1: \chapter{Conclusion}
2: In this dissertation we have analyzed the nonequilibrium formation of topological defects during a
3: second-order phase transition of both a quantum field in the early universe and a classical field appropriate
4: for the description of a condensed matter system. We also discussed the existence and
5: dynamics of a black hole phase transition in semiclassical gravity.
6:
7: We first studied the symmetry-breaking phase transition of a quantum scalar field
8: in the early universe. Using equations of motion derived from the two-loop 2PI-CTP effective
9: action we identified domains in the infrared portion of the
10: momentum-space power spectrum. We found that the domain size scales as a power-law with the
11: expansion rate of the universe. The observed power-law scaling, for both overdamped and underdamped evolution,
12: is in good agreement with the predictions of the Kibble-Zurek mechanism.
13:
14: We then studied the formation and interaction of topological textures in a nonequilibrium phase transition
15: of a classical O(3) scalar field theory in $2+1$ dimensions.
16: We presented two models of the nonequilibrium phase transition, a dissipative quench and an external quench.
17: In the external quench and at early times, we observed power-law scaling of the length scales of the texture distribution
18: in good agreement with the Kibble-Zurek mechanism. However, by the end
19: of the transition the length scales of the texture distribution result from a competition between the
20: length scale determined at freeze-out and the ordering dynamics of a textured system. Therefore a quantitative understanding
21: of the defect network at the end of the phase transition generally requires an understanding of both critical
22: dynamics {\it and} the interactions among topological defects.
23:
24: Finally, we studied a black hole phase transition in semiclassical gravity. We reviewed the thermodynamics
25: of the black hole phase transition, focusing on the calculation of the semiclassical free energy of a black hole
26: in thermal equilibrium. We determined that the black hole phase transition is entropically driven.
27: We applied a quantum atomic model to the black hole equilibrium system and showed that the phase transition
28: occurs as the excitation of a high energy state. We discussed the nonequilibrium dynamics of the
29: black hole phase transition and explored similar examples from the Kosterlitz-Thouless transition in
30: condensed matter to the Hagedorn transition in string theory.
31:
32: The power-law scaling of the defect density, observed here in both quantum and classical
33: nonequilibrium phase transitions, demonstrates, at least at early times, the viability of the
34: Kibble-Zurek mechanism of topological defect formation. However, as mentioned in Chapters 3 and 4, the power-law
35: scaling of the defect density is only an indirect and partial verification of the ideas presented in
36: the freeze-out scenario. In fact, the exact details of the dynamical
37: process through which the {\it field} correlation length controls the {\it defect}
38: separation remain somewhat obscure. Partly this is due to the complicated relationship between the field and
39: defect degrees of freedom. To remedy this, one possibility is to seek a dual topological
40: defect description of the entire nonequilibrium phase transition.
41: At least for certain systems we may be able to phrase the freeze-out
42: scenario solely in terms of equilibrium defect distributions and equilibrium relaxation times
43: for these defect distributions. Indeed, some tentative steps have already been made in this direction
44: \cite{williams:1999}.
45:
46: In the context of nonequilibrium phase transitions in quantum field theory, an important issue is the
47: development of techniques that would allow for an analysis of the entire phase
48: transition. As discussed in Chapter 3, although the two-loop approximation of the 2PI-CTP effective action
49: is adequate at early times in the phase transition, when long wavelength modes are sampling the spinodal instability,
50: the approximation is too simplistic to connect to late-time oscillations around the true vacua and the formation
51: and evolution of topological defects. To analyze the entirety of the phase transition in nonequilibrium quantum
52: field theory we propose a two-stage model of the phase transition.
53: In the first stage quantum field fluctuations can be evolved at early times using the known techniques
54: of nonequilibrium quantum field theory. In the second stage, when standard techniques fail,
55: we can attempt to match the field fluctuations to an {\it effective} (stochastic) classical Landau-Ginzburg equation.
56: The late-time evolution of the Landau-Ginzburg equation allows the field to
57: settle to the true vacuum. A similar program was initiated in Ref.~\cite{calzetta:1989} but with neither the focus on
58: topological defects nor an explicit solution of the late-time dynamics. The advantage of this
59: approach is a picture of the transition that extends from the phase dominated by quantum fluctuations to the phase dominated
60: by topological defects. In quantum field theory, such a complete picture has never been given.
61: Along these lines we continue our research.
62:
63:
64: