1: \documentstyle[preprint,aps,epsfig]{revtex}
2:
3: \newcommand{\be}{\begin{equation}}
4: \newcommand{\ee}{\end{equation}}
5: \newcommand{\bea}{\begin{eqnarray}}
6: \newcommand{\eea}{\end{eqnarray}}
7:
8: \newcommand{\alp}{{\alpha}_+ }
9: \newcommand{\alm}{{\alpha}_- }
10: \newcommand{\eett}{e^- e^+ \to t \bar{t} }
11:
12:
13: %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%
14: %% BEGINNING OF TEXT %%
15: %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%
16:
17:
18: \begin{document}
19:
20: \draft
21:
22: \preprint{
23: \begin{tabular}{l}
24: \hbox to\hsize{November, 2000\hfill KIAS-P00071}\\[-2mm]
25: \hbox to\hsize{ \hfill SNUTP 00-031}\\[-2mm]
26: \hbox to\hsize{ \hfill hep-ph/0011173}\\[-3mm]
27: \end{tabular}
28: }
29:
30:
31:
32: \title{
33: Probing $Z^\prime$ gauge boson with
34: the spin configuration of top quark pair production
35: at future $e^- e^+$ linear colliders
36: }
37:
38: \author{
39: Kang Young Lee$^1$,
40: Seong Chan Park$^2$,
41: H. S. Song$^2$,
42: and Chaehyun Yu$^2$
43: }
44:
45: \address{
46: $^{1}$ School of Physics, Korea Institute for Advanced Study,
47: Seoul 130-012, Korea\\
48: $^{2}$ Department of Physics,
49: Seoul National University, Seoul 151-742, Korea \\
50: }
51:
52: \date{\today}
53: \maketitle
54:
55: \begin{abstract}
56:
57: We explore the effects of extra neutral gauge boson
58: involved in the supersymmetric $E_6$ model
59: on the spin configuration of the top quark pair produced
60: at the polarized $e^- e^+$ collider.
61: Generic mixing terms are considered
62: including kinetic mixing terms as well as mass mixing.
63: In the off-diagonal spin basis of the standard model,
64: we show that the cross sections for the suppressed
65: spin configurations can be enhanced
66: with the effects of the $Z'$ boson
67: through the modification of
68: the spin configuration of produced top quark pair
69: enough to be measured in the Linear Colliders,
70: which provides the way to observe the effects
71: of $Z'$ boson and discriminate the pattern of
72: gauge group decomposition.
73: It is pointed out that the kinetic mixing
74: may dilute the effects of mass mixing terms,
75: and we have to perform the combined analysis.
76:
77: \end{abstract}
78:
79: \pacs{PACS number(s): 13.88.+e,12.60.Cn}
80:
81: %\begin{multicols}{2}
82: \narrowtext
83:
84: %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%
85: \section{Introduction}
86: %\label{sec:introduction}
87: %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%
88:
89: The existence of extra U(1) gauge group is inevitable
90: in many extended models derived by
91: grand unified theories (GUTs) of higher ranked gauge group
92: and superstring/M theories inspired models \cite{extraz}.
93: Moreover, the symmetry breaking scale for extra U(1) might be
94: as low as ${\cal O}(1)$ TeV in the context of supersymmetry
95: to provide the solution of the $\mu$ problem \cite{muproblem},
96: leading to the possibility to observe the effects of
97: the extra heavy neutral gauge boson, $Z'$ boson
98: at the future collider experiments.
99: The latest bound of the $Z'$ boson mass comes from
100: a direct search at the $p \bar{p}$ collider via Drell--Yan production
101: and subsequent decay to charged leptons \cite{CDF}.
102: Indirect constraints for the $Z'$ boson mass and
103: the $Z-Z'$ mixing angles are obtained from
104: high precision LEP data at the $Z$ peak energy and
105: from various low energy neutral current experiment data
106: \cite{erler,chay,langacker,indirectz}.
107: Very recently it is indicated that
108: a missing invisible width in $Z$ decays at LEP 1 and
109: a significantly negative $S$ parameter observed
110: in atomic parity violation of Cs atom can be explained properly
111: if the presence of an $Z^\prime$ boson is assumed \cite{apv}.
112: Thus it is timely and interesting to search for
113: an effective way to probe the
114: effects of $Z'$ boson at future colliders.
115:
116: As a larger class of $Z'$ models are considered
117: from the string perspective, meanwhile,
118: it is natural to introduce kinetic mixing term.
119: The kinetic mixing is a threshold effects of string models
120: at the string scale and can be generated
121: by the renormalization group (RG) evolution
122: from the high energy scale to the scale that we study.
123: Furthermore it may yield significant effects
124: on the phenomenologies of the $Z'$ couplings to the SM sector
125: \cite{babu}.
126:
127: In this paper, we study the effects of $Z'$ boson
128: involved in the supersymmetric E$_6$ model
129: in $\eett$ process at linear colliders (LC)
130: including the kinetic mixing term.
131: Charges of the standard model (SM) fermions for $Z'$ boson
132: are determined by the gauge group decompositions,
133: along with which the $\psi$-, $\chi$-, and $\eta$-models
134: are defined at low energy scale in the SUSY E$_6$ model framework.
135: Here we take the decoupling limit of the exotic fermions.
136: Since the asymmetry of the left- and right-handed couplings to
137: $Z'$ boson characterizes each model,
138: it is possible to distinguish models
139: using the spin informations of top quark pair
140: with the polarized initial $e^- e^+$ beams.
141: We can read out the information of the polarization of top quark
142: through the angular distribution of the decay products
143: \cite{spin-correlation}.
144: The large mass of the top quark prompts itself to decay before
145: hadronization and the information of the top spin
146: is free from the uncertainties of hadronization.
147: The top quark pair is produced in an unique spin configuration
148: at the polarized $e^- e^+$ collision,
149: which reveals remarkable features \cite{parke1,lee}
150: in the off-diagonal basis of spin.
151: Moreover it is interesting to observe the polarization of top quark
152: to probe new physics in this basis,
153: since the off-diagonal basis is model-dependently defined.
154:
155: The LC with $\sqrt{s}=500$ GeV is
156: the best testing ground for studying the $t \bar{t}$ production
157: in the off-diagonal basis.
158: If the CM energy is around at threshold of
159: top pair production, the top spins are determined
160: by the electron and positron momentum directions
161: since top quark pair is almost at rest.
162: Then the off-diagonal basis cannot be defined.
163: At high energy, $\sqrt{s} \gg m_t$,
164: the spin basis is close to the usual helicity basis
165: so that the angle $\xi \sim 0$.
166: Thus it is hard to extract the new physics effects
167: from $\xi$ although they exist.
168:
169: This paper is organized as follows.
170: In section II, the extra neutral gauge bosons
171: in the string inspired supersymmetric E$_6$ are briefly reviewed.
172: In section III, we present the formulae of scattering amplitudes
173: of $\eett$ process with the $Z'$ bosons
174: in a generic spin basis of the top quark pair.
175: The off-diagonal spin basis is defined and
176: discussed is the way how to probe the $Z'$ boson
177: through the spin configuration of $t \bar{t}$ pair.
178: In section IV, the numerical analysis for each models are performed
179: in the SM off-diagonal basis.
180: Section V is devoted to summary of the paper.
181:
182: %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%
183: \section{$Z^\prime$ boson in supersymmetric E$_6$ model}
184: %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%
185:
186: In the supersymmetric E$_6$ model,
187: there are two additional U(1) factors beyond the SM gauge group
188: since the rank of E$_6$ group is 6.
189: The canonical decompositions of $\psi$ and $\chi$ models are as follows:
190: \bea
191: {\rm E}_6 \rightarrow &{\rm SO(10)}&\times {\rm U(1)}_{\psi},
192: \nonumber \\
193: &{\rm SO(10)}& \rightarrow {\rm SU(5)} \times {\rm U(1)}_{\chi}.
194: \nonumber
195: \eea
196: After the extra U(1) symmetries are spontaneously broken
197: by the weak iso-singlet Higgs scalar(s),
198: the gauge bosons $Z_{\psi}$ and $Z_{\chi}$ corresponding to
199: the groups U(1)$_{\psi}$ and U(1)$_{\chi}$ respectively
200: become massive but are not mass eigenstates in general.
201: We call it $Z'$ a linear combination of $Z_{\psi}$ and $Z_{\chi}$
202: parametrized by the mixing angle ${\theta}_E$
203: \be
204: Z^\prime ({\theta}_E) \equiv
205: Z_{\chi} \cos {\theta}_E + Z_{\psi} \sin {\theta}_E,
206: \ee
207: which is relatively light enough to mix with the ordinary $Z$ boson
208: and relevant to the low energy phenomenology.
209: The orthogonal mode to $Z'$ boson is assumed to be so massive
210: that its effect is to be decomposed.
211: In the case of ${\theta}_E =0$, the $Z^\prime$ mode is
212: identified to $Z_{\psi}$ boson;
213: if ${\theta}_E =\pi /2$, $Z^\prime$ mode is $Z_{\chi}$ boson.
214: The $\eta$-model and corresponding $Z_{\eta}$ boson
215: is defined by setting ${\theta}_E =\tan^{-1} (-\sqrt{5/3})$.
216: Here we assume that exotic fermions are heavy enough to
217: be decoupled.
218:
219: In the effective rank-5 limit with only one extra neutral gauge boson,
220: the interaction Lagrangian is described by
221: \be
222: -{\cal L}_{\rm int} = \sum_{f} \bar{\Psi}_f {\gamma}^{\mu}
223: \bigg[ g_{3} {\lambda}^{\alpha} G^{\alpha} _\mu
224: + g_{2} {T^a}_f {W^a} _{\mu}
225: + g_{1} Y_f B_{\mu}
226: + g'_{1} {1 \over 2}
227: ({f^f}_{\rm V} -{{f^f}_{\rm A}}{\gamma ^5} ){Z}^{\prime}_{\mu}\bigg]
228: {\Psi}_f,
229: \ee
230: where
231: $\Psi _f$ is the fermion field with flavour $f$;
232: ${\lambda}^{\alpha}$ and $T^a$ are generators
233: of $SU(3)_{C}$ and $SU(2)_{L}$ gauge group respectively.
234: The extra gauge coupling is expressed by
235: $g_1^\prime \equiv {1 \over \sqrt \lambda} g_1$
236: with order 1 parameter $\lambda $.
237: The exact value of $\lambda$ depends upon the pattern of symmetry breaking
238: and we set the value 1 in the numerical analysis.
239: The couplings, ${f^f}_{V}$ and ${f^f}_{A}$ are the vector and
240: axial vector charges of the fermion for U(1)$^\prime$ group.
241: The U(1)$^\prime$ charge assignment is given in the Table 1
242: in terms of the vector and axial vector couplings of $Z'$ to fermions
243:
244: \begin{center}
245: \begin{tabular}{|c|c|c|c|c|c|c|}
246: \hline
247: Models
248: & \multicolumn{2}{c|}{$\psi$}
249: & \multicolumn{2}{c|}{$\chi$}
250: & \multicolumn{2}{c|}{$\eta$} \\ \cline{2-3}\cline{4-5}\cline{6-7}
251: {particles}& $f_{V}/\sqrt{5/72}$ & $f_{A}/\sqrt{5/72}$
252: & $ ~~2 \sqrt{6}f_{V}$~ & ~~$ 2 \sqrt{6}f_{A}$~
253: & $~~~~12 f_{ V}~~~$ & $~~~~ 12 f_{A}~~~$
254: \\ \hline \hline
255: $\nu$&0&1&4&-1&6&-4 \\ \hline
256: $e$ &0&1&2&1&3&-1 \\ \hline
257: $u$ &0&1&2&1&3&-1 \\ \hline
258: $d$ &0&1&-2&1&-3&-1 \\ \hline
259: \end{tabular}
260: \vskip 0.1cm
261: {\bf Table 1}: U(1)$'$ charge assignment for the standard model fermions
262:
263: \end{center}
264:
265: After the electroweak symmetry breaking,
266: the gauge sector of the Lagrangian with $Z'$ boson is given by
267: \be
268: {\cal L}_{\rm gauge}={\cal L}_{\rm kinetic}
269: +{\cal L}_{\rm mass}+{\cal L}_{\rm mix} ,
270: \ee
271: where the kinetic term and the mass term are written as
272: \bea
273: {\cal L}_{\rm kinetic} &=& - {1 \over 4 }
274: ( \hat{F}^{\mu \nu} \hat{F}_{\mu \nu}
275: + Z^{\mu \nu} Z_{\mu \nu}
276: + {Z^{\prime}}^{\mu \nu} {Z^\prime}_{\mu \nu}), \\
277: {\cal L}_{\rm mass} &=& { 1 \over 2}
278: ({m_Z}^2 Z^{\mu} Z_{\mu}
279: + {m_{Z^\prime}}^2 {Z^\prime}^\mu {Z^\prime}_\mu ) ,
280: \eea
281: where $\hat{F}$, $Z_{\mu \nu}$, and $Z'_{\mu \nu}$
282: are the usual field strength tensor for the fields
283: $\hat{A}_\mu$, $Z_\mu$ and $Z'_\mu$ respectively.
284: The fields $\hat{A}_\mu$ and $Z_\mu$ are defined by
285: \bea
286: Z&=& c_W W_3 - s_W B ,
287: \nonumber \\
288: \hat{A}&=& s_W W_3 + c_W B,
289: \eea
290: where the shortened notation
291: $s_W = \sin \theta_W$ and $c_W = \cos \theta_W$
292: with the weak mixing angle $\theta_W $.
293: We write ${\cal L}_{\rm mix}$ including the gauge invariant
294: kinetic mixing term,
295: \be
296: {\cal L}_{\rm mix}= -{\sin{\chi}\over 2} Z^{\prime}_{\mu \nu} B^{\mu \nu}
297: +{\delta M }^2 Z^{\prime}_{\mu} Z^{\mu},
298: \ee
299: where $B^{\mu \nu} = \partial_{\mu} B_{\nu} - \partial_\nu B_\mu$
300: is the field strength tensor of U(1)$_Y$ gauge boson.
301:
302: The mass eigenstates ($A, Z_1, Z_2$) are obtained
303: by diagonalizing the mass terms and kinetic terms
304: with the transformation
305: \be
306: {\left (\begin{array}{r} A~ \\
307: Z_1 \\
308: Z_2
309: \end{array} \right) }
310: ={\left (\begin{array}{rrr}
311: 1 & 0 & c_W s_{\chi} \\
312: 0 & c_{\zeta} & -c_{\zeta} s_W s_{\chi}+s_{\zeta} c_{\chi} \\
313: 0 & -s_{\zeta} & c_{\zeta}c_{\chi} +s_{\zeta} s_W s_{\chi}
314: \end{array} \right)}
315: {\left (\begin{array}{r} \hat{A} \\
316: Z~ \\
317: Z^{\prime}
318: \end{array} \right) }
319: \ee
320: where
321: \be
322: \tan {2\zeta} \equiv
323: { -2 c_{\chi} (\delta M^2 +m_Z^2 s_W s_{\chi} )
324: \over
325: m_{Z^\prime}^2 - m_Z^2 s_W^2 s_{\chi}^2
326: +2 \delta M^2 s_W s_{\chi} },
327: \ee
328: where $s_{\chi}=\sin \chi$, $c_{\chi}=\cos \chi$,
329: and
330: $s_{\zeta}=\sin \zeta$, $c_{\zeta}=\cos \zeta$.
331: The lighter $Z_1$ boson is identified to the ordinary $Z$ boson.
332: We recast the Lagrangian in terms of the mass eigenstates $Z_1$ and $Z_2$
333: to obtain the interaction terms of $Z_i f \bar f$, $i=1,2$ as
334: \bea
335: -{\cal L}_{Z_i f \bar f }
336: &=& {e \over 2 s_W c_W}
337: \left[ \left(1 + {\alpha T \over 2} \right)
338: \sum_{f} \bar{\Psi}_f \gamma ^\mu
339: [ (g^f_V + \zeta \tilde{f}^f_V )
340: -(g^f_A + \zeta \tilde{f}^f_A )\gamma_5 ]
341: {\Psi}_f {Z_1}_{\mu} \right.
342: \nonumber \\
343: &&~~~~~~~~~~~~ \left. + \sum_{f} \bar{\Psi}_f \gamma^\mu
344: [ (h^f_V - \zeta g^f_V )
345: -(h^f_A - \zeta g^f_A) \gamma_5 ]
346: \Psi_f {Z_2}_{\mu} \right]
347: \nonumber \\
348: &\equiv& \sum_{f} \sum_i {\bar{\Psi}}_f {\gamma ^\mu}
349: [ {V_i}^f -{A_i}^f {\gamma}_5 ]
350: {\Psi}_f {Z_i}_{\mu},
351: \eea
352: where the SM couplings are modified by $Z$-$Z'$ mixing effects
353: \be
354: g^f_A = T^f_3,~~~~ g^f_V =T^f_3 - 2 Q^f s_*^2 ,
355: \ee
356: and the extra U(1) couplings
357: \bea
358: \tilde{f}^f_{V,A} &\equiv& {g^\prime \over g} {f^f_{V,A} \over \cos \chi} ,
359: \nonumber \\
360: {h^f}_V &=& {{\tilde{f}}^f}_V + \tilde{s} ( {T^f}_3 - 2Q^f )\tan\chi,
361: \nonumber \\
362: {h^f}_A &=& {{\tilde{f}}^f}_A + \tilde{s} {T^f}_3 \tan\chi .
363: \eea
364: Effective weak mixing angles are defined by
365: \bea
366: s_{*}^2 &=& s_W^2 + \zeta~ c_W^2 s_W \tan \chi
367: -\zeta^2 { c_W^2 s_W^2 \over c_W^2 - s_W^2 }
368: \left({M_2^2 \over M_1^2} -1 \right),
369: \nonumber \\
370: \tilde{s} &=& s_W
371: + {s_W^3 \over c_W^2-s_W^2 }
372: \left( {\alpha S \over 4 c_W^2 } - {\alpha T \over 2} \right),
373: \eea
374: where the Peskin-Takeuchi variable $S$ and $T$ \cite{peskin}
375: are given by
376: \bea
377: \alpha S &=& 4 \zeta {c_W}^2 s_W \tan\chi ,
378: \nonumber \\
379: \alpha T &=& \zeta^2 \left( {M_2^2 \over M_1^2} -1 \right)
380: +2\zeta s_W \tan\chi,
381: \eea
382: up to the leading order of $\zeta$.
383:
384:
385: %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%
386: \section{Top quark pair production in the off-diagonal basis}
387: %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%
388:
389: For the process
390: \be \label{process}
391: e^- (p_1 , s_1 )~~ e^+ (p_2 , s_2 ) \rightarrow
392: t (k_1 , r_1 )~~ {\bar t}(k_2 , r_2 ),
393: \ee
394: we have s-channel Feynman diagrams mediated by
395: photon, $Z$ and $Z'$ boson exchanges depicted in Fig. 1.
396: In Eq. (\ref{process}), $p_i$ and $k_i$ denote the momenta
397: and $s_i$ and $r_i$ the polarizations
398: of electrons and top quarks respectively.
399: In the center of momentum (CM) frame, we write the momenta as
400: \be
401: p_1 = (E , E \hat{\bf n} ),~~~ p_2 = (E,- E \hat{\bf n}),~~~~
402: %k_1 = (E, 0,0,|\vec{k}| ),~~~ k_2 = (E, 0,0,- |\vec{k} |),
403: k_1 = (E, 0,0,|{\bf k}| ),~~~ k_2 = (E, 0,0,- |{\bf k} |),
404: \ee
405: where the unit vector $\hat{\bf n}=(-\sin \theta , 0 , \cos \theta )$
406: indicates the spatial direction of the electron beam.
407: We assume that the whole process is confined on the $xz$-plane
408: when taking the direction of the produced top quark
409: to be $z$-axis.
410:
411: We study the spin configuration of top quark pair
412: in a generic spin basis suggested in Ref. \cite{parke1}.
413: %The spin four-vectors of the top quark pair are chosen to be
414: %back-to-back in the zero momentum frame.
415: The spin states of the top quark and top anti-quark
416: are defined in their own rest-frame by decomposing their spins
417: along reference axes.
418: The reference axis for top quark is
419: expressed by an angle $\xi$ between the axis and
420: the top anti-quark momentum in the rest frame of the top quark
421: as depicted in Fig. 2.
422: The usual helicity basis is obtained by taking $\xi=\pi$.
423: In this general spin basis,
424: the explicit expression for spin four-vectors of the $t \bar{t}$
425: is given by :
426: \bea
427: r_1 &=& ( -{|{\bf k}| \over m} \cos \xi,\sin \xi,0, -{E \over m} \cos \xi ),
428: \nonumber \\
429: r_2 &=& ( -{|{\bf k}| \over m} \cos \xi,-\sin \xi,0,{E \over m} \cos \xi ),
430: \eea
431: in the CM frame.
432: It is to be notified that the spin vectors of the produced top quark pair
433: lie in the production plane at tree level
434: if the CP-invariance of the scattering amplitude is preserved.
435:
436: We have the scattering amplitudes for each spin configurations
437: of top quark pair produced by the left-handed polarized electron
438: and right-handed polarized positron beams, including $Z^\prime$ effects,
439: \bea \label{LR}
440: {\cal M}(LR,\uparrow \uparrow)&=&
441: - C_1 s (\cos {\theta} \sin{\xi} - 1/\gamma \sin{\theta} \cos{\xi})
442: + C_2 s \beta \sin{\xi}
443: =-{\cal M}(LR,\downarrow \downarrow),
444: \nonumber \\
445: {\cal M}(LR,\downarrow \uparrow)&=&
446: C_1 s (\cos {\theta} \cos{\xi} +1 + 1/\gamma \sin{\theta} \sin{\xi})
447: - C_2 s \beta (\cos{\theta}+\cos{\xi})
448: \nonumber \\
449: {\cal M}(LR,\uparrow \downarrow)&=&
450: C_1 s (\cos {\theta} \cos{\xi} -1 + 1/\gamma \sin{\theta} \sin{\xi})
451: + C_2 s \beta (\cos{\theta}-\cos{\xi}).
452: \eea
453: where $\beta \equiv \sqrt{1-4{m_t}^2 /s}$
454: and $\gamma \equiv 1/\sqrt{1-{\beta}^2}$.
455: The coefficients $C_1$ and $C_2$ are defined
456: by $ C_1 = P_{VV} +P_{VA}$ and $C_2 = P_{AV} +P_{AA}$,
457: and the effective coupling strength of
458: current-current interactions $P_{\alpha \beta}$ are given by
459: \bea
460: P_{VV}/ \sqrt{N_{c}}&\equiv&e^2 Q_t Q_e {D_0}(s) + {V_1}^t {V_1}^e
461: {D_1}(s)+{V_2}^t {V_2}^e {D_2}(s)
462: \nonumber \\
463: P_{VA}/ \sqrt{N_{c}}&\equiv&-{V_1}^t {A_1}^e {D_1}(s)
464: - {V_2}^t {A_2}^e {D_2}(s)
465: \nonumber \\
466: P_{AV}/ \sqrt{N_{c}}&\equiv&-{A_1}^t {V_1}^e {D_1}(s)
467: - {A_2}^t {V_2}^e {D_2}(s)
468: \nonumber \\
469: P_{AA}/ \sqrt{N_{c}}&\equiv&{A_1}^t {A_1}^e {D_1}(s)
470: + {A_2}^t {A_2}^e {D_2}(s),
471: \eea
472: where $N_{c}$ is the number of colors and
473: $Q_{t(e)}$ is the electric charge for the top quark (electron).
474: $D_0$, $D_1$ and $D_2$ are the propagation factors
475: for the photon, $Z_1$ and $Z_2$ bosons respectively;
476: \be
477: D_0 (s) \equiv \frac{1}{s},~~~~
478: D_1 (s) \equiv \frac{1}{s-m_1 ^2},~~~~
479: D_2 (s) \equiv \frac{1}{s-m_2 ^2 },
480: \ee
481: while
482: $V_i ^f $ and $A_i ^f$ are the model-dependent
483: vector and axial vector couplings for fermion $f$
484: and gauge boson $i=$ photon, $Z_1$, $Z_2$,
485: defined in Eq. (10).
486:
487: The scattering amplitudes for right-handed polarized electron
488: and left-handed polarized positron are obtained in the similar manner
489: \bea \label{RL}
490: {\cal M}(RL,\uparrow \uparrow)
491: &=& C_1 s
492: (\cos {\theta} \sin{\xi} - 1/\gamma \sin{\theta} \cos{\xi})
493: + C_2 s \beta \sin{\xi}
494: = -{\cal M}(RL,\downarrow \downarrow),
495: \nonumber \\
496: {\cal M}(RL,\downarrow \uparrow)
497: &=& -C_1 s
498: (\cos {\theta} \cos{\xi} -1 + 1/\gamma \sin{\theta} \sin{\xi})
499: + C_2 s \beta (\cos{\theta}-\cos{\xi}),
500: \nonumber \\
501: {\cal M}(RL,\uparrow \downarrow)
502: &=& -C_1 s (\cos {\theta} \cos{\xi} +1 + 1/\gamma \sin{\theta} \sin{\xi})
503: - C_2 s \beta (\cos{\theta}+\cos{\xi}),
504: \eea
505:
506: There exist the angles $\xi_{L}$ and $\xi_{R}$ such that
507: the scattering amplitudes for the like-spin states of top quark pair,
508: $(\uparrow ,\uparrow)$ and $(\downarrow , \downarrow)$
509: vanish for the left- and right-handed electron beam, respectively.
510: >From the Eq. (\ref{LR}) and (\ref{RL}),
511: we find the angle $\xi_L$ and $\xi_R$
512: \bea
513: {\xi}_L(s,\theta) &\equiv& \arctan \left[ \frac{\tan \theta}
514: {\gamma (1-(C_2/ C_1) \beta \sec \theta)} \right],
515: \nonumber \\
516: {\xi}_R(s,\theta) &\equiv& \arctan \left[ \frac{\tan \theta}
517: {\gamma (1+(C_2/ C_1) \beta \sec \theta)} \right],
518: \eea
519: which is always defined in terms of the scattering angle $\theta$.
520: It is called the {\it off-diagonal basis}
521: since only the scattering amplitudes for off-diagonal spin states
522: are non-zero \cite{parke1}.
523: For given kinematics, the angles ${\xi}_{L,R}$ are determined
524: by the model-dependent ratio $(C_2/C_1)$,
525: so ${\xi}_{L,R}$ depend upon the existence of new physics.
526:
527: One more interesting feature of the off-diagonal basis is that
528: the process into the $(\uparrow \downarrow)$ state
529: for the left-handed electron beam and the
530: $(\downarrow \uparrow)$ state for the right-handed one
531: is dominant.
532: This pure dominance is very stable under the one-loop QCD corrections
533: where the soft gluon emissions dominate
534: so that the QCD corrections are factored out.
535: At high energy, the degree of this dominance is close to
536: 100\%\cite{Why}.
537:
538:
539: %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%
540: \section{Analysis }
541: %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%
542:
543: In the off-diagonal basis,
544: the scattering amplitudes of the like-spin states are
545: identical to zero and so are the corresponding cross sections.
546: Including new physics effects,
547: the basis does not remain as the off-diagonal basis any more
548: and the characteristic features of the off-diagonal basis
549: is modified through the model-dependence of the angle $\xi_{L,R}$.
550: The $Z'$ boson exchange diagrams yield the deviation of
551: the cross sections for like-spin states from zero.
552: Therefore observation of sizable cross sections
553: for like-spin states can be a smoking-gun signals of new physics.
554:
555: In Fig. $3-5$, we plot the differential cross sections
556: for left-handed polarized electron beam
557: with respect to the scattering angle
558: in the $\psi$-, $\chi$- and $\eta$-models respectively.
559: The SM predictions are denoted by solid lines.
560: The dashed lines denote the model predictions with
561: no kinetic mixing terms, the dotted lines
562: the predictions with the kinetic mixing $\tan \chi = 0.2$
563: and the dash-dotted lines with $\tan \chi = -0.2$.
564: For the numerical analysis, we take $m_{Z'}=600$ GeV,
565: the lower bound from the direct search by CDF \cite{CDF},
566: and the mixing angles to be the latest bounds in Ref. \cite{erler}
567: to maximize the new contributions.
568: We have 2 lines for each predictions
569: corresponding to the upper and lower limits
570: of the $Z-Z'$ mixing angle $\zeta$ respectively.
571:
572: It is apparent from the figures that the cross sections
573: $\sigma(\uparrow \uparrow )$ and $ \sigma( \downarrow \downarrow)$
574: are nonzero with $Z'$ boson effects,
575: which can be as large as $10^{-2}$ pb,
576: of order 1\% of the total cross section of $t \bar{t}$ production.
577: With the expected integrated luminosity
578: $\int {\cal L} > 50$ fb$^{-1}$
579: for energy at $\sqrt{s} = 500$ GeV,
580: we will have more than 500 events for like-spin states,
581: which is sufficient to examine the nonzero cross section.
582: We also find that the pure dominance of $(\uparrow \downarrow)$ state
583: is contaminated with $Z'$ boson effects from the figures.
584: Cross sections for states other than $(\uparrow \downarrow)$ state
585: increases with $Z'$ boson effects in general.
586: However the pure dominance is essentially affected by
587: the alteration of $\sigma(\uparrow \downarrow)$,
588: since actually the total cross section is still dominated by
589: $(\uparrow \downarrow)$ state.
590: We present the ratios of $\sigma(\uparrow \downarrow)/\sigma_{total}$
591: for each model in Table 2.
592:
593: Since the asymmetry of vector and axial vector charges to
594: $Z'$ boson features the models, the forward-backward
595: asymmetry of $t \bar{t}$ production can be
596: an useful observable to discriminate models.
597: The forward-backward asymmetry $A_{FB}$ defined by
598: \be
599: A_{FB} = \frac{\sigma_F - \sigma_B}
600: {\sigma_F + \sigma_B}
601: \ee
602: increases with $Z'$ boson effects in the $\psi$-model
603: while it decreases in the $\chi$- and $\eta$-model
604: from the figures.
605: The $\eta$-model is a mixture of $\psi$- and $\chi$-models
606: and behaves about halfway.
607: The smallness of $A_{FB}$ is a characteristic feature of $\chi$-model.
608: The asymmetry $A_{FB}$ for each model is listed in Table 2.
609:
610: We find that the kinetic mixing derives much shift on the observables.
611: Here the kinetic mixing is taken to be $\tan \chi = \pm0.2$,
612: which is the bound obtained in Ref. \cite{rizzo}.
613: It is to be notified that the effects of kinetic mixing term
614: act on the effects of $Z'$ boson
615: both constructively and destructively
616: with respect to the sign of $\tan \chi$.
617: The effects of $Z'$ boson may be diluted and even canceled
618: by the kinetic mixing effects.
619: For instance, the pure dominance of $(\uparrow \downarrow)$
620: final state is almost recovered in the $\psi$-model
621: when $\tan \chi =-0.2$.
622: In this case, the precise measurement of $A_{FB}$
623: can still be an evidence of $Z'$ boson.
624: Hence it is essential to perform the analysis
625: with more than 2 observables
626: to probe the $Z'$ effects and to discriminate the models.
627:
628: \begin{center}
629: \begin{tabular}{cccccccc}
630: \hline \hline
631: & Models & $\tan \chi$ &
632: & $\sigma(e^-_L e^+_R \to t_{\uparrow} \bar{t}_\downarrow)/\sigma_{total}$
633: & & $A_{FB}$ & \\
634: \hline \hline
635: & SM & & & 99.3\% & & 0.4046 & \\
636: \hline
637: & & 0 & & 98.5\% & & 0.5539 & \\
638: & $\psi$ & 0.2 & & 95.6\% & & 0.6796 & \\
639: & & -0.2 & & 99.2\% & & 0.4703 & \\
640: \hline
641: & & 0 & & 94.4\% & & 0.0382 & \\
642: & $\chi$ & 0.2 & & 95.4\% & & 0.0886 & \\
643: & & -0.2 & & 93.6\% & & 0.0056 & \\
644: \hline
645: & & 0 & & 98.2\% & & 0.2556 & \\
646: & $\eta$ & 0.2 & & 97.5\% & & 0.2036 & \\
647: & & -0.2 & & 98.9\% & & 0.3279 & \\
648: \hline
649: \hline
650: \end{tabular}
651: \end{center}
652: \vskip 0.3cm
653: {\bf Table 2}: The ratios of the cross section for
654: $(\uparrow \downarrow)$ spin state of top quark pair
655: to the total cross section of $e^-_L e^+_R \to t \bar{t}$ production
656: in the SM off-diagonal basis
657: and the forward-backward asymmetries are presented
658: for the standard model, $\psi$-, $\chi$-, and $\eta$-models.
659:
660:
661:
662: %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%
663: \section{Summary and conclusions}
664: %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%
665:
666: We have explored the effects of $Z'$ boson arising
667: in the supersymmetric E$_6$ model framework
668: at $e^- e^+ \to t \bar{t}$ process,
669: including the kinetic mixing terms.
670: Considering the spin configuration of produced top quark pair,
671: we propose useful probes not only to search for the $Z'$ boson
672: but also to discriminate the models corresponding to
673: the pattern of gauge group decomposition.
674: Provided that we take the off-diagonal spin basis of the SM,
675: the existence of nonzero cross sections for diagonal spin states,
676: $t_\uparrow \bar{t}_\uparrow$ and $t_\downarrow \bar{t}_\downarrow$
677: can be a direct evidence of new physics.
678: As a matter of fact, only one spin configuration is appreciable
679: for top quark pair in this basis
680: and violation of such a pure dominance of a peculiar spin state
681: is a signature of $Z'$ gauge boson, which is almost
682: free from loop corrections.
683: Alternatively, $A_{FB}$ is an effectual observable
684: to probe $Z'$ boson due to the asymmetry of
685: left- and right-handed couplings of $Z'$ boson to fermions.
686: Meanwhile it is shown that the kinetic mixing effects results in
687: substantial shift on the observables discussed here.
688: Moreover changing the sign of kinetic mixing term, its effects
689: can be additive or subtractive to the mass mixing effects,
690: by which it is possible that the $Z'$ effects is wiped out.
691: As a consequence, we conclude that combined analysis
692: with more than one observable is indispensable
693: to study the structure of $Z'$ gauge boson.
694:
695:
696:
697: \acknowledgments
698:
699: This work is supported in part
700: by the BK21 program of Ministry of Education
701: for Seoul National University
702: and by the Korea Research Foundation (KRF-2000-D00077).
703:
704: \begin{references}
705:
706: \bibitem{extraz} {\it see}
707: J. Hewett and T. Rizzo, Phys. Rep. {\bf 183}, 193 (1989);
708: A. Leike, Phys. Rep. {\bf 317}, 143 (1999) and references therein.
709:
710: \bibitem{muproblem}
711: M. Cvetic and P. Langacker, hep-ph/9707451,
712: in {\it Perspectives in Supersymmetry}, edited by G.L. Kane,
713: (World Scientific, Singapore, 1998) p. 312;
714: P. Langacker, hep-ph/9805486.
715:
716: \bibitem{CDF} F. Abe {\it et al.}, CDF Collaboration, Phys. Rev. Lett.
717: {\bf 79}, 2192 (1997).
718:
719: \bibitem{erler}
720: J. Erler and P. Langacker, Phys. Lett. B {\bf 456}, 68 (1999).
721:
722: \bibitem{chay} J. Chay, K.Y. Lee and S.-h. Nam,
723: Phys. Rev. D {\bf 61}, 035002 (2000).
724:
725: \bibitem{langacker}
726: J. Erler and P. Langacker, Eur. Phys. J. C {\bf 3}, 90 (1998);
727: P. Langacker and M. Luo, Phys. Rev. D {\bf 45}, 278 (1992);
728: P. Langacker, M. Luo and A. Mann, Rev. Mod. Phys., {\bf 64}, 87 (1992).
729:
730: \bibitem{indirectz} G.-C. Cho, K. Hagiwara and Y. Umeda,
731: Nucl. Phys. {\bf B531}, 65 (1998);
732: Y. Umeda, G.-C. Cho and K. Hagiwara, Phys. Rev. D {\bf 58}, 115008 (1998);
733: G. Altarelli, {\it et al.}, Phys. Lett. B {\bf 263}, 459 (1991);
734: Mod. Phys. Lett. A {\bf 5}, 495 (1990).
735:
736: \bibitem{apv} J. Erler and P. Langacker, Phys. Rev. Lett. {\bf 84}, 212 (2000);
737: G.-C. Cho, Mod. Phys. Lett. A {\bf 15}, 311 (2000).
738:
739: \bibitem{babu}
740: K. S. Babu, C. Kolda and J. March-Russell, Phys. Rev.
741: D {\bf 57}, 6788 (1998);
742: {\it ibid} D {\bf 54}, 4635 (1996).
743:
744: \bibitem{spin-correlation}
745: G. Mahlon and S. Parke, Phys. Rev. D {\bf 53 }, 4886 (1996);
746: T. Arens and L.M. Sehgal, Phys. Rev. D {\bf 50 }, 4372 (1994);
747: Nucl. Phys. {\bf B393}, 46 (1993).
748:
749: \bibitem{parke1} S. Parke and Y. Shadmi, Phys. Lett. B {\bf 387}, 199 (1996).
750:
751: \bibitem{lee} K.Y. Lee, S.C. Park, H.S. Song, J. Song, C. Yu,
752: Phys. Rev. D {\bf 61}, 074005 (2000);
753: K.Y. Lee, H.S. Song, J. Song, C. Yu,
754: Phys. Rev. D {\bf 60}, 093002 (1999).
755:
756: \bibitem{peskin} M.E. Peskin and T. Takeuchi,
757: Phys. Rev. Lett. {\bf 65}, 964 (1990).
758:
759: \bibitem{rizzo} T.G. Rizzo,
760: Phys. Rev. D {\bf 59}, 015020 (1999).
761:
762: \bibitem{Why} S. Parke, hep-ph/9807573.
763:
764: %\bibitem{yuan} G.L. Kane, G.A. Ladinsky, and C.-P. Yuan,
765: % Phys. Rev. D {\bf 45}, 124 (1992).
766:
767:
768: \end{references}
769: %
770:
771: %\end{multicols}
772:
773: \newpage
774: {\Large \bf Figure Captions}
775: \vskip 2cm
776:
777: \begin{description}
778:
779: \item
780: Fig. 1 :
781: Feynman diagrams for the $e^- e^+ \to t \bar{t}$ process
782: (a) in the standard model, (b) with the $Z'$ boson.
783:
784: \item
785: Fig. 2 :
786: Definition of generic top spin basis
787: (a) in the top quark rest frame,
788: (b) in the anti-top quark rest frame.
789:
790: \item
791: Fig. 3 :
792: The differential cross sections in the $\psi$-model
793: for the spin configuration of the top quark pair,
794: drawn with respect to the scattering angle of the top quark
795: at $\sqrt{s} = 500$ GeV with the left-handed electron beam.
796: The solid line denotes the SM prediction; the dashed line includes
797: the $Z'$ boson effects with the kinetic mixing $\tan \chi = 0$,
798: the dotted line with $\tan \chi = 0.2$,
799: the dash-dotted line with $\tan \chi = -0.2$.
800:
801: \item
802: Fig. 4 :
803: The differential cross sections in the $\chi$-model
804: for the spin configuration of the top quark pair,
805: drawn with respect to the scattering angle of the top quark
806: at $\sqrt{s} = 500$ GeV with the left-handed electron beam.
807: The solid line denotes the SM prediction; the dashed line includes
808: the $Z'$ boson effects with the kinetic mixing $\tan \chi = 0$,
809: the dotted line with $\tan \chi = 0.2$,
810: the dash-dotted line with $\tan \chi = -0.2$.
811:
812: \item
813: Fig. 5 :
814: The differential cross sections in the $\eta$-model
815: for the spin configuration of the top quark pair,
816: drawn with respect to the scattering angle of the top quark
817: at $\sqrt{s} = 500$ GeV with the left-handed electron beam.
818: The solid line denotes the SM prediction; the dashed line includes
819: the $Z'$ boson effects with the kinetic mixing $\tan \chi = 0$,
820: the dotted line with $\tan \chi = 0.2$,
821: the dash-dotted line with $\tan \chi = -0.2$.
822:
823: \end{description}
824:
825: \begin{center}
826: \begin{figure}[htb]
827: \hbox to\textwidth{\hss\epsfig{file=fig1.eps,width=15cm}\hss}
828: \vspace{1cm}
829: \caption{\it
830: }
831: \end{figure}
832: \end{center}
833:
834: \newpage
835: \begin{center}
836: \begin{figure}[htb]
837: \hbox to\textwidth{\hss\epsfig{file=fig2.eps,width=15cm}\hss}
838: \vspace{1cm}
839: \caption{\it
840: }
841: \end{figure}
842: \end{center}
843:
844: \newpage
845: \begin{center}
846: \begin{figure}[htb]
847: \hbox to\textwidth{\hss\epsfig{file=fig3.eps,height=15cm}\hss}
848: \vspace{1cm}
849: \caption{\it
850: }
851: \end{figure}
852: \end{center}
853:
854: \newpage
855: \begin{center}
856: \begin{figure}[htb]
857: \hbox to\textwidth{\hss\epsfig{file=fig4.eps,height=15cm}\hss}
858: \vspace{1cm}
859: \caption{\it
860: }
861: \end{figure}
862: \end{center}
863:
864: \newpage
865: \begin{center}
866: \begin{figure}[htb]
867: \hbox to\textwidth{\hss\epsfig{file=fig5.eps,height=15cm}\hss}
868: \vspace{1cm}
869: \caption{\it
870: }
871: \end{figure}
872: \end{center}
873:
874:
875: \end{document}
876:
877:
878:
879: