1: \chapter{Applications and Conclusions}
2: \label{CONC}
3:
4: Some applications of the self-force caclulation are presented in this chapter and some important conclusions are drawn.
5: The effects of the scalar self-force are presented in detail.
6: The case of the gravitational self-force is also discussed.
7:
8: \section{Equations of Motion}
9: \label{CONCEM}
10:
11: In Chapter \ref{UFM} it was explained how the self-force on different particles moving in curved spacetime
12: can be calculated.
13: Since the ultimate goal is the determination of the motion of those particles, it is important to know how the self-force affects the equations of motion as well.
14:
15: Assume that a point particle that carries a finite charge $q$ (which can be a scalar charge, an electric charge or the mass of the particle)
16: is moving in a known background spacetime which is characterized by the metric $g_{ab}$.
17: For simplicity also assume that no other (external to the particle) scalar, electromagnetic or gravitational fields exist.
18: If the effects of the charge $q$ are ignored, the point particle moves on a background geodesic.
19: If the geodesic is described by $z^a(s)$, where $s$ is the proper time and $u^a$ is the tangent to the geodesic, the geodesic equation is
20: \begin{equation}
21: u^a \nabla_a u^b = 0
22: \end{equation}
23: where $\nabla_a$ is the covariant derivative with respect to the background metric $g_{ab}$.
24: The geodesic is assumed to be parametrized so that
25: \begin{equation}
26: u^a u_a = -1.
27: \label{uaua}
28: \end{equation}
29:
30: If the interaction of the particle with its own fields is to be taken into account, the self-force $\mathcal{F}_{\tx{self}}^{a}$ should be included into the equations of motion.
31: Specifically, if $m$ is the mass of the particle, the equation that holds is
32: \begin{equation}
33: m u^a \nabla_a u^b = \mathcal{F}_{\tx{self}}^b
34: \label{SFGeodesic}
35: \end{equation}
36: where $\mathcal{F}_{\tx{self}}^a$ is given by Equations (\ref{ScalarSF1}), (\ref{EMSF1}) and (\ref{GravSF1}) for the scalar, electromagnetic and gravitational field respectively and is of $O(q^2)$.
37:
38: \section{Effects of the Scalar Self-Force}
39: \label{EffectSF}
40:
41: In general, Equation (\ref{SFGeodesic}) gives the effect of the self-force on each component
42: of the 4-velocity of a scalar particle moving in spacetime, when the correct expression for the scalar self-force is substituted.
43: If the spherically symmetric Schwarzschild background is considered, it is easily deduced that only 3 components of the 4-velocity are affected by the self-force.
44: Indeed, as is explained in \cite{Wald}, the Schwarzschild metric has parity reflection symmetry $\theta \to \pi - \theta$,
45: so if the initial position $x^a$ and the initial tangent $u^a$ both lie on the equatorial plane $(\theta=\frac{\pi}{2})$ then the entire path must lie on the equatorial plane as well.
46: In addition, due to the spherical symmetry of the Schwarzschild background, every path can be brought by a rotation to the equatorial plane.
47: Consequently one can only consider equatorial orbits, without imposing any real restriction on the path of the particle.
48: The analysis that follows will be presented in \cite{dwdm} in more detail.
49:
50: Assume that a trajectory of the Schwarzschild background is described by the coordinates
51: \begin{equation}
52: x^a : \{ t_{\tx{s}} = \tau(s), r = R(s), \theta=\frac{\pi}{2}, \phi=\Phi(s) \}.
53: \end{equation}
54: If $E$ is the energy per unit mass and $J$ the angular momentum per unit mass of the particle, it can easily be shown that
55: \begin{equation}
56: \begin{split}
57: u^a &= \frac{dx^a}{ds} = \Big ( \frac{ER}{(R-2M)}, \: \dot{R},\: 0, \: \frac{J}{R^2} \Big ) \\
58: u_a &= g_{ab} u^a = \Big ( -E, \: \frac{\dot{R}R}{(R-2M)},\: 0,\: J \Big ).\\
59: \end{split}
60: \label{SchPath}
61: \end{equation}
62: The normalization condition given in Equation (\ref{uaua}) for the 4-velocity gives a relationship between $E$, $J$ and $\dot{R}$, specifically
63: \begin{equation}
64: E^2- \dot{R}^2 = \Big ( 1+\frac{J^2}{R^2} \Big ) \Big ( 1 - \frac{2M}{R} \Big ).
65: \label{Normal}
66: \end{equation}
67: If the interaction of the scalar particle with its own field is to be taken into account, the geodesic equation is modified to
68: \begin{equation}
69: u^a \nabla_a u_b = q \nabla_b \psi^{\tx{R}}.
70: \label{GeodesicPlusSF}
71: \end{equation}
72: Calculating the non-vanishing components of Equation (\ref{GeodesicPlusSF}) gives three separate equations, namely
73: \begin{eqnarray}
74: -\frac{du_t}{ds} &=& \frac{dE}{ds} = -q \partial_t \psi^{\tx{R}} \\ \label{dEds}
75: \frac{du_{\phi}}{ds} &=& \frac{dJ}{ds} = q \partial_{\phi} \psi^{\tx{R}} \\ \label{dphids}
76: \frac{d\dot{R}}{ds} &=& -\frac{M}{R^2} + \frac{R-3M}{R^4} J^2 + \frac{R-2M}{R} q \partial_r \psi^{\tx{R}}.
77: \label{dRdotds}
78: \end{eqnarray}
79:
80: In order to predict the effect of the self-force on circular orbits, one can assume that $\dot{R} =0$ and $\ddot{R}=0$ at some instant.
81: Then Equation (\ref{dRdotds}) gives the simple expression
82: \begin{equation}
83: J^2 = \frac{R^4}{R-3M} \Big ( \frac{M}{R^2} - \frac{R-2M}{R} q \partial_r \psi^{\tx{R}} \Big )
84: \label{CircOrb1}
85: \end{equation}
86: which gives the effect of the self-force on the angular momentum per unit mass of the scalar particle.
87:
88: Also, Equation (\ref{Normal}) gives
89: \begin{equation}
90: E^2 = \Big ( 1-\frac{2M}{R} \Big ) \Big ( 1+\frac{J^2}{R^2} \Big ).
91: \label{CircOrb2}
92: \end{equation}
93: Combining Equations (\ref{CircOrb1}) and (\ref{CircOrb2}) results in
94: \begin{equation}
95: E^2 = \frac{(R-2M)^2}{R (R-3M)} (1-qR\partial_r \psi^{\tx{R}})
96: \label{EnergySelfForce}
97: \end{equation}
98: which shows the effect of the self-force on the energy of the scalar particle.
99: All the results mentioned up to this point are exact.
100:
101: Since the effect of the scalar charge $q$ can be assumed to be small, the approximation
102: that $(R \partial_r \psi^{\tx{R}}) << 1$ can be made,
103: and Equation (\ref{EnergySelfForce}) for the energy $E$ can be written as
104: \begin{equation}
105: E = \frac{R-2M}{\sqrt{R(R-3M)}} (1-\frac{1}{2} q R\partial_r \psi^{\tx{R}}).
106: \label{CircOrb3}
107: \end{equation}
108:
109: The orbital frequency is defined as
110: \begin{equation}
111: \Omega' \equiv \frac{d\phi}{dt_{\tx{s}}} = \frac{J (R-2M)}{E R^3},
112: \label{OrbFreq}
113: \end{equation}
114: from Equation (\ref{SchPath}).
115: Substituting Equations (\ref{CircOrb1}) and (\ref{CircOrb3}) into Equation (\ref{OrbFreq}), and using again the approximation $(R \partial_r \psi^{\tx{R}}) << 1$, a simple expression for the effect of the self-force on the orbital frequency is obtained:
116: \begin{equation}
117: \Omega' = \sqrt{\frac{M}{R^3}} \Big [ 1 - \frac{1}{2} \frac{R(R-3M)}{M} q \partial_r \psi^{\tx{R}} \Big ].
118: \label{OrbFreqSF}
119: \end{equation}
120: As expected, if the interaction of the particle with its own scalar field is ignored, the well-known result $\Omega = \sqrt{MR^{-3}}$ is recovered.
121:
122:
123: \subsection{Calculation of the Self-Force}
124: \label{EffectSF1}
125:
126: A sample self-force calculation is presented in this section.
127: The scalar charge is assumed to be $q=1$ and to be moving on a circular orbit of radius $R=10M$ in a Schwarzschild background of $M=1$.
128:
129: The $lm$-components $\psi_{lm}(r)$ of the retarded field generated by the scalar charge and their contributions $\mathcal{F}_{l \: r}^{\tx{ret}}$ to the $l$-multipole modes of the retarded part of the self-force
130: are first calculated for $l=0,1, \ldots ,40$,
131: using the numerical code described in Chapter \ref{RSF} and given in Appendix \ref{A2}.
132: Then, the non-zero regularization parameters $A_r$, $B_r$ and $D_r$ are used \footnote{Remember that it was proven that $C_r=0$ for circular Schwarzschild orbits, in Chapter \ref{RP}.}
133: to subtract off the contributions of the singular-field self-force up to $O(l^{-2})$, according to Equation (\ref{SelfForceFinal}).
134: These results are shown in Figure (\ref{fig8_1}).
135: \begin{figure}[ht]
136: \centering
137: \includegraphics[height=10.1cm,width=13.1cm,clip]{res1.eps}
138: \caption{Scalar Self-Force}
139: \label{fig8_1}
140: \end{figure}
141: In that figure, the curve marked $F_l$ is the contribution $\mathcal{F}^{\tx{ret}}_{l\:r}$ as a function of $l$.
142: The curves marked $A$, $B$ and $D$ show the terms $(\mathcal{F}^{\tx{ret}}_{l\:r} - \mathcal{F}^{\tx{S}}_{l\:r})$ as functions of $l$, where $\mathcal{F}^{\tx{S}}_{l\:r}$ successively includes the contributions from the regularization parameters $A_r$, $B_r$ and $D_r$ respectively.
143: It is clear that the series for the self-force converges when the terms containing the regularization parameter $B_r$ are included.
144: However, the convergence becomes much faster the terms containing the parameter $D_r$ are also included.
145:
146: As is rigorously explained in \cite{detmeswhi},
147: the contributions from the $E_a$ terms in Equation (\ref{SelfForceFinal}) are successively
148: of order $l^{-4}$, $l^{-6}$, $\ldots$.
149: Specifically, the $O(l^{-4})$ term is associated with the parameter $E_r^1$,
150: the $O(l^{-6})$ term is associated with the parameter $E_r^2$ and,
151: in general, the $O(l^{-2k})$ term is associated with the parameter $E_r^{k-1}$.
152: The parameters $E_r^k$ are $l$-independent \cite{detmeswhi} and can be determined as follows.
153: The contribution from each term is proven \cite{detmeswhi} to be
154: \begin{equation}
155: E_r^{k} \frac{(2l+1)}{[ (2l-2k-1)(2l-2k+1) \ldots (3l+2k+1)(2k+2k+3)]} \mathcal{P}_{k+1/2}
156: \label{Residual}
157: \end{equation}
158: where
159: \begin{equation}
160: \mathcal{P}_{k+1/2} = \frac{(-1)^{k+1} 2^{k+\frac{3}{2}} }{[(2k+1)!!]^2}.
161: \end{equation}
162: Assume that the residual $(\mathcal{F}^{\tx{ret}}_{l\:r} - \mathcal{F}^{\tx{S}}_{l\:r})$ as a function of $l$,
163: resulting after the subtraction of the contribution of $A_r$, $B_r$ and $D_r$, is calculated.
164: The coefficients $E_r^k$ can be determined numerically by fitting that residual,
165: to a linear combination of terms of the form (\ref{Residual}) and successively removing their contributions.
166:
167: The curves marked $E^1, \ldots, E^5$ in Figure (\ref{fig8_1}) are the residuals resulting after the numerical fit of the parameters $E_r^1, \ldots, E^5_r$ respectively.
168: It was noticed that fitting more than four of the coefficients $E_r^k$ did not improve the residual, which had already reached machine accuracy by the fourth fitting.
169:
170:
171: \subsection{Change in Orbital Frequency}
172: \label{EffectSF2}
173:
174: It was shown in Section (\ref{EffectSF}) that the orbital frequency of the circular orbit
175: is affected by the self-force.
176: Using Equation (\ref{OrbFreqSF}) the difference in frequency can be calculated; it is
177: \begin{equation}
178: \frac{\Omega'-\Omega}{\Omega} = \frac{\Delta \Omega}{\Omega} = - \frac{1}{2} \frac{R(R-3M)}{M} q \partial_r \psi^{\tx{R}}.
179: \end{equation}
180: The effect of the self-force on the orbital frequency is shown in Figure (\ref{fig8_2}), where the ratio $(\Delta \Omega/\Omega)$ is plotted as a function of $(R/M)$.
181: The orbital frequency $\Omega$ before the self-force effects are included is also plotted for comparison.
182: \begin{figure}[h!]
183: \centering
184: \includegraphics[height=10.1cm,width=13.1cm,clip]{OmVsR.eps}
185: \caption{Change in Orbital Frequency}
186: \label{fig8_2}
187: \end{figure}
188:
189:
190: %\section{Effects of the Electromagnetic Self-Force}
191: %
192: %Assume that a particle that carries an electric charge $q$ is moving in a background spacetime $g_{ab}$.
193: %If no external electromagnetic fields are present,
194: %Equation (\ref{SFGeodesic}) gives the worldline of the particle that includes the self-force effect, if $\mathcal{F}^a_{\tx{self}}$ is substituted from Equation (\ref{EMSF1}).
195: %That worldline is not a geodesic.
196: %
197:
198: \section{Effects of the Gravitational Self-Force}
199: \label{CONCGrav}
200:
201: Assume that a particle of mass $m$ is moving in a background spacetime described by the metric $g_{ab}$, with no other extrernal fields present.
202: Equation (\ref{SFGeodesic}) gives the worldline of the particle that includes the self-force effect
203: if $\mathcal{F}^a_{\tx{self}}$ is substituted from Equation (\ref{GravSF1}).
204: Clearly, given the initial position and 4-velocity of the particle, that worldline is determined exclusively by the background metric $g_{ab}$ and the metric perturbation $h_{ab}^{\tx{R}}$ induced by the particle.
205: Both of these contributions are solutions of the homogeneous Einstein equations.
206:
207: An observer making local measurements of the metric in the vicinity of the particle measures two contributions to it.
208: The first contribution comes from the background metric $g_{ab}$ combined with the $h_{ab}^{\tx{R}}$-part of the actual metric perturbation generated by the particle.
209: Since both these terms obey the homogeneous Einstein equations, the observer sees no source for either one, so
210: no local measurement can allow him to distinguish $h_{ab}^{\tx{R}}$ from the background metric $g_{ab}$.
211: The second contribution is $h_{ab}^{\tx{S}}$, a metric perturbation also generated by the particle which, according to the observer, is sourced by the particle.
212: The local observer sees the particle move in a \emph{background} geodesic of the metric $(g_{ab}+h_{ab}^{\tx{R}})$.
213: Because he only makes local measurements, he observes no radiation generated by the moving particle and consequently no effect that he could describe as radiation reaction \cite{detwhi02}.
214:
215: