1: \begin{abstract}

2: We study spatially semidiscrete and fully discrete finite volume

3: element methods for the homogeneous heat equation with

4: homogeneous Dirichlet boundary conditions and derive error estimates

5: for smooth and nonsmooth initial data. We show that the results of

6: our earlier work \cite{clt11} for the lumped mass method carry over to

7: the present situation. In particular, in order for error estimates for

8: initial data only in $L_2$ to be of optimal second order for positive

9: time, a special condition is required, which is satisfied for

10: symmetric triangulations. Without any such condition, only first order

11: convergence can be shown, which is  illustrated by a counterexample.

12: Improvements  hold for triangulations that are almost symmetric and

13: piecewise almost symmetric.

14: \end{abstract}

15: