1: \subsection{High precision measurement of $\Delta m_{23}$ and
2: $\theta_{23}$ with $\nu_{\mu}$ disappearance}
3: \hspace*{\parindent}
4: The neutrino energy can be reconstructed
5: through quasi-elastic (QE) interactions as shown in Equation~\ref{jhf:eq:qe}
6: by the Super-Kamiokande (SK) detector.
7: In this analysis, we use the same muon selection criteria
8: as those used in the atmospheric neutrino analysis
9: by the Super Kamiokande collaboration~\cite{ATM};
10: fully contained single ring muon-like events
11: in a fiducial volume of $22.5$~kt.
12: The neutrino energy spectrum at SK
13: in five years exposure of the JHF OA2$^\circ$ neutrino beam
14: is shown in
15: Figure~\ref{fig:numu:ene}~(bottom) assuming no neutrino oscillation.
16: The observed energy spectrum for
17: the neutrino oscillation with the parameters of
18: $(\Delta m_{23}, \theta_{23}) = \rm (3\times 10^{-3} eV^2, \pi/4)$
19: is shown in
20: Figure~\ref{fig:numu:ene}~(top), which shows large dip at around 800~MeV.
21: In this analysis, $\theta_{13}$ is
22: approximated to be zero and thus $\sin^22\theta_{\mu e} = \sin^22\theta_{23}$.
23: The value of $\theta_{13}$ will be determined in the $\nu_\mu \rightarrow
24: \nu_e$ search.
25: %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%
26: \begin{figure}[!tb]
27: \renewcommand{\baselinestretch}{1}
28: \centerline{\epsfig{figure=fig/enue.eps,width=12cm}}
29: \vspace{-5mm}
30: \caption{\protect\footnotesize
31: The neutrino energy spectrum measured in SK for 5
32: years exposure of JHF OA2$^\circ$.
33: The top plot is in the case of neutrino oscillation with
34: parameters of $(\Delta m_{23}, \theta_{23}) =
35: (3\times 10^{-3}$~eV$^2, \pi/4)$.
36: The contribution of non-QE interactions is shown
37: by the shaded (blue) histogram. The bottom plot is for QE events
38: after subtracting the non-QE contributions. The dot is the case
39: of the oscillation corresponding to the top plot, and the
40: histogram is in the case of null oscillation. The error bar is
41: from the statistics of 5 years.}
42: \label{fig:numu:ene}
43: \end{figure}
44:
45: %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%
46:
47: In the oscillation analysis, the true neutrino energy
48: spectrum is extracted by subtracting the contribution
49: of non-QE background events.
50: To measure the oscillation parameters,
51: full Super-Kamiokande Monte Carlo events are generated and
52: the ratio between the ``measured'' spectrum at SK and the
53: the expected one without oscillation is fitted by the function
54: of $P(\nu_\mu \rightarrow \nu_\mu)$ in Equation~\ref{eqn:Pmm}
55: after subtracting the non-QE contribution.
56: Since the spectrum of non-QE events depends on the oscillation
57: parameters, the non-QE spectrum are updated by the fit result
58: at each iteration of the fitting.
59: The survival probability of $P(\nu_\mu \rightarrow \nu_\mu)$
60: is shown in Figure~\ref{numu:ratio}, which gives the fit result of
61: $(\Delta m_{23}, \sin^22\theta_{23}) = \rm
62: ((2.96 \pm 0.04) \times 10^{-3} eV^2, 1.0 \pm 0.01)$.
63: The oscillation pattern is clearly seen and the
64: $\sin^22\theta_{23}$ precision of 1~\%
65: and the $\Delta m_{23}$ precision of $4\times 10^{-5}$~$\rm eV^2$
66: are expected.
67: %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%
68: \begin{figure}[!tb]
69: \renewcommand{\baselinestretch}{1}
70: \centerline{\epsfig{figure=fig/osci.eps,width=12cm}}
71: \vspace{-4mm}
72: \caption{\protect\footnotesize
73: The ratio of the measured spectrum with neutrino
74: oscillation to the expected one without neutrino
75: oscillation after subtracting the contribution of non QE-events.
76: The fit result of the oscillation is overlaid.}
77: \label{numu:ratio}
78: \end{figure}
79:
80: %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%
81:
82: Several beam configurations are studied in the range of
83: $\Delta m_{23}$ between $1 \times 10^{-3}$ and
84: $1 \times 10^{-2}$~$\rm eV^2$.
85: The result is summarized in Figure~\ref{numu:result}.
86: With OA2$^\circ$, the maximum sensitivity to the oscillation parameters
87: is achieved at $\Delta m_{23}=(3 \sim 3.5) \times 10^{-3}$~$\rm eV^2$.
88: %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%
89: \begin{figure}[!tb]
90: \renewcommand{\baselinestretch}{1}
91: \centerline{\epsfig{figure=fig/sen.eps,width=17cm}}
92: \vspace{-7mm}
93: \caption{\protect\footnotesize
94: The final sensitivity of the neutrino oscillation parameters:
95: $\sin^22 \theta_{23}$ (left) and $\Delta m_{23}$ (right), as a function
96: of true $\Delta m_{23}$ ($\rm eV^2$). The $\sin^2 2 \theta_{23}$ is
97: set to 1.00. The result with OA2$^\circ$ is shown by the black (solid) line,
98: LE$1.5 \pi$ by the red (dashed) line and LE$3 \pi$ by the blue
99: (dotted) line.}
100: \label{numu:result}
101: \end{figure}
102: %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%
103:
104: So far, we assumed $\sin^22\theta_{23}=1.0$.
105: In the case of $\sin^22\theta_{23} = 0.9$, which is the lower
106: bound suggested by atmospheric neutrino result of Super-Kamiokande,
107: is shown in Figure~\ref{numu:result09}.
108: The precision is slightly worse due to non-oscillated
109: neutrino events at the oscillation maximum.
110: %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%
111: \begin{figure}[!tb]
112: \renewcommand{\baselinestretch}{1}
113: \centerline{\epsfig{figure=fig/sen_sin09.eps,width=17cm}}
114: \vspace{-7mm}
115: \caption{\protect\footnotesize
116: The final sensitivity of the neutrino oscillation parameters
117: in the case of $\sin^22 \theta_{23}=0.9$ shown by red (dashed) line:
118: $\sin^22 \theta_{23}$ (left) and $\Delta m_{23}$ (right), as a function
119: of true $\Delta m_{23}$ ($\rm eV^2$). As a reference,
120: the result of $\sin^22 \theta_{23} = 1.00$ is shown in black line (solid).}
121: \label{numu:result09}
122: \end{figure}
123: %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%
124:
125: By selecting the bin at the oscillation maximum,
126: the disappearance signal dip is enhanced and thus
127: the contribution of the systematic uncertainties are largely
128: suppressed.
129: For example, the depth of the dip in Figure~\ref{numu:ratio},
130: which corresponds to $1-\sin^22\theta_{23}$,
131: is as small as 3\%.
132: Thus, a systematic uncertainty of 10\% in the flux normalization
133: (far/near ratio) contributes to $3\%\times 0.1=$0.3\% in
134: the $\sin^22\theta_{23}$ measurement.
135: Assuming 10\% systematic uncertainty in the far/near ratio,
136: which is similar to K2K's number of 6\%,
137: 4\% uncertainty in the energy scale,
138: and 20\% uncertainty in the non-QE background subtraction,
139: the total systematic error is estimated to be less than 1~\% for
140: $\sin^22\theta_{23}$ and less than $1\times 10^{-4}$~$\rm eV^2$ for
141: $\Delta m_{23}$.
142: The systematic uncertainties are expected to be reduced further
143: below the statistical uncertainties
144: by the neutrino flux measurement using QE events and detailed non-QE
145: background measurement by the front detector,
146: by the pion production measurement,
147: and possibly a second near detector at a few km point which makes
148: the systematics in the far/near ratio negligible.
149:
150: The overall sensitivity of the first phase is expected to be 1\%
151: in precision for $\sin^22\theta_{23}$ and
152: better than $1\times 10^{-4}$~$\rm eV^2$
153: for $\Delta m_{23}$.
154:
155:
156:
157:
158:
159: