1:
2: %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%
3: %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%
4: \documentclass[11pt,aps,prd,preprint,groupedaddress,tightenlines,nofootinbib]{revtex4}
5: \usepackage{amsmath,amssymb,amsbsy,color,axodraw}
6: \usepackage{psfrag}
7: %\tightenlines
8:
9: %%Text Start
10:
11:
12: %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%% BEGINING OF MACROS %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%
13: \newcommand{\non}{\nonumber}
14: \def\dfrac#1#2{\displaystyle\frac{#1}{#2}}
15: %\newcommand{\bm}[1]{\mbox{\boldmath $#1$}}
16: \newcommand{\ovl}[1]{\overline{#1}}
17: \newcommand{\wt}[1]{\widetilde{#1}}
18: \newcommand{\eq}[1]{Eq.~(\ref{#1})}
19: \newcommand{\eqn}[1]{(\ref{#1})}
20: \newcommand{\p}{\partial}
21: \newcommand{\pslash}{p\kern-1ex /}
22: \newcommand{\lslash}{l\kern-1ex /}
23: \newcommand{\sslash}{s\kern-1ex /}
24: \newcommand{\Dslash}{{\cal D}\kern-1.5ex /}
25: \newcommand{\bpsi}{\overline{\psi}}
26: \newcommand{\bc}{\overline{c}}
27: \newcommand{\tr}{{\rm tr}}
28: \newcommand{\vev}[1]{\langle #1 \rangle}
29: \newcommand{\VEV}[1]{\left\langle{\rm T} #1\right\rangle}
30:
31: \newcommand{\be}{\begin{equation}}
32: \newcommand{\ee}{\end{equation}}
33: \newcommand{\bea}{\begin{eqnarray}}
34: \newcommand{\eea}{\end{eqnarray}}
35:
36: \newcommand{\set}[1]{\mbox{${\mathbb{#1}}$}}
37:
38: \newcommand{\pref}[1]{(\ref{#1})}
39: %\def\chpt{\raise0.4ex\hbox{$\chi$}PT}
40:
41: \newcommand{\pal}{\partial}
42: \newcommand{\la}{\langle}
43: \newcommand{\ra}{\rangle}
44: %
45: %========================================================================
46: % Nakamura's new math commands
47: %========================================================================
48: %
49: \newcommand{\kzbar}{\bar{K}^0}
50: \newcommand{\msbar}{\overline{\rm MS}}
51: \newcommand{\beal}{\begin{align}}
52: \newcommand{\enal}{\end{align}}
53: \newcommand{\nn}{\nonumber}
54:
55:
56: \begin{document}
57:
58: %\draft
59: %\preprint{UTHEP-???}
60: %\preprint{UTCCS-P-???}
61: \begin{flushright}
62: {\normalsize UTHEP-516}\\
63: {\normalsize UTCCP-P-19}\\
64: \end{flushright}
65:
66: \title{
67: %{\normalsize
68: %\begin{flushright}
69: %hep-th/0603012
70: %November 1998\
71: %\end{flushright}}
72: Perturbative renormalization factors for generic $\Delta s=2$
73: four-quark operators in domain-wall QCD with improved gauge action
74: }
75: \author{Yousuke Nakamura$^{1}$ and Yoshinobu Kuramashi$^{1,2}$}
76: \affiliation{
77: $^1$Graduate School of Pure and Applied Sciences,\\ University of Tsukuba, Tsukuba 305-8571, Japan \\
78: $^2$Center for Computational Physics,\\ University of Tsukuba, Tsukuba 305-8577, Japan
79: }
80:
81: \date{\today}
82:
83: %
84: %===========
85: \begin{abstract}
86: %===========
87: %
88:
89: We calculate one-loop renormalization factors of generic
90: $\Delta s=2$ four-quark operators for domain-wall QCD with
91: the plaquette gauge action and the Iwasaki gauge action.
92: The renormalization factors are presented in the modified
93: minimal subtraction ($\msbar$)
94: scheme with the naive dimensional regularization.
95: As an important application we show how to construct
96: the renormalization factors
97: for the operators contributing to $K^0-\kzbar$ mixing
98: in the supersymmetric models with the use of our results.
99:
100:
101: \end{abstract}
102:
103:
104: \maketitle
105: %\narrowtext
106:
107: %1
108: %=================
109: \section{Introduction}
110: %=================
111: %
112: Experimental studies of $K^0-\kzbar$ mixing provide us an opportunity
113: to deduce the indirect CP violation parameter $\epsilon_K$.
114: In the Standard Model (SM), the low-energy effective Hamiltonian contains
115: the dimension-six four-quark operator
116: ${\cal O}_{LL}={\bar s}\gamma_\mu(1-\gamma_5) d\cdot
117: {\bar s}\gamma_\mu(1-\gamma_5) d$, and its hadronic matrix element
118: $\la\kzbar\vert{\cal O}_{LL} \vert K^0 \ra$ is required
119: to determine $ \epsilon_K$ from the experimental results
120: of $K^0-\kzbar$ mixing.
121: On the other hand, the physics beyond the SM involves the
122: four-quark operators with more general chiral structures.
123: For example, the relevant operators in supersymmetric
124: models are\cite{fcnc_susy}
125: \bea
126: {\cal O}_1 &=&
127: \bar{s}^a\gamma_\mu(1-\gamma_5)d^a\bar{s}^b\gamma_\mu(1-\gamma_5)d^b,
128: \label{eq:op_susy1}\\
129: {\cal O}_2 &=&
130: \bar{s}^a(1-\gamma_5)d^a\bar{s}^b(1-\gamma_5)d^b,
131: \label{eq:op_susy2}\\
132: {\cal O}_3 &=&
133: \bar{s}^a(1-\gamma_5)d^b\bar{s}^b(1-\gamma_5)d^a,
134: \label{eq:op_susy3}\\
135: {\cal O}_4 &=&
136: \bar{s}^a(1-\gamma_5)d^a\bar{s}^b(1+\gamma_5)d^b,
137: \label{eq:op_susy4}\\
138: {\cal O}_5 &=&
139: \bar{s}^a(1-\gamma_5)d^b\bar{s}^b(1+\gamma_5)d^a,
140: \label{eq:op_susy5}
141: \eea
142: where $a$ and $b$ are color indices.
143:
144: Lattice QCD should be an ideal tool to determine
145: the above matrix elements from the first principles.
146: In the past decades, much effort have been devoted
147: to the calculation of $\la\kzbar\vert{\cal O}_{LL} \vert K^0\ra $
148: by employing various quark and
149: gauge actions\cite{bk_ks,bk_lee,bk_w,bk_orsay,bk_blum,bk_cppacs,bk_rbc,bk_tm,bk_boston,bk_ol}.
150: On the contrary, the matrix elements for the operators of
151: Eqs.(\ref{eq:op_susy1})$-$(\ref{eq:op_susy5}) are
152: less studied compared to the case of
153: ${\cal O}_{LL}$\cite{Allton99,lellouch05}.
154: Our aim is at a detailed study of them with the use of the
155: domain-wall quark formulation in lattice QCD, which
156: is expected to realize full chiral symmetry at finite lattice spacing
157: up to exponential fall-off of the explicit chiral symmetry breaking
158: contributions\cite{Shamir93,Shamir95} and
159: have been successfully applied to the calculation of
160: $\la\kzbar\vert{\cal O}_{LL} \vert K^0\ra$\cite{bk_blum,bk_cppacs,bk_rbc}.
161:
162: The matrix elements calculated on the lattice should be converted
163: to those defined in some continuum regularization scheme
164: [e.g., the modified minimal subtraction scheme ($\msbar$)].
165: This is achieved by the finite renormalization relating
166: the lattice composite operators to the continuum counterparts
167: defined in some reguarization scheme.
168: In this paper we present the perturbative results
169: of the renormalization factors
170: for the complete set of $\Delta s=2$ four-quark operators
171: consisting of physical quark fields in the domain-wall QCD (DWQCD).
172: With the use of our results one can obtain the renormalization factor
173: for an arbitrary $\Delta s=2$ four-quark operator.
174: This work is an extention of Refs.\cite{AIKT99,AIKT02},
175: where the renormalization
176: factors for the four-quark operators relevant in the SM are evaluated.
177:
178: This paper is organized as follows. In Sec.~\ref{sec:action} we introduce
179: the quark and gauge actions and the corresponding Feynman rules.
180: Section~\ref{sec:calculation} is devoted to explain
181: our calculational procedure of
182: the renormalization factors for the complete set
183: of $\Delta s=2$ four-quark operators. In Sec.~\ref{sec:susy},
184: with the use of our results,
185: we construct the renormalization factors for the SUSY operators
186: in Eqs.(\ref{eq:op_susy1})$-$(\ref{eq:op_susy5}).
187: We briefly discuss the mean
188: field improvement in Sec.~\ref{sec:mf}.
189: Our conclusions are summarized in Sec.~\ref{sec:conclusion}.
190:
191: The physical quantities are expressed in lattice units
192: and the lattice spacing $a$ is suppressed unless
193: necessary.
194: We take SU($N$) gauge group with the gauge coupling $g$
195: and the second Casimir $C_F=(N^2-1)/(2N)$, while $N=3$
196: is specified in the numerical calculations.
197:
198: %2
199: %=================================
200: \section{Action and Feynman rules}
201: \label{sec:action}
202: %=================================
203:
204: We take Shamir's domain-wall fermion action\cite{Shamir93}
205: given by
206: \bea
207: S_{\rm DW} &=&
208: \sum_n\sum_{s=1}^{N_s}
209: \Biggl[
210: \frac{1}{2}\sum_{\mu}\bigl[\bpsi(n)_s(-r+\gamma_\mu)U_\mu(n)\psi(n+\mu)_s
211: +\bpsi(n)_s(-r-\gamma_\mu)U^\dagger_\mu(n-\mu)\psi(n-\mu)_s \bigl]
212: \nn\\&&
213: +\frac{1}{2}\bigl[\bpsi(n)_s(1+\gamma_5)\psi(n)_{s+1}
214: +\bpsi(n)_s(1-\gamma_5)\psi(n)_{s-1}\bigl]
215: % \nn\\&&
216: +(M-1+4r)\bpsi(n)_s\psi(n)_s
217: \Biggl]
218: \nn\\&&
219: +m\sum_n\bigl[\bpsi(n)_{N_s}P_R\psi(n)_1+\bpsi(n)_1P_L\psi(n)_{N_s}\bigl],
220: \eea
221: where $n$ is a four-dimensional space-time coordinate and
222: $s$ is a fifth-dimensional or ``flavor'' index bounded
223: as $1\leqslant s\leqslant N_s$.
224: In this paper we conventinally take $N_s
225: \rightarrow \infty$ limit to avoid complications
226: arising from the finite $N_s$ such as mixing of
227: operators with different chiralities.
228: %\footnote{The numerical simulation is performed at
229: %finite $N_s$ and we should be careful when applying the
230: %renormalization factors given in this paper at infinite
231: %$N_s$.}
232: The domain-wall height $M$ is a parameter of the theory
233: which we set $0< M < 2$ to realize the massless
234: fermion at tree level.
235: $P_{R/L}$ is a projection operator
236: $P_{R/L}=(1\pm\gamma_5)/2$ and
237: the Wilson parameter is set to $r=-1$.
238: %For gauge part we employ a standard four-dimensional
239: % Wilson plaquette action and a four-dimensional RG
240: % improved gauge action (Iwasaki gauge action)
241: %and assume no gauge interaction along the fifth dimension.
242: The ``physical'' quark field are defined
243: by the boundary fermions in the fifth dimensional space:
244: \bea
245: q(n) &=& P_R\psi(n)_1+P_L\psi(n)_{N_s},
246: \label{eq:q_dw} \\
247: \bar{q}(n) &=& \bpsi(n)_{N_s}P_R+\bpsi(n)_1P_L,
248: \label{eq:qbar_dw}
249: \eea
250: whose mass is given by $m$.
251: %We will consider the QCD operators constructed from this
252: %quark fields, since this field has been actually used in
253: %the previous simulations\cite{Noaki03}.
254: Our renormalization procedure is based on the
255: Green functions consisting of only the ``physical''
256: quark fields.
257:
258: For the gauge part of the action we employ the
259: following form in four dimensions:
260: \bea
261: S_{\rm gluon}=\frac{1}{g^2}\Bigl[c_0\sum_{\rm plaquette}{\rm Tr} U_{\rm pl}
262: +c_1\sum_{\rm rectangle}{\rm Tr}U_{\rm rtg}+c_2\sum_{\rm chair}{\rm
263: Tr}U_{\rm chr}
264: +c_3\sum_{\rm parallelogram}{\rm Tr}U_{\rm plg}\Bigl],
265: \eea
266: where the first term represents the standard plaquette
267: action and the remaining terms are six-link loops formed
268: by a $1\times2$ rectangle, a bent $1\times2$ rectangle
269: (chair) and a 3-dimensional parallelogram.
270: The coefficients $c_0,\dots,c_3$ satisfy the
271: normalization condition
272: \bea
273: c_0+8c_1+16c_2+8c_3=1.
274: \eea
275: The RG improved gauge action is defined by setting the
276: parameters to the value suggested by an approximate
277: renormalization group analysis.
278: In the following we adopt $c_1=-0.331,c_2=c_3=0$ (Iwasaki)\cite{Iwasaki83}
279: for the RG improved gauge action
280: in addition to $c_1=c_2=c_3=0$ (plaquette).
281: With these choices of parameters the RG improved gauge
282: action is expected to realize smooth gauge field
283: fluctuations approximating those in the continuum limit
284: better than with the unimproved plaquette action.
285:
286: Weak coupling perturbation theory is developed by expressing the link
287: variable in terms of the gauge potential
288: \bea
289: U_{x,\mu}=\exp(igA_\mu(x+\frac{1}{2}\hat{\mu}))
290: \label{eqn:link}
291: \eea
292: and expanding in terms of the gauge coupling.
293: We adopt a covariant gauge fixing with a gauge parameter $\alpha$
294: defined by
295: \bea
296: S_{\rm GF} = \sum_x \frac{1}{2\alpha}
297: \left( \nabla_\mu A_\mu^a (x+\frac{1}{2}\hat{\mu}) \right)^2,
298: \eea
299: where $\nabla_\mu f_n\equiv (f_{n+\hat{\mu}}-f_n)$.
300:
301: The free part of the gluon action takes the form in momentum space
302: \bea
303: S_0 = \frac{1}{2} \int_{-\pi}^{\pi}\frac{d^4k}{(2\pi)^4}
304: \sum_{\mu, \nu}
305: A_\mu^a(k)
306: \left(G_{\mu\nu}(k)
307: -\left(1-\frac{1}{\alpha}\right)\hat{k}_\mu\hat{k}_\nu\right)
308: A_\nu^a(-k) ,
309: \eea
310: where
311: \bea
312: G_{\mu \nu}(k) = \hat{k}_\mu \hat{k}_\nu + \sum_\rho
313: (\hat{k}_\rho \delta_{\mu \nu} - \hat{k}_\mu \delta_{\rho
314: \nu}) q_{\mu \rho} \hat{k}_\rho
315: \eea
316: with
317: \bea
318: \hat{k}_\mu = 2 \sin\frac{k_\mu}{2}
319: \eea
320: and $q_{\mu \nu}$ is defined as
321: \bea
322: q_{\mu \nu} = (1-\delta_{\mu\nu})\left(1 - (c_1 - c_2 - c_3)
323: (\hat{k}_\mu^2 + \hat{k}_\nu^2) -(c_2 + c_3) \hat{k}^2\right) .
324: \eea
325: The gluon propagator can be written as
326: \bea
327: D_{\mu \nu}(k) &=& (\hat{k}^2)^{-2} \left[
328: \hat{k}_\mu \hat{k}_\nu + \sum_\sigma
329: (\hat{k}_\sigma \delta_{\mu \nu} - \hat{k}_\nu \delta_{\mu
330: \sigma} ) \hat{k}_\sigma A_{\sigma \nu} \right]
331: -(1-\alpha) \frac{\hat{k}_\mu \hat{k}_\nu}{(\hat{k}^2)^2}
332: \\
333: & = & (\hat{k}^2)^{-2} \left[
334: (1 - A_{\mu \nu} )\hat{k}_\mu \hat{k}_\nu
335: + \delta_{\mu \nu} \sum_\sigma \hat{k}_\sigma^2
336: A_{\nu \sigma} \right]
337: -(1-\alpha) \frac{\hat{k}_\mu \hat{k}_\nu}{(\hat{k}^2)^2} ,
338: \eea
339: where $A_{\mu \nu}$ is a function of $q_{\mu \nu}$ and
340: $\hat{k}_\mu$, whose form we refer to the original
341: literatures\cite{Iwasaki83,Weisz83}.
342: In this paper we will adopt the Feynman gauge($\alpha=1$) without loss of
343: generality, since the renormalization factors for the composite
344: operators do not depend on the choice of the gauge fixing condition.
345:
346: Quark-gluon vertices are also identical to those in the
347: $N_s$ flavor Wilson fermion.
348: We need only one gluon vertex for our present
349: calculation:
350: \bea
351: V_{1\mu}^A(k,p)_{st}=-igT^A\{\gamma_\mu\cos(-k_\mu/2+p_\mu/2)
352: -ir\sin(-k_\mu/2+p_\mu/2)\}\delta_{st},
353: \eea
354: where $k$ and $p$ represent incoming momentum into the
355: vertex (see Fig.1 of Ref.\cite{AIKT98}) and
356: $T^A (A=1,\dots,N^2-1)$ is a generator of color SU($N$).
357:
358: The fermion propagator originally takes $N_s\times N_s$
359: matrix form in $s$-flavor space.
360: In the present one-loop calculation,
361: however, we do not need the whole matrix elements because
362: we consider Green functions consisting of the physical
363: quark fields.
364: The relevant fermion propagators are restricted to the
365: following three types:
366: \bea
367: \langle q(-p)\bar{q}(p)\rangle&=&
368: \frac{-i\gamma_\mu\sin p_\mu+(1-We^{-\alpha})m}{-(1-e^\alpha W)
369: +m^2(1-We^{-\alpha})}\equiv S_q(p), \\
370: \langle q(-p)\bpsi(p,s)\rangle&=&
371: \frac{1}{F}\bigl[i\gamma_\mu\sin p_\mu-m(1-We^{-\alpha})\bigl]
372: (e^{-\alpha(N_s-s)}P_R+e^{-\alpha(s-1)}P_L) \nn \\&&
373: +\frac{1}{F}\Bigl[m\bigl[i\gamma_\mu\sin
374: p_\mu-m(1-We^{-\alpha})\bigl]-F\Bigl]
375: e^{-\alpha}(e^{-\alpha(s-1)}P_R+e^{-\alpha(N_s-s)}P_L), \\
376: \langle \psi(-p,s)\bar{q}(p)\rangle
377: &=&\frac{1}{F}(e^{-\alpha(N_s-s)}P_L+e^{-\alpha(s-1)}P_R)
378: \bigl[i\gamma_\mu\sin p_\mu-m(1-We^{-\alpha})\bigl] \nn\\&&
379: +\frac{1}{F} (e^{-\alpha(s-1)}P_L+e^{-\alpha(N_s-s)}P_R)e^{-\alpha}
380: \Bigl[m\bigl[i\gamma_\mu\sin
381: p_\mu-m(1-We^{-\alpha})\bigl]-F\Bigl]
382: \eea
383: with
384: \bea
385: W &=& 1-M-r\sum_\mu(1-\cos p_\mu), \\
386: \cosh (\alpha)&=&\frac{1+W^2+\sum_\mu\sin^2p_\mu}{2|W|} ,\\
387: F &=& 1-e^\alpha W-m^2(1-We^{-\alpha}) ,
388: \eea
389: where the argument $p$ in the factors $\alpha$ and $W$ is suppressed.
390:
391: In the perturbative calculation of Green functions
392: we assume that the
393: external quark momenta and masses are much
394: smaller than the lattice cutoff,
395: so that the external quark propagators can be expanded in
396: terms of them.
397: We have the following expressions as leading term of the
398: expansion:
399: \bea
400: \langle q\bar{q}\rangle_{\rm ext}(p) &=&\frac{1-w_0^2}{i\pslash+(1-w_0^2)m}, \\
401: \langle q\bpsi_s\rangle_{\rm ext}(p) &=&\langle q\bar{q}\rangle(p)
402: (w_0^{s-1}P_L+w_0^{N_s-s}P_R), \\
403: \langle \psi_s\bar{q}\rangle_{\rm ext}(p) &=&(w_0^{s-1}P_R+w_0^{N_s-s}P_L)\langle q\bar{q}\rangle(p),
404: \eea
405: where $w_0=1-M$.
406:
407:
408:
409:
410:
411: %4
412: %=============================================
413: \section{Renormalization factors for generic four-quark operators}
414: \label{sec:calculation}
415: %=============================================
416: %
417: We consider the complete set of parity-conserving
418: four-quark operators\cite{bk_w,DGMTV99}:
419: \bea
420: Q_1^{\pm} &\equiv&
421: \mathcal{O}_{VV+AA}^\pm\equiv\mathcal{O}_{VV}^\pm+\mathcal{O}_{AA}^\pm,
422: \label{eq:op_gen1}\\
423: Q_2^{\pm} &\equiv&
424: \mathcal{O}_{VV-AA}^\pm\equiv\mathcal{O}_{VV}^\pm-\mathcal{O}_{AA}^\pm, \label{eq:op_gen2}\\
425: Q_3^{\pm} &\equiv&
426: \mathcal{O}_{SS-PP}^\pm\equiv\mathcal{O}_{SS}^\pm-\mathcal{O}_{PP}^\pm, \label{eq:op_gen3} \\
427: Q_4^{\pm} &\equiv&
428: \mathcal{O}_{SS+PP}^\pm\equiv\mathcal{O}_{SS}^\pm+\mathcal{O}_{PP}^\pm, \label{eq:op_gen4}\\
429: Q_5^{\pm} &\equiv&
430: \mathcal{O}_{TT}^\pm, \label{eq:op_gen5}
431: \eea
432: where
433: \bea
434: \mathcal{O}_{\Gamma\Gamma}^\pm=\frac{1}{2}
435: \Bigl[(\bar{q}_1^a\Gamma q_2^a)(\bar{q}_3^b\Gamma q_4^b)\pm
436: (\bar{q}_1^a\Gamma q_4^a)(\bar{q}_3^b\Gamma q_2^b) \Bigl]
437: \label{eq:op_gen}
438: \eea
439: with
440: $\Gamma=\{\mathbf{1},\gamma_\mu,\sigma_{\mu\nu},\gamma_\mu\gamma_5,\gamma_5\}\equiv\{S,V,T,A,P\}$.
441: $a,b$ denote color indices and summation over them is assumed.
442: We should note that $q_i$ (i=1,2,3,4) are the physical quark fields
443: defined by Eqs.(\ref{eq:q_dw}) and (\ref{eq:qbar_dw}).
444: The parity-conserving parts of
445: Eqs.(\ref{eq:op_susy1})$-$(\ref{eq:op_susy5}) are expressed as
446: linear combinations of the above operators.
447: We find that Ref.\cite{bk_w} employs another choice of basis called
448: Fierz eigenbasis, which is more convenient in considering
449: the Fierz transformation of the four-quark operators.
450:
451:
452: We consider the following Green functions:
453: \bea
454: \langle Q^\pm_{i}\rangle_{\alpha\beta,\gamma\delta}^{ij,kl}&\equiv
455: \langle Q^\pm_{i}(q_1)_\alpha^i(\bar{q}_2)_\beta^j
456: (q_3)_\gamma^k(\bar{q}_4)_\delta^l\rangle,
457: \eea
458: where $\alpha, \beta, \gamma, \delta$
459: are spinor indices and $i, j, k, l$ are color indices.
460: %Because the renomalization factor dose not depend on external momenta
461: %$p_i$,we suppress them.
462: It is convenient to decompose the above Green functions as
463: \bea
464: \langle\mathcal{O}^\pm_{\Gamma\Gamma}\rangle_{\alpha\beta,\gamma\delta}^{ij,kl}
465: &\equiv&
466: \langle\mathcal{O}^\pm_{\Gamma\Gamma}(q_1)_\alpha^i(q_2)_\beta^j
467: (q_3)_\gamma^k(q_4)_\delta^l\rangle \notag \\
468: &=&\frac{1}{2}\langle[(\bar{q}_1^a\Gamma q_2^a)(\bar{q}_3^b\Gamma q_4^b)\pm
469: (\bar{q}_1^a\Gamma q_4^a)(\bar{q}_3^b\Gamma q_2^b)]
470: (q_1)_\alpha^i(q_2)_\beta^j(q_3)_\gamma^k(q_4)_\delta^l\rangle \notag \\
471: &=&\frac{1}{2}\Bigl[\langle (q_1)_\alpha^i\bar{q}_1^a\Gamma q_2^a(\bar{q}_2)_\beta^j
472: (q_3)_\gamma^k\bar{q}_3^b\Gamma q_4^b(\bar{q}_4)_\delta^l\rangle
473: \mp
474: \langle (q_1)_\alpha^i\bar{q}_1^a\Gamma q_4^a(\bar{q}_4)_\delta^l
475: (q_3)_\gamma^k\bar{q}_3^b\Gamma q_2^b(\bar{q}_2)_\beta^j
476: \rangle
477: \Bigl]. \label{matrixelements}
478: \eea
479: After trancating the external quark
480: propagators from $\langle Q^\pm_{i}\rangle$
481: with the multiplication of $i\pslash+(1-w_0^2)m$,
482: we obtain the vertex functions, which is written in the
483: following form up to the one-loop level:
484: \bea
485: (1-w^2_0)^4(\Lambda_i^\pm)_{\alpha\beta;\gamma\delta}^{ij;kl}
486: =(1-w_0^2)^4(\Lambda^{(0)\pm}_i+\Lambda_i^{(1)\pm})^{ij;kl}_{\alpha\beta;\gamma\delta},
487: \eea
488: where the superscript $(n)$ refers to the $n$th loop
489: level and the subscript $i$ identifies the operators
490: (\ref{eq:op_gen1})$-$(\ref{eq:op_gen5}).
491: The trivial factor $(1-w_0^2)^4$, which originates from the
492: external quark propagators, is factored out for convenience.
493: Since the renormalization factor does not depend on the
494: external momenta $p_i$, we suppress them.
495:
496: The tree level vertex functions $\Lambda^{(0)\pm}_i$ are given by
497: \bea
498: i&=&1,\hspace{0.5cm} \frac{1}{2}[V\otimes V+A\otimes A
499: \mp(V\odot V+A\odot A)]_{\alpha\beta;\gamma\delta}[1\tilde{\otimes}1]^{ij;kl}, \\
500: i&=&2,\hspace{0.5cm} \frac{1}{2}[V\otimes V-A\otimes A
501: \mp(V\odot V-A\odot A)]_{\alpha\beta;\gamma\delta}[1\tilde{\otimes}1]^{ij;kl}, \\
502: i&=&3,\hspace{0.5cm} \frac{1}{2}[S\otimes S-P\otimes P
503: \mp(S\odot S-P\odot P)]_{\alpha\beta;\gamma\delta}[1\tilde{\otimes}1]^{ij;kl}, \\
504: i&=&4,\hspace{0.5cm} \frac{1}{2}[S\otimes S+P\otimes P
505: \mp(S\odot S+P\odot P)]_{\alpha\beta;\gamma\delta}[1\tilde{\otimes}1]^{ij;kl}, \\
506: i&=&5,\hspace{0.5cm} \frac{1}{2}[T\otimes T \mp T\odot T]_{\alpha\beta;\gamma\delta}[1\tilde{\otimes}1]^{ij;kl},
507: \eea
508: where $\otimes,\odot$ act on the Dirac spinor space
509: as
510: $[\Gamma\otimes\Gamma]_{\alpha\beta;\gamma\delta}
511: \equiv(\Gamma)_{\alpha\beta}(\Gamma)_{\gamma\delta}$,
512: $[\Gamma\odot\Gamma]_{\alpha\beta;\gamma\delta}
513: \equiv(\Gamma)_{\alpha\delta}(\Gamma)_{\gamma\beta}$,
514: and $\tilde{\otimes},\tilde{\odot}$ on the color space as
515: $[1\tilde{\otimes}1]^{ij:kl}\equiv\delta_{ij}\delta_{kl}$,
516: $[1\tilde{\odot}1]^{ij:kl}\equiv\delta_{il}\delta_{kj}$.
517:
518: Now let us consider the one-loop vertex corrections depicted
519: by six diagrams in Fig.\ref{fig:vc_4}.
520: Their total contribution yields the vertex function at one-loop level:
521: \bea
522: i&=&1,\hspace{0.5cm} \Lambda^{(1)\pm}_1
523: =\int_{-\pi}^{\pi}\frac{d^4k}{(2\pi)^4}\Bigl[\bigl(I_{VV}^a+I_{AA}^a\bigl)+,\dots,+\bigl(I_{VV}^{c\prime}+I_{AA}^{c\prime}\bigl)\Bigl], \\
524: i&=&2,\hspace{0.5cm} \Lambda^{(1)\pm}_2
525: =\int_{-\pi}^{\pi}\frac{d^4k}{(2\pi)^4}\Bigl[\bigl(I_{VV}^a-I_{AA}^a\bigl)+,\dots,+\bigl(I_{VV}^{c\prime}-I_{AA}^{c\prime}\bigl)\Bigl], \\
526: i&=&3,\hspace{0.5cm} \Lambda^{(1)\pm}_3
527: =\int_{-\pi}^{\pi}\frac{d^4k}{(2\pi)^4}\Bigl[\bigl(I_{SS}^a-I_{PP}^a\bigl)+,\dots,+\bigl(I_{SS}^{c\prime}-I_{PP}^{c\prime}\bigl)\Bigl], \\
528: i&=&4,\hspace{0.5cm} \Lambda^{(1)\pm}_4
529: =\int_{-\pi}^{\pi}\frac{d^4k}{(2\pi)^4}\Bigl[\bigl(I_{SS}^a+I_{PP}^a\bigl)+,\dots,+\bigl(I_{SS}^{c\prime}+I_{PP}^{c\prime}\bigl)\Bigl], \\
530: i&=&5,\hspace{0.5cm} \Lambda^{(1)\pm}_5
531: =\int_{-\pi}^{\pi}\frac{d^4k}{(2\pi)^4}\Bigl[I_{TT}^{a}+,\dots,+I_{TT}^{c\prime}\Bigl],
532: \eea
533: where
534: %The contributions from Fig.~1(a),Fig.~1(b) and Fig.~1(c) takes the form
535: %\bea
536: %I_{\Gamma\Gamma}^a&=& \sum_{\alpha,\beta}\sum_{s,t}
537: % \langle q\bar{\psi}_s\rangle_{\rm ext}(0)V_{1\alpha}^A(0,k)\langle\psi_s\bar{q}\rangle(k)\Gamma
538: % \langle q\bar{\psi}_t\rangle(k) V_{1\beta}^B(-k,0)\langle\psi_tq\rangle_{\rm ext}(0)
539: % G_{\alpha\beta}^{AB}(k)\otimes\Gamma \\
540: %I_{\Gamma\Gamma}^b&=& \sum_{\alpha,\beta}\sum_{s,t}
541: % \langle q\bar{\psi}_s\rangle_{\rm ext}(0)V_{1\alpha}^A(0,k)\langle\psi_s\bar{q}\rangle(k)\Gamma
542: % \otimes\Gamma\langle q\bar{\psi}_t\rangle(k)V_{1\beta}^B(-k,0)\langle\psi_t\bar{q}\rangle_{ \rm ext}(0)
543: % G_{\alpha\beta}^{AB}(k) \\
544: %I_{\Gamma\Gamma}^c&=& \sum_{\alpha,\beta}\sum_{s,t}
545: % \langle q\bar{\psi}_s\rangle_{\rm ext}(0)V_{1\alpha}^A(0,k)\langle\psi_s\bar{q}\rangle(k)\Gamma
546: % \otimes\langle q\bar{\psi}_t\rangle_{\rm ext}(0)V_{1\beta}^B(0,-k)\langle \psi_t\bar{q}\rangle(-k)\Gamma
547: % G_{\alpha\beta}^{AB}(k)
548: %\eea
549: %where $\Gamma=\{\mathbf{1},\gamma_\mu,\sigma_{\mu\nu},\gamma_\mu\gamma_5,\gamma_5\}\equiv\{S,V,T,A,P\}$.
550: %After a little calculation the expressions of
551: %$I_{\Gamma\Gamma}^{a,b,c}$ are reduced to
552: \bea
553: I_{\Gamma\Gamma}^a&=& \frac{1}{2}g^2 (T^AT^A\tilde{\otimes}1)
554: K\Bigl[\{\gamma_\alpha\gamma_\beta\Gamma\gamma_\beta\gamma_\alpha\otimes\Gamma
555: \bigl(\frac{1}{4}A_{\alpha\beta}\sin^2k_\alpha\sin^2k_\beta
556: +\sum_{\sigma}A_{\alpha\sigma}\sin^2\frac{k_\sigma}{2}\cos^2\frac{k_\alpha}{2}\sin^2k_\beta\bigl)\nn\\
557: &+&\Gamma\otimes\Gamma\bigl(4\Delta_3^2-\frac{1}{4}\sum_{\sigma}\Delta_{1,1}^\alpha
558: +\frac{1}{4}\sum_\alpha\sin^4k_\alpha+T\bigl)\Bigl\}
559: \mp\{\otimes\leftrightarrow\odot\}], \label{iga}\\
560: I_{\Gamma\Gamma}^b&=& \frac{1}{2}g^2 (T^A\tilde{\otimes}T^A)
561: K \Bigl[\{\gamma_\alpha\gamma_\beta\Gamma\otimes\Gamma\gamma_\beta\gamma_\alpha
562: \bigl(\frac{1}{4}A_{\alpha\beta}\sin^2k_\alpha\sin^2k_\beta
563: +\sum_{\sigma}A_{\alpha\beta}\sin^2\frac{k_\sigma}{2}\cos^2\frac{k_\alpha}{2}\sin^2k_\beta\bigl)\nn\\
564: &+&\Gamma\otimes\Gamma\bigl(4\Delta_3^2-\frac{1}{4}\sum_\alpha\Delta_{1,1}^\alpha
565: +\frac{1}{4}\sum_\sigma\sin^4k_\sigma+T\bigl) \Bigl\}
566: \mp\{\otimes\leftrightarrow\odot\}], \label{igb} \\
567: I_{\Gamma\Gamma}^c&=& -\frac{1}{2}g^2 (T^A\tilde{\otimes}T^A)
568: K \Bigl[\{\gamma_\alpha\gamma_\beta\Gamma\otimes\gamma_\alpha\gamma_\beta\Gamma
569: \bigl(\frac{1}{4}A_{\alpha\beta}\sin^2k_\alpha\sin^2k_\beta
570: +\sum_{\sigma}A_{\alpha\sigma}\sin^2\frac{k_\sigma}{2}\cos^2\frac{k_\alpha}{2}\sin^2k_\beta\bigl)\nn\\
571: &+&\Gamma\otimes\Gamma\bigl(4\Delta_3^2-\frac{1}{4}\sum_\sigma\Delta_{1,1}^\sigma
572: +\frac{1}{4}\sum_\sigma\sin^2k_\sigma+T\bigl) \Bigl\}
573: \mp\{\otimes\leftrightarrow\odot\}] \label{igc}
574: \eea
575: with
576: \bea
577: K&\equiv&\frac{4}{\left(4\sum_{\mu}\sin^2\frac{k_{\mu}}{2}\right)^2}
578: \frac{1}{\tilde{F}_0^2\tilde{F}^2}, \\
579: \tilde{F}_0&\equiv& e^\alpha-w_0, \\
580: \tilde{F} &\equiv& e^{-\alpha}-W,\\
581: T &\equiv& r^2\Delta_1^2\tilde{F}^2+4r\Delta_3\Delta_1\tilde{F},\\
582: \Delta_3 &=& \frac{1}{4}\sum_\mu\sin^2k_\mu, \\
583: \Delta_1 &=& \sum_\mu\sin^2\frac{k_\mu}{2}, \\
584: \Delta_{1,1}^\mu &=&
585: \sum_\nu(\delta_{\mu\nu}+A_{\mu\nu})\sin^2k_\mu\sin^2k_\nu.
586: \eea
587: Summation over repeated indices is assumed.
588: The above expressions are obtained with the aid of
589: useful formula presented in Refs.\cite{AIKT98,AIKT99,AIKT02}.
590: We should note that the other three contributions
591: $I_{\Gamma\Gamma}^{a^\prime,b^\prime,c^\prime}$
592: from Figs.~1$a^\prime$, 1$b^\prime$, 1$c^\prime$ are
593: equal to $I_{\Gamma\Gamma}^{a,b,c}$ respectively.
594: After all, the total contribution becomes
595: \bea
596: \bigl(I_{VV}^a+I_{AA}^a\bigl)+,\dots,+\bigl(I_{VV}^{c\prime}+I_{AA}^{c\prime}\bigl) &=&
597: g^2[V\otimes V+A\otimes A\mp(V\odot V+A\odot A)]_{\alpha\beta:\gamma\delta}
598: [1\tilde{\otimes}1]^{ij:kl} \notag \\ &&
599: \times K[(\frac{1}{N}\mp1)A_{SP}+(2C_F-\frac{1}{N}\pm1)A_{VA}+2C_FT], \\
600: \bigl(I_{VV}^a-I_{AA}^a\bigl)+,\dots,+\bigl(I_{VV}^{c\prime}-I_{AA}^{c\prime}\bigl) &=&
601: g^2[V\otimes V-A\otimes A\mp(V\odot V-A\odot A)]_{\alpha\beta:\gamma\delta}
602: [1\tilde{\otimes}1]^{ij:kl} \notag \\&&
603: \times K[-\frac{1}{N}A_{SP}+(2C_F+\frac{1}{N})A_{VA}+2C_FT] \notag \\
604: &&+g^2[S\otimes S-P\otimes P\mp(S\odot S-P\odot P)]_{\alpha\beta:\gamma\delta}
605: [1\tilde{\otimes}1]^{ij:kl} \notag \\&&
606: \times K[\mp2 A_{SP}\pm 2A_{VA}], \\
607: \bigl(I_{SS}^a-I_{PP}^a\bigl)+,\dots,+\bigl(I_{SS}^{c\prime}-I_{PP}^{c\prime}\bigl)&=&
608: g^2[S\otimes S-P\otimes P\mp(S\odot S-P\odot P)]_{\alpha\beta:\gamma\delta}
609: [1\tilde{\otimes}1]^{ij:kl}\notag \\&&
610: \times K[2C_FA_{SP}+2C_FT],\\
611: \bigl(I_{SS}^a+I_{PP}^a\bigl)+,\dots,+\bigl(I_{SS}^{c\prime}+I_{PP}^{c\prime}\bigl)&=&
612: g^2[S\otimes S+P\otimes P\mp(S\odot S+P\odot P)]_{\alpha\beta:\gamma\delta}
613: [1\tilde{\otimes}1]^{ij:kl} \notag \\ &&
614: \times K[(2C_F\mp1)A_{SP}\pm A_{VA}+2C_FT] \notag \\
615: &&+g^2(1-w_0^2)^2([T\otimes T\mp T\otimes T]_{\alpha\beta:\gamma\delta}
616: [1\tilde{\otimes}1]^{ij:kl} \notag \\&&
617: \times K[(\frac{2}{3N}\mp\frac{1}{3})A_{SP}+(-\frac{2}{3N}\pm\frac{1}{3})A_{VA})], \\
618: I_{TT}^{a}+,\dots,+I_{TT}^{c\prime} &=&
619: g^2[T\otimes T\mp T\odot T]_{\alpha\beta:\gamma\delta}
620: [1\tilde{\otimes}1]^{ij:kl} \notag \\&&
621: \times K[(-\frac{2C_F}{3}\mp1)A_{SP}
622: +(\frac{8C_F}{3}\pm1)A_{VA}+2C_FT]\notag \\
623: &&+g^2[S\otimes S+P\otimes P\mp(S\odot S+ P\odot P)]_{\alpha\beta:\gamma\delta}
624: [1\tilde{\otimes}1]^{ij:kl} \notag \\&&
625: \times K(\frac{2}{N}\pm1)[A_{SP}-A_{VA}],
626: \eea
627: where we use the Fierz rearrangements:
628: \bea
629: \bigl[S\otimes S\bigl]\bigl[1\tilde{\odot}1\bigl] &=&
630: \frac{1}{4}\bigl[S\odot S+V\odot V-T\odot T-A\odot A+P\odot P\bigl]
631: \bigl[1\tilde{\otimes}1\bigl], \\
632: \bigl[V\otimes V\bigl]\bigl[1\tilde{\odot}1\bigl] &=&
633: \frac{1}{4}\bigl[4S\odot S-2V\odot V-2A\odot A-4P\odot P\bigl]
634: \bigl[1\tilde{\otimes}1\bigl], \\
635: \bigl[T\otimes T\bigl]\bigl[1\tilde{\odot}1\bigl] &=&
636: \frac{1}{4}\bigl[-6S\odot S-2T\odot T-6P\odot P\bigl]
637: \bigl[1\tilde{\otimes}1\bigl], \\
638: \bigl[A\otimes A\bigl]\bigl[1\tilde{\odot}1\bigl] &=&
639: \frac{1}{4}\bigl[-4S\odot S-2V\odot V-2A\odot A+4P\odot P\bigl]
640: \bigl[1\tilde{\otimes}1\bigl], \\
641: \bigl[P\otimes P\bigl]\bigl[1\tilde{\odot}1\bigl] &=&
642: \frac{1}{4}\bigl[S\odot S-V\odot V-T\odot T+A\odot A+P\odot P\bigl]
643: \bigl[1\tilde{\otimes}1\bigl].
644: %\bigl[V\otimes V+A\otimes A\bigl]\bigl[1\tilde{\odot}1\bigl] &=&
645: % -\bigl[V\odot V+A\odot A\bigl]\bigl[1\tilde{\otimes}1\bigl] \\
646: %\bigl[V\otimes V-A\otimes A\bigl]\bigl[1\tilde{\odot}1\bigl] &=&
647: % 2\bigl[S\odot S-P\odot P\bigl]\bigl[1\tilde{\otimes}1\bigl] \\
648: %\bigl[T\otimes T\bigl]\bigl[1\tilde{\odot}1\bigl] &=&
649: % \frac{1}{4}\bigl[-6S\odot S-6P\odot P-2T\odot T\bigl]
650: % \bigl[1\tilde{\otimes}1\bigl] \\
651: %\bigl[S\otimes S+P\otimes P\bigl]\bigl[1\tilde{\odot}1\bigl] &=&
652: % \frac{1}{2}\bigl[S\odot S+P\odot P-T\odot T\bigl]\bigl[1\tilde{\otimes}1\bigl]
653: \eea
654: Note that these formula do not include
655: Fermi statistics.
656:
657:
658: Comparing the one-loop results to the tree level ones we obtain
659: \bea
660: \Lambda_1^{\pm} &=& \Bigl[1+g^2\frac{N\mp1}{N}\{\mp\langle A_{SP}\rangle
661: +(N\pm2)\langle A_{VA}\rangle+(N\pm1)\langle
662: T\rangle\}\Bigl]\Lambda_1^{(0)\pm}, \label{lam1}\\
663: \Lambda_2^{\pm} &=& \Bigl[1+g^2\{-\frac{1}{N}\langle A_{SP}\rangle
664: +(2C_F+\frac{1}{N})\langle A_{VA}\rangle
665: +2C_F\langle T\rangle\}\Bigl]\Lambda_2^{(0)\pm} \notag \\&&
666: +g^2\{\mp2\langle A_{SP}\rangle\pm2\langle A_{VA}\rangle\}\Lambda_3^{(0)\pm}, \label{lam2}\\
667: \Lambda_3^{\pm} &=& \Bigl[1+g^22C_F\{\langle A_{SP}\rangle
668: +\langle T\rangle \}\Bigl]\Lambda_3^{(0)\pm}, \label{lam3}\\
669: \Lambda_4^{\pm} &=& \Bigl[1+g^2\frac{1}{N}\{(N^2\mp N-1)\langle A_{SP}\rangle
670: \pm N\langle A_{VA}\rangle+(N^2-1)\langle T\rangle \}\Bigl]\Lambda_4^{(0)\pm}\notag \\&&
671: +g^2\frac{2\mp N}{3N}\{\langle A_{SP}\rangle
672: -\langle A_{VA}\rangle\}\Lambda_5^{(0)\pm}, \label{lam4} \\
673: \Lambda_5^{\pm} &=&
674: \Bigl[1+g^2\{(-\frac{2C_F}{3}\mp1)\langle A_{SP}\rangle
675: +(\frac{8C_F}{3}\pm1)\langle A_{VA}\rangle
676: +2C_F\langle T\rangle \}\Bigl]\Lambda_5^{(0)\pm} \notag \\&&
677: +g^2(\frac{2}{N}\pm1)\{\langle A_{SP}\rangle-\langle A_{VA}\rangle\}
678: \Lambda_4^{(0)\pm} \label{lam5}
679: \eea
680: with
681: \bea
682: \langle X\rangle=\int_{-\pi}^\pi \frac{d^4k}{(2\pi)^4}K(k)X(k)
683: \eea
684: for $X=T,A_{VA},A_{SP}$.
685: We remark that $C_F\langle T+A_{VA}\rangle$ and
686: $C_F\langle T+A_{SP}\rangle$ correspond to the one-loop
687: vertex corrections to the (axial) vector and the
688: (pseudo) scalar density.
689: % which are expressed as
690: %$(T_{V,A}-1),(T_{S,P}-1)$ in Ref.\cite{AIKT98}.
691: $A_{VA}$ and $A_{SP}$ are expressed as follows:
692: \bea
693: A_{VA} &=& 4\Delta_3^2-\Delta_{1,1}^\mu+4s_\mu^2\Delta_{1,0}^\mu, \\
694: A_{SP} &=& 16\Delta_3\Delta_{1,0}^\mu
695: \eea
696: with
697: \bea
698: \Delta_{1,0}^\mu &=&
699: \sum_\nu(\delta_{\mu\nu}+A_{\mu\nu})\cos^2\frac{k_\mu}{2}\sin^2\frac{k_\nu}{2}.
700: \eea
701: The expressions of Eqs.\eqref{lam1} and \eqref{lam3}
702: show important properties of $Q_1$ and $Q_3$ in DWQCD
703: formalism:
704: the one-loop vertex corrections are multiplicative.
705: This is contrary to the Wilson case, in which the mixing
706: operators with different chiralities appears at the
707: one-loop level.
708: The results for $Q_1^{\pm}$ in Eq.\eqref{lam1}
709: are already obtained in Ref.~\cite{AIKT99}.
710:
711:
712: Combining the contribution from the quark self-energy
713: evaluated in Ref.~\cite{AIKT98} and the vertex corrections,
714: we obtain the lattice renormalization factors:
715: \bea
716: Z_{ij}^{\pm{\rm lat}} =(1-w_0^2)^2Z_w^2Z_2^2V_{ij}^\pm,
717: \eea
718: where
719: \bea
720: Z_2 &=& 1+\frac{g^2}{16\pi^2}C_F[\log(\lambda a)^2+\Sigma_1], \\
721: Z_w &=& 1-\frac{2w_0}{1-w_0^2}\frac{g^2C_F}{16\pi^2}\Sigma_3, \\
722: V_{ij}^\pm &=& \delta_{ij}+\frac{g^2}{16\pi^2}\bigl[\gamma_{ij}^\pm\log(\lambda a)^2+v_{ij}^\pm\bigl].
723: \eea\
724: $\lambda$ is the fictitious gluon mass introduced
725: to regularize the infrared divergences.
726: $\Sigma_1$ and $\Sigma_3$ are finite parts of the
727: renormalization factors of quark wave function and
728: overall factor $(1-w_0^2)$, whose numerical value is
729: given in Ref.\cite{AIKT02}.
730: The matrix $v_{ij}^\pm$ is expressed as
731: \bea
732: v_{ij}^\pm=\left(
733: \begin{array}{@{\,}ccccc@{\,}}
734: v_{11}^\pm&0&0&0&0 \\
735: 0&v_{22}^\pm& v_{23}^\pm&0&0 \\
736: 0&0 & v_{33}^\pm&0&0 \\
737: 0&0&0&v_{44}^\pm&v_{45}^\pm \\
738: 0&0&0&v_{54}^\pm&v_{55}^\pm \\
739: \end{array}
740: \right),
741: \eea
742: whose components are
743: \bea
744: v_{11}^+ &=& \frac{16\pi^2(N-1)}{N}\bigl[-\langle\langle A_{SP}\rangle\rangle
745: +(N+2)\langle\langle A_{VA}\rangle\rangle+(N+1)\langle T\rangle\bigl]
746: +\gamma_{11}^+\log\pi^2, \label{v1p}\\
747: v_{11}^- &=& \frac{16\pi^2(N+1)}{N}\bigl[\langle\langle A_{SP}\rangle\rangle
748: +(N-2)\langle\langle A_{VA}\rangle\rangle+(N-1)\langle T\rangle\bigl]
749: +\gamma_{11}^-\log\pi^2, \label{v1m}\\
750: v_{22}^\pm &=& \frac{16\pi^2}{N}\bigl[-\langle\langle A_{SP}\rangle\rangle
751: +N^2\langle\langle A_{VA}\rangle\rangle+(N^2-1)\langle T\rangle\bigl]
752: +\gamma_{22}^\pm\log\pi^2, \\
753: v_{23}^\pm &=& \mp16\pi^2\bigl[2\langle\langle A_{SP}\rangle\rangle
754: -2\langle\langle A_{VA}\rangle\rangle\bigl]
755: +\gamma_{23}^\pm\log\pi^2, \\
756: v_{33}^\pm &=& \frac{16\pi^2(N+1)(N-1)}{N}\bigl[\langle\langle A_{SP}\rangle\rangle
757: +\langle T\rangle\bigl]
758: +\gamma_{33}^\pm\log\pi^2, \\
759: %\eea
760: %\bea
761: v_{44}^\pm &=& \frac{16\pi^2}{N}\bigl[(N^2\mp N-1)\langle\langle A_{SP}\rangle\rangle
762: \pm N\langle\langle A_{VA}\rangle\rangle+(N^2-1)\langle T\rangle\bigl]
763: +\gamma_{44}^\pm\log\pi^2, \\
764: v_{45}^\pm &=& \frac{16\pi^2(2\mp N)}{3N}\bigl[\langle\langle A_{SP}\rangle\rangle
765: -\langle\langle A_{VA}\rangle\rangle\bigl]
766: +\gamma_{45}^\pm\log\pi^2, \\
767: %\eea
768: %\bea
769: v_{55}^\pm &=& \frac{16\pi^2}{N}\bigl[\frac{-N^2\mp3N+1}{3}\langle\langle A_{SP}\rangle\rangle
770: +\frac{4N^2\pm3N-4}{3}\langle\langle A_{VA}\rangle\rangle+(N^2-1)\langle T\rangle\bigl]
771: +\gamma_{55}^\pm\log\pi^2, \\
772: v_{54}^\pm &=& \frac{16\pi^2(2\pm N)}{N}\bigl[\langle\langle A_{SP}\rangle\rangle
773: -\langle\langle A_{VA}\rangle\rangle\bigl]
774: +\gamma_{54}^\pm\log\pi^2
775: \eea
776: with
777: \bea
778: \gamma_{ij}^{\pm} &=& \left(
779: \begin{array}{@{\,}ccccc@{\,}}
780: \gamma_{11}^\pm &0&0&0&0 \\
781: 0&\gamma_{22}^\pm& \gamma_{23}^\pm&0&0 \\
782: 0&0& \gamma_{33}^\pm&0&0 \\
783: 0&0&0&\gamma_{44}^\pm&\gamma_{45}^\pm \\
784: 0&0&0&\gamma_{54}^\pm&\gamma_{55}^\pm \\
785: \end{array}
786: \right) \notag \\
787: &=&
788: \left(
789: \begin{array}{@{\,}ccccc@{\,}}
790: \frac{(N\mp1)(N\mp2)}{N} &0&0&0&0 \\
791: 0&\frac{(N+2)(N-2)}{N}&\mp6&0&0 \\
792: 0&0& 4\frac{(N+1)(N-1)}{N}&0&0 \\
793: 0&0&0&\frac{4N^2\mp3N-4}{N}&\frac{2\mp N}{N} \\
794: 0&0&0&\frac{6\pm3N}{N}&\mp3 \\
795: \end{array}
796: \right). \label{anomaldim}
797: \eea
798: The infrared singularity in $\langle A_X\rangle$ is
799: subtracted as
800: \bea
801: \langle\langle A_X\rangle\rangle =\int_{-\pi}^\pi\frac{d^4k}{(2\pi)^4}
802: \Biggl[K(k)A_X(k)-c_X\frac{\theta(\pi^2-k^2)}{(k^2)^2}\Biggl],
803: \eea
804: where $c_{SP}=4$ and $c_{VA}=1$.
805:
806: The lattice operators and the continuum ones
807: defined in the $\msbar$ scheme with the naive dimensional
808: reguralization (NDR) are related as
809: \bea
810: Q_i^{\pm\msbar}(\mu) &=& \frac{1}{(1-\omega^2_0)^2Z_\omega^2}Z_{ij}^\pm(\mu
811: a)Q_j^{\pm{\rm lat}}(1/a)
812: % \\
813: %\left(
814: % \begin{array}{@{\,}c@{\,}}
815: % Q_1^{\msbar}(\mu) \\
816: % Q_2^{\msbar}(\mu) \\
817: % Q_3^{\msbar}(\mu) \\
818: % Q_4^{\msbar}(\mu) \\
819: % Q_5^{\msbar}(\mu) \\
820: % \end{array}
821: % \right)^{\pm}
822: % &=&
823: % \frac{1}{(1-\omega^2_0)^2Z_\omega^2}
824: %\left(
825: % \begin{array}{@{\,}ccccc@{\,}}
826: % Z_{11}^\pm(\mu a) &0&0&0&0 \\
827: % 0&Z_{22}^\pm(\mu a)& Z_{23}^\pm(\mu a)&0&0 \\
828: % 0&0& Z_{33}^\pm(\mu a)&0&0 \\
829: % 0&0&0&Z_{44}^\pm(\mu a)&Z_{45}^\pm(\mu a) \\
830: % 0&0&0&Z_{54}^\pm(\mu a)&Z_{55}^\pm(\mu a) \\
831: % \end{array}
832: % \right)
833: %\left(
834: % \begin{array}{@{\,}c@{\,}}
835: % Q_1^{lat}(1/a) \\
836: % Q_2^{lat}(1/a) \\
837: % Q_3^{lat}(1/a) \\
838: % Q_4^{lat}(1/a) \\
839: % Q_5^{lat}(1/a) \\
840: % \end{array}
841: % \right)^{\pm}
842: \eea
843: with
844: \bea
845: Z_{ij}^\pm(\mu a) &\equiv& \frac{(Z_2^{\msbar})^2}{Z_2^2}\frac{V_{ij}^{\pm\msbar}}{V_{ij}^{\pm}}
846: \notag\\
847: &=&
848: \delta_{ij}+\frac{g^2}{16\pi^2}\left[(\gamma_{ij}-2C_F\delta_{ij})\log(\mu a)^2+z_{ij}^\pm\right]
849: \label{eq:zij_def}\\
850: z_{ij}^\pm &=&
851: v_{ij}^{\pm\msbar}-v_{ij}^\pm+\delta_{ij}2C_F(\Sigma_1^{\msbar}-\Sigma_1) \\
852: \Sigma_1^{\msbar}({\rm NDR}) &=& \frac{1}{2},
853: \hspace{1cm}
854: v_{11}^{+\msbar}({\rm NDR})=-5,
855: \hspace{1cm}
856: v_{11}^{-\msbar}({\rm NDR})=6 \\
857: v_{ij}^{\pm\msbar}({\rm NDR}) &=& \left(
858: \begin{array}{@{\,}cccc@{\,}}
859: v_{22}^{\pm\msbar}& v_{23}^{\pm\msbar}&0&0 \\
860: v_{32}^{\pm\msbar}& v_{33}^{\pm\msbar}&0&0 \\
861: 0&0&v_{44}^{\pm\msbar}&v_{45}^{\pm\msbar} \\
862: 0&0&v_{54}^{\pm\msbar}&v_{55}^{\pm\msbar} \\
863: \end{array}
864: \right)
865: = \left(
866: \begin{array}{@{\,}cccc@{\,}}
867: -\frac{7}{6}& -1&0&0 \\
868: \pm\frac{3}{2}& \frac{19}{3}&0&0 \\
869: 0&0& \frac{17}{3}\mp 1 & \frac{1}{3}\mp1 \\
870: 0&0& 1 & \frac{1}{3}\mp{2} \\
871: \end{array}
872: \right)
873: \eea
874: where
875: %$\delta_{ij}$ is Cronecker's delta ,
876: %$\gamma_{ij}$ is consistent with \eqref{anomaldim}.
877: $v_{ij}^{\pm\msbar}$ are for the case of $N=3$.
878: %Here we notice that the finite part on lattice can be
879: %written in terms of the one loop correction to bilinear operators.
880: The continuum counterparts of the wave-function renormalization factor
881: and the vertex corrections
882: are evaluated by employing the same gauge fixing condition
883: and the same infrared regulator as the lattice case.
884: Here it should be noted that the one-loop vertex corrections require to
885: specify the evanescent operators, which originates from the property
886: that the Fierz transformation cannot be defined in the NDR scheme\cite{BW90}.
887: We employ the following evanescent operators:
888: \bea
889: E_{VV}^{\rm NDR}&=&\gamma_\alpha\gamma_\beta V\otimes V\gamma_\alpha\gamma_\beta
890: -\{(D^2-2D+2)V\otimes V+2(1-D)A\otimes A\},\\
891: E_{AA}^{\rm NDR}&=&\gamma_\alpha\gamma_\beta A\otimes A\gamma_\alpha\gamma_\beta
892: -\{2(1-D)V\otimes V+(D^2-2D+2)A\otimes A\},\\
893: E_{SS}^{\rm NDR}&=&\gamma_\alpha\gamma_\beta S\otimes S\gamma_\alpha\gamma_\beta
894: -\{(D^2-5D+8)S\otimes S+(4-D)P\otimes P+(2-D)T\otimes T\},\\
895: E_{PP}^{\rm NDR}&=&\gamma_\alpha\gamma_\beta P\otimes P\gamma_\alpha\gamma_\beta
896: -\{(4-D)S\otimes S+(D^2-5D+8)P\otimes P+(2-D)T\otimes T\},\\
897: E_{TT}^{\rm NDR}&=&\gamma_\alpha\gamma_\beta T\otimes T\gamma_\alpha\gamma_\beta
898: -\{6(2-D)S\otimes S+6(2-D)P\otimes P+(D^2-2D+4)T\otimes T\},
899: \eea
900: where $D$ is the reduced space-time dimension.
901:
902: Numerical values for $v_{ij}$ and $z_{ij}$ are evaluated
903: by momentum integration, which is performed by a mode sum
904: for a periodic box of a
905: size $L^4$ after transforming the momentum variable
906: through $k_\mu=q_\mu-\sin q_\mu$.
907: We employ the size $L=64$ for integrals,
908: and numerical error is estimated by varying $L$ from
909: 64 to 60. The results are presented in Table
910: I,$\dots$,VI for the plaquette gauge action and in Table
911: VII,$\dots$,XII for the Iwasaki gauge action as a
912: function of $M$.
913: These values are evaluated with $N=3$.
914:
915:
916: %5
917: %=============================================
918: \section{Renormalization factors for SUSY operators}
919: \label{sec:susy}
920: %=============================================
921: %
922: Let us consider the parity-conserving parts of the SUSY operators
923: in Eqs.(\ref{eq:op_susy1})$-$(\ref{eq:op_susy5}),
924: which are relevant for $K^0-\kzbar$ mixing.
925: They are related to the operators
926: of Eqs.(\ref{eq:op_gen1})$-$(\ref{eq:op_gen5}) as
927: \bea
928: {\cal O}_1 &=& Q_1^+, \\
929: {\cal O}_2 &=& Q_4^+, \\
930: {\cal O}_3 &=& -\frac{1}{2}(Q_4^+-Q_5^+), \\
931: {\cal O}_4 &=& Q_3^+, \\
932: {\cal O}_5 &=& -\frac{1}{2}Q_2^+,
933: \eea
934: where we take $q_1=q_3=s$ and $q_2=q_4=d$ in Eq.(\ref{eq:op_gen}).
935: With the use of these relations,
936: the renormalization factors for ${\cal O}_i$ are expressed as
937: \bea
938: {\cal O}_1^{\msbar}(\mu) &=& \frac{1}{(1-\omega^2_0)^2Z_\omega^2}
939: [Z_{11}^+(\mu a){\cal O}_1^{{\rm lat}}(1/a)], \\
940: {\cal O}_2^{\msbar}(\mu) &=& \frac{1}{(1-\omega^2_0)^2Z_\omega^2}
941: [(Z_{44}^+(\mu a)+Z_{45}^+(\mu a)){\cal O}_2^{{\rm lat}}(1/a)
942: +2Z_{45}^+(\mu a){\cal O}_3^{{\rm lat}}(1/a)], \\
943: {\cal O}_3^{\msbar}(\mu) &=& \frac{1}{(1-\omega^2_0)^2Z_\omega^2}
944: [(Z_{55}^+(\mu a)-Z_{45}^+(\mu a)){\cal O}_3^{{\rm lat}}(1/a)\nn\\
945: &&-\frac{1}{2}(Z_{44}^+(\mu a)+Z_{45}^+(\mu a)
946: -Z_{54}^+(\mu a)-Z_{55}^+(\mu a)){\cal O}_2^{{\rm lat}}(1/a)], \\
947: {\cal O}_4^{\msbar}(\mu) &=& \frac{1}{(1-\omega^2_0)^2Z_\omega^2}
948: [Z_{33}^+(\mu a){\cal O}_4^{{\rm lat}}(1/a)
949: -2Z_{32}^+(\mu a){\cal O}_5^{{\rm lat}}(1/a)], \\
950: {\cal O}_5^{\msbar}(\mu) &=& \frac{1}{(1-\omega^2_0)^2Z_\omega^2}
951: [Z_{22}^+(\mu a){\cal O}_5^{{\rm lat}}(1/a)
952: -\frac{1}{2}Z_{23}^+(\mu a){\cal O}_4^{{\rm lat}}(1/a)],
953: \eea
954: where $Z_{ij}^{+}$ are given in Eq.(\ref{eq:zij_def}).
955:
956: %
957: %==============================================
958: \section{Mean field improvement}
959: \label{sec:mf}
960: %==============================================
961: %
962: Let us briefly explain the mean-field improvement on the
963: renormalization factors of the four-quark operators in
964: Eqs.(\ref{eq:op_gen1})$-$(\ref{eq:op_gen5}).
965: We follow the discussion in Sec.VI of Ref.\cite{AIKT02}.
966: The renormalization factors with the mean field improvement
967: for the four-quark operators are given by
968: \bea
969: Q_i^{\pm\msbar}(\mu) &=& \frac{u^2}{(1-\omega^2_0)^2Z_\omega^2}Z_{ij}^\pm(\mu
970: a)Q_j^{\pm{\rm lat}}(1/a), \\
971: Z_{ij}^{\pm}&=&
972: \delta_{ij}+\frac{g^2}{16\pi^2}\left[(\gamma_{ij}-2C_F\delta_{ij})\log(\mu a)^2+z_{ij}^{\pm{\rm MF}}\right], \\
973: z_{ij}^{\pm \rm MF} &=&
974: v_{ij}^{\pm\msbar}-v_{ij}^\pm+\delta_{ij}2C_F(\Sigma_1^{\msbar}-\Sigma_1)
975: +\delta_{ij}16\pi^2C_FT_{MF},
976: %&=& +\delta_{ij}16\pi^2 C_F T_{\rm MF}
977: %+\sum_{i=0}^{6} a_i w_0^i,
978: \label{susybpmf}
979: \eea
980: where $T_{\rm MF}$ is the one-loop correction to the mean field factor
981: defined by
982: \be
983: u=1-g^2 C_F\frac{T_{\rm MF}}{2}+\cdots
984: \ee
985: and $w_0=1-{\tilde M}$ with ${\tilde M}=M-4(1-u)$.
986: %The values of $a_i$ are given in Tables~\ref{tab:bpmf_p} and
987: %\ref{tab:bpmf_i}.
988: Note that the overall factor $(1-\omega^2_0)^2Z_\omega^2$ is
989: mean-field improved following the description in Ref.\cite{AIKT02}.
990:
991: Now it is instructive to evaluate the magnitude of
992: the renormalization factors in current representative simulations.
993: We take Ref.\cite{Noaki03} as an example, where
994: a quenched simulation of domain-wall QCD was made at
995: $\beta=6.0$ for the plaquette gauge action with $M=1.8$ and
996: $\beta=2.6$ for the Iwasaki gauge action with $M=1.8$.
997: The mean field improved $\msbar$ coupling $g^2_{\msbar}(1/a)$
998: at the scale $\mu=1/a$ is obtained from
999: \bea
1000: \frac{1}{g^2_{\msbar}}(1/a)=P\frac{\beta}{6}+d_g+c_p
1001: \eea
1002: for the plaquette gauge action, while
1003: \bea
1004: \frac{1}{g^2_{\msbar}}(1/a)=(c_0 P+8c_1R )\frac{\beta}{6}+d_g
1005: +c_0\cdot c_p+8c_1\cdot c_{R1}
1006: \eea
1007: for the Iwasaki gauge action,
1008: where the values of $d_g$ and $c_p$ are listed in Table XVI of
1009: Ref.\cite{AIKT02}. $P$ denotes the expectation value of the plaquette
1010: and $R$ for the $1\times 2$ rectangular.
1011: Their values are taken from Ref.\cite{bk_cppacs}.
1012: The domain-wall height $M=1.8$
1013: is replaced with
1014: ${\tilde M}=1.3112$ (plaquette) and ${\tilde M}=1.4198$ (Iwasaki),
1015: respectively, according to ${\tilde M}=M-4(1-u)$ with $u=P^{1/4}$.
1016: The mean field improved values for the renormalization factors $Z_{ij}^{\pm}$
1017: at the scale $\mu =1/a$ are given in Table~\ref{tab:susybp}.
1018: We find reasonable magnitude of corrections to the tree-level results
1019: for all the renormalization factors.
1020:
1021: %
1022: %=============================================
1023: \section{Conclusion}
1024: \label{sec:conclusion}
1025: %=============================================
1026: %
1027: In this paper we have evaluated the renormalization factors
1028: for the generic four-quark operators
1029: at the one-loop level
1030: in DWQCD with the plaquette and Iwasaki gauge actions.
1031: As an application we explain how to construct the renormalization
1032: factors for the SUSY operators by using our results.
1033: We also show that taking the parameters employed in Ref.\cite{Noaki03}
1034: the numerical values for the
1035: renormalization factors result in
1036: reasonable magnitude with the mean-field improvement.
1037: %
1038: %
1039: %=====================
1040: \section*{Acknowledgments}
1041: %=====================
1042: %
1043: This work is supported in part by Grants-in-Aid of the Ministory
1044: of Education (No.15740165).
1045: %
1046: %=======
1047: %\appendix
1048: %=======
1049: %
1050:
1051: %
1052:
1053: %\newpage
1054:
1055: \input{ref.tex}
1056:
1057: \newpage
1058:
1059: \newpage
1060: %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%
1061: %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%% table %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%
1062: %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%
1063: %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%
1064: \begin{table}[t]
1065: \begin{center}
1066: \caption{Numerical values for $v_{ij}$ $(i,j=1,\dots,5)$ as a
1067: function of $M$ with plaquette gauge action.}
1068: \begin{tabular}{|cccccc|}
1069: \hline
1070: \hline
1071: $M$ \hspace{0.8cm} & \hspace{0.8cm}$v_{11}^+$\hspace{0.8cm} & \hspace{0.8cm}$v_{11}^-$\hspace{0.8cm} & \hspace{0.8cm}$v_{22}^\pm$\hspace{0.8cm} & \hspace{0.8cm}$v_{23}^+$\hspace{0.8cm} & \hspace{0.8cm}$v_{23}^-$\hspace{0.8cm} \\
1072: \hline
1073: $0.1$ & $13.5696(73)$&$11.5369(73)$&$13.2308(18)$&$2.0327(66)$&$-2.0327(66)$ \\
1074: $0.2$ & $13.0548(73)$&$12.5870(73)$&$12.9768(18)$&$0.4678(66)$&$-0.4678(66)$ \\
1075: $0.3$ & $12.6404(73)$&$13.4380(73)$&$12.7733(18)$&$-0.7976(66)$&$0.7976(66)$ \\
1076: $0.4$ & $12.2775(72)$&$14.1882(72)$&$12.5960(18)$&$-1.9107(65)$&$1.9107(65)$ \\
1077: $0.5$ & $11.9450(73)$&$14.8801(73)$&$12.4342(18)$&$-2.9352(66)$&$2.9352(66)$ \\
1078: $0.6$ & $11.6307(72)$&$15.5380(72)$&$12.2819(18)$&$-3.9073(65)$&$3.9073(65)$ \\
1079: $0.7$ & $11.3269(73)$&$16.1781(73)$&$12.1354(18)$&$-4.8512(66)$&$4.8512(66)$ \\
1080: $0.8$ & $11.0275(72)$&$16.8129(72)$&$11.9918(18)$&$-5.7853(65)$&$5.7853(65)$ \\
1081: $0.9$ & $10.7276(74)$&$17.4523(74)$&$11.8484(18)$&$-6.7247(66)$&$6.7247(66)$ \\
1082: $1.0$ & $10.4225(73)$&$18.1071(73)$&$11.7033(18)$&$-7.6845(65)$&$7.6845(65)$ \\
1083: $1.1$ & $10.1073(73)$&$18.7869(73)$&$11.5539(18)$&$-8.6796(66)$&$8.6796(66)$ \\
1084: $1.2$ & $9.7767(75)$&$19.5039(75)$&$11.3979(19)$&$-9.7271(67)$&$9.7271(67)$ \\
1085: $1.3$ & $9.4243(73)$&$20.2719(73)$&$11.2322(18)$&$-10.8475(66)$&$10.8475(66)$ \\
1086: $1.4$ & $9.0419(75)$&$21.1082(75)$&$11.0529(19)$&$-12.0664(67)$&$12.0664(67)$ \\
1087: $1.5$ & $8.6183(73)$&$22.0373(73)$&$10.8548(18)$&$-13.4191(65)$&$13.4191(65)$ \\
1088: $1.6$ & $8.1375(74)$&$23.0928(74)$&$10.6301(18)$&$-14.9553(66)$&$14.9553(66)$ \\
1089: $1.7$ & $7.5747(73)$&$24.3277(73)$&$10.3669(18)$&$-16.7531(66)$&$16.7531(66)$ \\
1090: $1.8$ & $6.8864(73)$&$25.8324(73)$&$10.0440(18)$&$-18.9460(66)$&$18.9460(66)$ \\
1091: $1.9$ & $5.9812(73)$&$27.7944(73)$&$9.6168(18)$&$-21.8132(66)$&$21.8132(66)$ \\
1092: \hline
1093: \hline
1094: \end{tabular}
1095: \end{center}
1096: \end{table}
1097:
1098:
1099: %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%
1100: \begin{table}[b]
1101: \begin{center}
1102: \caption{Numerical values for $v_{ij}$ $(i,j=1,\dots,5)$ as a
1103: function of $M$ with plaquette gauge action.}
1104: \begin{tabular}{|llllll|}
1105: \hline
1106: \hline
1107: $M$\hspace{0.8cm} &\hspace{0.8cm}$v_{33}^\pm$\hspace{0.8cm} &\hspace{0.8cm}$v_{44}^+$
1108: \hspace{0.8cm} & \hspace{0.8cm}$v_{44}^-$\hspace{0.8cm} & \hspace{0.8cm}$v_{45}^+$
1109: \hspace{0.8cm} &\hspace{0.8cm}$v_{45}^-$\hspace{0.8cm}\\
1110: \hline
1111: $0.1$ & $10.182(12)$&$11.1981(84)$&$9.165(15)$&$0.11293(37)$&$-0.5646(18)$ \\
1112: $0.2$ & $12.275(12)$&$12.5090(84)$&$12.041(15)$&$0.02599(37)$&$-0.1299(18)$ \\
1113: $0.3$ & $13.970(12)$&$13.5709(84)$&$14.369(15)$&$-0.04431(37)$&$0.2216(18)$ \\
1114: $0.4$ & $15.462(12)$&$14.5067(83)$&$16.417(15)$&$-0.10615(36)$&$0.5307(18)$ \\
1115: $0.5$ & $16.837(12)$&$15.3693(84)$&$18.305(15)$&$-0.16307(36)$&$0.8153(18)$ \\
1116: $0.6$ & $18.143(12)$&$16.1893(83)$&$20.097(15)$&$-0.21707(36)$&$1.0854(18)$ \\
1117: $0.7$ & $19.412(12)$&$16.9866(84)$&$21.838(15)$&$-0.26951(37)$&$1.3476(18)$ \\
1118: $0.8$ & $20.670(11)$&$17.7771(83)$&$23.562(15)$&$-0.32141(36)$&$1.6070(18)$ \\
1119: $0.9$ & $21.935(12)$&$18.5731(85)$&$25.298(15)$&$-0.37359(37)$&$1.8680(18)$ \\
1120: $1.0$ & $23.230(12)$&$19.3878(84)$&$27.072(15)$&$-0.42692(36)$&$2.1346(18)$ \\
1121: $1.1$ & $24.573(12)$&$20.2335(84)$&$28.913(15)$&$-0.48220(37)$&$2.4110(18)$ \\
1122: $1.2$ & $25.989(12)$&$21.1250(86)$&$30.852(15)$&$-0.54040(37)$&$2.7020(19)$ \\
1123: $1.3$ & $27.504(12)$&$22.0798(84)$&$32.927(15)$&$-0.60264(37)$&$3.0132(18)$ \\
1124: $1.4$ & $29.153(12)$&$23.1193(86)$&$35.186(15)$&$-0.67036(37)$&$3.3518(19)$ \\
1125: $1.5$ & $30.983(12)$&$24.2739(84)$&$37.693(15)$&$-0.74550(36)$&$3.7275(18)$ \\
1126: $1.6$ & $33.063(12)$&$25.5853(85)$&$40.541(15)$&$-0.83085(37)$&$4.1542(18)$ \\
1127: $1.7$ & $35.496(12)$&$27.1199(84)$&$43.873(15)$&$-0.93073(37)$&$4.6536(18)$ \\
1128: $1.8$ & $38.463(12)$&$28.9900(84)$&$47.936(15)$&$-1.05255(37)$&$5.2628(18)$ \\
1129: $1.9$ & $42.337(12)$&$31.4299(84)$&$53.243(15)$&$-1.21184(37)$&$6.0592(18)$ \\
1130: \hline
1131: \hline
1132: \end{tabular}
1133: \end{center}
1134: \end{table}
1135:
1136:
1137: \clearpage
1138: \newpage
1139: %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%
1140: \begin{table}[t]
1141: \begin{center}
1142: \caption{Numerical values for $v_{ij}$ $(i,j=1,\dots,5)$ as a
1143: function of $M$ with plaquette gauge action.}
1144: \begin{tabular}{|ccccc|}
1145: \hline
1146: \hline
1147: $M$\hspace{0.8cm} &\hspace{0.8cm}$v_{55}^+$\hspace{0.8cm} &\hspace{0.8cm}$v_{55}^-$
1148: \hspace{0.8cm} & \hspace{0.8cm}$v_{54}^+$\hspace{0.8cm} & \hspace{0.8cm}$v_{54}^-$
1149: \hspace{0.8cm}\\
1150: \hline
1151: $0.1$ & $14.8119(33)$&$12.7791(33)$&$-1.6939(55)$&$0.3388(11)$ \\
1152: $0.2$ & $13.3406(33)$&$12.8729(33)$&$-0.3898(55)$&$0.0780(11)$ \\
1153: $0.3$ & $12.1530(33)$&$12.9506(33)$&$0.6647(55)$&$-0.1329(11)$ \\
1154: $0.4$ & $11.1099(32)$&$13.0206(33)$&$1.5922(54)$&$-0.3184(11)$ \\
1155: $0.5$ & $10.1512(33)$&$13.0864(33)$&$2.4460(55)$&$-0.4892(11)$ \\
1156: $0.6$ & $9.2429(33)$&$13.1502(33)$&$3.2561(54)$&$-0.6512(11)$ \\
1157: $0.7$ & $8.3622(33)$&$13.2135(33)$&$4.0427(55)$&$-0.8085(11)$ \\
1158: $0.8$ & $7.4920(32)$&$13.2774(32)$&$4.8211(54)$&$-0.9642(11)$ \\
1159: $0.9$ & $6.6181(33)$&$13.3428(33)$&$5.6039(55)$&$-1.1208(11)$ \\
1160: $1.0$ & $5.7264(33)$&$13.4109(33)$&$6.4038(55)$&$-1.2808(11)$ \\
1161: $1.1$ & $4.8031(33)$&$13.4827(33)$&$7.2330(55)$&$-1.4466(11)$ \\
1162: $1.2$ & $3.8324(34)$&$13.5595(34)$&$8.1059(56)$&$-1.6212(11)$ \\
1163: $1.3$ & $2.7953(33)$&$13.6428(33)$&$9.0396(55)$&$-1.8079(11)$ \\
1164: $1.4$ & $1.6679(34)$&$13.7343(34)$&$10.0553(56)$&$-2.0111(11)$ \\
1165: $1.5$ & $0.4177(33)$&$13.8368(33)$&$11.1826(55)$&$-2.2365(11)$ \\
1166: $1.6$ & $-1.0018(33)$&$13.9535(33)$&$12.4627(55)$&$-2.4925(11)$ \\
1167: $1.7$ & $-2.6633(33)$&$14.0898(33)$&$13.9609(55)$&$-2.7922(11)$ \\
1168: $1.8$ & $-4.6917(33)$&$14.2543(33)$&$15.7883(55)$&$-3.1577(11)$ \\
1169: $1.9$ & $-7.3491(33)$&$14.4641(33)$&$18.1777(55)$&$-3.6355(11)$ \\
1170: \hline
1171: \hline
1172: \end{tabular}
1173: \end{center}
1174: \end{table}
1175:
1176:
1177: %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%
1178: \begin{table}[b]
1179: \begin{center}
1180: \caption{Numerical values for $z_{ij}$ $(i,j=1,\dots,5)$ as a
1181: function of $M$ with plaquette gauge action.}
1182: \begin{tabular}{|llllll|}
1183: \hline
1184: \hline
1185: $M$\hspace{0.8cm} &\hspace{0.8cm}$z_{11}^+$\hspace{0.8cm} &\hspace{0.8cm}$z_{11}^-$
1186: \hspace{0.8cm} &\hspace{0.8cm}$z_{22}^\pm$\hspace{0.8cm} &
1187: \hspace{0.8cm}$z_{23}^+$\hspace{0.8cm} &
1188: \hspace{0.8cm}$z_{23}^-$\hspace{0.8cm}\\
1189: \hline
1190: $0.1$ & $-52.33012(24)$&$-39.2974(68)$&$-48.1580(13)$&$-3.0327(66)$&$1.0327(66)$ \\
1191: $0.2$ & $-51.4142(13)$&$-39.9464(53)$&$-47.50286(22)$&$-1.4678(66)$&$-0.5322(66)$ \\
1192: $0.3$ & $-50.6609(11)$&$-40.4585(55)$&$-46.960537(34)$&$-0.2024(66)$&$-1.7976(66)$ \\
1193: $0.4$ & $-50.0050(14)$&$-40.9157(51)$&$-46.49015(35)$&$0.9107(65)$&$-2.9107(65)$ \\
1194: $0.5$ & $-49.41704(64)$&$-41.3522(72)$&$-46.0729(17)$&$1.9352(66)$&$-3.9352(66)$ \\
1195: $0.6$ & $-48.8806(11)$&$-41.7879(54)$&$-45.698460(58)$&$2.9073(65)$&$-4.9073(65)$ \\
1196: $0.7$ & $-48.3854(18)$&$-42.2366(48)$&$-45.36057(67)$&$3.8512(66)$&$-5.8512(66)$ \\
1197: $0.8$ & $-47.92464(38)$&$-42.7100(61)$&$-45.05553(70)$&$4.7853(65)$&$-6.7853(65)$ \\
1198: $0.9$ & $-47.49355(14)$&$-43.2182(68)$&$-44.7810(12)$&$5.7247(66)$&$-7.7247(66)$ \\
1199: $1.0$ & $-47.0888(16)$&$-43.7734(50)$&$-44.53624(49)$&$6.6845(65)$&$-8.6845(65)$ \\
1200: $1.1$ & $-46.707975(79)$&$-44.3876(67)$&$-44.3212(12)$&$7.6796(66)$&$-9.6796(66)$ \\
1201: $1.2$ & $-46.3494(12)$&$-45.0765(55)$&$-44.137215(96)$&$8.7271(67)$&$-10.7271(67)$ \\
1202: $1.3$ & $-46.011799(83)$&$-45.8593(65)$&$-43.9864(10)$&$9.8475(66)$&$-11.8475(66)$ \\
1203: $1.4$ & $-45.6944(11)$&$-46.7608(56)$&$-43.872137(23)$&$11.0664(67)$&$-13.0664(67)$ \\
1204: $1.5$ & $-45.3964(14)$&$-47.8155(51)$&$-43.79961(34)$&$12.4191(65)$&$-14.4191(65)$ \\
1205: $1.6$ & $-45.11658(35)$&$-49.0719(70)$&$-43.7758(15)$&$13.9553(66)$&$-15.9553(66)$ \\
1206: $1.7$ & $-44.8518(17)$&$-50.6049(49)$&$-43.81064(62)$&$15.7531(66)$&$-17.7531(66)$ \\
1207: $1.8$ & $-44.59306(72)$&$-52.5390(73)$&$-43.9174(18)$&$17.9460(66)$&$-19.9460(66)$ \\
1208: $1.9$ & $-44.3086(13)$&$-55.1218(53)$&$-44.11077(18)$&$20.8132(66)$&$-22.8132(66)$ \\
1209: \hline
1210: \hline
1211: \end{tabular}
1212: \end{center}
1213: \end{table}
1214:
1215: \clearpage
1216: \newpage
1217: %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%
1218: \begin{table}[t]
1219: \begin{center}
1220: \caption{Numerical values for $z_{ij}$ $(i,j=1,\dots,5)$ as a
1221: function of $M$ with plaquette gauge action.}
1222: \begin{tabular}{|llllll|}
1223: \hline
1224: \hline
1225: $M$\hspace{0.8cm} &\hspace{0.8cm}$z_{33}^\pm$\hspace{0.8cm} &\hspace{0.8cm}$z_{44}^+$
1226: \hspace{0.8cm} & \hspace{0.8cm}$z_{44}^-$\hspace{0.8cm} & \hspace{0.8cm}$z_{45}^+$
1227: \hspace{0.8cm} &\hspace{0.8cm}$z_{45}^-$\hspace{0.8cm}\\
1228: \hline
1229: $0.1$ & $-37.609(11)$&$-40.2919(79)$&$-36.259(14)$&$-0.77960(37)$&$1.8980(18)$ \\
1230: $0.2$ & $-39.3012(97)$&$-41.2018(64)$&$-38.734(13)$&$-0.69265(37)$&$1.4633(18)$ \\
1231: $0.3$ & $-40.6569(99)$&$-41.9248(66)$&$-40.722(13)$&$-0.62236(37)$&$1.1118(18)$ \\
1232: $0.4$ & $-41.8562(94)$&$-42.5675(61)$&$-42.478(13)$&$-0.56052(36)$&$0.8026(18)$ \\
1233: $0.5$ & $-42.976(12)$&$-43.1748(83)$&$-44.110(15)$&$-0.50360(36)$&$0.5180(18)$ \\
1234: $0.6$ & $-44.0595(97)$&$-43.7725(65)$&$-45.680(13)$&$-0.44959(36)$&$0.2480(18)$ \\
1235: $0.7$ & $-45.1374(92)$&$-44.3785(59)$&$-47.230(13)$&$-0.39715(37)$&$-0.0142(18)$ \\
1236: $0.8$ & $-46.234(10)$&$-45.0075(72)$&$-48.793(14)$&$-0.34526(36)$&$-0.2737(18)$ \\
1237: $0.9$ & $-47.368(11)$&$-45.6723(79)$&$-50.397(14)$&$-0.29307(37)$&$-0.5346(18)$ \\
1238: $1.0$ & $-48.5631(93)$&$-46.3875(61)$&$-52.072(13)$&$-0.23975(36)$&$-0.8013(18)$ \\
1239: $1.1$ & $-49.841(11)$&$-47.1675(78)$&$-53.847(14)$&$-0.18447(37)$&$-1.0777(18)$ \\
1240: $1.2$ & $-51.228(10)$&$-48.0310(66)$&$-55.758(13)$&$-0.12627(37)$&$-1.3686(19)$ \\
1241: $1.3$ & $-52.758(11)$&$-49.0006(76)$&$-57.848(14)$&$-0.06403(37)$&$-1.6799(18)$ \\
1242: $1.4$ & $-54.472(10)$&$-50.1052(67)$&$-60.172(13)$&$0.00369(37)$&$-2.0184(19)$ \\
1243: $1.5$ & $-56.4282(95)$&$-51.3854(62)$&$-62.804(13)$&$0.07884(36)$&$-2.3942(18)$ \\
1244: $1.6$ & $-58.709(11)$&$-52.8977(81)$&$-65.853(15)$&$0.16418(37)$&$-2.8209(18)$ \\
1245: $1.7$ & $-61.4402(93)$&$-54.7304(60)$&$-69.483(13)$&$0.26406(37)$&$-3.3203(18)$ \\
1246: $1.8$ & $-64.836(12)$&$-57.0300(84)$&$-73.976(15)$&$0.38589(37)$&$-3.9294(18)$ \\
1247: $1.9$ & $-69.3305(97)$&$-60.0906(64)$&$-79.904(13)$&$0.54518(37)$&$-4.7259(18)$ \\
1248: \hline
1249: \hline
1250: \end{tabular}
1251: \end{center}
1252: \end{table}
1253:
1254: %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%
1255: \begin{table}[b]
1256: \begin{center}
1257: \caption{Numerical values for $z_{ij}$ $(i,j=1,\dots,5)$ as a
1258: function of $M$ with plaquette gauge action.}
1259: \begin{tabular}{|ccccc|}
1260: \hline
1261: \hline
1262: $M$\hspace{0.8cm} &\hspace{0.8cm}$z_{55}^+$\hspace{0.8cm} &
1263: \hspace{0.8cm}$z_{55}^-$\hspace{0.8cm} &
1264: \hspace{0.8cm}$z_{54}^+$\hspace{0.8cm} &
1265: \hspace{0.8cm}$z_{54}^-$\hspace{0.8cm}\\
1266: \hline
1267: $0.1$ & $-50.2390(38)$&$-44.2063(28)$&$2.6939(55)$&$0.6612(11)$ \\
1268: $0.2$ & $-48.3667(54)$&$-43.8989(12)$&$1.3898(55)$&$0.9220(11)$ \\
1269: $0.3$ & $-46.8402(52)$&$-43.6378(14)$&$0.3353(55)$&$1.1329(11)$ \\
1270: $0.4$ & $-45.5041(54)$&$-43.4147(11)$&$-0.5922(54)$&$1.3184(11)$ \\
1271: $0.5$ & $-44.2900(34)$&$-43.2252(32)$&$-1.4460(55)$&$1.4892(11)$ \\
1272: $0.6$ & $-43.1594(51)$&$-43.0668(14)$&$-2.2561(54)$&$1.6512(11)$ \\
1273: $0.7$ & $-42.0874(58)$&$-42.93862(80)$&$-3.0427(55)$&$1.8085(11)$ \\
1274: $0.8$ & $-41.0558(43)$&$-42.8412(21)$&$-3.8211(54)$&$1.9642(11)$ \\
1275: $0.9$ & $-40.0507(39)$&$-42.7754(27)$&$-4.6039(55)$&$2.1208(11)$ \\
1276: $1.0$ & $-39.0594(56)$&$-42.74392(96)$&$-5.4038(55)$&$2.2808(11)$ \\
1277: $1.1$ & $-38.0704(40)$&$-42.7500(26)$&$-6.2330(55)$&$2.4466(11)$ \\
1278: $1.2$ & $-37.0717(53)$&$-42.7988(14)$&$-7.1059(56)$&$2.6212(11)$ \\
1279: $1.3$ & $-36.0494(41)$&$-42.8970(25)$&$-8.0396(55)$&$2.8079(11)$ \\
1280: $1.4$ & $-34.9872(52)$&$-43.0536(15)$&$-9.0553(56)$&$3.0111(11)$ \\
1281: $1.5$ & $-33.8626(54)$&$-43.2816(11)$&$-10.1826(55)$&$3.2365(11)$ \\
1282: $1.6$ & $-32.6439(37)$&$-43.5992(29)$&$-11.4627(55)$&$3.4925(11)$ \\
1283: $1.7$ & $-31.2805(57)$&$-44.03354(85)$&$-12.9609(55)$&$3.7922(11)$ \\
1284: $1.8$ & $-29.6816(33)$&$-44.6276(33)$&$-14.7883(55)$&$4.1577(11)$ \\
1285: $1.9$ & $-27.6450(53)$&$-45.4581(13)$&$-17.1777(55)$&$4.6355(11)$ \\
1286: \hline
1287: \hline
1288: \end{tabular}
1289: \end{center}
1290: \end{table}
1291:
1292: \clearpage
1293: \newpage
1294: %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%
1295: %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%% table IN IWASAKI %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%
1296: %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%
1297:
1298: %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%
1299: \begin{table}[t]
1300: \begin{center}
1301: \caption{Numerical values for$v_{ij}$ $(i,j=1,\dots,5)$ as a function
1302: of $M$ with Iwasaki gauge action.}
1303: \begin{tabular}{|llllll|}
1304: \hline
1305: \hline
1306: $M$\hspace{0.8cm} &\hspace{0.8cm}$v_{11}^+$\hspace{0.8cm} &\hspace{0.8cm}$v_{11}^-$
1307: \hspace{0.8cm} &\hspace{0.8cm}$v_{22}^\pm$\hspace{0.8cm} &\hspace{0.8cm}$v_{23}^+$
1308: \hspace{0.8cm}&\hspace{0.8cm}$v_{23}^-$\hspace{0.8cm}\\
1309: \hline
1310: $0.1$ & $14.1911(73)$&$10.1069(73)$&$13.5104(18)$&$4.0842(66)$&$-4.0842(66)$ \\
1311: $0.2$ & $13.7193(73)$&$11.0602(73)$&$13.2761(18)$&$2.6591(66)$&$-2.6591(66)$ \\
1312: $0.3$ & $13.3494(73)$&$11.8105(73)$&$13.0929(18)$&$1.5389(66)$&$-1.5389(66)$ \\
1313: $0.4$ & $13.0327(72)$&$12.4558(72)$&$12.9365(18)$&$0.5769(65)$&$-0.5769(65)$ \\
1314: $0.5$ & $12.7480(73)$&$13.0378(73)$&$12.7963(18)$&$-0.2899(66)$&$0.2899(66)$ \\
1315: $0.6$ & $12.4836(72)$&$13.5804(72)$&$12.6664(18)$&$-1.0968(65)$&$1.0968(65)$ \\
1316: $0.7$ & $12.2320(73)$&$14.0990(73)$&$12.5431(18)$&$-1.8670(66)$&$1.8670(66)$ \\
1317: $0.8$ & $11.9874(72)$&$14.6053(72)$&$12.4237(18)$&$-2.6179(65)$&$2.6179(65)$ \\
1318: $0.9$ & $11.7451(74)$&$15.1082(74)$&$12.3057(18)$&$-3.3631(66)$&$3.3631(66)$ \\
1319: $1.0$ & $11.5011(73)$&$15.6173(73)$&$12.1871(18)$&$-4.1162(65)$&$4.1162(65)$ \\
1320: $1.1$ & $11.2508(73)$&$16.1409(73)$&$12.0658(18)$&$-4.8901(66)$&$4.8901(66)$ \\
1321: $1.2$ & $10.9896(75)$&$16.6892(75)$&$11.9395(19)$&$-5.6997(67)$&$5.6997(67)$ \\
1322: $1.3$ & $10.7118(73)$&$17.2742(73)$&$11.8055(18)$&$-6.5624(66)$&$6.5624(66)$ \\
1323: $1.4$ & $10.4101(75)$&$17.9105(75)$&$11.6602(19)$&$-7.5004(67)$&$7.5004(67)$ \\
1324: $1.5$ & $10.0748(73)$&$18.6191(73)$&$11.4988(18)$&$-8.5444(65)$&$8.5444(65)$ \\
1325: $1.6$ & $9.6912(74)$&$19.4294(74)$&$11.3142(18)$&$-9.7382(66)$&$9.7382(66)$ \\
1326: $1.7$ & $9.2365(73)$&$20.3887(73)$&$11.0952(18)$&$-11.1523(66)$&$11.1523(66)$ \\
1327: $1.8$ & $8.6700(73)$&$21.5799(73)$&$10.8217(18)$&$-12.9099(66)$&$12.9099(66)$ \\
1328: $1.9$ & $7.9044(73)$&$23.1801(73)$&$10.4503(18)$&$-15.2758(66)$&$15.2758(66)$ \\
1329: \hline
1330: \hline
1331: \end{tabular}
1332: \end{center}
1333: \end{table}
1334:
1335: %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%
1336: \begin{table}[b]
1337: \begin{center}
1338: \caption{Numerical values for $v_{ij}$ $(i,j=1,\dots,5)$
1339: as a function of $M$ with Iwasaki gauge action.}
1340: \begin{tabular}{|llllll|}
1341: \hline
1342: \hline
1343: $M$\hspace{0.8cm} &\hspace{0.8cm}$v_{33}^\pm$\hspace{0.8cm} &\hspace{0.8cm}$v_{44}^+$
1344: \hspace{0.8cm} &\hspace{0.8cm}$v_{44}^-$\hspace{0.8cm} &\hspace{0.8cm}$v_{45}^+$
1345: \hspace{0.8cm} &\hspace{0.8cm}$v_{45}^-$\hspace{0.8cm} \\
1346: \hline
1347: $0.1$ & $7.384(12)$&$9.4262(84)$&$5.342(15)$&$0.22690(37)$&$-1.1345(18)$ \\
1348: $0.2$ & $9.287(12)$&$10.6170(84)$&$7.958(15)$&$0.14773(37)$&$-0.7386(18)$ \\
1349: $0.3$ & $10.785(12)$&$11.5540(84)$&$10.015(15)$&$0.08549(37)$&$-0.4275(18)$ \\
1350: $0.4$ & $12.071(12)$&$12.3596(83)$&$11.783(15)$&$0.03205(36)$&$-0.1603(18)$ \\
1351: $0.5$ & $13.231(12)$&$13.0862(84)$&$13.376(15)$&$-0.01610(36)$&$0.0805(18)$ \\
1352: $0.6$ & $14.312(12)$&$13.7632(83)$&$14.860(15)$&$-0.06093(36)$&$0.3047(18)$ \\
1353: $0.7$ & $15.344(12)$&$14.4102(84)$&$16.277(15)$&$-0.10372(37)$&$0.5186(18)$ \\
1354: $0.8$ & $16.351(11)$&$15.0416(83)$&$17.660(15)$&$-0.14544(36)$&$0.7272(18)$ \\
1355: $0.9$ & $17.350(12)$&$15.6687(85)$&$19.032(15)$&$-0.18684(37)$&$0.9342(18)$ \\
1356: $1.0$ & $18.361(12)$&$16.3033(84)$&$20.420(15)$&$-0.22868(36)$&$1.1434(18)$ \\
1357: $1.1$ & $19.401(12)$&$16.9559(84)$&$21.846(15)$&$-0.27167(37)$&$1.3584(18)$ \\
1358: $1.2$ & $20.489(12)$&$17.6392(86)$&$23.339(15)$&$-0.31665(37)$&$1.5832(19)$ \\
1359: $1.3$ & $21.649(12)$&$18.3680(84)$&$24.930(15)$&$-0.36458(37)$&$1.8229(18)$ \\
1360: $1.4$ & $22.911(12)$&$19.1606(86)$&$26.661(15)$&$-0.41669(37)$&$2.0834(19)$ \\
1361: $1.5$ & $24.315(12)$&$20.0432(84)$&$28.588(15)$&$-0.47469(36)$&$2.3734(18)$ \\
1362: $1.6$ & $25.921(12)$&$21.0524(85)$&$30.791(15)$&$-0.54101(37)$&$2.7051(18)$ \\
1363: $1.7$ & $27.824(12)$&$22.2475(84)$&$33.400(15)$&$-0.61957(37)$&$3.0979(18)$ \\
1364: $1.8$ & $30.186(12)$&$23.7315(84)$&$36.641(15)$&$-0.71721(37)$&$3.5861(18)$ \\
1365: $1.9$ & $33.364(12)$&$25.7261(84)$&$41.002(15)$&$-0.84865(37)$&$4.2433(18)$ \\
1366: \hline
1367: \hline
1368: \end{tabular}
1369: \end{center}
1370: \end{table}
1371:
1372: \clearpage
1373: \newpage
1374: %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%
1375: \begin{table}[t]
1376: \begin{center}
1377: \caption{Numerical values for
1378: $v_{ij}$ $(i,j=1,\dots,5)$ as a function of $M$ with Iwasaki gauge action.}
1379: \begin{tabular}{|lllll|}
1380: \hline
1381: \hline
1382: $M$\hspace{0.8cm} &\hspace{0.8cm}$v_{55}^+$\hspace{0.8cm} &\hspace{0.8cm}$v_{55}^-$
1383: \hspace{0.8cm} &\hspace{0.8cm}$v_{54}^+$\hspace{0.8cm} &\hspace{0.8cm}$v_{54}^-$
1384: \hspace{0.8cm}\\
1385: \hline
1386: $0.1$ & $16.6870(33)$&$12.6028(33)$&$-3.4035(55)$&$0.6807(11)$ \\
1387: $0.2$ & $15.3443(33)$&$12.6852(33)$&$-2.2159(55)$&$0.4432(11)$ \\
1388: $0.3$ & $14.2899(33)$&$12.7510(33)$&$-1.2824(55)$&$0.2565(11)$ \\
1389: $0.4$ & $13.3852(32)$&$12.8083(33)$&$-0.4808(54)$&$0.0962(11)$ \\
1390: $0.5$ & $12.5708(33)$&$12.8607(33)$&$0.2416(55)$&$-0.0483(11)$ \\
1391: $0.6$ & $11.8133(33)$&$12.9102(33)$&$0.9140(54)$&$-0.1828(11)$ \\
1392: $0.7$ & $11.0910(33)$&$12.9580(33)$&$1.5559(55)$&$-0.3112(11)$ \\
1393: $0.8$ & $10.3875(32)$&$13.0055(32)$&$2.1816(54)$&$-0.4363(11)$ \\
1394: $0.9$ & $9.6899(33)$&$13.0530(33)$&$2.8025(55)$&$-0.5605(11)$ \\
1395: $1.0$ & $8.9856(33)$&$13.1018(33)$&$3.4302(55)$&$-0.6860(11)$ \\
1396: $1.1$ & $8.2624(33)$&$13.1525(33)$&$4.0751(55)$&$-0.8150(11)$ \\
1397: $1.2$ & $7.5064(34)$&$13.2061(34)$&$4.7497(56)$&$-0.9499(11)$ \\
1398: $1.3$ & $6.7014(33)$&$13.2638(33)$&$5.4687(55)$&$-1.0937(11)$ \\
1399: $1.4$ & $5.8266(34)$&$13.3270(34)$&$6.2503(56)$&$-1.2501(11)$ \\
1400: $1.5$ & $4.8532(33)$&$13.3976(33)$&$7.1203(55)$&$-1.4241(11)$ \\
1401: $1.6$ & $3.7400(33)$&$13.4782(33)$&$8.1152(55)$&$-1.6230(11)$ \\
1402: $1.7$ & $2.4212(33)$&$13.5735(33)$&$9.2936(55)$&$-1.8587(11)$ \\
1403: $1.8$ & $0.7807(33)$&$13.6905(33)$&$10.7582(55)$&$-2.1516(11)$ \\
1404: $1.9$ & $-1.4308(33)$&$13.8449(33)$&$12.7298(55)$&$-2.5460(11)$ \\
1405: \hline
1406: \hline
1407: \end{tabular}
1408: \end{center}
1409: \end{table}
1410:
1411: %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%
1412: \begin{table}[b]
1413: \begin{center}
1414: \caption{Numerical values for
1415: $z_{ij}$ $(i,j=1,\dots,5)$ as a function of $M$ with Iwasaki gauge action.}
1416: \begin{tabular}{|llllll|}
1417: \hline
1418: \hline
1419: $M$\hspace{0.8cm} &\hspace{0.8cm}$z_{11}^+$\hspace{0.8cm} &\hspace{0.8cm}$z_{11}^-$
1420: \hspace{0.8cm} &\hspace{0.8cm}$z_{22}^\pm$\hspace{0.8cm} &\hspace{0.8cm}$z_{23}^+$
1421: \hspace{0.8cm} &\hspace{0.8cm}$z_{23}^-$\hspace{0.8cm}\\
1422: \hline
1423: $0.1$ & $-30.25980(58)$&$-15.1756(72)$&$-25.7458(17)$&$-5.0842(66)$&$3.0842(66)$ \\
1424: $0.2$ & $-29.43439(58)$&$-15.7753(72)$&$-25.1579(17)$&$-3.6591(66)$&$1.6591(66)$ \\
1425: $0.3$ & $-28.77133(70)$&$-16.2324(73)$&$-24.6815(18)$&$-2.5389(66)$&$0.5389(66)$ \\
1426: $0.4$ & $-28.20508(57)$&$-16.6282(71)$&$-24.2756(17)$&$-1.5769(65)$&$-0.4231(65)$ \\
1427: $0.5$ & $-27.70614(68)$&$-16.9960(72)$&$-23.9211(18)$&$-0.7101(66)$&$-1.2899(66)$ \\
1428: $0.6$ & $-27.25798(48)$&$-17.3548(70)$&$-23.6075(16)$&$0.0968(65)$&$-2.0968(65)$ \\
1429: $0.7$ & $-26.85022(60)$&$-17.7173(72)$&$-23.3281(17)$&$0.8670(66)$&$-2.8670(66)$ \\
1430: $0.8$ & $-26.47585(51)$&$-18.0938(70)$&$-23.0788(16)$&$1.6179(65)$&$-3.6179(65)$ \\
1431: $0.9$ & $-26.12985(57)$&$-18.4929(72)$&$-22.8570(17)$&$2.3631(66)$&$-4.3631(66)$ \\
1432: $1.0$ & $-25.80864(62)$&$-18.9249(72)$&$-22.6613(17)$&$3.1162(65)$&$-5.1162(65)$ \\
1433: $1.1$ & $-25.50947(72)$&$-19.3996(73)$&$-22.4912(18)$&$3.8901(66)$&$-5.8901(66)$ \\
1434: $1.2$ & $-25.23026(60)$&$-19.9299(73)$&$-22.3469(17)$&$4.6997(67)$&$-6.6997(67)$ \\
1435: $1.3$ & $-24.96938(47)$&$-20.5318(71)$&$-22.2298(16)$&$5.5624(66)$&$-7.5624(66)$ \\
1436: $1.4$ & $-24.72536(72)$&$-21.2258(74)$&$-22.1421(18)$&$6.5004(67)$&$-8.5004(67)$ \\
1437: $1.5$ & $-24.49673(63)$&$-22.0411(72)$&$-22.0875(17)$&$7.5444(65)$&$-9.5444(65)$ \\
1438: $1.6$ & $-24.28127(49)$&$-23.0195(71)$&$-22.0710(16)$&$8.7382(66)$&$-10.7382(66)$ \\
1439: $1.7$ & $-24.07481(51)$&$-24.2271(71)$&$-22.1002(16)$&$10.1523(66)$&$-12.1523(66)$ \\
1440: $1.8$ & $-23.86686(71)$&$-25.7767(73)$&$-22.1852(18)$&$11.9099(66)$&$-13.9099(66)$ \\
1441: $1.9$ & $-23.62377(52)$&$-27.8995(71)$&$-22.3364(16)$&$14.2758(66)$&$-16.2758(66)$ \\
1442: \hline
1443: \hline
1444: \end{tabular}
1445: \end{center}
1446: \end{table}
1447:
1448: \clearpage
1449: \newpage
1450: %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%
1451: \begin{table}[t]
1452: \begin{center}
1453: \caption{Numerical values for
1454: $z_{ij}$ $(i,j=1,\dots,5)$ as a function of $M$ with Iwasaki gauge action.}
1455: \begin{tabular}{|llllll|}
1456: \hline
1457: \hline
1458: $M$\hspace{0.8cm} &\hspace{0.8cm}$z_{33}^\pm$\hspace{0.8cm} &\hspace{0.8cm}$z_{44}^+$
1459: \hspace{0.8cm} &\hspace{0.8cm}$z_{44}^-$\hspace{0.8cm} &\hspace{0.8cm}$z_{45}^+$
1460: \hspace{0.8cm}&\hspace{0.8cm}$z_{45}^-$\hspace{0.8cm}\\
1461: \hline
1462: $0.1$ & $-12.119(12)$&$-15.8282(82)$&$-9.744(15)$ &$-0.89357(37)$&$2.4678(18)$ \\
1463: $0.2$ & $-13.669(12)$&$-16.6654(83)$&$-12.006(15)$&$-0.81440(37)$&$2.0720(18)$ \\
1464: $0.3$ & $-14.873(12)$&$-17.3093(84)$&$-13.770(15)$&$-0.75216(37)$&$1.7608(18)$ \\
1465: $0.4$ & $-15.910(11)$&$-17.8654(82)$&$-15.288(15)$&$-0.69872(36)$&$1.4936(18)$ \\
1466: $0.5$ & $-16.856(12)$&$-18.3777(83)$&$-16.668(15)$&$-0.65056(36)$&$1.2528(18)$ \\
1467: $0.6$ & $-17.753(11)$&$-18.8709(81)$&$-17.968(15)$&$-0.60573(36)$&$1.0287(18)$ \\
1468: $0.7$ & $-18.629(12)$&$-19.3618(83)$&$-19.229(15)$&$-0.56294(37)$&$0.8147(18)$ \\
1469: $0.8$ & $-19.506(11)$&$-19.8634(81)$&$-20.481(15)$&$-0.52123(36)$&$0.6061(18)$ \\
1470: $0.9$ & $-20.402(12)$&$-20.3867(83)$&$-21.750(15)$&$-0.47983(37)$&$0.3992(18)$ \\
1471: $1.0$ & $-21.336(12)$&$-20.9442(83)$&$-23.060(15)$&$-0.43799(36)$&$0.1899(18)$ \\
1472: $1.1$ & $-22.326(12)$&$-21.5479(84)$&$-24.438(15)$&$-0.39499(37)$&$-0.0250(18)$ \\
1473: $1.2$ & $-23.396(12)$&$-22.2132(84)$&$-25.913(15)$&$-0.35002(37)$&$-0.2499(19)$ \\
1474: $1.3$ & $-24.573(11)$&$-22.9589(82)$&$-27.521(15)$&$-0.30209(37)$&$-0.4896(18)$ \\
1475: $1.4$ & $-25.893(12)$&$-23.8092(85)$&$-29.310(15)$&$-0.24998(37)$&$-0.7501(19)$ \\
1476: $1.5$ & $-27.404(12)$&$-24.7985(83)$&$-31.343(15)$&$-0.19198(36)$&$-1.0401(18)$ \\
1477: $1.6$ & $-29.178(12)$&$-25.9758(82)$&$-33.714(15)$&$-0.12566(37)$&$-1.3717(18)$ \\
1478: $1.7$ & $-31.329(11)$&$-27.4191(82)$&$-36.571(15)$&$-0.04710(37)$&$-1.7645(18)$ \\
1479: $1.8$ & $-34.050(12)$&$-29.2617(84)$&$-40.172(15)$&$0.05055(37)$&$-2.2527(18)$ \\
1480: $1.9$ & $-37.750(11)$&$-31.7788(82)$&$-45.055(15)$&$0.18199(37)$&$-2.9099(18)$ \\
1481: \hline
1482: \hline
1483: \end{tabular}
1484: \end{center}
1485: \end{table}
1486:
1487: %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%
1488: \begin{table}[b]
1489: \begin{center}
1490: \caption{Numerical values for
1491: $z_{ij}$ $(i,j=1,\dots,5)$ as a function of $M$ with Iwasaki gauge action.}
1492: \begin{tabular}{|lllll|}
1493: \hline
1494: \hline
1495: $M$\hspace{0.8cm} &\hspace{0.8cm}$z_{55}^+$\hspace{0.8cm} & \hspace{0.8cm}$z_{55}^-$
1496: \hspace{0.8cm} & \hspace{0.8cm}$z_{54}^+$\hspace{0.8cm} & \hspace{0.8cm}$z_{54}^-$
1497: \hspace{0.8cm}\\
1498: \hline
1499: $0.1$ & $-29.4224(34)$&$-21.3382(31)$&$4.4035(55)$&$0.3193(11)$ \\
1500: $0.2$ & $-27.7261(34)$&$-21.0670(31)$&$3.2159(55)$&$0.5568(11)$ \\
1501: $0.3$ & $-26.3784(33)$&$-20.8395(33)$&$2.2824(55)$&$0.7435(11)$ \\
1502: $0.4$ & $-25.2243(34)$&$-20.6474(31)$&$1.4808(54)$&$0.9038(11)$ \\
1503: $0.5$ & $-24.1957(33)$&$-20.4855(32)$&$0.7584(55)$&$1.0483(11)$ \\
1504: $0.6$ & $-23.2544(35)$&$-20.3512(30)$&$0.0860(54)$&$1.1828(11)$ \\
1505: $0.7$ & $-22.3759(34)$&$-20.2430(32)$&$-0.5559(55)$&$1.3112(11)$ \\
1506: $0.8$ & $-21.5427(34)$&$-20.1606(30)$&$-1.1816(54)$&$1.4363(11)$ \\
1507: $0.9$ & $-20.7413(35)$&$-20.1044(31)$&$-1.8025(55)$&$1.5605(11)$ \\
1508: $1.0$ & $-19.9598(34)$&$-20.0761(32)$&$-2.4302(55)$&$1.6860(11)$ \\
1509: $1.1$ & $-19.1877(33)$&$-20.0778(33)$&$-3.0751(55)$&$1.8150(11)$ \\
1510: $1.2$ & $-18.4138(35)$&$-20.1135(32)$&$-3.7497(56)$&$1.9499(11)$ \\
1511: $1.3$ & $-17.6257(36)$&$-20.1881(30)$&$-4.4687(55)$&$2.0937(11)$ \\
1512: $1.4$ & $-16.8085(34)$&$-20.3088(33)$&$-5.2503(56)$&$2.2501(11)$ \\
1513: $1.5$ & $-15.9418(34)$&$-20.4862(32)$&$-6.1203(55)$&$2.4241(11)$ \\
1514: $1.6$ & $-14.9968(36)$&$-20.7350(31)$&$-7.1152(55)$&$2.6230(11)$ \\
1515: $1.7$ & $-13.9262(35)$&$-21.0785(31)$&$-8.2936(55)$&$2.8587(11)$ \\
1516: $1.8$ & $-12.6442(33)$&$-21.5540(33)$&$-9.7582(55)$&$3.1516(11)$ \\
1517: $1.9$ & $-10.9552(35)$&$-22.2310(31)$&$-11.7298(55)$&$3.5460(11)$ \\
1518: \hline
1519: \hline
1520: \end{tabular}
1521: \end{center}
1522: \end{table}
1523: \clearpage
1524: \newpage
1525: %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%
1526: \begin{table}[t]
1527: \begin{center}
1528: \caption{Numerical values of $Z_{ij}^{\pm}$ $(i,j=1,\dots,5)$
1529: for plaquette gauge action (upper part)
1530: and Iwasaki gauge action (lower part).}
1531: \label{tab:susybp}
1532: \begin{tabular}{l|llllll|}
1533: \hline
1534: \hline
1535: $\beta$ & $P$ & $g_{\msbar}^2(1/a)$ & $M$ & & \\
1536: $6.0$ & $0.59374$ & $2.1793$ & $1.80$ & &\\
1537: \hline
1538: $\tilde M$& $Z_{11}^+$ &$Z_{11}^-$& $Z_{22}^\pm$ & $Z_{23}^+$
1539: & $Z_{23}^-$ \\
1540: $1.3112$ & $0.7287$ & $0.7289$ & $0.7564$ & $0.1378$ & $-0.1654$ \\
1541: &$Z_{33}^+$& $Z_{32}^\pm$ &$Z_{44}^+$& $Z_{44}^-$& $Z_{45}^+$ \\
1542: & $0.6325$ & $\pm0.0207$ & $0.6853$ & $0.5613$ & $-0.0007790$ \\
1543: & $Z_{45}^-$ &$Z_{55}^+$&$Z_{55}^-$& $Z_{54}^+$& $Z_{54}^-$\\
1544: & $-0.02371$ &$0.8674$ & $0.7710$ & $-0.1125$ & $0.03906$\\
1545: \hline
1546: \hline
1547: \hline
1548: $\beta$ & $P$ & $R$ &$g_{\msbar}^2(1/a)$ & $M$ & \\
1549: $2.6$ & $0.67063$ & $0.45283$ & $2.2479$ & $1.80$ &
1550: \\
1551: \hline
1552: $\tilde M$& $Z_{11}^+$ &$Z_{11}^-$& $Z_{22}^\pm$ & $Z_{23}^+$
1553: & $Z_{23}^-$ \\
1554: $1.4198$ & $0.8062$ & $0.8531$ & $0.8425$ & $0.09548$ & $-0.1239$\\
1555: &$Z_{33}^+$& $Z_{32}^\pm$ &$Z_{44}^+$& $Z_{44}^-$& $Z_{45}^+$\\
1556: & $0.7847$ & $\pm0.02135$ &$0.8158$ & $0.7346$ & $-0.003395$ \\
1557: &$Z_{45}^-$& $Z_{55}^+$&$Z_{55}^-$& $Z_{54}^+$& $Z_{54}^-$\\
1558: & $-0.01150$& $0.9207$ & $0.8680$ & $-0.07719$ & $0.03252$ \\
1559: \hline
1560: \hline
1561: \end{tabular}
1562: \end{center}
1563: \end{table}
1564:
1565: \clearpage
1566: \newpage
1567: %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%% FIGURES %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%
1568: \begin{figure}
1569: \begin{center}
1570: %\setlength{\unitlength}{2pt}
1571: \begin{picture}(420,450)(0,20)
1572: %\put(30,130){Fig.1'}
1573: \Text(60,60)[l]{${\rm a}^\prime$}
1574: \Vertex(70,166){4.5}
1575: \Vertex(70,154){4.5}
1576: \ArrowLine(68,166)(8,226)
1577: \ArrowLine(132,226)(72,166)
1578: \ArrowLine(68,154)(8,94)
1579: \ArrowLine(132,94)(72,154)
1580: \Gluon(20,105)(120,105){5}{8}
1581: %
1582: %\put(30,230){Fig.1}
1583: \Text(60,260)[l]{a}
1584: \Text(0,440)[l]{$\alpha,i$}
1585: \Text(115,440)[l]{$\beta,j$}
1586: \Text(0,285)[l]{$\gamma,k$}
1587: \Text(115,285)[l]{$\delta,l$}
1588: \Vertex(70,366){4.5}
1589: \Vertex(70,354){4.5}
1590: \ArrowLine(68,366)(8,426)
1591: \ArrowLine(132,426)(72,366)
1592: \ArrowLine(68,354)(8,294)
1593: \ArrowLine(132,294)(72,354)
1594: \Gluon(20,415)(120,415){-5}{8}
1595: %
1596: %\put(100,130){Fig.2}
1597: \Text(200,60)[l]{${\rm b}^\prime$}
1598: \Vertex(210,166){4.5}
1599: \Vertex(210,154){4.5}
1600: \ArrowLine(208,166)(148,226)
1601: \ArrowLine(272,226)(212,166)
1602: \ArrowLine(208,154)(148,94)
1603: \ArrowLine(272,94)(212,154)
1604: \Gluon(260,213)(260,107){-5}{8}
1605: %
1606: %\put(100,230){Fig.2}
1607: \Text(200,260)[l]{b}
1608: \Vertex(210,366){4.5}
1609: \Vertex(210,354){4.5}
1610: \ArrowLine(208,366)(148,426)
1611: \ArrowLine(272,426)(212,366)
1612: \ArrowLine(208,354)(148,294)
1613: \ArrowLine(272,294)(212,354)
1614: \Gluon(160,413)(160,307){5}{8}
1615: %
1616: %\put(170,130){Fig.3}
1617: \Text(340,60)[l]{${\rm c}^\prime$}
1618: \Vertex(350,166){4.5}
1619: \Vertex(350,154){4.5}
1620: \ArrowLine(348,166)(288,226)
1621: \ArrowLine(412,226)(352,166)
1622: \ArrowLine(348,154)(288,94)
1623: \ArrowLine(412,94)(352,154)
1624: \GlueArc(350,160)(30,51,230){-5}{7}
1625: %
1626: %\put(170,230){Fig.3}
1627: \Text(340,260)[l]{c}
1628: \Vertex(350,366){4.5}
1629: \Vertex(350,354){4.5}
1630: \ArrowLine(348,366)(288,426)
1631: \ArrowLine(412,426)(352,366)
1632: \ArrowLine(348,354)(288,294)
1633: \ArrowLine(412,294)(352,354)
1634: \GlueArc(350,360)(30,-50,130){-5}{7}
1635: \end{picture}
1636: \end{center}
1637: \caption{One-loop vertex corrections for the four-quark operator.
1638: $\alpha,\beta,\gamma,\delta$ and $i,j,k,l$ label Dirac and color
1639: indices respectively.}
1640: \label{fig:vc_4}
1641: \end{figure}
1642:
1643:
1644:
1645:
1646:
1647:
1648: %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%
1649:
1650:
1651: \end{document}
1652:
1653:
1654:
1655:
1656:
1657:
1658:
1659:
1660:
1661:
1662:
1663:
1664:
1665:
1666: