1: %\batchmode
2: \documentclass[12pt]{article}
3: \topmargin 0cm
4: \textwidth 154mm
5: \textheight 230mm
6: \hoffset -1.2cm
7: \voffset -.5cm
8: \topskip 0mm
9:
10: \newcommand{\nc}{\newcommand}
11: \nc{\renc}{\renewcommand}
12:
13:
14:
15: % needed packages
16: %\usepackage{calc}
17: %\usepackage{ifthen}
18: \usepackage{graphicx}
19: %\usepackage{epsfig}
20: %\usepackage{miniplot}
21:
22: % supplementary packages
23: %\usepackage{wrapfig}
24: %\usepackage{subfigure}
25: %\usepackage{rotfloat}
26:
27: %\usepackage{showkeys}
28:
29:
30: % ***********************************************************
31: % ********************** latexcom.tex ***********************
32: % ***********************************************************
33: %
34: % ============================ Definitions ===================
35: %
36:
37: \nc{\half}{{\textstyle{1\over2}}}
38: \nc{\etal}{\mbox{\it et al. }}
39: \nc{\ie}{{\it i.e.}}
40: \nc{\eg}{{\it e.g.}}
41:
42: \renc{\thefootnote}{\arabic{footnote}}
43: \nc{\capt}[1]{{\bf Figure.} {\small\sl #1}}
44:
45: % --- For equation numbering like (sec.eq) ---
46: %\nc{\seqnoll}{\setcounter{equation}{0}}
47: %\renc{\theequation}{\thesection.\arabic{equation}}
48: %\renc{\Section}[2]{\bc\section{\sc #2}\label{#1}\seqnoll\ec}
49:
50:
51: \nc{\eqs}[2]{\mbox{Eqs.~(\ref{#1},\,\ref{#2})}}
52: \nc{\eq}[1]{\mbox{Eq.~(\ref{#1})}}
53:
54:
55: \nc{\figs}[2]{\mbox{Figs.~(\ref{#1},\,\ref{#2})}}
56: \nc{\fig}[1]{\mbox{Fig~.(\ref{#1})}}
57:
58: \def\jump{\vskip 1truecm}
59:
60: %
61: \nc{\tag}[1]{\label{#1} \marginpar{{\footnotesize #1}}}
62: \nc{\mtag}[1]{\label{#1} \mbox{\marginpar{{\footnotesize #1}}}}
63: %............................................................
64: %Macros for draft version/final version
65: \renc{\baselinestretch}{1.5}
66: %\pagestyle{headings}
67: \jot 1ex
68: %
69: \newlength{\overeqskip}
70: \newlength{\undereqskip}
71: \setlength{\overeqskip}{\jot}
72: \setlength{\undereqskip}{\jot}
73: %
74: %DRAFT MODE: Undo % on the following lines
75: %\nc{\be}[1]{{\marginpar{{\footnotesize #1}}}
76: % \vspace{\overeqskip}\begin{equation} \mbox{$\label{#1}$}}
77: %\nc{\bea}[1]{{\marginpar{{\footnotesize #1}}}
78: % \vspace{\overeqskip}\begin{eqnarray} \mbox{$\label{#1}$}}
79: %\nc{\Section}[2]{{\marginpar{{\footnotesize #1}}}
80: % \section{#2}\label{#1}}
81: %\nc{\Bibitem}[1]{\bibitem{#1}{\marginpar{{\footnotesize #1}}}}
82: %\nc{\Label}[1]{\label{#1}{\marginpar{{\footnotesize #1}}}}
83: %FINAL MODE: Undo % on the following lines
84: \nc{\be}[1]{\begin{equation} \mbox{$\label{#1}$}}
85: \nc{\bea}[1]{\begin{eqnarray} \mbox{$\label{#1}$}}
86: \nc{\Section}[2]{\section{#2}\label{#1}}
87: \nc{\Bibitem}[1]{\bibitem{#1}}
88: \nc{\Label}[1]{\label{#1}}
89: %..............................................................
90:
91: \nc{\eea}{\vspace{\undereqskip}\end{eqnarray}}
92: \nc{\ee}{\vspace{\undereqskip}\end{equation}}
93: \nc{\bdm}{\begin{displaymath}}
94: \nc{\edm}{\end{displaymath}}
95: \nc{\dpsty}{\displaystyle}
96: \nc{\bc}{\begin{center}}
97: \nc{\ec}{\end{center}}
98: \nc{\ba}{\begin{array}}
99: \nc{\ea}{\end{array}}
100: \nc{\bab}{\begin{abstract}}
101: \nc{\eab}{\end{abstract}}
102: \nc{\btab}{\begin{tabular}}
103: \nc{\etab}{\end{tabular}}
104: \nc{\bit}{\begin{itemize}}
105: \nc{\eit}{\end{itemize}}
106: \nc{\ben}{\begin{enumerate}}
107: \nc{\een}{\end{enumerate}}
108: \nc{\bfig}{\begin{figure}}
109: \nc{\efig}{\end{figure}}
110: %
111: %------------------- Math commands, general --------------------
112: %
113: \nc{\arreq}{&\!=\!&}
114: \nc{\arrmi}{&\!-\!&}
115: \nc{\arrpl}{&\!+\!&}
116: \nc{\arrap}{&\!\!\!\approx\!\!\!&}
117: \nc{\non}{\nonumber\\*}
118: \nc{\align}{\!\!\!\!\!\!\!\!&&}
119:
120:
121: \def\lsim{\; \raise0.3ex\hbox{$<$\kern-0.75em
122: \raise-1.1ex\hbox{$\sim$}}\; }
123: \def\gsim{\; \raise0.3ex\hbox{$>$\kern-0.75em
124: \raise-1.1ex\hbox{$\sim$}}\; }
125: \nc{\DOT}{\hspace{-0.08in}{\bf .}\hspace{0.1in}}
126: \nc{\Laada}{\hbox {$\sqcap$ \kern -1em $\sqcup$}}
127: \nc\loota{{\scriptstyle\sqcap\kern-0.55em\hbox{$\scriptstyle\sqcup$}}}
128: \nc\Loota{{\sqcap\kern-0.65em\hbox{$\sqcup$}}}
129: \nc\laada{\Loota}
130: \nc{\qed}{\hskip 3em \hbox{\BOX} \vskip 2ex}
131: \def\Re{{\rm Re}\hskip2pt}
132: \def\Im{{\rm Im}\hskip2pt}
133: \nc{\real}{{\rm I \! R}}
134: \nc{\Z}{{\sf Z \!\!\! Z}}
135: \nc{\complex}{{\rm C\!\!\! {\sf I}\,\,}}
136: \def\bigid{\leavevmode\hbox{\small1\kern-3.8pt\normalsize1}}
137: \def\id{\leavevmode\hbox{\small1\kern-3.3pt\normalsize1}}
138: %\nc{\id}{{\bf 1}}
139: %\nc{\id}{{1\!\!1}}
140: \nc{\slask}{\!\!\!/}
141: \nc{\bis}{{\prime\prime}}
142: \nc{\pa}{\partial}
143: \nc{\na}{\nabla}
144: \nc{\ra}{\rangle}
145: \nc{\la}{\langle}
146: \nc{\goto}{\rightarrow}
147: \nc{\swap}{\leftrightarrow}
148:
149: \nc{\EE}[1]{ \mbox{$\cdot10^{#1}$} }
150: \nc{\abs}[1]{\left|#1\right|}
151: \nc{\at}[2]{\left.#1\right|_{#2}}
152: \nc{\norm}[1]{\|#1\|}
153: \nc{\abscut}[2]{\Abs{#1}_{\scriptscriptstyle#2}}
154: \nc{\vek}[1]{{\rm\bf #1}}
155: \nc{\integral}[2]{\int\limits_{#1}^{#2}}
156: \nc{\inv}[1]{\frac{1}{#1}}
157: \nc{\dd}[2]{{{\partial #1}\over{\partial #2}}}
158: \nc{\ddd}[2]{{{{\partial}^2 #1}\over{\partial {#2}^2}}}
159: \nc{\dddd}[3]{{{{\partial}^2 #1}\over
160: {\partial #2 \partial #3}}}
161: \nc{\dder}[2]{{{d #1}\over{d #2}}}
162: \nc{\ddder}[2]{{{d^2 #1}\over{d {#2}^2}}}
163: \nc{\dddder}[3]{{d^2 #1}\over
164: {d #2 d #3}}
165: \nc{\dx}[1]{d\,^{#1}x}
166: \nc{\dy}[1]{d\,^{#1}y}
167: \nc{\dz}[1]{d\,^{#1}z}
168: \nc{\dl}[1]{\frac{d\,^{#1}l}{(2\pi)^{#1}}}
169: \nc{\dk}[1]{\frac{d\,^{#1}k}{(2\pi)^{#1}}}
170: \nc{\dq}[1]{\frac{d\,^{#1}q}{(2\pi)^{#1}}}
171:
172: %
173: \nc{\cc}{\mbox{$c.c.$ }}
174: \nc{\hc}{\mbox{$h.c.$ }}
175: \nc{\cf}{cf.\ }
176: \nc{\erfc}{{\rm erfc}}
177: \nc{\Tr}{{\rm Tr\,}}
178: \nc{\tr}{{\rm tr\,}}
179: \nc{\pol}{{\rm pol}}
180: \nc{\sign}{{\rm sign}}
181: \nc{\bfT}{{\bf T }}
182: \def\eV{{\rm\ eV}}
183: \def\GeV{{\rm\ GeV}}
184: \def\MeV{{\rm\ MeV}}
185: \def\keV{{\rm\ keV}}
186: \def\TeV{{\rm\ TeV}}
187:
188: \nc{\cA}{{\cal A}}
189: \nc{\cB}{{\cal B}}
190: \nc{\cD}{{\cal D}}
191: \nc{\cE}{{\cal E}}
192: \nc{\cG}{{\cal G}}
193: \nc{\cH}{{\cal H}}
194: \nc{\cL}{{\cal L}}
195: \nc{\cO}{{\cal O}}
196: \nc{\cT}{{\cal T}}
197: \nc{\cN}{{\cal N}}
198: %
199: %----------------------Math commands, almost general -------------
200: \nc{\rvac}[1]{|{\cal O}#1\rangle}
201: \nc{\lvac}[1]{\langle{\cal O}#1|}
202: \nc{\rvacb}[1]{|{\cal O}_\beta #1\rangle}
203: \nc{\lvacb}[1]{\langle{\cal O}_\beta #1 |}
204: \nc{\bb}{\bar{\beta}}
205: \nc{\bt}{\tilde{\beta}}
206: \nc{\ctH}{\tilde{\cal H}}
207: \nc{\chH}{\hat{\cal H}}
208: %
209: %---------------------- swedish characters ---------------------------
210: \nc{\1}{\aa}
211: \nc{\2}{\"{a}}
212: \nc{\3}{\"{o}}
213: \nc{\4}{\AA}
214: \nc{\5}{\"{A}}
215: \nc{\6}{\"{O}}
216: %
217: %---------------------- greek characters ---------------------------
218: \nc{\al}{\alpha}
219: \nc{\g}{\gamma}
220: \nc{\Del}{\Delta}
221: \nc{\e}{\epsilon}
222: \nc{\eps}{\epsilon}
223: \nc{\lam}{\lambda}
224: \nc{\om}{\omega}
225: \nc{\Om}{\Omega}
226: \nc{\ve}{\varepsilon}
227: \nc{\mn}{{\mu\nu}}
228: %\nc{\k}{\kappa}
229: \nc{\vp}{\varphi}
230:
231: %
232: %---------------------------- Journals -------------------------
233: %
234: \nc{\advp}[3]{{\it Adv.\ in\ Phys.\ }{{\bf #1} {(#2)} {#3}}}
235: \nc{\annp}[3]{{\it Ann.\ Phys.\ (N.Y.)\ }{{\bf #1} {(#2)} {#3}}}
236: \nc{\apl}[3]{{\it Appl. Phys. Lett. }{{\bf #1} {(#2)} {#3}}}
237: \nc{\apj}[3]{{\it Ap.\ J.\ }{{\bf #1} {(#2)} {#3}}}
238: \nc{\apjl}[3]{{\it Ap.\ J.\ Lett.\ }{{\bf #1} {(#2)} {#3}}}
239: \nc{\app}[3]{{\it Astropart.\ Phys.\ }{{\bf #1} {(#2)} {#3}}}
240: \nc{\cmp}[3]{{\it Comm.\ Math.\ Phys.\ }{{ \bf #1} {(#2)} {#3}}}
241: \nc{\cqg}[3]{{\it Class.\ Quant.\ Grav.\ }{{\bf #1} {(#2)} {#3}}}
242: \nc{\epl}[3]{{\it Europhys.\ Lett.\ }{{\bf #1} {(#2)} {#3}}}
243: \nc{\ijmp}[3]{{\it Int.\ J.\ Mod.\ Phys.\ }{{\bf #1} {(#2)} {#3}}}
244: \nc{\ijtp}[3]{{\it Int.\ J.\ Theor.\ Phys.\ }{{\bf #1} {(#2)} {#3}}}
245: \nc{\jmp}[3]{{\it J.\ Math.\ Phys.\ }{{ \bf #1} {(#2)} {#3}}}
246: \nc{\jpa}[3]{{\it J.\ Phys.\ A\ }{{\bf #1} {(#2)} {#3}}}
247: \nc{\jpc}[3]{{\it J.\ Phys.\ C\ }{{\bf #1} {(#2)} {#3}}}
248: \nc{\jap}[3]{{\it J.\ Appl.\ Phys.\ }{{\bf #1} {(#2)} {#3}}}
249: \nc{\jpsj}[3]{{\it J.\ Phys.\ Soc.\ Japan\ }{{\bf #1} {(#2)} {#3}}}
250: \nc{\lmp}[3]{{\it Lett.\ Math.\ Phys.\ }{{\bf #1} {(#2)} {#3}}}
251: \nc{\mpl}[3]{{\it Mod.\ Phys.\ Lett.\ }{{\bf #1} {(#2)} {#3}}}
252: \nc{\ncim}[3]{{\it Nuov.\ Cim.\ }{{\bf #1} {(#2)} {#3}}}
253: \nc{\np}[3]{{\it Nucl.\ Phys.\ }{{\bf #1} {(#2)} {#3}}}
254: \nc{\npps}[3]{{\it Nucl.\ Phys.\ Proc.\ Suppl.\ }{{\bf #1} {(#2)} {#3}}}
255: \nc{\pr}[3]{{\it Phys.\ Rev.\ }{{\bf #1} {(#2)} {#3}}}
256: \nc{\pra}[3]{{\it Phys.\ Rev.\ A\ }{{\bf #1} {(#2)} {#3}}}
257: \nc{\prb}[3]{{\it Phys.\ Rev.\ B\ }{{{\bf #1} {(#2)} {#3}}}}
258: \nc{\prc}[3]{{\it Phys.\ Rev.\ C\ }{{\bf #1} {(#2)} {#3}}}
259: \nc{\prd}[3]{{\it Phys.\ Rev.\ D\ }{{\bf #1} {(#2)} {#3}}}
260: \nc{\prl}[3]{{\it Phys.\ Rev.\ Lett.\ }{{\bf #1} {(#2)} {#3}}}
261: \nc{\pl}[3]{{\it Phys.\ Lett.\ }{{\bf #1} {(#2)} {#3}}}
262: \nc{\prep}[3]{{\it Phys.\ Rep.\ }{{\bf #1} {(#2)} {#3}}}
263: \nc{\prsl}[3]{{\it Proc.\ R.\ Soc.\ London\ }{{\bf #1} {(#2)} {#3}}}
264: \nc{\ptp}[3]{{\it Prog.\ Theor.\ Phys.\ }{{\bf #1} {(#2)} {#3}}}
265: \nc{\ptps}[3]{{\it Prog\ Theor.\ Phys.\ suppl.\ }{{\bf #1} {(#2)} {#3}}}
266: \nc{\physa}[3]{{\it Physica\ A\ }{{\bf #1} {(#2)} {#3}}}
267: \nc{\physb}[3]{{\it Physica\ B\ }{{\bf #1} {(#2)} {#3}}}
268: \nc{\phys}[3]{{\it Physica\ }{{\bf #1} {(#2)} {#3}}}
269: \nc{\rmp}[3]{{\it Rev.\ Mod.\ Phys.\ }{{\bf #1} {(#2)} {#3}}}
270: \nc{\rpp}[3]{{\it Rep.\ Prog.\ Phys.\ }{{\bf #1} {(#2)} {#3}}}
271: \nc{\sjnp}[3]{{\it Sov.\ J.\ Nucl.\ Phys.\ }{{\bf #1} {(#2)} {#3}}}
272: \nc{\spjetp}[3]{{\it Sov.\ Phys.\ JETP\ }{{\bf #1} {(#2)} {#3}}}
273: \nc{\yf}[3]{{\it Yad.\ Fiz.\ }{{\bf #1} {(#2)} {#3}}}
274: \nc{\zetp}[3]{{\it Zh.\ Eksp.\ Teor.\ Fiz.\ }{{\bf #1} {(#2)} {#3}}}
275: \nc{\zp}[3]{{\it Z.\ Phys.\ }{{\bf #1} {(#2)} {#3}}}
276: \nc{\ibid}[3]{{\sl ibid.\ }{{\bf #1} {#2} {#3}}}
277: %
278: %
279: % *****************************************************************
280: % ****************** end of latexcom.tex **************************
281: % *****************************************************************
282: %
283: % ------------------------ local commands -----------------------
284: \nc{\rf}[1]{(\ref{#1})}
285: \nc{\nn}{\nonumber \\*}
286: \nc{\bfB}{\bf{B}}
287: \nc{\bfv}{\bf{v}}
288: \nc{\bfx}{\bf{x}}
289: \nc{\bfy}{\bf{y}}
290: \nc{\vx}{\vec{x}}
291: \nc{\vy}{\vec{y}}
292: \nc{\oB}{\overline{B}}
293: \nc{\oI}{\overline{I}}
294: \nc{\oR}{\overline{R}}
295: \nc{\rar}{\rightarrow}
296: \nc{\ti}{\times}
297: \nc{\slsh}{\hskip-5pt/}
298: \nc{\sm}{Standard~Model~}
299: \nc{\MP}{M_{\rm Pl}}
300: \nc{\tp}{t_{\rm Pl}}
301: \nc{\ave}{\bar{E}}
302: \def\mes#1{{d^3{#1}\over (2\pi )^3}}
303: %\renc{\dk}{{d^3k\over (2\pi)^3 2\omega_k}}
304: \def\sepand{\rule{14cm}{0pt}\and}
305: \nc{\eff}{{\rm eff}}
306: \nc{\kk}{\vek{k}}
307: \nc{\pp}{{\rm p}}
308: \nc{\ga}{g_{a\gamma}}
309: \nc{\vv}{\\}
310: \nc{\eee}{{\bf E}}
311: \nc{\bbb}{{\bf B}}
312: \nc{\qcd}{T_{\rm QCD}}
313: \nc{\G}{\rm \ G}
314: \def\vec#1{{\bf #1}}
315: %\batchmode
316:
317:
318: %\newcounter{eqnn} \newcounter{eqs} \newcounter{secn}
319: %\newcounter{subn}
320: %\def\sec{\addtocounter{secn}{1}\setcounter{subn}{0}
321: %\setcounter{eqs}{0}$\bf \thesecn $}
322: %\def\sub{\addtocounter{subn}{1} $\bf \thesecn.\thesubn $}
323: %\def\eqn{\addtocounter{eqs}{1}\;\;\;(\thesecn.\theeqs)}
324: %\def\eq{\addtocounter{eqnn}{1}\;\;\;(\theeqnn)}
325: \def\lae{\;^{<}_{\sim} \;} \def\gae{\; ^{>}_{\sim} \;}
326: %\def\udd{u^{c}d^{c}d^{c}} \def\ffr{\phi_{R}}
327: %\def\sr{\psi_{R}} \def\ffi{\phi_{I}} \def\si{\psi_{I}}
328: %\def\dfr{\dot{\phi}_{R}} \def\dsr{\dot{\psi}_{R}}
329: %\def\dfi{\dot{\phi}_{I}} \def\dsi{\dot{\psi}_{I}}
330: %\def\ddfr{\ddot{\phi}_{R}} \def\ddsr{\ddot{\psi}_{R}}
331: %\def\ddfi{\ddot{\phi}_{I}} \def\ddsi{\ddot{\psi}_{I}}
332: %\def\tt{\tilde{\theta}}
333: \def\tu{\tilde{\mu}}
334: \def\te{\tilde{\epsilon}}
335: \def\rd{\dot{R}}
336: \def\tee{\tilde{E}}
337:
338: \def\udd{u^{c}d^{c}d^{c}}
339: \def\hl{H_{u}L}
340: \def\uude{u^{c}u^{c}d^{c}e^{c}}
341: \def\ell{e^{c}LL}
342:
343:
344: %\def\om{\omega}
345: \def\snu{\tilde{\nu}}
346: \begin{document}
347: {\title{\vskip-2truecm{\hfill {{\small \\
348: \hfill \\
349: }}\vskip 1truecm}
350: {\bf Two-Field Q-ball Solutions of Supersymmetric Hybrid Inflation}}
351: %\vspace{1.2cm}
352: {\author{
353: {\sc Matt Broadhead$^{1}$ and John McDonald$^{2}$}\\
354: {\sl\small Dept. of Mathematical Sciences, University of Liverpool,
355: Liverpool L69 3BX, England}
356: }
357: \maketitle
358: %\vspace{1cm}
359: %\newpage
360: \begin{abstract}
361: \noindent
362:
363: We demonstrate the existence of
364: two-field Q-ball solutions of the scalar field equations of
365: supersymmetric D- and F-term hybrid inflation. The solutions consist of a complex
366: inflaton field together with a real symmetry breaking field. Such inflatonic
367: Q-balls may play a fundamental role in reheating and the post-inflation era of
368: supersymmetric hybrid inflation models.
369:
370:
371:
372:
373: \end{abstract}
374: \vfil
375: \footnoterule
376: {\small $^1$mattb@amtp.liv.ac.uk}
377: {\small $^2$mcdonald@amtp.liv.ac.uk}
378:
379:
380: %
381: \thispagestyle{empty}
382: \newpage
383: \setcounter{page}{1}
384:
385:
386: \section{Introduction}
387:
388: Hybrid inflation models \cite{hi,lr} are a
389: favoured class of inflation model, being able to account
390: for both a flat inflaton potential during inflation and for a
391: massive inflaton and reheating after
392: inflation, without requiring very small couplings.
393: In supersymmetry (SUSY) there are two
394: classes of hybrid inflation model, D-term inflation \cite{dti} and
395: F-term inflation \cite{fti}, depending on
396: whether the energy density driving inflation originates in a D-term or F-term
397: contribution to the scalar potential.
398:
399: An important period in early Universe cosmology is the era
400: immediately following the end of inflation,
401: the post-inflation era. Important physical processes such as baryogenesis
402: are likely to
403: occur during the post-inflation era, whilst
404: reheating of the Universe will occur at the end of this era.
405: In hybrid inflation models it is known that quantum fluctuations of the inflaton
406: sector fields will rapidly grow and become non-linear at the end of inflation
407: \cite{tp,icf,cpr,matt1}.
408: The question of the subsequent
409: evolution of the non-linear field configurations in realistic SUSY inflation models
410: remains to be fully explored, but one possibility is that
411: non-topological soliton
412: configurations will form \cite{icf,cpr,iballs}. The most stable such configuration
413: will tend to be the
414: dominant one, since this will come to dominate the energy density of the Universe
415: and so determine the physics of the post-inflation era.
416:
417:
418: In SUSY hybrid inflation models the scalar
419: fields are generally complex, and therefore can carry conserved global
420: $U(1)$ charges. Depending on the form of the scalar
421: potential, it is then possible that a Q-ball made of
422: inflaton sector fields exists \cite{qb}. If such Q-balls formed at the end of inflation,
423: the Universe following inflation would be highly
424: inhomogeneous, with all the energy density concentrated
425: in the form of inflatonic
426: Q-balls. Post-inflation physics would then take place
427: against this cosmological background \cite{icf,matt1,fdd}, whilst
428: reheating would occur via the eventual decay of the Q-balls\footnote{This
429: possibility has previously been realised in the
430: context of a single field chaotic inflation model \cite{ke1}.}.
431:
432: The purpose of this paper is to demonstrate the existence of inflatonic Q-balls
433: in SUSY hybrid inflation
434: models. We will present numerical
435: examples of two-field Q-ball solutions, composed of
436: a complex inflaton field carrying a global
437: $U(1)$ charge and a real symmetry breaking field.
438:
439: The paper is organised as follows.
440: In Section 2 we discuss SUSY hybrid inflation models and the Q-ball equations.
441: In Section 3 we demonstrate the existence of two field Q-ball solutions of these
442: equations for the case of D- and F-term inflation.
443: In Section 4 we present our conclusions.
444:
445: \section{Q-ball Equations of SUSY Hybrid Inflation}
446:
447: SUSY hybrid inflation models are either F-term or D-term models.
448: The simplest F-term inflation model has a superpotential of the form \cite{lr,fti}
449: \be{hi1} W = \frac{\eta}{2} S(\Phi^{2} - \mu^{2}) ~,\ee
450: where $S$ is the inflaton and $\Phi$ is a field which gains an expectation
451: value which terminates inflation. $\mu^{2}$ and $\eta$ are real and positive.
452: The scalar potential is then
453: \be{hi2} V = \eta^{2} |S|^{2}|\Phi|^{2} +
454: \frac{\eta^{2}}{4} |\Phi^{2}-\mu^{2}|^{2}
455: ~.\ee
456: The scalar potential has an R-symmetry under which only $S$ transforms, which
457: manifests itself as a global $U(1)$ symmetry in the scalar potential, $S \rightarrow
458: e^{i \alpha}S$, with respect to which we can define a conserved global charge.
459:
460: D-term inflation models have a superpotential of the form \cite{dti}
461: \be{e1} W = \lambda S \Phi_{+} \Phi_{-} ~.\ee
462: The scalar potential is given by,
463: \be{e2} V = \lambda^{2}|S|^{2}\left(|\Phi_{+}|^{2} + |\Phi_{-}|^{2}\right)
464: + \lambda^{2} |\Phi_{+}|^{2} |\Phi_{-}|^{2} + \frac{g^{2}}{2} \left(|\Phi_{+}|^{2}
465: - |\Phi_{-}|^{2} + \xi\right)^{2} ~,\ee
466: where $S$ is the inflaton, $\Phi_{\pm}$ are fields with charges $\pm$1 with respect
467: to a
468: Fayet-Illiopoulos $U(1)_{FI}$ gauge symmetry, $\xi > 0$ is the Fayet-Illiopoulos
469: term and
470: $g$ is the $U(1)_{FI}$ gauge coupling.
471:
472: The D-term inflation scalar potential is a function
473: of $|S|$, $|\Phi_{+}|$ and $|\Phi_{-}|$ and therefore
474: has three global $U(1)$ symmetries, $S \rightarrow e^{i \alpha} S$ ($U(1)_{S}$),
475: $\Phi_{+} \rightarrow e^{i \beta_{+}} \Phi_{+}$ ($U(1)_{+}$)
476: and $\Phi_{-} \rightarrow e^{i \beta_{-}} \Phi_{-}$ ($U(1)_{-}$).
477: We can define conserved charges with
478: respect to these global $U(1)$ symmetries, $Q_{S}$, $Q_{+}$ and $Q_{-}$.
479:
480: Since SUSY hybrid inflation models have conserved global charges,
481: it is possible that there exist Q-balls \cite{qb}.
482: We first review the case of a single complex field $\Phi$ with $U(1)$ symmetry
483: $\Phi \rightarrow e^{i \alpha} \Phi$. The Q-ball configuration is
484: derived by minimizing the energy whilst fixing
485: the charge via a Lagrange multiplier i.e.
486: by minimizing the functional \cite{ks}
487: \be{e3} E_{\omega}= E + \omega \left(Q - \int d^{3}x \rho_{Q}\right) ~,\ee
488: with respect to the scalar fields and $\omega$, where $E$ is the total energy of the
489: field configuration
490: \be{e4} E = \int d^{3}x \; |\dot{\Phi}|^{2} + |\underline{\nabla} \Phi|^{2}
491: + V(|\Phi|) ~\ee
492: and $\rho_{Q}$ is the charge density
493: \be{e5} \rho_{Q} = i( \dot{\Phi}^{\dagger}\Phi - \Phi^{\dagger} \dot{\Phi}) ~.\ee
494: $E_{\omega}$ may be equivalently written as
495: \be{e6} E_{\omega}(\dot{\Phi},\Phi,\omega) = \int d^{3}x \left( |\dot{\Phi}
496: - i \omega \Phi|^{2} +
497: |\underline{\nabla}\Phi|^{2} + V(\Phi) - \omega^{2} |\Phi|^{2} \right) + \omega Q
498: ~.\ee
499: This should be minimized with respect to $\dot{\Phi}$, $\Phi$ and $\omega$.
500: To minimize with respect to $\dot{\Phi}$ we require $\Phi(\vec{x},t)
501: = \Phi(\vec{x}) e^{i \omega t}$. Substituting this into \eq{e6} gives
502: \be{e7} E_{\omega}(\Phi(\vec{x}),\omega) = \int d^{3}x \left(
503: |\underline{\nabla}\Phi(\vec{x})|^{2}
504: + V(\Phi(\vec{x})) - \omega^{2} |\Phi(\vec{x})|^{2} \right) + \omega Q ~.\ee
505: Extremizing this with respect to $\Phi(\vec{x})$ implies that
506: \be{e8} \underline{\nabla}^{2} \Phi(\vec{x}) = \frac{\partial
507: V_{\omega}\left(\Phi(\vec{x})\right)}{\partial \Phi^{\dagger}} ~\ee
508: where $V_{\omega} = V - \omega^{2} |\Phi|^{2}$.
509: At this point $\Phi(\vec{x})$ could still have a space-dependent complex phase,
510: $\theta(\vec{x})$.
511: If $V(\Phi) = V(|\Phi|)$, as it must when $\Phi$ transforms under a $U(1)$ symmetry,
512: then \eq{e7} is generally
513: minimized by the choice $\theta = $ {\it constant},
514: which may be chosen such that $\Phi(\vec{x})$ is real.
515: A minimum energy configuration should be spherically symmetric.
516: Then, with $\Phi(\vec{x}) = \phi(r)/\sqrt{2}$ ($\phi(r)$ real), \eq{e8} becomes
517: \be{e9} \frac{ \partial^{2} \phi}{\partial r^{2}} +\frac{2}{r} \frac{\partial
518: \phi}{\partial r} = \frac{ \partial V}{\partial \phi} - \omega^{2} \phi ~.\ee
519: We refer to this as the Q-ball equation.
520: The solutions of \eq{e9} should satisfy the boundary
521: conditions that the field tends to the vacuum as
522: $r \rightarrow \infty$ and that $\partial \phi/\partial
523: r \rightarrow 0$ as $r \rightarrow 0$.
524:
525:
526: The above analysis generalizes to the multiple complex
527: scalar field case of SUSY hybrid inflation.
528: For each value of $\omega$ there can be many
529: solutions of the Q-ball equations satisfying the boundary conditions,
530: each with a different energy and charge. In particular, there will be a
531: range of solutions of different energy and $\omega$ for a given global
532: charge.
533: Each of these solutions is a Q-ball in the sense that it is
534: a solution of the scalar field equations corresponding to a
535: non-topological soliton which has
536: a time-independent amplitude as a function of $r$.
537: However, these Q-balls will be metastable with respect to
538: the lowest energy Q-ball solution.
539: The stable Q-ball solution is the lowest energy
540: field configuration for a given global charge,
541: obtained by minimizing the energy functional
542: with respect to $\omega$ for a fixed charge.
543:
544: We will refer to solutions of \eq{e9} which are not minimum energy
545: solutions for a given charge as 'metastable Q-balls'.
546: The existence of one metastable Q-ball solution for a given charge is sufficient
547: to prove the existence of the stable Q-ball; it is either the minimum energy
548: solution itself or there exists a lower energy solution of
549: \eq{e9} carrying the same global charge.
550:
551:
552: In the following we will focus on the case of D-term inflation.
553: This is because, as we will show, the
554: Q-ball equations for the case of F-term inflation
555: are equivalent to those of D-term inflation with $\lambda = \sqrt{2}g$. Therefore
556: the F-term inflation Q-balls are a subset of those of D-term inflation.
557:
558: We now consider three Lagrange multipliers
559: $\omega$, $\gamma_{+}$ and $\gamma_{-}$, corresponding to the conserved
560: charges $Q_{S}$, $Q_{+}$ and $Q_{-}$ respectively. The functional is now
561: \be{e10} E_{\omega} = E + \omega \left(Q_{S} - \int d^{3}x \rho_{Q_{S}}\right)
562: + \gamma_{+} \left(Q_{+} - \int d^{3}x \rho_{Q_{+}}\right)
563: + \gamma_{-} \left(Q_{-} - \int d^{3}x \rho_{Q_{-}}\right)
564: ~,\ee
565: where
566: \be{e11} E = \int d^{3}x \; |\dot{S}|^{2} + |\underline{\nabla} S|^{2} +
567: |\dot{\Phi}_{+}|^{2} + |\underline{\nabla} \Phi_{+}|^{2} +
568: |\dot{\Phi}_{-}|^{2} + |\underline{\nabla} \Phi_{-}|^{2}
569: + V(|S|, |\Phi_{+}|, |\Phi_{-}|) ~,\ee
570: \be{e12} \rho_{Q_{S}} = i( \dot{S}^{\dagger}S - S^{\dagger} \dot{S}) ~\ee
571: and
572: \be{e13} \rho_{Q_{\pm}} = i( \dot{\Phi}_{\pm}^{\dagger}
573: \Phi_{\pm} - \Phi_{\pm}^{\dagger}
574: \dot{\Phi}_{\pm}) ~.\ee
575: As before, minimizing the time derivative terms implies that
576: $S(\vec{x},t )= S(\vec{x})e^{i \omega t}$ and $\Phi_{\pm}(\vec{x},t) =
577: \Phi_{\pm}(\vec{x})e^{i \gamma_{\pm} t}$.
578: For D-term inflation, $V = V(|S|,|\Phi_{+}|,|\Phi_{-}|)$. Therefore the minimum
579: energy
580: configuration will correspond to real $S(\vec{x})$ and $\Phi_{\pm}(\vec{x})$.
581: Assuming a spherically symmetric minimum energy configuration
582: then implies that
583: $S = s(r)e^{i \omega t}/\sqrt{2}$ and $\Phi_{\pm} =
584: \phi_{\pm}(r)e^{i\gamma_{\pm} t}/\sqrt{2}$. The vacuum of D-term inflation
585: corresponds to $|\Phi_{-}| = \xi^{1/2}$ and $S = \Phi_{+} = 0$. Therefore we must
586: have $\gamma_{-} = 0$
587: in order to reach the $\Phi_{-}$ vacuum expectation value as $r \rightarrow \infty$.
588: Thus the D-term inflation Q-ball must have $Q_{-} = 0$.
589: Since $\Phi_{+} \rightarrow 0$ as $r \rightarrow \infty$, the Q-ball could, in
590: principle,
591: carry a $U(1)_{+}$ charge. However, it is unlikely that a Q-ball solution with a
592: $U(1)_{+}$
593: charge exists. This is because the effective mass of the $\Phi_{+}$ scalar increases
594: as $|\Phi_{-}|$ decreases from $\xi$ and $S$ increases from zero as $r \rightarrow 0$.
595: Thus a $U(1)_{+}$ charge is likely to be energetically disfavoured.
596: Therefore we will focus on the case $Q_{+} = 0$, for which $\gamma_{+} = 0$.
597:
598: The corresponding Q-ball equations are then
599: \be{e14} \frac{ \partial^{2} s}{\partial r^{2}} +\frac{2}{r} \frac{\partial s}{\partial
600: r} = \frac{\lambda^{2}}{2}
601: \left(\phi_{+}^{2} +\phi_{-}^{2}\right) s - \omega^{2} s ~,\ee
602: \be{e15a} \frac{ \partial^{2} \phi_{+}}{\partial r^{2}} +\frac{2}{r} \frac{\partial
603: \phi_{+}}{\partial r} =
604: \frac{\lambda^{2}}{2}\left(s^{2}+\phi_{-}^{2}\right)\phi_{+}
605: + g^{2} \left(\xi - \frac{\phi_{-}^{2}}{2}\right)\phi_{+} +
606: \frac{g^{2}}{2} \phi_{+}^{3}
607: ~\ee
608: and
609: \be{e15b} \frac{ \partial^{2} \phi_{-}}{\partial r^{2}} +\frac{2}{r} \frac{\partial
610: \phi_{-}}{\partial r} =
611: \frac{\lambda^{2}}{2}\left(s^{2}+\phi_{+}^{2}\right)\phi_{-}
612: - g^{2} \left(\xi + \frac{\phi_{+}^{2}}{2}\right)\phi_{-} +
613: \frac{g^{2}}{2} \phi_{-}^{3}
614: ~.\ee
615: For $\phi_{-}^{2} \leq 2 \xi$, which will be true for any
616: solution tending to the vacuum as $r \rightarrow \infty$,
617: the only solution of \eq{e15a} which satisfies the boundary conditions $\phi_{+}
618: \rightarrow 0$
619: as $r \rightarrow \infty$ and $\partial \phi_{+}/\partial r \rightarrow 0$ as $r \rightarrow 0$
620: is $\phi_{+}(r) = 0$ $\forall r$. This follows since for a minimum energy solution
621: we expect
622: $\partial \phi_{+}/\partial r \leq 0$, such that $\phi_{+}(r)$ is monotonically decreasing
623: to zero as $r$ increases. Since the right hand side of \eq{e15a} is positive $\forall r$,
624: it then follows that $\partial^{2} \phi_{+} /\partial r^{2} > 0$ $\forall r$. However,
625: for a monotonically decreasing $\phi_{+}(r)$ we require that
626: $\partial^{2} \phi_{+} /\partial r^{2} < 0$ at $r=0$.
627: Therefore there is no non-trivial solution. Thus
628: for a Q-ball with $Q_{S} \neq 0$ and $Q_{+} = 0$, the Q-ball equations become
629: \be{e16} \frac{ \partial^{2} s}{\partial r^{2}} +\frac{2}{r} \frac{\partial s}{\partial
630: r} = \frac{\lambda^{2}}{2}\phi_{-}^{2} s - \omega^{2} s ~\ee
631: and
632: \be{e17} \frac{ \partial^{2} \phi_{-}}{\partial r^{2}} +\frac{2}{r} \frac{\partial
633: \phi_{-}}{\partial r} =
634: \left(\frac{\lambda^{2}}{2}s^{2} - g^{2} \xi\right)\phi_{-} + \frac{g^{2}}{2} \phi_{-}^{3}
635: ~.\ee
636: Therefore the Q-ball solution of D-term inflation with $Q_{+} = 0$
637: consists of a complex $S$ field and a real
638: $\Phi_{-}$ field, with a $Q_{S}$ charge but no $Q_{-}$ charge.
639: The energy and charge of the resulting Q-ball soultion are given by
640: \be{e18} E = \int 4 \pi r^{2} dr \left[ \frac{1}{2} \left( \frac{\partial s}{\partial
641: r}\right)^{2} +
642: \frac{1}{2} \left( \frac{\partial \phi_{-}}{\partial r}\right)^{2}
643: + \frac{\omega^{2} s^{2}}{2} + V(s,\phi_{-}) \right]
644: ~\ee
645: and
646: \be{e19} Q_{S} = \omega \int 4 \pi r^{2} dr \; s^{2} ~.\ee
647:
648: In the case of F-term inflation, only the $S$ field can carry a global charge.
649: Therefore, upon performing the minimization of the energy
650: functional, from minimizing
651: with respect to $\dot{S}$ and $\dot{\Phi}$ we
652: obtain $S(\vec{x},t) = S(\vec{x})e^{i \omega t}$
653: and $\Phi(\vec{x},t) = \Phi(\vec{x})$.
654: The potential, \eq{hi2}, is explicitly dependent upon the phase of $\Phi$.
655: However, for $\mu^{2}$ real and positive the energy functional will still
656: be minimized by having both $S(\vec{x})$ and $\Phi(\vec{x})$ real and positive.
657: Therefore with $S(\vec{x}) = s(r)/\sqrt{2}$ and $\Phi(\vec{x}) = \phi(r)/\sqrt{2}$,
658: the Q-ball equations become
659: \be{e20} \frac{ \partial^{2} s}{\partial r^{2}} +\frac{2}{r} \frac{\partial s}{\partial
660: r} = \frac{\eta^{2}}{2}\phi^{2} s - \omega^{2} s ~\ee
661: and
662: \be{e21} \frac{ \partial^{2} \phi}{\partial r^{2}} +\frac{2}{r} \frac{\partial
663: \phi}{\partial r} =
664: \left(\frac{\eta^{2}}{2}s^{2} - \frac{\eta^{2}}{2} \xi\right)\phi
665: + \frac{\eta^{2}}{4} \phi^{3}
666: ~.\ee
667: These equations are the same as the two-field D-term inflation equations,
668: \eq{e16} and \eq{e17}, when $\phi_{-} \leftrightarrow \phi$, $\lambda
669: \leftrightarrow \eta$
670: and $g \leftrightarrow \eta/\sqrt{2}$ i.e. when $\lambda = \sqrt{2}g$.
671:
672: \section{Numerical Two-Field Q-Ball Solutions}
673:
674: In this section we will present a number of numerical solutions of
675: \eq{e16} and \eq{e17} corresponding to Q-balls. We consider $g = 1$ throughout.
676:
677: For a given $\lambda$
678: there will be a range of solutions corresponding to different values of $Q_{S}$.
679: In Figure 1 we show a Q-ball solution for $s(r)$
680: and $\phi_{-}(r)$ for the case
681: $\lambda = 0.5$. (We use units such that $\xi = 1$.)
682: In Figure 2 we show a solution for
683: $\lambda = 1$. In Figure 3 we show a solution for the special case
684: $\lambda = \sqrt{2}g$,
685: corresponding to the case of F-term inflation. In Table 1 we summarise the properties
686: of these example Q-ball solutions. (We define the radius as the value of $r$ within
687: which $90\%$ of the total Q-ball energy is contained.) $E/Q_{S}$ is less than
688: the $S$ mass in vacuum for all of these solutions
689: ($m_{S}= \lambda \xi^{1/2} \equiv \lambda$ in our
690: units), so in the absence of additional couplings to the MSSM fields
691: the Q-balls will be absolutely stable as a result of $Q_{S}$ conservation.
692: (However, once the (unknown) couplings of the inflaton sector fields to
693: the MSSM fields are included, the inflatonic Q-balls will decay to
694: MSSM fields via conventional inflaton decay.)
695: An interesting feature of these solutions is that the value of
696: $s(r = 0)$ at the centre of the
697: Q-balls is {\it larger} than the value at which the symmetry breaking phase
698: transition ending inflation occurs,
699: $s(r = 0) > s_{c} = \sqrt{2} g \xi^{1/2}/\lambda$ ($\equiv 1.41 g/\lambda$ for
700: $\xi = 1$). However, in the Q-ball solution, where the field
701: configuration is dependent
702: upon the gradient energy as well as the potential energy, the symmetry
703: breaking field, $\phi_{-}$, remains non-zero throughout the Q-ball.
704:
705:
706: \begin{figure}[htbp]
707: \begin{center}
708: \includegraphics[width=0.75\textwidth]{qball0.5.eps}
709: \caption{\footnotesize{Q-ball profile for $\lambda=0.5$ and
710: $g = 1$.}}
711: \label{fig:fig2}
712: \end{center}
713: \end{figure}
714:
715: \begin{table}[htbp]
716: \begin{center}
717: \begin{tabular}{|c|c|c|c|c|c|c|c|}
718: \hline $\lambda$ & $\omega$ & $s_{o}$
719: & $\phi_{o}$ & $E$ & $Q_{S}$ & $E/Q_{S}$ & $r$ \\
720: \hline $0.5$ & $0.375$ & $0.20$ &
721: $0.00371$ & $2894$
722: & $6346$ & $0.456$ & $8.31$ \\
723: \hline $1.0$ & $0.800$ & $3.00$ & $0.14357$ & $378$ &
724: $396$ & $0.956$ & $4.33$ \\
725: \hline $\sqrt{2}$ & $1.125$ & $2.44$ & $0.19680$ & $180$
726: & $132$ & $1.368$ & $3.11$ \\
727: \hline
728: \end{tabular}
729: \caption{\footnotesize{Properties of example Q-ball solutions for $g=1$.}}
730: \label{fig:fig1}
731: \end{center}
732: \end{table}
733:
734: \newpage
735:
736:
737: In Table 2 we give the values of $\omega$, $s(r=0)$,
738: $\phi_{-}(r=0)$, $r$ and $E/Q_{S}$ for metastable Q-balls with $\lambda =
739: 1$, $g = 1$ and fixed charge $Q_{S} \approx 395$.
740: Since the value of $Q_{S}$ is generally much larger than 1, the Q-balls may be
741: studied classically.
742: Metastable Q-ball solutions exist for a finite range of $\omega$.
743: The lowest value of $E/Q_{S}$ corresponds to the true Q-ball solution.
744: As $\omega$ decreases, the value of $E/Q_{S}$ decreases,
745: implying that the binding energy of the $S$ charges in the Q-ball is
746: increasing. An interesting feature is that the value of $s$ at the centre
747: of the Q-ball increases whilst $r$ decreases as
748: $E/Q_{S}$ increases, indicating that the metastable Q-balls have a
749: larger gradient energy than the true Q-balls for a given charge.
750:
751:
752:
753: \begin{figure}[hp]
754: \begin{center}
755: \includegraphics[width=0.75\textwidth]{qball1.0.eps}
756: \caption{\footnotesize{Q-ball profile for $\lambda = 1$ and
757: $g = 1$.}}
758: \label{fig:fig3}
759: \end{center}
760: \end{figure}
761:
762:
763:
764:
765: \begin{figure}[hp]
766: \begin{center}
767: \includegraphics[width=0.75\textwidth]{qball1.414.eps}
768: \caption{\footnotesize{Q-ball profile
769: for $\lambda =\sqrt{2}$ and
770: $g = 1$ (F-term inflation).}}
771: \label{fig:fig4}
772: \end{center}
773: \end{figure}
774:
775:
776:
777:
778:
779: \begin{table}[htbp]
780: \begin{center}
781: \begin{tabular}{|c|c|c|c|c|}
782: \hline \bf{$\omega$} & $s_{o}$ & $\phi_{o}$ & $r$
783: & $E/Q_{S}$ \\
784: \hline $0.800$ & $3.00$ & $0.1436$ & $4.33$ & 0.956\\
785: \hline $0.810$ & $3.18$ & $0.1160$ & $4.07$ & 0.978\\
786: \hline $0.815$ & $3.20$ & $0.1153$ & $4.03$ & 0.981\\
787: \hline $0.820$ & $3.26$ & $0.1082$ & $3.94$ & 0.982 \\
788: \hline $0.825$ & $3.30$ & $0.1044$ & $3.92$ & 0.991 \\
789: \hline $0.849$ & $3.48$ & $0.0903$ & $3.65$ & 0.999\\
790: \hline
791: \end{tabular}
792: \caption{\footnotesize{Table of properties of metastable Q-balls for $\lambda =1$
793: and $g = 1$.}}
794: \end{center}
795: \end{table}
796:
797:
798: \newpage
799: \section{Conclusions}
800:
801: We have provided examples of inflatonic
802: Q-ball solutions of the SUSY
803: D-term hybrid inflation scalar field equations for
804: typical values of the dimensionless couplings $\lambda$
805: and $g$, including the special case $\lambda = \sqrt{2}g$,
806: corresponding to F-term inflation. Since $E/Q_{S} < m_{S}$
807: for these solutions, $Q_{S}$ conservation implies that
808: the Q-balls are stable up to the
809: decay of the inflaton sector particles they are made of to
810: particles in the minimal SUSY Standard Model sector.
811: Inflatonic Q-balls may form at the end of SUSY hybrid inflation
812: via the formation
813: of neutral condensate lumps and their subsequent decay into Q-ball,
814: anti-Q-ball pairs.
815: In this case there would be a highly inhomogeneous post-inflation era,
816: with the energy density of the Universe concentrated inside the Q-balls
817: and reheating via Q-ball decay. We hope to
818: discuss in detail the classically stable Q-ball solutions and the
819: process of Q-ball formation following SUSY hybrid inflation in future
820: work.
821:
822:
823: \begin{thebibliography}{50}
824:
825: \Bibitem{hi} A.D.Linde, \pr{D49}{1994}{748}.
826:
827: \Bibitem{lr} D.Lyth and A.Riotto, \prep{314}{1999} 1.
828:
829: \Bibitem{dti} E.Halyo \pl{B387}{1996}{43};
830: P.Binetruy and G.Dvali, \pl{B388}{1996}{241}.
831:
832: \Bibitem{fti} E.J.Copeland, A.R.Liddle, D.H.Lyth, E.D.Stewart and
833: D.Wands, \pr{D49}{1994}{6410}.
834:
835: \Bibitem{tp} G.Felder, J.Garcia-Bellido, P.B.Greene, L.Kofman,
836: A.Linde and I.Tkachev, \prl{87}{2001}{011601};
837: G.Felder and L.Kofman, \pr{D63}{2001}{103503};
838: G.Felder, L.Kofman and A.Linde, \pr{D64}{2001}{123517}.
839:
840: \Bibitem{icf} J.McDonald, \pr{D66}{2002}{043525}.
841:
842: \Bibitem{cpr} E.J.Copeland, S.Pascoli and
843: A.Rajantie, \pr{D65}{2002}{103517}.
844:
845: \Bibitem{matt1} M.Broadhead and J.McDonald, {\it hep-ph/0505298}.
846:
847: \Bibitem{iballs} S.Kasuya, M.Kawasaki and
848: F.Takahashi, \pl{B559}{2003}{99}.
849:
850: \Bibitem{qb} S.Coleman, \np{B262}{1985}{263}.
851:
852: \Bibitem{fdd} J.McDonald, {\it hep-ph/0305306}.
853:
854: \Bibitem{ke1} K.Enqvist, S.Kasuya and A.Mazumdar, \prl{89}{2002}{091301};
855: \pr{D66}{2002}{043505}.
856:
857: \Bibitem{ks} A.Kusenko, \pl{B404}{1997}{285}; \pl{B405}{1997}{108}.
858:
859: \end{thebibliography}
860:
861: \end{document}
862: ********************************************************************
863: ********************************************************************
864:
865:
866:
867:
868:
869:
870:
871:
872:
873:
874: