1: \begin{abstract}

2: Wilson chiral perturbation theory (WChPT)

3: is the effective field theory describing the

4: long-distance properties of lattice QCD with 

5: Wilson or twisted-mass fermions.

6: We consider here WChPT for the theory with

7: two light flavors of Wilson fermions or a single light twisted-mass fermion.

8: Discretization errors introduce three low energy constants (LECs)

9: into partially quenched WChPT at ${\cal O}(a^2)$, conventionally

10: called $W_6'$, $W_7'$ and $W_8'$. The phase structure of the

11: theory at non-zero $a$ depends on the sign of the combination

12: $2 W'_6+W'_8$, while the spectrum of the lattice Hermitian

13: Wilson-Dirac operator depends on all three constants.

14: It has been argued, based on the positivity of 

15: partition functions of fixed topological charge, 

16: and on the convergence of graded group integrals

17: that arise in the $\epsilon$-regime of ChPT,

18: that there is a constraint on the

19: LECs arising from the underlying lattice theory. In particular,

20: for $W_6'=W_7'=0$, the constraint found is $W'_8\le0$.

21: Here we provide an alternative line of argument, based on mass inequalities

22: for the underlying partially quenched theory.

23: We find that $W'_8\le0$, irrespective of the values of $W'_6$

24: and $W'_7$. 

25: Our constraint implies that $2 W'_6> |W'_8|$

26: if the phase diagram is to be described by the first-order

27: scenario, as recent simulations suggest is the case for some

28: choices of action.

29: 

30: %

31: \end{abstract}

32: