1: \begin{abstract}

2: This paper presents a theoretical and numerical investigation of the following practical question:

3: Should the time difference quotients of the snapshots be used to generate the proper orthogonal decomposition basis functions?

4: The answer to this question is important, since some published numerical studies use the time difference quotients, whereas other numerical studies do not.

5: The criterion used in this paper to answer this question is the rate of convergence of the error of the reduced order model with respect to the number of proper orthogonal decomposition basis functions.

6: Two cases are considered: the $no\_DQ$ case, in which the snapshot difference quotients are not used, and the $DQ$ case, in which the snapshot difference quotients are used.

7: The error estimates suggest that the convergence rates in the $C^0(L^2)$-norm and in the $C^0(H^1)$-norm are optimal for the $DQ$ case, but suboptimal for the $no\_DQ$ case.

8: The convergence rates in the $L^2(H^1)$-norm are optimal for both the $DQ$ case and the $no\_DQ$ case.

9: Numerical tests are conducted on the heat equation and on the Burgers equation.

10: The numerical results support the conclusions drawn from the theoretical error estimates.

11: Overall, the theoretical and numerical results strongly suggest that, in order to achieve optimal pointwise in time rates of convergence with respect to the number of proper orthogonal decomposition basis functions, one should use the snapshot difference quotients.

12: 

13: %\blue{Traian: finish!}

14: \end{abstract}

15: