it Phys. Rev. B} {\bf 45} 4885.
382: \bibitem{mala}Rao Mala N, Chaplot S L, Choudhury N, Rao K R, Azuah R T, Montfrooij W T and Bennington S M 1999 {\it Phy. Rev. B} {\bf 60} 12061.
383: \bibitem{mittal}Mittal R, Chaplot S L, Sen A, Achary S N and Tyagi A K 2003 {\it Phy. Rev. B} {\bf 67} 134303.
384: \bibitem{chap2}Chaplot S L (unpublished).
385: \bibitem{james}James D W, Parry R M and Leong W H 1978 {\it J. Raman Spectrosc.} {\bf 7} 71.
386: \bibitem{pols}Polski C H, Martinez L M, Leinenweber K, VerHelst M A, Angell C A and Wolf G H 2000 {\it Phy. Rev. B} {\bf 61} 5934.
387: \bibitem{sjol}Sjolander A 1958 {\it Ark. Fys.} {\bf 14} 315.
388: \bibitem{gal}Galeener F L, Mikkelsen Jr. J C, Wright A C, Sinclair R N, Desa J A E and Wong J 1980 {\it J. Non-Cryst. Solids} {\bf 42} 23.
389: \bibitem{alio}Aliotta F, Maisano G, Migliardo P, Vasi C, Wanderlingh F, Smith G P and Triolo R 1981 {\it J. Chem. Phys.} {\bf 75} 613.
390: \bibitem{ang3}Angell C A, Williams E, Rao K J and Tucker J C 1977 {\it J. Chem. Phys.} {\bf 81} 238.
391: \end{thebibliography}
392:
393:
394:
395: \Figures
396: \begin{figure}
397: \caption{\label{fig1}Crystal
398: structures of polymorphs of ZnCl$_{2}$, viz. (a)
399: $\alpha$-ZnCl$_{2}$, (b) $\beta$-ZnCl$_{2}$, (c)
400: $\gamma$-ZnCl$_{2}$ and (d) $\delta$-ZnCl$_{2}$. The small
401: circles represent Cl atoms, while Zn atoms are located inside (not
402: visible here) the ZnCl$_{4}$ tetrahedra.}
403:
404: \caption{\label{fig2}Pressure dependence of phonon modes in (a)
405: $\alpha$-ZnCl$_{2}$ (b) $\gamma$-ZnCl$_{2}$ and (c)
406: $\delta$-ZnCl$_{2}$.}
407:
408: \caption{\label{fig3}Calculated phonon
409: dispersion relations in $\alpha$-ZnCl$_{2}$.}
410:
411: \caption{\label{fig4}Plots of (a) experimental and (b) calculated
412: neutron weighted phonon density of states for
413: $\alpha$-ZnCl$_{2}$. The multiphonon contribution at 300 K has
414: been subtracted from the experimental data to obtain the
415: experimental one-phonon spectrum. The corresponding calculated
416: spectrum has been convoluted with the energy resolution of the
417: instrument.}
418:
419: \caption{\label{fig5} (a) Calculated partial phonon
420: density of states of various atoms in $\alpha$-ZnCl$_{2}$. (b) A
421: comparison of calculated one phonon density of states in various
422: crystalline polymorphs of ZnCl$_{2}$.}
423:
424: \caption{\label{fig6}Plots
425: of (a) heat capacity ($C_{P}$) and (b) Debye temperature ($\theta_{D}$)
426: for all the crystalline polymorphs of ZnCl$_{2}$. The
427: inset in (a) shows the specific heat differences of
428: various polymorphs with respect to the $\alpha$-phase.}
429:
430: \caption{\label{fig7}Calculated plots of the mode Gr\"uneisen
431: parameter and the volume thermal expansion coefficients of
432: ZnCl$_{2}$ in its various crystalline phases.}
433:
434: \caption{\label{fig8}Calculated equations of state for
435: crystalline ZnCl$_{2}$ in (a) $\alpha$ (b) $\beta$ (c) $\gamma$
436: and (d) $\delta$ phases.}
437: \end{figure}
438:
439:
440: \Tables
441: \Table{\label{tab1}Group theoretical classification of zone-centre phonon modes in various crystalline polymorphs of ZnCl$_{2}$. Raman and infra-red active phonon branches are indicated within the bracket by {\it{R}} and {\it{ir}} respectively.}
442: \br
443: \multicolumn{1}{c}{Phase}&\multicolumn{1}{c}{Crystal system}&\multicolumn{1}{c}{Space-group}&\multicolumn{1}{c}{Z}&\multicolumn{1}{c}{Group theoretical classification at zone-centre} \\
444: \mr
445: $\alpha$&Tetragonal&$I\bar{4}2d$&4&${A_{1}(R) + 2A_{2} + 2B_{1}(R) + 3B_{2}(R,ir) + 5E(R,ir)}$ \\
446: $\beta$&Monoclinic&$P2_{1}/n$&12&${27A_{g}(R) + 27A_{u}(ir) + 27B_{g}(R) + 27B_{u}(ir)}$ \\
447: $\gamma$&Tetragonal&$P4_{2}/nmc$&2&${A_{1g}(R) + 2A_{2u}(ir) + 2B_{1g}(R) + B_{2u}(ir) + 3E_{g}(R) + 3E_{u}(ir)}$ \\
448: $\delta$&Orthorhombic&$Pna2_{1}$&4&${9A_{1}(R,ir) + 9A_{2}(R) + 9B_{1}(R,ir) + 9B_{2}(R,ir)}$ \\
449: \br
450: \end{tabular}
451: \end{indented}
452: \end{table}
453:
454:
455: \Table{\label{tab2}Transferable potential parameters for ZnCl$_{2}$ polymorphs.}
456: \br
457: \multicolumn{2}{c}{$R$(\AA)}&\multicolumn{3}{c}{C$_{ij}$(eV\AA$^{6}$)}& $D(eV)$ & $n$(\AA$^{-1}$) & $r_{0}$(\AA)\\
458: Zn&Cl&Zn-Zn&Zn-Cl&Cl-Cl\\
459: \mr
460: 1.03&2.52&20&135&550&3.00&4.60&2.30\\
461: \br
462: \end{tabular}
463: \end{indented}
464: \end{table}
465:
466: \Table{\label{tab3a}Lattice constants and position parameters
467: for $\alpha$-ZnCl$_{2}$. For the space group $I\bar{4}2d$, Zn
468: atoms are located at (0,0,0) and $\left({1\over 2},0,{3\over 4}
469: \right)$ while Cl atoms are located at general positions of
470: $\left(x,{1\over 4},{1\over 8} \right)$, $\left(\bar{x},{3\over
471: 4},{1\over 8} \right)$, $\left({1\over 4},\bar{x},{7\over 8}
472: \right)$, $\left({3\over 4},x,{7\over 8} \right)$ respectively.}
473: \br
474: &\multicolumn{1}{c}{This work}&\multicolumn{1}{c}{Experimental data} \\
475: &&\multicolumn{1}{c}{(Ref. 1)} \\
476: \mr
477: {$a$(\AA)}&5.406&5.410 \\
478: {$c$(\AA)}&10.415&10.300 \\
479: V{(\AA$^{3}$)}&304.34&301.46 \\
480: \emph{x}&0.24&0.25 \\
481: \br
482: \end{tabular}
483: \end{indented}
484: \end{table}
485:
486:
487: \Table{\label{tab3b}Lattice constants and position parameters
488: for $\beta$-ZnCl$_{2}$. For the space group $P2_{1}/n$, Zn and Cl
489: atoms are located at general positions of $(x,y,z)$,
490: $\left(\bar{x}+{1\over 2},y+{1\over 2},\bar{z}+{1\over 2}
491: \right)$, $(\bar{x},\bar{y},\bar{z})$, $\left(x+{1\over
492: 2},\bar{y}+{1\over 2},z+{1\over 2} \right)$ respectively.}
493: \br
494: &\multicolumn{3}{c}{This work}&\multicolumn{3}{c}{Experimental data} \\
495: &\multicolumn{3}{c}{}&\multicolumn{3}{c}{(Ref. 1)} \\
496: \mr
497: $a$(\AA)&\multicolumn{3}{c}{6.519}&\multicolumn{3}{c}{6.500} \\
498: $b$(\AA)&\multicolumn{3}{c}{11.330}&\multicolumn{3}{c}{11.300} \\
499: $c$(\AA)&\multicolumn{3}{c}{12.272}&\multicolumn{3}{c}{12.300} \\
500: $\beta$($^{o}$)&\multicolumn{3}{c}{89.8}&\multicolumn{3}{c}{90.0}\\
501: V(\AA$^{3}$) &\multicolumn{3}{c}{906.43}&\multicolumn{3}{c}{903.43}\\
502: \mr
503: Atom&\emph{x}&\emph{y}&\emph{z}&\emph{x}&\emph{y}&\emph{z} \\
504: \mr
505: Zn&0.165&0.167&0.065&0.167&0.167&0.063 \\
506: Zn&0.166&0.499&0.186&0.167&0.500&0.188 \\
507: Zn&0.666&0.667&0.187&0.667&0.667&0.188 \\
508: Cl&0.328&0.003&0.127&0.333&0.000&0.125 \\
509: Cl&0.326&0.334&0.124&0.333&0.333&0.125 \\
510: Cl&0.335&0.663&0.128&0.333&0.667&0.125 \\
511: Cl&0.836&0.167&0.127&0.833&0.167&0.125 \\
512: Cl&0.835&0.503&0.127&0.833&0.500&0.125 \\
513: Cl&0.828&0.831&0.122&0.833&0.833&0.125 \\
514: \br
515: \end{tabular}
516: \end{indented}
517: \end{table}
518:
519:
520: \Table{\label{tab3c}Lattice constants and position parameters
521: for $\gamma$-ZnCl$_{2}$. For the space group $P4_{2}/nmc$, Zn
522: atoms are located at (0,0,0) and $\left({1\over 2},{1\over
523: 2},{1\over 2} \right)$ while Cl atoms are located at general
524: positions of $\left(0,{1\over 2},z \right)$, $\left(0,{1\over
525: 2},z+{1\over 2} \right)$, $\left({1\over
526: 2},0,\bar{z}+{1\over 2} \right)$, $\left({1\over 2},0,\bar{z}
527: \right)$ respectively.}
528: \br
529: & {This work} & {Experimental data} \\
530: & & {(Ref. 1)} \\
531: \mr
532: $a$(\AA)& {3.733} & {3.700} \\
533: $c$(\AA)& {10.859} & {10.670} \\
534: V(\AA$^{3}$) & {151.31} & {146.07} \\
535: \emph{z} & 0.121& 0.125 \\
536: \br
537: \end{tabular}
538: \end{indented}
539: \end{table}
540:
541:
542: \Table{\label{tab3d}Lattice constants and position parameters
543: for $\delta$-ZnCl$_{2}$. For the space group $Pna2_{1}$, Zn and Cl
544: atoms are located at general positions of $(x,y,z)$,
545: $\left(\bar{x},\bar{y},z+{1\over 2} \right)$, $\left(x+{1\over
546: 2},\bar{y}+{1\over 2},z \right)$, $\left(\bar{x}+{1\over
547: 2},y+{1\over 2},z+{1\over 2} \right)$ respectively. U(\AA$^{2}$)
548: gives the isotropic thermal amplitudes.}
549: \br
550: &\multicolumn{4}{c}{This work} & \multicolumn{4}{c}{Experimental data} \\
551: &\multicolumn{4}{c}{} & \multicolumn{4}{c}{(Ref. 2)} \\
552: \mr
553: $a$(\AA)&\multicolumn{4}{c}{6.444} & \multicolumn{4}{c}{6.443} \\
554: $b$(\AA)&\multicolumn{4}{c}{7.666} & \multicolumn{4}{c}{7.693} \\
555: $c$(\AA)&\multicolumn{4}{c}{6.122} & \multicolumn{4}{c}{6.125} \\
556: $\beta$($^{o}$)&\multicolumn{4}{c}{90.0} & \multicolumn{4}{c}{90.0}\\
557: V(\AA$^{3}$)&\multicolumn{4}{c}{302.40} &
558: \multicolumn{4}{c}{303.59}\\
559: \mr
560: Atom&\emph{x}&\emph{y}&\emph{z}&U&\emph{x}&\emph{y}&\emph{z}&U \\
561: \mr
562: Zn&0.081&0.125&0.378&0.0303&0.0818&0.1251&0.3750&0.0253 \\
563: Cl&0.075&0.122&0.005&0.0296&0.0702&0.1223&0.0041&0.0305 \\
564: Cl&0.084&0.630&0.003&0.0296&0.0841&0.6332&0.0062&0.0292 \\
565: \br
566: \end{tabular}
567: \end{indented}
568: \end{table}
569:
570:
571: \Table{\label{tab4a}Comparison of calculation and experimental
572: data of optical modes in $\alpha$-ZnCl$_{2}$. Modes of $A_{2}$
573: representation are not optically active.}
574: \br
575: \multicolumn{7}{c}{Optical phonon modes ($cm^{-1}$)} \\
576: \multicolumn{1}{c}{Representations} & \multicolumn{1}{c}{This work} & \multicolumn{5}{c}{Experimental data} \\
577: \multicolumn{1}{c}{} & \multicolumn{1}{c}{} &
578: \multicolumn{1}{c}{(Ref. 3)} & \multicolumn{1}{c}{(Ref. 23)} &
579: \multicolumn{1}{c}{(Ref. 31)} \\
580: \mr
581: $A_{1}$&223&226&233&245 \\
582: $A_{2}$&147&&& \\
583: &301&&& \\
584: $B_{1}$&94&117&&113 \\
585: &273&&& \\
586: $B_{2}$&111&128&&128 \\
587: &325&&& \\
588: $E$&75&76&82&80 \\
589: &99&100&103&103 \\
590: &263&&& \\
591: &327&&& \\
592: \br
593: \end{tabular}
594: \end{indented}
595: \end{table}
596:
597: \Table{\label{tab4b}Comparison of calculation and experimental
598: data of optical modes in $\beta$-ZnCl$_{2}$.}
599: \br
600: \multicolumn{8}{c}{Optical phonon modes ($cm^{-1}$)} \\
601: \multicolumn{4}{c}{This work} & \multicolumn{2}{c}{Experimental data} \\
602: \multicolumn{4}{c}{} & \multicolumn{1}{c}{(Ref. 31)} & \multicolumn{1}{c}{(Ref. 23)} \\
603: \multicolumn{1}{c}{$A_{g}$} & \multicolumn{1}{c}{$B_{g}$} &
604: \multicolumn{1}{c}{$A_{u}$} & \multicolumn{1}{c}{$B_{u}$} &
605: \multicolumn{1}{c}{($A_{g}$,$B_{g}$})&
606: \multicolumn{1}{c}{($A_{u}$,$B_{u}$})\\
607: \mr
608: 34&33&34&36 \\
609: 40&47&43&52&&42 \\
610: 44&49&48&57&& 57 \\
611: 47&55&53&61&&61 \\
612: 48&61&58&69&&70 \\
613: 57&66&64&74 \\
614: 64&71&70&84 \\
615: 70&75&93&86&78& \\
616: 72&79&94&100&&99 \\
617: 90&91&108&107&104&105 \\
618: 102&104&110&116&108& \\
619: 114&111&120&127&118&123 \\
620: 122&114&120&144&125&135 \\
621: 135&136&141&222 \\
622: 148&138&216&232&231& \\
623: 222&221&231&254&250 &\\
624: 241&236&252&257 \\
625: 248&248&261&266&268 & \\
626: 261&260&264&273&278 &\\
627: 266&267&270&308 \\
628: 273&268&308&317 \\
629: 311&312&316&324 \\
630: 315&320&324&326 \\
631: 324&322&327&328 \\
632: 327&327&328&340 \\
633: 328&328&340 \\
634: 340&340 \\
635: \br
636: \end{tabular}
637: \end{indented}
638: \end{table}
639:
640: \Table{\label{tab4c}Comparison of calculation and experimental
641: data of optical modes in $\gamma$-ZnCl$_{2}$.}
642: \br
643: \multicolumn{4}{c}{Optical phonon modes ($cm^{-1}$)} \\
644: \multicolumn{1}{c}{Representations} & \multicolumn{1}{c}{This work} & \multicolumn{2}{c}{Experimental data} \\
645: \multicolumn{1}{c}{} & \multicolumn{1}{c}{} &
646: \multicolumn{1}{c}{(Ref. 3)} & \multicolumn{1}{c}{(Ref. 31)} \\
647: \mr
648: $A_{1g}$&244&248&252 \\
649: $A_{2u}$&258 \\
650: $B_{1g}$&66 \\
651: &271 \\
652: $B_{2u}$&216 \\
653: $E_{g}$&44&36&38 \\
654: &92&88&80 \\
655: &322 \\
656: $E_{u}$&68 \\
657: &318 \\
658: \br
659: \end{tabular}
660: \end{indented}
661: \end{table}
662:
663: \Table{\label{tab4d}Comparison of calculation and experimental
664: data of optical modes in $\delta$-ZnCl$_{2}$.}
665: \br
666: \multicolumn{6}{c}{Optical phonon modes ($cm^{-1}$)} \\
667: \multicolumn{4}{c}{This work}&\multicolumn{2}{c}{Experimental data} \\
668: \multicolumn{4}{c}{}&\multicolumn{1}{c}{(Ref. 3)}&\multicolumn{1}{c}{(Ref. 16)} \\
669: \multicolumn{1}{c}{$A_{1}$}&\multicolumn{1}{c}{$A_{2}$}&\multicolumn{1}{c}{$B_{1}$}&\multicolumn{1}{c}{$B_{2}$} \\
670: \mr
671: 45&50&50&72&&39,49,59 \\
672: 75&55&67&91&&74,83,88 \\
673: 92&76&108&118&&96,100,102,106 \\
674: 112&104&128&141&147&109,124,129 \\
675: 222&128&242&267&&226,250 \\
676: 264&235&270&269&278&272,282 \\
677: 324&269&317&298&&321 \\
678: 329&318&326&329 \\
679: &327 \\
680: \br
681: \end{tabular}
682: \end{indented}
683: \end{table}
684:
685: \end{document}
686: