1: %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%
2:
3: \documentclass{elsart}
4:
5: \usepackage{graphics}
6: \usepackage{graphicx}% Include figure files
7: \usepackage{dcolumn}% Align table columns on decimal point
8: \usepackage{bm}% bold math
9:
10: \usepackage{latexsym}
11: \usepackage{bbm} % double-striked fonts for sets of integer numbers etc.
12: \usepackage{ifthen} % needed for Feynman-Slash macro
13: \usepackage{exscale} % correct scaling of math-symbols
14: \usepackage[intlimits]{amsmath} % improved mathematical typesetting
15: \usepackage{amsfonts}
16: \usepackage{amssymb,amscd}
17: \usepackage[dvips]{epsfig}
18: \usepackage{array}
19: \usepackage{wrapfig}
20:
21: \newcommand*{\La}{\mathcal{L}}
22: \newcommand*{\no}{\noindent}
23: \newcommand*{\bea}{\begin{eqnarray}}
24: \newcommand*{\eea}{\end{eqnarray}}
25: \newcommand*{\be}{\begin{equation}}
26: \newcommand*{\ee}{\end{equation}}
27: \newcommand*{\pd}{\partial}
28: \newcommand*{\pdm}{\pd_{\mu}}
29: \newcommand*{\pdn}{\pd_{\nu}}
30: \newcommand*{\pdi}{\pd_{i}}
31: \newcommand*{\pda}[1]{\pd_#1}
32: \newcommand*{\pref}[1]{(\ref{#1})}
33: \newcommand*{\img}{\mathrm{im}}
34: \newcommand*{\mn}{{\mu\nu}}
35: \newcommand*{\rr}{\mathbb{R}}
36: \newcommand*{\gh}{\mathrm{gh}}
37: \newcommand*{\sdet}{\mathrm{sdet}}
38: \newcommand*{\str}{\mathrm{str}}
39: \newcommand*{\uth}{^\mathsf{th}}
40: \newcommand*{\ust}{^\mathsf{st}}
41: \newcommand*{\prefr}[2]{(\ref{#1}-\ref{#2})}
42: \newcommand*{\nn}{\nonumber}
43: \newcommand*{\vn}{\vec\nabla}
44: \newcommand*{\tr}{\mathrm{tr}}
45: \newcommand*{\diag}{\mathrm{diag}}
46: \newcommand*{\indexsep}{,}
47: \newcommand*{\tl}{\mathrm{tl}}
48: \newcommand*{\1}{1\!\!\!\bot}
49: \newcommand*{\Tr}{\mathrm{Tr}}
50:
51: \begin{document}
52:
53: \begin{frontmatter}
54:
55: \title{Infrared-suppressed gluon propagator \\
56: in 4d Yang-Mills theory \\ in a Landau-like gauge}
57:
58: \author[a]{Attilio Cucchieri}\ead{attilio@ifsc.usp.br}
59: \author[a,b]{Axel Maas}\ead{axelmaas@web.de}
60: \author[a]{Tereza Mendes}\ead{mendes@ifsc.usp.br}
61:
62: \address[a]{Instituto de F\'\i sica de S\~ao Carlos, Universidade de S\~ao Paulo,
63: Caixa Postal 369, 13560-970 S\~ao Carlos, SP, Brazil}
64: \address[b]{Gesellschaft f\"ur Schwerionenforschung mbH, Planckstra{\ss}e 1,
65: D-64291 Darmstadt, Germany}
66:
67: \date{\today}
68:
69: %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%
70:
71: \begin{abstract}
72: The infrared behavior of the gluon propagator is directly related to confinement in QCD.
73: Indeed, the Gribov-Zwanziger scenario of confinement predicts an infrared vanishing
74: (transverse) gluon propagator in Landau-like gauges, implying violation of
75: reflection positivity and gluon confinement. Finite-volume effects make
76: it very difficult to observe (in the minimal Landau gauge) an infrared suppressed
77: gluon propagator in lattice simulations of the four-dimensional case.
78: Here we report results for the $SU(2)$ gluon propagator in a gauge that interpolates
79: between the minimal Landau gauge (for gauge parameter $\lambda$ equal to 1) and
80: the minimal Coulomb gauge (corresponding to $\lambda = 0$).
81: For small values of $\lambda$ we find that the spatially-transverse
82: gluon propagator $D^\tr(0,|\vec p|)$, considered as a function of the spatial momenta
83: $|\vec p|$, is clearly infrared suppressed. This result is in agreement with the
84: Gribov-Zwanziger scenario and with previous numerical results in the minimal
85: Coulomb gauge. We also discuss the nature of the limit $\lambda \to 0$ (complete
86: Coulomb gauge) and its relation to the standard Coulomb gauge ($\lambda = 0$).
87: Our findings are corroborated by
88: similar results in the three-dimensional case, where the infrared suppression is observed
89: for all considered values of $\lambda$.
90: \end{abstract}
91:
92: \begin{keyword}
93: % keywords here, in the form: keyword \sep keyword
94: Yang-Mills theory \sep
95: Gluon propagator \sep
96: Confinement \sep
97: Interpolating gauge
98: % PACS codes here, in the form: \PACS code \sep code
99: \PACS 11.15.Ha
100: \sep 12.38.Aw
101: \sep 14.70.Dj
102: \end{keyword}
103: %
104: \end{frontmatter}
105:
106: %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%
107:
108: \section{Introduction}
109:
110: The infrared behavior of the gluon propagator is linked to the confinement of
111: gluons.\cite{Alkofer:2000wg} In particular, the confinement scenario of Gribov and
112: Zwanziger\cite{Gribov,gribov1,gribov2,Zwanziger:1993dh,Zwanziger,zwanziger1,Zwanziger:2003cf}
113: predicts a (transverse) gluon propagator vanishing at zero (Euclidean) momentum in Landau
114: gauge and in Landau-like gauges (or $\lambda$-gauges).
115: The latter class refers to gauges interpolating between the
116: Landau and the Coulomb gauge\cite{Baulieu:1998kx}, with a gauge condition (in
117: $d$ dimensions) given by
118: \be
119: \lambda \, \pd_0 A_0^a \, + \,\pd_1 A_1^a \, + \, \ldots \, + \,\pd_{d-1} A_{d-1}^a
120: \,= \, 0 \; ,
121: \label{gcinterpol}
122: \ee
123: where the gauge parameter $\lambda$ is between 1 and 0.
124: Let us recall that an infrared (IR) null gluon propagator has
125: far-reaching consequences. Indeed, such a particle cannot have a positive
126: semi-definite spectral function\cite{Oehme,oehme1,oehme2,oehme3} or, as a consequence, a K\"allen-Lehmann
127: representation. This is regarded as one possible manifestation of confinement,\cite{Alkofer:2000wg,Mandula:1999nj,Alkofer:2003jj} when considering
128: Euclidean correlation functions.\footnote{Thus,
129: it is a sufficient condition for gluon confinement.\cite{Alkofer:2000wg,Alkofer:2003jj}}
130:
131: The question of whether the Landau-gauge gluon propagator is indeed null at zero momentum
132: is a long-standing one. Various continuum methods, based on functional approaches, yield
133: a vanishing gluon propagator.\cite{Alkofer:2000wg,Zwanziger,zwanziger1,Zwanziger:2003cf,vonSmekal,Lerche:2002ep,vs1,vs2,vs3,vs4,vs5,vs6,vs7,Fischer:2006vf}
134: This result is rather tightly constrained,\cite{Fischer:2006vf} i.e.\
135: it seems to be the only possible solution satisfying both Dyson-Schwinger equations
136: and functional renormalization-group equations. At the same time, lattice calculations
137: in four dimensions have obtained an IR-suppressed Landau-gauge gluon propagator $D(p)$ only
138: when using strongly-asymmetric lattices\cite{Silva:2005hb} or a coupling constant in the
139: strong-coupling regime.\cite{Cucchieri:1997fy} For lattice couplings in the scaling region
140: and using symmetric lattices, one finds for the Landau-gauge gluon propagator an
141: increase slower than $1/p^2$ as one approaches the IR region\cite{irgluon,ir1,ir2,ir3},
142: with a finite value for
143: $p = 0$.\cite{large,large1,large2,Cucchieri:2006xi} The fact that a propagator decreasing at small momenta
144: is not observed in the 4d case, even for volumes of almost (10 fm)$^4$,\cite{Cucchieri:2006xi}
145: is probably due to very strong finite-size effects.\cite{large,large1,large2,Cucchieri:2006xi,sternbeck,sternbeck1,fv,fv1}
146: This assumption is supported by numerical results in the 3d case, where much larger lattice
147: sides are accessible. In this case, there is substantial evidence for an IR-suppressed
148: gluon propagator in Landau gauge,\cite{Cucchieri:1999sz,Cucchieri:2001tw,Cucchieri:2003di}
149: in agreement with continuum calculations.\cite{Zwanziger,Maas:2004se} However, also in
150: this case, a reliable extrapolation of $D(0)$ to the infinite-volume limit is still
151: lacking.\cite{Cucchieri:2003di} Finally, let us recall that lattice Landau calculations\cite{Langfeld,langfeld1,sternbeck,sternbeck1} have also obtained
152: direct evidence for the non-positivity of the gluon spectral function, both in the three- and
153: in the four-dimensional cases.
154:
155: The Gribov-Zwanziger confinement scenario applies also to Coulomb gauge.\cite{Gribov,gribov1,gribov2,DanCoulomb,dc1,dc2,reviews,reviews1}
156: In this case it is important to observe that the standard
157: Coulomb-gauge-fixing condition $\, \pd_1 A_1^a \, + \, \ldots \, + \,\pd_{d-1} A_{d-1}^a
158: \,= \, 0 \, $
159: is not a complete one, due to the residual gauge degrees of freedom $g(t)$. On the
160: other hand, a possible complete Coulomb gauge condition\cite{Baulieu:1998kx} can be obtained
161: using the class of gauges defined in \pref{gcinterpol}. Indeed, the parameter $\lambda$
162: interpolates between the Landau ($\lambda = 1$) and a complete Coulomb gauge, corresponding
163: to the limit\footnote{Clearly, since the gauge fixing \pref{gcinterpol} is complete for any
164: $\lambda \neq 0$, it is also a complete one when considering the limit $\lambda \to 0$.\cite{Baulieu:1998kx}}
165: $\lambda \to 0$. Therefore, the complete
166: Coulomb gauge condition is, by definition, a smooth limiting case of the interpolating gauge
167: \pref{gcinterpol} while, of course, this is not the case for the standard Coulomb condition
168: ($\lambda = 0$). Let us recall that the gauge condition \pref{gcinterpol} above can be
169: obtained by minimizing the (lattice) functional\footnote{A similar functional can be defined
170: in the continuum.}
171: \be
172: {\mathcal E}[g] \,=\, - \,\Tr \sum_{x} \; \left[ \, \lambda \, U_0(x) \,+ \,
173: \sum_{i=1}^{d-1} \, U_i(x) \, \right] \; ,
174: \label{eq:defElambda}
175: \ee
176: where $U_\mu(x)$ indicates a lattice link variable in the $\mu$ direction. Then, the
177: limiting case $\lambda \to 0$ corresponds to minimizing the following two
178: functionals\cite{Cucchieri:2000gu}
179: \bea
180: {\mathcal E}_{\mbox{hor}}[g(\vec x)] &=& - \,\Tr \sum_{x} \; \sum_{i=1}^{d-1} \, U_i(x)
181: \label{ECoulomb} \\
182: {\mathcal E}_{\mbox{ver}}[g(t)] &=& - \,\Tr \sum_{x} \; U_0(x) \; . \label{Eresidual}
183: \eea
184: The minimization of the first functional is equivalent to a Landau gauge condition fixed on
185: each time slice, using $g(\vec x)$ gauge transformations, i.e.\ it corresponds to the
186: standard (incomplete) Coulomb gauge. The minimization of the second functional,
187: considering only $g(t)$ gauge transformations, provides additional constraints, necessary
188: to eliminate the residual gauge degrees of freedom. Note that we can also write
189: $ \,{\mathcal E}_{\mbox{ver}}[g(t)] = - \,\Tr \sum_{t} \; Q_0(t) \,$,
190: with $\, Q_0(t) = \sum_{\vec x} \; U_0(t,\vec x) \,$.
191: Then, the minimization of ${\mathcal E}_{\mbox{ver}}[g(t)]$ is like a one-dimensional
192: Landau gauge fixing.
193: Of course, quantities defined in terms of spatial link variables $U_i(x)$
194: are not affected by the residual gauge condition obtained by minimizing the functional
195: ${\mathcal E}_{\mbox{ver}}[g(t)]$.
196:
197: Numerical studies in minimal Coulomb gauge have shown [for the $SU(2)$ case in 4d] that the
198: instantaneous transverse gluon propagator $D^{tr}(\vec p)$ is indeed suppressed in the IR
199: limit.\cite{Cucchieri:2000gu,Cucchieri,cucchieri1,otherCoulomb,oc1} Also, in the infinite-volume
200: limit, it has been found\cite{Cucchieri:2000gu,Cucchieri,cucchieri1} that $D^{tr}(\vec p)$ is well
201: described by a Gribov-like propagator with a pair of purely imaginary poles
202: $m^2 = \pm i y$. These results are in agreement with the Gribov-Zwanziger confinement
203: scenario.\cite{Gribov,gribov1,gribov2,DanCoulomb,dc1,dc2} The fact that, for a given lattice size $L$
204: (in fm), one sees an IR-suppressed transverse gluon propagator
205: in 4d-Coulomb gauge and in 3d-Landau gauge
206: but not in 4d-Landau gauge may be related to a quantitatively different IR suppression
207: in the two cases.
208: Indeed, functional methods\cite{Zwanziger,Maas:2004se,Coulomb,coulomb1,coulomb2,coulomb3} predict a stronger suppression
209: in 4d-Coulomb gauge and in 3d-Landau gauge than in 4d-Landau gauge, i.e.\ the so-called IR
210: gluon exponent $\alpha_D$ should be larger for the 4d-Coulomb and the 3d-Landau cases.
211:
212: One should note that, for any non-zero value of $\lambda$, the gauge condition
213: \pref{gcinterpol} is essentially a {\em deformed} Landau gauge, i.e.\ the IR
214: exponents of the propagators do not depend on $\lambda$\cite{Fischer:2005qe}.
215: In particular, calculations using Dyson-Schwinger equations suggest\cite{Fischer:2005qe}
216: that, at momenta sufficiently small compared to a separation momenta $p_s$,
217: the transverse gluon propagator behaves as in Landau gauge, i.e.\ all
218: Lorentz and color components of the gluon propagator vanish at zero four-momentum.
219: However, the limit $\lambda \to 0$ can also be thought of as sending to zero the momentum
220: $p_s$, which separates Coulomb-gauge-like from Landau-gauge-like behavior.
221: Indeed, for any finite value $\lambda \neq 0$ and given the Landau gauge condition
222: $ \pd_{\mu} A_{\mu}^a = 0 $, we can obtain the gauge condition
223: \be
224: \pd_0 A_0^a \, + \lambda^{-1} \left[ \,\pd_1 A_1^a \, + \,
225: \ldots \, + \,\pd_{d-1} A_{d-1}^a \, \right] = \, 0 \;
226: \ee
227: by using the rescaling\footnote{In Ref.~\cite{Fischer:2005qe}, a similar rescaling
228: was used to show that Dyson-Schwinger equations for $\lambda$-gauges are equivalent
229: to the Landau case for all $\lambda\neq 0$ .} $x_i \to x_i / \lambda$ for $i \neq 0$.
230: This implies, in momentum space, the rescaling $p_i \to \lambda \, p_i$. Thus, if we
231: consider only spatial momenta, we find\footnote{Of course, this simple explanation
232: is correct only at tree-level and can be modified by the renormalization of
233: $\lambda$.} that $p_s$ is rescaled to $\lambda \, p_s$ and goes to zero when
234: $\lambda \to 0$. As a consequence, one should expect that, for very small values
235: of $\lambda$, all correlation functions would show a Coulomb-like behavior
236: for momenta $p > p_s$, with $p_s$ very small. In particular, the correlation
237: function that corresponds to the transverse (instantaneous) gluon propagator in
238: Coulomb gauge should become more and more IR suppressed as the parameter
239: $\lambda$ approaches zero. Investigating whether this is the case is the aim of this work.
240:
241: %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%
242:
243: \section{Numerical results}
244:
245: Following Eqs.\ (8) and (9) of Ref.~\cite{Fischer:2005qe}, we can consider on
246: the lattice the three-dimensionally transverse gluonic correlation function
247: \be
248: D^\tr(p_0,|\vec p|) \; = \; \left(\delta_{ij} - \frac{p_i p_j}{{\vec p\,}^2}\right)
249: \frac{ < A_i^a(p) A_j^a(-p) > }{(N_c^2-1) (d-2) V} \label{dtr} \; .
250: \ee
251: At zero four-momentum one has
252: \be
253: D^\tr(0) \; = \; \delta_{ij} \frac{ < A_i^a(0) A_j^a(0) > }{(N_c^2-1) (d-1) V}
254: \label{dtr0} \; .
255: \ee
256: Here, $N_c$ is the number of colors, $V$ is the $d$-dimensional lattice volume,
257: Lorentz indices $i, j$ are summed only over the $d-1$ spatial directions and
258: $A_i^a(p)$ is the $d$-dimensional Fourier transform of the gluon field.
259: Let us recall that, by considering only spatial momenta (i.e.\ $p_0 = 0$), the function
260: $\,D^\tr(0,|\vec p|)\,$ is predicted to be IR suppressed --- and vanishing at zero
261: momentum --- for all non-zero values of $\lambda$ in three and in four dimensions.\cite{Fischer:2005qe}
262: Also, when $\lambda$ is null,
263: the above definition yields the instantaneous part of the three-dimensional transverse
264: gluon propagator\cite{Cucchieri:2000gu}
265: \be
266: D^{\mathrm{inst}}(|\vec p|) \; = \; \sum_t
267: \left(\delta_{ij} - \frac{p_i p_j}{{\vec p\,}^2}\right)
268: \frac{ < A_i^a(t,\vec p) A_j^a(t,-\vec p) > }{(N_c^2-1) (d-2) V} \label{dinst} \; ,
269: \ee
270: where now the Fourier transform of the gluon field is evaluated for each time slice.
271: Indeed, when $\lambda$ is null, the gauge transformations $g(t)$ are independent of
272: the gauge transformation $g(\vec x)$ and the
273: two sets of transformations commute. Then, the terms in Eqs.\ \pref{dtr} that depend
274: explicitly on $g(t)$ are averaged to zero and one is left with the expression above.
275: Note that this explanation is valid whether the residual gauge freedom $g(t)$ is
276: fixed or not.
277:
278: Here we evaluate numerically $D^\tr(0,|\vec p|)$ as a function of $|\vec p|$ for $SU(2)$
279: Yang-Mills theory in three and in four dimensions for several values of the parameter $\lambda$.
280: Details of the simulations can be found in.\cite{Cucchieri:2003di,Cucchieri:2006tf}
281: Let us note that for $\lambda \neq 1$ the numerical gauge fixing is
282: very similar to the usual Landau gauge fixing.\cite{Cucchieri:2001tw} On the
283: other hand, when $\lambda$ goes to zero one sees\cite{Cucchieri:1998ta} that more
284: iterations are needed in order to satisfy a given numerical accuracy for the gauge fixing,
285: in agreement with a recent analytic study.\cite{Cucchieri:2003fb}
286: This problem can be partially reduced by adding some extra gauge fixing
287: sweeps in the $\mu=0$ direction for each iteration of the gauge-fixing algorithm, i.e.\
288: by considering gauge transformations $g(t)$ that depend only on the $\mu=0$ component of $x$.
289: Finally, we did not consider here possible systematic effects related to the breaking
290: of rotational symmetry or to the existence of Gribov copies. The former type of effects
291: can be parameterized by\cite{Ma:1999kn} $a^2 p^{[4]}$, where $a$ is the lattice
292: spacing and $p^{[4]} = \sum_{\mu} p_{\mu}^4$. Therefore, this type of effects are
293: not expected to play a significant role in the IR region, considered here.
294: As for the latter type of effects, in the infinite-volume limit, averages taken over
295: configurations belonging to the so-called Gribov region $\Omega$ should coincide\cite{Zwanziger:2003cf}
296: with averages obtained by restricting the functional integral to the so-called fundamental
297: modular region $\Gamma$, whose interior is free of Gribov copies.
298:
299: \begin{figure}
300: \begin{center}
301: \includegraphics[width=0.7\linewidth]{3d}\\
302: \includegraphics[width=0.7\linewidth]{4d}
303: \end{center}
304: \caption{\label{fig}
305: The gluonic correlation function $D^\tr(0,|\vec p|)$
306: in three (top figure) and four (bottom figure) dimensions.
307: The spatial momenta $|\vec p|$ are chosen along a single axis. Circles indicate data
308: for $\lambda=1$ (Landau gauge), crosses are used for $\lambda=1/2$, squares for
309: $\lambda=1/10$, triangles for $\lambda=1/20$, stars for $\lambda=1/100$ and
310: upside-down triangles represent results at $\lambda=0$ (Coulomb gauge). Data
311: have been obtained at $\beta=4.2$ in three dimensions and at $\beta=2.2$ in four dimensions.
312: The lattice size is $40^3 \approx $ (6.9 fm)$^3$ in three dimensions and $22^4 \approx$
313: (4.6 fm)$^4$ in four dimensions. In addition, in the bottom panel, diamonds correspond
314: to a $40^4 \approx $ (8.4 fm)$^4$ lattice at $\lambda=1/100$.
315: The physical scale has been set using Refs.~\protect\cite{Cucchieri:2003di,Fingberg:1992ju}.
316: Note that our error bars are smaller than the sizes of the symbols.
317: Also, for $\lambda=0$, we consider the standard (incomplete) Coulomb gauge.}
318: \end{figure}
319:
320: \begin{figure}
321: \begin{center}
322: \includegraphics[width=0.7\linewidth]{3d00}\\
323: \includegraphics[width=0.7\linewidth]{4d00}
324: \end{center}
325: \caption{\label{fig0}
326: Same as in Fig.\ \ref{fig}, except that here we show data for the $D_{00}(0,|\vec p|)$
327: tensor component.
328: }
329: \end{figure}
330:
331: Our results\footnote{Preliminary results have been presented in Ref.~\cite{Maas,maas1}.}
332: are reported in Figure \ref{fig}. In three dimensions,
333: a well-defined maximum (and thus an IR suppression) is visible
334: for all values of $\lambda$. This includes also Landau gauge ($\lambda = 1$),
335: confirming earlier results.\cite{Cucchieri:1999sz,Cucchieri:2001tw,Cucchieri:2003di}
336: As can be seen from the plot, the maximum value attained by the propagator seems
337: to move to larger momenta with decreasing $\lambda$, going from about 400 MeV in the
338: Landau case\cite{Cucchieri:2003di} to about 600 MeV for the Coulomb case.
339: At the same time, as $\lambda$ decreases, the maximum becomes more visible.
340: In four dimensions, on the other hand, no discernible
341: peak is visible in Landau gauge when considering the volume $V = 22^4$.
342: Decreasing $\lambda$, however, leads to a suppression
343: of the propagator in the IR region. In particular, at the smallest value of $\lambda$
344: considered, i.e.\ $\lambda=1/100$ and for a lattice volume $V = 40^4$,
345: a maximum is seen also in four dimensions.
346: This maximum is as visible as the one in three dimensions in Landau gauge.
347: Thus for small $\lambda$, just as for Coulomb gauge,\cite{Cucchieri:2000gu}
348: one sees a maximum of the transverse gluon propagator already for relatively small
349: volumes.
350:
351: A similar $\lambda$-dependence is also seen in the tensor component $D_{00}(0,|\vec p|)$. In
352: particular, as $\lambda$ becomes small,
353: this tensor component of the gluon propagator becomes enhanced for small
354: (nonzero) values of $|\vec p|$ (see Fig.\ \ref{fig0}). Let us recall that, in Coulomb gauge,
355: the $D_{00}$ component is IR divergent already at the perturbative level. Moreover,
356: the instantaneous part of $D_{00}$ is related to the color Coulomb potential
357: and should be diverging as $1/|\vec p|^4$ at small momenta.\cite{DanCoulomb,dc1,dc2,Cucchieri:2000gu,Cucchieri,cucchieri1,otherCoulomb,oc1}
358: Thus, from the discussion presented in the Introduction, one
359: could expect to observe a $D_{00}$ component enhanced at intermediate momenta $p > p_s$
360: but still suppressed at small momenta. This is indeed the case and from the plots
361: in Fig.\ \ref{fig0} one clearly sees how this enhancement is developing for $|\vec p| \neq 0$
362: as the value of $\lambda$ decreases. Let us stress that the discontinuity in the behavior
363: of the propagator at $|\vec p| \neq 0$ is observed since we are taking the limit
364: $\lambda \to 0$. A similar discontinuity is also obtained when implementing the complete
365: Coulomb gauge described in the Introduction.\footnote{This is a consequence
366: of the minimization of ${\mathcal E}_{\mbox{ver}}[g(t)]$, defined in Eq.\ \pref{Eresidual}.}
367: On the other hand, for the
368: incomplete Coulomb gauge, $D_{00}$ is clearly a continuous function of $|\vec p|$
369: (see Fig.\ \ref{fig0}).
370:
371: As said in the Introduction, the IR exponent $\alpha_D$ for the transverse
372: correlator is predicted to show a discontinuity in the limit $\lambda\to 0$.
373: This is not seen from our data. However, a reliable check of this prediction
374: can only be obtained if one has control over the infinite-volume and the
375: continuum limits, which we have not yet achieved. On the other hand,
376: taking the limit $\lambda \to 0$ clearly induces a discontinuity in
377: the behavior of the temporal component $D_{00}$.\cite{Fischer:2005qe}
378:
379: %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%
380:
381: \section{Conclusions}
382:
383: We have presented the first direct observation of an IR-suppressed gluonic correlation
384: function on a symmetric 4d lattice in a Landau-like gauge, with gauge parameter
385: $\lambda$ as in Eq.\ \pref{gcinterpol}. (Landau gauge is obtained for $\lambda = 1$,
386: while Coulomb gauge corresponds to $\lambda = 0$.)
387: The suppression is seen for sufficiently small $\lambda$ when
388: considering moderately small lattice volumes.
389: Judging from the results shown for the 3d case, it is conceivable that a similar suppression
390: might be observed for any $\lambda$ if a large enough lattice side is considered.
391: Furthermore, since the limit $\lambda \to 1$ is smooth,\cite{Baulieu:1998kx,Fischer:2005qe}
392: we expect to see an IR suppression for sufficiently large lattices also in Landau gauge.
393: Moreover, we have obtained that the $D_{00}$ component of the gluon propagator gets enhanced
394: in the IR region (for $|\vec p| \neq 0$) at small values of the interpolating parameter
395: $\lambda$. These results clearly demonstrate the transformation of the correlation functions
396: from Landau gauge towards Coulomb gauge when considering the limit $\lambda \to 0$.
397: They also provide additional support to the Gribov-Zwanziger scenario of confinement,
398: establishing an IR suppression of gluonic correlation functions in four dimensions
399: beyond Coulomb gauge. The use of the interpolating gauge thus constitutes a
400: promising alternative to studies in Landau gauge, since finite-size effects
401: are significantly smaller, allowing a more efficient investigation of the gauge
402: dependence of correlation functions of confined objects.
403:
404: %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%
405:
406: \section*{Acknowledgments}
407:
408: A.\ M.\ was supported in part by the DFG under grant number MA 3935/1-1.
409: A.\ C.\ and T.\ M.\ were supported by FAPESP (under grants \# 00/05047-5 and 05/59919-7)
410: and by CNPq. The ROOT framework\cite{Brun:1997pa} has been used in this project.
411: Part of our simulations has been done on the IBM supercomputer at S\~ao Paulo
412: University (FAPESP grant \# 04/08928-3).
413:
414: %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%
415:
416: \begin{thebibliography}{0}
417:
418: \bibitem{Alkofer:2000wg}
419: R.\ Alkofer and L.\ von Smekal,
420: %``The infrared behavior of QCD Green's functions: Confinement, dynamical
421: %symmetry breaking, and hadrons as relativistic bound states,''
422: Phys.\ Rept.\ {\bf 353} (2001) 281 [arXiv:hep-ph/0007355].
423:
424: \bibitem{Gribov}
425: %\bibitem{Gribov:1977wm}
426: V.\ N.\ Gribov,
427: %``Quantization of non-Abelian gauge theories,''
428: Nucl.\ Phys.\ B {\bf 139} (1978) 1.
429: %\bibitem{Zwanziger:1990by}
430:
431: \bibitem{gribov1}
432: D.\ Zwanziger,
433: %``Vanishing color magnetization in lattice Landau and Coulomb gauges,''
434: Phys.\ Lett.\ B {\bf 257} (1991) 168.
435:
436: \bibitem{gribov2}
437: D.\ Zwanziger,
438: %``Vanishing of zero momentum lattice gluon propagator and color
439: %confinement,''
440: Nucl.\ Phys.\ B {\bf 364} (1991) 127.
441:
442: \bibitem{Zwanziger:1993dh}
443: D.\ Zwanziger,
444: %``Fundamental modular region, Boltzmann factor and area law in lattice gauge
445: %theory,''
446: Nucl.\ Phys.\ B {\bf 412} (1994) 657.
447:
448: \bibitem{Zwanziger}
449: D. Zwanziger,
450: %``Non-perturbative Landau gauge and infrared critical exponents in QCD,''
451: Phys.\ Rev.\ D {\bf 65} (2002) 094039 [arXiv: hep-th/0109224].
452:
453: \bibitem{zwanziger1}
454: D. Zwanziger,
455: %``Time-independent stochastic quantization, DS equations, and infrared
456: %critical exponents in QCD,''
457: Phys.\ Rev.\ D {\bf 67} (2003) 105001 [arXiv: hep-th/0206053].
458:
459: \bibitem{Zwanziger:2003cf}
460: D.\ Zwanziger,
461: %``Non-perturbative Faddeev-Popov formula and infrared limit of QCD,''
462: Phys.\ Rev.\ D {\bf 69} (2004) 016002 [arXiv: hep-ph/0303028].
463:
464: \bibitem{Baulieu:1998kx}
465: L.\ Baulieu and D.\ Zwanziger,
466: %``Renormalizable non-covariant gauges and Coulomb gauge limit,''
467: Nucl.\ Phys.\ B {\bf 548} (1999) 527 [arXiv:hep-th/9807024].
468:
469: \bibitem{Oehme}
470: R.\ Oehme and W.\ Zimmermann,
471: %``Quark And Gluon Propagators In Quantum Chromodynamics,''
472: Phys.\ Rev.\ D {\bf 21} (1980) 471.
473:
474: \bibitem{oehme1}
475: R.\ Oehme and W.\ Zimmermann,
476: %``Gauge Field Propagator And The Number Of Fermion Fields,''
477: Phys.\ Rev.\ D {\bf 21} (1980) 1661.
478:
479: \bibitem{oehme2}
480: K.\ Nishijima,
481: %``Confinement of quarks and gluons,''
482: Int.\ J.\ Mod.\ Phys.\ A {\bf 9} (1994) 3799.
483:
484: \bibitem{oehme3}
485: K.\ Nishijima,
486: %``Confinement of quarks and gluons. 2,''
487: Int.\ J.\ Mod.\ Phys.\ A {\bf 10} (1995) 3155.
488:
489: \bibitem{Mandula:1999nj}
490: J.\ E.\ Mandula,
491: %``The gluon propagator,''
492: Phys.\ Rept.\ {\bf 315} (1999) 273 [arXiv:hep-lat/9907020].
493:
494: \bibitem{Alkofer:2003jj}
495: R.\ Alkofer, W.\ Detmold, C.\ S.\ Fischer and P.\ Maris,
496: %``Analytic properties of the Landau gauge gluon and quark propagators,''
497: Phys.\ Rev.\ D {\bf 70} (2004) 014014 [arXiv:hep-ph/0309077].
498:
499: \bibitem{vonSmekal}
500: L.\ von Smekal, A.\ Hauck and R.\ Alkofer,
501: %``The infrared behavior of gluon and ghost propagators in Landau gauge QCD,''
502: Phys.\ Rev.\ Lett.\ {\bf 79} (1997) 3591 [arXiv:hep-ph/9705242].
503:
504: \bibitem{Lerche:2002ep}
505: C.~Lerche and L.~von Smekal,
506: %``On the infrared exponent for gluon and ghost propagation in Landau gauge
507: %QCD,''
508: Phys.\ Rev.\ D {\bf 65}, 125006 (2002)
509: [arXiv:hep-ph/0202194].
510: %%CITATION = PHRVA,D65,125006;%%
511:
512: \bibitem{vs1}
513: L.\ von Smekal, A.\ Hauck and R.\ Alkofer,
514: %``A solution to coupled Dyson-Schwinger equations for gluons and ghosts in
515: %Landau gauge,''
516: Annals Phys.\ {\bf 267} (1998) 1 [Erratum-ibid.\ {\bf 269} (1998) 182]
517: [arXiv:hep-ph/9707327].
518:
519: \bibitem{vs2}
520: C.\ S.\ Fischer and R.\ Alkofer,
521: %``Infrared exponents and running coupling of SU(N) Yang-Mills theories,''
522: Phys.\ Lett.\ B {\bf 536} (2002) 177 [arXiv:hep-ph/0202202].
523:
524: \bibitem{vs3}
525: C.\ S.\ Fischer, R.\ Alkofer and H.\ Reinhardt,
526: %The Elusiveness of Infrared Critical Exponents in Landau Gauge Yang-Mills Theories,
527: Phys.\ Rev.\ D {\bf 65} (2002) 094008 [arXiv:hep-ph/0202195].
528:
529: \bibitem{vs4}
530: H.\ Gies,
531: %``Running coupling in Yang-Mills theory: A flow equation study,''
532: Phys.\ Rev.\ D {\bf 66} (2002) 025006 [arXiv:hep-th/0202207].
533:
534: \bibitem{vs5}
535: C.\ S.\ Fischer and H.\ Gies,
536: %``Renormalization flow of Yang-Mills propagators,''
537: JHEP {\bf 0410} (2004) 048 [arXiv:hep-ph/0408089].
538:
539: \bibitem{vs6}
540: J.\ M.\ Pawlowski, D.\ F.\ Litim, S.\ Nedelko and L.\ von Smekal,
541: %``Infrared behaviour and fixed points in Landau gauge QCD,''
542: Phys.\ Rev.\ Lett.\ {\bf 93} (2004) 152002 [arXiv:hep-th/0312324].
543:
544: \bibitem{vs7}
545: R.\ Alkofer, C.\ S.\ Fischer and F.\ J.\ Llanes-Estrada,
546: %``Vertex functions and infrared fixed point in Landau gauge SU(N) Yang-Mills
547: %theory,''
548: Phys.\ Lett.\ B {\bf 611} (2005) 279 [arXiv:hep-th/0412330].
549:
550: \bibitem{Fischer:2006vf}
551: C.\ S.\ Fischer and J.\ M.\ Pawlowski,
552: %``Uniqueness of infrared asymptotics in Landau gauge Yang-Mills theory,''
553: Phys.\ Rev.\ D {\bf 75} (2007) 025012 [arXiv:hep-th/0609009].
554: %%CITATION = PHRVA,D75,025012;%%
555:
556: \bibitem{Silva:2005hb}
557: P.\ J.\ Silva and O.\ Oliveira,
558: %``Infrared Gluon Propagator from lattice QCD: results from large asymmetric
559: %lattices,''
560: Phys.\ Rev.\ D {\bf 74} (2006) 034513 [arXiv:hep-lat/0511043].
561:
562: \bibitem{Cucchieri:1997fy}
563: A.\ Cucchieri,
564: %``Infrared behavior of the gluon propagator in lattice Landau gauge,''
565: Phys.\ Lett.\ B {\bf 422} (1998) 233 [arXiv:hep-lat/9709015].
566:
567: \bibitem{irgluon}
568: F.\ Gutbrod,
569: %``A study of the gluon propagator in SU(2) lattice gauge theory,''
570: DESY-96-252; % [http://www-library.desy.de/ cgi-bin/showprep.pl?desy96-252]
571:
572: \bibitem{ir1}
573: A.\ Cucchieri,
574: %``Gribov copies in the minimal Landau gauge: The influence on gluon and
575: %ghost propagators,''
576: Nucl.\ Phys.\ B {\bf 508} (1997) 353 [arXiv:hep-lat/9705005].
577:
578: \bibitem{ir2}
579: D.\ B.\ Leinweber, J.\ I.\ Skullerud, A.\ G.\ Williams and C.\ Parrinello,
580: % [UKQCD collaboration],
581: %``Gluon propagator in the infrared region,''
582: Phys.\ Rev.\ D {\bf 58} (1998) 031501(R) [arXiv:hep-lat/9803015].
583:
584: \bibitem{ir3}
585: S.\ Furui and H.\ Nakajima,
586: %``Infrared features of the Landau gauge QCD,''
587: Phys.\ Rev.\ D {\bf 69} (2004) 074505 [arXiv:hep-lat/0305010].
588:
589: \bibitem{large}
590: J.\ C.\ R.\ Bloch, A.\ Cucchieri, K.\ Langfeld and T.\ Mendes,
591: %``Propagators and running coupling from SU(2) lattice gauge theory,''
592: Nucl.\ Phys.\ B {\bf 687} (2004) 76 [arXiv:hep-lat/0312036].
593:
594: \bibitem{large1}
595: A.\ Sternbeck, E.\ M.\ Ilgenfritz, M.\ M\"uller-Preussker and A.\ Schiller,
596: %``Going infrared in SU(3) Landau gauge gluodynamics,''
597: Phys.\ Rev.\ D {\bf 72} (2005) 014507 [arXiv:hep-lat/0506007].
598:
599: \bibitem{large2}
600: P.\ Boucaud {\it et al.},
601: %``Short comment about the lattice gluon propagator at vanishing momentum,''
602: arXiv:hep-lat/0602006.
603:
604: \bibitem{Cucchieri:2006xi}
605: A.\ Cucchieri and T.\ Mendes,
606: %``Propagators, running coupling and condensates in lattice QCD,''
607: arXiv:hep-ph/0605224.
608:
609: \bibitem{sternbeck}
610: A.\ Sternbeck,
611: %``The infrared behavior of lattice QCD Green's functions,''
612: arXiv:hep-lat/0609016, Ph.\ D.\ Thesis (Humboldt Universit\"at, Berlin).
613:
614: \bibitem{sternbeck1}
615: A.\ Sternbeck, E.\ M.\ Ilgenfritz, M.\ Muller-Preussker, A.\ Schiller
616: and I.\ L.\ Bogolubsky,
617: %``Lattice study of the infrared behavior of QCD Green's functions in Landau
618: %gauge,''
619: PoS {\bf LAT2006} (2006) 076 [arXiv:hep-lat/0610053].
620:
621: \bibitem{fv}
622: %\bibitem{Fischer:2007pf}
623: C.\ S.\ Fischer, A.\ Maas, J.\ M.\ Pawlowski and L.\ von Smekal,
624: %``Large volume behaviour of Yang-Mills propagators,''
625: arXiv:hep-ph/0701050.
626:
627: \bibitem{fv1}
628: A.~Cucchieri, A.~Maas and T.~Mendes,
629: %``Infrared properties of propagators in Landau-gauge pure Yang-Mills theory
630: %at finite temperature,''
631: Phys.\ Rev.\ D {\bf 75}, 076003 (2007)
632: [arXiv:hep-lat/0702022].
633: %%CITATION = PHRVA,D75,076003;%%
634:
635: \bibitem{Cucchieri:1999sz}
636: A.\ Cucchieri,
637: %``Infrared behavior of the gluon propagator in lattice Landau gauge: The
638: %three-dimensional case,''
639: Phys.\ Rev.\ D {\bf 60} (1998) 034508 [arXiv:hep-lat/9902023].
640:
641: \bibitem{Cucchieri:2001tw}
642: A.\ Cucchieri, F.\ Karsch and P.\ Petreczky,
643: %``Propagators and dimensional reduction of hot SU(2) gauge theory,''
644: Phys.\ Rev.\ D {\bf 64} (2001) 036001 [arXiv:hep-lat/0103009].
645:
646: \bibitem{Cucchieri:2003di}
647: A.\ Cucchieri, T.\ Mendes and A.\ R.\ Taurines,
648: %``SU(2) Landau gluon propagator on a 140**3 lattice,''
649: Phys.\ Rev.\ D {\bf 67} (2003) 091502(R) [arXiv:hep-lat/0302022].
650:
651: \bibitem{Maas:2004se}
652: A.\ Maas, J.\ Wambach, B.\ Gr\"uter and R.\ Alkofer,
653: %``High-Temperature Limit of Landau-Gauge Yang-Mills Theory,''
654: Eur.\ Phys.\ J.\ C {\bf 37}, No.3 (2004) 335 [arXiv:hep-ph/0408074].
655:
656: \bibitem{Langfeld}
657: K.\ Langfeld, H.\ Reinhardt and J.\ Gattnar,
658: %``Gluon propagators and quark confinement,''
659: Nucl.\ Phys.\ B {\bf 621} (2002) 131 [arXiv:hep-ph/0107141].
660:
661: \bibitem{langfeld1}
662: A.\ Cucchieri, T.\ Mendes and A.\ R.\ Taurines,
663: %``Positivity violation for the lattice Landau gluon propagator,''
664: Phys.\ Rev.\ D {\bf 71} (2005) 051902(R) [arXiv:hep-lat/0406020].
665:
666: \bibitem{DanCoulomb}
667: %\bibitem{Zwanziger:1998ez}
668: D.\ Zwanziger,
669: % ``Renormalization in the Coulomb gauge and order parameter for confinement
670: %in QCD,''
671: Nucl.\ Phys.\ B {\bf 518} (1998) 237.
672:
673: \bibitem{dc1}
674: A.\ Cucchieri and D.\ Zwanziger,
675: %``Renormalization group calculation of color Coulomb potential,''
676: Phys.\ Rev.\ D {\bf 65} (2002) 014002.
677:
678: \bibitem{dc2}
679: %\bibitem{Zwanziger:2002sh}
680: D.\ Zwanziger,
681: %``No confinement without Coulomb confinement,''
682: Phys.\ Rev.\ Lett.\ {\bf 90} (2003) 102001.
683:
684: \bibitem{reviews}
685: %\bibitem{Dokshitzer:2004ie}
686: Y.\ L.\ Dokshitzer and D.\ E.\ Kharzeev,
687: %``The Gribov conception of quantum chromodynamics,''
688: Ann.\ Rev.\ Nucl.\ Part.\ Sci.\ {\bf 54} (2004) 487.
689:
690: \bibitem{reviews1}
691: %\bibitem{Cucchieri:2006hi}
692: A.\ Cucchieri,
693: %``Lattice results in Coulomb gauge,''
694: AIP Conf.\ Proc.\ {\bf 892} (2007) 22
695: [arXiv:hep-lat/0612004].
696: %%CITATION = APCPC,892,22;%%
697:
698: \bibitem{Cucchieri:2000gu}
699: A.\ Cucchieri and D.\ Zwanziger,
700: % ``Numerical study of gluon propagator and confinement scenario in minimal
701: %Coulomb gauge,''
702: Phys.\ Rev.\ D {\bf 65} (2002) 014001.
703:
704: \bibitem{Cucchieri}
705: % \bibitem{Cucchieri:2000kw}
706: A.\ Cucchieri and D.\ Zwanziger,
707: %``Fit to gluon propagator and Gribov formula,''
708: Phys.\ Lett.\ B {\bf 524} (2002) 123.
709:
710: \bibitem{cucchieri1}
711: %\bibitem{Cucchieri:2001za}
712: A.\ Cucchieri, T.\ Mendes and D.\ Zwanziger,
713: % ``SU(2) running coupling constant and confinement in minimal Coulomb and
714: %Landau gauges,''
715: Nucl.\ Phys.\ Proc.\ Suppl.\ {\bf 106} (2002) 697.
716:
717: \bibitem{otherCoulomb}
718: %\bibitem{Cucchieri:2002su}
719: A.\ Cucchieri and D.\ Zwanziger,
720: %``Gluon propagator and confinement scenario in Coulomb gauge,''
721: Nucl.\ Phys.\ Proc.\ Suppl.\ {\bf 119} (2003) 727.
722:
723: \bibitem{oc1}
724: %\bibitem{Langfeld:2004qs}
725: K.\ Langfeld and L.\ Moyaerts,
726: %``Propagators in Coulomb gauge from SU(2) lattice gauge theory,''
727: Phys.\ Rev.\ D {\bf 70} (2004) 074507.
728:
729: \bibitem{Coulomb}
730: D.\ Zwanziger,
731: %``Analytic calculation of color-Coulomb potential and color confinement,''
732: Phys.\ Rev.\ D {\bf 70} (2004) 094034 [arXiv: hep-ph/0312254].
733:
734: \bibitem{coulomb1}
735: C.\ Feuchter and H.\ Reinhardt,
736: %``Variational solution of the Yang-Mills Schroedinger equation in Coulomb
737: %gauge,''
738: Phys.\ Rev.\ D {\bf 70} (2004) 105021 [arXiv:hep-th/0408236].
739:
740: \bibitem{coulomb2}
741: H.\ Reinhardt and C.\ Feuchter,
742: %``On the Yang-Mills wave functional in Coulomb gauge,''
743: Phys.\ Rev.\ D {\bf 71} (2005) 105002 [arXiv:hep-th/0408237].
744:
745: \bibitem{coulomb3}
746: W.\ Schleifenbaum, M.\ Leder and H.\ Reinhardt,
747: %``Infrared analysis of propagators and vertices of Yang-Mills theory in
748: %Landau and Coulomb gauge,''
749: Phys.\ Rev.\ D {\bf 73} (2006) 125019 [arXiv:hep-th/0605115].
750:
751: \bibitem{Fischer:2005qe}
752: C.\ S.\ Fischer and D.\ Zwanziger,
753: %``Infrared behaviour and running couplings in interpolating gauges in QCD,''
754: Phys.\ Rev.\ D {\bf 72} (2005) 054005 [arXiv:hep-ph/0504244].
755:
756: \bibitem{Cucchieri:2006tf}
757: A.\ Cucchieri, A.\ Maas and T.\ Mendes,
758: %``Exploratory study of three-point Green's functions in Landau-gauge
759: %Yang-Mills theory,''
760: Phys.\ Rev.\ D {\bf 74} (2006) 014503 [arXiv:hep-lat/0605011].
761:
762: \bibitem{Cucchieri:1998ta}
763: A.\ Cucchieri and T.\ Mendes,
764: %``Gauge fixing and gluon propagator in lambda-gauges,''
765: arXiv:hep-lat/9902024.
766:
767: \bibitem{Cucchieri:2003fb}
768: A.\ Cucchieri and T.\ Mendes,
769: %``Critical slowing-down in SU(2) Landau-gauge-fixing algorithms at beta =
770: %infinity,''
771: Comput.\ Phys.\ Commun.\ {\bf 154} (2003) 1 [arXiv:hep-lat/0301019].
772:
773: \bibitem{Ma:1999kn}
774: J.\ P.\ Ma,
775: %``A study of gluon propagator on coarse lattice,''
776: Mod.\ Phys.\ Lett.\ A {\bf 15} (2000) 229
777: [arXiv:hep-lat/9903009].
778: %%CITATION = MPLAE,A15,229;%%
779:
780: \bibitem{Maas}
781: A.\ Maas, A.\ Cucchieri and T.\ Mendes,
782: %``Propagators in Yang-Mills theory for different gauges,''
783: arXiv:hep-lat/ 0610123.
784:
785: \bibitem{maas1}
786: % A.\ Maas, A.\ Cucchieri and T.\ Mendes,
787: %``On the infrared behavior of Green's functions in Yang-Mills theory,''
788: Braz.\ J.\ Phys.\ {\bf 37N1B} (2007) 219 [arXiv:hep-lat/0610006].
789: %%CITATION = BJPHE,37N1B,219;%%
790:
791: \bibitem{Fingberg:1992ju}
792: J.\ Fingberg, U.\ M.\ Heller and F.\ Karsch,
793: %``Scaling and asymptotic scaling in the SU(2) gauge theory,''
794: Nucl.\ Phys.\ B {\bf 392} (1993) 493 [arXiv:hep-lat/9208012].
795:
796: \bibitem{Brun:1997pa}
797: R.\ Brun and F.\ Rademakers,
798: %``ROOT: An object oriented data analysis framework,''
799: Nucl.\ Instrum.\ Meth.\ A {\bf 389} (1997) 81.
800:
801: \end{thebibliography}
802:
803: \end{document}
804:
805: %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%
806: