hep-ph0507111/fin.tex
1: \chapter{Summary and Outlook}
2: \label{fin}
3: 
4: \begin{quote}
5: \small\singlespace``There is no supersymmetry.'' \\ \flushright \vspace{-12pt} \emph{Carlos Wagner, in the middle of his 2002 TASI Lecture,\\ \emph{Introduction to Supersymmetry.}}
6: \end{quote}
7: Experiments to search with unprecedented sensitivity for particles and phenomena beyond the Standard Model of particle physics lie just over the horizon. These experimental advances make urgent the task of theorists to prepare to extract evidence for new physics from the empirical data by improving our ability to calculate reliably within the Standard Model, and then to be ready to deduce the implications of the new discoveries for our existing models of physical phenomena.
8: 
9: In this work we have chipped modestly away at these complementary tasks. First, taking note of the already-existing evidence of the inadequacy of the Standard Model in the baryon asymmetry of the Universe, we took steps toward a more reliable calculation of the BAU predicted by the scenario of electroweak baryogenesis in the MSSM, and comparing the sizes of $CP$-violating phases required by this scenario with the limits already placed on them by the null results of searches for electric dipole moments of electrons, neutrons, and $^{199}$Hg atoms. Making use of the closed-time path formalism for quantum field theory incorporating the effects of finite-temperature and nonequilbrium physics, we found regions of parameter space in the MSSM for which the baryon asymmetry would be enhanced over the predictions of semi-classical calculations. In these regions, electroweak baryogenesis is found to account successfully for the BAU with $CP$-violating phases in the MSSM as small as $10^{-2-3}$, which are still consistent with current bounds from EDM searches. Future electron and neutron EDM searches, however, should be sensitive enough to rule out this scenario for baryogenesis if no EDMs (or too small EDMs) are found, or to detect positively nonzero EDMs of this size. Such a discovery, combined with discoveries of superpartners with masses consistent with our predictions, would constitute strong evidence that the baryon asymmetry could indeed have been produced during the electroweak phase transition. More likely, EDM searches and LHC results will further restrict the parameter space in the MSSM that could allow for successful electroweak baryogenesis, and point our investigations in the direction of other models (either extending the MSSM or favoring a different mechanism for baryogenesis) that could be the correct account of the particles which actually exist in Nature and the origin of those which ended up as the matter that makes up all of our observable (and improbable \cite{Graesser:2004ng}) Universe today.
10: 
11: On the Standard Model front, we employed effective field theories in QCD to untangle perturbatively-calculable and unknown nonperturbative effects in processes involving the strong interactions by organizing the theory in powers of some small parameter. We applied soft-collinear effective theory combined with non-relativistic QCD to the exclusive radiative decay of $\Upsilon$ or other quarkonia to light hadrons. It has been known that in inclusive radiative $\Upsilon$ decays the decay channel involving the $b\bar b$ pair in a color-octet configuration can be as important as the color-singlet channel in the kinematic region of near-maximal photon energy, $E_\gamma\sim M_\Upsilon/2$. In exclusive decays, however, we showed that the color-octet channel could be safely ignored, thanks to the power counting in the effective theory of the color-singlet and color-octet contributions to the $\Upsilon\rightarrow\gamma H$ decay rate. The power counting and perturbative matching produced an operator which dominantly contributes to the decay rate, leading us to predict that the dominant decay product in radiative $\Upsilon$ decay should be the $f_2(1270)$, which should be produced in a helicity-zero state. The limited experimental evidence so far lends support to this prediction, although the helicity of the produced $f_2$ has not yet been positively identified. Our analysis also suggests a larger branching fraction for $\Upsilon\rightarrow\gamma f_2$ than the data so far indicate. Further data on this decay and other radiative decays, if consistent with the effective theory predictions, would lend powerful support to the validity of the effective theory expansion, establishing its reliability for use in other processes, especially those which relate more directly to searches for new particles.
12: 
13: Such processes are the production of hadronic jets in lepton collisions or, in our formulation, $Z$ decays. SCET isolated for us the soft gluon matrix elements giving the leading nonperturbative corrections to event shape distributions in hadronic $Z$ decays or, equivalently, $e^+e^-$ annhilation. Reliable calculation of these variables in QCD is essential to separate the Standard Model background in such processes in searches for new physics. Universalities among nonperturbative contributions to different event shapes would reduce the uncertainties in these calcualtions greatly, improving our ability to find deviations from Standard Model predictions while also revealing new information about QCD itself. We attempted to find such relations in the $Z$ decay distributions in jet energy, thrust, jet masses, jet broadenings, $C$ parameter, and other variables. The theory, however, did not fully acquiesce to our hopes, leaving us only one relation between the thrust and jet mass sum distributions. Experimental tests of models proposing more extensive relations among these nonperturbative corrections seem to confirm our findings. This suggests a future direction of research to define  new event shape variables, other than those standardly used in the past, which may receive universal nonperturbative corrections. This task was begun in perturbative QCD in Refs.~\cite{Berger:2003iw,Berger:2003pk}, and could be analyzed also in SCET. Similar methods could also be applied to other classes of events with QCD-jet backgrounds, or to the study of processes with collinear hadrons in the initial state, as occurs at any hadron collider.
14: 
15: 
16: Precision tests at low energy which constrain parameters of proposed models of physics beyond the Standard Model together with reduction of uncertainties in calculations of strong interaction phenomena prepare the way for the further scrutiny of the Standard Model to ever higher precision and perhaps the discovery of new particles and phenomena which lie beyond it. It is the task of the theorist to develop reliable methods to predict the observables in these phenomena and be prepared to understand the implications thereof on our models for the particles which make up our Universe and how they were generated in the very beginning.
17: