1: 

2: \documentclass{ws-p8-50x6-00}

3: \def\rightnote{{\it \ \ Quantum Gravity at the GR16}}

4: \begin{document}

5: \title{GR16: Quantum General Relativity}

6: \author{Carlo Rovelli}

7: 

8: \address{Physics Department, University of Pittsburgh, PA-15260, USA\\

9: Centre de Physique Theorique, Luminy, Marseille, F-13288, EU\\ 

10: E-mail: rovelli@cpt.univ-mrs.fr}

11: 

12: \maketitle \abstracts{This is the report of the 

13: {\em Quantum General Relativity\/} session, at the 16th International

14: Conference on General Relativity \& Gravitation, held on July 15th to

15: 21st 2001, in Durban, South Africa.  This report will appear on the

16: Proceedings of the conference.}

17: 

18: \section{Highlights}

19: 

20: Current research in quantum gravity is very lively.  The research is

21: actively developing both towards the construction of the fundamental

22: theory and towards applications.

23: 

24: A large part of the efforts to develop the general theory of the

25: quantum gravitational field is presently concentrated in {\em loop

26: quantum gravity,} in its various forms.  The general theory of loop

27: quantum gravity was reviewed at this conference in a plenary talk by

28: Abhay Ashtekar.  In the session, several specific aspects of the

29: theory were discussed.  The current efforts to understand the low

30: energy behavior of loop quantum gravity were reviewed by Abhay

31: Ashtekar and Jerzy Lewandowski.  The covariant spacetime version of

32: the theory, denoted {\em spinfoam\/} theory, and some notable

33: finiteness results due also to Alejandro Perez and Louis Crane were

34: illustrated by myself.  Various aspects of the discreteness of the

35: geometry predicted by loop quantum gravity were discussed by Seth

36: Major.  Unfortunately, Martin Bojowald had to cancel his participation

37: to the conference at the last minute, and his scheduled communication

38: on his exciting recent results on the application of loop quantum

39: gravity to the initial singularity had to be cancelled.  The

40: simplicial approach, whose recent developments were reviewed by Ruth

41: Williams, has also recently converged with loop quantum gravity.  In

42: fact, on the one hand the spinfoam formalism include the Barrett Crane

43: simplicial model, on the other hand it can be viewed as the covariant

44: version of (canonical) loop quantum gravity.  Altogether, loop

45: quantum gravity appears to be in a very exciting phase of intense

46: development and novel results.

47: 

48: Other approaches to quantum gravity were considered in the session as

49: well.  In particular: non commutative geometry (Kamesh Wali), the

50: string motivated AdS/CFT theory (Robert Mann), lattice and functional

51: formalisms (Renate Loll).

52: 

53: The most studied applications of quantum gravity are in black hole

54: physics, gravitational collapse, and cosmological models.  The

55: application of quantum gravity to gravitational collapse is a long

56: studied problem.  A new and rather surprising results presented by

57: Peter H\'aj{\'\i}\v cek, obtained via a careful hamiltonian analysis

58: of the problem came therefore as a surprise: a shell bounces and

59: re-expands, and the singularity disappears.  The collapse problem was

60: discussed also by Mike Ryan, Cenalo Vaz and Valentin Gladush.

61: 

62: The most characteristic physical system for quantum gravity is

63: certainly the quantum black hole.  There are now two well-known

64: derivations of the Bekenstein-Hawking black hole entropy from a

65: complete quantum gravity theory, obtained respectively within string

66: theory and within loop quantum gravity.  But a complete physical

67: understanding of the quantum black hole thermal behavior is not yet

68: available, and the problem keeps raising interest.  The problem was

69: discussed in the session by Steven Carlip, Gabor Kunstatter and Louis

70: Witten.  Finally, a cosmological model with a perfect fluid was discussed by

71: Julio Fabris.  

72: 

73: I'll now illustrate all the contributions to the session in more

74: detail.

75: 

76: \section{General theory: loop quantum gravity}

77: 

78: \begin{description}

79: 

80: \item[\em Abhay Ashtekar: ``Semiclassical issues in nonperturbative QG" ] 

81: Ashtekar discussed the use of a detailed mathematical theory of

82: quantum geometry, in order to analyze the fundamental discreteness of

83: spacetime predicted by loop quantum gravity.  This discreteness makes

84: it difficult to relate the underlying `polymer excitations' of quantum

85: geometry to the Fock states normally used in low energy physics.  To

86: bridge this gap, using some recent results of Varadarajan, Ashtekar

87: and Lewandowski have located, analyzed and used Minkowskian Fock

88: states in the background independent framework.  The fundamental

89: discreteness is lost in the standard semi-classical description

90: because Fock states constitute only a small subset of all

91: non-perturbative states.  While the quantum geometry operators have

92: purely discrete eigenvalues in the full theory, none of these

93: eigenvectors belong to the Fock space.  This framework is well-suited

94: to address two key questions: Can the background-independent,

95: non-perturbative theory reproduce the familiar low-energy physics on,

96: say, suitable coarse graining?  and, Can one pin-point where and why

97: perturbation theory fails?  Ashtekar described work in progress on

98: both these fronts. 

99: 

100: \item[\em Carlo Rovelli: ``Spin foam models" ]  A spin foam model can be

101: seen as the covariant, or Feynman integral, version of a loop quantum

102: gravity theory.  A spin foam represents a four-geometry and the model

103: is formulated as a sum over these four-geometries.  Remarkably, there

104: is a duality between these models and certain particular field

105: theories defined on group manifolds (Group Field Theory, or GFT).  The

106: sum over spin foam can be generated as the Feynman perturbative

107: expansion of the GFT. Each spacetime appears therefore as the Feynman

108: graph of the auxiliary GFT theory.  This phenomenon is a 4d analog of

109: a phenomenon first noticed in 2d quantum gravity, or ```zero

110: dimensional string theory", where the spacetime could be obtained as

111: Feynman graphs of an auxiliary matrix model.  The main result

112: presented is that (up to certain degenerate terms) the theory is {\em

113: finite\/} order by order in the perturbation expansion.  This allows

114: finite three-geometry to three-geometry transition amplitudes to be

115: perturbatively computed explicitly in the physical, lorentzian, 4d

116: theory.

117: 

118: \item[\em Seth Major: ``Discrete geometry" ]  Major presented recent

119: results on the spectra of the angle, area, and volume operators,

120: including limits placed on the level of discreteness by semiclassical

121: behavior and classic tests of fundamental physics.

122: 

123: \item[\em Ruth Williams: ``Progress in discrete quantum gravity" ] 

124: Approaches to discrete quantum gravity include sums over histories

125: using the simplicial analogue of the Einstein action formulated by

126: Regge, and state sum models, such as the Ponzano-Regge and Turaev-Viro

127: models in three dimensions and the Barrett-Crane model in four

128: dimensions.  There has been a remarkable convergence with the loop

129: quantum gravity approach, in recent years.  Williams described

130: progress with simplicial and state sum models, including a discrete

131: version of the calculation of the ground state wave function for

132: linearized gravity, and an investigation of perturbations of

133: three-dimensional state sum models.

134: 

135: \end{description}

136: 

137: \section{General theory: others}

138: \begin{description}

139: 

140: \item[\em Kamesh Wali: ``Action functionals on a two-sheeted spacetime" ]

141: Wali proposes a model of left- and right- chiral fields living on the

142: two-sheeted space-time along with two distinct gauge fields, within

143: the framework of non-commutative geometry.  The mathematics presented

144: generalizes the fundamental concepts of Riemannian geometry, such as

145: differential forms, connection and curvature.  The model has a rich

146: and complex structure with new interaction terms to be explored.  One

147: of them is a parity violating interaction arising from the

148: gravitational sector of their generalized theory.

149: 

150: \item[\em Robert Mann: ``Conserved quantities in AdS/CFT" ]  The talk

151: reported on work concerning the problem of defining conserved charges

152: in gravitational theory.  This is a long-standing problem in general

153: relativity -- the equivalence principle implies that locally gravity

154: cannot be distinguished from acceleration, and the problem of defining

155: a local measure of gravitational energy and angular momentum has

156: remained elusive.  A reasonable measure of success has been attained

157: in recent years using the Brown/York quasilocal formalism, which

158: proposes a definition of conserved quantities enclosed by a $(d-2)$

159: surface in $d$ dimensions.  A generic problem with the quasilocal

160: formalism is that the conserved quantities typically diverge as the

161: mean radial size of the enclosed surface becomes infinite.  A recent

162: proposal inspired by the AdS/CFT correspondence offers a potential

163: resolution to this difficulty.  This conjectured correspondence states

164: that a quantum theory of gravity whose boundary conditions are the

165: same as those of asymptotically anti de Sitter (AdS) spacetime is in

166: 1-1 correspondence with a quantum conformal field theory (CFT) defined

167: on the boundary of this spacetime.  Quantum field theories generically

168: have counterterms, and the correspondence suggests that these

169: counterterms should be geometric invariants of the induced metric on

170: the boundary at infinity.  Employing this proposal, Mann computed the

171: energy, angular momentum and entropy of spacetimes containing rotating

172: black holes with NUT charge (ie in the general Kerr-NUT-anti de Sitter

173: class).  He found in all cases that the conserved quantities were

174: finite.  No reference spacetime was required at any stage of the

175: calculation.  He then showed how to extend this prescription to

176: asymptotically flat spacetimes, and obtained corresponding results

177: that are finite.  The interpretation of these quantities in

178: spacetimes with NUT charge is still obscure.

179: 

180: \item[\em Renate Loll: ``The conformal factor problem" ] Under certain

181: assumption on the behavior of the partition function under

182: renormalization, one finds the interesting result that the well known

183: divergence due to the conformal modes is cancelled by a Faddeev-Popov

184: determinant.  This result confirms that absence of the conformal

185: sickness noticed by Loll in the lorentzian lattice models.

186: 

187: \end{description}

188: 

189: 

190: \section{Gravitational collapse}

191: 

192: \begin{description}

193: \item[\em Peter H\'aj{\'\i}\v cek: ``Gravitational collapse" ]

194: H\'aj{\'\i}\v cek studies the quantum dynamics of a self-gravitating

195: null shell for the spherically symmetric case, using only gauge

196: invariant quantities (Dirac observables).  The definition of evolution

197: is based on an asymptotically non-trivial symmetry of the model (time

198: translation element of the BMS group).  H\'aj{\'\i}\v cek proves in

199: particular, that a version of quantum theory exists, in which the

200: shell bounces and re-expands, and in which the singularity disappears. 

201: The quantum metric outside the shell contains a time-dependent mixture

202: of black and white holes.  These remarkable and surprising results

203: raised much interest and a lively discussion, in the session.

204: 

205: \item[\em Michael Ryan: ``Quantum collapse of dust shell: solutions" ] 

206: A hamiltonian formulation of the problem of the collapse of a dust

207: shell given by H\'aj{\'\i}\v cek and Kijowski and Kucha\v r allows one

208: to study the the minisuperspace problem of the quantum collapse of a

209: spherically symmetric dust shell, albeit with a very complicated

210: Hamiltonian operator.  Ryan presented both analytic approximate

211: solutions and exact numerical solutions to the problem.  Since the

212: solutions involve only geometrical variables defined on the shell, it

213: is necessary to reconstruct the quantum spacetime geometry around the

214: shell (possible in this special spherically symmetric case) in order

215: to discuss the interpretation of the solutions in terms of spacetime

216: geometry, especially the position of the shell with respect to

217: horizons.  This allowed Ryan to consider the quantum evolution of the

218: shell in spacetime.

219: 

220: \item[\em Cenalo Vaz: ``LeMaitre-Tolman-Bondi collapse" ]  Vaz applied the

221: Kuchar transformation to LeMaitre-Tolman-Bondi models of inhomogeneous

222: dust collapse.  Dirac's constraint quantization leads to a simple

223: Wheeler-DeWitt equation with a general mass function.  A solution was

224: presented over the entire class of models considered.  These solutions

225: cover collapse into both black holes and naked singularities (up to

226: the Cauchy Horizon) and can be employed in the study of quantum

227: gravitational effects in the final stages of collapse with different

228: initial conditions as well as, it is hoped, in the study of

229: inhomogeneous cosmologies.

230: 

231: \item[\em Valentin Gladush: ``Quasiclassical spherical

232: configuration" ]  Gladush has considered a quasi-classical model of

233: self-gravitating spherical dust shell, and studied the energy

234: spectrum using quasi-classical quantization rules, and the stability

235: of the system.

236: 

237: \end{description}

238: 

239: \section{Black holes}

240: \begin{description}

241: \item[\em Steven Carlip: ``Boundary conditions, constraints, BH entropy" ]  

242: Recent work by a number of authors has suggested that black hole

243: entropy may have a microscopic description in terms of a boundary

244: conformal field theory, living either near the horizon or at spatial

245: infinity.  Carlip described a new approach to boundary conditions near

246: such a boundary, in which the fall-off requirements are introduced as

247: a set of second class constraints that modify the algebra of

248: diffeomorphisms.  For Liouville theory in a dynamical background, this

249: approach leads to the standard central charge; for dilaton gravity,

250: the result is a Virasoro algebra with a classical central charge of

251: the form required to explain the Bekenstein-Hawking entropy.

252: 

253: \item[\em Gabor Kunstatter: ``Quantum Mechanics of Charged BHs" ]

254: Basic properties of black hole thermodynamics were used to quantize

255: generic charged black holes in the Euclidean sector.  The analysis led

256: to a discrete spectrum for the horizon area that is qualitatively

257: consistent with the results of Bekenstein, Mukhanov and others, but

258: different from the spectrum predicted by loop quantum gravity.  In

259: particular, the area spectrum was shown generically to be equally

260: spaced.  Quantization of the charge sector gave the condition $Q=me$,

261: for integer $m$, as expected, but a consistency condition constrained

262: the fine structure constant $e^2/\hbar$ to be a rational number.  Near

263: extremal black holes were shown to be highly quantum objects. 

264: Moreover, with a standard choice of factor ordering, extremal black

265: holes did not appear in the physical spectrum at all.

266: 

267: \item[\em Louis Witten: ``BH Quantization in Canonical Gravity" ] 

268: Witten started from the observation that the Schwarzschild black hole

269: can be viewed as a special case of the marginally bound

270: LeMaitre-Tolman-Bondi models of dust collapse corresponding to a

271: constant mass function.  Using a midi-superspace quantization of the

272: collapse for an arbitrary mass function illustrated in this same

273: session by C Vaz, Witten showed that the solution leads both to

274: Bekensteins’s area spectrum for black holes as well as to the black

275: hole entropy.  In this context, the entropy is naturally interpreted

276: as the loss of information of the original matter distribution within

277: the collapsing cloud.

278: 

279: \end{description}

280: 

281: \section{Finite dimensional models}

282: 

283: \begin{description}

284: 

285: \item[\em Julio Fabris: ``Quantum cosmological perfect fluid" ]   Fabris

286: quantized the gravity-perfect fluid system, employing the Schutz's

287: formalism.  The matter degrees of freedom allow to recover the notion

288: of time.  Wave-functions are obtained in closed form, in the

289: mini-superspace, and the expectation value for the scale factor is

290: computed, yielding a singularity-free, bouncing Universe.  He showed

291: that these results are recovered by a classical system where, besides

292: the ordinary matter employed in the quantization procedure, a

293: universal repulsive fluid with a stiff matter equation of state is

294: added. 

295: 

296: \end{description}

297: \end{document}

298: 

299: