1: \begin{proof}

2: If $\mathtt{u}(c)\mathtt{u}(d)^{\ast}$ is a web, 

3: then every face has an even number 

4: of adjacent trivalent vertices which translate to 

5: say that $cd^{\ast}$ has an even number of markers 

6: per connected component, and we are done.

7: 

8: Conversely, assume (without loss of generality) that 

9: $cd^{\ast}$ has only one circle $C$, and that $C$ is orientable. 

10: If $C$ is not marked, then 

11: we are done since the associated circle in $\mathtt{u}(c)\mathtt{u}(d)^{\ast}$ is 

12: an ordinary circle. Otherwise, follow $C$ from $\rpoint$ onwards in the 

13: anticlockwise fashion. 

14: By admissibility, going around $C$ in this way always passes the 

15: marked caps in $d^{\ast}$ and then the marked cups in $c$. This can be best seen via example 

16: (we leave it to the reader to make this rigorous):

17: \begin{gather}\label{eq:proof-by-example}

18: \xy

19: (0,0)*{

20: \includegraphics[scale=.85]{figs/6-83.pdf}

21: };

22: \endxy

23: \end{gather}

24: Next, the number of markers on $C$ is even since 

25: $cd^{\ast}$ is orientable.  

26: This together with the above observation 

27: (and recalling that taking ${}^{\ast}$ on webs 

28: reverses the orientation of phantom edges) 

29: ensures that 

30: all 

31: neighboring phantom edge pairs of $\mathtt{u}(c)\mathtt{u}(d)^{\ast}$ 

32: are well-attached, and that $\mathtt{u}(c)\mathtt{u}(d)^{\ast}$ 

33: has an even number of trivalent vertices, i.e. 

34: $\mathtt{u}(c)\mathtt{u}(d)^{\ast}$ 

35: is well-oriented.

36: \end{proof}

37: