1: \begin{abstract}

2: A variety of shooting methods for computing fully discrete

3: time-periodic solutions of partial differential equations, including

4: Newton-Krylov and optimization-based methods, are discussed and used

5: to determine the periodic, compressible, viscous flow around a 2D

6: flapping airfoil. The Newton-Krylov method uses matrix-free GMRES to

7: solve the linear systems of equations that arise in the nonlinear

8: iterations, with matrix-vector products computed via the linearized

9: sensitivity evolution equations. The adjoint method is used to compute

10: gradients for the gradient-based optimization shooting methods. The

11: Newton-Krylov method is shown to exhibit superior convergence to the

12: optimal solution for these fluid problems, and fully leverages

13: quality starting data.

14: 

15: The central contribution of this work is the derivation of the

16: adjoint equations and the corresponding adjoint method for fully discrete,

17: time-periodically constrained partial differential equations. These adjoint

18: equations constitute a linear, two-point boundary value problem that is

19: provably solvable.  The periodic adjoint method is used to compute gradients

20: of quantities of interest along the manifold of time-periodic solutions of the

21: discrete partial differential equation, which is verified against a

22: second-order finite difference approximation. These gradients are then used in

23: a gradient-based optimization framework to determine the energetically optimal

24: flapping motion of a 2D airfoil in compressible, viscous flow over a single

25: cycle, such that the time-averaged thrust is identically zero. In less than

26: $20$ optimization iterations, the flapping energy was reduced nearly an order

27: of magnitude and the thrust constraint satisfied to $5$ digits of accuracy.

28: \end{abstract}

29: