1: %\documentclass[draft]{ws-procs975x65}

2: %\documentclass[square]{ws-procs975x65}

3: \documentclass{ws-procs975x65}

4: 

5: \def\l{\label}

6: \def\ct{\cite}

7: \def\r{\ref}

8: \def\lgth{[\,\mbox{length}\,]}

9: \def\gam{\gamma}

10: 

11: \def\del{\delta}

12: \def\eps{\epsilon}

13: \def\Th{\Theta}

14: \def\sig{\sigma}

15: \def\om{\omega}

16: \def\udot{\dot{u}}

17: \def\3nab{\tilde{\nabla}}

18: \def\sq{\square}

19: \def\fd{{\bf e}}

20: \def\p{\partial}

21: \def\lgl{\langle}

22: \def\rgl{\rangle}

23: \def\la {\langle}

24: \def\ra {\rangle}

25: \def\c{\mbox{curl}}

26: \def\div{\mbox{div}}

27: \def\tl{\tilde}

28: \def\hsp5{\hspace{5mm}}

29: \newcommand{\sfrac}[2]{{\textstyle{#1\over#2}}}

30: \def\case#1/#2{\textstyle\frac{#1}{#2}}

31: \def\rd {\displaystyle{\cdot}}

32: \def\ts {\textstyle}

33: \def\be {\begin{equation}}

34: \def\ee {\end{equation}}

35: \def\bea {\begin{eqnarray}}

36: \def\eea {\end{eqnarray}}

37: \def\cs{c_{s}^{2}}

38: \def\ub {u_{\!_B}}

39: \def\vb {v_{\!_B}}

40: \def\eb {e_{\!_B}}

41: \def\st {\sigma_{\!_T}}

42: \def\ne {n_{\!_E}}

43: \def\ts {\textstyle}

44: \def\bi {\bibitem}

45: \def\case#1/#2{\textstyle\frac{#1}{#2} }

46: \def\rf#1{(\ref{#1})}

47: %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%

48: \def\cqg{{\em Class. Quantum Grav.\/} }

49: \def\grg{{\em Gen. Rel. Grav.\/} }

50: \def\prd{{\em Phys. Rev.\/} {\bf D}}

51: \def\prl{{\em Phys. Rev. Lett.\/} }

52: \def\apj{{\em Astrophys. J.\/} }

53: \def\jmp{{\em J. Math. Phys.\/} }

54: \def\mn{{\em Mon. Not. Roy. Astr. Soc.\/} }

55: 

56: %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%

57: \begin{document}

58: 

59: \title{AN ANALYSIS OF THE SHEAR DYNAMICS IN BIANCHI I \\ COSMOLOGIES WITH $R^n$-GRAVITY}

60: 

61: \author{J. A. LEACH$^{1\,*}$, P. K. S. DUNSBY$^{1\,2}$ and S. CARLONI$^{1}$}

62: 

63: \address{1. Department of Mathematics and Applied Mathematics,\\ University of Cape Town, Rondebosch,

64: 7701, South Africa\\

65: 2. South African Astronomical Observatory,\\ Observatory, Cape Town,

66: South Africa \\ $^*$E-mail: jannie.leach@uct.ac.za\\}

67: 

68: \begin{abstract}

69: We consider the case of $R^n$-gravity and perform a detailed

70: analysis of the dynamics in Bianchi I cosmologies which exhibit {\it

71: local rotational symmetry}  (LRS). We find exact solutions and study their

72: behaviour and stability in terms of the values of the parameter $n$.

73: In particular, we found a set of cosmic histories in which the

74: universe is initially isotropic, then develops shear anisotropies

75: which approaches a constant value.

76: \end{abstract}

77: 

78: \keywords{Higher Order Gravity; $f(R)$-theories; Isotropisation;

79: Bianchi I spacetimes.}

80: 

81: \bodymatter

82: 

83: %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%

84: \section{Introduction}

85: %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%

86: 

87: The dynamical systems approach \cite{Dynamical} has been used with great success over the last 30 years,  to  a gain

88: (qualitative) description of the global dynamics of cosmological models. This method provides a useful tool for finding exact

89: solutions which correspond to fixed points of the system. 

90: 

91: Carloni {\it et al} \cite{Carloni05} have recently used this method

92: to study the dynamics of $R^n$-theories in

93: Friedmann-Lema\^{i}tre-Robertson-Walker (FLRW) universes. Clifton

94: and Barrow \cite{Clifton05} used the dynamical systems approach to

95: determine the extent to which exact solutions can be considered as

96: attractors of spatially flat universes at late times. They compared

97: the predictions of these results with a range of observations and

98: argued that the parameter $n$ in FLRW may only deviate

99: from GR by a very small amount ($n-1\sim 10^{-19}$).

100: 

101: The main aim of this paper \cite{Leach06} is to see how the shear behaves in LRS

102: Bianchi I cosmologies in $R^n$- gravity and whether these models

103: isotropises at early and late times. To achieve this goal we use

104: the theory of dynamical systems \cite{Dynamical} to analyse the system of equations

105: governing the evolution of this model with and without matter. 

106: 

107: 

108: %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%

109: \section{Dynamics in LRS Bianchi I cosmologies}

110: %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%

111: 

112: The cosmological equations that we require for our analysis are:

113: \begin{eqnarray}

114: &&\dot{\Th} + \sfrac{1}{3}\,\Th^{2} + 2\sigma^2 -\frac{1}{2n}R -

115: (n-1)\frac{\dot{R}}{R}\Th+\frac{\mu}{nR^{n-1}} =0,

116: \label{Ray:R^n_B1} \\

117: &&

118: \sfrac{1}{3}\,\Th^{2}-\sigma^2+(n-1)\frac{\dot{R}}{R}\Th-\frac{(n-1)}{2n}R-\frac{\mu}{nR^{n-1}}=0,

119: \label{3R:Rn_B1} \\

120: &&\dot{\sig}= -\left(\Th+ (n-1)\frac{\dot{R}}{R}\right)\sigma,

121: \label{sigdot:Rn_LRS_B1} \\

122: &&\dot{\mu}=-(1+w)\mu\Th, \label{cons:perfect}

123: \end{eqnarray}

124: where $\Theta =\sfrac{3\dot{a}}{a}$ is the volume expansion and

125: $\sigma$ is the shear

126: ($\sigma^2=\sfrac{1}{2}\sigma_{ab}\sigma^{ab}$).

127: 

128: In order to convert the above equations  into a system of autonomous

129: first order differential equations, we define the following set of

130: expansion normalised variables;

131: \begin{equation}\label{DS:var}

132: \Sigma =\frac{3\sigma^2}{\Th^2}\; , \quad x =

133: \frac{3\dot{R}}{R\Th}(n-1)\; ,\quad  y = \frac{3R}{2n\Th^2}(n-1)\; ,

134: \quad  z = \frac{3\mu}{nR^{n-1}\Th^2}\; ,

135: \end{equation} whose

136: equations are

137: \begin{eqnarray}\label{DS:eqn_mat}

138: && \Sigma'=2\left(-2+2\Sigma-\frac{y}{n-1}-2x+z\right)\Sigma,

139: \nonumber

140: \\

141: && x' = y(2+x)-\frac{y}{n-1}(2+nx)-2x-2x^2+xz+(1-3w)z+2x\Sigma,  \\

142: && y'=\frac{y}{n-1}\left[(3-2n)x-2y+2(n-1)z+4(n-1)\Sigma+2(n-1)\right], \nonumber \\

143: && z' = z\left[ 2z-(1+3w)-3x-\frac{2y}{n-1}+4\Sigma\right] ,

144: \nonumber\\

145: && 1-\Sigma+x-y-z=0, \nonumber

146: \end{eqnarray}

147: where primes denote derivatives with respect to a new time variable

148: $\tau=\ln a$.

149: 

150: The solutions associated to the fixed points can be obtained from:

151: \begin{eqnarray}

152: && \dot{\Th}=\frac{1}{3 \alpha}\Th^2, \quad \quad \quad \quad

153: \alpha=\left(2+\Sigma_i-\sfrac{n}{n-1}y_i\right)^{-1},

154: \label{Theta_eqn} \\

155: && \frac{\dot{\sig}}{\sigma}= - \frac{\beta}{3}\Th, \quad \quad

156: \quad \quad \beta =2+\Sigma_i+y_i+z_i. \label{sigma_eqn}

157: \end{eqnarray}

158: Under the condition that $n \neq 1$ and the terms inside the

159: brackets of \rf {Theta_eqn}, do not add up to zero, these equations

160: may be integrated to give the following solutions

161: \begin{equation}\label{DS:sol_gen_mat}

162: a=a_0\left(t-t_0\right)^\alpha, \quad \quad \quad \quad

163: \sigma=\sigma_0 a^{-\beta}.

164: \end{equation}

165: 

166: In terms of our expansion normalised variables

167: \rf{DS:var}, the energy density  is given by

168: \begin{equation}\label{DS:mu}

169: \mu \propto zy^{n-1}\Th^{2n}.

170: \end{equation}

171: From this relation it can be seen that when $z=0$ and $y \neq 0$ the

172: energy density is zero. However when $y=0$ and $z \neq 0$ the

173: behaviour of $\mu$ does depend on the value of $n$. In this case the

174: energy density is zero when $n>1$ but is divergent when $n<1$. When

175: both $y$ and $z$ are equal to zero and $n<1$, one can only determine

176: the behaviour of $\mu$ by direct substitution into the cosmological

177: equations.

178: %---------------------------------

179: \subsection{Vacuum analysis}

180: %---------------------------------

181: 

182: The vacuum case is characterised  by  $z=0$. In this case we can obtain the fixed points of   \rf{DS:eqn_mat} by setting  $\Sigma'=0$ and $y'=0$.  We find one isotropic

183: fixed point ($\mathcal{A}):\ \left(0,\sfrac{4n-5}{2n-1}\right)$ and a

184: line of fixed points ($\mathcal{L}_1):\ \left(\Sigma_*,0\right)$, with non-vanishing shear. The isotropic fixed

185: point is an attractor (stable node) for values of the parameter $n$

186: in the ranges $n<1/2$, $1/2<n<1$ and $n>5/4$. In the range $1<n<5/4$

187: this point is a repeller (unstable node) and therefore may be seen

188: as a past attractor.

189: However, we also have attractors for $(\sigma/H)_*<<1$ on

190: $\mathcal{L}_1$. Therefore inflation may not be needed since the shear

191: anisotropy approaches a constant value which may be chosen as the

192: expansion normalised shear observed today\cite{Bunn96,Kogut97,Jaffe05} ($(\sigma/H)_*< 10^{-9}$), provided that other observational

193: constraints such as nucleosynthesis are satisfied.

194: 

195: The phase space is divided into two regions by the line $y=1-\Sigma$, which represents all points for which the shear dissipate at the same rate as in GR. The region $y<1-\Sigma$ represents a {\it fast shear

196: dissipation} (FSD) regime where shear dissipates faster than in

197: GR, and the region $y>1-\Sigma$, is a {\it slow shear

198: dissipation} (SSD) regime where the shear dissipates

199: slower than in GR (see Figure 1). 

200: 

201: \def\figsubcap#1{\par\noindent\centering\footnotesize(#1)}

202: \begin{figure}[tbp]%

203: \begin{center}

204:   \parbox{2.1in}{\epsfig{figure=RnB3.eps,width=2 in}\figsubcap{a}}

205:   \hspace*{4pt}

206:   \parbox{2.1in}{\epsfig{figure=RnB4.eps,width=2 in}\figsubcap{b}}

207:   \caption{Phase space of the

208: vacuum model. (a) $1/2<n<1$. (b) $1<n<5/4$. The shaded regions

209: represents the regions of initial conditions for which the shear

210: will always evolve

211: faster than in GR.}%

212:   \label{fig1}

213: \end{center}

214: \end{figure}

215: 

216: %---------------------------------

217: \subsection{Matter analysis}

218: %---------------------------------

219: Setting $\Sigma'=0$, $y'=0$ and $z'=0$ we obtain three isotropic

220: fixed points and a line

221: of fixed points with non-vanishing shear.

222: 

223: We observe the same kind of behaviour as in the vacuum case;  the

224: phase space is however 3-dimensional, but is similarly divided into

225: two regions, by the plane $1=\Sigma+y+z$. The space above the plane

226: is a SSD region and below a FSD region. 

227: 

228: 

229: %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%

230: \section{Conclusions}

231: 

232: In conclusion we have shown that $R^n$- gravity modifies the

233: dynamics of the shear in LRS Bianchi I cosmologies by altering the

234: rate at which the shear dissipates. There are cases in which the

235: shear always dissipates slower or faster than in GR, and there are

236: ones which make the transition from first evolving faster and then

237: slower (and {\it vice versa}) than in GR.

238: 

239: \begin{thebibliography}{99}

240: 

241: \bibitem{Dynamical} Wainwright J and Ellis G F R (ed) 1997 {\it

242: Dynamical systems in cosmology} (Cambridge: Cambridge University

243: Press) (see also references therein)

244: 

245: \bibitem{Carloni05} Carloni S, Dunsby P K S, Capozziello S and Troisi

246: A 2005 \cqg {\bf 22} 4839

247: 

248: \bibitem{Clifton05} Clifton T and Barrow J D 2005 \prd {\bf 72} 103005

249: 

250: \bibitem{Leach06} Leach J A, Carloni S and Dunsby P K S 2006 \cqg {\bf 23}

251: 4915 

252: 

253: \bibitem{Bunn96} Bunn E F, Ferreira P G and Silk J 1996 \prl {\bf

254: 77} 2883

255: 

256: \bibitem{Kogut97} Kogut A, Hinshaw G and Banday A J 1997 \prd {\bf

257: 55} 1901

258: 

259: \bibitem{Jaffe05} Jaffe T R, Banday A J, Eriksen H K, G\'{o}rski K M

260: and Hansen F K 2005 \apj {\bf 629} L1

261: \end{thebibliography}

262: \end{document}

263: