1: <HTML>
2: <HEAD>
3: <META HTTP-EQUIV="Content-Type" CONTENT="text/html; charset=windows-1252">
4: <META NAME="Generator" CONTENT="Microsoft Word 97">
5: <TITLE>E-Business and Learning Processes:</TITLE>
6: </HEAD>
7: <BODY>
8:
9: <B><FONT SIZE=4><P ALIGN="CENTER">Globalisation, E-Business and SMEs:</P>
10: <P ALIGN="CENTER">Evidence from the Italian District of Prato</P>
11: </B></FONT><I><P ALIGN="CENTER"></P>
12: <B><P ALIGN="CENTER">Lucia Piscitello</P>
13: </B><P ALIGN="CENTER">Dipartimento di Economia e Produzione, Politecnico di Milano (Italy)</P>
14: <P ALIGN="CENTER">Piazza Leonardo da Vinci, 32 – 20133 Milano– Italy</P>
15: <P ALIGN="CENTER">tel. +39.02.2399 2740, fax +39.02.2399 2710</P>
16: <P ALIGN="CENTER">lucia.piscitello@polimi.it</P>
17: <P ALIGN="CENTER"></P>
18: <B><P ALIGN="CENTER">Francesca Sgobbi</P>
19: </B><P ALIGN="CENTER">Dipartimento di Economia e Produzione, Politecnico di Milano (Italy)</P>
20: <P ALIGN="CENTER">Piazza Leonardo da Vinci, 32 – 20133 Milano– Italy</P>
21: <P ALIGN="CENTER">tel. +39.02.2399 2741, fax +39.02.2399 2710</P>
22: <P ALIGN="CENTER">francesca.sgobbi@polimi.it</P>
23: </I><P ALIGN="CENTER"></P>
24: <I><FONT SIZE=2><P ALIGN="CENTER">Financial support from the Cofinanziamento Murst 2000 is</FONT><FONT SIZE=3> </FONT><FONT SIZE=2>gratefully</FONT><FONT SIZE=3> </FONT><FONT SIZE=2>acknowledged. The authors wish to thank Valerio Manfrini for his valuable help in data collection, Sergio Mariotti for his comments on an earlier version of the paper, and the participants in the International Conference on Entrepreneurship and Learning, Naples, June 2001. The paper is a joint effort by the authors. Nonetheless, Lucia Piscitello drafted sections 1-2 and Francesca Sgobbi sections 3-4, while section 5 was written together.</P>
25: </I></FONT><P ALIGN="CENTER"></P>
26: <P ALIGN="CENTER">Preliminary version – Please do not quote</P>
27: <P ALIGN="CENTER"></P>
28: <B><P ALIGN="JUSTIFY">Short abstract</P>
29: </B><P ALIGN="JUSTIFY">The paper explores the attitude of SMEs located in industrial districts towards e-business as a means to face the challenges posed by globalisation. By resorting to case studies conducted in the textile district of Prato, the research evidences the positive attitude of the interviewed entrepreneurs towards e-business. However, the characteristics of the considered products (textiles) and the district structure strongly affect the path followed to explore the opportunity offered by e-business. Moreover, collected evidence suggests that only few representative firms of the district might be able to embrace the full range of opportunities provided by e-business, and that isolated actions are not enough to foster collective learning and growth processes involving the whole district.</P>
30: <B><P ALIGN="JUSTIFY"></P>
31: <P ALIGN="CENTER"> </P>
32: <FONT SIZE=4><P ALIGN="CENTER">Globalisation, E-Business and SMEs:</P>
33: <P ALIGN="CENTER">Evidence from the Italian District of Prato</P>
34: </B></FONT><P ALIGN="JUSTIFY"></P>
35: <P ALIGN="JUSTIFY"> </P>
36: <P ALIGN="JUSTIFY"> </P>
37: <OL>
38:
39: <B><P ALIGN="JUSTIFY"><LI>Introduction</LI></P>
40: </B><P ALIGN="JUSTIFY">Two interconnected phenomena are marking the evolution of economic systems: the globalisation of markets and the diffusion of information and communication technologies (ICTs) and the Internet. At the firm level, their concurrent effects impact on both internal organisation and inter-firm relationships. In principles, by resorting to e-business firms may reduce the costs of information-intensive activities, such as communications management and sales and marketing. These opportunities may especially favour small and medium enterprises (SMEs), given the emphasis put by the Internet on deverticalisation processes and on the creation of local, national, and international networks (Bangemann Report, 1994; OECD, 1998a). Yet, if electronic commerce downsizes some historical barriers to the competitiveness of SMEs, other obstacles remain, such as the access to financial markets, the availability of qualified personnel, the management of physical flows of goods traded on electronic markets (Piscitello, 1995; Mutinelli, 1997). Moreover, new barriers are rising, such as the access to network infrastructures, often discriminatory against SMEs, or the need to achieve visibility for on-line brands, often connected with dimensional factors (Brynjolfsson and Smith, 1999; Mariotti and Sgobbi, 2001). Size also affects the relative importance of the actors involved in shaping the new norms required for managing on-line transactions.</P>
41: <P ALIGN="JUSTIFY">The paper explores the attitude of SMEs towards globalisation and e-business. Specifically, the context considered is a peculiar SMEs-intensive productive environment: the manufacturing industrial district. Manufacturing industrial districts traditionally constitute examples of winning SMEs’ networks, characterised by common industrial culture and intense input-output interactions. Firms belonging to the district benefit from a complex system of interrelationships intimately related to production systems, economic and social actors, district-specific culture, and collective learning (Camagni, 1991). </P>
42: <P ALIGN="JUSTIFY">At least in principle, the traditional integration of multiple competencies and multiple economic actors along the value chain that characterises the industrial district could make it a "natural candidate" to join the Internet economy, given the emphasis that both districts and e-business put on flexibility and network-based relationships. However, the actual chance to transfer the winning district model to the globalised Internet economy is threatened by serious challenges. A great distance exists between the ICTs at the base of e-business and the traditional background of district-located entrepreneurs. In the traditional district, competencies and know-how are often implicit and embodied into products, while communication through telematic networks requires sharing explicit, codified information. At the same time, the district know-how focuses on translating operative intuitions into product and process innovations, while e-business also puts the emphasis on the capability to map operational, cognitive, and communication processes (Enright and Ffowcs-Williams, 2000). Moreover, the adoption of ICTs implies the resort to innovative technology suppliers, who may not share with the adopters the same "language" and culture.</P>
43: <P ALIGN="JUSTIFY">In other words, the entrepreneurs of industrial districts are called to adapt their competencies and capabilities in order to keep up competing successfully in the transforming reference framework. New knowledge might need to be sourced from different origins as firms become less and less capable of supplying all the knowledge required. Therefore, inter-firm and inter-institution linkages assume increasing importance.</P>
44: <P ALIGN="JUSTIFY"></P>
45: <P ALIGN="JUSTIFY">The paper presents empirical evidence resulting from the Italian textile district of Prato. Specifically, it highlights the learning processes followed by firms in order to enter the global arena through the Internet economy. The performed analysis, based on case studies, shows that learning processes are taking place, and that pro-active entrepreneurs are creatively exploring the opportunities offered by the Internet to promote their businesses even abroad. However, it is also clear that the transition to the Internet economy still involves a reduced percentage of potential participants, and that institutional actions are crucial in order to foster a larger participation.</P>
46: <P ALIGN="JUSTIFY">The rest of the paper is organised as follows. Section two analyses the relationship between globalisation, e-business and SMEs, and puts forward the research hypotheses driving the empirical analysis. Section three illustrates the main features of the district of Prato and the research methodology, while empirical findings are presented and discussed in Section four. Section five concludes the paper with some policy remarks and suggestions for the future research agenda. </P>
47: <P ALIGN="JUSTIFY"></P>
48: <B><P ALIGN="JUSTIFY"><LI>Globalisation, e-business and SMEs. The research hypotheses</LI></P></OL>
49:
50: </B><P ALIGN="JUSTIFY">In a context characterised by increasing globalisation, the growing involvement of SMEs in the internationalisation of production is getting more and more attention by researchers, policy makers, and practitioners (Buckley <I>et al.</I>, 1988; Buckley, 1989; European Network for SME Research, 1993; UNCTAD, 1993; Audretsch, 1995; Fujita, 1995a and 1995b; Storey, 1995).</P>
51: <P ALIGN="JUSTIFY">Theoretical and empirical studies (Buckley, 1989; Acs <I>et al.</I>, 1997) already concluded that smaller companies are sensitive to the inherent risks involved in international activities and particularly foreign direct investments (FDI). SMEs suffer from internal constraints related to the scarcity of financial, managerial and information resources, necessary to face the uncertainty and the risk involved in undertaking activities on a foreign market. </P>
52: <P ALIGN="JUSTIFY">Nonetheless, size is not necessarily a barrier to internationalisation as SMEs can find ways to overcome their smallness (Gomes-Casseres, 1997; Coviello and McAuley, 1999). Indeed, SMEs which develop and maintain ownership/competitive advantages related to the possession and exploitation of monopoly power, and the possession of scarce, unique and sustainable resources and capabilities, are likely to attempt growth internationally. These advantages are necessary to overcome those of foreign competitors abroad and to face the uncertainty inherent to foreign markets (Dunning, 1981), and might relate to the membership to a cluster (network/district). Indeed, rather than on small businesses as stand alone organisations, empirical analysis is progressively focusing on networks and clusters of SMEs (Porter, 1998; Enright and Ffowcs-Williams, 2000; OECD, 2000) as they allow small firms to combine the advantages of small scale with various of the benefits of large scale; they enhance the productivity, rate of innovation and competitive performances of the firms (Enright and Ffowcs-Williams, 2000). In particular, special attention has been devoted to Italian industrial districts (Micelli and di Maria, 2000; Rullani <I>et al.</I>, 2000; RUR-Censis, 2001), which constitute a peculiar reality (see Becattini, 1998; Brusco and Paba, 1997) where SMEs act as a whole and their growth opportunities rely on the characteristics of local embeddeness within the district itself. Industrial districts are characterised by several intertwined factors originating scale and scope economies, both static and dynamic, which increase SMEs’ efficiency and competitiveness. Those factors concern the strong specialisation, the network organisation, the collective learning processes, the circulation of information, knowledge and technologies, the widespread entrepreneurship, the high quality, mobility and flexibility of human resources, the strong domestic rivalry, the solid linkages between the economic and the social environment (Mariotti and Mutinelli, 2001). They are also responsible for the two main key aspects distinguishing industrial districts, which might become weaknesses in a context where global presence and international organisation of activities are increasingly needed conditions to compete:</P>
53: <OL TYPE="i">
54:
55: <P ALIGN="JUSTIFY"><LI>the highly localised character of SMEs’ competitive advantages, which form a local-specific unique integrated system hardly replicable in other contexts;</LI></P>
56: <P ALIGN="JUSTIFY"><LI>the strong tendency to path-dependent growth, which makes SMEs willing to undertake incremental, rather than radical, changes. This may lock-in district firms, making them unable to grow and capture opportunities in different (also foreign) markets. </LI></P></OL>
57:
58: <P ALIGN="JUSTIFY">Previous empirical studies (<I>e.g.</I> Mariotti and Mutinelli, 2001) have shown that some structural characteristics of the district could help SMEs to overcome such limitations to their international growth. Specifically, the presence of local leader as well as the presence of foreign-owned firms within the district have been shown to drive the international expansion of the district. The idea developed in the present paper is that the diffusion of information and communication technologies (ICTs) and the Internet, by reducing spatial and temporal constraints as well as information costs, may especially favour SMEs and districts in particular, given the intriguing similarity between Internet-based networks and industrial districts. The resort to Internet emphasises the chance of increasing operative efficiency by promoting networks of specialised firms (Venkatraman and Henderson, 1998). This solution somehow reflects a traditional winning feature of the industrial district: a relatively large number of highly specialised firms that achieve high product quality and flexibility through quick and effective inter-firm communication. The difference between the two models stays in the means supporting inter-firms communication flows: the Internet, in the first case, and direct and personal contacts in the case of districts. Accordingly, three interesting questions do arise: (Q1) Will the diffusion of Internet-based communication reinforce the beneficial network effect originally generated among district firms by geographical proximity? (Q2) Will awareness of network-related benefits make district firms, SMEs included, more willing to join the e-economy? (Q3) Moreover, will the elimination of time and spatial constraints help district-based SMEs to face the challenge of globalisation? </P>
59: <P ALIGN="JUSTIFY"></P>
60: <P ALIGN="JUSTIFY">Answering these questions is not trivial. The international literature about the relationship between ICTs and SMEs’ international competitiveness and growth has mainly focused so far on the challenges and opportunities offered by e-business (<I>e.g.</I>, OECD, 2000), the modalities adopted by firms to approach new technologies [<FONT SIZE=2>For a critical analysis of emerging "strategic approaches" to the Internet, see Porter (2001)</FONT>], and the complementarities between specific industries and the features of the new electronic channel (<I>e.g.</I>, EITO, 2000). However, as to the authors’ knowledge, available evidence on SMEs’ approach towards e-business is still fragmentary and sparse (e.g. Hamill, 1997; Chappell and Feindt, 1999; OECD, 1998b; Bonaccorsi and Rossi, 2001; Micelli and di Maria, 2000). </P>
61: <P ALIGN="JUSTIFY">In order to attempt to provide an answer to these key questions, the present paper empirically investigates the following research hypotheses.</P>
62: <I><P ALIGN="JUSTIFY"></P>
63: </I><B><P ALIGN="JUSTIFY">Q1:</B> Will the diffusion of Internet-based communication reinforce the beneficial network effect originally generated among district firms by geographical proximity?</P>
64: <P ALIGN="JUSTIFY"></P>
65: <P ALIGN="JUSTIFY">E-business may potentially assume a crucial role within the specific reality of an industrial district, as it allows existing firms to integrate the different stages of their value chain. By enabling new options, ICTs and Internet may reinforce relationships and ease information and knowledge exchanges within the district.</P>
66: <P ALIGN="JUSTIFY">Listed by growing complexity, the tools offered by Internet-based communications to reinforce intra-district relationships include:</P>
67: <OL>
68:
69: <P ALIGN="JUSTIFY"><LI>internal communication channels among employees (Intranet);</LI></P>
70: <P ALIGN="JUSTIFY"><LI>more intense communication channels with commercial intermediaries, eventually ending up with the establishment of proper on-line business-to-business relationships;</LI></P>
71: <P ALIGN="JUSTIFY"><LI>new uni- and/or bi-directional communication channels with customers, possibly providing them also with on line assistance;</LI></P>
72: <P ALIGN="JUSTIFY"><LI>enriched communication with suppliers (from a simple exchange of information and services, to proper on-line transaction systems);</LI></P>
73: <P ALIGN="JUSTIFY"><LI>fully integration of internal and external processes.</LI></P></OL>
74:
75: <P ALIGN="JUSTIFY">However, within the context of a small firm, the entrepreneur’s cultural and technical background matters. Specifically, a rather conservative entrepreneur would tend to remain attached to traditional information sources and communication systems (as participation in exhibitions, direct contacts with suppliers and customers), while an aware firm tends to add new information systems to the traditional ones.</P>
76: <P ALIGN="JUSTIFY">Therefore, the operative research questions becomes:<I> </P>
77: <P ALIGN="JUSTIFY">How do Internet-based solutions adopted in the district of Prato support intra-district relationships? How does the entrepreneur’s culture affect the on-line presence?</P>
78: </I><P ALIGN="JUSTIFY"></P>
79: <B><P ALIGN="JUSTIFY">Q2:</B> Will awareness of network-related benefits make district firms, SMEs included, more willing to join the e-economy?</P>
80: <P ALIGN="JUSTIFY"></P>
81: <P ALIGN="JUSTIFY">According to SES Canada Research (1999), firms acquire awareness of network-related benefits only incrementally, and this reflects into a step-by-step approach to Internet-related applications. At the beginning, firms adopt Internet only for communicating and gathering information; subsequently they start to buy and sell on-line, and only in the latest stage of the development path they execute financial operations. </P>
82: <P ALIGN="JUSTIFY">The international literature also suggests that European firms, as opposed to the US ones, and especially the smaller ones, adopt a defensive rather than strategic approach towards Internet (e.g. Andersen Consulting, 1999; EITO, 2000). Indeed, they perceive e-business solutions mainly as reactive tools to face up competitors which are already present on the web; they<I> </I>use the Internet to solve internal problems and most firms regard it only as a complementary marketing instrument.</P>
83: <P ALIGN="JUSTIFY">Therefore, the operative research questions are:</P>
84: <I><P ALIGN="JUSTIFY">Which phase are experiencing the SMEs in the district of Prato? Do they adopt a simple reactive approach or do they instead behave as proactive subjects?</P>
85: </I><P ALIGN="JUSTIFY"></P>
86: <B><P ALIGN="JUSTIFY">Q3: </B>Will the elimination of time and spatial constraints help SMEs to face the challenge of globalisation?</P>
87: <P ALIGN="JUSTIFY"></P>
88: <P ALIGN="JUSTIFY">E-business assumes a crucial role also in reshaping the relationships between the district firms and their outside counterparts (Rullani <I>et al.</I>, 2000), as it allows firms to extend their competitive advantage across the district borders. Specifically, firms operating in the downstream stages of the value chain gain a larger perspective of their markets, while firms in the intermediate stages are given the opportunity to purchase inputs on global markets. </P>
89: <P ALIGN="JUSTIFY">As far as SMEs’ international growth is concerned, the effective use of the Internet can provide a low cost gateway to international markets and help smaller firms to overcome many of the barriers or obstacles to internationalisation they commonly experience (Hamill, 1997). Specifically, SMEs wishing to expand abroad suffer from scarcity of financial and managerial resources, scarce experience in managing international operations, and higher sensitivity to the likelihood of failure. Nonetheless, an Internet connection can help SMEs in overcoming some constraints related to the gathering of objective knowledge and provide them with new growth opportunities (Dandrige and Levensbury, 1998; Poon and Swatman, 1997; Poon and Jevons, 1997) by:</P>
90: <OL>
91:
92: <P ALIGN="JUSTIFY"><LI>improving communications with actual and potential customers, suppliers, and partners abroad;</LI></P>
93: <P ALIGN="JUSTIFY"><LI>generating a wealth of information on market trends and development worldwide, and providing an "ear on the ground" on the latest technology and R&D; </LI></P>
94: <P ALIGN="JUSTIFY"><LI>supplying a powerful tool of international promotion and sales.</LI></P></OL>
95:
96: <P ALIGN="JUSTIFY">However, ICTs in general and Internet in particular remain still inappropriate supports to develop and distribute tacit knowledge (Polanyi, 1967), which is hard to codify and transmit. For this reason, some authors (<I>e.g.</I> Petersen <I>et al.</I>, 2000) highlight that Internet may not affect SMEs’ crucial competencies to growth abroad (especially through direct presence). </P>
97: <P ALIGN="JUSTIFY">It is worth observing that the issue is extremely relevant in an era characterised by increasing globalisation, in which the local environment and territory play – almost paradoxically – a crucial role (Porter 1990, Solvell and Zander 1995). In particular, industrial districts are traditionally shaped as closed networks, which interface with the external world through agents and specialised operators. The advent of Internet, i.e. the globalisation of information, might provide them with a new perspective. Strict relationships between different actors and stages of the value chain so far benefited from spatial agglomeration economies, which historically favoured the birth and growth of industrial districts. From this viewpoint, the advent of new technologies and the related reduction of spatial constraints, suggest a rather contradictory scenario, often named as the <I>location paradox</I> (Storper, 1997; Enright, 1998; Porter, 1998). On the one hand, by reinforcing intra-district relationships, ICTs enhance the network characteristics of the district. On the other one, by reducing the need of face-to-face contacts, ICTs allow firms to globalise and exploit their advantage upon foreign markets. </P>
98: <P ALIGN="JUSTIFY">Therefore, the operative research questions become:</P>
99: <I><P ALIGN="JUSTIFY">Are SMEs in the district of Prato aware of the chance offered by ICT technologies to exploit their competitive advantages and to capture new opportunities abroad? How are they exploiting (or planning to exploit) them? Do new ICT technologies strengthen the emergence of a location paradox in the district of Prato, or do they allow firms to better face the paradox?</P>
100: </I><P ALIGN="JUSTIFY"></P>
101: <B><P ALIGN="JUSTIFY">3. The empirical analysis</P>
102: </B><P ALIGN="JUSTIFY">In order to provide preliminary evidence on the research issues outlined in the above Section, an empirical analysis was performed by interviewing a selected sample of entrepreneurs in the Italian textile district of Prato. Before describing the research methodology, the present Section offers some information about the district.</P>
103: <P ALIGN="JUSTIFY"></P>
104: <I><P ALIGN="JUSTIFY">3.1. The district of Prato</P>
105: </I><P ALIGN="JUSTIFY">The district, located in Tuscany, includes the province of Prato, also involving some municipalities in the provinces of Florence and Pistoia. The district comprises over 6.500 firms, whose manufacturing specialisation includes the production of yarn for the knitting industry, fabric for the clothing industry, textile products for furnishing, nonwaven cloths, special cloths for industrial uses, and knitting goods.</P>
106: <P ALIGN="JUSTIFY">Several reasons oriented our attention towards the district of Prato. First, Prato represents the largest district all over the world: it employs 50.000 people, <I>i.e.</I> 18% of residents in the district and 7% of employment in the Italian textile industry. Besides the largest, Prato is also one of the oldest industrial districts: its history dates back to the XIII century and has been characterised by continuous evolution [<FONT SIZE=2>For a recent publication which focuses on the origins as well as on the most recent evolution of the district of Prato, see Becattini (2000)</FONT>]. </P>
107: <P ALIGN="JUSTIFY">The current structure of the district is marked by high fragmentation of productive activities among a large number of SMEs [<FONT SIZE=2>Firms in the district employ on average 8 employees</FONT>]. This situation resulted from the adaptive reaction to the changes that affected the textiles markets after World War II (Becattini, 2000; Mariti, 1979). The need to cope with quantitative and qualitative variability of demand in international markets outlined the need for flexibility, which induced integrated fabric manufacturers to outsource a large number of operations to local specialised smaller suppliers.</P>
108: <P ALIGN="JUSTIFY">Two main categories of actors can be identified: "lanifici impannatori" (fabric manufacturers) and suppliers. About 900 fabric manufacturers sale fabric cloths to garment makers, wholesale dealers, and buyers. Only a reduced number of "impannatori" actually own and manage integrated manufacturing activities. Processes performed by "impannatori" mainly concern the first steps of the textile value chain (market analyses and product innovation) and the last ones (sales and marketing). In most cases, manufacturing activity is limited to the production of sample collections and to quality tests. However, fabric manufacturers devote large efforts to co-ordinate productive processes outsourced to suppliers. The latter (about 5.600 firms in the district) comprise spinning mills, weaving mills, finishing factories, dyeing plants, knitwear manufacturers. While fabric manufacturers are more concerned with product innovation, suppliers often develop process innovations.</P>
109: <P ALIGN="JUSTIFY">The importance of the district immediately arises from the analysis of main economic indicators. In 2000, the district total turnover amounted to 8,500 billion Italian liras, representing 27% of the total turnover of the Italian textile industry. In the same year, the value of exported goods reached 5,700 billion Italian liras, covering 67% of the total district production. The district of Prato totalled 15% of the global export of the Italian textile industry. Moreover, the firms located in the district covered 20% of the world exports of wool fabrics.</P>
110: <P ALIGN="JUSTIFY">The attitude of local institutions represents a further reason that makes the district of Prato an interesting testbed for apprising the risks and opportunity prospected by e-business to SMEs. Public and private institutions in the district have demonstrated higher than average awareness of the potential impact associated to the development of the Information Society. The cabling of the district industrial areas, currently going on (RUR-Censis, 2001), also included the appraisal of the opportunity to promote a local TLCs carrier (Tocco <I>et al.</I>, 1998). Moreover, public and private institutions co-operate in promoting various initiatives to foster on-line active participation by firms and citizens. Example are supplied by the citizen-oriented PO-NET project (http://www-po.net.prato.it), the experimental on-line stock exchange for raw materials and yarn ("Borsa materie prime e filati", www.ui.prato.it/borsa), the dedicated portals (<I>e.g.</I> Portale Prato, http://www.portaleprato.it/home.htm). </P>
111: <P ALIGN="JUSTIFY"></P>
112: <I><P ALIGN="JUSTIFY">3.2. The selected sample</P>
113: </I><P ALIGN="JUSTIFY">The empirical analysis consists of 12 case studies concerning innovative firms of the district of Prato. The case studies were built up by interviewing the entrepreneurs running the selected companies. Interviews were also complemented by the analysis of the web sites managed by the selected companies [<FONT SIZE=2>In order to gain a better insight about the firms’ attitude towards e-business and the Internet, we also interviewed two local suppliers of technology: Cyber.net, an ISP active since 1995, and Multidata, a supplier of information systems specialised in the textile industry with 25 years of experience</FONT>].</P>
114: <P ALIGN="JUSTIFY">Potentially interesting companies were selected with the help of the Unione Industriale di Prato, which supplied a list of 900 companies suitable to satisfy the following criteria:</P>
115:
116: <UL>
117: <P ALIGN="JUSTIFY"><LI>manufacturing SMEs [<FONT SIZE=2>The district also includes other types of firms, such as carriers or tool machine producers specialised in the textile industry. However, given the preliminary nature of the research, we focused the analysis on the core of the district activity, <I>i.e.</I> the production of textile goods</FONT>];</LI></P>
118: <P ALIGN="JUSTIFY"><LI>involvement in innovation activities concerning either product, processes, strategy, or organisational innovation;</LI></P>
119: <P ALIGN="JUSTIFY"><LI>existence of a company web site;</LI></P>
120: <P ALIGN="JUSTIFY"><LI>commercial or productive internationalisation.</LI></P></UL>
121:
122: <P ALIGN="JUSTIFY">A further selection was made thanks to Pratotrade, a local producers’ association which involves 140 particularly innovative firms. Out of the 45 selected companies owning a web sites, 12 accepted to be interviewed. Accordingly, the final sample includes 8 fabric manufacturers, two spinning mills, and two knitwear manufacturers.</P>
123: <P ALIGN="JUSTIFY">All interviews, which took place in February 2001, followed a semi-structured questionnaire which explored the company profile, the relationships with clients and suppliers, the activity in international markets, the features of the company information systems, and the use of ICTs.</P>
124: <P ALIGN="JUSTIFY"></P>
125: <B><P ALIGN="JUSTIFY">4. The results</P>
126: </B><P ALIGN="JUSTIFY">The most significant data collected through the interviews are synthesised in Table 1 and 2: Table 1 depicts the profile of the sampled companies, while Table 2 reports initiatives in the areas of ICTs and e-business. Before interpreting the collected evidence in order to answer the questions stated in Section 2, it may be interesting to point out some general results.</P>
127: <OL>
128:
129: <P ALIGN="JUSTIFY"><LI>Most companies in the sample started their activity after 1960: this evidence witnesses the processes of vertical disintegration which characterised the district after World Word II (Becattini, 2000).</LI></P>
130: <P ALIGN="JUSTIFY"><LI>The importance of exhibitions as marketing media is much larger for fabric manufacturers than for spinning mills and knitwear producers. Exhibitions represent the most important source of commercial contacts for <I>impannatori</I>, while spinning mills and knitwear manufacturers are usually directly contacted by their clients.</LI></P>
131: <P ALIGN="JUSTIFY"><LI>Given the closer position to end markets, fabric and knitwear manufacturers usually present larger collections. Moreover, collections of fabric manufacturers are usually followed by one or more "flashes" during the season, in order to tune production to emerging fashion trends.</LI></P>
132: <P ALIGN="JUSTIFY"><LI>For all the interviewed companies, exports cover a remarkable share of total turnover, in line with the evidence from the overall district.</LI></P></OL>
133:
134: <P ALIGN="JUSTIFY">The following paragraphs will try to outline common trends in the approach of the sampled companies to e-business in general and as a tool for internationalisation in particular. Of course, given the reduced dimension and the non-representativeness of the selected sample, evidence should be carefully interpreted and by no means extended to the whole district. However, also basing on the preliminary results from quantitative analyses which the authors are carrying on in other Italian districts, we are persuaded that observed behaviours do not belong to outliers.</P>
135: <P ALIGN="JUSTIFY"></P>
136: <I><P ALIGN="JUSTIFY">4.1. Are Internet-based applications affecting intra-district relationships?</P>
137: <P ALIGN="JUSTIFY"></P>
138: <P ALIGN="JUSTIFY">Is Internet supporting intra-district relationships?</P>
139: </I><P ALIGN="JUSTIFY">Interviewed entrepreneurs look aware of the chances offered by ICTs in order to increase the company’s efficiency by integrating internal processes (6 out of 12 respondents). Attention also focuses on integrating the company processes with those of far-away clients: most of examined web sites offer clients the chance to check the orders status and the availability of stocks.</P>
140: <P ALIGN="JUSTIFY">Nevertheless, interviewed entrepreneurs look less prone to resort to ICTs as a means to increase their integration with local clients and suppliers. Only 4 companies out of 12 quoted the opportunity to integrate their processes with the suppliers’ ones as an expected benefit from the web. This choice may be tracked to the specific features of the examined sector: the small dimension and the reduced ICTs competencies of suppliers may hamper upstream integration via Internet. Two interviewed firms (Company 1 and 10) explicitly quoted the daily personal visits to suppliers as an organisational solution that on the one hand favours co-ordination and ensures the respect of delivery dates, but on the other one obstacles ICT-based integration.</P>
141: <P ALIGN="JUSTIFY">In sum, Internet is increasingly perceived as a more efficient means of communication with far-away counterparts than traditional tools such as fax or telephone contacts. However, personal contact is still regarded as the most simple and effective form of communication within the district. This evidence reflects the strong component of tacit, uncodifiable knowledge which still permeates knowledge exchanges between client and supplier in the intermediate steps of the value chain. Tacit knowledge cannot be transferred via TLCs network, which convey information, hence codified knowledge. A relevant example is supplied by Company 2, whose entrepreneur explicitly recognised the difficulty of exporting local core competencies as an obstacle to internationalisation processes. </P>
142: <P ALIGN="JUSTIFY"></P>
143: <I><P ALIGN="JUSTIFY">How does the entrepreneur’s culture affect the on-line presence?</P>
144: </I><P ALIGN="JUSTIFY">Collected data show a strong connection between the entrepreneur’s attitudes towards the Internet and the projects implemented at a specific company. Given the relatively small dimensions of firms, and the lack of background in ICTs, the entrepreneur is often in charge of defining contents and functions of the company web site. For example, one of the oldest web sites examined (Company 2), established in 1997, was directly developed by the entrepreneur. The site presents various original features, such as the on-line bulletin news for the company trade agents, or the on-line order of collection samples. The last feature provides an example of a "creative" use of the Internet as a means to promote the company’s products also when their non-standardised features hamper their on-line tradability. Potential clients are given the chance to order samples up to a minimum of 20 swatches, hence reducing the length of the order cycle. The interest of such a feature for the textile sector is witnessed by the fact that one of the largest ISP of Prato, Tex.net, subsequently decided to include it among the services offered to its textile business clients.</P>
145: <P ALIGN="JUSTIFY"></P>
146: <I><P ALIGN="JUSTIFY">4.2.Are network-related benefits encouraging SMEs to join the e-economy?</P>
147: <P ALIGN="JUSTIFY"></P>
148: <P ALIGN="JUSTIFY">Which steps characterise the on-line participation?</P>
149: </I><P ALIGN="JUSTIFY">Collected data clearly show that the implementation of e-commerce only takes place after some intermediate steps [<FONT SIZE=2>The evidence provided by the examined sample as for the steps followed in the development of e-business may be affected by the requirements imposed to select the universe of potential candidates to the interview. Since interviewed companies were required to have a company web site, all respondents already overcame the obstacles posed by the initial lack of information, awareness, and competencies</FONT>]. Following an experience curve, firms progressively add new functions and services to their web sites, from the most simple ones (on-line catalogues) to more articulated and interactive features. As a matter of fact, all the sites which offer only general information about the company products and commercial contacts are relatively recent (five sites, active since 1999). Four firms complement company information with additional services such as on-line catalogues, on-line information on products availability and delivery dates for clients and agents, or on-line order of samples, but do not offer e-commerce services. Finally, the three companies in the sample which accept on-line orders through their web site (Companies 5, 7, and 10) boast longer experience and complement e-commerce services with additional features. </P>
150: <P ALIGN="JUSTIFY">The choice to follow an incremental path in increasing the web site functions follows from the constrains posed to brick-and-mortar companies by the existing equipment and by the lack of ICTs and Internet competencies. This point is clearly illustrated by Company 1, whose web site currently offers information on the firm, trade agents contacts, and an on-line catalogue. The entrepreneur declared the intention to add on-line information on delivery time and stocks availability for registered clients and agents. However, the reduced reliability of information from the warehouse was recognised as an obstacle to the additional feature. Also the entrepreneur of Company 2 pointed out the lack of required web competencies as an obstacle to the implementation of on-line information on delivery time and e-commerce.</P>
151: <P ALIGN="JUSTIFY">Collected data also show that, depending on the nature of the traded good, e-commerce may not be the ultimate stage of development for a web site. Ten companies out of 12 recognised in the nature of textile products an obstacle to e-commerce. Indeed, the non-standard features of textiles can be properly evaluated only by direct contact. Company 9 further stresses this argument. The firm, a spinning mill, projects to implement e-commerce solutions, but limited to raw yarn, a product characterised by standard features.</P>
152: <P ALIGN="JUSTIFY">Only one firm (Company 3) underlined the importance of the Internet as a source of information about raw materials prices and potential suppliers: on the contrary, all firms in the sample tended to stress the importance of the Internet as a client-oriented tool. The downstream orientation of web site holders may reduce the awareness of Internet related benefits: not only a source of increased turnover, but also a source of reduced costs, through the rationalisation of purchases. From this point of view, initiatives such as the experimental on-line stock exchange for raw materials and yarn (Borsa materie prime e filati) run by the local Chamber of Industry may serve as a stimulus to further explore the Internet potentialities also on the supply side.</P>
153: <P ALIGN="JUSTIFY"></P>
154: <I><P ALIGN="JUSTIFY">Reactive or pro-active approach?</P>
155: </I><P ALIGN="JUSTIFY">Ten out of the twelve interviewed entrepreneurs quoted the desire to increase the firm’s visibility as a reason to build up their web site. On the contrary, no one justified the entry on-line as a reaction to the web sites opened by competitors. Wait-and-see behaviours were detected for the introduction of e-commerce (<I>e.g.</I>, Company 3), mainly justified by the recognised lack of specific competencies and the desire to wait for a more mature attitude by clients.</P>
156: <P ALIGN="JUSTIFY">For sure, the Internet is currently regarded as a complementary marketing channel rather than an alternative to the existing ones. Once more, this attitude is strongly influenced by the characteristics of the considered industry and the involved products: as already reported, various interviewed companies underlined the impact of the product features on the actual chance of implementing e-commerce solutions.</P>
157: <P ALIGN="JUSTIFY"></P>
158: <I><P ALIGN="JUSTIFY">4.3. Are Internet-based applications helping SMEs to face the challenge of globalisation?</P>
159: <P ALIGN="JUSTIFY"></P>
160: <P ALIGN="JUSTIFY">E-business as a means to internationalise the district</P>
161: </I><P ALIGN="JUSTIFY">Foreign markets absorb an important share of the output of all interviewed companies: only in one case (Company 8) exports are less than 50% of turnover. Performed interviews outlined that the Internet is increasingly perceived as a tool for improving the quality of the relationship with trade agents. Given the diversification of foreign markets and the difficulty of building up proprietary sales networks, multifirm agents often represent a mandatory choice for SMEs. However, the firm’s products compete with competitors’ products in the agent’s portfolio, and several companies reported problems in managing the network of multifirm agents (<I>e.g.</I>, Companies 3 and 9). Accordingly, a growing number of companies relies to the Internet as a solution to focus the attention of multifirm agents on their products thanks to a higher level of involvement.</P>
162: <P ALIGN="JUSTIFY">In order to improve the quality of their presence abroad, 4 companies declared their commitment to opening a commercial branch in a foreign country, 2 stated they are planning a joint venture with a foreign partner, and 4 reported their interest in entering international alliances or agreements. However, no company in the examined sample owns foreign direct investments: moreover, they do not contemplate such an option in the forthcoming future. The lack of interest for the internationalisation of productive activities in order to increase the company’s competitiveness is justified by two issues. </P>
163:
164: <UL>
165: <P ALIGN="JUSTIFY"><LI>First, the production of the district of Prato is characterised by intense variability: all interviewed entrepreneurs pointed out the capability of interpreting emerging fashion trends and complying with specific requirements from customers as a key factor for surviving in an increasingly competitive environment. Accordingly, given the fragmentation of the value chain among a large number of local specialised suppliers, effective and efficient communication becomes a must in order to implement quickly the required changes in the scheduled production. By hampering direct contacts, a greater physical distance between client and supplier firms would obstacle mutual understanding on structured and less structured issues, and delay the reactivity of production systems.</LI></P>
166: <P ALIGN="JUSTIFY"><LI>Second, the high impact of the locally available core competencies on the quality of the final product is perceived as an obstacle to the internationalisation of productive activities (Company 2). At the same time, some entrepreneurs (<I>e.g.</I> Company 9) explicitly indicated the export of know-how through the internationalisation of production as a threat to the uniqueness of the district capabilities.</LI></P></UL>
167:
168: <P ALIGN="JUSTIFY">The development of e-business does not seem to affect the above issues, which mainly relate to the transfer of tacit knowledge. Accordingly, e-business does not currently look as a tool able to trigger processes of productive internationalisation. On the contrary, an interest exists to use e-business as a means for reinforcing commercial internationalisation. As a matter of fact, no one among the interviewed entrepreneurs declared that the web site was specifically implemented to reach new foreign clients: the entrepreneurs reported the activation of new contacts through the web site (Company 4, 5, and 9), but more as a "beneficial side effect" than as a pursued one. This attitude also reflects in the features of implemented web site functions, such as on-line catalogues for registered clients (Company 3), information on products availability for clients and agents (Company 7 and 10), information on delivery time (Company 5), on-line bulletin news for trade agents (Company 2). All these services are specifically oriented at improving the relationship with existing clients and agents, <I>i.e.</I>, with economic subjects with whom the company already established consolidated relationships.</P>
169: <P ALIGN="JUSTIFY"></P>
170: <I><P ALIGN="JUSTIFY">The location paradox</P>
171: </I><P ALIGN="JUSTIFY">For all interviewed companies, an apparent opposition exists: production activities are concentrated at the district level, while trade activities span all over the world. Apart from Company 2, all fabric manufacturers limit their manufacturing activity to the production of samples collection and to quality controls. Manufacturing activities to fulfil acquired orders are performed by a relatively high number of smaller suppliers, selected and co-ordinated by the fabric manufacturer. Even if to a different extent, this consideration also applies to interviewed companies in other stages of the textile value chain: only Company 9, a spinning mill, runs a partially integrated production. The high degree of labour division witnesses two critic success factors in the district of Prato: </P>
172:
173: <UL>
174: <P ALIGN="JUSTIFY"><LI>first, the crucial role of timely and effective communication among economic actors, which involves high reliance of district firms on their co-located suppliers; </LI></P>
175: <P ALIGN="JUSTIFY"><LI>second, the importance of suppliers’ competencies, given their high impact on the performance of the downstream firm.</LI></P></UL>
176:
177: <P ALIGN="JUSTIFY">Accordingly, it is not surprising that e-business initiatives undertaken by interviewed companies develop outside rather than inside the district. E-business initiatives rely on structured information and explicit knowledge, and are therefore unfit to cope with the informal contacts required by the extensive division of labour which characterises the district of Prato.</P>
178: <P ALIGN="JUSTIFY">On the contrary, the performed analysis outlined an often pro-active attitude in promoting e-business initiatives outside the district, mainly involving sales and marketing activities. In summary, collected evidence seems to reinforce what stated by Enright and Ffowcs-Williams (2000): "In general, globalisation will tend to lead to the concentration rather than dispersion of economic activities if its driving forces have a greater impact on marketing than on production".</P>
179: <P ALIGN="JUSTIFY"></P>
180: <OL START=5>
181:
182: <B><P ALIGN="JUSTIFY"><LI>Conclusions</LI></P></OL>
183:
184: </B><P ALIGN="JUSTIFY">The present paper investigated SMEs’ attitude and perception towards e-business within the context of the textile district of Prato. Despite the limited number of considered companies, some interesting results emerged.</P>
185:
186: <UL>
187: <P ALIGN="JUSTIFY"><LI>On-line companies believe that, despite the reduced current impact, Internet will become in the future an important source of competitive advantage. Many interviewed companies project to empower their web sites, and also sites initially conceived as non-interactive ones progressively enriched, witnessing the existence of learning processes.</LI></P></UL>
188:
189:
190: <UL>
191: <P ALIGN="JUSTIFY"><LI>The characteristics of the considered products (textiles) remarkably affect the evolutionary paths followed by firms in exploring Internet potentiality.</LI></P>
192: <P ALIGN="JUSTIFY"><LI>Also the district structure strongly influences the entrepreneurs’ choices in terms of on-line presence. Web site services must take into account existing equipment and competencies both inside and outside the firm. </LI></P>
193: <P ALIGN="JUSTIFY"><LI>However, entrepreneurs’ initiatives outline the will and the capability to reap available benefits by implementing "creative" on-line services which overcome or go around existing constrains. If e-commerce of fabrics is hampered by the product features, on-line order of samples allows anyway to speed up the order cycle. If intra-district flows of tacit knowledge prevent the effective resort to the Internet with local suppliers, attention focuses on e-relationships with final clients.</LI></P></UL>
194:
195: <P ALIGN="JUSTIFY">Empirical findings show that the cultural substrate of the industrial district represents a noteworthy restriction to the introduction of ICTs. In fact, the need for codification and standardisation of information and routines discourages the animal spirits dwelling the district, and crucial information and expertise tend to remain embodied within products rather than being codified and exchanged through newer and quicker channels. The creation and the development of knowledge and competencies is likely to remain within the real (as opposed to the virtual) district, as they are hardly reproducible on-line. Nonetheless, on-line advertising of a district common brand could foster significant positive externalities. </P>
196: <P ALIGN="JUSTIFY">The evidence has shown that only few representative firms of the district might be able to embrace the full range of opportunities provided by e-business, and to implement large projects. Nonetheless, our conviction is that isolated actions couldn’t foster any collective learning and growth, but only compromise the structure of the district itself. On the contrary, the joined involvement of institutions, industrial and service firms (TLCs operators, banks, etc) firms, as well as other local actors (industrial associations, labour unions, etc) should address the restructuring of the actual organisation model. Local institutions, in particular, are called to focus their efforts in order to drive SMEs towards the new forms of business, which should in turn be sized for them and the district’s growth. Specifically, efforts should be directed to: (i) enlighten firms to invest in more courageous projects for their presence on line. In fact, so far, the bulk of existing projects pertains only to the exploitation of cheap virtual promotion; (ii) provide firms with the technological platforms needed for supporting their relationships, and with <I>ad hoc</I> education and training programs. </P></BODY>
197: </HTML>
198: