1: \documentclass[aps,showpacs,two column]{revtex4}
2: \usepackage{graphicx}% Include figure files
3: \usepackage{bm}% bold math
4: \usepackage{amsfonts,amsmath,amssymb}
5: \usepackage[squaren]{SIunits}
6:
7: \begin{document}
8:
9: \title{Intrinsic electron-doping in nominal ``non-doped" superconducting
10: (La,Y)$_2$CuO$_4$ thin films grown by dc magnetron sputtering}
11: \author{L. Zhao, G. Wu, R. H. Liu and X. H. Chen}
12: \altaffiliation{Corresponding author} \email{chenxh@ustc.edu.cn}
13: \affiliation{Hefei National Laboratory for Physical Science at
14: Microscale and Department of Physics, University of Science and
15: Technology of China, Hefei, Anhui 230026, People's Republic of
16: China}
17:
18: \begin{abstract}
19:
20: The superconducting nominal ``non-doped"
21: La$_{1.85}$Y$_{0.15}$CuO$_{4}$ (LYCO) thin films are successfully
22: prepared by dc magnetron-sputtering and \emph{in situ}
23: post-annealing in vacuum. The best T$_{\texttt{C0}}$ more than 13K
24: is achieved in the optimal LYCO films with highly pure c-axis
25: oriented T'-type structure. In the normal state, the
26: quasi-quadratic temperature dependence of resistivity, the negative
27: Hall coefficient and effect of oxygen content in the films are quite
28: similar to the typical Ce-doped n-type cuprates, suggesting that
29: T'-LYCO shows the electron-doping nature like known n-type
30: cuprates, and is not a band superconductor as proposed previously.
31: The charge carriers are considered to be induced by oxygen
32: deficiency.
33: \end{abstract}
34: \vskip 15 pt
35:
36: \pacs{74.72.Dn, 74.78.Bz, 74.62.Dh, 74.90.+n}
37:
38: \narrowtext
39:
40: \maketitle
41:
42: \section{INTRODUCTION}
43:
44: Although the intense research since the discovery of
45: high-temperature superconductors by Bednorz and M\"{u}ller in
46: 1986\cite{Bednorz}, the underlying mechanism for high temperature
47: superconductivity remains elusive. It is well known that the parent
48: compounds of all the high-temperature superconductors are
49: antiferromagnetic half-filled Mott insulators in which the strong
50: electronic correlation exists. Upon increasing doping holes or
51: electrons to CuO$_2$ sheets, the long-range antiferromagnetism is
52: destroyed and superconductivity can be induced at the certain doping
53: levels.
54:
55: However, the new class of T'-structure cuprate superconductors,
56: recently discovered by NTT research group, are nominal ``non-doped"
57: T'-(La, RE)$_{2}$CuO$_{4}$ (RE = Sm, Eu, Gd, Tb, Lu, and Y). RE is
58: the isovalent cation with La and don't provide necessary charge
59: carriers to CuO$_2$ planes. They claimed that oxygen deficiencies
60: can't afford a main source of charge carriers and these new
61: superconductors are most plausibly so-called ``band superconductors"
62: \cite{naito, noda}. But they lacked further investigation on
63: physical properties of these new class of superconductors.
64: Furthermore, no other group can reproduce their work and acquire
65: superconducting samples. Only one unsuccessful attempt was reported
66: recently \cite{Idemoto}. It is urgent to confirm these results at
67: present.
68:
69: According to our experimental experiences in the synthesis of
70: La-based 214 cuprate films such as La$_{2-x}$Ce$_{x}$CuO$_{4}$(LCCO)
71: films by sputtering and pulsed laser deposition (PLD) in the last
72: several years \cite{thesis}, we studied the La-Y-Cu-O system. In
73: this paper, we report the successful growth of the superconducting
74: T'-LYCO films by dc magnetron sputtering. The behaviors of
75: resistivity and Hall effect are investigated to disclose the nature
76: of charge carriers in T'-LYCO.
77:
78:
79:
80: \section{EXPERIMENT DETAILS}
81:
82:
83: The La$_{1.85}$Y$_{0.15}$CuO$_{4}$ (LYCO) films were fabricated by
84: on-axis dc magnetron sputtering using a stoichiometric ceramic
85: target. The target was synthesized by conventional solid state
86: reaction. The appropriate powders of La$_2$O$_3$, Y$_2$O$_3$ and
87: CuO of high purity with the composition ratio of cation La: Y:
88: Cu=1.85:0.15:1.0, were mixed, grounded and sintered in air at
89: 980$\celsius$ for 48 hours with several intermediate regrindings.
90: The calcined powder was then pressed into a 5 mm-thick disk with
91: 50mm in diameter and was sintered at 1050$\celsius$ for 24 hours.
92:
93:
94: The (100)-cut SrTiO$_3$ (d=3.905\AA) and LSAT
95: [(LaAlO$_3$)$_{0.3}$(Sr$_2$AlTaO$_6$)$_{0.7}$] (d=3.868\AA) were
96: used as substrates for deposition of LYCO films. The substrates were
97: fixed to the heater which was located right above the target at a
98: height of 35mm. The base pressure of the chamber prior to deposition
99: was below $5\times10^{-4}$Pa. The sputtering gas was pure argon, and
100: the pressure in the chamber was kept at about 60Pa during the
101: deposition. Subsequently, LYCO was deposited at the temperature
102: T$_D$ = 600- 755$\celsius$ . After deposition, the samples were
103: first slowly cooled down to T$_A$ =600$\celsius$ in high vacuum
104: (below $10^{-4}$Pa), then annealed at this temperature for 15-30
105: minutes to remove the excess apical oxygen and finally followed by
106: very slow cooling to room temperature in high vacuum. usually 15
107: minute's annealing in high vacuum is enough and longer annealing
108: have no improving effect on the superconducting properties of the
109: LYCO films. During the deposition, the sputtering current was
110: ordinarily kept at about 200mA and the typical film thickness is
111: around 3000\AA ~after one hour's deposition. For these films thicker
112: than 2500\AA, there is no distinct difference on the transport
113: properties of these films grown on whether STO or LSAT substrates in
114: our experiments.
115:
116: All the films are characterized by an x-ray diffractometer
117: (Panalytical, X'pert Pro), using Cu K$\alpha$ radiation. Their
118: surface morphology and thickness are observed using an atomic
119: force microscope (AFM, Digital Instruments). The measurements of
120: resistivity and Hall coefficients are carried through by standard
121: 6-lead technology, using a superconducting quantum interference
122: device (SQUID, Quantum Design, MPMS-7\emph{XL}). The Ag electrodes
123: were deposited by evaporation through a copper mask.
124:
125: \section{RESULTS AND DISCUSSION}
126:
127:
128: Fig. 1 shows the x-ray diffraction pattern of the
129: La$_{1.85}$Y$_{0.15}$CuO$_{4}$ target. Except the trace of
130: un-reacted yttrium oxide, all the peaks are indexed assuming the
131: La$_2$CuO$_4$-like T-214 structure. The calculated lattice constants
132: of the orthorhombic lattice are, a = 5.355\AA , b = 5.399\AA ,and c
133: = 13.136\AA. These lattice constants are slight less than these of
134: La$_2$CuO$_4$ (a = 5.356\AA , b = 5.402\AA , c = 13.14\AA),
135: consistent with the partial substitution of larger La$^{3+}$ (ion
136: radii is 1.216\AA) by smaller Y{$^{3+}$ (1.075\AA).
137: \begin{figure}
138: \includegraphics[width=0.40\textwidth]{fig1.eps}
139: \caption{ Powder x-ray diffraction patterns of La$_{1.85}$Y$_
140: {0.15}$CuO$_{4}$ target, the peak marked with stars is from a
141: small quantity of un-reacted Y$_2$O$_3$.\\}
142: \end{figure}
143:
144: La$^{3+}$ is the largest ion among lanthanide series, and the
145: detailed analysis on the perovskite crystallographic Goldshimidt
146: tolerance factor \emph{t}, have told us that La-214 tends to form
147: the T-type phase while T'-phase is unstable at relative lower
148: synthesis temperature \cite{goodenough}. By extrapolating the T/T'
149: phase boundary in the La$_{2-y}$Nd$_{y}$CuO$_{4}$ system to y=0,
150: Manthiram and Goodenough\cite{goodenough} predicted that
151: T'-La$_2$CuO$_4$ can only be stabilized below 425$\celsius$.
152: Although partially substitution of La$^{3+}$ by smaller Y$^{3+}$
153: will reduce slightly the average ion radius of A-site, and shift
154: slightly the T/T' phase boundary to higher temperature, It is still
155: too hard to realize the preparation of T'-phase bulk material.
156: Conventional solid state reaction can only achieve T-phase.
157: Nevertheless compared with the solid-state reaction process, the
158: preparation of thin films can usually be realized at relative lower
159: temperature. Furthermore the appropriate epitaxy strain through
160: suitable substrates can stabilize some meta-stable phases
161: \cite{Tsukada}.
162:
163:
164: The x-ray diffraction patterns of LYCO films deposited at various
165: temperatures are shown in Fig. 2. The c-axis lattice constant of the
166: LYCO is 12.45\AA~ for T'-type structure and 13.136\AA~ for T-type
167: structure, respectively. Therefore, these two kinds of competing
168: structures can easily be distinguished in x-ray diffraction. As
169: mentioned above, the phase competition between the T'- and T-
170: structures also exists during the growth of the LYCO films and the
171: T'-phase is preferable at lower deposition temperature.
172:
173: \begin{figure}
174: \includegraphics[width=0.4\textwidth]{fig2.eps}
175: \caption{ X-ray diffraction patterns($\theta-2\theta$ scan) of LYCO
176: films grown on STO and LSAT substrates at various deposition
177: temperatures 755$\celsius$, 725$\celsius$, 690$\celsius$,
178: 650$\celsius$, and 600$\celsius$. The peak marked with ``$\ast$" is
179: the (200) reflection belonging to Cu$_2$O impurity. The un-indexed
180: peaks are due to the substrates.}
181: \end{figure}
182:
183: From Fig. 2, one can see that the LYCO films with pure T'-phase can
184: be synthesized only when the deposition temperature T$_{D}$ is near
185: 690$\celsius$. Upon increasing T$_{D}$, the diffraction peaks
186: belonging to T-phase develop, indicating the coexistence of two
187: phases in the films. They are both highly c-axis oriented and only
188: (00\emph{l}) peaks exist, except the small (200) peak of Cu$_2$O
189: impurity (marked with ``$\ast$" in Fig.2, appears only when
190: deposition temperature is higher than 725$\celsius$). With
191: increasing T$_{D}$, the proportion of T'-phase component in the
192: films decreases rapidly, and that of T-phase component increases
193: correspondingly. It is consistent with above analysis on the phase
194: competition in LYCO. However, as we decrease T$_{D}$ further, the
195: T'-214 phase prefers the (110)-oriented epitaxy on STO or LAST
196: substrates, which is usually observed in the film preparation of
197: other cuprate perovskite families. When T$_{D}$=600$\celsius$, the
198: films are nearly pure (110)-oriented. Only (110) and (220) peaks can
199: be observed.
200:
201: Therefore, to acquire the high quality T'-LYCO films, the optimal
202: deposition temperature should be around 690$\celsius$. The optimal
203: films are of the highly c-axis oriented T'-214 structure without
204: detectable T-phase impurity by x-ray diffraction. The typical full
205: width at half maximum (FWHM) of rocking curves through (006)
206: reflection of the optimal films is only 0.28\degree, which
207: confirms the good epitaxial growth of these films.
208:
209: The surface morphology of typical films, studied by AFM, are shown
210: in Fig. 3. Although the highly pure c-axis oriented T'-structure in
211: the LYCO films has been confirmed by x-ray analysis, some randomly
212: distributed particles on the film surface can be observed. The
213: similar particles were also observed in the LCCO films grown by
214: magnetron sputtering, which were considered mainly cuprous oxide
215: Cu$_{2}$O \cite{lzhao}. Excessive Cu element in the films exists in
216: the form of CuO$_{x}$ particles, which suggest that there exists
217: preferential sputtering during the deposition process. The higher
218: deposition temperature help to crystallize these amorphous oxide
219: particles and make them detectable by x-ray diffraction, as shown in
220: Fig. 2(a). According to our experiences in the previous transport
221: measurements in LCCO film prepared by magnetron sputtering, we
222: believe that these CuO$_{x}$ particles on the surface have no
223: observable effect on the transport properties of the films.
224:
225: \begin{figure}
226: \includegraphics[width=0.32\textwidth]{fig3.eps}
227: \caption{Typical AFM image of the LYCO thin film deposited on the
228: STO substrate at 690$\celsius$.}
229: \end{figure}
230:
231: The films in Fig. 4(a) are deposited at higher T$_{D}$, in which
232: highly insulating T-phase co-exists as an impurity with
233: superconducting T'-phase component. The coexistence leads to the
234: partial superconducting (SC) transition (caused by the T'-phase
235: component) appended to the whole insulating background (by the
236: T-phase one). Upon increasing T$_{D}$, the proportion of the T'-214
237: component reduces and the SC transition weakens, shifting to lower
238: temperature at the same time as shown in the inset of Fig. 4(a).
239:
240: \begin{figure}
241: \includegraphics[width=0.40\textwidth]{fig4.eps}
242: \caption{The temperature dependence of the resistivity $\rho$ of
243: films deposited at different T$_D$: (a)755$\celsius$,
244: 725$\celsius$; (b) 650$\celsius$, 620$\celsius$, 600$\celsius$.
245: The inset in (a) shows superconducting transitions in detail.}
246: \end{figure}
247:
248: The films in Fig. 4(b) are deposited at lower T$_{D}$. As T$_{D}$
249: decreases farther, the (110) component develops from the c-axis
250: oriented optimal films, and becomes dominant near
251: T$_{D}$=600$\celsius$, which has been shown in Fig. 2(e). The (110)
252: component introduces the contribution of out-of-plane transport to
253: the whole $\rho-\tt{T}$ behavior of T'-LYCO films. On the other
254: hand, lower deposition temperature rather strongly hinders the
255: crystallization process and make deoxygenation in vacuum more
256: difficult. At present, we cannot extract $\rho_{c}$ and $\rho_{ab}$
257: quantitatively from our results because poor crystallization and
258: grain boundary existing in films deposited at low T$_{D}$. As
259: T$_{D}$ decreases, the influence of both unremoval of apical oxygen
260: and grain boundary lead to the larger resistivity above T$_{C}$ and
261: more incomplete SC transition as well. It is possible that the
262: semiconducting nature in normal state could arise from the
263: contribution of out-of-plane resistivity. Similar results are
264: reported in the study on the anisotropy of
265: Nd$_{2-x}$Ce$_{x}$CuO$_{4}$(NCCO) through the films with different
266: orientations \cite{NCCOfilms}.
267:
268:
269: For the optimal T'-214 films deposited at 690$\celsius$, the temperature dependence
270: of the resistivity is shown in Fig.5 (a). The T$_{\texttt{C}0}=$13.5K
271: and the width of SC transition less than 1.5K (10-90\% criterion) were acquired. The optimal film
272: shows a metallic behavior in the whole range above T$_{C}$ except
273: for a slight upturn approaching T$_{C}$ when $\texttt{T} < \texttt{T}_{min}\sim$50K.
274: In contrast to the well-known linear temperature dependence in the hole-doped
275: cuprates like YBCO, the nearly quadratic dependence of $\rho$ in the
276: normal state is observed. This kind of behavior is similar to those
277: observed in the electron-doped cuprates around optimal doping, such
278: as Ln$_{2-x}$Ce$_{x}$CuO$_{4}$ (Ln=La, Pr, Nd, and Sm)\cite{Sawa,
279: Crusellas, Brinkmann, Greene}. Now most researchers consider it as a
280: Landau-Fermi liquid behavior due to electron-electron scattering.
281:
282: \begin{figure}
283: \includegraphics[width=0.40\textwidth]{fig5.eps}
284: \caption{Temperature dependence of resistivity for optimal c-axis
285: oriented T'-LYCO films. (a)$\rho$ vs. T , the dashed line is the
286: fit to the formula (\ref{fit}); (b)$\rho$ vs.
287: $T^2\texttt{ln(}T/T_F\texttt{)}$. $T_F=5000$K is used and the
288: straight in (b) line is a guide to eyes.}
289: \end{figure}
290:
291: The rigid formula for two-dimensional Landau-Fermi liquid
292: \begin{equation} \label{fit}
293: \rho(T)=\rho_0+A(T/T_F)^2\texttt{ln}(T/T_F).
294: \end{equation}
295: is used to fit the data. Where $T_F$ is the Fermi temperature (we
296: take $T_F$ =5000K here) and
297: $\rho_0$ residual resistivity \cite{Tsuei}. In the normal state the fitting
298: is quite good above T$_{min}$, which is further confirmed by the
299: fine linearity in the plot of in Fig. 5(b). The quadratic
300: temperature dependence with logarithmic correction have been also
301: observed in other electron-doped cuprates \cite{wangsst}, which
302: suggest the T'-LYCO may intrinsically be a typical electron-doped
303: cuprate.
304:
305: \begin{figure}
306: \includegraphics[width=0.40\textwidth]{fig6.eps}
307: \caption{Temperature dependence of the resistivity $\rho$ (a) and
308: Hall coefficient R$_H$ (b) of the optimal film deposited at
309: T$_D$=690$\celsius$.}
310: \end{figure}
311:
312: To clarify the origin of charge carriers, Hall coefficient R$_{H}$
313: of the optimal films was measured as shown in Fig. 6. The negative
314: R$_{H}$ in normal states confirms the intrinsic
315: electron-doped nature in T'-214 LYCO films. The R$_{H}$ decreases
316: gradually as temperature cooling from room temperature down to about
317: 100K. Upon decreasing temperature further, a slight upturn toward to
318: zero occurs. This kind of behavior is quite similar with other
319: electron-doped cuprates as NCCO \cite{wangprb} and
320: PCCO\cite{Brinkmann} at slightly less optimal doping level.
321:
322: \begin{figure}
323: \includegraphics[width=0.40\textwidth]{fig7.eps}
324: \caption{Temperature dependence of the resistivity $\rho$ (a) and
325: Hall coefficient R$_H$ (b) of the LYCO film that was deposited at
326: T$_D$=690$\celsius$ and annealed at lower vacuum. }
327: \end{figure}
328:
329: Till now, we cannot observe any prominent difference in T'-LYCO from
330: the Ce-doped T'-214 cuprate superconductors. Since Y$^{3+}$ and
331: La$^{3+}$ are isovalent in T'-LYCO, no net charge can be provided by
332: doped Y$^{+3}$. The most probable origin of charge carriers is from
333: oxygen deficiency since the superconductivity of our films can only
334: be acquired by annealing in high vacuum.
335:
336: At present, there is no way to determine the oxygen content in thin
337: films accurately and straightforwardly. To confirm our assumption,
338: we deposited LYCO films at the optimal temperature (T$_{D}$
339: =690$\celsius$) but annealing them in lower vacuum (P$_{O_2}\sim
340: 0.6\times 10^{-2}$}Pa) by tuning the slide valve at the front end of
341: the molecular pump. These films are still of pure T'-214 phase, but
342: with less oxygen deficiency.
343:
344: Their resistivity are much larger than the previous optimal films
345: annealing in high vacuum (P$ <1.0\times 10^{-4}$Pa). At low
346: temperature the insulating behavior is observed, and no
347: superconductivity is found down to 4 K as shown in Fig. 7(a). The
348: Hall coefficient R$_H$ was also investigated as shown in Fig. 7(b).
349: R$_H$ is negative in the whole temperature range and decreases with
350: decreasing temperature. The absolute value of R$_H$ is much larger
351: than that for optimal films, indicating less effective carrier
352: density and being consistent with larger resistivity. This oxygen
353: dependence of Hall behavior has been observed in
354: Nd$_{1.85}$Ce$_{0.15}$CuO$_{4-\delta}$ films by varying oxygen
355: content \cite{Jiang}. Because the limit of vacuum that the
356: sputtering chamber can reach is lower than that of the MBE chamber
357: in the NTT group(P$_{O_2}<10^{-8}$ Torr) \cite{naito, noda}. Tuning
358: the films to the overdoped region in the phase diagram cannot be
359: performed by introducing more oxygen deficiency currently.
360:
361:
362: \section{CONCLUSIONS}
363: We have successfully synthesized the superconducting T'-phase LYCO
364: films by dc magnetron sputtering. The optimal growth conditions are
365: explored in detail. The appropriate deposition temperature and
366: succedent \emph{in situ} annealing in high vacuum are the most
367: crucial to acquire superconducting films with pure c-axis
368: orientation. The optimal T$_{C}$ of our samples is lower than the
369: reported MBE-grown films (above 20K) at present. The biggest
370: restriction to improve T$_{C}$ is the limit of vacuum one can
371: achieve. Detailed studies on the resistivity and Hall coefficient on
372: T'-LYCO films, suggesting that this kind of so-called ``non-doped"
373: superconductor is intrinsically electron-doped cuprates. No exciting
374: prominent difference in T'-LYCO from the well-known Ce-doped T'-214
375: cuprate superconductors(as LCCO, NCCO and PCCO) is observed in
376: experiments. The charge carriers are the most likely from severe
377: oxygen deficiency. But besides reducing \emph{t} factor to improving
378: the stability of T'-structure slightly, the role of Y$^{3+}$ ion in
379: superconducting T'-LYCO is still elusive now. We have prepared
380: Y-doped T'- Nd$_{2}$CuO$_{4}$ and Pr$_{2}$CuO$_{4}$ in films and
381: bluk forms, in which there is no need for Y$^{3+}$ ions to stabilize
382: T'-214 structure. But no superconductivity is observed
383: \cite{nycopyco}. We suppose that the cooperation of large-sized
384: La$^{3+}$ ions with smaller Y$^{3+}$ may enable the sufficient
385: deficiency of oxygen in T'-structure to induce superconductivity.
386: Further studies on the T'-LYCO films at various Y-doping levels
387: and the in-plane substitution effect by magnetic or non-magnetic
388: impurities are currently in process.
389:
390: \begin{acknowledgments}
391:
392: The authors would like to thank G. Y. Wang, T. Wu, B. Guan and X.
393: G. Luo, for their assistance on the measurements and useful
394: discussions. This work is supported by the Nature Science Foundation
395: of China and by the Ministry of Science and Technology of China (973
396: project No: 2006CB601001), and by the Knowledge Innovation Project
397: of Chinese Academy of Sciences.
398:
399: \end{acknowledgments}
400:
401:
402:
403:
404: \begin{thebibliography}{}
405: \bibitem{Bednorz}
406: J. G. Bednorz and K. A. M\"{u}ller, Z. Phys. B {\bf 64}, 189 (1986)
407: \bibitem{naito}
408: A. Tsukada, Y. Krockenberger, M. Noda, H. Yamamoto, D. Manske, L.
409: Alff, and M. Naito, Solid State Communications {\bf 133} 427 (2005)
410: \bibitem{noda}
411: M. Noda, A. Tsukad, H. Yamamoto, and M. Naito, Physica C {\bf
412: 426-431} 220 (2005)
413: \bibitem{Idemoto}
414: Y. Idemoto, T. Miyabe, and N. Koura, Journal of the Ceramic Society
415: of Japan {\bf 114}, 359 (2006)
416: \bibitem{thesis}
417: L. Zhao, PhD thesis (2005)
418: \bibitem{goodenough}
419: A. Manthiram and J. B. Goodenough, J. Solid State Chem. {\bf 92},
420: 231 (1991)
421: \bibitem{Tsukada}
422: A. Tsukada, T. Greibe and M.Naito, Phys. Rev. B {\bf 66}, 184515
423: (2002)
424: \bibitem{lzhao}
425: L. Zhao, H. Wu, J. Miao, H.Yang, F. C. Zhang, X. G. Qiu and B. R.
426: Zhao£¬Supercond. Sci. Technol. {\bf 17} 1361 (2004).
427: \bibitem{NCCOfilms}
428: A. I. Ponomarev, T. B. Charikova, A. N. Ignatenkov, A. O. Tashlykov,
429: and A. A. Ivanov, Low Temp. Phys. {\bf 30}, 885(2004)
430: \bibitem{Sawa}
431: A. Sawa, M. Kawasaki, H. Takagi and Y. Tokura, Phys. Rev. B {\bf
432: 66}, 014531 (2002)
433: \bibitem{Crusellas}
434: M. A. Crusellas, J. Fontcuberta, S. Pinol, T. Grenet and J. Beille,
435: Physica C {\bf180}, 313 (1991)
436: \bibitem{Brinkmann}
437: M. Brinkmann, H. Bach, and K. Westerholt, Phys. Rev. B {\bf 54},
438: 6680 (1996)
439: \bibitem{Greene}
440: S.J. Hagen, J.L. Peng, and R.L. Greene, et al, Phys. Rev. B {\bf
441: 43}, 13606(1991)
442: \bibitem{Tsuei}
443: C.C. Tsuei, A. Gupta and G. Koren, Physica C {\bf 161}, 415 (1989)
444: \bibitem{wangsst}
445: C. H. Wang, L. Huang, L. Wang, Y. Peng, X. G. Luo, Y.M.Xiong and X.
446: H. Chen, Supercond. Sci. Technol. {\bf 17} 469 (2004)
447: \bibitem{wangprb}
448: C. H. Wang, G. Y. Wang, T. Wu, Z. Feng, X. G. Luo and X. H. Chen,
449: Phys. Rev. B, {\bf 72}, 132506 (2005)
450: \bibitem{Jiang}
451: Wu Jiang et al., Phys. Rev. Lett. {\bf 73}, 1291 (1994)
452: \bibitem{nycopyco}
453: L. Zhao et al., in preparation.
454: \end{thebibliography}
455:
456: \end{document}
457: