1: %%%%%%%%%%%%%% THE SKELETON FILE FOR JHEP PROCEEDINGS %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%
2: %%%%%%%%%%%%%%% Look at the documentation for syntax %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%
3: %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%% http://jhep/JOURNAL/tex.html %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%
4:
5: \documentclass[proceedings]{JHEP3}
6:
7: \PrHEP{PrHEP hep2001}
8: \conference{International Europhysics Conference on HEP}
9:
10: \usepackage{epsfig}
11:
12: %physical particles
13: \def\mathswitchr#1{\relax\ifmmode{\mathrm{#1}}\else$\mathrm{#1}$\fi}
14: \newcommand{\Pf}{\mathswitchr f}
15: \newcommand{\PV}{\mathswitchr V}
16: \newcommand{\PW}{\mathswitchr W}
17: \newcommand{\PZ}{\mathswitchr Z}
18: \newcommand{\Pe}{\mathswitchr e}
19: \newcommand{\Pdbar}{\bar{\mathswitchr d}}
20: \newcommand{\Pu}{\mathswitchr u}
21: \newcommand{\TeV}{\unskip\,\mathrm{TeV}}
22: \newcommand{\GeV}{\unskip\,\mathrm{GeV}}
23: \newcommand{\MeV}{\unskip\,\mathrm{MeV}}
24: \newcommand{\ri}{{\mathrm{i}}}
25: \newcommand{\gV}{g^\PV}
26: \newcommand{\laV}{\lambda^\PV}
27: \newcommand{\kaV}{\kappa^\PV}
28: \newcommand{\gVWW}{g_{VWW}}
29: \newcommand{\gZWW}{g_{ZWW}}
30: \newcommand{\gAWW}{g_{AWW}}
31:
32: \newcommand{\U}{\mathrm{U}}
33: \newcommand{\SU}{\mathrm{SU}}
34:
35: \renewcommand{\O}{\cal O}
36: \newcommand{\Gmu}{\mathswitch {G_\mu}}
37:
38: % particle masses
39: \def\mathswitch#1{\relax\ifmmode#1\else$#1$\fi}
40: \newcommand{\MW}{\mathswitch {M_\PW}}
41: \newcommand{\MZ}{\mathswitch {M_\PZ}}
42:
43: % shorthands for SM parameters
44: \newcommand{\rw}{\mathswitchr w}
45: \newcommand{\sw}{\mathswitch {s_\rw}}
46: \newcommand{\cw}{\mathswitch {c_\rw}}
47:
48: \newcommand{\RacoonWW}{{\sc RacoonWW}}
49: \newcommand{\YFSWW}{{\sc YFSWW3}}
50:
51: \title{Precise predictions for \boldmath{$\Pe^+\Pe^- \to 4 f (+\gamma)$}
52: %with RacoonWW%
53: with anomalous couplings%
54: \footnote{{\RacoonWW} can be downloaded from
55: {\tt http://ltpth.web.psi.ch/racoonww/racoonww.html}.}}
56:
57: \author{Ansgar Denner\thanks{This work was supported in part by the
58: Swiss Bundesamt f\"ur Bildung und Wissenschaft and by the European
59: Union under contract HPRN-CT-2000-00149.}
60: \\
61: Paul Scherrer Institut,
62: CH-5232 Villigen PSI, Switzerland\\
63: E-mail: \email{Ansgar.Denner@psi.ch}}
64:
65: \author{Stefan Dittmaier%
66: \footnote{Heisenberg Fellow of the
67: Deutsche Forschungsgemeinschaft DFG}\\
68: Deutsches Elektronen-Synchrotron DESY,
69: D-22603 Hamburg, Germany \\
70: E-mail: \email{Stefan.Dittmaier@desy.de}}
71:
72: \author{\speaker{Markus Roth}\\
73: Institut f\"ur Theoretische Physik,
74: Universit\"at Karlsruhe,
75: D-76128 Karlsruhe, Germany\\
76: E-mail: \email{roth@particle.uni-karlsruhe.de}}
77:
78: \author{Doreen Wackeroth\\
79: Department of Physics and Astronomy,
80: University of Rochester, Rochester,
81: NY~14627-0171, USA \\
82: E-mail: \email{dow@pas.rochester.edu}}
83:
84: \abstract{The relevance of radiative corrections to $4f$
85: production at LEP2 and future $\Pe^+ \Pe^-$ colliders is emphasized,
86: and their treatment in the event generator \RacoonWW\ is
87: briefly discussed.
88: In particular, the non-universal corrections are compared
89: with the signature of anomalous triple gauge-boson couplings.
90: For $4f+\gamma$ production the influence of anomalous
91: quartic gauge-boson couplings on photon-energy distributions is
92: illustrated.}
93:
94: \begin{document}
95:
96: \section{Relevance of radiative corrections}
97:
98: From 1996 to 2000, LEP2 has operated very successfully above the
99: $\PW$-pair threshold allowing for a thorough investigation of
100: $\PW$-pair production (see e.g.\ Ref.~\cite{lep2} and references
101: therein). The results of the four LEP experiments provide accurate
102: tests of the non-Abelian structure of the Electroweak Standard Model
103: (SM) and a precise measurement of the $\PW$-boson mass. While the
104: precision of the $\PW$-pair production cross section at LEP2 has
105: reached the per-cent level, the final LEP2 precision for the
106: $\PW$-boson mass will be 30--$35\MeV$. At a future $\Pe^+ \Pe^-$
107: linear collider, the accuracy of the cross-section measurement will be
108: at the per-mille level, and the precision of $\PW$-mass determination
109: is expected to be $15 \MeV$ by reconstructing the $\PW$ bosons from
110: their decay products \cite{MWreconstruct} and about $6 \MeV$ from a
111: threshold scan \cite{MWthreshold} of the total W-pair cross section.
112:
113: In order to account for the experimental precision at LEP2,
114: %\looseness -1
115: considerable theoretical effort was undertaken in the past years, as
116: it is reviewed in Refs.~\cite{Beenakker:1996kt,Grunewald:2000ju}. In
117: the present calculations, the $\PW$ bosons are treated as resonances
118: in the full 4-fermion processes, $\Pe^+ \Pe^- \to 4 \Pf\,
119: (+\,\gamma)$, and radiative corrections are taken into account in a
120: proper way. These can be split into universal and non-universal
121: corrections. The former comprise leading-logarithmic corrections (LL)
122: from initial-state radiation (ISR), higher-order corrections included
123: upon a proper choice of the input-parameter scheme (running or
124: effective couplings), and the Coulomb singularity. The remaining
125: corrections are called non-universal since they depend on the process
126: under investigation. The full $\O(\alpha)$ corrections to the $4f$
127: processes are not necessary to match the accuracy of LEP2, and it is
128: sufficient to take only those corrections into account that are
129: enhanced by two resonant $\PW$~bosons. The leading term of an
130: expansion about the two $\PW$ poles provides the so-called {\it
131: double-pole approximation} (DPA) \cite{DPA}. In this approximation,
132: there are {\it factorizable corrections}, which are the ones to
133: on-shell $\PW$-pair production and on-shell $\PW$ decay, and {\it
134: non-factorizable corrections}, which originate from soft-photon
135: exchange between the production and decay stages. Different versions
136: of such a pole expansion have been used in the literature
137: \cite{DPAversions,Denner:2000bj,Jadach:2000kw}. Although several
138: Monte Carlo programs exist that include universal corrections, only
139: two event generators, \YFSWW\ \cite{Jadach:2000kw,Jadach:1998hi} and
140: \RacoonWW\ \cite{Denner:2000bj,Denner:1999gp}, include non-universal
141: corrections.
142:
143: While the DPA approach is sufficient for the LEP2 accuracy
144: \cite{Grunewald:2000ju,Jadach:2001cz}, the extremely high experimental
145: precision at a future linear collider is a great challenge for future
146: theoretical predictions, in particular since the DPA is not reliable
147: near the $\PW$-pair threshold. The full $\O(\alpha)$ corrections have
148: to be known for all $4f$ final states, and leading effects beyond
149: $\O(\alpha)$ have to be included in the theoretical predictions
150: properly. For instance, leading and sub-leading Sudakov logarithms
151: become important and amount to several per cent in the $\TeV$ range
152: \cite{Denner}.
153:
154: \section{Non-universal corrections vs.\ anomalous
155: triple gauge-boson couplings}
156:
157: \FIGURE{
158: \label{fig:ATGC1}
159: \epsfig{file=wprod.lambdaA.200.eps,height=8.5cm,width=7cm}
160: \epsfig{file=wprod.kappaA.200.eps,height=8.5cm,width=7cm}
161: \caption{Influence of anomalous triple gauge-boson couplings and
162: non-universal corrections in the $\PW^+$-production-angle
163: distribution for the process $\Pe^+ \Pe^- \to \Pu \Pdbar \mu^-
164: \bar\nu_\mu$ at $\sqrt{s}=200 \GeV$ } }%
165: As already mentioned, one of the main goals at LEP2 is the
166: investigation of the non-Abelian structure of the SM. A proper way to
167: study possible deviations from the SM is the measurement of anomalous
168: couplings. Recently, anomalous quartic \cite{Denner:2001vr} and
169: triple gauge-boson couplings have been incorporated in \RacoonWW. A
170: general parametrization of charged anomalous triple gauge-boson
171: couplings has been suggested in Ref.~\cite{Hagiwara:1987vm}. We have
172: implemented these couplings in \RacoonWW\ in the conventions of
173: Ref.~\cite{Gounaris:1996rz}, which differ from the former by a sign in
174: the parity-violating terms. The implementation of neutral triple
175: gauge-boson couplings in \RacoonWW\ follows the general
176: parametrizations of Ref.~\cite{Gounaris:2000kf}.
177:
178: In the numerical discussion, we compare the influence of the anomalous
179: charged gauge-boson couplings with the effect of the non-universal
180: corrections. We adopt the same SM input parameters and the same set of
181: phase-space cuts as in Refs.~\cite{Grunewald:2000ju,Denner:2000bj}.
182: In particular, we use the ``bare'' recombination scheme, where the
183: photon is recombined with a charged fermion if their invariant mass is
184: smaller than $5 \GeV$. Following a convention widely used in the LEP2
185: data analysis, we consider only the P- and C-conserving anomalous
186: coupling operators with the coupling constants $g^Z_1$, $\kappa_Z$,
187: $\kappa_\gamma$, $\lambda_Z$, and $\lambda_\gamma$, which are further
188: constrained by
189: $$
190: \Delta \kappa_Z= \Delta g_1^Z - \Delta \kappa_\gamma \tan^2 \theta_\rw ,
191: \qquad \lambda_Z=\lambda_\gamma,
192: $$
193: where $\theta_\rw$ is the weak mixing angle and $\Delta$ indicates the
194: deviation from the corresponding SM values
195: $g_1^Z=\kappa_Z=\kappa_\gamma=1$ and $\lambda_Z=\lambda_\gamma=0$.
196: Hence, we are left with the three independent parameters $\Delta g^Z_1$,
197: $\Delta\kappa_\gamma$, and $\lambda_\gamma$.
198: \FIGURE[h]{
199: \epsfig{file=wprod.gZ.200.eps,height=8.5cm,width=7cm}
200: \caption{As in Figure \ref{fig:ATGC1}}
201: \label{fig:ATGC2}
202: }%
203:
204:
205: %\begin{sloppypar}
206: In Figures \ref{fig:ATGC1} and \ref{fig:ATGC2} we study the
207: influence of the anomalous couplings on the $\PW^+$-production-angle
208: distribution for the process $\Pe^+ \Pe^- \to \Pu \Pdbar \mu^-
209: \bar\nu_\mu$ at the centre-of-mass energy of $\sqrt{s}=200 \GeV$, as
210: predicted by \RacoonWW. All numbers are normalized to the
211: tree-level cross section including higher-order LL ISR up to order
212: $O(\alpha^3)$ via structure functions. The relative deviations for
213: different values of the anomalous couplings are compared with the
214: corresponding predictions including non-universal $\O(\alpha)$
215: corrections instead of anomalous couplings. The labels indicate the
216: values of the corresponding anomalous coupling constants, which are
217: chosen to be of the order of the actual accuracy achieved by the LEP
218: experiments. The comparison shows clearly that the non-universal
219: corrections are of the same size as the contributions from anomalous
220: couplings and, thus, have to be taken into account in the
221: determination of the anomalous couplings at LEP2.
222: %\end{sloppypar}
223: %\pagebreak[4]
224:
225: \section{Anomalous quartic gauge-boson couplings in
226: \boldmath{$4f+\gamma$} production}
227:
228: Finally, we study the effects of anomalous quartic gauge-boson
229: couplings in $4f+\gamma$ production. Specifically, we consider the
230: P-conserving couplings $a_0$, $a_c$, and $a_n$, which have been
231: investigated in Ref.~\cite{Belanger:1992qh}, and the P-violating
232: couplings $\tilde a_0$ and $\tilde a_c$, which have been recently
233: introduced in Ref.~\cite{Denner:2001vr}. In this analysis we use the
234: improved Born approximation mode \cite{Denner:2001vr} of \RacoonWW\
235: for $4f + \gamma$ production which includes corrections from
236: higher-order ISR and from the Coulomb singularity. We adopt the same
237: SM input parameters as in Refs.~\cite{Grunewald:2000ju,Denner:2000bj};
238: in particular, we apply the ADLO/TH cuts.
239:
240: \FIGURE[b]{
241: \label{fig:AQGC}
242: \epsfig{file=Egam.eps,height=8.5cm,width=7cm}
243: \epsfig{file=Egam.rel.eps,height=8.5cm,width=7cm}
244: \caption{Influence of anomalous quartic gauge-boson couplings on the
245: photon-energy distribution for the process $\Pe^+ \Pe^- \to \Pu
246: \Pdbar \mu^- \bar\nu_\mu \gamma$ at $\sqrt{s}=200 \GeV$ }}
247: Figure~\ref{fig:AQGC} shows the photon-energy spectrum (l.h.s.)\ and
248: the corresponding relative deviation from the SM (r.h.s.) for
249: different values of the anomalous couplings. The values of the
250: anomalous couplings are of the order of the present experimental
251: accuracy. Only one curve for the coupling $a_0$ and the corresponding
252: P-violating coupling $\tilde a_0$ (also for $a_n$ and $\tilde a_n$) is
253: plotted since the respective results are indistinguishable. Within
254: the statistical error, the contributions from $a_0$, $a_n$, $\tilde
255: a_0$, and $\tilde a_n$ are symmetric under a change in sign,
256: signalling that the quadratic anomalous terms are dominating the
257: squared amplitude. However, an effect from changing the sign is
258: visible for $a_c$, where the interference of anomalous and SM
259: contributions becomes visible.
260: %The deviations from the SM are large for hard photons and vanish for
261: Since the deviations from the SM are largest for hard photons, effects
262: from anomalous quartic gauge-boson couplings can be observed best near
263: the kinematical threshold for \PW-pair production in the $E_\gamma$
264: distribution.
265:
266:
267:
268: \begin{thebibliography}{99}
269:
270: \newcommand{\vj}[4]{{\sl #1 }{\bf #2 }\ifnum#3<100 (19#3) \else (#3) \fi #4}
271:
272: \bibitem{lep2}
273: D. Charleton, these proceedings;\\
274: %\cite{:2001xv}
275: %\bibitem{:2001xv}
276: The LEP Collaborations ALEPH, DELPHI, L3, OPAL, the LEP Electroweak
277: Working Group, and the SLD Heavy Flavor and Electroweak Groups,
278: CERN-EP-2001-021,
279: %``A combination of preliminary electroweak measurements and constraints on the standard model,''
280: hep-ex/0103048.
281: %%CITATION = HEP-EX 0103048;%%
282:
283: \bibitem{MWreconstruct}
284: %\cite{Accomando:1998wt}
285: %\bibitem{Accomando:1998wt}
286: E.~Accomando {\it et al.} [ECFA/DESY LC Physics Working Group
287: Collaboration],
288: %``Physics with e+ e- linear colliders,''
289: Phys.\ Rept.\ {\bf 299} (1998) 1
290: [hep-ph/9705442].
291: %%CITATION = HEP-PH 9705442;%%
292:
293: \bibitem{MWthreshold}
294: %\cite{Wilson:2001aw}
295: %\bibitem{Wilson:2001aw}
296: G.~Wilson,
297: %``Precision measurement of the W mass with a polarised threshold scan at a linear collider,''
298: LC-PHSM-2001-009, in
299: {\it 2nd ECFA/DESY Study 1998-2001}, p.~1498;\\
300: %\cite{Aguilar-Saavedra:2001rg}
301: %\bibitem{Aguilar-Saavedra:2001rg}
302: J.~A.~Aguilar-Saavedra {\it et al.} [ECFA/DESY LC Physics Working Group
303: Collaboration],
304: TESLA Technical Design Report Part III,
305: %: Physics at an e+e- Linear Collider,
306: hep-ph/0106315;\\
307: %%CITATION = HEP-PH 0106315;%%
308: %\cite{Abe:2001nq}
309: %\bibitem{Abe:2001nq}
310: T.~Abe {\it et al.} [American Linear Collider Working Group Collaboration],
311: Linear collider physics resource book for Snowmass 2001,
312: %. 3: Studies of exotic and standard model physics,''
313: hep-ex/0106057.
314: %%CITATION = HEP-EX 0106057;%%
315:
316: %\cite{Beenakker:1996kt}
317: \bibitem{Beenakker:1996kt}
318: W.~Beenakker {\it et al.},
319: %``WW Cross-sections and Distributions,''
320: in {\sl Physics at LEP2}, eds.\ G.~Altarelli, T.~Sj\"o\-strand and
321: F.~Zwirner (CERN 96-01, Geneva, 1996), Vol.~1, p.~79
322: [hep-ph/9602351].
323: %%CITATION = HEP-PH 9602351;%%
324:
325: %\cite{Grunewald:2000ju}
326: \bibitem{Grunewald:2000ju}
327: M.~W.~Gr\"unewald {\it et al.},
328: in {\it Reports of the Working Groups on Precision Calculations
329: for LEP2 Physics}, eds.\ S.~Jadach, G.~Passarino and R.~Pittau
330: (CERN 2000-009, Geneva, 2000), p.~1
331: [hep-ph/0005309].
332: %%CITATION = HEP-PH 0005309;%%
333:
334: \bibitem{DPA}
335: %{\bf reference for the DPA concept (Stuart, Oldenborgh et al, more?)}
336: %\cite{Aeppli:1994rs}
337: %\bibitem{Aeppli:1994rs}
338: A.~Aeppli, G.~J.~van Oldenborgh and D.~Wyler,
339: %``Unstable particles in one loop calculations,''
340: Nucl.\ Phys.\ B {\bf 428} (1994) 126
341: [hep-ph/9312212];\\
342: %%CITATION = HEP-PH 9312212;%%
343: %\cite{Denner:1998ia}
344: %\bibitem{Denner:1998ia}
345: A.~Denner, S.~Dittmaier and M.~Roth,
346: %``Non-factorizable photonic corrections to e+ e- --> W W --> 4fermions,''
347: Nucl.\ Phys.\ B {\bf 519} (1998) 39
348: [hep-ph/9710521].
349: %%CITATION = HEP-PH 9710521;%%
350:
351: \bibitem{DPAversions}
352: %{\bf reference for the DPA versions used in the literature (BBC, YFSWW,
353: %DDRW, KKS)}
354: %\cite{Beenakker:1999gr}
355: %\bibitem{Beenakker:1999gr}
356: W.~Beenakker, F.~A.~Berends and A.~P.~Chapovsky,
357: %``Radiative corrections to pair production of unstable particles: Results for e+ e- $\to$ 4fermions,''
358: Nucl.\ Phys.\ B {\bf 548} (1999) 3
359: [hep-ph/9811481];\\
360: %\cite{Kurihara:2001um}
361: %\bibitem{Kurihara:2001um}
362: Y.~Kurihara, M.~Kuroda and D.~Schildknecht,
363: %``On e+ e- $\to$ W+ W- $\to$ 4f (+ gamma) at LEP2,''
364: Phys.\ Lett.\ B {\bf 509} (2001) 87
365: [hep-ph/0104201].
366: %%CITATION = HEP-PH 0104201;%%
367:
368:
369: %\cite{Denner:2000bj}
370: \bibitem{Denner:2000bj}
371: A.~Denner, S.~Dittmaier, M.~Roth and D.~Wackeroth,
372: %``Electroweak radiative corrections to e+ e- --> W W --> 4fermions in double-pole approximation: The RACOONWW approach,''
373: Nucl.\ Phys.\ B {\bf 587} (2000) 67
374: [hep-ph/0006307];
375: %%CITATION = HEP-PH 0006307;%%
376: %\cite{Denner:2000kn}
377: %\bibitem{Denner:2000kn}
378: %A.~Denner, S.~Dittmaier, M.~Roth and D.~Wackeroth,
379: %``O(alpha) corrections to e+ e- $\to$ W W $\to$ 4fermions(+gamma): First numerical results from RACOONWW,''
380: Phys.\ Lett.\ B {\bf 475} (2000) 127
381: [hep-ph/9912261].
382: %%CITATION = HEP-PH 9912261;%%
383:
384: %%CITATION = HEP-PH 9811481;%%
385: %\cite{Jadach:2000kw}
386: \bibitem{Jadach:2000kw}
387: S.~Jadach, W.~Placzek, M.~Skrzypek, B.~F.~L.~Ward and Z.~Was,
388: %``Precision predictions for (un)stable W+ W- pair production at and beyond LEP2 energies,''
389: hep-ph/0007012.
390: %%CITATION = HEP-PH 0007012;%%
391:
392: %\cite{Jadach:1998hi}
393: \bibitem{Jadach:1998hi}
394: S.~Jadach, W.~Placzek, M.~Skrzypek, B.~F.~L.~Ward and Z.~Was,
395: %``Exact O(alpha) gauge invariant YFS exponentiated Monte Carlo for (un)stable W+ W- production at and beyond LEP2 energies,''
396: Phys.\ Lett.\ B {\bf 417} (1998) 326
397: [hep-ph/9705429];
398: %%CITATION = HEP-PH 9705429;%%
399: %\cite{Jadach:2000tz}
400: %\bibitem{Jadach:2000tz}
401: %S.~Jadach, W.~Placzek, M.~Skrzypek, B.~F.~L.~Ward and Z.~Was,
402: %``Final state radiative effects for the exact O(alpha) YFS exponentiated (un)stable W+ W- production at and beyond LEP2 energies,''
403: Phys.\ Rev.\ D {\bf 61} (2000) 113010
404: [hep-ph/9907436] %;
405: %%CITATION = HEP-PH 9907436;%%
406: %\cite{Jadach:2000kw}
407: %\bibitem{Jadach:2000kw}
408: %S.~Jadach, W.~Placzek, M.~Skrzypek, B.~F.~L.~Ward and Z.~Was,
409: %``Precision predictions for (un)stable W+ W- pair production at and beyond LEP2 energies,''
410: %hep-ph/0007012
411: and
412: %%CITATION = HEP-PH 0007012;%%
413: %\cite{Jadach:2001uu}
414: %\bibitem{Jadach:2001uu}
415: %S.~Jadach, W.~Placzek, M.~Skrzypek, B.~F.~L.~Ward and Z.~Was,
416: %``The Monte Carlo event generator YFSWW3 version 1.16 for W pair production and decay at LEP2/LC energies,''
417: hep-ph/0103163.
418: %%CITATION = HEP-PH 0103163;%%
419:
420: %\cite{Denner:1999gp}
421: \bibitem{Denner:1999gp}
422: A.~Denner, S.~Dittmaier, M.~Roth and D.~Wackeroth,
423: %``Predictions for all processes e+ e- --> 4fermions + gamma,''
424: Nucl.\ Phys.\ B {\bf 560} (1999) 33
425: [hep-ph/9904472].
426: %%CITATION = HEP-PH 9904472;%%
427:
428: %\cite{Jadach:2001cz}
429: \bibitem{Jadach:2001cz}
430: S.~Jadach, W.~Placzek, M.~Skrzypek, B.~F.~L.~Ward and Z.~Was,
431: %``On theoretical uncertainties of the W boson mass measurement at LEP2,''
432: hep-ph/0109072.
433: %%CITATION = HEP-PH 0109072;%%
434:
435: \bibitem{Denner}
436: A. Denner, these proceedings and references therein.
437:
438: %\cite{Denner:2001vr}
439: \bibitem{Denner:2001vr}
440: A.~Denner, S.~Dittmaier, M.~Roth and D.~Wackeroth,
441: %``Probing anomalous quartic gauge-boson couplings via e+ e- $\to$ 4fermions + gamma,''
442: Eur.\ Phys.\ J.\ C {\bf 20} (2001) 201
443: [hep-ph/0104057].
444: %%CITATION = HEP-PH 0104057;%%
445:
446: %\cite{Hagiwara:1987vm}
447: \bibitem{Hagiwara:1987vm}
448: K.~Hagiwara, R.~D.~Peccei, D.~Zeppenfeld and K.~Hikasa,
449: %``Probing The Weak Boson Sector In E+ E- $\to$ W+ W-,''
450: Nucl.\ Phys.\ B {\bf 282} (1987) 253.
451: %%CITATION = NUPHA,B282,253;%%
452:
453: %\cite{Gounaris:1996rz}
454: \bibitem{Gounaris:1996rz}
455: G.~Gounaris {\it et al.},
456: %``Triple Gauge Boson Couplings,''
457: in {\sl Physics at LEP2},
458: eds. G.~Altarelli, T.~Sj\"ostrand and F.~Zwirner,
459: (CERN-96/01, Geneva, 1996) p.~79,
460: hep-ph/9601233.
461: %%CITATION = HEP-PH 9601233;%%
462:
463: %\cite{Gounaris:2000kf}
464: \bibitem{Gounaris:2000kf}
465: G.~J.~Gounaris, J.~Layssac and F.~M.~Renard,
466: %``Signatures of the anomalous Z gamma and Z Z production at the lepton and hadron colliders,''
467: Phys.\ Rev.\ D {\bf 61} (2000) 073013
468: [hep-ph/9910395] and
469: %%CITATION = HEP-PH 9910395;%%
470: %\cite{Gounaris:2000dn}
471: %\bibitem{Gounaris:2000dn}
472: %G.~J.~Gounaris, J.~Layssac and F.~M.~Renard,
473: %``Off-shell structure of the anomalous Z and gamma self-couplings,''
474: Phys.\ Rev.\ D {\bf 62} (2000) 073012
475: [hep-ph/0005269].
476: %%CITATION = HEP-PH 0005269;%%
477:
478: %\cite{Belanger:1992qh}
479: \bibitem{Belanger:1992qh}
480: G.~B\'elanger and F.~Boudjema,
481: %``Probing quartic couplings of weak bosons through three vectors production at a 500-GeV NLC,''
482: Phys.\ Lett.\ B {\bf 288} (1992) 201;\\
483: %%CITATION = PHLTA,B288,201;%%
484: %\cite{Eboli:1994wg}
485: %\bibitem{Eboli:1994wg}
486: O.~J.~Eboli, M.~C.~Gonzalez-Garcia and S.~F.~Novaes,
487: %``Quartic anomalous couplings in e gamma colliders,''
488: Nucl.\ Phys.\ B {\bf 411} (1994) 381
489: [hep-ph/9306306];\\
490: %%CITATION = HEP-PH 9306306;%%
491: %\cite{AbuLeil:1995jg}
492: %\bibitem{AbuLeil:1995jg}
493: G.~Abu Leil and W.~J.~Stirling,
494: %``Anomalous quartic couplings in W+ W- gamma production at e+ e- colliders,''
495: J.\ Phys.\ G{\bf 21} (1995) 517
496: [hep-ph/9406317];\\
497: %%CITATION = HEP-PH 9406317;%%
498: %\cite{Stirling:2000ek}
499: %\bibitem{Stirling:2000ek}
500: W.~J.~Stirling and A.~Werthenbach,
501: %``Anomalous quartic couplings in W+ W- gamma, Z0 Z0 gamma and Z0 gamma gamma production at present and future e+ e- colliders,''
502: Eur.\ Phys.\ J.\ C {\bf 14} (2000) 103
503: [hep-ph/9903315].
504: %%CITATION = HEP-PH 9903315;%%
505:
506:
507:
508: \end{thebibliography}
509:
510:
511:
512: \end{document}
513:
514:
515: