hep-ph0211462/int.tex
1: \section{Introduction}
2: 
3: Compelling evidences in favor of neutrino oscillations,
4: driven by small neutrino masses and neutrino mixing, were obtained
5: in the
6: Super-Kamiokande
7: \cite{Fukuda:1998mi,%
8: Fukuda:1998ah,%
9: Fukuda:2000np,%
10: Fukuda:2001nj,%
11: Fukuda:2002pe},
12: SNO
13: \cite{Ahmad:2001an,%
14: Ahmad:2002jz,%
15: Ahmad:2002ka},
16: KamLAND
17: \cite{hep-ex/0212021}
18: and other
19: atmospheric
20: \cite{Allison:1999ms,%
21: Ambrosio:2000qy},
22: solar
23: \cite{Cleveland:1998nv,%
24: Hampel:1998xg,%
25: Altmann:2000ft,%
26: astro-ph/0204245}
27: and long-baseline
28: \cite{Ahn:2002up}
29: neutrino experiments.
30: These findings have brought
31: \emph{the physics of massive and mixed neutrinos}
32: in the front line of the research in particle physics and astrophysics\footnote{
33: See Ref.~\cite{Neutrino-Unbound-note}
34: for an
35: extensive bibliography on neutrino physics and astrophysics.
36: }.
37: 
38: From all the existing terrestrial and astrophysical data
39: it follows that neutrino masses are smaller
40: than the masses of other fundamental fermions (lepton and quarks)
41: by many orders of magnitude.
42: There is a general consensus that the smallness of neutrino masses is 
43: due to 
44: New Physics beyond the Standard Model. 
45: In the most attractive see-saw mechanism of neutrino mass generation
46: \cite{see-saw},
47: the smallness of neutrino masses is due to
48: the violation of the total lepton number on a scale which is much larger than
49: the electroweak scale.
50: 
51: There are many open problems in the physics of massive and mixed neutrinos:
52: 
53: \begin{itemize}
54: 
55: \item
56: How many light neutrinos with definite mass exist in nature?
57: 
58: The minimal number of massive neutrinos is equal to the number of
59: active (flavor) neutrinos (three).
60: If, however, sterile neutrinos exist, the number of massive neutrinos is larger than three
61: (see Refs.~\cite{BGG-review-98,hep-ph/0202058}). 
62: The data of all the existing neutrino oscillation experiments
63: (solar
64: \cite{Cleveland:1998nv,%
65: Hampel:1998xg,%
66: Altmann:2000ft,%
67: astro-ph/0204245,%
68: Fukuda:2002pe,%
69: Ahmad:2001an,%
70: Ahmad:2002jz,%
71: Ahmad:2002ka},
72: atmospheric
73: \cite{Fukuda:1998mi,%
74: Fukuda:1998ah,%
75: Fukuda:2000np,%
76: Allison:1999ms,%
77: Ambrosio:2000qy}
78: and LSND
79: \cite{LSND})
80: require the existence of (at least) four massive neutrinos.
81: LSND is the single accelerator experiment in which the
82: transition $\bar \nu_{\mu}\to \bar \nu_{e}$ has been observed.
83: The check of the LSND claim is an urgent problem. This will be done
84: by the MiniBooNE experiment
85: \cite{hep-ex/0211039}, which started recently.
86: 
87: \item
88: What is the nature of the neutrinos with definite mass: are they
89: purely neutral Majorana particles, or Dirac particles, possessing a
90: conserved total lepton number?
91: 
92: The answer to this fundamental question can be obtained through
93: the investigation of processes in which the total lepton number is not conserved.
94: The most promising process is neutrinoless double $\beta$-decay
95: of some even-even nuclei.
96: There are many new experiments on the search for 
97: neutrinoless double $\beta$-decay now in preparation
98: (see Ref.~\cite{Cremonesi:2002is}),
99: which will push the experimental sensitivity at a level
100: that is about two orders of magnitude better than today's sensitivity.
101: We will discuss neutrinoless double $\beta$-decay in this review.
102: 
103: \item
104: What are the absolute values of the neutrino masses?
105: 
106: Neutrino oscillations are due to differences of phases which
107: different massive components 
108: of the initial flavor neutrino states pick up during their evolution.
109: As a result,
110: neutrino oscillation experiments allow to obtain information only
111: on neutrino mass-squared differences
112: (see Refs.~\cite{CWKim-book-93,Mohapatra-book-98,BGG-review-98,hep-ph/0202058}).
113: It is very important that neutrino oscillation experiments 
114: are sensitive to tiny neutrino mass-squared differences,
115: because of
116: the possibility to explore very large distances and small energies.
117: The measurement of the absolute values of neutrino masses 
118: at a level of a few eV is a
119: challenging problem. 
120: This review is dedicated to the discussion of this problem
121: (see also Ref.~\cite{Pas:2001nd}).
122: 
123: \end{itemize}
124: 
125: Let us mention also the very important problems of 
126: the precise determination of the values of the neutrino oscillation parameters
127: and the search for CP violation in neutrino oscillations.
128: These problems will be investigated in experiments at the future Super-Beam facilities
129: and Neutrino factories
130: (see Refs.~\cite{Lindner:2002vt,Aoki:2002ks,Nakaya-Nu2002,hep-ph/0210113}).
131: We will not discuss them here.
132: 
133: We will start
134: in Section~\ref{Status of neutrino oscillations}
135: with a short review of the present status of neutrino oscillations. 
136: We will consider neutrino oscillations in
137: solar, atmospheric and long-baseline neutrino experiments
138: in the framework of mixing of three neutrinos.
139: The importance for neutrino mixing
140: of the results of the long-baseline reactor experiments CHOOZ and Palo Verde,
141: in which no
142: indication in favor of neutrino oscillations was found, will be stressed.
143: 
144: In Section~\ref{Neutrino mass from beta-decay experiments}
145: we will consider the Mainz
146: \cite{Weinheimer:1999tn,Bonn:2002jw,hep-ex/0210050}
147: and Troitsk
148: \cite{Lobashev:1999tp,Lobashev:2001uu}
149: experiments on the measurement of the neutrino mass through the detailed investigation of the end-point 
150: part of the $\beta$-spectrum of tritium.
151: We will discuss also the future KATRIN tritium experiment
152: \cite{Osipowicz:2001sq}.
153: 
154: In Section~\ref{Muon and tau neutrino mass measurements}
155: we briefly review the most recent results of
156: the experiments on the measurement of the effect of neutrino masses in pion and tau
157: decays.
158: 
159: Section~\ref{Neutrinoless double-beta decay}
160: is dedicated to neutrinoless double $\beta$-decay.
161: Even though in this review we are mainly interested in the possibilities to obtain information
162: about the absolute values of the neutrino masses from the investigation of this process,
163: some aspects of the theory of the process will be also presented.
164: 
165: %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%
166: 
167: The role of neutrinos in Astrophysics and Cosmology has been under the
168: scrutiny of physicists with ever increasing intensity over the last few
169: decades
170: (see Refs.~\cite{Pas:2001nd,Dolgov:2002wy,Dolgov:2002ad,Kainulainen:2002pu,%
171: Raffelt:2002ed,Raffelt:2002tu,hep-ex/0202043,Olive:2002qg,hep-ph/0210089}).
172: Actually, the intimate relationship of neutrinos and astrophysics
173: goes even further back in time when Bethe and others realized that the
174: inner workings of the Sun proceed via the thermonuclear reactions that
175: burn hydrogen into helium and release neutrinos. Since then there has
176: been a steady increase in interest and involvement in the study of neutrinos
177: in astrophysical environments. Not only the interest in solar neutrinos
178: has been particularly intense over the last years, where such epochal
179: events as their detection on Earth in a variety of underground experiments
180: have been milestones of late 20th century high energy physics, but also
181: the involvement of neutrinos in stellar core collapse has been theoretically
182: analyzed and observationally established in the momentous detection of neutrinos
183: of SN1987A and, furthermore, the influence and role of neutrinos in the
184: cosmic evolution has been a major area of research in contemporary high energy
185: physics.
186: 
187: Seminal work on neutrinos and Cosmology was pursued in the late
188: sixties and early seventies when neutrinos appeared as ideal candidates
189: to contribute substantially to the matter density of the Universe
190: (see Ref.~\cite{Dolgov:1981hv}). In fact,
191: hot dark matter models were popular for quite some time as they seemed to
192: render a satisfactory model for structure formation. Of course, the interest
193: in neutrinos worked then and still works now both ways; from the cosmological arena, neutrinos
194: were welcomed in the new cosmological Paradigm but also from the Particle
195: Physics side, Cosmology/Astrophysics was used and is used even more so today to constrain and sharpen
196: the still not well known properties of neutrinos.
197: 
198: The main focus of this review is the mass of neutrinos and especially their
199: absolute mass. So we have selected the issues in Cosmology/Astrophysics
200: that have relevant impact on the extraction of information concerning
201: neutrino mass. They are contained in Sections~\ref{Cosmology},
202: \ref{Cosmic Rays} and \ref{Supernova Neutrinos}.
203: We start in Subsection~\ref{The Gerstein-Zeldovich limit on neutrino masses} by
204: introducing the famous Gerstein-Zeldovich upper bound on the total sum of neutrino
205: masses that can contribute to the matter density of the Universe
206: \cite{Gershtein:1966gg,Cowsik:1972gh}.
207: Subsection~\ref{Microwave Background Anisotropies}
208: is dedicated to an overview of the temperature fluctuations of the
209: Cosmic Microwave Background
210: Radiation (CMB) with a special attention to the characteristics of the peak structure
211: of the angular power spectrum
212: (see Ref.~\cite{Hu:2001bc}).
213: There, the influence of neutrino mass on the anisotropy
214: spectrum is explicitly discussed. Although it is shown that this influence is
215: not as significant as the role of other cosmological parameters that enter
216: the angular spectrum of temperature fluctuations,
217: Subsection~\ref{Microwave Background Anisotropies} is relatively
218: long as compared to the other Subsections in Section~\ref{Cosmology} because in any analysis
219: of cosmological import the CMB is of pivotal importance. 
220: Subsection~\ref{Galaxy Redshift Surveys} is devoted
221: to Galaxy Redshift Surveys. Neutrino mass has a remarkable effect on the
222: power spectrum of matter distribution and this effect is observable in the
223: large samples of data compiled in present galaxy distribution surveys or to be
224: collected in future surveys. The final astrophysical source of information
225: discussed in this review, namely Lyman $\alpha$ forests studies, is dealt with in
226: Subsection~\ref{Lyman alpha forests}. The last Subsection
227: in Section~\ref{Cosmology}, Subsection~\ref{Neutrino mass bounds}, contains the summary of all
228: relevant neutrino mass limits obtained in the actual analysis by different groups and
229: by different authors of the astrophysical/cosmological sources that have been
230: discussed in the foregoing Subsections. It contains also a brief report on the prospects
231: for neutrino mass in this rapidly changing field of Cosmology and Astrophysics.
232: 
233: Another topic that we cover in our review concerns cosmic rays. A probe
234: of neutrino properties could come from the observation
235: of cosmic rays
236: with energies exceeding the Greisen-Zapsepin-Kuzmin cutoff
237: \cite{Greisen:1966jv,Zatsepin:1966jv}. 
238: A possible explanation could be the so-called $Z$-burst scenario
239: \cite{Fargion:1997ft,Weiler:1997sh},
240: where a flux of ultra high energy neutrinos interacts with relic
241: cosmological neutrinos, producing cosmic rays through the $Z$-resonance.
242: The resonance condition involves the masses of neutrinos and we
243: review the status of this mechanism in Section~\ref{Cosmic Rays}
244: (see also Ref.~\cite{Pas:2001nd}).
245: 
246: In 1987 the observation of neutrinos coming from supernova 1987A
247: in the Large Magellanic Cloud
248: marked the beginning of extra solar system neutrino astronomy
249: and allowed to get information on the supernova mechanism
250: and neutrino properties
251: (see Refs.~\cite{Trimble-RMP60-859-1988,Wheeler:2002gw}).
252: In particular,
253: the values of the neutrino masses are limited
254: by the lack of spread of the observed neutrino signal,
255: which would be caused by energy-dependent
256: velocities of sufficiently massive neutrinos
257: \cite{Zatsepin:1968,Pakvasa:1972gz,Cabibbo:1980,Piran:1981zz,Fargion:1981xc}.
258: In Section~\ref{Supernova Neutrinos}
259: we review
260: the classification and rate of supernovae
261: (Section~\ref{Supernova Types and Rates}),
262: the current theory of core-collapse supernova dynamics
263: (Section~\ref{Core-Collapse Supernova Dynamics}),
264: the observation of SN1987A neutrinos
265: (Section~\ref{SN1987A}),
266: the inferred limits on neutrino masses
267: (Section~\ref{Neutrino Mass}),
268: and the future prospects for supernova neutrino detection
269: (Section~\ref{Future}).
270: 
271: