1: %\input defs.eoi_epsfig
2: %\input defs.eoi
3:
4: \def\({ \left( }
5: \def\){ \right) }
6: \def\b{\begin{equation}}
7: \def\e{\end{equation}}
8: \def\={\ =\ }
9: \def\ap{\ \approx\ }
10: \def\+{\ +\ }
11: \def\-{\ -\ }
12: \def\lc{\ell_c}
13: \def\Ls{\cal L \rm}
14: \def\ls{\cal l \rm}
15: \def\mumu{$\mu^+\mu^-$}
16: \def\ee{$e^+e^-$}
17: \def\rr{}
18: \def\bb{}
19:
20:
21: %\begin{document}
22:
23: \section{Liquid Argon TPC}
24:
25: The recent successful operation of the ICARUS 300-ton liquid-argon
26: time-projection-chamber prototype \cite{Rubbia77,ICARUS,icarus_tm_01_09}
27: indicates that it is timely to
28: review the possibilities for large-scale application of this technology for
29: accelerator-based neutrino physics, neutrino astrophysics, and proton
30: decay \cite{lanndd,franco1,icarus_02_02}.
31:
32: A liquid argon detector for neutrino physics is a total absorption calorimeter with
33: time-projection readout via the signal of drifting electrons collected in crossed
34: planes of wires. The effective pixel size is about $5 \times 5 \times 5$ mm$^3$,
35: compared to the radiation length of 14 cm and nuclear interaction length of 55 cm.
36: At a drift field strength of 500 V/cm, the drift velocity is about 1 mm/$\mu$s, so the
37: drift time over, say, 5 m would be 5 ms. Even if operated at the Earth's surface with
38: no shielding, a liquid argon TPC has only about 1 (localized) cosmic-ray track per
39: m$^2$ of horizontal surface per drift time, so events appear very clean, as shown in
40: Fig.~\ref{icarus2}.
41:
42: \begin{figure}[htp] % h = here, t = top, b = bottom, p = new page
43: \begin{center}
44: \includegraphics*[width=5in]{icarus6.eps}
45: \parbox{5.5in} % change 5.5in to \hsize for full-width caption
46: {\caption[ Short caption for table of contents ]
47: {\label{icarus2} An event from the recent cosmic-ray test run of ICARUS
48: \cite{ICARUS},
49: showing excellent track resolution over long drift distances in zero magnetic
50: field.
51: }}
52: \end{center}
53: \end{figure}
54:
55: Because a liquid argon TPC is a total absorption detector with fine-grained sampling,
56: it offers superior separation of charged-current and neutral-current neutrino interactions,
57: as we as excellent identification of $e/\mu/\pi/K/p$, included $\pi^0$'s. Hence, it
58: is the most effective detector per unit mass for $\nu_\mu \to \nu_e$ appearance measurements
59: (of $\sin^2 2 \theta_{13}$, the sign of $\Delta m^2_{23}$, CP violation, ...), as shown
60: in Fig.~\ref{harris}.
61:
62: \begin{figure}[htp] % h = here, t = top, b = bottom, p = new page
63: \begin{center}
64: \includegraphics*[width=4in]{harris_comparison2.eps}
65: \parbox{5.5in} % change 5.5in to \hsize for full-width caption
66: {\caption[ Short caption for table of contents ]
67: {\label{harris} Comparison of several types of detectors in measuring
68: $\sin^2 2\theta_{13}$ in the presence of backgrounds typical of
69: a pion-decay neutrino beam at intermediate baselines \cite{harris_nnn02}.
70: The detector labeled ICARUS \cite{ICARUS}
71: is a liquid argon time projection chamber. With a 25-kton liquid
72: argon detector, and an off-axis NuMI neutrino beam,
73: the sensitivity to $\sin^2 2\theta_{13}$ would be at least 0.002.
74: }}
75: \end{center}
76: \end{figure}
77:
78: To obtain economies of scale, a large liquid argon detector should be implemented in a
79: single cryostat, such as those commonly used in the liquefied natural gas industry.
80: Cryogenic volumes of up to 200,000 m$^3$ (= 280 kton if liquid argon) are now in
81: use, as sketched in Fig.~\ref{larfig1}.
82:
83: \begin{figure}[htp] % h = here, t = top, b = bottom, p = new page
84: \begin{center}
85: \parbox{3in}{\includegraphics*[width=3in]{lng_tank3.eps}}
86: \parbox{3in}{\includegraphics*[width=3in]{lng_tank_inside2.eps}}
87: \parbox{5.5in} % change 5.5in to \hsize for full-width caption
88: {\caption[ Short caption for table of contents ]
89: {\label{larfig1} Photographs of cryogenic storage tanks of volumes $\approx 100,000$
90: m$^3$.
91: }}
92: \end{center}
93: \end{figure}
94:
95: An overall concept of a large magnetized liquid argon detector is shown in
96: Fig.~\ref{lanndd1}.
97: Anticipating the possibility that neutrino beams are eventually
98: sent to it from more than one accelerator, the magnetic field is vertical so the
99: trajectories of secondary particles are generally orthogonal to the magnetic field.
100:
101: \begin{figure}[htp] % h = here, t = top, b = bottom, p = new page
102: \begin{center}
103: \includegraphics*[width=3in]{landd_truck.eps}
104: \parbox{5.5in} % change 5.5in to \hsize for full-width caption
105: {\caption[ Short caption for table of contents ]
106: {\label{lanndd1} Concept of a 70-kton Liquid Argon Neutrino and Nucleon Decay
107: Detector (LANNDD) \cite{lanndd,franco1}.
108: }}
109: \end{center}
110: \end{figure}
111:
112: The usable drift distance in a liquid argon detector is limited by oxygen impurities to
113: 2-5~m. The diameter of a large liquid argon detector will be greater than (twice) the
114: maximum drift distance, so the readout must consist of a set of parallel anode and
115: cathode planes that subdivide the detector, as shown in Figs.~\ref{lanndd1} and
116: \ref{lanndd_top}.
117:
118: \begin{figure}[htp] % h = here, t = top, b = bottom, p = new page
119: \begin{center}
120: \includegraphics*[width=2.5in]{lanndd_top.eps}
121: \parbox{5.5in} % change 5.5in to \hsize for full-width caption
122: {\caption[ Short caption for table of contents ]
123: {\label{lanndd_top} Top view of the electrode arrangement of a 70-kton
124: Liquid Argon Neutrino and Nucleon Decay
125: Detector (LANNDD) \cite{franco1}.
126: }}
127: \end{center}
128: \end{figure}
129:
130: A large liquid argon detector has excellent capability to search for nucleon decay
131: \cite{larpdk},
132: particularly because it is almost fully efficient for the decay $p \to K^+ \bar\nu_\mu$
133: that is favored in many SO(10) SUSY models \cite{Pati}.
134:
135: The data acquisition for a liquid-argon TPC can operate in a pipelined, deadtimeless mode,
136: with zero-suppression \cite{icarus_daq}. This could permit fully live
137: operation at the Earth's surface for nucleon decay studies, in addition to triggered
138: data collection of neutrino interactions from a pulsed accelerator beam. The data rate
139: would, of course, be quite high in this case. It may nonetheless be less costly to
140: implement a high rate data-acquisition system than to reduce the un-triggered data rate by
141: siting the detector deep underground.
142:
143: \begin{figure}[htp] % h = here, t = top, b = bottom, p = new page
144: \begin{center}
145: \includegraphics*[width=4in]{icarus_frontend.eps}
146: \parbox{5.5in} % change 5.5in to \hsize for full-width caption
147: {\caption[ Short caption for table of contents ]
148: {\label{frontend} Scheme of the front-end electronics of the ICARUS detector
149: \cite{icarus_daq}.
150: }}
151: \end{center}
152: \end{figure}
153:
154: \begin{figure}[htp] % h = here, t = top, b = bottom, p = new page
155: \begin{center}
156: \includegraphics*[width=4in]{icarus_backend.eps}
157: \parbox{5.5in} % change 5.5in to \hsize for full-width caption
158: {\caption[ Short caption for table of contents ]
159: {\label{backend} Scheme of the back-end electronics of the ICARUS detector
160: \cite{icarus_daq}.
161: }}
162: \end{center}
163: \end{figure}
164:
165: \begin{figure}[htp] % h = here, t = top, b = bottom, p = new page
166: \begin{center}
167: \includegraphics*[width=3in]{icarus_readout_modules.eps}
168: \parbox{5.5in} % change 5.5in to \hsize for full-width caption
169: {\caption[ Short caption for table of contents ]
170: {\label{modules} Readout electronics of the ICARUS detector
171: \cite{icarus_daq}.
172: }}
173: \end{center}
174: \end{figure}
175:
176: In the future, neutrino beams from pion decay may be supplanted by those from muon decay
177: \cite{study2}, in which cases beams of $\nu_\mu$ and $\bar\nu_e$ or $\bar\nu_\mu$ and $\nu_e$
178: would be available. To take advantage of such beams for studies of CP violation, the
179: sign of the final state lepton much be determined in the detector, which must therefore
180: be immersed in a magnetic field. A liquid argon TPC is compatible with a superimposed
181: magnetic field. The sign of muons could be well determined with a field of only 0.1 T,
182: and the sign of electrons up to a few GeV energy could be determined in a field of 0.5 T
183: by analysis of the curvature of tracks in the electromagnetic shower
184: \cite{venice,argonprop}.
185:
186: As well as being the highest-performance large detector for neutrinos, a liquid argon TPC
187: is also one of the least costly. Liquid argon costs about \$1M per kton, or \$20m for a
188: 20 kton detector. Such a detector would require about 100k readout channels,
189: at a cost of about \$10M. The greatest cost uncertainty at present is in the storage tank
190: and associated cryogenic/purification system. A initial engineering study on this
191: issue is underway \cite{Mulholland}. If the cryo system cost proves to be of order the
192: cost of the argon itself, then a 20 kton detector would cost about \$50M -- which would make
193: a liquid argon TPC the price/performance leader for large neutrino detectors.
194:
195:
196: %\end{document}