1: %!PS-Adobe-2.0

2: %%Copyright: Copyright (c) 1993 AT&T, All Rights Reserved

3: %%Version: 3.4

4: %%DocumentFonts: (atend)

5: %%Pages: (atend)

6: %%EndComments

7: /DpostDict 200 dict def

8: DpostDict begin

9: %

10: % Copyright (c) 1993 AT&T, All Rights Reserved

11: %

12: % Version 3.4 prologue for troff files.

13: %

14: 

15: /#copies 1 store

16: /Prologue (dpost.ps) def

17: /aspectratio 1 def

18: /formsperpage 1 def

19: /landscape false def

20: /linewidth .3 def

21: /magnification 1 def

22: /margin 0 def

23: /orientation 0 def

24: /resolution 720 def

25: /rotation 1 def

26: /xoffset 0 def

27: /yoffset 0 def

28: 

29: /roundpage true def

30: /useclippath true def

31: /pagebbox [0 0 612 792] def

32: 

33: /R  /Times-Roman def

34: /I  /Times-Italic def

35: /B  /Times-Bold def

36: /BI /Times-BoldItalic def

37: /H  /Helvetica def

38: /HI /Helvetica-Oblique def

39: /HB /Helvetica-Bold def

40: /HX /Helvetica-BoldOblique def

41: /CW /Courier def

42: /CO /Courier def

43: /CI /Courier-Oblique def

44: /CB /Courier-Bold def

45: /CX /Courier-BoldOblique def

46: /PA /Palatino-Roman def

47: /PI /Palatino-Italic def

48: /PB /Palatino-Bold def

49: /PX /Palatino-BoldItalic def

50: /Hr /Helvetica-Narrow def

51: /Hi /Helvetica-Narrow-Oblique def

52: /Hb /Helvetica-Narrow-Bold def

53: /Hx /Helvetica-Narrow-BoldOblique def

54: /KR /Bookman-Light def

55: /KI /Bookman-LightItalic def

56: /KB /Bookman-Demi def

57: /KX /Bookman-DemiItalic def

58: /AR /AvantGarde-Book def

59: /AI /AvantGarde-BookOblique def

60: /AB /AvantGarde-Demi def

61: /AX /AvantGarde-DemiOblique def

62: /NR /NewCenturySchlbk-Roman def

63: /NI /NewCenturySchlbk-Italic def

64: /NB /NewCenturySchlbk-Bold def

65: /NX /NewCenturySchlbk-BoldItalic def

66: /ZD /ZapfDingbats def

67: /ZI /ZapfChancery-MediumItalic def

68: /S  /S def

69: /S1 /S1 def

70: /GR /Symbol def

71: 

72: /inch {72 mul} bind def

73: /min {2 copy gt {exch} if pop} bind def

74: 

75: /setup {

76: 	counttomark 2 idiv {def} repeat pop

77: 

78: 	landscape {/orientation 90 orientation add def} if

79: 	/scaling 72 resolution div def

80: 	linewidth setlinewidth

81: 	1 setlinecap

82: 

83: 	pagedimensions

84: 	xcenter ycenter translate

85: 	orientation rotation mul rotate

86: 	width 2 div neg height 2 div translate

87: 	xoffset inch yoffset inch neg translate

88: 	margin 2 div dup neg translate

89: 	magnification dup aspectratio mul scale

90: 	scaling scaling scale

91: 

92: 	addmetrics

93: 	0 0 moveto

94: } def

95: 

96: /pagedimensions {

97: 	useclippath userdict /gotpagebbox known not and {

98: 		/pagebbox [clippath pathbbox newpath] def

99: 		roundpage currentdict /roundpagebbox known and {roundpagebbox} if

100: 	} if

101: 	pagebbox aload pop

102: 	4 -1 roll exch 4 1 roll 4 copy

103: 	landscape {4 2 roll} if

104: 	sub /width exch def

105: 	sub /height exch def

106: 	add 2 div /xcenter exch def

107: 	add 2 div /ycenter exch def

108: 	userdict /gotpagebbox true put

109: } def

110: 

111: /landscapepage {

112: 	landscape not {

113: 		0 height scaling div neg translate	% not quite

114: 		90 rotate

115: 	} if

116: } bind def

117: 

118: /portraitpage {

119: 	landscape {

120: 		width scaling div 0 translate	% not quite

121: 		-90 rotate

122: 	} if

123: } bind def

124: 

125: /addmetrics {

126: 	/Symbol /S null Sdefs cf

127: 	/Times-Roman /S1 StandardEncoding dup length array copy S1defs cf

128: } def

129: 

130: /pagesetup {

131: 	/page exch def

132: 	currentdict /pagedict known currentdict page known and {

133: 		page load pagedict exch get cvx exec

134: 	} if

135: } def

136: 

137: /decodingdefs [

138: 	{counttomark 2 idiv {y moveto show} repeat}

139: 	{neg /y exch def counttomark 2 idiv {y moveto show} repeat}

140: 	{neg moveto {2 index stringwidth pop sub exch div 0 32 4 -1 roll widthshow} repeat}

141: 	{neg moveto {spacewidth sub 0.0 32 4 -1 roll widthshow} repeat}

142: 	{counttomark 2 idiv {y moveto show} repeat}

143: 	{neg setfunnytext}

144: ] def

145: 

146: /setdecoding {/t decodingdefs 3 -1 roll get bind def} bind def

147: 

148: /w {neg moveto show} bind def

149: /m {neg dup /y exch def moveto} bind def

150: /done {/lastpage where {pop lastpage} if} def

151: 

152: /f {

153: 	dup /font exch def findfont exch

154: 	dup /ptsize exch def scaling div dup /size exch def scalefont setfont

155: 	linewidth ptsize mul scaling 10 mul div setlinewidth

156: 	/spacewidth ( ) stringwidth pop def

157: } bind def

158: 

159: /changefont {

160: 	/fontheight exch def

161: 	/fontslant exch def

162: 	currentfont [

163: 		1 0

164: 		fontheight ptsize div fontslant sin mul fontslant cos div

165: 		fontheight ptsize div

166: 		0 0

167: 	] makefont setfont

168: } bind def

169: 

170: /sf {f} bind def

171: 

172: /cf {

173: 	dup length 2 idiv

174: 	/entries exch def

175: 	/chtab exch def

176: 	/newencoding exch def

177: 	/newfont exch def

178: 

179: 	findfont dup length 1 add dict

180: 	/newdict exch def

181: 	{1 index /FID ne {newdict 3 1 roll put}{pop pop} ifelse} forall

182: 

183: 	newencoding type /arraytype eq {newdict /Encoding newencoding put} if

184: 

185: 	newdict /Metrics entries dict put

186: 	newdict /Metrics get

187: 	begin

188: 		chtab aload pop

189: 		1 1 entries {pop def} for

190: 		newfont newdict definefont pop

191: 	end

192: } bind def

193: 

194: %

195: % A few arrays used to adjust reference points and character widths in some

196: % of the printer resident fonts. If square roots are too high try changing

197: % the lines describing /radical and /radicalex to,

198: %

199: %	/radical	[0 -75 550 0]

200: %	/radicalex	[-50 -75 500 0]

201: %

202: % Move braceleftbt a bit - default PostScript character is off a bit.

203: %

204: 

205: /Sdefs [

206: 	/bracketlefttp		[201 500]

207: 	/bracketleftbt		[201 500]

208: 	/bracketrighttp		[-81 380]

209: 	/bracketrightbt		[-83 380]

210: 	/braceleftbt		[203 490]

211: 	/bracketrightex		[220 -125 500 0]

212: 	/radical		[0 0 550 0]

213: 	/radicalex		[-50 0 500 0]

214: 	/parenleftex		[-20 -170 0 0]

215: 	/integral		[100 -50 500 0]

216: 	/infinity		[10 -75 730 0]

217: ] def

218: 

219: /S1defs [

220: 	/underscore		[0 80 500 0]

221: 	/endash			[7 90 650 0]

222: ] def

223: end

224: %%EndProlog

225: %%BeginSetup

226: DpostDict begin

227: mark

228: /resolution 720 def

229: setup

230: 2 setdecoding

231: %

232: % Copyright (c) 1993 AT&T, All Rights Reserved

233: %

234: % Version 3.4 drawing procedures for dpost. Automatically pulled in when

235: % needed.

236: %

237: 

238: /inpath false def

239: /savematrix matrix def

240: 

241: /Dl {

242: 	inpath

243: 		{pop pop neg lineto}

244: 		{newpath neg moveto neg lineto stroke}

245: 	ifelse

246: } bind def

247: 

248: /De {

249: 	/y1 exch 2 div def

250: 	/x1 exch 2 div def

251: 	/savematrix savematrix currentmatrix def

252: 	neg exch x1 add exch translate

253: 	x1 y1 scale

254: 	0 0 1 0 360

255: 	inpath

256: 		{1 0 moveto arc savematrix setmatrix}

257: 		{newpath arc savematrix setmatrix stroke}

258: 	ifelse

259: } bind def

260: 

261: /Da {

262: 	/dy2 exch def

263: 	/dx2 exch def

264: 	/dy1 exch def

265: 	/dx1 exch def

266: 	dy1 add neg exch dx1 add exch

267: 	dx1 dx1 mul dy1 dy1 mul add sqrt

268: 	dy1 dx1 neg atan

269: 	dy2 neg dx2 atan

270: 	inpath

271: 		{arc}

272: 		{newpath arc stroke}

273: 	ifelse

274: } bind def

275: 

276: /DA {

277: 	/dy2 exch def

278: 	/dx2 exch def

279: 	/dy1 exch def

280: 	/dx1 exch def

281: 	dy1 add neg exch dx1 add exch

282: 	dx1 dx1 mul dy1 dy1 mul add sqrt

283: 	dy1 dx1 neg atan

284: 	dy2 neg dx2 atan

285: 	inpath

286: 		{arcn}

287: 		{newpath arcn stroke}

288: 	ifelse

289: } bind def

290: 

291: /Ds {

292: 	/y2 exch def

293: 	/x2 exch def

294: 	/y1 exch def

295: 	/x1 exch def

296: 	/y0 exch def

297: 	/x0 exch def

298: 	x0 5 x1 mul add 6 div

299: 	y0 5 y1 mul add -6 div

300: 	x2 5 x1 mul add 6 div

301: 	y2 5 y1 mul add -6 div

302: 	x1 x2 add 2 div

303: 	y1 y2 add -2 div

304: 	inpath

305: 		{curveto}

306: 		{newpath x0 x1 add 2 div y0 y1 add -2 div moveto curveto stroke}

307: 	ifelse

308: } bind def

309: end

310: %%EndSetup

311: %%Page: 1 1

312: gsave %matrix defaultmatrix setmatrix

313: 90 rotate 4 72 mul .55 -72 mul moveto /Times-Roman findfont

314: 20 scalefont setfont 0.3 setgray (arXiv:cs.NI/0002011   17 Feb 2000) show grestore

315: DpostDict begin

316: /saveobj save def

317: mark

318: 1 pagesetup

319: %INFO[COMPANY:  AT&T Labs - Research]

320: %INFO[DATE: August 10, 1999.]

321: %INFO[WORK PROJECT: 311305-0199]

322: %INFO[FILING CASE: 39394]

323: %INFO[AUTHOR: NAME = N. F. Maxemchuk, ORG = HA1730000, LOC = FP, ROOM = 2C225, PHONE = 6240, AFFILIATION = AT&T Labs - Research]

324: %INFO[AUTHOR: NAME = D. H. Shur, ORG = HA173000, LOC = FP, ROOM = 2C225, PHONE = 6240, AFFILIATION = AT&T Labs - Research]

325: %INFO[DOCUMENT NUMBER: 11382-860514-02]

326: %INFO[DOCUMENT STYLE: CODE = RP, TYPE = Released Paper]

327: %INFO[TITLE: <START>]

328: 12 B f

329: (An Internet Multicast System for the Stock Market)7 2624 1 1553 960 t

330: %INFO[TITLE: <END>]

331: %INFO[TITLE: <END>]

332: 11 I f

333: (N. F. Maxemchuk)2 780 1 2490 1140 t

334: (D. H. Shur)2 478 1 2641 1260 t

335: 10 R f

336: (AT&T Labs - Research)3 939 1 2410 1440 t

337: 10 I f

338: (ABSTRACT)2643 1800 w

339: %INFO[ABSTRACT: HEADING = ABSTRACT]

340: %INFO[ABSTRACT: <START>]

341: 10 R f

342: ( The)1 229( moving toward a distributed, international, twenty-four hour, electronic stock exchange.)10 3784(We are)1 307 3 720 2100 t

343: ( system is a natural application of)6 1469( This)1 249( or internet technology.)3 995(exchange will use the global Internet,)5 1607 4 720 2220 t

344: ( there are a large number of receivers that should receive the same information)13 3580(multicast because)1 740 2 720 2340 t

345: (simultaneously.)720 2460 w

346: ( current multicast protocols lack the)5 1539( The)1 225(The data requirements for the stock exchange are discussed.)8 2556 3 720 2700 t

347: ( describe a distributed architecture)4 1474( We)1 213( this application.)2 714(reliability, fairness, and scalability needed in)5 1919 4 720 2820 t

348: ( a modi\256cation of the RMP protocol, that has characteristics)9 2547(together with a reliable multicast protocol,)5 1773 2 720 2940 t

349: (appropriate for this application.)3 1259 1 720 3060 t

350: (The architecture is used in three applications:)6 1813 1 720 3300 t

351: ( being conducted on the)4 1030( the \256rst, we construct a uni\256ed stock ticker of the transactions that are)13 3057(\320 In)1 233 3 720 3480 t

352: ( the same combined ticker)4 1096( objective is to deliver the)5 1100( Our)1 218(various physical and electronic exchanges.)4 1756 4 870 3600 t

353: (reliably and simultaneously to all receivers, anywhere in the world.)9 2687 1 870 3720 t

354: ( are delivered to a single)5 1063( the second, we construct a uni\256ed sequence of buy and sell offers that)13 3024(\320 In)1 233 3 720 3900 t

355: ( same fair access to an)5 939( objective is to give all traders the)7 1421( Our)1 215(exchange or a collection of exchanges.)5 1595 4 870 4020 t

356: ( the loss characteristics of the)5 1293(exchange independent of their relative distances to the exchange or)9 2877 2 870 4140 t

357: (international network.)1 882 1 870 4260 t

358: ( trading \257oor that can replace the current exchanges.)8 2155( the third, we construct a distributed, electronic)7 1932(\320 In)1 233 3 720 4440 t

359: (This application uses the innovations from the \256rst two applications to combine their fairness attributes.)14 4150 1 870 4560 t

360: %INFO[ABSTRACT: <END>]

361: %INFO[SECTION: LEVEL = 1, NUMBER = 1.  , HEADING = Introduction]

362: 9 B f

363: (1. Introduction)1 604 1 720 4920 t

364: 10 R f

365: ( a marketplace where)3 882(An exchange is any organization, association or group which provides or maintains)11 3438 2 720 5100 t

366: ( exchanges around the)3 940(securities, options, futures or commodities can be traded. There are hundreds of)11 3380 2 720 5220 t

367: (world. Yahoo lists 107 stock exchanges.)5 1612 1 720 5340 t

368: ( is located in a single physical place and all data)10 1949( exchange)1 403( The)1 207(Traditional stock exchanges are centralized.)4 1761 4 720 5580 t

369: ( centralized system is responsible for)5 1628( The)1 235(\(both market and trades\) \257ows through a single system.)8 2457 3 720 5700 t

370: (transaction reporting, and settlements for the purpose of exchanging assets.)9 3003 1 720 5820 t

371: ( the centralized)2 637(Electronic exchanges, like the NASDAQ, allow remotely located traders to connect with)11 3683 2 720 6060 t

372: ( traders send and receive information, trades, etc., over dedicated access lines and private)13 3793(system. The)1 527 2 720 6180 t

373: ( are expensive, and thus limit who can be connected.)9 2104(networks. Connections)1 941 2 720 6300 t

374: ( now allows, or is on the verge of allowing, almost anyone to connect to almost any electronic)17 3827(The Internet)1 493 2 720 6540 t

375: ( communication technology is enabling the)5 1924( Internet)1 400( at very low cost.)4 845(exchange, in any country,)3 1151 4 720 6660 t

376: ( exchanges and a number of Internet based private stock trading systems are)12 3265(restructuring of the stock)3 1055 2 720 6780 t

377: ( The)1 212( systems, such as the NASDAQ.)5 1331( stock trading systems interface into other trading)7 2034(emerging. Private)1 743 4 720 6900 t

378: ( may satisfy buy and sell requests among their own subscriber base, or may pass on the trade)17 3739(private system)1 581 2 720 7020 t

379: (to the larger exchange.)3 908 1 720 7140 t

380: ( noted in these excerpts from the prepared remarks by)9 2165(The electronic stock market presents opportunities, as)6 2155 2 720 7380 t

381: cleartomark

382: showpage

383: saveobj restore

384: end

385: %%EndPage: 1 1

386: %%Page: 2 2

387: DpostDict begin

388: /saveobj save def

389: mark

390: 2 pagesetup

391: 10 R f

392: (- 2 -)2 166 1 2797 480 t

393: ( the)1 165( before)1 323( and CEO of the National Association of Securities Dealers Inc.)10 2738( Chairman)1 463(Frank G. Zarb,)2 631 5 720 960 t

394: (National Press Club in Washington, D.C. on Wednesday, June 23, 1999:)10 2901 1 720 1080 t

395: 10 I f

396: (In a very few years, trading securities will be digital, global, and accessible 24 hours a day.)16 3682 1 1080 1320 t

397: ( able to get stock price quotations instantly and instantly execute a trade any time of)15 3388(People will be)2 572 2 1080 1560 t

398: (day or night, anywhere on the globe, with stock markets linked and almost all-electronic.)13 3564 1 1080 1680 t

399: ( markets, they will see global alliances, mergers, and new electronic ventures. That)12 3468(As for stock)2 492 2 1080 1920 t

400: (will give companies listed on these markets access to pools of capital internationally, not just)14 3960 1 1080 2040 t

401: ( worldwide list of companies as easily as)7 1700(domestically, and consumers will be able to invest in a)9 2260 2 1080 2160 t

402: (trading locally.)1 617 1 1080 2280 t

403: ( technology-driven)1 769(This 21st century stock market will be multi-dealer, computer-screen based,)9 3191 2 1080 2520 t

404: (and open to all - all because people will have access to information that they want to act on.)18 3696 1 1080 2640 t

405: 10 R f

406: ( excerpts from a New York)5 1178(An electronic exchange also creates technical challenges, as noted in these)10 3142 2 720 2880 t

407: ( interview with Arthur Levitt, the chairman of the Securities and)10 2711(Times article on Sept. 23, 1999, of an)7 1609 2 720 3000 t

408: (Exchange Commission:)1 953 1 720 3120 t

409: 10 I f

410: (Levitt seems most concerned that if trading continues to migrate to the new electronic market)14 3960 1 1080 3360 t

411: ( about orders and transactions across)5 1550( Information)1 534(systems, investors may not get the best prices.)7 1876 3 1080 3480 t

412: ( allows the creation of)4 915( he said,)2 344( Technology,)1 545(the entire market are not now available in one place.)9 2156 4 1080 3600 t

413: ( investors will be fully informed about prices everywhere, from the New)11 2920(a central system in which)4 1040 2 1080 3720 t

414: (York Stock Exchange, the NASDAQ, the American Stock Exchange and the new systems.)12 3535 1 1080 3840 t

415: ( to)1 107(He stressed that he was asking for the development of a technology that would allow all orders)16 3853 2 1080 4080 t

416: (be shown to investors, not an institution or place where all orders would be executed.)14 3427 1 1080 4200 t

417: 10 R f

418: ( The)1 211( architecture and protocol which can meet these challenges, and more.)10 2858(We are proposing a distributed)4 1251 3 720 4440 t

419: ( focus on stock exchanges)4 1134( this document we)3 802( In)1 157(architecture is used to implement three applications.)6 2227 4 720 4560 t

420: ( to other types of exchanges and the fairness attributes are)10 2531(although many of the ideas are applicable)6 1789 2 720 4680 t

421: (appropriate for some distributed games.)4 1589 1 720 4800 t

422: ( of trading \257oors, distributed globally, are)6 1719(In the \256rst application, the trades that are executed on hundreds)10 2601 2 720 5040 t

423: ( presented to millions or tens of millions of investors,)9 2382(merged into a single information stream and)6 1938 2 720 5160 t

424: ( the same)2 383( objective is to provide the same information stream, with all of the reports in)14 3122(internationally. Our)1 815 3 720 5280 t

425: ( time, no matter where in the world they are, or where the trading)13 2686(order, to all of the investors at the same)8 1634 2 720 5400 t

426: ( of the reliable multicast protocol,)5 1449( meet this objective using a modi\256ed version)7 1917( We)1 206(\257oors are located.)2 748 4 720 5520 t

427: ( our architecture does not have the scaling problems that are common in many)13 3320( show that)2 443(RMP[1]. We)1 557 3 720 5640 t

428: (reliable multicast applications.)2 1224 1 720 5760 t

429: ( merged into a single stream)5 1139(In the second application, the buy and sell orders from millions of investors are)13 3181 2 720 6000 t

430: ( exchanges)1 458( The)1 223( presented to several exchanges.)4 1354(and presented to a single exchange, or simultaneously)7 2285 4 720 6120 t

431: ( city as an exchange have an)6 1261( investors that are in the same)6 1307( Currently,)1 478(operate under their own rules.)4 1274 4 720 6240 t

432: ( time and)2 378( both investors see a ticker at the same)8 1568( If)1 120(advantage over investors on the other side of the world.)9 2254 4 720 6360 t

433: (submit a bid, the bid from the closer investor may reach the exchange several seconds earlier on the)17 4320 1 720 6480 t

434: ( application differs from the)4 1124( This)1 229( give all investors fair access to the exchange.)8 1834( objective is to)3 592(average. Our)1 541 5 720 6600 t

435: ( cryptographic techniques, and the trust)5 1595( The)1 209( the cryptographic techniques that must be used.)7 1953(\256rst mostly in)2 563 4 720 6720 t

436: (relationships, will be explained in section 6, after the architecture is described in section 4.)14 3619 1 720 6840 t

437: ( buy, sell, and cancel orders to create a)8 1617(In the third application we use a distributed rule to operate on the)12 2703 2 720 7080 t

438: ( exchange makes use of the sequencing property of RMP, and also the)12 3175( This)1 259(distributed exchange.)1 886 3 720 7200 t

439: ( every other receiver has seen the same sequence.)8 2061(characteristic that every receiver eventually knows that)6 2259 2 720 7320 t

440: ( exchanges can)2 615( Distributed)1 506( rules for executing trades.)4 1085(This distributed exchange can operate under several)6 2114 4 720 7440 t

441: cleartomark

442: showpage

443: saveobj restore

444: end

445: %%EndPage: 2 2

446: %%Page: 3 3

447: DpostDict begin

448: /saveobj save def

449: mark

450: 3 pagesetup

451: 10 R f

452: (- 3 -)2 166 1 2797 480 t

453: (be among the trading \257oors in the \256rst two applications.)9 2238 1 720 960 t

454: %INFO[SECTION: LEVEL = 1, NUMBER = 2.  , HEADING = RMP]

455: 9 B f

456: (2. RMP)1 319 1 720 1200 t

457: 10 R f

458: ( 1983 to build a distributed database, with redundant data,)9 2326(The RMP protocol was originally implemented in)6 1994 2 720 1380 t

459: ( buffer over\257ows)2 713( computers on the Ethernet independently lost messages due to)9 2637( The)1 219(on an Ethernet[2].)2 751 4 720 1500 t

460: ( and the multicast)3 849( protocol predated the word "multicast")5 1807( The)1 251(caused by competing processes.)3 1413 4 720 1620 t

461: ( has)1 163( RBP)1 245( the reliable broadcast protocol, RBP.)5 1526( was originally called)3 875( It)1 117(implementation on the Internet[3].)3 1394 6 720 1740 t

462: (three characteristics that distinguishes it from earlier protocols.)7 2518 1 720 1860 t

463: ( characteristic of RBP is that it guarantees that every receiver places the messages in the same)16 3971(The \256rst)1 349 2 720 2100 t

464: ( databases are simpler to implement when the programs running on the different)12 3428(sequence. Redundant)1 892 2 720 2220 t

465: ( database)1 377( message sequencing preserves the)4 1417( RBP's)1 320(machines always place the database in the same state.)8 2206 4 720 2340 t

466: (state.)720 2460 w

467: ( has the)2 319(The second characteristic of RBP is that every receiver eventually knows that every other receiver)14 4001 2 720 2700 t

468: ( reason for redundant data is to be able to operate during failures that make some copies)16 3573( primary)1 346(data. The)1 401 3 720 2820 t

469: ( only committing database operations that can be performed on every active)11 3173( By)1 180(of the data unavailable.)3 967 3 720 2940 t

470: (copy of the database, we guarantee data consistency when copies of the database fail and are restored.)16 4065 1 720 3060 t

471: ( is that it uses only one control message per data message, independent of)13 3044(The third characteristic of RBP)4 1276 2 720 3300 t

472: ( number of messages that are transmitted when)7 1912( The)1 211(the number of receivers, when there aren't any losses.)8 2197 3 720 3420 t

473: ( number of control messages should be compared with earlier)9 2477( The)1 207(there are losses is derived in reference 4.)7 1636 3 720 3540 t

474: ( when there aren't any losses,)5 1200(reliable protocols, that require at least as many control messages as receivers)11 3120 2 720 3660 t

475: (without providing the \256rst two characteristics.)5 1843 1 720 3780 t

476: ( NASA)1 340( applied to the Internet multicast network and called RMP[5].)9 2620(A modi\256ed version of RBP was)5 1360 3 720 4020 t

477: (maintains a WEB site for recent work on RMP at http://research.ivv.nasa.gov/RMP/.)10 3386 1 720 4140 t

478: %INFO[SECTION: LEVEL = 2, NUMBER = 2.1  , HEADING = The Original Protocol]

479: 9 B f

480: ( Original Protocol)2 696(2.1 The)1 309 2 720 4320 t

481: 10 R f

482: ( modi\256ed to meet the requirements of the stock exchange, it is necessary to)13 3066(Before describing how RMP is)4 1254 2 720 4500 t

483: ( \256rst part operates on multicast messages)6 1643( The)1 206( protocol has two parts.)4 939( The)1 206( operation.)1 428(understand its original)2 898 6 720 4620 t

484: ( The)1 227( of the messages from the sources.)6 1504( guarantees delivery and ordering)4 1419( It)1 132(during normal operation.)2 1038 5 720 4740 t

485: ( database)1 397(second part is a reformation protocol that reorganizes the broadcast group and guarantees)12 3923 2 720 4860 t

486: ( with the \256rst part of the)6 1068( this paper we are only concerned)6 1436( In)1 149(consistency after failures and recoverys.)4 1667 4 720 4980 t

487: ( phase commit procedure and is completely)6 1760( original reformation protocol is based on a three)8 1992(protocol. The)1 568 3 720 5100 t

488: ( use a simpler, centralized procedure in this application.)8 2229(distributed. We)1 641 2 720 5220 t

489: (There are)1 384 1 720 5460 t

490: 10 I f

491: (n)1135 5460 w

492: 10 R f

493: (sources and)1 474 1 1216 5460 t

494: 10 I f

495: (m)1721 5460 w

496: 10 R f

497: ( sources and receivers may be the same or)8 1734( The)1 212( 1.)1 107(receivers, as shown in \256gure)4 1163 4 1824 5460 t

498: ( objective is for the)4 795(different. The)1 579 2 720 5580 t

499: 10 I f

500: (m)2125 5580 w

501: 10 R f

502: ( place the messages from the)5 1175(receivers to)1 468 2 2228 5580 t

503: 10 I f

504: (n)3901 5580 w

505: 10 R f

506: (sources in the same order,)4 1059 1 3981 5580 t

507: ( is accomplished by having a single)6 1517( This)1 244( fail to receive which messages.)5 1349(regardless of which receivers)3 1210 4 720 5700 t

508: ( of)1 114( acknowledgement assign the message a sequence number and all)9 2682( The)1 212(receiver acknowledge messages.)2 1312 4 720 5820 t

509: ( guarantee that every)3 857( We)1 196(the receivers place the messages in the order indicated by the sequence number.)12 3267 3 720 5940 t

510: ( messages by sequentially passing the responsibility to acknowledge messages to each)11 3454(receiver has all of the)4 866 2 720 6060 t

511: ( preceding messages before acknowledging a new)6 2090(receiver and requiring a receiver to acquire all of the)9 2230 2 720 6180 t

512: (message.)720 6300 w

513: (A message from source)3 975 1 720 6540 t

514: 10 I f

515: (s)1733 6540 w

516: 10 R f

517: (contains the label \()3 796 1 1810 6540 t

518: 10 I f

519: (s)2614 6540 w

520: 10 R f

521: (,)2661 6540 w

522: 10 I f

523: (M)2694 6540 w

524: 7 I f

525: (s)2788 6560 w

526: 10 R f

527: (\) to signify that it is the)6 1012 1 2831 6540 t

528: 10 I f

529: (M)3881 6540 w

530: 7 I f

531: (s)3969 6559 w

532: (th)3969 6500 w

533: 10 R f

534: (message from source)2 868 1 4070 6540 t

535: 10 I f

536: (s)4976 6540 w

537: 10 R f

538: (.)5015 6540 w

539: (Source)720 6660 w

540: 10 I f

541: (s)1024 6660 w

542: 10 R f

543: (transmits message)1 732 1 1090 6660 t

544: 10 I f

545: (M)1849 6660 w

546: 7 I f

547: (s)1943 6680 w

548: 10 R f

549: (at regular intervals until it receives an acknowledgement or decides that the)11 3035 1 2005 6660 t

550: ( operating it initiates the)4 1052( a source decides that the token site is not)9 1827( When)1 307(token site is not operating.)4 1134 4 720 6780 t

551: (reformation process to form a new token group.)7 1907 1 720 6900 t

552: ( of the receivers is)4 735( Each)1 250( turns acknowledging messages from sources by passing a token.)9 2605(The receivers take)2 730 4 720 7140 t

553: (assigned a unique number from 0 to)6 1641 1 720 7260 t

554: 10 I f

555: (m)2420 7260 w

556: 10 S f

557: (-)2516 7260 w

558: 10 R f

559: ( the token site at receiver number)6 1528(1. When)1 396 2 2587 7260 t

560: 10 I f

561: (r)4569 7260 w

562: 10 R f

563: (sends an)1 374 1 4666 7260 t

564: (acknowledgement, the message serves three separate functions:)6 2535 1 720 7380 t

565: cleartomark

566: showpage

567: saveobj restore

568: end

569: %%EndPage: 3 3

570: %%Page: 4 4

571: DpostDict begin

572: /saveobj save def

573: mark

574: 4 pagesetup

575: 10 R f

576: (- 4 -)2 166 1 2797 480 t

577: 2448 2256 864 432 De

578: (Broadcast Medium)1 763 1 3337 2276 t

579: 1422 1716 216 216 De

580: 1630 1756 1703 1766 Dl

581: 1630 1756 1690 1799 Dl

582: 2779 2216 1630 1756 Dl

583: 2779 2215 2706 2205 Dl

584: 2779 2215 2719 2172 Dl

585: 1962 1716 216 216 De

586: 2160 1775 2229 1800 Dl

587: 2160 1776 2209 1830 Dl

588: 2790 2195 2160 1775 Dl

589: 2789 2196 2720 2171 Dl

590: 2789 2195 2740 2141 Dl

591: 2502 1716 216 216 De

592: 2658 1812 2706 1868 Dl

593: 2659 1813 2674 1885 Dl

594: 2831 2159 2658 1812 Dl

595: 2831 2159 2783 2103 Dl

596: 2830 2158 2815 2086 Dl

597: 3042 1716 216 216 De

598: 3100 1813 3085 1885 Dl

599: 3101 1812 3053 1868 Dl

600: 2928 2159 3101 1812 Dl

601: 2929 2158 2944 2086 Dl

602: 2928 2159 2976 2103 Dl

603: 3582 1716 216 216 De

604: 3599 1776 3550 1830 Dl

605: 3599 1775 3530 1800 Dl

606: 2970 2195 3600 1775 Dl

607: 2970 2195 3019 2141 Dl

608: 2970 2196 3039 2171 Dl

609: 4122 1716 216 216 De

610: 4129 1756 4069 1799 Dl

611: 4129 1756 4056 1766 Dl

612: 2980 2216 4129 1756 Dl

613: 2980 2215 3040 2172 Dl

614: 2980 2215 3053 2205 Dl

615: ( 2)1 540(Sources 1)1 -2808 2 4363 1736 t

616: (. . .)2 125 1 2548 1711 t

617: 10 I f

618: (s)3131 1736 w

619: 10 R f

620: (. . .)2 125 1 3628 1711 t

621: 10 I f

622: (n)4205 1736 w

623: 1394 960 1394 1500 Dl

624: 1664 960 1394 960 Dl

625: 1664 1500 1664 960 Dl

626: 1394 1500 1664 1500 Dl

627: 10 R f

628: (. . .)2 125 1 1468 1279 t

629: 1934 960 1934 1500 Dl

630: 2204 960 1934 960 Dl

631: 2204 1500 2204 960 Dl

632: 1934 1500 2204 1500 Dl

633: (. . .)2 125 1 2008 1279 t

634: (. . .)2 125 1 2548 1225 t

635: 3014 960 3014 1500 Dl

636: 3284 960 3014 960 Dl

637: 3284 1500 3284 960 Dl

638: 3014 1500 3284 1500 Dl

639: (. . .)2 125 1 3088 1279 t

640: (. . .)2 125 1 3628 1225 t

641: 4094 960 4094 1500 Dl

642: 4364 960 4094 960 Dl

643: 4364 1500 4364 960 Dl

644: 4094 1500 4364 1500 Dl

645: (. . .)2 125 1 4168 1279 t

646: (Transmitted)4473 1142 w

647: (Messages)4473 1250 w

648: (1,1)1468 1088 w

649: (1,2)1468 1196 w

650: (1,)1424 1412 w

651: 10 I f

652: (M)1499 1412 w

653: 7 R f

654: (1)1593 1432 w

655: 10 R f

656: (2,1)2008 1088 w

657: (2,2)2008 1196 w

658: (2,)1964 1412 w

659: 10 I f

660: (M)2039 1412 w

661: 7 R f

662: (2)2133 1432 w

663: 10 R f

664: (s,1)3093 1088 w

665: (s,2)3093 1196 w

666: (s,)3054 1412 w

667: 10 I f

668: (M)3118 1412 w

669: 7 I f

670: (s)3212 1432 w

671: 10 R f

672: (n,1)4168 1088 w

673: (n,2)4168 1196 w

674: (n,)4124 1412 w

675: 10 I f

676: (M)4199 1412 w

677: 7 I f

678: (n)4293 1432 w

679: 10 R f

680: 882 2904 216 216 De

681: 1093 2868 1154 2828 Dl

682: 1092 2868 1166 2862 Dl

683: 2777 2290 1092 2868 Dl

684: 2776 2291 2715 2331 Dl

685: 2777 2291 2703 2297 Dl

686: 1134 2904 1098 2904 Dl

687: 1206 2904 1170 2904 Dl

688: 1278 2904 1242 2904 Dl

689: 1350 2904 1314 2904 Dl

690: 1422 2904 1386 2904 Dl

691: 1422 2904 1350 2922 Dl

692: 1422 2904 1350 2886 Dl

693: 800 3552 800 4524 Dl

694: 1178 3552 800 3552 Dl

695: 1178 4524 1178 3552 Dl

696: 800 4524 1178 4524 Dl

697: (1)836 3680 w

698: (t ?)1 147 1 836 4436 t

699: 1422 2904 216 216 De

700: 1628 2856 1684 2809 Dl

701: 1627 2857 1699 2842 Dl

702: 2782 2303 1627 2857 Dl

703: 2781 2303 2725 2350 Dl

704: 2782 2302 2710 2317 Dl

705: 1674 2904 1638 2904 Dl

706: 1746 2904 1710 2904 Dl

707: 1818 2904 1782 2904 Dl

708: 1890 2904 1854 2904 Dl

709: 1962 2904 1926 2904 Dl

710: 1962 2904 1890 2922 Dl

711: 1962 2904 1890 2886 Dl

712: 1340 3552 1340 4524 Dl

713: 1718 3552 1340 3552 Dl

714: 1718 4524 1718 3552 Dl

715: 1340 4524 1718 4524 Dl

716: (1)1376 3680 w

717: (t ?)1 147 1 1376 4436 t

718: 1962 2904 216 216 De

719: 2155 2836 2199 2777 Dl

720: 2154 2835 2221 2805 Dl

721: 2795 2323 2154 2836 Dl

722: 2794 2323 2750 2382 Dl

723: 2795 2324 2728 2354 Dl

724: 2214 2904 2178 2904 Dl

725: 2286 2904 2250 2904 Dl

726: 2358 2904 2322 2904 Dl

727: 2430 2904 2394 2904 Dl

728: 2502 2904 2466 2904 Dl

729: 2502 2904 2430 2922 Dl

730: 2502 2904 2430 2886 Dl

731: (. . .)2 125 1 2008 4033 t

732: 2502 2904 216 216 De

733: 2652 2804 2662 2731 Dl

734: 2651 2803 2695 2744 Dl

735: 2838 2356 2651 2804 Dl

736: 2837 2355 2827 2428 Dl

737: 2838 2356 2794 2415 Dl

738: 2754 2904 2718 2904 Dl

739: 2826 2904 2790 2904 Dl

740: 2898 2904 2862 2904 Dl

741: 2970 2904 2934 2904 Dl

742: 3042 2904 3006 2904 Dl

743: 3042 2904 2970 2922 Dl

744: 3042 2904 2970 2886 Dl

745: 2420 3552 2420 4524 Dl

746: 2798 3552 2420 3552 Dl

747: 2798 4524 2798 3552 Dl

748: 2420 4524 2798 4524 Dl

749: (1)2456 3680 w

750: (t ?)1 147 1 2456 4436 t

751: 3042 2904 216 216 De

752: 3108 2803 3064 2744 Dl

753: 3107 2804 3097 2731 Dl

754: 2921 2356 3108 2804 Dl

755: 2921 2356 2965 2415 Dl

756: 2922 2355 2932 2428 Dl

757: 3294 2904 3258 2904 Dl

758: 3366 2904 3330 2904 Dl

759: 3438 2904 3402 2904 Dl

760: 3510 2904 3474 2904 Dl

761: 3582 2904 3546 2904 Dl

762: 3582 2904 3510 2922 Dl

763: 3582 2904 3510 2886 Dl

764: 2960 3552 2960 4524 Dl

765: 3338 3552 2960 3552 Dl

766: 3338 4524 3338 3552 Dl

767: 2960 4524 3338 4524 Dl

768: (1)2996 3680 w

769: 3582 2904 216 216 De

770: 3605 2835 3538 2805 Dl

771: 3604 2836 3560 2777 Dl

772: 2964 2323 3605 2836 Dl

773: 2964 2324 3031 2354 Dl

774: 2965 2323 3009 2382 Dl

775: 3834 2904 3798 2904 Dl

776: 3906 2904 3870 2904 Dl

777: 3978 2904 3942 2904 Dl

778: 4050 2904 4014 2904 Dl

779: 4122 2904 4086 2904 Dl

780: 4122 2904 4050 2922 Dl

781: 4122 2904 4050 2886 Dl

782: 3500 3552 3500 4524 Dl

783: 3878 3552 3500 3552 Dl

784: 3878 4524 3878 3552 Dl

785: 3500 4524 3878 4524 Dl

786: (1)3536 3680 w

787: (t ?)1 147 1 3536 4436 t

788: 4122 2904 216 216 De

789: 4132 2857 4060 2842 Dl

790: 4131 2856 4075 2809 Dl

791: 2977 2303 4132 2857 Dl

792: 2977 2302 3049 2317 Dl

793: 2978 2303 3034 2350 Dl

794: 4374 2904 4338 2904 Dl

795: 4446 2904 4410 2904 Dl

796: 4518 2904 4482 2904 Dl

797: 4590 2904 4554 2904 Dl

798: 4662 2904 4626 2904 Dl

799: 4662 2904 4590 2922 Dl

800: 4662 2904 4590 2886 Dl

801: (. . .)2 125 1 4168 4033 t

802: 4662 2904 216 216 De

803: 4667 2868 4593 2862 Dl

804: 4666 2868 4605 2828 Dl

805: 2982 2290 4667 2868 Dl

806: 2982 2291 3056 2297 Dl

807: 2983 2291 3044 2331 Dl

808: 4580 3552 4580 4524 Dl

809: 4958 3552 4580 3552 Dl

810: 4958 4524 4958 3552 Dl

811: 4580 4524 4958 4524 Dl

812: (1)4616 3680 w

813: (t ?)1 147 1 4616 4436 t

814: (Receivers)5173 2924 w

815: (Token Ring)1 475 1 5173 2600 t

816: 4914 2904 4878 2904 Dl

817: 4976 2904 4940 2904 Dl

818: 5040 2904 5004 2904 Dl

819: 5040 2868 5040 2904 Dl

820: 5040 2796 5040 2832 Dl

821: 5040 2724 5040 2760 Dl

822: 5040 2652 5040 2688 Dl

823: 5040 2580 5040 2616 Dl

824: 5004 2580 5040 2580 Dl

825: 4931 2580 4967 2580 Dl

826: 4858 2580 4894 2580 Dl

827: 4785 2580 4821 2580 Dl

828: 4713 2580 4749 2580 Dl

829: 4641 2580 4677 2580 Dl

830: 4568 2580 4604 2580 Dl

831: 4495 2580 4531 2580 Dl

832: 4422 2580 4458 2580 Dl

833: 4350 2580 4386 2580 Dl

834: 4278 2580 4314 2580 Dl

835: 4205 2580 4241 2580 Dl

836: 4132 2580 4168 2580 Dl

837: 4060 2580 4096 2580 Dl

838: 3987 2580 4023 2580 Dl

839: 3914 2580 3950 2580 Dl

840: 3841 2580 3877 2580 Dl

841: 3769 2580 3805 2580 Dl

842: 3697 2580 3733 2580 Dl

843: 3624 2580 3660 2580 Dl

844: 3551 2580 3587 2580 Dl

845: 3479 2580 3515 2580 Dl

846: 3406 2580 3442 2580 Dl

847: 3334 2580 3370 2580 Dl

848: 3261 2580 3297 2580 Dl

849: 3188 2580 3224 2580 Dl

850: 3116 2580 3152 2580 Dl

851: 3043 2580 3079 2580 Dl

852: 2970 2580 3006 2580 Dl

853: 2898 2580 2934 2580 Dl

854: 2826 2580 2862 2580 Dl

855: 2753 2580 2789 2580 Dl

856: 2680 2580 2716 2580 Dl

857: 2607 2580 2643 2580 Dl

858: 2535 2580 2571 2580 Dl

859: 2462 2580 2498 2580 Dl

860: 2389 2580 2425 2580 Dl

861: 2317 2580 2353 2580 Dl

862: 2244 2580 2280 2580 Dl

863: 2172 2580 2208 2580 Dl

864: 2099 2580 2135 2580 Dl

865: 2026 2580 2062 2580 Dl

866: 1954 2580 1990 2580 Dl

867: 1882 2580 1918 2580 Dl

868: 1809 2580 1845 2580 Dl

869: 1736 2580 1772 2580 Dl

870: 1663 2580 1699 2580 Dl

871: 1591 2580 1627 2580 Dl

872: 1518 2580 1554 2580 Dl

873: 1445 2580 1481 2580 Dl

874: 1373 2580 1409 2580 Dl

875: 1301 2580 1337 2580 Dl

876: 1228 2580 1264 2580 Dl

877: 1155 2580 1191 2580 Dl

878: 1082 2580 1118 2580 Dl

879: 1010 2580 1046 2580 Dl

880: 938 2580 974 2580 Dl

881: 865 2580 901 2580 Dl

882: 792 2580 828 2580 Dl

883: 720 2580 756 2580 Dl

884: 720 2616 720 2580 Dl

885: 720 2688 720 2652 Dl

886: 720 2760 720 2724 Dl

887: 720 2832 720 2796 Dl

888: 720 2904 720 2868 Dl

889: 756 2904 720 2904 Dl

890: 818 2904 782 2904 Dl

891: 882 2904 846 2904 Dl

892: 882 2904 810 2922 Dl

893: 882 2904 810 2886 Dl

894: (0 1)1 590 1 965 2924 t

895: (. . .)2 125 1 2008 2899 t

896: 10 I f

897: (r)2518 2924 w

898: 10 S f

899: (-)2581 2924 w

900: 10 R f

901: (1)2652 2924 w

902: 10 I f

903: (r r)1 506 1 3131 2924 t

904: 10 S f

905: (+)3661 2924 w

906: 10 R f

907: (1)3732 2924 w

908: (. . .)2 125 1 4168 2899 t

909: 10 I f

910: (m)4662 2924 w

911: 10 S f

912: (-)4758 2924 w

913: 10 R f

914: (1)4829 2924 w

915: (Received)5067 3950 w

916: (Messages)5067 4058 w

917: (Token Site)1 436 1 2932 3086 t

918: 3150 3120 3168 3192 Dl

919: 3150 3120 3132 3192 Dl

920: 3150 3444 3150 3120 Dl

921: (1. Ack)1 266 1 3200 3200 t

922: 10 I f

923: (t)3491 3200 w

924: 10 R f

925: (for Msg \()2 377 1 3544 3200 t

926: 10 I f

927: (s)3929 3200 w

928: 10 R f

929: (,)3976 3200 w

930: 10 I f

931: (M)4009 3200 w

932: 7 I f

933: (s)4103 3220 w

934: 10 R f

935: (\))4146 3200 w

936: 2988 3444 3150 3444 Dl

937: 2988 3444 3060 3426 Dl

938: 2988 3444 3060 3462 Dl

939: (2. Ack token to)3 616 1 2163 3404 t

940: 10 I f

941: (r)2804 3404 w

942: 10 S f

943: (-)2867 3404 w

944: 10 R f

945: (1)2938 3404 w

946: 3312 3444 3150 3444 Dl

947: 3312 3444 3240 3462 Dl

948: 3312 3444 3240 3426 Dl

949: (3. Pass token to)3 628 1 3312 3404 t

950: 10 I f

951: (r)3965 3404 w

952: 10 S f

953: (+)4028 3404 w

954: 10 R f

955: (1)4099 3404 w

956: (. . .)2 125 1 3088 4033 t

957: (t)2996 4436 w

958: (. . .)2 125 1 2548 3979 t

959: (t-1)2456 4328 w

960: (. . .)2 125 1 3628 3763 t

961: (t-m+1)3536 3896 w

962: (t-m+2 ?)1 314 1 3536 4004 t

963: (...)3653 4220 w

964: (t-r)4616 4034 w

965: (t-r+1 ?)1 269 1 4616 4142 t

966: (. . .)2 125 1 4708 3832 t

967: (. . .)2 125 1 4708 4264 t

968: (t-r+1)836 4081 w

969: (t-r+2 ?)1 269 1 836 4189 t

970: (. . .)2 125 1 928 3855 t

971: (. . .)2 125 1 928 4287 t

972: (t-r+2)1376 4127 w

973: (t-r+3 ?)1 269 1 1376 4235 t

974: (. . .)2 125 1 1468 3878 t

975: (. . .)2 125 1 1468 4310 t

976: 10 B f

977: (Figure 1.)1 383 1 2013 4764 t

978: 10 R f

979: (The Reliable Broadcast Protocol)3 1301 1 2446 4764 t

980: ( message acknowledges \()3 1011(1. The)1 330 2 795 4944 t

981: 10 I f

982: (s)2144 4944 w

983: 10 R f

984: (,)2191 4944 w

985: 10 I f

986: (M)2224 4944 w

987: 7 I f

988: (s)2318 4964 w

989: 10 R f

990: (\) and assigns it global sequence number)6 1592 1 2361 4944 t

991: 10 I f

992: (t)3978 4944 w

993: 10 R f

994: (.)4006 4944 w

995: ( the previous token site, receiver)5 1387( message is an acknowledgement to)5 1513(2. The)1 330 3 795 5124 t

996: 10 S f

997: (\354)4076 5087 w

998: (\356)4076 5187 w

999: 10 I f

1000: (r)4125 5134 w

1001: 10 S f

1002: (-)4188 5134 w

1003: 10 R f

1004: (1)4259 5134 w

1005: 10 S f

1006: (\374)4309 5087 w

1007: (\376)4309 5187 w

1008: 10 R f

1009: (mod)4366 5124 w

1010: 10 I f

1011: (m)4585 5124 w

1012: 10 R f

1013: (, that the)2 383 1 4657 5124 t

1014: (token was successfully transferred to)4 1474 1 970 5249 t

1015: 10 I f

1016: (r)2469 5249 w

1017: 10 R f

1018: (.)2508 5249 w

1019: ( message transfers the token to the next token site, receiver)10 2353(3. The)1 330 2 795 5429 t

1020: 10 S f

1021: (\354)3511 5392 w

1022: (\356)3511 5492 w

1023: 10 I f

1024: (r)3560 5439 w

1025: 10 S f

1026: (+)3623 5439 w

1027: 10 R f

1028: (1)3694 5439 w

1029: 10 S f

1030: (\374)3744 5392 w

1031: (\376)3744 5492 w

1032: 10 R f

1033: (mod)3801 5429 w

1034: 10 I f

1035: (m)4020 5429 w

1036: 10 R f

1037: (.)4092 5429 w

1038: (Token site)1 452 1 720 5554 t

1039: 10 I f

1040: (r)1230 5554 w

1041: 10 R f

1042: (periodically sends acknowledgement)2 1541 1 1327 5554 t

1043: 10 I f

1044: (t)2926 5554 w

1045: 10 R f

1046: ( receives acknowledgement)2 1170(until it)1 298 2 3012 5554 t

1047: 10 I f

1048: (t)4539 5554 w

1049: 10 S f

1050: (+)4591 5554 w

1051: 10 R f

1052: (1, which)1 378 1 4662 5554 t

1053: (acknowledges that receiver)2 1103 1 720 5674 t

1054: 10 S f

1055: (\354)1864 5637 w

1056: (\356)1864 5737 w

1057: 10 I f

1058: (r)1913 5684 w

1059: 10 S f

1060: (+)1976 5684 w

1061: 10 R f

1062: (1)2047 5684 w

1063: 10 S f

1064: (\374)2097 5637 w

1065: (\376)2097 5737 w

1066: 10 R f

1067: (mod)2154 5674 w

1068: 10 I f

1069: (m)2373 5674 w

1070: 10 R f

1071: ( an acknowledgement isn't received in a)6 1655( If)1 124(accepted the token.)2 783 3 2478 5674 t

1072: (speci\256ed number of attempts, receiver)4 1543 1 720 5799 t

1073: 10 I f

1074: (r)2292 5799 w

1075: 10 R f

1076: (decides that receiver)2 827 1 2360 5799 t

1077: 10 I f

1078: (r)3216 5799 w

1079: 10 S f

1080: (+)3279 5799 w

1081: 10 R f

1082: ( a reformation)2 575(1 is inoperable and initiates)4 1115 2 3350 5799 t

1083: ( order to prevent unnecessary reformations, receiver)6 2361(process. In)1 505 2 720 5919 t

1084: 10 I f

1085: (r)3658 5919 w

1086: 10 S f

1087: (+)3721 5919 w

1088: 10 R f

1089: (1 transmits a special token)4 1248 1 3792 5919 t

1090: (acknowledgement when there are no source messages to acknowledge.)8 2828 1 720 6039 t

1091: (As soon as)2 455 1 720 6279 t

1092: 10 I f

1093: (r)1211 6279 w

1094: 10 R f

1095: (sends acknowledgement)1 984 1 1286 6279 t

1096: 10 I f

1097: (t)2307 6279 w

1098: 10 R f

1099: (it gives up the right to acknowledge new source messages, even)10 2668 1 2372 6279 t

1100: (though it is not certain that)5 1080 1 720 6399 t

1101: 10 S f

1102: (\354)1834 6362 w

1103: (\356)1834 6462 w

1104: 10 I f

1105: (r)1883 6409 w

1106: 10 S f

1107: (+)1946 6409 w

1108: 10 R f

1109: (1)2017 6409 w

1110: 10 S f

1111: (\374)2067 6362 w

1112: (\376)2067 6462 w

1113: 10 R f

1114: (mod)2124 6399 w

1115: 10 I f

1116: (m)2343 6399 w

1117: 10 R f

1118: ( guarantees that at most one receiver)6 1457( This)1 228(has received the token.)3 914 3 2441 6399 t

1119: (acknowledges source messages.)2 1277 1 720 6524 t

1120: (Receiver)720 6764 w

1121: 10 S f

1122: (\354)1113 6727 w

1123: (\356)1113 6827 w

1124: 10 I f

1125: (r)1162 6774 w

1126: 10 S f

1127: (+)1225 6774 w

1128: 10 R f

1129: (1)1296 6774 w

1130: 10 S f

1131: (\374)1346 6727 w

1132: (\376)1346 6827 w

1133: 10 R f

1134: (mod)1403 6764 w

1135: 10 I f

1136: (m)1622 6764 w

1137: 10 R f

1138: ( by acknowledgement)2 890(does not accept the token transferred)5 1495 2 1725 6764 t

1139: 10 I f

1140: (t)4142 6764 w

1141: 10 R f

1142: (until it has all of the)5 838 1 4202 6764 t

1143: (acknowledgements and source messages that were acknowledged up to and including)10 3505 1 720 6889 t

1144: 10 I f

1145: (t)4259 6889 w

1146: 10 R f

1147: ( receiver)1 353( a)1 78(. When)1 322 3 4287 6889 t

1148: (accepts the token it also assumes responsibility for servicing retransmission requests for)11 3515 1 720 7009 t

1149: ( source messages that other receivers failed to receive,)8 2168(\320 acknowledged)1 726 2 720 7189 t

1150: cleartomark

1151: showpage

1152: saveobj restore

1153: end

1154: %%EndPage: 4 4

1155: %%Page: 5 5

1156: DpostDict begin

1157: /saveobj save def

1158: mark

1159: 5 pagesetup

1160: 10 R f

1161: (- 5 -)2 166 1 2797 480 t

1162: ( receivers have)2 627( for the source messages that either the source or one of the other)13 2778(\320 acknowledgements)1 915 3 720 960 t

1163: (failed to receive, and)3 836 1 870 1080 t

1164: ( for token passing messages that a previous token site failed to receive.)12 2831(\320 acknowledgements)1 915 2 720 1260 t

1165: ( receiver requests missing messages when it)6 1824( A)1 133( from other receivers are explicit.)5 1384(Retransmission requests)1 979 4 720 1500 t

1166: ( source message \()3 877(receives an acknowledgement for a)4 1638 2 720 1620 t

1167: 10 I f

1168: (s)3243 1620 w

1169: 10 R f

1170: (,)3290 1620 w

1171: 10 I f

1172: (M)3323 1620 w

1173: 7 I f

1174: (s)3417 1640 w

1175: 10 R f

1176: (\) that has not been received, an)6 1580 1 3460 1620 t

1177: (acknowledgement with a larger sequence number)5 1990 1 720 1740 t

1178: 10 I f

1179: (t)2738 1740 w

1180: 10 R f

1181: (than expected, or a message from source)6 1638 1 2794 1740 t

1182: 10 I f

1183: (s)4460 1740 w

1184: 10 R f

1185: (with a larger)2 512 1 4528 1740 t

1186: 10 I f

1187: (M)720 1860 w

1188: 7 I f

1189: (s)814 1880 w

1190: 10 R f

1191: ( a source)2 362( If)1 120( requests from sources and previous token sites are implicit.)9 2427( Retransmission)1 671(than expected.)1 581 5 879 1860 t

1192: ( that the source failed)4 871(retransmits a message that has been acknowledged, the retransmission server assumes)10 3449 2 720 1980 t

1193: ( previous token site retransmits a token passing message, the)9 2677( a)1 98( If)1 145(to receive the acknowledgement.)3 1400 4 720 2100 t

1194: ( Receiver)1 408( assumes that it failed to receive the token passing acknowledgement.)10 2816(retransmit server)1 676 3 720 2220 t

1195: 10 I f

1196: (r)4649 2220 w

1197: 10 R f

1198: (\(the last)1 323 1 4717 2220 t

1199: ( requests until it receives the acknowledgement for)7 2137(token holder\) does not stop servicing retransmission)6 2183 2 720 2340 t

1200: ( is at least one site that is responding to retransmission)10 2397( guarantees that there)3 913( This)1 249(passing the token.)2 761 4 720 2460 t

1201: ( particular, if receiver)3 890(requests. In)1 494 2 720 2580 t

1202: 10 I f

1203: (r)2138 2580 w

1204: 10 S f

1205: (+)2201 2580 w

1206: 10 R f

1207: ( messages to accept the token, it)6 1332(1 does not have all of the requisite)7 1436 2 2272 2580 t

1208: (can recover them from)3 905 1 720 2700 t

1209: 10 I f

1210: (r)1650 2700 w

1211: 10 R f

1212: (before accepting the token.)3 1080 1 1714 2700 t

1213: ( acknowledgements and place the messages in the sequence)8 2591(Receivers process arriving messages and)4 1729 2 720 2940 t

1214: ( receiver,)1 370( Each)1 249(indicated by the sequence number of the acknowledgements.)7 2435 3 720 3060 t

1215: 10 I f

1216: (r)3799 3060 w

1217: 10 R f

1218: (, tracks)1 288 1 3838 3060 t

1219: 10 I f

1220: (t)4151 3060 w

1221: 7 I f

1222: (r)4190 3080 w

1223: 10 R f

1224: (and)4250 3060 w

1225: 10 I f

1226: (M)4419 3060 w

1227: 7 I f

1228: (s)4513 3080 w

1229: 7 R f

1230: (,)4545 3080 w

1231: 7 I f

1232: (r)4568 3080 w

1233: 10 R f

1234: (for each)1 323 1 4628 3060 t

1235: 10 I f

1236: (s)4976 3060 w

1237: 10 R f

1238: (,)5015 3060 w

1239: (where)720 3180 w

1240: 10 I f

1241: (t)989 3180 w

1242: 7 I f

1243: (r)1028 3200 w

1244: 10 R f

1245: (is the next acknowledgement number that)5 1672 1 1089 3180 t

1246: 10 I f

1247: (r)2787 3180 w

1248: 10 R f

1249: (expects, and)1 495 1 2853 3180 t

1250: 10 I f

1251: (M)3375 3180 w

1252: 7 I f

1253: (s)3469 3200 w

1254: 7 R f

1255: (,)3501 3200 w

1256: 7 I f

1257: (r)3524 3200 w

1258: 10 R f

1259: (is the next message that)4 957 1 3586 3180 t

1260: 10 I f

1261: (r)4570 3180 w

1262: 10 R f

1263: (expects to)1 404 1 4636 3180 t

1264: (process from source)2 835 1 720 3300 t

1265: 10 I f

1266: (s)1596 3300 w

1267: 10 R f

1268: (. Receiver)1 445 1 1635 3300 t

1269: 10 I f

1270: (r)2121 3300 w

1271: 10 R f

1272: (has all of the acknowledgements below)5 1652 1 2201 3300 t

1273: 10 I f

1274: (t)3893 3300 w

1275: 7 I f

1276: (r)3932 3320 w

1277: 10 R f

1278: (. Receiver)1 444 1 3967 3300 t

1279: 10 I f

1280: (r)4451 3300 w

1281: 10 R f

1282: (has received)1 510 1 4530 3300 t

1283: (acknowledgements for all)2 1031 1 720 3420 t

1284: 10 I f

1285: (M)1776 3420 w

1286: 7 I f

1287: (s)1870 3440 w

1288: 10 S f

1289: (<)1921 3420 w

1290: 10 I f

1291: (M)1992 3420 w

1292: 7 I f

1293: (s)2086 3440 w

1294: 7 R f

1295: (,)2118 3440 w

1296: 7 I f

1297: (r)2141 3440 w

1298: 10 R f

1299: (.)2176 3420 w

1300: ( are sent unless a missing)5 1088(The receivers use a negative acknowledgement strategy: No control messages)9 3232 2 720 3660 t

1301: ( a receiver detects a missing message, it)7 1850( When)1 325( detected.)1 419(acknowledgement or source message is)4 1726 4 720 3780 t

1302: ( is)1 112(periodically requests the message until it receives the message or decides that the retransmit server)14 4208 2 720 3900 t

1303: (inoperable and initiates a reformation process.)5 1846 1 720 4020 t

1304: (When)900 4320 w

1305: 10 I f

1306: (r)1163 4320 w

1307: 10 R f

1308: (receives source message \()3 1032 1 1227 4320 t

1309: 10 I f

1310: (s)2267 4320 w

1311: 10 R f

1312: (,)2314 4320 w

1313: 10 I f

1314: (M)2347 4320 w

1315: 7 I f

1316: (s)2441 4340 w

1317: 10 R f

1318: (\):)2484 4320 w

1319: (if:)1050 4500 w

1320: 10 I f

1321: (M)1200 4500 w

1322: 7 I f

1323: (s)1294 4520 w

1324: 10 S f

1325: (<)1345 4500 w

1326: 10 I f

1327: (M)1416 4500 w

1328: 7 I f

1329: (s)1510 4520 w

1330: 7 R f

1331: (,)1542 4520 w

1332: 7 I f

1333: (r)1565 4520 w

1334: 10 R f

1335: (, \()1 83 1 1600 4500 t

1336: 10 I f

1337: (s)1691 4500 w

1338: 10 R f

1339: (,)1738 4500 w

1340: 10 I f

1341: (M)1771 4500 w

1342: 7 I f

1343: (s)1865 4520 w

1344: 10 R f

1345: (\) is a duplicate.)3 610 1 1908 4500 t

1346: (if:)1050 4680 w

1347: 10 I f

1348: (M)1200 4680 w

1349: 7 I f

1350: (s)1294 4700 w

1351: 10 S f

1352: (=)1345 4680 w

1353: 10 I f

1354: (M)1416 4680 w

1355: 7 I f

1356: (s)1510 4700 w

1357: 7 R f

1358: (,)1542 4700 w

1359: 7 I f

1360: (r)1565 4700 w

1361: 10 R f

1362: (,)1600 4680 w

1363: (if: \()1 483 1 1200 4860 t

1364: 10 I f

1365: (s)1691 4860 w

1366: 10 R f

1367: (,)1738 4860 w

1368: 10 I f

1369: (M)1771 4860 w

1370: 7 I f

1371: (s)1865 4880 w

1372: 10 R f

1373: ( the store waiting for)4 868(\) is not in the store of waiting messages, it is placed in)12 2264 2 1908 4860 t

1374: (acknowledgement.)1650 4980 w

1375: (otherwise: \()1 474 1 1200 5160 t

1376: 10 I f

1377: (s)1682 5160 w

1378: 10 R f

1379: (,)1729 5160 w

1380: 10 I f

1381: (M)1762 5160 w

1382: 7 I f

1383: (s)1856 5180 w

1384: 10 R f

1385: (\) is a duplicate.)3 610 1 1899 5160 t

1386: (if:)1050 5340 w

1387: 10 I f

1388: (M)1200 5340 w

1389: 7 I f

1390: (s)1294 5360 w

1391: 10 S f

1392: (>)1345 5340 w

1393: 10 I f

1394: (M)1416 5340 w

1395: 7 I f

1396: (s)1510 5360 w

1397: 7 R f

1398: (,)1542 5360 w

1399: 7 I f

1400: (r)1565 5360 w

1401: 10 R f

1402: (, The acknowledgement for \()4 1155 1 1600 5340 t

1403: 10 I f

1404: (s)2763 5340 w

1405: 10 R f

1406: (,)2810 5340 w

1407: 10 I f

1408: (M)2843 5340 w

1409: 7 I f

1410: (s)2937 5360 w

1411: 10 S f

1412: (-)2988 5340 w

1413: 10 R f

1414: ( is missing, and is requested.)5 1147(1 \))1 91 2 3059 5340 t

1415: (When)900 5700 w

1416: 10 I f

1417: (r)1163 5700 w

1418: 10 R f

1419: (receives acknowledgement)1 1077 1 1227 5700 t

1420: 10 I f

1421: (t)2329 5700 w

1422: 10 R f

1423: (for \()1 174 1 2382 5700 t

1424: 10 I f

1425: (s)2564 5700 w

1426: 10 R f

1427: (,)2611 5700 w

1428: 10 I f

1429: (M)2644 5700 w

1430: 7 I f

1431: (s)2738 5720 w

1432: 10 R f

1433: (\),)2781 5700 w

1434: (if:)1050 5880 w

1435: 10 I f

1436: (t)1200 5880 w

1437: 10 S f

1438: (<)1252 5880 w

1439: 10 I f

1440: (t)1323 5880 w

1441: 7 I f

1442: (r)1362 5900 w

1443: 10 R f

1444: (, acknowledgement)1 776 1 1397 5880 t

1445: 10 I f

1446: (t)2198 5880 w

1447: 10 R f

1448: (is a duplicate.)2 552 1 2251 5880 t

1449: (if:)1050 6060 w

1450: 10 I f

1451: (t)1200 6060 w

1452: 10 S f

1453: (=)1252 6060 w

1454: 10 I f

1455: (t)1323 6060 w

1456: 7 I f

1457: (r)1362 6080 w

1458: 10 R f

1459: (,)1397 6060 w

1460: (if: \()1 483 1 1200 6240 t

1461: 10 I f

1462: (s)1691 6240 w

1463: 10 R f

1464: (,)1738 6240 w

1465: 10 I f

1466: (M)1771 6240 w

1467: 7 I f

1468: (s)1865 6260 w

1469: 10 R f

1470: ( message is placed in position)5 1216(\) has been received, the)4 954 2 1908 6240 t

1471: 10 I f

1472: (t)4108 6240 w

1473: 10 R f

1474: (in the receive list and)4 874 1 4166 6240 t

1475: 10 I f

1476: (t)1650 6360 w

1477: 7 I f

1478: (r)1689 6380 w

1479: 10 R f

1480: (and)1749 6360 w

1481: 10 I f

1482: (M)1918 6360 w

1483: 7 I f

1484: (s)2012 6380 w

1485: 7 R f

1486: (,)2044 6380 w

1487: 7 I f

1488: (r)2067 6380 w

1489: 10 R f

1490: (are incremented.)1 664 1 2127 6360 t

1491: (otherwise: \()1 483 1 1200 6540 t

1492: 10 I f

1493: (s)1691 6540 w

1494: 10 R f

1495: (,)1738 6540 w

1496: 10 I f

1497: (M)1771 6540 w

1498: 7 I f

1499: (s)1865 6560 w

1500: 10 R f

1501: (\) is missing and is requested before processing acknowledgement)8 2612 1 1908 6540 t

1502: 10 I f

1503: (t)4545 6540 w

1504: 10 R f

1505: (.)4573 6540 w

1506: (if:)1050 6720 w

1507: 10 I f

1508: (t)1200 6720 w

1509: 10 S f

1510: (>)1252 6720 w

1511: 10 I f

1512: (t)1323 6720 w

1513: 7 I f

1514: (r)1362 6740 w

1515: 10 R f

1516: (, acknowledgement)1 776 1 1397 6720 t

1517: 10 I f

1518: (t)2198 6720 w

1519: 10 S f

1520: (-)2250 6720 w

1521: 10 R f

1522: (1 is missing and is requested before processing acknowledgement)8 2629 1 2321 6720 t

1523: 10 I f

1524: (t)4975 6720 w

1525: 10 R f

1526: (.)5003 6720 w

1527: ( passed, RMP guarantees that every receiver eventually receives the acknowledged messages)11 3723(As the token is)3 597 2 720 7020 t

1528: ( a)1 79( When)1 298( eventually knows that every other receiver has received these messages.)10 3000(and that every receiver)3 943 4 720 7140 t

1529: ( all)1 127(new acknowledgement is transmitted, the receiver that acknowledged that message has that message and)13 4193 2 720 7260 t

1530: ( also infer that the previous token sites had)8 1741( can)1 168( We)1 193(of the acknowledged source messages that preceded it.)7 2218 4 720 7380 t

1531: cleartomark

1532: showpage

1533: saveobj restore

1534: end

1535: %%EndPage: 5 5

1536: %%Page: 6 6

1537: DpostDict begin

1538: /saveobj save def

1539: mark

1540: 6 pagesetup

1541: 10 R f

1542: (- 6 -)2 166 1 2797 480 t

1543: ( instance, when)2 726( For)1 243( acknowledgements.)1 869(all of the messages that they required to send their)9 2482 4 720 960 t

1544: (acknowledgement)720 1080 w

1545: 10 I f

1546: (t)1471 1080 w

1547: 10 R f

1548: (is transmitted from receiver)3 1106 1 1524 1080 t

1549: 10 I f

1550: (r)2655 1080 w

1551: 10 R f

1552: (:)2694 1080 w

1553: (\320 receiver)1 470 1 720 1260 t

1554: 10 I f

1555: (r)1215 1260 w

1556: 10 R f

1557: (has all of the acknowledged messages up to and including the)10 2463 1 1279 1260 t

1558: 10 I f

1559: (t)3767 1260 w

1560: 7 I f

1561: (th)3806 1220 w

1562: 10 R f

1563: (message,)3894 1260 w

1564: (\320 receiver)1 470 1 720 1440 t

1565: 10 S f

1566: (\354)1223 1403 w

1567: (\356)1223 1503 w

1568: 10 I f

1569: (r)1272 1450 w

1570: 10 S f

1571: (-)1335 1450 w

1572: 10 R f

1573: (1)1406 1450 w

1574: 10 S f

1575: (\374)1456 1403 w

1576: (\376)1456 1503 w

1577: 10 R f

1578: (mod)1513 1440 w

1579: 10 I f

1580: (m)1732 1440 w

1581: 10 R f

1582: (has all of the acknowledged messages up to and including the \()11 2521 1 1829 1440 t

1583: 10 I f

1584: (t)4358 1440 w

1585: 10 S f

1586: (-)4410 1440 w

1587: 10 R f

1588: (1 \))1 91 1 4481 1440 t

1589: 7 I f

1590: (th)4583 1400 w

1591: 10 R f

1592: (message,)4671 1440 w

1593: (\320)720 1625 w

1594: (. . .)2 125 1 895 1600 t

1595: (, and that)2 369 1 1045 1625 t

1596: (\320 receiver)1 470 1 720 1805 t

1597: 10 S f

1598: (\354)1239 1768 w

1599: (\356)1239 1868 w

1600: 10 I f

1601: (r)1288 1815 w

1602: 10 S f

1603: (-)1351 1815 w

1604: 10 I f

1605: (m)1422 1815 w

1606: 10 S f

1607: (+)1518 1815 w

1608: 10 R f

1609: (1)1589 1815 w

1610: 10 S f

1611: (\374)1639 1768 w

1612: (\376)1639 1868 w

1613: 10 R f

1614: (mod)1696 1805 w

1615: 10 I f

1616: (m)1915 1805 w

1617: 10 R f

1618: ( of the acknowledged messages up to and including the message)10 2738(has all)1 274 2 2028 1805 t

1619: (acknowledged by)1 701 1 870 1930 t

1620: 10 I f

1621: (t)1596 1930 w

1622: 10 S f

1623: (-)1648 1930 w

1624: 10 I f

1625: (m)1719 1930 w

1626: 10 S f

1627: (+)1815 1930 w

1628: 10 R f

1629: (1.)1886 1930 w

1630: (Since)720 2050 w

1631: 10 S f

1632: (\354)980 2013 w

1633: (\356)980 2113 w

1634: 10 I f

1635: (r)1029 2060 w

1636: 10 S f

1637: (-)1092 2060 w

1638: 10 I f

1639: (m)1163 2060 w

1640: 10 S f

1641: (\374)1235 2013 w

1642: (\376)1235 2113 w

1643: 10 R f

1644: (mod)1292 2050 w

1645: 10 I f

1646: (m)1511 2050 w

1647: 10 S f

1648: (=)1632 2050 w

1649: 10 I f

1650: (r)1736 2050 w

1651: 10 R f

1652: (, when the)2 423 1 1775 2050 t

1653: 10 I f

1654: (t)2228 2050 w

1655: 7 I f

1656: (th)2267 2010 w

1657: 10 R f

1658: (acknowledgement is transmitted all of the other receivers have all)9 2679 1 2361 2050 t

1659: (of the source messages up to and including the message acknowledged by)11 2953 1 720 2175 t

1660: 10 I f

1661: (t)3698 2175 w

1662: 10 S f

1663: (-)3750 2175 w

1664: 10 I f

1665: (m)3821 2175 w

1666: 10 S f

1667: (+)3917 2175 w

1668: 10 R f

1669: (1.)3988 2175 w

1670: ( other receivers receive the)4 1133(Even if none of the)4 821 2 720 2415 t

1671: 10 I f

1672: (t)2714 2415 w

1673: 7 I f

1674: (th)2753 2375 w

1675: 10 R f

1676: (acknowledgement, when the)2 1169 1 2856 2415 t

1677: 10 I f

1678: (t)4065 2415 w

1679: 7 I f

1680: (th)4104 2375 w

1681: 10 R f

1682: (acknowledgement is)1 833 1 4207 2415 t

1683: (transmitted receiver)1 821 1 720 2535 t

1684: 10 I f

1685: (r)1592 2535 w

1686: 10 R f

1687: ( including)1 428(knows that all of the receivers have all or the messages up to and)13 2930 2 1682 2535 t

1688: (\()720 2655 w

1689: 10 I f

1690: (t)761 2655 w

1691: 10 S f

1692: (-)813 2655 w

1693: 10 I f

1694: (m)884 2655 w

1695: 10 S f

1696: (+)980 2655 w

1697: 10 R f

1698: (1 \))1 91 1 1051 2655 t

1699: 7 I f

1700: (th)1153 2615 w

1701: 10 R f

1702: ( addition,)1 378(message. In)1 496 2 1241 2655 t

1703: (\320 receiver)1 470 1 720 2835 t

1704: 10 S f

1705: (\354)1244 2798 w

1706: (\356)1244 2898 w

1707: 10 I f

1708: (r)1293 2845 w

1709: 10 S f

1710: (-)1356 2845 w

1711: 10 R f

1712: (1)1427 2845 w

1713: 10 S f

1714: (\374)1477 2798 w

1715: (\376)1477 2898 w

1716: 10 R f

1717: (mod)1534 2835 w

1718: 10 I f

1719: (m)1753 2835 w

1720: 10 R f

1721: ( all of the messages up to and including the)9 1927(knows that all receivers have)4 1242 2 1871 2835 t

1722: (\()870 2960 w

1723: 10 I f

1724: (t)911 2960 w

1725: 10 S f

1726: (-)963 2960 w

1727: 10 I f

1728: (m)1034 2960 w

1729: 10 R f

1730: (\))1114 2960 w

1731: 7 I f

1732: (th)1158 2920 w

1733: 10 R f

1734: (message,)1246 2960 w

1735: (\320 receiver)1 470 1 720 3140 t

1736: 10 S f

1737: (\354)1244 3103 w

1738: (\356)1244 3203 w

1739: 10 I f

1740: (r)1293 3150 w

1741: 10 S f

1742: (-)1356 3150 w

1743: 10 R f

1744: (2)1427 3150 w

1745: 10 S f

1746: (\374)1477 3103 w

1747: (\376)1477 3203 w

1748: 10 R f

1749: (mod)1534 3140 w

1750: 10 I f

1751: (m)1753 3140 w

1752: 10 R f

1753: ( all of the messages up to and including the)9 1927(knows that all receivers have)4 1242 2 1871 3140 t

1754: (\()870 3265 w

1755: 10 I f

1756: (t)911 3265 w

1757: 10 S f

1758: (-)963 3265 w

1759: 10 I f

1760: (m)1034 3265 w

1761: 10 S f

1762: (-)1130 3265 w

1763: 10 R f

1764: (1 \))1 91 1 1201 3265 t

1765: 7 I f

1766: (th)1303 3225 w

1767: 10 R f

1768: (message,)1391 3265 w

1769: (\320)720 3445 w

1770: (. . .)2 125 1 895 3420 t

1771: (, and that,)2 394 1 1045 3445 t

1772: (\320 receiver)1 470 1 720 3625 t

1773: 10 S f

1774: (\354)1236 3588 w

1775: (\356)1236 3688 w

1776: 10 I f

1777: (r)1285 3635 w

1778: 10 S f

1779: (-)1348 3635 w

1780: 10 I f

1781: (m)1419 3635 w

1782: 10 S f

1783: (+)1515 3635 w

1784: 10 R f

1785: (1)1586 3635 w

1786: 10 S f

1787: (\374)1636 3588 w

1788: (\376)1636 3688 w

1789: 10 R f

1790: ( the)1 161(, and therefore, all of the receivers know that all of the receivers have all of)15 3194 2 1685 3625 t

1791: (messages up to and including the \()6 1382 1 870 3750 t

1792: 10 I f

1793: (t)2260 3750 w

1794: 10 S f

1795: (-)2312 3750 w

1796: 10 I f

1797: (m)2383 3750 w

1798: 10 S f

1799: (+)2479 3750 w

1800: 10 R f

1801: (2 \))1 91 1 2550 3750 t

1802: 7 I f

1803: (th)2652 3710 w

1804: 10 R f

1805: (message.)2740 3750 w

1806: ( a negative acknowledgement strategy, receivers)5 1943(When there are no new source messages to acknowledge in)9 2377 2 720 3990 t

1807: ( can provide)2 537( We)1 210( or acknowledgements do not detect their loss.)7 2007(that missed the last source messages)5 1566 4 720 4110 t

1808: ( periodically passing the token when there are no new source)10 2613(reception guarantees in bounded time by)5 1707 2 720 4230 t

1809: (messages to acknowledge.)2 1056 1 720 4350 t

1810: %INFO[SECTION: LEVEL = 1, NUMBER = 3.  , HEADING = Requirements of the Application]

1811: 9 B f

1812: ( of the Application)3 714(3. Requirements)1 654 2 720 4590 t

1813: 10 R f

1814: ( different from those of a replicated database on a local)10 2249(The requirements of a global stock market are very)8 2071 2 720 4770 t

1815: ( the original RMP)3 741( of the issues that are caused by these differences are addressed by)12 2743( Some)1 286(area network.)1 550 4 720 4890 t

1816: ( will state)2 395( We)1 191( RMP protocol and architecture.)4 1296( other issues require modi\256cations of the)6 1638(protocol. However,)1 800 5 720 5010 t

1817: (the differences, then describe the modi\256cations that are needed to address them.)11 3190 1 720 5130 t

1818: (In the stock market applications:)4 1304 1 720 5370 t

1819: ( is)1 118( This)1 254( and leave the applications frequently.)5 1649( are a large number of receivers that join)8 1817(1. There)1 407 5 795 5550 t

1820: ( of stock)2 378(particularly true in the \256rst application, where we distribute a uni\256ed ticker to millions)13 3692 2 970 5670 t

1821: (traders.)970 5790 w

1822: ( must pass the token millions of times before the guarantees)10 2432( network with millions of receivers)5 1416(\320 A)1 222 3 970 5970 t

1823: (that are available with RMP are realized.)6 1632 1 1120 6090 t

1824: ( its time)2 391( receivers enter or join the group frequently, the protocol will spend most of)13 3463(\320 If)1 216 3 970 6270 t

1825: (reorganizing the receiver list, rather than ordering messages.)7 2413 1 1120 6390 t

1826: ( messages will be lost by some receivers and have to be recovered.)12 2663(\320 Most)1 356 2 970 6570 t

1827: ( and receivers in the stock market cannot be trusted to the extent that they are trusted in a)18 3590( sources)1 325(2. The)1 330 3 795 6750 t

1828: (distributed database.)1 821 1 970 6870 t

1829: ( is unreasonable to expect individuals who are competing in a stock market to cooperate to)15 3859(\320 It)1 211 2 970 7050 t

1830: (recover missed messages and or to provide fair access to one another.)11 2776 1 1120 7170 t

1831: cleartomark

1832: showpage

1833: saveobj restore

1834: end

1835: %%EndPage: 6 6

1836: %%Page: 7 7

1837: DpostDict begin

1838: /saveobj save def

1839: mark

1840: 7 pagesetup

1841: 10 R f

1842: (- 7 -)2 166 1 2797 480 t

1843: ( new trading price)3 792( A)1 145( of the stock market applications data quickly becomes obsolete.)9 2781( many)1 269(3. In)1 258 5 795 960 t

1844: (replaces the price from a few seconds earlier.)7 1804 1 970 1080 t

1845: ( number of messages in a uni\256ed stock ticker is much greater than in a local, replicated database.)17 3867(4. The)1 330 2 795 1260 t

1846: ( than the average)3 696( may be periods when the average arrival rate of messages will be greater)13 2992(\320 There)1 382 3 970 1440 t

1847: ( queue of messages waiting to be)6 1410( these periods the)3 744( During)1 349(time that it takes to pass a token.)7 1417 4 1120 1560 t

1848: ( persists, the backlog of unacknowledged)5 1812( the high arrival rate)4 937( If)1 148(acknowledged increases.)1 1023 4 1120 1680 t

1849: (messages increases and may result in unacceptable delays.)7 2333 1 1120 1800 t

1850: ( composite ticker may exceed the amount of data that can pass through)12 2876( amount of data in the)5 889(\320 The)1 305 3 970 1980 t

1851: (the receivers in the repair group.)5 1296 1 1120 2100 t

1852: ( to some of the end)5 788( amount of data will frequently exceed the bit rate that can be transmitted)13 2977(\320 The)1 305 3 970 2280 t

1853: ( system should not be constrained by the least capable receiver.)10 2531(users. The)1 435 2 1120 2400 t

1854: ( the same)2 401( data should be delivered to all of the recipients simultaneously so that they all have)15 3514(5. The)1 330 3 795 2580 t

1855: (opportunity to act on the information.)5 1505 1 970 2700 t

1856: ( lives in the)3 500( trader that)2 454( A)1 133( delivery time should not depend on the location of the receiver.)11 2678(\320 The)1 305 5 970 2880 t

1857: ( the ticker at the same time as a trader in a different part)13 2230(same city as a trading \257oor should receive)7 1690 2 1120 3000 t

1858: ( delay alone may exceed 100)5 1345(of the world - even though the difference in propagation)9 2575 2 1120 3120 t

1859: (milliseconds.)1120 3240 w

1860: ( of the probability of message loss between different)8 2216( delivery time should be independent)5 1549(\320 The)1 305 3 970 3420 t

1861: (locations and the time that it takes to recover the missing messages.)11 2703 1 1120 3540 t

1862: ( hold)1 208( should)1 296( This)1 232( source should have an equal opportunity to have its data received promptly.)12 3096(6. Every)1 413 5 795 3720 t

1863: ( near the receiver, and have few message losses and others are far and)13 2849(even though some sources are)4 1221 2 970 3840 t

1864: (must retransmit several times.)3 1199 1 970 3960 t

1865: ( among a)2 408( achieves transmitter fairness by rotating the site that acknowledges messages)10 3300(\320 RMP)1 362 3 970 4140 t

1866: ( portal for the)3 615( effect, the entry)3 725( In)1 157(group of receivers that are distributed around the world.)8 2423 4 1120 4260 t

1867: ( have the best access)4 897(sequence of acknowledged messages moves so that the transmitters that)9 3023 2 1120 4380 t

1868: (changes.)1120 4500 w

1869: ( concerns must be addressed, including:)5 1592(7. Security)1 508 2 795 4680 t

1870: ( transmission access to authorized sources,)5 1708(\320 constraining)1 644 2 970 4860 t

1871: ( early reception of the data stream,)6 1382(\320 preventing)1 577 2 970 5040 t

1872: ( reception to authorized receivers,)4 1354(\320 limiting)1 468 2 970 5220 t

1873: ( spoo\256ng or adding to the repaired sequence, and)8 1960(\320 preventing)1 577 2 970 5400 t

1874: ( denial of service attacks.)4 1011(\320 preventing)1 577 2 970 5580 t

1875: ( system must quickly detect and adjust to the failure of any components.)12 2889(8. The)1 330 2 795 5760 t

1876: ( detected within the time it)5 1084( token passing mechanism guarantees that repair group failures are)9 2681(\320 The)1 305 3 970 5940 t

1877: ( in the original protocol the cycle time)7 1536( However,)1 442(takes the token to cycle around the repair group.)8 1942 3 1120 6060 t

1878: (is dependent on the number of receivers and the average arrival rate of messages.)13 3240 1 1120 6180 t

1879: ( messages that are lost by the receivers on a multicast network on the Internet are correlated.)16 3688(9. The)1 330 2 795 6360 t

1880: ( at a)2 194( a message is lost or corrupted)6 1287( When)1 301( multicast network is physically a tree network.)7 1983(\320 The)1 305 5 970 6540 t

1881: (node of the tree, all of the receivers that are fed from that node lose the same message.)17 3449 1 1120 6660 t

1882: ( many receivers lose the same message there may be a NACK implosion)12 2900(\320 When)1 388 2 970 6840 t

1883: 7 R f

1884: (6 , 7 , 8 , 9)6 224 1 4263 6800 t

1885: 10 R f

1886: (.)4495 6840 w

1887: cleartomark

1888: showpage

1889: saveobj restore

1890: end

1891: %%EndPage: 7 7

1892: %%Page: 8 8

1893: DpostDict begin

1894: /saveobj save def

1895: mark

1896: 8 pagesetup

1897: 10 R f

1898: (- 8 -)2 166 1 2797 480 t

1899: %INFO[SECTION: LEVEL = 1, NUMBER = 4.  , HEADING = Architecture]

1900: 9 B f

1901: (4. Architecture)1 604 1 720 960 t

1902: 10 R f

1903: ( The)1 210( and trust issues in the stock market application lead to a change in the basic architecture.)16 3643(The scaling)1 467 3 720 1140 t

1904: ( quantity of data)3 658( The)1 207( the inner layer is constrained to trusted components.)8 2127(architecture is multi-layered, and)3 1328 4 720 1260 t

1905: (transmitted in this application results in a replication of parts of the architecture.)12 3204 1 720 1380 t

1906: ( The)1 221(All three of the stock market applications use the multicast architecture that is shown in \256gure 2.)16 4099 2 720 1620 t

1907: ( The)1 215( core of the architecture on a global multicast tree.)9 2096(reliable multicast protocol, RMP, operates in the)6 2009 3 720 1740 t

1908: ( the large number of sources or receivers in an application onto a more)13 3234(layered architecture maps)2 1086 2 720 1860 t

1909: ( secondary sources are aggregated)4 1365( Speci\256cally)1 523( that operate in the core of the protocol.)8 1585(manageable numbers)1 847 4 720 1980 t

1910: ( as depicted in \256gure 2.)5 972(at primary sources, and primary and secondary receivers distribute data customers)10 3348 2 720 2100 t

1911: ( with less than a few hundred receivers and less than a few thousand sources, even though)16 3621(RMP can operate)2 699 2 720 2220 t

1912: ( scaling issues associated)3 1043( The)1 217( applications may have millions of sources and receivers.)8 2378(the stock market)2 682 4 720 2340 t

1913: (most reliable multicast protocols are avoided by the architecture, rather than being resolved by the protocol.)15 4306 1 720 2460 t

1914: 2520 3540 720 360 De

1915: (Global Multicast Tree)2 882 1 3265 3560 t

1916: 900 3090 180 180 De

1917: 10 I f

1918: (S)934 3110 w

1919: 7 I f

1920: (P)995 3130 w

1921: 10 R f

1922: 1078 3110 1152 3110 Dl

1923: 1078 3111 1143 3144 Dl

1924: 2792 3518 1077 3110 Dl

1925: 2792 3519 2718 3519 Dl

1926: 2791 3518 2726 3485 Dl

1927: 1440 3090 180 180 De

1928: 10 I f

1929: (S)1474 3110 w

1930: 7 I f

1931: (P)1535 3130 w

1932: 10 R f

1933: 1615 3118 1689 3123 Dl

1934: 1616 3119 1678 3158 Dl

1935: 2794 3511 1615 3118 Dl

1936: 2794 3511 2720 3506 Dl

1937: 2793 3510 2731 3471 Dl

1938: 1980 3090 180 180 De

1939: 10 I f

1940: (S)2014 3110 w

1941: 7 I f

1942: (P)2075 3130 w

1943: 10 R f

1944: 2148 3133 2220 3152 Dl

1945: 2149 3134 2203 3184 Dl

1946: 2800 3495 2148 3133 Dl

1947: 2801 3496 2729 3477 Dl

1948: 2800 3495 2746 3445 Dl

1949: 2520 3090 180 180 De

1950: 10 I f

1951: (S)2554 3110 w

1952: 7 I f

1953: (P)2615 3130 w

1954: 10 R f

1955: 2656 3167 2708 3219 Dl

1956: 2656 3167 2677 3238 Dl

1957: 2833 3462 2656 3167 Dl

1958: 2833 3462 2781 3410 Dl

1959: 2833 3462 2812 3391 Dl

1960: 3060 3090 180 180 De

1961: 10 I f

1962: (S)3094 3110 w

1963: 7 I f

1964: (P)3155 3130 w

1965: 10 R f

1966: 3103 3167 3082 3238 Dl

1967: 3103 3167 3051 3219 Dl

1968: 2926 3462 3103 3167 Dl

1969: 2926 3462 2947 3391 Dl

1970: 2926 3462 2978 3410 Dl

1971: 3600 3090 180 180 De

1972: 10 I f

1973: (S)3634 3110 w

1974: 7 I f

1975: (P)3695 3130 w

1976: 10 R f

1977: 3610 3134 3556 3184 Dl

1978: 3611 3133 3539 3152 Dl

1979: 2959 3495 3611 3133 Dl

1980: 2959 3495 3013 3445 Dl

1981: 2958 3496 3030 3477 Dl

1982: 4140 3090 180 180 De

1983: 10 I f

1984: (S)4174 3110 w

1985: 7 I f

1986: (P)4235 3130 w

1987: 10 R f

1988: 4143 3119 4081 3158 Dl

1989: 4144 3118 4070 3123 Dl

1990: 2965 3511 4144 3118 Dl

1991: 2966 3510 3028 3471 Dl

1992: 2965 3511 3039 3506 Dl

1993: 4680 3090 180 180 De

1994: 10 I f

1995: (S)4714 3110 w

1996: 7 I f

1997: (P)4775 3130 w

1998: 10 R f

1999: 4681 3111 4616 3144 Dl

2000: 4682 3110 4608 3110 Dl

2001: 2967 3518 4682 3110 Dl

2002: 2968 3518 3033 3485 Dl

2003: 2968 3519 3042 3519 Dl

2004: (Primary Sources)1 663 1 4795 3260 t

2005: 2115 2730 180 180 De

2006: 10 I f

2007: (S)2152 2750 w

2008: 7 I f

2009: (S)2213 2770 w

2010: 10 R f

2011: 2272 2790 2337 2824 Dl

2012: 2273 2789 2314 2850 Dl

2013: 2542 3029 2272 2789 Dl

2014: 2541 3029 2476 2995 Dl

2015: 2541 3030 2500 2969 Dl

2016: 2384 2730 180 180 De

2017: 10 I f

2018: (S)2423 2750 w

2019: 7 I f

2020: (S)2484 2770 w

2021: 10 R f

2022: 2506 2814 2548 2875 Dl

2023: 2506 2814 2514 2887 Dl

2024: 2578 3005 2506 2814 Dl

2025: 2578 3005 2536 2944 Dl

2026: 2577 3005 2569 2932 Dl

2027: 2655 2730 180 180 De

2028: 10 I f

2029: (S)2692 2750 w

2030: 7 I f

2031: (S)2753 2770 w

2032: 10 R f

2033: 2713 2814 2705 2887 Dl

2034: 2713 2814 2671 2875 Dl

2035: 2641 3005 2713 2814 Dl

2036: 2642 3005 2650 2932 Dl

2037: 2641 3005 2683 2944 Dl

2038: 2924 2730 180 180 De

2039: 10 I f

2040: (S)2963 2750 w

2041: 7 I f

2042: (S)3024 2770 w

2043: 10 R f

2044: 2946 2789 2905 2850 Dl

2045: 2947 2790 2882 2824 Dl

2046: 2677 3029 2947 2789 Dl

2047: 2678 3030 2719 2969 Dl

2048: 2678 3029 2743 2995 Dl

2049: (Secondary Sources)1 762 1 3129 2750 t

2050: 1710 3404 180 180 De

2051: 10 I f

2052: (X)1739 3424 w

2053: 7 I f

2054: (R)1811 3444 w

2055: 10 R f

2056: 1710 3675 180 180 De

2057: 10 I f

2058: (X)1739 3695 w

2059: 7 I f

2060: (R)1811 3715 w

2061: 10 R f

2062: (Reformation Servers)1 829 1 881 3560 t

2063: 1440 4080 180 180 De

2064: 10 I f

2065: (R)1469 4100 w

2066: 7 I f

2067: (P)1541 4120 w

2068: 10 R f

2069: 1614 4045 1674 4002 Dl

2070: 1613 4046 1686 4036 Dl

2071: 2795 3573 1613 4046 Dl

2072: 2796 3574 2736 3617 Dl

2073: 2796 3573 2723 3583 Dl

2074: 1656 4080 1620 4080 Dl

2075: 1736 4080 1700 4080 Dl

2076: 1818 4080 1782 4080 Dl

2077: 1898 4080 1862 4080 Dl

2078: 1980 4080 1944 4080 Dl

2079: 1980 4080 1908 4098 Dl

2080: 1980 4080 1908 4062 Dl

2081: 1980 4080 180 180 De

2082: 10 I f

2083: (R)2009 4100 w

2084: 7 I f

2085: (P)2081 4120 w

2086: 10 R f

2087: 2145 4028 2194 3974 Dl

2088: 2145 4030 2214 4005 Dl

2089: 2804 3591 2144 4030 Dl

2090: 2804 3591 2755 3645 Dl

2091: 2804 3589 2735 3614 Dl

2092: 2196 4080 2160 4080 Dl

2093: 2276 4080 2240 4080 Dl

2094: 2358 4080 2322 4080 Dl

2095: 2438 4080 2402 4080 Dl

2096: 2520 4080 2484 4080 Dl

2097: 2520 4080 2448 4098 Dl

2098: 2520 4080 2448 4062 Dl

2099: 2520 4080 180 180 De

2100: 10 I f

2101: (R)2549 4100 w

2102: 7 I f

2103: (P)2621 4120 w

2104: 10 R f

2105: 2651 3999 2666 3927 Dl

2106: 2650 3999 2698 3943 Dl

2107: 2839 3621 2650 3999 Dl

2108: 2838 3620 2823 3692 Dl

2109: 2839 3620 2791 3676 Dl

2110: 2736 4080 2700 4080 Dl

2111: 2816 4080 2780 4080 Dl

2112: 2898 4080 2862 4080 Dl

2113: 2978 4080 2942 4080 Dl

2114: 3060 4080 3024 4080 Dl

2115: 3060 4080 2988 4098 Dl

2116: 3060 4080 2988 4062 Dl

2117: 3060 4080 180 180 De

2118: 10 I f

2119: (R)3089 4100 w

2120: 7 I f

2121: (P)3161 4120 w

2122: 10 R f

2123: 3109 3999 3061 3943 Dl

2124: 3108 3999 3093 3927 Dl

2125: 2920 3621 3109 3999 Dl

2126: 2920 3620 2968 3676 Dl

2127: 2921 3620 2936 3692 Dl

2128: 3276 4080 3240 4080 Dl

2129: 3356 4080 3320 4080 Dl

2130: 3438 4080 3402 4080 Dl

2131: 3518 4080 3482 4080 Dl

2132: 3600 4080 3564 4080 Dl

2133: 3600 4080 3528 4098 Dl

2134: 3600 4080 3528 4062 Dl

2135: 3600 4080 180 180 De

2136: 10 I f

2137: (R)3629 4100 w

2138: 7 I f

2139: (P)3701 4120 w

2140: 10 R f

2141: 3614 4030 3545 4005 Dl

2142: 3614 4028 3565 3974 Dl

2143: 2955 3591 3615 4030 Dl

2144: 2955 3589 3024 3614 Dl

2145: 2955 3591 3004 3645 Dl

2146: 3816 4080 3780 4080 Dl

2147: 3896 4080 3860 4080 Dl

2148: 3978 4080 3942 4080 Dl

2149: 4058 4080 4022 4080 Dl

2150: 4140 4080 4104 4080 Dl

2151: 4140 4080 4068 4098 Dl

2152: 4140 4080 4068 4062 Dl

2153: 4140 4080 180 180 De

2154: 10 I f

2155: (R)4169 4100 w

2156: 7 I f

2157: (P)4241 4120 w

2158: 10 R f

2159: 4146 4046 4073 4036 Dl

2160: 4146 4045 4086 4002 Dl

2161: 2964 3573 4146 4046 Dl

2162: 2963 3573 3036 3583 Dl

2163: 2964 3574 3024 3617 Dl

2164: (Primary Receivers)1 740 1 4615 4100 t

2165: (Token Ring)1 475 1 4615 3830 t

2166: 4356 4080 4320 4080 Dl

2167: 4428 4080 4392 4080 Dl

2168: 4500 4080 4464 4080 Dl

2169: 4500 4044 4500 4080 Dl

2170: 4500 3966 4500 4002 Dl

2171: 4500 3887 4500 3923 Dl

2172: 4500 3810 4500 3846 Dl

2173: 4464 3810 4500 3810 Dl

2174: 4391 3810 4427 3810 Dl

2175: 4318 3810 4354 3810 Dl

2176: 4245 3810 4281 3810 Dl

2177: 4172 3810 4208 3810 Dl

2178: 4099 3810 4135 3810 Dl

2179: 4026 3810 4062 3810 Dl

2180: 3954 3810 3990 3810 Dl

2181: 3881 3810 3917 3810 Dl

2182: 3808 3810 3844 3810 Dl

2183: 3736 3810 3772 3810 Dl

2184: 3663 3810 3699 3810 Dl

2185: 3589 3810 3625 3810 Dl

2186: 3517 3810 3553 3810 Dl

2187: 3444 3810 3480 3810 Dl

2188: 3371 3810 3407 3810 Dl

2189: 3299 3810 3335 3810 Dl

2190: 3226 3810 3262 3810 Dl

2191: 3153 3810 3189 3810 Dl

2192: 3080 3810 3116 3810 Dl

2193: 3007 3810 3043 3810 Dl

2194: 2934 3810 2970 3810 Dl

2195: 2862 3810 2898 3810 Dl

2196: 2789 3810 2825 3810 Dl

2197: 2716 3810 2752 3810 Dl

2198: 2643 3810 2679 3810 Dl

2199: 2570 3810 2606 3810 Dl

2200: 2497 3810 2533 3810 Dl

2201: 2424 3810 2460 3810 Dl

2202: 2352 3810 2388 3810 Dl

2203: 2279 3810 2315 3810 Dl

2204: 2206 3810 2242 3810 Dl

2205: 2134 3810 2170 3810 Dl

2206: 2061 3810 2097 3810 Dl

2207: 1987 3810 2023 3810 Dl

2208: 1915 3810 1951 3810 Dl

2209: 1842 3810 1878 3810 Dl

2210: 1769 3810 1805 3810 Dl

2211: 1697 3810 1733 3810 Dl

2212: 1624 3810 1660 3810 Dl

2213: 1551 3810 1587 3810 Dl

2214: 1478 3810 1514 3810 Dl

2215: 1405 3810 1441 3810 Dl

2216: 1332 3810 1368 3810 Dl

2217: 1260 3810 1296 3810 Dl

2218: 1260 3846 1260 3810 Dl

2219: 1260 3923 1260 3887 Dl

2220: 1260 4002 1260 3966 Dl

2221: 1260 4080 1260 4044 Dl

2222: 1296 4080 1260 4080 Dl

2223: 1368 4080 1332 4080 Dl

2224: 1440 4080 1404 4080 Dl

2225: 1440 4080 1368 4098 Dl

2226: 1440 4080 1368 4062 Dl

2227: 1575 4530 180 180 De

2228: 10 I f

2229: (R)1607 4550 w

2230: 7 I f

2231: (S)1679 4570 w

2232: 10 R f

2233: 1725 4462 1759 4397 Dl

2234: 1726 4462 1787 4421 Dl

2235: 2009 4147 1725 4463 Dl

2236: 2008 4147 1974 4212 Dl

2237: 2009 4147 1948 4188 Dl

2238: 1735 4472 1779 4413 Dl

2239: 1736 4472 1802 4441 Dl

2240: 2809 3597 1734 4473 Dl

2241: 1791 4530 1755 4530 Dl

2242: 1844 4530 1808 4530 Dl

2243: 1844 4530 1772 4548 Dl

2244: 1844 4530 1772 4512 Dl

2245: 1844 4530 180 180 De

2246: 10 I f

2247: (R)1878 4550 w

2248: 7 I f

2249: (S)1950 4570 w

2250: 10 R f

2251: 1961 4443 1964 4369 Dl

2252: 1960 4444 1998 4380 Dl

2253: 2043 4166 1960 4443 Dl

2254: 2043 4166 2040 4240 Dl

2255: 2043 4165 2005 4229 Dl

2256: 1998 4464 2034 4400 Dl

2257: 1997 4464 2059 4425 Dl

2258: 2817 3606 1997 4465 Dl

2259: 2060 4530 2024 4530 Dl

2260: 2114 4530 2078 4530 Dl

2261: 2114 4530 2042 4548 Dl

2262: 2114 4530 2042 4512 Dl

2263: 2115 4530 180 180 De

2264: 10 I f

2265: (R)2147 4550 w

2266: 7 I f

2267: (S)2219 4570 w

2268: 10 R f

2269: 2179 4444 2141 4380 Dl

2270: 2178 4443 2175 4369 Dl

2271: 2096 4166 2179 4443 Dl

2272: 2096 4165 2134 4229 Dl

2273: 2096 4166 2099 4240 Dl

2274: 2256 4455 2281 4386 Dl

2275: 2256 4455 2311 4406 Dl

2276: 2828 3615 2255 4455 Dl

2277: 2204 4404 2204 4440 Dl

2278: 2204 4350 2204 4386 Dl

2279: 2193 4317 2204 4350 Dl

2280: 2174 4259 2185 4292 Dl

2281: 2154 4201 2165 4234 Dl

2282: 2134 4144 2145 4177 Dl

2283: 2134 4145 2174 4206 Dl

2284: 2133 4143 2139 4217 Dl

2285: 1664 4440 1646 4368 Dl

2286: 1665 4440 1683 4368 Dl

2287: 1664 4404 1664 4440 Dl

2288: 1664 4350 1664 4386 Dl

2289: 1694 4332 1664 4350 Dl

2290: 1757 4294 1727 4312 Dl

2291: 1819 4257 1789 4275 Dl

2292: 1881 4219 1851 4237 Dl

2293: 1943 4181 1913 4199 Dl

2294: 2005 4144 1975 4162 Dl

2295: (Secondary Receivers)1 839 1 2320 4550 t

2296: (Secondary Token Ring)2 921 1 743 4370 t

2297: 1664 4980 540 270 De

2298: 1935 4890 1935 4620 Dl

2299: 1934 4890 1916 4818 Dl

2300: 1935 4890 1953 4818 Dl

2301: (Re-Multicast)1960 4700 w

2302: (Local Multicast Tree)2 837 1 2229 5000 t

2303: 1440 5430 180 180 De

2304: (R)1497 5450 w

2305: 1591 5362 1625 5297 Dl

2306: 1590 5362 1651 5321 Dl

2307: 1874 5047 1590 5363 Dl

2308: 1710 5430 180 180 De

2309: (R)1767 5450 w

2310: 1826 5343 1829 5269 Dl

2311: 1826 5344 1864 5280 Dl

2312: 1908 5066 1825 5343 Dl

2313: 1980 5430 180 180 De

2314: (R)2037 5450 w

2315: 2043 5344 2005 5280 Dl

2316: 2043 5343 2040 5269 Dl

2317: 1961 5066 2044 5343 Dl

2318: 2250 5430 180 180 De

2319: (R)2307 5450 w

2320: 2279 5362 2218 5321 Dl

2321: 2278 5362 2244 5297 Dl

2322: 1995 5047 2279 5363 Dl

2323: (Customers)2455 5450 w

2324: 3960 4530 540 270 De

2325: 4230 4440 4230 4170 Dl

2326: 4230 4440 4212 4368 Dl

2327: 4230 4440 4248 4368 Dl

2328: (Re-Multicast)3683 4250 w

2329: (Local Multicast Tree)2 837 1 3202 4454 t

2330: 3735 4980 180 180 De

2331: (R)3791 5000 w

2332: 3885 4912 3919 4847 Dl

2333: 3886 4912 3947 4871 Dl

2334: 4169 4597 3885 4913 Dl

2335: 4004 4980 180 180 De

2336: (R)4062 5000 w

2337: 4121 4893 4124 4819 Dl

2338: 4120 4894 4158 4830 Dl

2339: 4203 4616 4120 4893 Dl

2340: 4275 4980 180 180 De

2341: (R)4331 5000 w

2342: 4339 4894 4301 4830 Dl

2343: 4338 4893 4335 4819 Dl

2344: 4256 4616 4339 4893 Dl

2345: 4544 4980 180 180 De

2346: (R)4602 5000 w

2347: 4573 4912 4512 4871 Dl

2348: 4574 4912 4540 4847 Dl

2349: 4290 4597 4574 4913 Dl

2350: (Customers)4749 5000 w

2351: 4590 4350 180 180 De

2352: 10 I f

2353: (R)4625 4370 w

2354: 7 I f

2355: (x)4697 4390 w

2356: 10 R f

2357: (Repair Server)1 551 1 4795 4370 t

2358: 4674 4439 4686 4512 Dl

2359: 4673 4440 4650 4510 Dl

2360: 4641 4890 4673 4440 Dl

2361: 4640 4890 4628 4817 Dl

2362: 4641 4889 4664 4819 Dl

2363: 4638 4430 4623 4502 Dl

2364: 4639 4430 4591 4486 Dl

2365: 4405 4898 4639 4430 Dl

2366: 4406 4899 4421 4827 Dl

2367: 4405 4899 4453 4843 Dl

2368: 4320 4080 4392 4095 Dl

2369: 4320 4080 4376 4128 Dl

2370: 4680 4260 4320 4080 Dl

2371: 4679 4259 4607 4244 Dl

2372: 4679 4259 4623 4211 Dl

2373: 4293 4144 4366 4156 Dl

2374: 4294 4144 4352 4189 Dl

2375: 4615 4285 4293 4143 Dl

2376: 4616 4285 4543 4273 Dl

2377: 4615 4285 4557 4240 Dl

2378: 7 R f

2379: ( .)1 0(. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .)135 4878 2 710 4263 t

2380: (.)5570 4226 w

2381: (.)5570 4190 w

2382: (.)5570 4153 w

2383: (.)5570 4116 w

2384: (.)5570 4080 w

2385: (.)5570 4044 w

2386: (.)5570 4007 w

2387: (.)5570 3971 w

2388: (.)5570 3934 w

2389: (.)5570 3897 w

2390: (.)5570 3861 w

2391: (.)5570 3825 w

2392: (.)5570 3788 w

2393: (.)5570 3752 w

2394: (.)5570 3715 w

2395: (.)5570 3679 w

2396: (.)5570 3643 w

2397: (.)5570 3606 w

2398: (.)5570 3569 w

2399: (.)5570 3532 w

2400: (.)5570 3496 w

2401: (.)5570 3460 w

2402: (.)5570 3423 w

2403: (.)5570 3387 w

2404: (.)5570 3350 w

2405: (.)5570 3314 w

2406: (.)5570 3278 w

2407: (.)5570 3241 w

2408: (.)5570 3204 w

2409: (.)5570 3168 w

2410: (.)5570 3131 w

2411: (.)5570 3095 w

2412: (.)5570 3059 w

2413: (.)5570 3022 w

2414: (.)5570 2985 w

2415: (.)5570 2949 w

2416: ( .)1 0( . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .)135 -4860(. .)1 18 3 5570 2913 t

2417: (.)710 2949 w

2418: (.)710 2985 w

2419: (.)710 3022 w

2420: (.)710 3059 w

2421: (.)710 3095 w

2422: (.)710 3131 w

2423: (.)710 3168 w

2424: (.)710 3204 w

2425: (.)710 3241 w

2426: (.)710 3278 w

2427: (.)710 3314 w

2428: (.)710 3350 w

2429: (.)710 3387 w

2430: (.)710 3423 w

2431: (.)710 3460 w

2432: (.)710 3496 w

2433: (.)710 3532 w

2434: (.)710 3569 w

2435: (.)710 3606 w

2436: (.)710 3643 w

2437: (.)710 3679 w

2438: (.)710 3715 w

2439: (.)710 3752 w

2440: (.)710 3788 w

2441: (.)710 3825 w

2442: (.)710 3861 w

2443: (.)710 3897 w

2444: (.)710 3934 w

2445: (.)710 3971 w

2446: (.)710 4007 w

2447: (.)710 4044 w

2448: (.)710 4080 w

2449: (.)710 4116 w

2450: (.)710 4153 w

2451: (.)710 4190 w

2452: (.)710 4226 w

2453: (.)710 4263 w

2454: 10 R f

2455: (Reliable Multicast Protocol)2 1100 1 4480 2870 t

2456: 10 I f

2457: (R)3618 5445 w

2458: 7 I f

2459: (T)3690 5465 w

2460: 10 S f

2461: (=)3786 5445 w

2462: (\354)3898 5358 w

2463: (\355)3898 5458 w

2464: (\356)3898 5558 w

2465: 10 I f

2466: (R)3947 5445 w

2467: 7 I f

2468: (P)4019 5465 w

2469: 10 R f

2470: (,)4078 5445 w

2471: 10 I f

2472: (R)4111 5445 w

2473: 7 I f

2474: (S)4183 5465 w

2475: 10 S f

2476: (\374)4226 5358 w

2477: (\375)4226 5458 w

2478: (\376)4226 5558 w

2479: 10 B f

2480: (Figure 2.)1 383 1 1304 5830 t

2481: 10 R f

2482: (The general multicast architecture for the stock market applications.)8 2719 1 1737 5830 t

2483: %INFO[SECTION: LEVEL = 2, NUMBER = 4.1  , HEADING = Receivers]

2484: 9 B f

2485: (4.1 Receivers)1 529 1 720 6190 t

2486: 10 R f

2487: (The primary receivers,)2 939 1 720 6370 t

2488: 10 I f

2489: (R)1701 6370 w

2490: 7 I f

2491: (P)1773 6390 w

2492: 10 R f

2493: ( are trusted to share the)5 1018( components)1 525( These)1 305(, take part in the RMP protocol.)6 1368 4 1824 6370 t

2494: ( can be owned and operated by the network provider)9 2124( They)1 258( favor speci\256c customers.)3 1029(information and not to)3 909 4 720 6490 t

2495: ( receivers in the RMP)4 939( set of)2 276( The)1 221(or they can be licensed and regulated by a government organization.)10 2884 4 720 6610 t

2496: ( it is)2 195( Therefore,)1 478( stable and does not change as individual traders join or leave an application.)13 3210(protocol is)1 437 4 720 6730 t

2497: ( group when a network based receiver fails and not when customers,)11 2809(only necessary to reform the receiver)5 1511 2 720 6850 t

2498: 10 I f

2499: (R)720 6970 w

2500: 10 R f

2501: (, join or leave the application.)5 1190 1 781 6970 t

2502: (The)720 7210 w

2503: 10 I f

2504: (R)902 7210 w

2505: 7 I f

2506: (P)974 7230 w

2507: 10 R f

2508: (place the source messages in the same sequence, then multicast the sequence to the)13 3341 1 1077 7210 t

2509: 10 I f

2510: (R)4446 7210 w

2511: 10 R f

2512: ( is no)2 223(. There)1 310 2 4507 7210 t

2513: (limit on the number)3 828 1 720 7330 t

2514: 10 I f

2515: (R)1585 7330 w

2516: 10 R f

2517: ( an)1 130(that can receive the multicast signal from)6 1719 2 1683 7330 t

2518: 10 I f

2519: (R)3568 7330 w

2520: 7 I f

2521: (P)3640 7350 w

2522: 10 R f

2523: ( in order to meet our)5 873(. However,)1 476 2 3691 7330 t

2524: (fairness conditions, the region of an)5 1506 1 720 7450 t

2525: 10 I f

2526: (R)2266 7450 w

2527: 7 I f

2528: (P)2338 7470 w

2529: 10 R f

2530: ( must be limited by the loss characteristics of the)9 2095('s remulticast)1 556 2 2389 7450 t

2531: cleartomark

2532: showpage

2533: saveobj restore

2534: end

2535: %%EndPage: 8 8

2536: %%Page: 9 9

2537: DpostDict begin

2538: /saveobj save def

2539: mark

2540: 9 pagesetup

2541: 10 R f

2542: (- 9 -)2 166 1 2797 480 t

2543: (network and the delay from that)5 1283 1 720 960 t

2544: 10 I f

2545: (R)2029 960 w

2546: 7 I f

2547: (P)2101 980 w

2548: 10 R f

2549: (to its)1 199 1 2178 960 t

2550: 10 I f

2551: (R)2402 960 w

2552: 10 R f

2553: ( addition, multicast regions should overlap so that if an)9 2199('s. In)1 230 2 2463 960 t

2554: 10 I f

2555: (R)4917 960 w

2556: 7 I f

2557: (P)4989 980 w

2558: 10 R f

2559: ( area of the network increases, an)6 1385(fails, or if the loss in an)6 989 2 720 1080 t

2560: 10 I f

2561: (R)3128 1080 w

2562: 10 R f

2563: (can obtain the information from an alternate)6 1817 1 3223 1080 t

2564: (source until the network is reformed.)5 1475 1 720 1200 t

2565: (Increasing)720 1440 w

2566: 10 I f

2567: (m)1161 1440 w

2568: 10 R f

2569: ( can improve the quality of the data delivered)8 1829(, decreases the size of the remulticast regions and)8 1978 2 1233 1440 t

2570: (to)720 1560 w

2571: 10 I f

2572: (R)842 1560 w

2573: 10 R f

2574: ( as)1 127(. However,)1 484 2 903 1560 t

2575: 10 I f

2576: (m)1558 1560 w

2577: 10 R f

2578: ( time to detect failed)4 893(increases, the)1 556 2 1674 1560 t

2579: 10 I f

2580: (R)3166 1560 w

2581: 7 I f

2582: (P)3238 1580 w

2583: 10 R f

2584: (and the time to guarantee that all of the)8 1708 1 3332 1560 t

2585: ( If)1 143(receivers have an acknowledged message increases.)5 2205 2 720 1680 t

2586: 10 I f

2587: (m)3121 1680 w

2588: 10 R f

2589: (becomes very large the protocol becomes)5 1794 1 3246 1680 t

2590: ( use a)2 233( We)1 191( the correlated losses on the global multicast tree.)8 1996(susceptible to NACK implosion because of the)6 1900 4 720 1800 t

2591: (layered architecture, with secondary receivers,)4 1858 1 720 1920 t

2592: 10 I f

2593: (R)2605 1920 w

2594: 7 I f

2595: (S)2677 1940 w

2596: 10 R f

2597: (, to improve the quality of the data delivered to)9 1899 1 2720 1920 t

2598: 10 I f

2599: (R)4646 1920 w

2600: 10 R f

2601: (without)4734 1920 w

2602: (as large an increase in)4 880 1 720 2040 t

2603: 10 I f

2604: (m)1625 2040 w

2605: 10 R f

2606: (.)1697 2040 w

2607: (The secondary receivers,)2 999 1 720 2280 t

2608: 10 I f

2609: (R)1747 2280 w

2610: 7 I f

2611: (S)1819 2300 w

2612: 10 R f

2613: ( same source messages and)4 1102( receive the)2 465( They)1 258(, are also trusted network servers.)5 1353 4 1862 2280 t

2614: (acknowledgements as the)2 1046 1 720 2400 t

2615: 10 I f

2616: (R)1803 2400 w

2617: 7 I f

2618: (P)1875 2420 w

2619: 10 R f

2620: ( the)1 159( However,)1 452(, and remulticast the same sequence of messages.)7 2049 3 1926 2400 t

2621: 10 I f

2622: (R)4623 2400 w

2623: 7 I f

2624: (S)4695 2420 w

2625: 10 R f

2626: (do not)1 265 1 4775 2400 t

2627: ( an)1 137( When)1 306( messages and do not take part in the primary token loop.)11 2484(acknowledge source)1 828 4 720 2520 t

2628: 10 I f

2629: (R)4518 2520 w

2630: 7 I f

2631: (S)4590 2540 w

2632: 10 R f

2633: (detects a)1 364 1 4676 2520 t

2634: ( requests the message from a speci\256c)6 1498(missing acknowledgement or source message it)5 1920 2 720 2640 t

2635: 10 I f

2636: (R)4166 2640 w

2637: 7 I f

2638: (P)4238 2660 w

2639: 10 R f

2640: (that is assigned to)3 723 1 4317 2640 t

2641: ( the)1 154( Therefore,)1 474(support it, rather than from the token site.)7 1711 3 720 2760 t

2642: 10 I f

2643: (R)3091 2760 w

2644: 7 I f

2645: (S)3163 2780 w

2646: 10 R f

2647: (do not increase the time required to detect a)8 1802 1 3238 2760 t

2648: (failed)720 2880 w

2649: 10 I f

2650: (R)972 2880 w

2651: 7 I f

2652: (P)1044 2900 w

2653: 10 R f

2654: (or add to the NACK implosion on the global multicast tree.)10 2374 1 1120 2880 t

2655: (The)720 3120 w

2656: 10 I f

2657: (R)907 3120 w

2658: 7 I f

2659: (S)979 3140 w

2660: 10 R f

2661: (in a region pass a secondary token between themselves to detect failures and guarantee that all of)16 3986 1 1054 3120 t

2662: ( messages are received by all of the)7 1443(the source)1 412 2 720 3240 t

2663: 10 I f

2664: (R)2604 3240 w

2665: 7 I f

2666: (S)2676 3260 w

2667: 10 R f

2668: ( secondary tokens are numbered to correspond with)7 2087(. The)1 234 2 2719 3240 t

2669: (the primary tokens and an)4 1117 1 720 3360 t

2670: 10 I f

2671: (R)1882 3360 w

2672: 7 I f

2673: (S)1954 3380 w

2674: 10 R f

2675: (does not pass the token until it has the acknowledgements and source)11 2997 1 2043 3360 t

2676: ( make the same inferences)4 1088( site that receives a secondary token can)7 1668( A)1 132(messages up to that token number.)5 1432 4 720 3480 t

2677: ( received the primary token could make about sites in the)10 2295(about the sites in the secondary group as a site that)10 2025 2 720 3600 t

2678: ( ring includes an)3 690( secondary token)2 696( Each)1 259(primary group.)1 609 4 720 3720 t

2679: 10 I f

2680: (R)3008 3720 w

2681: 7 I f

2682: (P)3080 3740 w

2683: 10 R f

2684: ( That)1 242(on the primary token ring.)4 1082 2 3165 3720 t

2685: 10 I f

2686: (R)4523 3720 w

2687: 7 I f

2688: (P)4595 3740 w

2689: 10 R f

2690: (can infer)1 360 1 4680 3720 t

2691: (state of the secondary group and transfer that information to the primary group.)12 3169 1 720 3840 t

2692: ( that we)2 346(As we increase the number of receivers in a secondary group we encounter the same problems)15 3974 2 720 4080 t

2693: (encountered as we increased)3 1155 1 720 4200 t

2694: 10 I f

2695: (m)1906 4200 w

2696: 10 R f

2697: ( layers)1 268( Two)1 238( takes longer to pass the token around the secondary group.)10 2415(. It)1 141 4 1978 4200 t

2698: ( reduce the number of token passes required to detect failures or guarantee delivery,)13 3463(of receivers can only)3 857 2 720 4320 t

2699: 10 I f

2700: (L)720 4440 w

2701: 7 R f

2702: (2)787 4460 w

2703: 10 R f

2704: ( the number of passes in a single layer architecture,)9 2063(, by the square root of)5 891 2 830 4440 t

2705: 10 I f

2706: (L)3811 4440 w

2707: 7 R f

2708: (1)3878 4460 w

2709: 10 R f

2710: ( we have a group of 100)6 976(. If)1 143 2 3921 4440 t

2711: (receivers)720 4560 w

2712: 10 I f

2713: (L)1123 4560 w

2714: 7 R f

2715: (1)1190 4580 w

2716: 10 S f

2717: (=)1282 4560 w

2718: 10 R f

2719: ( each)1 227( we organize the 100 receivers into 10 secondary groups of 10 receivers,)12 3117(100. If)1 310 3 1386 4560 t

2720: ( token passes to circulate the token and the primary group also has 10 members)14 3181(secondary group requires 10)3 1139 2 720 4680 t

2721: (so that we require 10 token passes to detect a failure,)10 2169 1 720 4800 t

2722: 10 I f

2723: (L)2920 4800 w

2724: 7 R f

2725: (2)2987 4820 w

2726: 10 S f

2727: (=)3046 4800 w

2728: 10 R f

2729: ( have 10,000 receivers,)3 943( we)1 147(10. If)1 247 3 3117 4800 t

2730: 10 I f

2731: (L)4486 4800 w

2732: 7 R f

2733: (1)4553 4820 w

2734: 10 S f

2735: (=)4645 4800 w

2736: 10 R f

2737: (10 , 000)2 291 1 4749 4800 t

2738: (and)720 4920 w

2739: 10 I f

2740: (L)889 4920 w

2741: 7 R f

2742: (2)956 4940 w

2743: 10 S f

2744: (=)1048 4920 w

2745: 10 R f

2746: (100.)1152 4920 w

2747: ( With)1 260(We can generalize the layered receiver architecture.)6 2125 2 720 5169 t

2748: 10 I f

2749: (i)3141 5169 w

2750: 10 R f

2751: (layers,)3205 5169 w

2752: 10 I f

2753: (L)3504 5169 w

2754: 7 I f

2755: (i)3571 5189 w

2756: 10 S f

2757: (=)3648 5169 w

2758: 7 I f

2759: (i)3757 5129 w

2760: 13 S f

2761: (\326` `)1 198 1 3785 5189 t

2762: 10 I f

2763: (L)3865 5169 w

2764: 7 R f

2765: (1)3932 5189 w

2766: 10 R f

2767: ( land surface of the)4 808(. The)1 241 2 3991 5169 t

2768: (earth is about 57)3 669 1 720 5289 t

2769: 10 I f

2770: (x)1397 5289 w

2771: 10 R f

2772: (10)1449 5289 w

2773: 7 R f

2774: (6)1554 5249 w

2775: 10 R f

2776: ( we place 10,000 receivers uniformly over the surface, the maximum)10 2769( If)1 118(square miles.)1 529 3 1624 5289 t

2777: ( is less than 50 miles, which is most likely adequate to provide our delay and loss)16 3443(distance to a receiver)3 877 2 720 5409 t

2778: ( stock market systems won't have to provide uniform access to the entire land surface)14 3435( our)1 160(guarantees. Since)1 725 3 720 5529 t

2779: ( be more than suf\256cient to limit our token rings to a few 10's of)14 2598(of the earth, two layers of receivers should)7 1722 2 720 5649 t

2780: (receivers.)720 5769 w

2781: ( effort)1 262( Best)1 244( and guaranteed delivery.)3 1056(Within a region we can provide two grades of service, best effort)11 2758 4 720 6009 t

2782: ( delivery)1 372( Guaranteed)1 529( traders.)1 341(delivers all of the messages that are not lost in the regional area to the)14 3078 4 720 6129 t

2783: ( guarantee delivery by colocating retransmit servers,)6 2140( We)1 196(recovers all of the messages.)4 1176 3 720 6249 t

2784: 10 I f

2785: (R)4265 6249 w

2786: 7 I f

2787: (x)4337 6269 w

2788: 10 R f

2789: (, with the)2 391 1 4376 6249 t

2790: 10 I f

2791: (R)4800 6249 w

2792: 7 I f

2793: (P)4872 6269 w

2794: 10 R f

2795: (or)4957 6249 w

2796: 10 I f

2797: (R)720 6369 w

2798: 7 I f

2799: (S)792 6389 w

2800: 10 R f

2801: ( an)1 119(. When)1 313 2 835 6369 t

2802: 10 I f

2803: (R)1292 6369 w

2804: 10 R f

2805: (detects a missing sequence number, it can request the message from)10 2714 1 1378 6369 t

2806: 10 I f

2807: (R)4117 6369 w

2808: 7 I f

2809: (x)4189 6389 w

2810: 10 R f

2811: (.)4228 6369 w

2812: %INFO[SECTION: LEVEL = 2, NUMBER = 4.2  , HEADING = Sources]

2813: 9 B f

2814: (4.2 Sources)1 459 1 720 6669 t

2815: 10 R f

2816: (The sources,)1 523 1 720 6849 t

2817: 10 I f

2818: (S)1287 6849 w

2819: 7 I f

2820: (P)1348 6869 w

2821: 10 R f

2822: ( are)1 166( There)1 302( into the reliable multicast group.)5 1427(, are trusted to enter valid data messages)7 1746 4 1399 6849 t

2823: (authentication)720 6969 w

2824: 7 R f

2825: (10 , 11 , 12)4 266 1 1291 6929 t

2826: 10 R f

2827: ( can extend trust to a large number of sources,)9 1948(and certi\256cate granting systems that)4 1489 2 1603 6969 t

2828: ( addition, RMP requires)3 997( In)1 145(however, we can keep tighter security with a smaller number of participants.)11 3178 3 720 7089 t

2829: ( techniques)1 458(that each receiver maintain state information about each source and some of our cryptographic)13 3862 2 720 7209 t

2830: ( large, it becomes)3 728( the number of sources becomes)5 1318( As)1 168(require receivers to share a secret with each source.)8 2106 4 720 7329 t

2831: (dif\256cult to maintain source speci\256c information.)5 1932 1 720 7449 t

2832: cleartomark

2833: showpage

2834: saveobj restore

2835: end

2836: %%EndPage: 9 9

2837: %%Page: 10 10

2838: DpostDict begin

2839: /saveobj save def

2840: mark

2841: 10 pagesetup

2842: 10 R f

2843: (- 10 -)2 216 1 2772 480 t

2844: ( number of receivers,)3 865(While the constraint on the number of sources isn't as severe as the constraint on the)15 3455 2 720 960 t

2845: ( number)1 333( order to keep the)4 714( In)1 137(there should not be millions or ten's of millions of sources in an RMP group.)14 3136 4 720 1080 t

2846: ( be layered: The)3 654(of sources that participate in RMP to a few thousand, the sources can also)13 2971 2 720 1200 t

2847: 10 I f

2848: (S)4373 1200 w

2849: 7 I f

2850: (P)4434 1220 w

2851: 10 R f

2852: (participate in)1 527 1 4513 1200 t

2853: (RMP; The)1 420 1 720 1320 t

2854: 10 I f

2855: (S)1165 1320 w

2856: 7 I f

2857: (P)1226 1340 w

2858: 10 R f

2859: (trust a set of secondary brokers,)5 1269 1 1302 1320 t

2860: 10 I f

2861: (S)2596 1320 w

2862: 7 I f

2863: (S)2657 1340 w

2864: 10 R f

2865: (; And, each)2 457 1 2700 1320 t

2866: 10 I f

2867: (S)3182 1320 w

2868: 7 I f

2869: (S)3243 1340 w

2870: 10 R f

2871: (trusts a set of customers.)4 985 1 3311 1320 t

2872: %INFO[SECTION: LEVEL = 2, NUMBER = 4.3  , HEADING = Reformation]

2873: 9 B f

2874: (4.3 Reformation)1 649 1 720 1620 t

2875: 10 R f

2876: ( that the receiver has failed if it does not receive)10 1927(In a positive acknowledgement protocol the source assumes)7 2393 2 720 1800 t

2877: ( group failures are detected)4 1105( Token)1 310( transmission attempts.)2 930(an acknowledgement after a speci\256ed number of)6 1975 4 720 1920 t

2878: (when an)1 348 1 720 2040 t

2879: 10 I f

2880: (S)1106 2040 w

2881: 7 I f

2882: (P)1167 2060 w

2883: 10 R f

2884: ( for a message, a token site fails to pass a token, or a)13 2275(fails to receive an acknowledgement)4 1509 2 1256 2040 t

2885: ( a site detects a failure it noti\256es a)8 1399( When)1 293( acknowledgement.)1 781(receiver cannot recover a missing message or)6 1847 4 720 2160 t

2886: (reformation server,)1 764 1 720 2280 t

2887: 10 I f

2888: (X)1509 2280 w

2889: 7 I f

2890: (R)1581 2300 w

2891: 10 R f

2892: ( are redundant reformation servers in case one fails.)8 2063(. There)1 307 2 1632 2280 t

2893: (The)720 2520 w

2894: 10 I f

2895: (X)904 2520 w

2896: 7 I f

2897: (R)976 2540 w

2898: 10 R f

2899: ( that have failures.)3 752(is responsible for forming new primary and secondary token rings in the groups)12 3232 2 1056 2520 t

2900: (It also assigns addresses for the remulticasts from the)8 2194 1 720 2640 t

2901: 10 I f

2902: (R)2947 2640 w

2903: 7 I f

2904: (T)3019 2660 w

2905: 10 R f

2906: (\(the set of)2 415 1 3099 2640 t

2907: 10 I f

2908: (R)3547 2640 w

2909: 7 I f

2910: (P)3619 2660 w

2911: 10 R f

2912: (and)3702 2640 w

2913: 10 I f

2914: (R)3878 2640 w

2915: 7 I f

2916: (S)3950 2660 w

2917: 10 R f

2918: (\) and adjusts the scope of)5 1047 1 3993 2640 t

2919: ( receive from at least two multicast sources but two multicast)10 2557(their multicasts so that every customer can)6 1763 2 720 2760 t

2920: (sources that use the same address do not overlap.)8 1960 1 720 2880 t

2921: (In the original RBP protocol the reformation process was distributed, instead of centralized, and every)14 4320 1 720 3120 t

2922: ( centralized protocol is simpler)4 1253( The)1 209( server.)1 297(operable receiver was equally likely to become the reformation)8 2561 4 720 3240 t

2923: ( which server becomes)3 974(because it does not have an election phase to decide)9 2250 2 720 3360 t

2924: 10 I f

2925: (X)3990 3360 w

2926: 7 I f

2927: (R)4062 3380 w

2928: 10 R f

2929: ( the stock market)3 748(. In)1 179 2 4113 3360 t

2930: ( it may be limited to a subgroup of receivers on)10 1992(application the reformation is more complicated because)6 2328 2 720 3480 t

2931: ( addition, the)2 549( In)1 145(particular secondary rings.)2 1085 3 720 3600 t

2932: 10 I f

2933: (X)2536 3600 w

2934: 7 I f

2935: (R)2608 3620 w

2936: 10 R f

2937: (needs to have more information because the reformation)7 2344 1 2696 3600 t

2938: ( The)1 233( multicast regions and possibly changing the remulticast addresses.)8 2902(operation includes adjusting)2 1185 3 720 3720 t

2939: ( better maintained in a small)5 1185( is)1 127( group structures, multicast ranges, etc.)5 1614(additional information on receiver)3 1394 4 720 3840 t

2940: (number of)1 413 1 720 3960 t

2941: 10 I f

2942: (X)1158 3960 w

2943: 7 I f

2944: (R)1230 3980 w

2945: 10 R f

2946: (than in possibly 100,000)3 984 1 1306 3960 t

2947: 10 I f

2948: (R)2315 3960 w

2949: 7 I f

2950: (T)2387 3980 w

2951: 10 R f

2952: ('s.)2434 3960 w

2953: ( token group, the)3 689(To determine the operable receivers and reform a)7 1989 2 720 4200 t

2954: 10 I f

2955: (X)3427 4200 w

2956: 7 I f

2957: (R)3499 4220 w

2958: 10 R f

2959: (multicasts several invitations to join)4 1461 1 3579 4200 t

2960: ( positive acknowledgment protocol to send a)6 1919( operable receivers use a)4 1071( The)1 228(a new group of receivers.)4 1102 4 720 4320 t

2961: (message to)1 442 1 720 4440 t

2962: 10 I f

2963: (X)1188 4440 w

2964: 7 I f

2965: (R)1260 4460 w

2966: 10 R f

2967: ( the receiver does not receive the acknowledgement it decides that the)11 2812(. If)1 143 2 1311 4440 t

2968: 10 I f

2969: (X)4293 4440 w

2970: 7 I f

2971: (R)4365 4460 w

2972: 10 R f

2973: (failed and tries)2 597 1 4443 4440 t

2974: (another)720 4560 w

2975: 10 I f

2976: (X)1047 4560 w

2977: 7 I f

2978: (R)1119 4580 w

2979: 10 R f

2980: ( message to)2 472(. The)1 233 2 1170 4560 t

2981: 10 I f

2982: (X)1903 4560 w

2983: 7 I f

2984: (R)1975 4580 w

2985: 10 R f

2986: ( of the receiver's last acknowledged message,)6 1837(includes the number)2 816 2 2054 4560 t

2987: 10 I f

2988: (t)4734 4560 w

2989: 7 I f

2990: (r)4773 4580 w

2991: 10 R f

2992: (. The)1 232 1 4808 4560 t

2993: ( loop, decides on the starting message number)7 1954(reformation server creates a new token)5 1622 2 720 4680 t

2994: 10 I f

2995: (t)4337 4680 w

2996: 10 R f

2997: (, and appoints a)3 675 1 4365 4680 t

2998: (receiver with)1 523 1 720 4800 t

2999: 10 I f

3000: (t)1268 4800 w

3001: 7 I f

3002: (r)1307 4820 w

3003: 10 S f

3004: (\263)1350 4800 w

3005: 10 I f

3006: (t)1413 4800 w

3007: 10 R f

3008: (as the token site.)3 666 1 1466 4800 t

3009: (The starting message number,)3 1213 1 720 5040 t

3010: 10 I f

3011: (t)1963 5040 w

3012: 10 R f

3013: ( the uni\256ed ticker)3 720( In)1 139( the new repair group depends on the application.)8 2019(, for)1 171 4 1991 5040 t

3014: (the token can start at)4 854 1 720 5160 t

3015: 10 I f

3016: (t)1606 5160 w

3017: 10 S f

3018: (=)1658 5160 w

3019: 10 I f

3020: (t)1729 5160 w

3021: 7 I f

3022: (r)1768 5180 w

3023: 7 R f

3024: (, max)1 144 1 1800 5180 t

3025: 10 S f

3026: (+)1968 5160 w

3027: 10 R f

3028: ( a distributed trading \257oor we may want to be more conservative, as)12 2787(1. In)1 214 2 2039 5160 t

3029: ( in the distributed database on RBP)6 1507(we were)1 349 2 720 5280 t

3030: 10 I f

3031: (,)2576 5280 w

3032: 7 R f

3033: (2)2606 5240 w

3034: 10 R f

3035: (to make certain that trades aren't lost when sites fail or)10 2350 1 2690 5280 t

3036: (recover.)720 5400 w

3037: %INFO[SECTION: LEVEL = 2, NUMBER = 4.4  , HEADING = Striping]

3038: 9 B f

3039: (4.4 Striping)1 474 1 720 5700 t

3040: 10 R f

3041: ( rate that can be)4 719(The amount of data in the composite stock ticker will almost always exceed the bit)14 3601 2 720 5880 t

3042: (transmitted to an individual customer,)4 1543 1 720 6000 t

3043: 10 I f

3044: (R)2294 6000 w

3045: 10 R f

3046: ( of data in the composite ticker may also exceed the)10 2118( amount)1 331(. The)1 236 3 2355 6000 t

3047: (amount of data that can be processed by an)8 1766 1 720 6120 t

3048: 10 I f

3049: (R)2517 6120 w

3050: 7 I f

3051: (T)2589 6140 w

3052: 10 R f

3053: ( of these problems are addressed)5 1334( Both)1 252(in the repair group.)3 786 3 2668 6120 t

3054: ( the stripes that are used to solve the two problems)10 2140( However,)1 452( into common groups.)3 914(by "striping" stocks)2 814 4 720 6240 t

3055: (have different widths.)2 873 1 720 6360 t

3056: ( having one set of)4 738(Instead of)1 402 2 720 6600 t

3057: 10 I f

3058: (R)1892 6600 w

3059: 7 I f

3060: (T)1964 6620 w

3061: 10 R f

3062: (that process all of the messages, stocks are organized in stripes of related)12 2997 1 2043 6600 t

3063: ( for the RMP protocol at the core of the architecture)10 2143( stripe uses a different multicast address)6 1645(stocks. Each)1 532 3 720 6720 t

3064: (and uses a different set)4 934 1 720 6840 t

3065: 10 I f

3066: (R)1684 6840 w

3067: 7 I f

3068: (T)1756 6860 w

3069: 10 R f

3070: ( stripe is limited to a group of stocks that have few)11 2089( A)1 127(to process the messages.)3 991 3 1833 6840 t

3071: ( by all of the)4 529(enough messages to be processed)4 1364 2 720 6960 t

3072: 10 I f

3073: (R)2644 6960 w

3074: 7 I f

3075: (T)2716 6980 w

3076: 10 R f

3077: ( the)1 153(. Since)1 303 2 2763 6960 t

3078: 10 I f

3079: (R)3250 6960 w

3080: 7 I f

3081: (T)3322 6980 w

3082: 10 R f

3083: (are provided by the network, rather than)6 1640 1 3400 6960 t

3084: ( weak links - and that they are)7 1305(the customers, we can assume that all of the processors are similar - no)13 3015 2 720 7080 t

3085: ( of wide)2 331( should be a relatively small number)6 1472( There)1 285(among the more powerful processors that are available.)7 2232 4 720 7200 t

3086: (stripes in the core of the architecture.)6 1482 1 720 7320 t

3087: cleartomark

3088: showpage

3089: saveobj restore

3090: end

3091: %%EndPage: 10 10

3092: %%Page: 11 11

3093: DpostDict begin

3094: /saveobj save def

3095: mark

3096: 11 pagesetup

3097: 10 R f

3098: (- 11 -)2 216 1 2772 480 t

3099: (An)720 960 w

3100: 10 I f

3101: (R)873 960 w

3102: 7 I f

3103: (T)945 980 w

3104: 10 R f

3105: ( narrower stripes of more closely related stocks)7 1936(organizes the data on the stripe that it receives into)9 2081 2 1023 960 t

3106: ( amount of data on one of the \256nal stripes)9 1662( The)1 205(and transmits each stripe on a different remulticast addresses.)8 2453 3 720 1080 t

3107: ( minimum reception rate of the)5 1275(is limited by the)3 666 2 720 1200 t

3108: 10 I f

3109: (R)2693 1200 w

3110: 10 R f

3111: ( of the)2 269(. Any)1 254 2 2754 1200 t

3112: 10 I f

3113: (R)3309 1200 w

3114: 10 R f

3115: (in the remulticast region can receive the)6 1638 1 3402 1200 t

3116: (data on one stripe and an)5 1025 1 720 1320 t

3117: 10 I f

3118: (R)1776 1320 w

3119: 10 R f

3120: ( instance, if)2 473( For)1 194( rate lines can receive the data on multiple stripes.)9 2041(with higher)1 464 4 1868 1320 t

3121: (the least capable)2 667 1 720 1440 t

3122: 10 I f

3123: (R)1416 1440 w

3124: 10 R f

3125: (have 56 Kbps modems,)3 950 1 1506 1440 t

3126: 10 I f

3127: (R)2485 1440 w

3128: 7 I f

3129: (T)2557 1460 w

3130: 10 R f

3131: ( customer with a)3 678( A)1 127( data into 56 Kbps stripes.)5 1069(organizes the)1 533 4 2633 1440 t

3132: ( on a small group of)5 892(56 Kbps modem may select any one remulticast address and receive information)11 3428 2 720 1560 t

3133: ( with a 45 Mbps connection may simultaneously view the information on the stocks)13 3429(stocks, while a broker)3 891 2 720 1680 t

3134: ( be a relatively large number of narrow stripes at the edge of the)13 2739( should)1 307( There)1 297(in 800 different stripes.)3 977 4 720 1800 t

3135: (architecture.)720 1920 w

3136: %INFO[SECTION: LEVEL = 1, NUMBER = 5.  , HEADING = Protocol Modifications]

3137: 9 B f

3138: ( Modi\256cations)1 548(5. Protocol)1 439 2 720 2280 t

3139: 10 R f

3140: ( data in the stock market applications require modi\256cations of the)10 2729(The fairness issues and the quantity of)6 1591 2 720 2580 t

3141: ( major changes are)3 750( The)1 205(basic RMP protocol.)2 825 3 720 2700 t

3142: ( delivery,)1 377(1. delayed)1 485 2 795 2880 t

3143: ( driven, rather than event driven, token passing, and)8 2071(2. time)1 353 2 795 3060 t

3144: ( reduction.)1 427(3. NACK)1 458 2 795 3240 t

3145: (In the modi\256ed protocol, the)4 1157 1 720 3480 t

3146: 10 I f

3147: (R)1906 3480 w

3148: 7 I f

3149: (T)1978 3500 w

3150: 10 R f

3151: (wait)2054 3480 w

3152: 10 S f

3153: (D)2255 3480 w

3154: 7 I f

3155: (A)2327 3500 w

3156: 10 R f

3157: ( is acknowledged and the time that it)7 1503(between the time a message)4 1130 2 2407 3480 t

3158: ( The)1 239(is remulticast.)1 595 2 720 3600 t

3159: 10 I f

3160: (R)1613 3600 w

3161: 7 I f

3162: (T)1685 3620 w

3163: 10 R f

3164: ( clocks can be synchronized by a network)7 1896( The)1 238(have synchronized clocks.)2 1116 3 1790 3600 t

3165: (protocol)720 3720 w

3166: 7 R f

3167: (13 , 14)2 168 1 1058 3680 t

3168: 10 R f

3169: ( the)1 161( When)1 302( receiving a signal from a satellite and adjusting for differences in delay.)12 3059(, or by)2 284 4 1234 3720 t

3170: ( The)1 222(token site acknowledges a source message, it timestamps the acknowledgement.)9 3365 2 720 3840 t

3171: 10 I f

3172: (R)4349 3840 w

3173: 7 I f

3174: (T)4421 3860 w

3175: 10 R f

3176: (remulticast a)1 530 1 4510 3840 t

3177: (message)720 3960 w

3178: 10 S f

3179: (D)1096 3960 w

3180: 7 I f

3181: (A)1168 3980 w

3182: 10 R f

3183: ( delay)1 255( The)1 219(after the message's time stamp.)4 1312 3 1258 3960 t

3184: 10 S f

3185: (D)3083 3960 w

3186: 7 I f

3187: (A)3155 3980 w

3188: 10 R f

3189: (compensates for the difference in reception)5 1795 1 3245 3960 t

3190: (times at the different)3 844 1 720 4080 t

3191: 10 I f

3192: (R)1594 4080 w

3193: 7 I f

3194: (T)1666 4100 w

3195: 10 R f

3196: (caused by differences in propagation delay from the source and the time to detect)13 3297 1 1743 4080 t

3197: ( when all of the)4 641( system is fair)3 570( A)1 126(and recover missing messages.)3 1243 4 720 4200 t

3198: 10 I f

3199: (R)3330 4200 w

3200: 7 I f

3201: (T)3402 4220 w

3202: 10 R f

3203: (simultaneously retransmit the message)3 1561 1 3479 4200 t

3204: (to their local customers.)3 960 1 720 4320 t

3205: ( is transferred periodically, every)4 1361(In the modi\256ed protocol, the token)5 1433 2 720 4560 t

3206: 10 S f

3207: (t)3549 4560 w

3208: 7 I f

3209: (t)3604 4580 w

3210: 10 R f

3211: (seconds, and acknowledges all of)4 1373 1 3667 4560 t

3212: ( that were missed by the previous token)7 1703(the unacknowledged source messages, including any messages)6 2617 2 720 4680 t

3213: (sites. The)1 430 1 720 4800 t

3214: 10 I f

3215: (t)1197 4800 w

3216: 7 I f

3217: (th)1236 4760 w

3218: 10 R f

3219: ( of)1 131(token passing message can acknowledge a sequence)6 2215 2 1346 4800 t

3220: 10 I f

3221: (k)3740 4800 w

3222: 10 R f

3223: (source messages, where)2 1001 1 3832 4800 t

3224: 10 I f

3225: (k)4881 4800 w

3226: 10 R f

3227: (is)4973 4800 w

3228: ( messages are assigned sequence numbers)5 1676(variable. The)1 551 2 720 4920 t

3229: 10 I f

3230: (s)2972 4920 w

3231: 10 R f

3232: (to)3036 4920 w

3233: 10 I f

3234: (s)3139 4920 w

3235: 10 S f

3236: (+)3202 4920 w

3237: 10 I f

3238: (k)3273 4920 w

3239: 10 S f

3240: (-)3341 4920 w

3241: 10 R f

3242: (1.)3412 4920 w

3243: ( that the maximum token transfer rate may not be as fast as the message arrival rate)16 3390(In section 5.1 we show)4 930 2 720 5160 t

3244: ( occurs in the original RMP protocol the queue of messages that are)12 2731( this)1 173( When)1 291(in some of our applications.)4 1125 4 720 5280 t

3245: ( acknowledged grows and the latency before messages are acknowledged can become large.)12 3782(waiting to be)2 538 2 720 5400 t

3246: (Acknowledging multiple messages prevents this from happening.)6 2617 1 720 5520 t

3247: ( event driven)2 533( an)1 124( In)1 138(We can acknowledge multiple source messages without passing the token periodically.)10 3525 4 720 5760 t

3248: ( all of the waiting messages, or wait for the next message when there are no)15 3111(protocol we can acknowledge)3 1209 2 720 5880 t

3249: ( low)1 185( event driven protocol transmits fewer tokens when the message arrival rate is)12 3218( An)1 181(messages waiting.)1 736 4 720 6000 t

3250: (and acknowledges source messages sooner when the message arrival rate is high.)11 3242 1 720 6120 t

3251: ( start)1 204( To)1 168( token transfers have compelling advantages for the stock market applications.)10 3200(However, periodic)1 748 4 720 6360 t

3252: ( deterministic times to recover missing messages, detect failed)8 2550(with, periodic token transfers provide more)5 1770 2 720 6480 t

3253: ( times are more deterministic)4 1193( The)1 212( guarantee that all of the sites have received a message.)10 2272(receivers and to)2 643 4 720 6600 t

3254: ( instead of)2 446(because we detect missing acknowledgments when their scheduled transmission time passes,)10 3874 2 720 6720 t

3255: ( next acknowledgement is initiated by the arrival)7 1992( The)1 211( we receive the next acknowledgement.)5 1603(waiting until)1 514 4 720 6840 t

3256: (of the next source message, which is a random variable that may be long relative to the token transfer time.)19 4278 1 720 6960 t

3257: ( fair, all or the)4 576(In section 5.1 we show that a periodic token transfer system is)11 2496 2 720 7200 t

3258: 10 I f

3259: (R)3819 7200 w

3260: 7 I f

3261: (T)3891 7220 w

3262: 10 R f

3263: (remulticast them messages)2 1075 1 3965 7200 t

3264: (at the same time, when)4 990 1 720 7320 t

3265: 10 S f

3266: (D)1753 7320 w

3267: 7 I f

3268: (A)1825 7340 w

3269: 10 S f

3270: (> t)1 115 1 1892 7320 t

3271: 7 I f

3272: (t)2018 7340 w

3273: 10 R f

3274: ( protocol there is a)4 811( the original RMP)3 774( In)1 151(, just one token transfer time.)5 1258 4 2046 7320 t

3275: ( that a receiver)3 598(relationship between the number of token passes, up to a complete cycle, and the probability)14 3722 2 720 7440 t

3276: cleartomark

3277: showpage

3278: saveobj restore

3279: end

3280: %%EndPage: 11 11

3281: %%Page: 12 12

3282: DpostDict begin

3283: /saveobj save def

3284: mark

3285: 12 pagesetup

3286: 10 R f

3287: (- 12 -)2 216 1 2772 480 t

3288: ( we delay delivery, we can guarantee a higher probability of simultaneous)11 3334( When)1 324(has a message.)2 662 3 720 960 t

3289: (remulticast, but cannot guarantee fairness.)4 1685 1 720 1080 t

3290: (A secondary advantage of periodic token transfers is that the other)10 2769 1 720 1320 t

3291: 10 I f

3292: (R)3526 1320 w

3293: 7 I f

3294: (T)3598 1340 w

3295: 10 R f

3296: (detect a failed token site when a)6 1358 1 3682 1320 t

3297: ( do not have to wait for a source to complain that it is unable to elicit an)17 2889( We)1 189(token isn't transferred on time.)4 1242 3 720 1440 t

3298: ( sources makes it)3 754( failure detection and reporting responsibility from the)7 2326(acknowledgement. Removing)1 1240 3 720 1560 t

3299: ( section 7 we show that this can be an important)10 2210( In)1 162( operate with less trusted sources.)5 1487(possible to)1 461 4 720 1680 t

3300: (characteristic in an environment where all trading \257oors are not equally trusted.)11 3177 1 720 1800 t

3301: ( has mechanisms)2 685( RMP)1 266( in reliable multicast systems.)4 1202(NACK implosion is considered an important problem)6 2167 4 720 2040 t

3302: ( architecture)1 508( Our)1 218( available to other reliable multicast protocols.)6 1934(to reduce NACK implosion that are not)6 1660 4 720 2160 t

3303: ( reduction mechanisms)2 949(reduces NACK implosion to the point where it is not a problem, and the NACK)14 3371 2 720 2280 t

3304: ( section 5.3 we describe the reduction)6 1619( In)1 152( in the current stock market applications.)6 1742(should not be used)3 807 4 720 2400 t

3305: (mechanisms in case NACK implosion becomes a problem in a future system.)11 3091 1 720 2520 t

3306: %INFO[SECTION: LEVEL = 2, NUMBER = 5.1  , HEADING = Delay - Fairness and Latency]

3307: 9 B f

3308: ( - Fairness and Latency)4 902(5.1 Delay)1 379 2 720 2820 t

3309: 10 R f

3310: (The original RMP protocol was event driven.)6 1824 1 720 3120 t

3311: 10 S f

3312: (D)2596 3120 w

3313: 7 I f

3314: (A)2668 3140 w

3315: 10 R f

3316: ( is transmitted there is)4 895(seconds after an acknowledgement)3 1399 2 2746 3120 t

3317: ( a receiver that missed the acknowledgement is still unaware of the fact that the)14 3577(a probability that)2 743 2 720 3240 t

3318: ( missed acknowledgement)2 1074( probability that the receiver is unaware of a)8 1834( The)1 214(acknowledgement is missing.)2 1198 4 720 3360 t

3319: 10 S f

3320: (D)720 3480 w

3321: 7 I f

3322: (A)792 3500 w

3323: 10 R f

3324: ( been)1 228(seconds after it occurs is a function of the number of additional acknowledgements that have)14 3928 2 884 3480 t

3325: ( the subsequent acknowledgements to remain unaware of the)8 2596( receiver must miss all of)5 1107(transmitted. A)1 617 3 720 3600 t

3326: ( number of additional acknowledgements that are transmitted in an interval of)11 3109( The)1 205(original loss.)1 517 3 720 3720 t

3327: 10 S f

3328: (D)4576 3720 w

3329: 7 I f

3330: (A)4648 3740 w

3331: 10 R f

3332: (seconds)4724 3720 w

3333: ( we wait, the more likely it is that a receiver detects and recovers)13 2614( longer)1 281( The)1 206(is a variable, and may be zero.)6 1219 4 720 3840 t

3334: ( there is a tradeoff between delay and fairness.)8 1852( Therefore,)1 467(a missing message.)2 769 3 720 3960 t

3335: ( we)1 154( can state that, when)4 860( We)1 200(In the modi\256ed, time driven protocol we can make a much stronger claim.)12 3106 4 720 4200 t

3336: (make)720 4320 w

3337: 10 S f

3338: (D)962 4320 w

3339: 7 I f

3340: (A)1034 4340 w

3341: 10 R f

3342: ( then all operable receivers will recover the message before)9 2367(suf\256ciently large)1 675 2 1111 4320 t

3343: 10 S f

3344: (D)4178 4320 w

3345: 7 I f

3346: (A)4250 4340 w

3347: 10 R f

3348: (or the system will)3 714 1 4326 4320 t

3349: ( the token)2 396( statement isn't as strong as the guarantees that are provided by circulating)12 2978( This)1 228(be in reformation.)2 718 4 720 4440 t

3350: (around the entire loop, but we will show that)8 1790 1 720 4560 t

3351: 10 S f

3352: (D)2535 4560 w

3353: 7 I f

3354: (A)2607 4580 w

3355: 10 R f

3356: (is much smaller than the time to circulate the token.)9 2070 1 2683 4560 t

3357: ( Make)1 280(The token passing message is scheduled at a particular time.)9 2434 2 720 4800 t

3358: 10 S f

3359: (D)3462 4800 w

3360: 7 I f

3361: (A)3534 4820 w

3362: 10 R f

3363: ( to either)2 363(long enough for a receiver)4 1064 2 3613 4800 t

3364: ( upon its late arrival, recover that message, then recover)9 2320(detect the missing token passing message, based)6 2000 2 720 4920 t

3365: ( When)1 293(any missing source messages that were acknowledged, or start a reformation process.)11 3461 2 720 5040 t

3366: 10 S f

3367: (D)4504 5040 w

3368: 7 I f

3369: (A)4576 5060 w

3370: 10 R f

3371: ( least)1 214(is at)1 169 2 4657 5040 t

3372: (this long, every)2 631 1 720 5160 t

3373: 10 I f

3374: (R)1382 5160 w

3375: 7 I f

3376: (T)1454 5180 w

3377: 10 R f

3378: ( system)1 308(either has the acknowledged message and remulticasts it simultaneously or the)10 3200 2 1532 5160 t

3379: (is being reformed.)2 729 1 720 5280 t

3380: (At)720 5520 w

3381: 10 S f

3382: (d)858 5520 w

3383: 7 I f

3384: (N)918 5540 w

3385: 10 R f

3386: ( infer that they have missed the token passing)8 1932(after a scheduled token passing message, receivers)6 2097 2 1011 5520 t

3387: ( be very)2 329( delay in packet networks is a random variable and can)10 2239( The)1 210(message and request a retransmission.)4 1542 4 720 5640 t

3388: (long.)720 5760 w

3389: 10 S f

3390: (d)993 5760 w

3391: 7 I f

3392: (N)1053 5780 w

3393: 10 R f

3394: ( long enough to guarantee that a reasonable fraction of the messages, not all of the)15 3597(is only)1 290 2 1153 5760 t

3395: ( penalty for not making)4 942( The)1 206(messages, are received.)2 937 3 720 5880 t

3396: 10 S f

3397: (d)2831 5880 w

3398: 7 I f

3399: (N)2891 5900 w

3400: 10 R f

3401: ( of the messages are extra)5 1027(long enough to receive all)4 1041 2 2972 5880 t

3402: (requests and retransmissions.)2 1168 1 720 6000 t

3403: ( token passing messages and source messages are recovered with a positive acknowledgement)12 3962(Both the)1 358 2 720 6240 t

3404: ( the request at regular intervals,)5 1353( resend)1 305(protocol. We)1 566 3 720 6360 t

3405: 10 S f

3406: (t)2988 6360 w

3407: 7 I f

3408: (r)3043 6380 w

3409: 10 R f

3410: (, and declare the system inoperable if after)7 1828 1 3078 6360 t

3411: 10 I f

3412: (k)4950 6360 w

3413: 7 I f

3414: (r)5005 6380 w

3415: 10 R f

3416: ( after)1 213( Therefore,)1 472(attempts the request is not answered.)5 1495 3 720 6480 t

3417: 10 S f

3418: (d)2931 6480 w

3419: 7 I f

3420: (N)2991 6500 w

3421: 10 S f

3422: (+)3062 6480 w

3423: 10 R f

3424: (2)3133 6480 w

3425: 10 I f

3426: (k)3191 6480 w

3427: 7 I f

3428: (r)3246 6500 w

3429: 10 S f

3430: (t)3289 6480 w

3431: 7 I f

3432: (r)3344 6500 w

3433: 10 R f

3434: (a receiver either has the source message)6 1630 1 3410 6480 t

3435: ( interval)1 340( The)1 215( has declared the system inoperable and asked for a reformation.)10 2668(that was acknowledged, or)3 1097 4 720 6600 t

3436: ( 2)1 81(between requests is at least)4 1101 2 720 6720 t

3437: 10 S f

3438: (d)1910 6720 w

3439: 7 I f

3440: (N)1970 6740 w

3441: 10 S f

3442: (+)2041 6720 w

3443: 10 I f

3444: (X)2112 6720 w

3445: 10 S f

3446: (+)2197 6720 w

3447: 10 I f

3448: (P)2268 6720 w

3449: 10 R f

3450: (, where)1 299 1 2329 6720 t

3451: 10 I f

3452: (X)2659 6720 w

3453: 10 R f

3454: (is the time to transmit the request and response and)9 2099 1 2751 6720 t

3455: 10 I f

3456: (P)4881 6720 w

3457: 10 R f

3458: (is)4973 6720 w

3459: (the time to process the request and response.)7 1780 1 720 6840 t

3460: ( for the token site to)5 817( order)1 237( In)1 135(There is an underlying assumption that token sites transmit the token on time.)12 3131 4 720 7080 t

3461: (always have the token before it is scheduled to transfer it, the time between token transfers,)15 3645 1 720 7200 t

3462: 10 S f

3463: (t)4390 7200 w

3464: 7 I f

3465: (t)4445 7220 w

3466: 10 R f

3467: (, must be long)3 567 1 4473 7200 t

3468: ( to determine that the token transfer message was lost, recover that message, then)13 3311(enough for the token site)4 1009 2 720 7320 t

3469: ( Therefore,)1 498(recover any source messages that are missing.)6 2023 2 720 7440 t

3470: 10 S f

3471: (t)3297 7440 w

3472: 7 I f

3473: (t)3352 7460 w

3474: 10 S f

3475: (\263 d)1 145 1 3421 7440 t

3476: 7 I f

3477: (N)3577 7460 w

3478: 10 S f

3479: (+)3648 7440 w

3480: 10 R f

3481: (2)3719 7440 w

3482: 10 I f

3483: (k)3777 7440 w

3484: 7 I f

3485: (r)3832 7460 w

3486: 10 S f

3487: (t)3875 7440 w

3488: 7 I f

3489: (r)3930 7460 w

3490: 10 R f

3491: (\()4006 7440 w

3492: 10 S f

3493: (= D)1 165 1 4055 7440 t

3494: 7 I f

3495: (A)4231 7460 w

3496: 10 R f

3497: ( is)1 122( system)1 334(\). The)1 294 3 4290 7440 t

3498: cleartomark

3499: showpage

3500: saveobj restore

3501: end

3502: %%EndPage: 12 12

3503: %%Page: 13 13

3504: DpostDict begin

3505: /saveobj save def

3506: mark

3507: 13 pagesetup

3508: 10 R f

3509: (- 13 -)2 216 1 2772 480 t

3510: (completely fair as long as the)5 1243 1 720 960 t

3511: 10 I f

3512: (R)2002 960 w

3513: 7 I f

3514: (T)2074 980 w

3515: 10 R f

3516: (wait one token passing time after the message is timestamped before)10 2880 1 2160 960 t

3517: (remulticasting it.)1 678 1 720 1080 t

3518: (The token passing time can be calculated as)7 1973 1 720 1320 t

3519: 10 S f

3520: (t)2750 1320 w

3521: 7 I f

3522: (t)2805 1340 w

3523: 10 S f

3524: (=)2882 1320 w

3525: 10 R f

3526: (\( 1)1 91 1 2986 1320 t

3527: 10 S f

3528: (+)3093 1320 w

3529: 10 R f

3530: (2)3164 1320 w

3531: 10 I f

3532: (k)3222 1320 w

3533: 7 I f

3534: (r)3277 1340 w

3535: 10 R f

3536: (\))3320 1320 w

3537: 10 S f

3538: (d)3369 1320 w

3539: 7 I f

3540: (N)3429 1340 w

3541: 10 S f

3542: (+)3500 1320 w

3543: 10 I f

3544: (k)3571 1320 w

3545: 7 I f

3546: (r)3626 1340 w

3547: 10 R f

3548: (\()3669 1320 w

3549: 10 I f

3550: (X)3710 1320 w

3551: 10 S f

3552: (+)3795 1320 w

3553: 10 I f

3554: (P)3866 1320 w

3555: 10 R f

3556: (\).)3935 1320 w

3557: 10 S f

3558: (d)4075 1320 w

3559: 7 I f

3560: (N)4135 1340 w

3561: 10 R f

3562: (is the sum of the)4 793 1 4247 1320 t

3563: ( a source and receiver plus the router delays for our "reasonable fraction of the)14 3229(propagation delay between)2 1091 2 720 1440 t

3564: ( Therefore,)1 471( miles.)1 271( circumference of the earth is about 25,000)7 1733(messages." The)1 651 4 720 1560 t

3565: 10 S f

3566: (d)3875 1560 w

3567: 7 I f

3568: (N)3935 1580 w

3569: 10 R f

3570: (should be on the order of)5 1021 1 4019 1560 t

3571: ( of the stock)3 524( backbone)1 419( The)1 217(75 milliseconds to allow the signal to propagate half way around the world.)12 3160 4 720 1680 t

3572: ( bandwidth and is not subject to the large delays)9 1932(market network, where RMP is implemented, has dedicated)7 2388 2 720 1800 t

3573: ( have priority over new source)5 1316( addition, control messages should)4 1464( In)1 154(that occur in the public Internet.)5 1386 4 720 1920 t

3574: ( on a path can probably be kept to a few hundred milliseconds.)12 2636( "reasonable" router delay)3 1067(messages. The)1 617 3 720 2040 t

3575: ( Therefore,)1 473(The processors in the network are dedicated to this application.)9 2577 2 720 2160 t

3576: 10 I f

3577: (P)3801 2160 w

3578: 10 R f

3579: (can be kept to a few 10's of)7 1147 1 3893 2160 t

3580: ( relative to \256le transfers, and the)6 1361( source and control messages in the system are short,)9 2212(milliseconds. The)1 747 3 720 2280 t

3581: ( Therefore,)1 484(backbone is a high rate, multi-megabit per second transmission facility.)9 3008 2 720 2400 t

3582: 10 I f

3583: (X)4254 2400 w

3584: 10 R f

3585: ( In)1 149(is negligible.)1 534 2 4357 2400 t

3586: (typical protocols,)1 694 1 720 2520 t

3587: 10 I f

3588: (k)1439 2520 w

3589: 7 I f

3590: (r)1494 2540 w

3591: 10 S f

3592: (=)1545 2520 w

3593: 10 R f

3594: ( stock market)2 540( In)1 134( 3 seconds.)2 443( these parameters, the token transfer time is about)8 1982(3. With)1 325 5 1616 2520 t

3595: ( peak)1 227(systems we expect many more than one new source message every 3 seconds, particularly during)14 4093 2 720 2640 t

3596: ( messages with the same token passing)6 1680( shows the need to acknowledge multiple source)7 2073(periods. This)1 567 3 720 2760 t

3597: (message.)720 2880 w

3598: %INFO[SECTION: LEVEL = 2, NUMBER = 5.2  , HEADING = NACK Reduction]

3599: 9 B f

3600: ( Reduction)1 418(5.2 NACK)1 424 2 720 3180 t

3601: 10 R f

3602: ( is to limit the subset)5 862(The standard mechanism for reducing NACK implosion in reliable multicast systems)10 3458 2 720 3480 t

3603: ( In)1 135( the receivers.)2 560(of receivers that request a missing message, but to multicast the missing message to all of)15 3625 3 720 3600 t

3604: ( time different subsets of receivers can request the missing message until all of the)14 3387(subsequent intervals of)2 933 2 720 3720 t

3605: ( a receiver requests a message and a receiver that is scheduled to)12 2731( If)1 129( opportunity.)1 530(receivers have had the)3 930 4 720 3840 t

3606: ( does not request the)4 921(request the message in a later interval receives the multicast, the later receiver)12 3399 2 720 3960 t

3607: ( strategy is particularly appropriate in the)6 1749( This)1 246(retransmission, and the number of NACK's is reduced.)7 2325 3 720 4080 t

3608: (Internet where the multicast is transmitted on a tree and many receivers miss the same message.)15 3826 1 720 4200 t

3609: ( Therefore,)1 477( the token must have all of the source message.)9 1970(In the RMP protocol the receiver that accepts)7 1873 3 720 4440 t

3610: ( receivers that request missing messages, we must guarantee that a receiver has)12 3240(when we de\256ne subsets of)4 1080 2 720 4560 t

3611: (an opportunity to recover a missing message before it becomes the token site.)12 3098 1 720 4680 t

3612: ( have one receiver in each)5 1117(The simplest and most economical method of de\256ning subsets in RMP is to)12 3203 2 720 4920 t

3613: ( it becomes the token site,)5 1053( receiver can only request missing messages before)7 2070( A)1 126(subset, the next token site.)4 1071 4 720 5040 t

3614: ( can recover any message that was also missed by a preceding token)12 2841(but, before becoming the token site,)5 1479 2 720 5160 t

3615: ( approach is that a site may have to wait an entire token rotation before it)15 3004( disadvantage with this)3 940(site. The)1 376 3 720 5280 t

3616: (can recover a missing message.)4 1255 1 720 5400 t

3617: ( site can recover a missing message, we give several sites the opportunity)12 2967(In order to reduce the time until a)7 1353 2 720 5640 t

3618: ( around the token ring to minimize the)7 1612( space those sites equidistant)4 1197( We)1 200(to request the missing message.)4 1311 4 720 5760 t

3619: ( token)1 248( If)1 117( missing message.)2 727(maximum time until a receiver can request a)7 1777 4 720 5880 t

3620: 10 I f

3621: (t)3615 5880 w

3622: 10 R f

3623: (is sent by receiver)3 726 1 3669 5880 t

3624: 10 I f

3625: (r)4421 5880 w

3626: 10 R f

3627: (, de\256ne sets of)3 580 1 4460 5880 t

3628: (receivers)720 6085 w

3629: 10 I f

3630: (S)1111 6085 w

3631: 7 I f

3632: (i)1172 6105 w

3633: 7 R f

3634: (,)1197 6105 w

3635: 7 I f

3636: (t)1220 6105 w

3637: 10 S f

3638: (=)1297 6085 w

3639: (\354)1409 5998 w

3640: (\355)1409 6098 w

3641: (\356)1409 6198 w

3642: 10 R f

3643: (\()1458 6085 w

3644: 10 I f

3645: (r)1499 6085 w

3646: 10 S f

3647: (+)1562 6085 w

3648: 10 I f

3649: (i)1633 6085 w

3650: 10 S f

3651: (+)1685 6085 w

3652: 10 R f

3653: (1)1756 6085 w

3654: 10 S f

3655: (+)1822 6085 w

3656: 10 I f

3657: (j * k)2 138 1 1893 6085 t

3658: 7 I f

3659: (p)2042 6105 w

3660: 10 R f

3661: (\) mod)1 227 1 2093 6085 t

3662: 10 I f

3663: (m)2361 6085 w

3664: 10 R f

3665: (for 0)1 207 1 2474 6085 t

3666: 10 S f

3667: (\243)2697 6085 w

3668: 10 I f

3669: (j)2768 6085 w

3670: 10 S f

3671: (\243)2812 6085 w

3672: 10 R f

3673: (\()2883 6085 w

3674: 10 I f

3675: (m)2924 6085 w

3676: 10 S f

3677: (-)3020 6085 w

3678: 10 I f

3679: (i)3091 6085 w

3680: 10 S f

3681: (-)3143 6085 w

3682: 10 R f

3683: (1 \))1 91 1 3214 6085 t

3684: 10 I f

3685: (/ k)1 80 1 3313 6085 t

3686: 7 I f

3687: (p)3404 6105 w

3688: 10 S f

3689: (\374)3447 5998 w

3690: (\375)3447 6098 w

3691: (\376)3447 6198 w

3692: 10 R f

3693: (, for)1 173 1 3496 6085 t

3694: 10 I f

3695: (i)3710 6085 w

3696: 10 S f

3697: (=)3762 6085 w

3698: 10 R f

3699: (0 , 1 ,... ,)4 282 1 3833 6085 t

3700: 10 I f

3701: (k)4123 6085 w

3702: 7 I f

3703: (p)4178 6105 w

3704: 10 S f

3705: (-)4237 6085 w

3706: 10 R f

3707: ( there are)2 382(1, where)1 350 2 4308 6085 t

3708: 10 I f

3709: (m)720 6310 w

3710: 10 R f

3711: ( 0 to)2 208(receivers numbered)1 797 2 831 6310 t

3712: 10 I f

3713: (m)1876 6310 w

3714: 10 S f

3715: (-)1972 6310 w

3716: 10 R f

3717: ( a receiver in)3 562( After)1 275(1 in the token group.)4 890 3 2043 6310 t

3718: 10 I f

3719: (S)3810 6310 w

3720: 7 I f

3721: (i)3871 6330 w

3722: 7 R f

3723: (,)3896 6330 w

3724: 7 I f

3725: (t)3919 6330 w

3726: 10 R f

3727: (receives token)1 588 1 3987 6310 t

3728: 10 I f

3729: (t)4615 6310 w

3730: 10 S f

3731: (+)4667 6310 w

3732: 10 I f

3733: (i)4738 6310 w

3734: 10 R f

3735: (it can)1 234 1 4806 6310 t

3736: (request the message acknowledged by)4 1588 1 720 6430 t

3737: 10 I f

3738: (t)2349 6430 w

3739: 10 R f

3740: ( this assignment, every receiver can)5 1499( With)1 265( is still missing.)3 675(, if it)2 224 4 2377 6430 t

3741: (request a missing message within)4 1338 1 720 6550 t

3742: 10 I f

3743: (k)2083 6550 w

3744: 7 I f

3745: (p)2138 6570 w

3746: 10 R f

3747: (token passes.)1 527 1 2206 6550 t

3748: (If)720 6790 w

3749: 10 I f

3750: (m / k)2 160 1 816 6790 t

3751: 7 I f

3752: (p)987 6810 w

3753: 10 R f

3754: (is an integer, each receiver requests any missing messages in the interval it is scheduled to accept)16 3980 1 1060 6790 t

3755: (the token, and every)3 824 1 720 6910 t

3756: 10 I f

3757: (k)1574 6910 w

3758: 7 I f

3759: (p)1623 6929 w

3760: (th)1623 6870 w

3761: 10 R f

3762: ( the other \()3 447( In)1 137(interval after that.)2 720 3 1715 6910 t

3763: 10 I f

3764: (k)3027 6910 w

3765: 7 I f

3766: (p)3082 6930 w

3767: 10 S f

3768: (-)3141 6910 w

3769: 10 R f

3770: (1 \))1 91 1 3212 6910 t

3771: 7 I f

3772: (th)3314 6870 w

3773: 10 R f

3774: (intervals, the receiver listens in case one)6 1634 1 3406 6910 t

3775: (of its missing messages is recovered by one of the other receivers.)11 2639 1 720 7030 t

3776: ( a missing message if a receiver in an earlier set requests)11 2313(Since the receivers in the later sets do not request)9 2007 2 720 7270 t

3777: (the same message and the retransmission is received, the average number of requests for retransmission is)15 4320 1 720 7390 t

3778: cleartomark

3779: showpage

3780: saveobj restore

3781: end

3782: %%EndPage: 13 13

3783: %%Page: 14 14

3784: DpostDict begin

3785: /saveobj save def

3786: mark

3787: 14 pagesetup

3788: 10 R f

3789: (- 14 -)2 216 1 2772 480 t

3790: ( sites that miss the message than there are sets, we can)11 2256( on the average, there are more)6 1273( If,)1 148(clearly reduced.)1 643 4 720 960 t

3791: ( average number of requests by putting fewer receivers in the sets that make the initial)15 3590(further reduce the)2 730 2 720 1080 t

3792: ( should "tune" the number of receivers in each set so)10 2150( We)1 193( requests.)1 382(requests than in the sets that make later)7 1595 4 720 1200 t

3793: ( can also reduce the number)5 1121( We)1 189( same in each subset.)4 844(that, on the average, the probability of a request is the)10 2166 4 720 1320 t

3794: ( by placing receivers in different sets if they are likely, because of their positions on the original)17 3883(of requests)1 437 2 720 1440 t

3795: (multicast tree, to miss the same messages.)6 1682 1 720 1560 t

3796: ( NACK is that it increases the delay until a)9 1748(A problem with limiting the number of receivers that transmit a)10 2572 2 720 1800 t

3797: ( we have to wait for)5 845( the stock market application)4 1198( In)1 144(missing message may be acquired.)4 1428 4 720 1920 t

3798: 10 I f

3799: (k)4370 1920 w

3800: 7 I f

3801: (p)4425 1940 w

3802: 10 R f

3803: (token passes,)1 537 1 4503 1920 t

3804: ( NACK reduction increases)3 1100( Since)1 272(instead of one, for complete fairness.)5 1477 3 720 2040 t

3805: 10 S f

3806: (D)3594 2040 w

3807: 7 I f

3808: (A)3666 2060 w

3809: 10 R f

3810: ( market applications,)2 837(in the stock)2 461 2 3742 2040 t

3811: ( for recovering)2 604( a different application we may replace fairness with a penalty)10 2552( In)1 140(we do not recommend it.)4 1024 4 720 2160 t

3812: ( this type of an application, NACK reduction may be bene\256cial.)10 2552( In)1 133(the message later.)2 712 3 720 2280 t

3813: %INFO[SECTION: LEVEL = 1, NUMBER = 6.  , HEADING = Security]

3814: 9 B f

3815: (6. Security)1 434 1 720 2640 t

3816: 10 R f

3817: ( and)1 195( application)1 470(The security issues are among the biggest differences between the the Internet stock market)13 3655 3 720 2820 t

3818: ( section 3 we identi\256ed the following security concerns:)8 2236( In)1 133(the local network database.)3 1086 3 720 2940 t

3819: ( transmission access to authorized sources,)5 1708(1. constraining)1 669 2 795 3120 t

3820: ( early reception of the data stream,)6 1382(2. preventing)1 602 2 795 3300 t

3821: ( reception to authorized receivers,)4 1354(3. limiting)1 493 2 795 3480 t

3822: ( or adding to the repaired sequence, and)7 1590(4. spoo\256ng)1 520 2 795 3660 t

3823: ( of service.)2 440(5. denial)1 419 2 795 3840 t

3824: (The global multicast group,)3 1132 1 720 4080 t

3825: 10 I f

3826: (G)1886 4080 w

3827: 7 I f

3828: (M)1969 4100 w

3829: 10 R f

3830: (, includes)1 392 1 2035 4080 t

3831: 10 I f

3832: (S)2461 4080 w

3833: 7 I f

3834: (P)2522 4100 w

3835: 10 R f

3836: (,)2573 4080 w

3837: 10 I f

3838: (R)2632 4080 w

3839: 7 I f

3840: (P)2704 4100 w

3841: 10 R f

3842: (,)2755 4080 w

3843: 10 I f

3844: (R)2814 4080 w

3845: 7 I f

3846: (S)2886 4100 w

3847: 10 R f

3848: (and)2963 4080 w

3849: 10 I f

3850: (R)3141 4080 w

3851: 7 I f

3852: (x)3213 4100 w

3853: 10 R f

3854: ( that a source)3 559( \256rst security concern is)4 990(. Our)1 239 3 3252 4080 t

3855: ( The)1 206( in the sequence of messages that are remulticast.)8 1973(outside our set will transmit messages that are placed)8 2141 3 720 4200 t

3856: (messages in)1 488 1 720 4320 t

3857: 10 I f

3858: (G)1241 4320 w

3859: 7 I f

3860: (M)1324 4340 w

3861: 10 R f

3862: (are delayed before they are remulticast to)6 1698 1 1423 4320 t

3863: 10 I f

3864: (R)3154 4320 w

3865: 10 R f

3866: ( receivers get the messages)4 1116(so that all of the)4 676 2 3248 4320 t

3867: ( members of the)3 646(simultaneously. The)1 836 2 720 4440 t

3868: 10 I f

3869: (R)2252 4440 w

3870: 7 I f

3871: (T)2324 4460 w

3872: 10 R f

3873: ( second concern)2 642( Our)1 205(are trusted not to divulge the messages early.)7 1797 3 2396 4440 t

3874: (is that an unauthorized receiver will eavesdrop on)7 1987 1 720 4560 t

3875: 10 I f

3876: (G)2732 4560 w

3877: 7 I f

3878: (M)2815 4580 w

3879: 10 R f

3880: (.)2881 4560 w

3881: ( our)1 163( In)1 138(We address the \256rst two concerns with a combination of cryptographic and networking techniques.)13 4019 3 720 4800 t

3882: ( a few hundred)3 607(architecture there are only)3 1058 2 720 4920 t

3883: 10 I f

3884: (S)2414 4920 w

3885: 7 I f

3886: (P)2475 4940 w

3887: 10 R f

3888: ( can operate)2 489(. We)1 217 2 2526 4920 t

3889: 10 I f

3890: (G)3261 4920 w

3891: 7 I f

3892: (M)3344 4940 w

3893: 10 R f

3894: (on a public network if each)5 1109 1 3439 4920 t

3895: 10 I f

3896: (S)4577 4920 w

3897: 7 I f

3898: (P)4638 4940 w

3899: 10 R f

3900: (shares a)1 322 1 4718 4920 t

3901: (secret key with the group of)5 1162 1 720 5040 t

3902: 10 I f

3903: (R)1916 5040 w

3904: 7 I f

3905: (T)1988 5060 w

3906: 10 R f

3907: ( each)1 216( If)1 125(and encrypt its messages.)3 1042 3 2069 5040 t

3908: 10 I f

3909: (S)3486 5040 w

3910: 7 I f

3911: (P)3547 5060 w

3912: 10 R f

3913: (has a different key, the encryption)5 1408 1 3632 5040 t

3914: ( can also operate)3 697( We)1 199(also identi\256es the source, and hides messages from other sources.)9 2714 3 720 5160 t

3915: 10 I f

3916: (G)4365 5160 w

3917: 7 I f

3918: (M)4448 5180 w

3919: 10 R f

3920: (on a private)2 491 1 4549 5160 t

3921: (network, and use \256rewalls to prevent unauthorized transmitters and receivers.)9 3096 1 720 5280 t

3922: ( the advantage that the bandwidth of the backbone network is not shared with)13 3131(The networking approach has)3 1189 2 720 5520 t

3923: ( addition, a network with restricted access reduces the threat)9 2441( In)1 137(the public network, and can be guaranteed.)6 1742 3 720 5640 t

3924: ( type of)2 319(of denial of service attacks since those with legitimate access to the resources have obtained some)15 4001 2 720 5760 t

3925: ( with a separate secret for each source, has the advantage that the)12 2666( cryptographic approach,)2 1008(approval. A)1 503 3 720 5880 t

3926: 10 I f

3927: (S)4928 5880 w

3928: 7 I f

3929: (P)4989 5900 w

3930: 10 R f

3931: ( do not have)3 500( We)1 191( the same degree as when they transmit in the clear on a private network.)14 2949(are not trusted to)3 680 4 720 6000 t

3932: ( from using or redistributing the messages from other sources.)9 2570(to trust the sources to refrain)5 1200 2 720 6120 t

3933: 10 I f

3934: (G)4550 6120 w

3935: 7 I f

3936: (M)4633 6140 w

3937: 10 R f

3938: (can use)1 306 1 4734 6120 t

3939: ( multicast and a shared secret that is different for)9 2065(both mechanisms: A private network for the backbone)7 2255 2 720 6240 t

3940: (each source.)1 492 1 720 6360 t

3941: (Our third concern is to restrict access to the data that is remulticast by the)14 3032 1 720 6600 t

3942: 10 I f

3943: (R)3784 6600 w

3944: 7 I f

3945: (T)3856 6620 w

3946: 10 R f

3947: ( electronic stock)2 670( are)1 153(. There)1 314 3 3903 6600 t

3948: ( the)1 156(markets, like NASDAQ, that require)4 1504 2 720 6720 t

3949: 10 I f

3950: (R)2414 6720 w

3951: 10 R f

3952: ( objective is to make our)5 1030( Our)1 214(to be part of a private network.)6 1287 3 2509 6720 t

3953: ( general population, less expensively, by using the public Internet to connect the)12 3243(system accessible to the)3 963 2 720 6840 t

3954: 10 I f

3955: (R)4954 6840 w

3956: 10 R f

3957: (.)5015 6840 w

3958: (This does not prevent some participants from having dedicated connections.)9 3040 1 720 6960 t

3959: (An)720 7200 w

3960: 10 I f

3961: (R)875 7200 w

3962: 7 I f

3963: (T)947 7220 w

3964: 10 R f

3965: ( the remulticast sequence away for free, to attract customers, or the)11 2772(, ISP, or stock market can give)6 1274 2 994 7200 t

3966: ( sell the multicast)3 748( order to)2 370( In)1 149(sequence can be sold by the month, like a subscription for a newspaper.)12 3053 4 720 7320 t

3967: (sequence on the public Internet, the)5 1519 1 720 7440 t

3968: 10 I f

3969: (R)2284 7440 w

3970: 7 I f

3971: (T)2356 7460 w

3972: 10 R f

3973: (decrypt the messages from the)4 1298 1 2449 7440 t

3974: 10 I f

3975: (S)3793 7440 w

3976: 7 I f

3977: (T)3854 7460 w

3978: 10 R f

3979: (, then re-encrypt the entire)4 1139 1 3901 7440 t

3980: cleartomark

3981: showpage

3982: saveobj restore

3983: end

3984: %%EndPage: 14 14

3985: %%Page: 15 15

3986: DpostDict begin

3987: /saveobj save def

3988: mark

3989: 15 pagesetup

3990: 10 R f

3991: (- 15 -)2 216 1 2772 480 t

3992: ( key is sold to each of the receivers,)8 1659( The)1 234(sequence with a new key.)4 1138 3 720 960 t

3993: 10 I f

3994: (R)3805 960 w

3995: 10 R f

3996: ( when the)2 444(, and is changed)3 730 2 3866 960 t

3997: (subscriptions expire.)1 827 1 720 1080 t

3998: ( of selling and distributing the remulticast key is similar to the problems encountered in other)15 3803(The problem)1 517 2 720 1320 t

3999: ( However,)1 445( information has limited value, in that the key can be bought.)11 2489( The)1 210(Internet distribution systems.)2 1176 4 720 1440 t

4000: ( problem has been addressed)4 1163( This)1 232( discourage someone who buys the key from giving it to others.)11 2586(we must)1 339 4 720 1560 t

4001: ( publishing experiment that also used Internet multicast)7 2253(in an earlier electronic)3 912 2 720 1680 t

4002: 7 R f

4003: (15 , 16)2 168 1 3890 1640 t

4004: 10 R f

4005: ( that experiment the)3 811(. In)1 163 2 4066 1680 t

4006: ( was sent to each subscriber when they paid for the service with their)13 2869(key was included in a program that)6 1451 2 720 1800 t

4007: ( away a copy of the)5 788( key is masked by the credit card number, so that a recipient who gives)14 2873( The)1 208(credit card.)1 451 4 720 1920 t

4008: ( this does)2 384( While)1 297( for the program to be useful.)6 1185(program must also give away his credit card number in order)10 2454 4 720 2040 t

4009: (not prevent a person from giving away the program, it should discourage him.)12 3118 1 720 2160 t

4010: ( malicious user)2 625( A)1 132( public Internet.)2 655(The \256nal two security concerns occur on the remulticast groups on the)11 2908 4 720 2400 t

4011: ( may \257ood the)3 605(may pretend to be the remulticast receiver and insert false messages into the sequence, or)14 3715 2 720 2520 t

4012: (multicast group to prevent others from receiving the repaired sequence.)9 2849 1 720 2640 t

4013: ( there are a)3 442( Since)1 273( cryptographic approach for dealing with pretenders is digital signatures.)9 2909(The conventional)1 696 4 720 2880 t

4014: ( receivers, the digital signature should use public key cryptography)9 2805(large number of untrusted)3 1079 2 720 3000 t

4015: 7 R f

4016: (17 , 18)2 168 1 4609 2960 t

4017: 10 R f

4018: ( a)1 83(. In)1 172 2 4785 3000 t

4019: ( that the)2 346(public key system only the remulticast source can sign the message, but any receiver can verify)15 3974 2 720 3120 t

4020: ( in)1 106( key systems require more computation than we would like to perform)11 2854( Public)1 310(message is legally signed.)3 1050 4 720 3240 t

4021: (this application.)1 639 1 720 3360 t

4022: ( assume that an attacker cannot remove multicast messages.)8 2403( We)1 190( in our system are numbered.)5 1169(The messages)1 558 4 720 3600 t

4023: ( tell which of the)4 741( cannot)1 308( We)1 205(We can therefore detect that messages have been added to the sequence.)11 3066 4 720 3720 t

4024: ( the)1 154(duplicate messages are real, but we can decide that some messages are forgeries and not act on any of)18 4166 2 720 3840 t

4025: (information.)720 3960 w

4026: ( by cryptographic)2 758(Flooding the multicast group to deny service to the receivers cannot be prevented)12 3562 2 720 4200 t

4027: ( group, we can eliminate illegal transmitters by)7 1916( there is only one source in our multicast)8 1674(techniques. Since)1 730 3 720 4320 t

4028: ( addition,)1 388( In)1 142(con\256guring routers to only multicast the signal from a particular source on a particular port.)14 3790 3 720 4440 t

4029: (assuming that \257ooding is illegal or at least discouraged by ISP's, it can eventually be stopped.)15 3756 1 720 4560 t

4030: %INFO[SECTION: LEVEL = 1, NUMBER = 7.  , HEADING = Applications]

4031: 9 B f

4032: (7. Applications)1 599 1 720 4920 t

4033: 10 R f

4034: (The three applications of the RMP protocol are)7 1883 1 720 5100 t

4035: ( uni\256ed ticker of the transactions on the physical and electronic trading \257oors,)12 3115(1. a)1 219 2 795 5280 t

4036: ( merged stream of buy and sell orders, and)8 1699(2. a)1 219 2 795 5460 t

4037: ( distributed trading \257oor.)3 1000(3. a)1 219 2 795 5640 t

4038: ( The)1 215( relatively small number of sources and a very large number of receivers.)12 3037(The \256rst application has a)4 1068 3 720 5760 t

4039: ( third)1 214( The)1 205( small number of receivers.)4 1089(second application has a very large number of sources and a relatively)11 2812 4 720 5880 t

4040: (application has the same number of sources and receivers, both of which may be large.)14 3464 1 720 6000 t

4041: ( is used to create a level playing)7 1327( RMP)1 269(In the \256rst two applications we are primarily interested in fairness.)10 2724 3 720 6240 t

4042: ( are also interested in the)5 1090( the third application we)4 1051( In)1 153(\256eld for investors independent of their location.)6 2026 4 720 6360 t

4043: ( of messages to every receiver, so that receivers can)9 2290(protocol's ability to provide the same sequence)6 2030 2 720 6480 t

4044: ( protocol's ability)2 721( are also interested in the)5 1025( we)1 172(independently determine which transactions have occurred.)5 2402 4 720 6600 t

4045: ( witnessed them, so that the)5 1245(to only commit transactions after a speci\256ed number of receivers have)10 3075 2 720 6720 t

4046: (transactions can survive system failures.)4 1611 1 720 6840 t

4047: %INFO[SECTION: LEVEL = 2, NUMBER = 7.1  , HEADING = Unified Ticker:]

4048: 9 B f

4049: ( Ticker:)1 308(7.1 Uni\256ed)1 439 2 720 7140 t

4050: 10 R f

4051: ( objective is to)3 610( The)1 213( receives a list of the trades on every trading \257oor.)10 2084(In the uni\256ed ticker every investor)5 1413 4 720 7320 t

4052: ( investors)1 394( The)1 213( of the investors have the same information on trades.)9 2213(create a level playing \256eld where all)6 1500 4 720 7440 t

4053: cleartomark

4054: showpage

4055: saveobj restore

4056: end

4057: %%EndPage: 15 15

4058: %%Page: 16 16

4059: DpostDict begin

4060: /saveobj save def

4061: mark

4062: 16 pagesetup

4063: 10 R f

4064: (- 16 -)2 216 1 2772 480 t

4065: (receive the list in the same order, at the same time, no matter where in the world they are located.)19 3886 1 720 960 t

4066: ( the RMP architecture,)3 928(The sources in)2 596 2 720 1200 t

4067: 10 I f

4068: (S)2277 1200 w

4069: 7 I f

4070: (P)2338 1220 w

4071: 10 R f

4072: ( trading \257oors operate independently)4 1502( The)1 213(, are the trading \257oors.)4 936 3 2389 1200 t

4073: ( may be physical places, others may be Internet servers, and still)11 2614( Some)1 283(under their own rules and customs.)5 1423 3 720 1320 t

4074: ( know the rules and)4 794( Investors)1 418(others may be the distributed trading \257oors described in the third application.)11 3108 3 720 1440 t

4075: (risks associated with the different trading \257oors and contact them directly or through a broker.)14 3763 1 720 1560 t

4076: ( multicast)1 395(There are a few hundred trading \257oors and they submit their list of trades directly to the the RMP)18 3925 2 720 1800 t

4077: ( network is a virtual private network and the trading \257oors are inside a \256rewall.)14 3248( core multicast)2 602(group. The)1 470 3 720 1920 t

4078: ( are trusted to place only an honest and timely)9 1992( They)1 272( \257oors are trusted to a certain extent.)7 1577(The trading)1 479 4 720 2040 t

4079: ( to divulge their own trades before they are)8 1774(accounting of their trades into the multicast sequence, and not)9 2546 2 720 2160 t

4080: ( that this degree of cooperation can be enforced by the regulatory)11 2623( assume)1 320( We)1 189(reported on the uni\256ed ticker.)4 1188 4 720 2280 t

4081: (agencies or by the fear of being excluded from the uni\256ed ticker.)11 2588 1 720 2400 t

4082: (Each trading \257oor shares a secret key with the group of receivers,)11 2736 1 720 2640 t

4083: 10 I f

4084: (R)3492 2640 w

4085: 7 I f

4086: (T)3564 2660 w

4087: 10 R f

4088: ( it)1 93(, and encrypts the messages that)5 1336 2 3611 2640 t

4089: ( encryption serves two functions: Firstly, it acts as a signature of the)12 2782( The)1 210( multicast sequence.)2 817(places in the)2 511 4 720 2760 t

4090: ( it reduces the degree of trust in trading \257oors, since)10 2247( Secondly,)1 464( the data.)2 397(trading \257oor that has entered)4 1212 4 720 2880 t

4091: ( second)1 302( The)1 205( it is available on the uni\256ed ticker.)7 1410(trading \257oors cannot acquire and use the information before)8 2403 4 720 3000 t

4092: ( \257oors are not all equals and different \257oors may be)10 2153(function is particularly important because the trading)6 2167 2 720 3120 t

4093: (under different international regulatory agencies, with different rules and penalties.)9 3317 1 720 3240 t

4094: (The multicast receivers,)2 966 1 720 3480 t

4095: 10 I f

4096: (R)1716 3480 w

4097: 7 I f

4098: (T)1788 3500 w

4099: 10 R f

4100: ( receivers,)1 415( primary)1 346( The)1 210(, are owned by the network operator.)6 1498 4 1835 3480 t

4101: 10 I f

4102: (R)4335 3480 w

4103: 7 I f

4104: (P)4407 3500 w

4105: 10 R f

4106: (, acknowledge)1 582 1 4458 3480 t

4107: ( At)1 177(and time stamp the source messages.)5 1605 2 720 3600 t

4108: 10 S f

4109: (D)2554 3600 w

4110: 7 I f

4111: (A)2626 3620 w

4112: 10 R f

4113: ( on the order of 3 seconds in an)8 1461(after the timestamp,)2 850 2 2729 3600 t

4114: (international system, either all of the)5 1675 1 720 3720 t

4115: 10 I f

4116: (R)2463 3720 w

4117: 7 I f

4118: (T)2535 3740 w

4119: 10 R f

4120: (have the acknowledged message, or the network has)7 2390 1 2650 3720 t

4121: ( of the)2 265( All)1 183( process.)1 354(malfunctioned and gone into the reformation)5 1819 4 720 3840 t

4122: 10 I f

4123: (R)3371 3840 w

4124: 7 I f

4125: (T)3443 3860 w

4126: 10 R f

4127: (decrypt a source message at the same)6 1520 1 3520 3840 t

4128: (time and remulticast that message in their regional areas.)8 2271 1 720 3960 t

4129: ( the uni\256ed ticker is)4 822( If)1 122(The regional multicasts may be outside the \256rewalls of the virtual private network.)12 3376 3 720 4200 t

4130: ( an ISP, it is)4 487(being sold, rather than provided as a free service to the receivers in a region or the customers of)18 3833 2 720 4320 t

4131: ( key is)2 271( This)1 233(re-encrypted with a secret key that is different from the key that is used by any of the sources.)18 3816 3 720 4440 t

4132: ( multicast in the)3 690( The)1 221(shared with all of the receivers in a region, as described in the previous section.)14 3409 3 720 4560 t

4133: ( options for dealing with these)5 1288( The)1 220( service attacks.)2 664(regional area is susceptible to spoo\256ng or denial of)8 2148 4 720 4680 t

4134: (threats are also described in section 6.)6 1516 1 720 4800 t

4135: ( receiver,)1 375( A)1 127(The messages in the regional multicast may be lost.)8 2102 3 720 5040 t

4136: 10 I f

4137: (R)3354 5040 w

4138: 10 R f

4139: ( missing)1 343(, can detect a lost message by a)7 1282 2 3415 5040 t

4140: ( can colocate a retransmit server,)5 1337( We)1 193(sequence number.)1 725 3 720 5160 t

4141: 10 I f

4142: (R)3005 5160 w

4143: 7 I f

4144: (x)3077 5180 w

4145: 10 R f

4146: (, at an)2 251 1 3116 5160 t

4147: 10 I f

4148: (R)3397 5160 w

4149: 7 I f

4150: (T)3469 5180 w

4151: 10 R f

4152: (. When)1 318 1 3516 5160 t

4153: 10 I f

4154: (R)3864 5160 w

4155: 10 R f

4156: (detects a missing sequence)3 1085 1 3955 5160 t

4157: (number, it requests the message from)5 1542 1 720 5280 t

4158: 10 I f

4159: (R)2297 5280 w

4160: 7 I f

4161: (x)2369 5300 w

4162: 10 R f

4163: ( data transmitted in a uni\256ed ticker is temporal and many)10 2391(. The)1 241 2 2408 5280 t

4164: ( the next value of a stock is)7 1230( Once)1 281(customers may only be interested in the most recent stock prices.)10 2809 3 720 5400 t

4165: ( may be other)3 624( There)1 308( previous price.)2 670(received, there is no reason for these customers to retrieve the)10 2718 4 720 5520 t

4166: ( customers may retrieve the)4 1123( These)1 293( predict trends.)2 606(customers who wish to accurately plot the stock price to)9 2298 4 720 5640 t

4167: (missing transactions.)1 839 1 720 5760 t

4168: ( with maintaining)2 716(There is an expense associated)4 1240 2 720 6000 t

4169: 10 I f

4170: (R)2706 6000 w

4171: 7 I f

4172: (x)2778 6020 w

4173: 10 R f

4174: ( provider can recover the expense by selling)7 1794(. Network)1 429 2 2817 6000 t

4175: ( the same messages will be)5 1089( is likely that)3 529( It)1 114(two levels of service, one with and one without retransmissions.)9 2588 4 720 6120 t

4176: ( retransmissions)1 659( The)1 217( should be multicast.)3 864( retransmissions)1 658( Therefore,)1 478(lost by many receivers in a region.)6 1444 6 720 6240 t

4177: ( sold separately)2 623( retransmit key can be)4 889( The)1 207(can be encrypted with a different key than the original multicast.)10 2601 4 720 6360 t

4178: ( that pay for the higher level of service can)9 1817( receivers)1 395( Only)1 261(by the same techniques as the multicast key.)7 1847 4 720 6480 t

4179: ( ISP may also give away the base service and charge for the more)13 2696( An)1 178(decrypt the retransmitted messages.)3 1446 3 720 6600 t

4180: (reliable service.)1 631 1 720 6720 t

4181: ( data in a uni\256ed stock ticker will be signi\256cantly greater than the amount of data that a)17 3708(The amount of)2 612 2 720 6960 t

4182: ( the base rate of the receivers is 56 Kbps,)9 1649( If)1 117( is addressed by striping.)4 995( problem)1 360( This)1 230(typical user can receive.)3 969 6 720 7080 t

4183: ( stripe is)2 343( Each)1 251( joined in stripes that are unlikely to require a data rate exceeding 56 Kbps.)14 3025(similar stocks are)2 701 4 720 7200 t

4184: ( modem can only select one stripe at a)8 1533( trader with a 56 Kbps)5 900( A)1 124(transmitted on a different multicast address.)5 1763 4 720 7320 t

4185: (time while a trader with a 1.5 Mbps line may simultaneously follow the stocks on 25 stripes.)16 3698 1 720 7440 t

4186: cleartomark

4187: showpage

4188: saveobj restore

4189: end

4190: %%EndPage: 16 16

4191: %%Page: 17 17

4192: DpostDict begin

4193: /saveobj save def

4194: mark

4195: 17 pagesetup

4196: 10 R f

4197: (- 17 -)2 216 1 2772 480 t

4198: ( case, the entire)3 638( this)1 175( In)1 138(Striping, with much wider stripes, may also be necessary in the backbone network.)12 3369 4 720 960 t

4199: (multicast infrastructure,)1 959 1 720 1080 t

4200: 10 I f

4201: (R)1709 1080 w

4202: 7 I f

4203: (P)1781 1100 w

4204: 10 R f

4205: ('s,)1832 1080 w

4206: 10 I f

4207: (R)1959 1080 w

4208: 7 I f

4209: (S)2031 1100 w

4210: 10 R f

4211: ('s, and)1 271 1 2074 1080 t

4212: 10 I f

4213: (R)2374 1080 w

4214: 7 I f

4215: (x)2446 1100 w

4216: 10 R f

4217: ( The)1 209('s, is duplicated for each stripe.)5 1270 2 2485 1080 t

4218: 10 I f

4219: (S)3993 1080 w

4220: 7 I f

4221: (P)4054 1100 w

4222: 10 R f

4223: ('s transmit transactions)2 935 1 4105 1080 t

4224: ( assume that network bandwidth will not constrain)7 2053( We)1 193(involving different stocks on the appropriate stripe.)6 2074 3 720 1200 t

4225: ( and that the stripes are needed because the)8 1733(the stock transactions that can be reported, as in the end system,)11 2587 2 720 1320 t

4226: (message rate exceeds the throughput of the)6 1718 1 720 1440 t

4227: 10 I f

4228: (R)2463 1440 w

4229: 7 I f

4230: (T)2535 1460 w

4231: 10 R f

4232: (.)2582 1440 w

4233: %INFO[SECTION: LEVEL = 2, NUMBER = 7.2  , HEADING = Unified Orders]

4234: 9 B f

4235: ( Orders)1 298(7.2 Uni\256ed)1 439 2 720 1740 t

4236: 10 R f

4237: ( offers can be)3 566( The)1 214( stocks at a given price.)5 982(The uni\256ed order system is a sequence of offers to buy or sell)12 2558 4 720 1920 t

4238: ( objective is to give all of)6 1028( Our)1 207( can be open to all participating exchanges.)7 1738(directed to a speci\256c exchange or)5 1347 4 720 2040 t

4239: (the traders a fair opportunity to place their bids in the sequence of offers.)13 2910 1 720 2160 t

4240: (If the buy and sell offers are directed to a single exchange, the order of the sequence may be binding on the)21 4320 1 720 2400 t

4241: ( open to all exchanges, the offer may just be an invitation for a broker to)15 3009( the offer is)3 484( If)1 125(trades that occur.)2 702 4 720 2520 t

4242: ( is too large to be handled by a single)9 1508( open offer to all exchanges may also be an order that)11 2147( An)1 173(close a deal.)2 492 4 720 2640 t

4243: (exchange.)720 2760 w

4244: ( are many sources and a small number of receivers.)9 2107( There)1 289(This system is the inverse of the uni\256ed ticker.)8 1924 3 720 3000 t

4245: ( may seem wasteful to circulate the)6 1468( It)1 121( is one receiver, a single trading \257oor.)7 1581(In the degenerate case there)4 1150 4 720 3120 t

4246: (token among the)2 668 1 720 3240 t

4247: 10 I f

4248: (R)1414 3240 w

4249: 7 I f

4250: (P)1486 3260 w

4251: 10 R f

4252: (that are distributed around the world, just to give the sequence to a single trading \257oor)15 3476 1 1564 3240 t

4253: ( the circulating token is needed for fairness.)7 1746( However,)1 440(in a single location.)3 783 3 720 3360 t

4254: ( sources that are in the same city as)8 1432(If all of the sources transmit their offers directly to the trading \257oor, the)13 2888 2 720 3600 t

4255: ( the propagation and)3 839( Firstly,)1 344( of the world.)3 559(the exchange have an advantage over sources on the other side)10 2578 4 720 3720 t

4256: ( and secondly, the average number of trys to have the message)11 2659(network delays may be seconds shorter,)5 1661 2 720 3840 t

4257: ( different parts of the world receive the)7 1615( two traders in)3 601( If)1 125(correctly received may be several times smaller.)6 1979 4 720 3960 t

4258: ( price, the trader in the same city as)8 1448(uni\256ed ticker and decide simultaneously to sell their stocks at the same)11 2872 2 720 4080 t

4259: (the trading \257oor will almost always have its order registered \256rst.)10 2611 1 720 4200 t

4260: ( token, the portal that allows messages to enter the system spends equal amounts of time at)16 3707(With a rotating)2 613 2 720 4440 t

4261: ( into the system \256rst depends on where the portal is)10 2144( trader that gets)3 648( The)1 215(different locations on the globe.)4 1313 4 720 4560 t

4262: (located when the two traders decide to enter their offers, and not where the trading \257oor is located.)17 3938 1 720 4680 t

4263: ( These)1 307( trading \257oors.)2 624(The sources in this application include brokers and individual traders as well as)12 3389 3 720 4920 t

4264: ( sources may)2 541( The)1 215( uni\256ed ticker.)2 600(sources cannot be trusted to the same extent as the trading \257oors in the)13 2964 4 720 5040 t

4265: ( may transmit a large number of messages to disrupt the)10 2436(make offers without the proper resources, or)6 1884 2 720 5160 t

4266: ( addition, there may be too many sources for the)9 1930(system. In)1 436 2 720 5280 t

4267: 10 I f

4268: (R)3111 5280 w

4269: 7 I f

4270: (T)3183 5300 w

4271: 10 R f

4272: (to have a different shared secret with each.)7 1705 1 3255 5280 t

4273: ( sources,)1 354( The)1 209(Both of these problems are solved by not giving the sources direct access to the RMP group.)16 3757 3 720 5520 t

4274: 10 I f

4275: (S)720 5640 w

4276: 7 I f

4277: (P)781 5660 w

4278: 10 R f

4279: ( are the only sources inside the)6 1339( These)1 306(, are either owned by the network or are completely trusted.)10 2563 3 832 5640 t

4280: ( sources,)1 349( The)1 205(network \256rewall.)1 682 3 720 5760 t

4281: 10 I f

4282: (S)1981 5760 w

4283: 10 R f

4284: (, must present credentials to the)5 1265 1 2031 5760 t

4285: 10 I f

4286: (S)3321 5760 w

4287: 7 I f

4288: (P)3382 5780 w

4289: 10 R f

4290: (that they own the stock that they would)7 1581 1 3459 5760 t

4291: ( the)1 147( Alternatively,)1 602(like to sell or that they have the funds that they would like to spend.)14 2712 3 720 5880 t

4292: 10 I f

4293: (S)4206 5880 w

4294: 10 R f

4295: (may have accounts)2 759 1 4281 5880 t

4296: (with the)1 329 1 720 6000 t

4297: 10 I f

4298: (S)1078 6000 w

4299: 7 I f

4300: (P)1139 6020 w

4301: 10 R f

4302: ( there are)2 380( If)1 121( upon password system.)3 970(, in which case they must prove their identity by an agreed)11 2379 4 1190 6000 t

4303: (too many)1 382 1 720 6120 t

4304: 10 I f

4305: (S)1134 6120 w

4306: 10 R f

4307: (for the network based)3 888 1 1216 6120 t

4308: 10 I f

4309: (S)2136 6120 w

4310: 7 I f

4311: (P)2197 6140 w

4312: 10 R f

4313: ( can be secondary sources,)4 1084(to track, there)2 565 2 2280 6120 t

4314: 10 I f

4315: (S)3960 6120 w

4316: 7 I f

4317: (S)4021 6140 w

4318: 10 R f

4319: (, that trust the)3 568 1 4064 6120 t

4320: 10 I f

4321: (S)4663 6120 w

4322: 10 R f

4323: (and are)1 296 1 4744 6120 t

4324: (trusted by the)2 544 1 720 6240 t

4325: 10 I f

4326: (S)1289 6240 w

4327: 7 I f

4328: (P)1350 6260 w

4329: 10 R f

4330: (.)1401 6240 w

4331: %INFO[SECTION: LEVEL = 2, NUMBER = 7.3  , HEADING = Distributed Trading Floor]

4332: 9 B f

4333: ( Trading Floor)2 571(7.3 Distributed)1 599 2 720 6420 t

4334: 10 R f

4335: ( participants may)2 694( The)1 208( construct a distributed, international trading \257oor.)6 2033(The third application uses RMP to)5 1385 4 720 6600 t

4336: ( may be one of the sources in)7 1216( trading \257oor)2 538( This)1 236(be individual traders, brokers, or the other trading \257oors.)8 2330 4 720 6720 t

4337: ( participants may enter buy, sell or stop orders and must see all of the orders.)15 3160( of the)2 265( All)1 183(the uni\256ed ticker.)2 712 4 720 6840 t

4338: (Depending on the sequence of the orders, each participant knows which trades have occurred.)13 3742 1 720 6960 t

4339: ( are large numbers of)4 887( There)1 292( problems of the previous two applications.)6 1789(This application has many of the)5 1352 4 720 7200 t

4340: ( the)1 159( Both)1 257( trusted.)1 334(sources and receivers, none of which is)6 1643 4 720 7320 t

4341: 10 I f

4342: (S)3150 7320 w

4343: 7 I f

4344: (P)3211 7340 w

4345: 10 R f

4346: (and)3299 7320 w

4347: 10 I f

4348: (R)3480 7320 w

4349: 7 I f

4350: (T)3552 7340 w

4351: 10 R f

4352: ( are)1 158( They)1 267(must be network based.)3 979 3 3636 7320 t

4353: ( The)1 207( data.)1 218(distributed around the world to provide fair entry and distribution of the)11 2883 3 720 7440 t

4354: 10 I f

4355: (S)4055 7440 w

4356: 7 I f

4357: (P)4116 7460 w

4358: 10 R f

4359: (verify the credentials)2 846 1 4194 7440 t

4360: cleartomark

4361: showpage

4362: saveobj restore

4363: end

4364: %%EndPage: 17 17

4365: %%Page: 18 18

4366: DpostDict begin

4367: /saveobj save def

4368: mark

4369: 18 pagesetup

4370: 10 R f

4371: (- 18 -)2 216 1 2772 480 t

4372: (of the)1 236 1 720 960 t

4373: 10 I f

4374: (S)987 960 w

4375: 10 R f

4376: ( upon the RMP sequence and the rules of the particular trading \257oor, an)13 2927( Based)1 299(and enter the bids.)3 747 3 1067 960 t

4377: ( site)1 170( making the token)3 734( By)1 172(arbiter declares trades to be made and reports the trade on an appropriate ticker.)13 3244 4 720 1080 t

4378: ( sell)1 167(the arbiter we can guarantee that the arbiter has the most complete acknowledged sequence of buy and)16 4153 2 720 1200 t

4379: (orders.)720 1320 w

4380: ( one)1 182( If)1 129( rules are semantic.)3 809( Some)1 291( a number of different rules that we can use to make trades.)12 2519(There are)1 390 6 720 1560 t

4381: (participant offers to buy a stock at price)7 1595 1 720 1680 t

4382: 10 I f

4383: (A)2341 1680 w

4384: 10 R f

4385: (and another offer to sell the stock at price)8 1657 1 2428 1680 t

4386: 10 I f

4387: (B)4110 1680 w

4388: 10 S f

4389: (<)4220 1680 w

4390: 10 I f

4391: (A)4291 1680 w

4392: 10 R f

4393: (, should the trade)3 688 1 4352 1680 t

4394: (be made at)2 444 1 720 1800 t

4395: 10 I f

4396: (A)1195 1800 w

4397: 10 R f

4398: (,)1256 1800 w

4399: 10 I f

4400: (B)1312 1800 w

4401: 10 R f

4402: ( post buys)2 420( \257oors may)2 462( Some)1 284( rules are a matter of style.)6 1097( Other)1 283(, or somewhere in between.)4 1121 6 1373 1800 t

4403: ( highest bidder gets to buy the stock)7 1448(and sells, others may be run a single round, high bid auction, where the)13 2872 2 720 1920 t

4404: ( \257oors can be modeled after the Amsterdam \257ower)8 2061( Other)1 281( offered by the second highest bidder.)6 1529(at the price)2 449 4 720 2040 t

4405: (auction.)720 2160 w

4406: ( trades reliably even when there are system)7 1804(RMP offers very strong guarantees that can be used to make)10 2516 2 720 2400 t

4407: ( An)1 187( assume that the token site is the arbiter.)8 1721( instance,)1 393(failures. For)1 529 4 720 2520 t

4408: 10 I f

4409: (R)3590 2520 w

4410: 7 I f

4411: (P)3662 2540 w

4412: 10 R f

4413: (that has the token can report a)6 1287 1 3753 2520 t

4414: ( next time that this)4 749( The)1 206( match.)1 295(tentative trade as soon as it sees a)7 1339 4 720 2640 t

4415: 10 I f

4416: (R)3335 2640 w

4417: 7 I f

4418: (P)3407 2660 w

4419: 10 R f

4420: (receives the token it can report that the)7 1556 1 3484 2640 t

4421: (trade is con\256rmed because every)4 1331 1 720 2760 t

4422: 10 I f

4423: (R)2082 2760 w

4424: 7 I f

4425: (P)2154 2780 w

4426: 10 R f

4427: ( trade information cannot be lost as long)7 1647( The)1 210( report.)1 293(has received the)2 654 4 2236 2760 t

4428: (as one of the)3 507 1 720 2880 t

4429: 10 I f

4430: (R)1252 2880 w

4431: 7 I f

4432: (P)1324 2900 w

4433: 10 R f

4434: (survives.)1400 2880 w

4435: %INFO[SECTION: LEVEL = 1, NUMBER = 8.  , HEADING = Conclusions]

4436: 9 B f

4437: (8. Conclusions)1 579 1 720 3120 t

4438: 10 R f

4439: ( ensures)1 325( RMP)1 263( stock exchange.)2 664(We have described an architecture and protocols for an Internet-based global)10 3068 4 720 3300 t

4440: (fair and timely entry and delivery of data, and scales globally.)10 2473 1 720 3420 t

4441: 10 I f

4442: (REFERENCES)2574 3900 w

4443: 10 R f

4444: ( Broadcast Protocols," ACM Transactions on Computer)6 2297( Chang, N. F. Maxemchuk, "Reliable)5 1537([1] J-M.)1 402 3 804 4080 t

4445: (Systems, Vol. 2, No. 3, Aug. '84, pp. 251-273.)8 1869 1 1020 4200 t

4446: ( a Broadcast Network,")3 969( Chang, "Simplifying Distributed Database Systems Design by Using)8 2865([2] J-M.)1 402 3 804 4380 t

4447: (Proc SIGMOD '84, pp 223-233, June 1984.)6 1751 1 1020 4500 t

4448: ( "Multicast Routing in Internetworks and extended LAN's," ACM SIGCOMM '88, Aug.)11 3568( Deering,)1 371([3] S.)1 297 3 804 4680 t

4449: (1988, Stanford, Calif., pp 55-64.)4 1302 1 1020 4800 t

4450: ( J-M. Chang, "Analysis of the Messages Transmitted in a Broadcast Protocol,")11 3250( F. Maxemchuk,)2 673([4] N.)1 313 3 804 4980 t

4451: (Proc ICC '84, pp 1263-1267, May, 1984.)6 1649 1 1020 5100 t

4452: ( S. Kaplan, "A High Performance Totally Ordered Multicast)8 2737( Whetten, T. Montgomery,)3 1191([5] B.)1 308 3 804 5280 t

4453: ( Distributed Systems, number 938 in LCNS, Springer Verlag,)8 2591(Protocol,," Theory and Practice in)4 1429 2 1020 5400 t

4454: (1994.)1020 5520 w

4455: ( Schemes in Multicast)3 889( Pejhan, M. Schwartz, D. Anastassiou, "Error Control Using Retransmission)9 3050([6] S.)1 297 3 804 5700 t

4456: (Transport Protocols for Real-Time Media", IEEE/ACM Trans. on Networking, vo. 4, no. 3, June)13 4020 1 1020 5820 t

4457: (1996, pp. 413-427.)2 758 1 1020 5940 t

4458: ( Maxemchuk, K. Padmanabhan, S. Lo, "A Cooperative Packet Recovery Protocol for Multicast)12 3817( F.)1 106([7] N.)1 313 3 804 6120 t

4459: ( 259-266.)1 408(Video," Int. Conf. on Network Protocols, Oct. 29-31 1997, Atlanta Georgia. pp.)11 3190 2 1020 6240 t

4460: ( R. G. Hertwich, H. Stuttgen, "HeiTP - a transport protocol for ST-II,")12 2938( Delgrossi, C. Halstrick,)3 996([8] L.)1 302 3 804 6420 t

4461: (Proc of IEEE Globcom '92, 1992, pp. 1369-1332)7 1970 1 1020 6540 t

4462: ( J. Crowcroft, "Multipoint Communications: A Survey of Protocols, Functions)9 3151( Diot, W. Dabbous,)3 777([9] C.)1 308 3 804 6720 t

4463: (and Mechanisms," IEEE JSAC, Apr. 1997, vol. 15, no. 3, pp. 277-290.)11 2831 1 1020 6840 t

4464: ( Service for Open Network)4 1128( G. Steiner, C. Neuman, J. I. Schiller, "Kerberos: An Authentication)10 2828([10] J.)1 330 3 754 7020 t

4465: (Systems," USENIX Winter Conference, Feb. 9-12, 1988, Dallas Texas, pp. 191-202.)10 3386 1 1020 7140 t

4466: ( Computer Networks," IEEE)3 1259( Clifford, T. Tso, "Kerberos: An Authentication Service for)8 2669([11] B.)1 358 3 754 7320 t

4467: (Communications Magazine, September 1994, Vol. 32, No. 9, pgs. 33-38.)9 2923 1 1020 7440 t

4468: cleartomark

4469: showpage

4470: saveobj restore

4471: end

4472: %%EndPage: 18 18

4473: %%Page: 19 19

4474: DpostDict begin

4475: /saveobj save def

4476: mark

4477: 19 pagesetup

4478: 10 R f

4479: (- 19 -)2 216 1 2772 480 t

4480: ( IEEE Trans.)2 524( Harn, H-Y. Lin, "Key Management for Decentralized Computer Network Services,")10 3410([12] L.)1 352 3 754 960 t

4481: (on Commun., Vol. 41, No. 12, Dec. 1993, pp. 1777-1779.)9 2313 1 1020 1080 t

4482: ( The Network Time Protocol," IEEE Trans. on)7 2080( L. Mills, "Internet Time Synchronization:)5 1843([13] D.)1 363 3 754 1260 t

4483: (Communications, Vol. 39, pp. 1482-1493, Oct. 1991.)6 2136 1 1020 1380 t

4484: ( IEEE/ACM)1 518( L. Mills, "Improved Algorithms for Synchronizing Computer Network Clocks,")9 3405([14] D.)1 363 3 754 1560 t

4485: (Trans. on Networking, Vol. 3, No. 3, pp. 245-254, June 1995.)10 2467 1 1020 1680 t

4486: ( 5,)1 119( F. Maxemchuk, "Electronic Document Distribution," ATT Technical Journal, vol. 73, no.)11 3804([15] N.)1 363 3 754 1860 t

4487: (Sept. 1994, pg 73-80.)3 861 1 1020 1980 t

4488: ( Brassil, S. Low, N. F. Maxemchuk, "Copyright Protection for the Electronic Distribution of)13 3835( T.)1 121([16] J.)1 330 3 754 2160 t

4489: ( 1181-)1 294( vol. 87, no. 7, pp.)5 783(Text Documents," Invited Paper - Proceedings of the IEEE, July 1999,)10 2943 3 1020 2280 t

4490: (1196.)1020 2400 w

4491: ( Willett, "A Tutorial on Public Key Cryptography" Computers & Security I \(1982\) pp. 72-79,)14 3906([17] M.)1 380 2 754 2580 t

4492: (North-Holland Publishing Company.)2 1481 1 1020 2700 t

4493: ( Cryptography," Proceedings of the IEEE, Vol. 76,)7 2100( Dif\256e, "The First Ten Years of Public-Key)7 1801([18] W.)1 385 3 754 2880 t

4494: (No. 5, May 1988, pp. 560-577.)5 1238 1 1020 3000 t

4495: cleartomark

4496: showpage

4497: saveobj restore

4498: end

4499: %%EndPage: 19 19

4500: %%Trailer

4501: DpostDict begin

4502: done

4503: end

4504: %%Pages: 19

4505: %%DocumentFonts: Times-Bold Times-Italic Times-Roman Symbol

4506: