1: \documentclass[showpacs,preprintnumbers,amsmath,amssymb,twocolumn]{revtex4} 

2:  

3: \usepackage{graphicx}% Include figure files 

4: \usepackage{dcolumn}% Align table columns on decimal point 

5: \usepackage{bm}% bold math 

6: \def\sint{\int \!\!\!\!\!\!\!\! \sum_{p}} 

7: \def\sintex{\int \!\!\!\!\!\! \sum_{p}} 

8: \def\tr{\mbox{tr}\,} 

9: \def\Tr{\mbox{Tr}\,} 

10: \def\res{\mbox{Res}} 

11: \def\re{\mbox{Re}\,} 

12: \def\openone{\leavevmode\hbox{\small1\kern-3.8pt\normalsize1}}% 

13:  

14: \def\mf{{\mbox{\tiny\em MFA}}} 

15: \def\vol{{\mbox{\tiny\em V}}} 

16: \def\qq{\langle\bar qq\rangle} 

17:  

18: \def\bea{\begin{eqnarray}} 

19: \def\eea{\end{eqnarray}} 

20: \def\beq{\begin{equation}} 

21: \def\eeq{\end{equation}} 

22:  

23: \def\nn{\nonumber} 

24: \def\Tr{{\,\mbox{Tr}}} 

25:  

26: \begin{document} 

27:  

28: \title{Color Neutral Ground State of 2SC Quark Matter} 

29: \author{D. Blaschke$^{a,b}$, D. G\'omez Dumm$^{c,d}$, 

30: A. G. Grunfeld$^{e}$ and N. N. Scoccola$^{d,e,f}$} 

31: \affiliation{$^a$ Gesellschaft f\"ur Schwerionenforschung (GSI) mbH, 

32: Planckstr. 1, D-64291 Darmstadt, Germany\\ 

33: $^b$ Bogoliubov Laboratory for Theoretical Physics, JINR Dubna, 141980 Dubna, 

34: Russia\\ 

35: $^c$ IFLP,CONICET - Depto. de F\'isica, FCE, Universidad Nacional de La Plata, 

36: C.C. 67, 1900 La Plata, Argentina\\ 

37: $^d$ CONICET, Rivadavia 1917, 1033 Buenos Aires, Argentina\\ 

38: $^e$ Physics Department, Comisi\'on Nacional de Energ\'ia At\'omica, 

39: Av. Libertador 8250, 1429 Buenos Aires, Argentina\\ 

40: $^f$ Universidad Favaloro, Sol\'is 453, 1078 Buenos Aires, Argentina} 

41:  

42:  

43: \begin{abstract} 

44: We construct a new color neutral ground state of two-flavor color 

45: superconducting quark matter. It is shown that, in contrast with the 

46: conventionally considered ground state with diquark pairing in only one 

47: color direction, this new state is stable against arbitrary diquark 

48: fluctuations. In addition, the thermodynamical potential is found to 

49: be lower for this new state than for the conventional one. 

50: \end{abstract} 

51:  

52: \date{\today} 

53:  

54: \pacs{11.30.Qc, 12.38.Lg, 11.10.Wx, 25.75.Nq} 

55:  

56: \maketitle 

57:  

58: Recent investigations on the QCD phase diagram have discovered a rich 

59: diversity of color superconducting quark matter phases at low temperatures 

60: and intermediate densities \cite{cscreview}. 

61: Particularly interesting are possible implications of 

62: these results for the physics of compact stars \cite{cscstars} as well as 

63: heavy ion collision experiments \cite{cschic} addressing the domain of 

64: densities and temperatures where the strange quarks are still heavy and 

65: confined \cite{Ruster:2005jc,Blaschke:2005uj} . In both 

66: systems, the constraint of global color neutrality has to be fulfilled. In 

67: addition, the constraint of global electric neutrality has to be satisfied 

68: when macroscopic objects like compact stars are considered and flavor 

69: changing processes have enough time to adjust $u$ and $d$ quark chemical 

70: potentials according to $\beta$-equilibrium. 

71:  

72: %{\bf Say something of complexity of QCd in this region and 

73: %justified the sue of models} 

74:  

75: In view of the nonperturbative character of QCD, the theoretical 

76: treatment of hadronic matter at the vicinity of the phase 

77: transitions for low temperatures and finite densities is a problem 

78: of highest complexity, where rigorous theoretical approaches are 

79: not yet available and lattice QCD simulations are up to now not 

80: applicable. Therefore one has to rely on effective 

81: field-theoretical models of interacting quark matter, which are 

82: built taking into account the symmetry requirements of the QCD 

83: lagrangian and offer the possibility of dealing with the yet 

84: simplified interactions in a systematic way. Chiral quark models 

85: of QCD that adopt a current-current form of the interaction with 

86: mesonic and diquark components have been particularly useful, 

87: since the theories can be bosonized in a straightforward way. In 

88: the meson-diquark representation of these models an effective 

89: quantum hadrodynamics can be derived \cite{cahill}, but it has not 

90: yet been used to explore the QCD phase diagram. A preparatory step 

91: for this formidable task is the investigation of the mean field 

92: approximation (MFA), where important progress has been recently 

93: made within a nonlocal, covariant formuation that has been 

94: extended even to the study of color superconductivity in the QCD 

95: phase diagram~\cite{Blaschke:2004cc}. 

96:  

97: %{\bf Something is missing here ... color neutrality constraints - tha aim 

98: %of the paper} 

99:  

100: The two-flavor color superconductivity (2SC) phase of quark matter 

101: has been first considered in instanton-motivated QCD models in 

102: \cite{Rapp:1997zu}, where the question of color neutrality was 

103: disregarded. However, it was soon realized that the 2SC phase in 

104: which color symmetry is broken by the orientation of the diquark 

105: field in one of the color directions (2SC-$b$) entails a mismatch 

106: in the quark densities of paired and unpaired colors provided that 

107: color chemical potentials are all equal to each other, 

108: $\mu_r=\mu_g=\mu_b$. Therefore, in the 2SC-$b$ state color 

109: neutrality requires color charge chemical potentials to be 

110: readjusted so that $\mu_8=\frac12 (\mu_r+\mu_g-2\mu_b)$ acquires a 

111: nonvanishing value while $\mu_3=\frac32 (\mu_r-\mu_g)$ remains 

112: zero due to the degeneracy of the red and green colors. While this 

113: adjustment of $\mu_8\neq 0$ has long been considered a proper 

114: solution of the color neutrality constraint \cite{Huang:2002zd}, a 

115: recent investigation of fluctuations around the mean field 

116: oriented in the blue (0,0,1) direction has revealed the 

117: instability of this state once color neutrality is required 

118: \cite{hjz}. In the present paper we investigate the entire space 

119: of mean-field orientations in order to look for color neutral 

120: states which are stable against fluctuations. We find that these 

121: correspond to color neutral symmetric states (2SC-s) for which the 

122: condensates are equal in modulus in all the three directions of the 

123: color space. 

124:  

125: As in Ref.~\cite{hjz}, we consider the simplest version of the 

126: flavor SU(2) Nambu$-$Jona-Lasinio model \cite{njl,njlquark,klev}, 

127: extended so as to include the quark-quark interaction sector and 

128: finite chemical potentials 

129: \begin{eqnarray} 

130: \label{njl} {\cal L} &=& 

131: \bar{\psi}\left(i\gamma^{\mu}\partial_{\mu}+\mu\gamma_0 - \hat 

132: m\right)\psi 

133: +G_S\!\left[\!\left(\bar{\psi}\psi\right)^2\!+\left(\bar{\psi}i\gamma_5\vec{ 

134: \tau}\psi\right)^2\right]\nonumber\\ 

135: &+&\! G_D\left(\bar\psi^c_{i\alpha} 

136: i\gamma^5\epsilon^{ij}\epsilon^{\alpha\beta\gamma}\psi_{j\beta}\right) 

137: \left(\bar\psi_{i\alpha} 

138: i\gamma^5\epsilon^{ij}\epsilon^{\alpha\beta\gamma}\psi^c_{j\beta}\right) 

139: \ . 

140: \end{eqnarray} 

141: Here $\hat m$ is the diagonal current mass matrix for light 

142: quarks, $G_S$ and $G_D$ are coupling constants in color singlet 

143: and anti-triplet channels respectively, and  $\psi_{i\alpha}$ 

144: stands for quark fields with flavor index $i=u,d$ and color index 

145: $\alpha=r,g,b$ (charge conjugated fields are given by 

146: $\psi_{i\alpha}^c = i\gamma^2\gamma^0\bar\psi_{i\alpha}^T$). The 

147: Pauli matrices ${\vec\tau} =(\tau_1, \tau_2, \tau_3)$ act in 

148: flavor space, while and $\epsilon^{ij}$ and 

149: $\epsilon^{\alpha\beta\gamma}$ are totally antisymmetric tensors 

150: in flavor and color spaces, respectively. In the present letter we 

151: are mainly concerned with the effect of color neutrality on the 

152: ground state of a two-flavor color superconductor, therefore we 

153: will restrict here the discussion to the flavor symmetric case and 

154: consider the extension to electrically neutral matter elsewhere. 

155: Regarding quark chemical potentials, the elements of the matrix 

156: \begin{equation} 

157: \label{mu1} 

158: \mu={\rm diag}\,(\mu_{r},\mu_{g},\mu_{b},\mu_{r},\mu_{g},\mu_{b}) 

159: \end{equation} 

160: can be written as 

161: \begin{eqnarray} 

162: \label{mu2} 

163: &&\mu_{r}=\mu_B/3+\mu_8/3+\mu_3/3\ ,\nonumber\\ 

164: &&\mu_{g}=\mu_B/3+\mu_8/3-\mu_3/3\ ,\nonumber\\ 

165: &&\mu_{b}=\mu_B/3-2\mu_8/3\ , 

166: \end{eqnarray} 

167: where $\mu_B$ is the baryon chemical potential, while $\mu_8$ and 

168: $\mu_3$ are introduced to ensure color charge neutrality. Our aim 

169: is to discuss the color superconducting phase of the model in the 

170: mean-field approximation, which in general is characterized by 

171: nonvanishing diquark condensates 

172: \begin{equation} 

173: \label{delta} 

174: \Delta_\alpha = -\,2\,G_D\,\langle 

175: \bar\psi^c_{i\beta}i\gamma^5\epsilon^{ij} 

176: \epsilon^{\beta\gamma\alpha}\psi_{j\gamma}\rangle, 

177: ~~~\alpha=r, g, b\ . 

178: \end{equation} 

179: For standard values of the diquark coupling, $G_D=\frac34 G_S$, 

180: there is no simultaneous chiral symmetry breaking in this phase. 

181: In addition, since for light quarks the current quark masses are 

182: significantly smaller than the typical values of $\mu_B$ and 

183: $\Delta_\alpha$, for the purpose of the present study we can 

184: safely neglect both these small masses and the corresponding 

185: mesonic mean fields. Within this limit, we proceed to calculate 

186: the thermodynamical potential per unit volume at zero temperature. 

187: For convenience we perform our calculations in Euclidean space, 

188: where the thermodynamical potential in MFA is given by 

189: \begin{equation} 

190: \Omega^\mf \ = \ \frac{\Delta^2}{4 G_D} - \frac{1}{2} \int 

191: \frac{d^4 p}{(2\pi)^4} \ \ln \; {\rm det}\; M \ , 

192: \label{OmegaMFA} 

193: \end{equation} 

194: and the constraint of global color neutrality has to be obeyed, 

195: i.e. color charge densities should vanish 

196: \begin{equation}

197: \label{Qvan}

198: Q_\alpha=-\partial \Omega / \partial \mu_\alpha = 0~, ~~\alpha=3,8~.

199: \end{equation}

200: Here we have defined $\Delta^2 = \sum_{\alpha=r,g,b} 

201: \Delta_\alpha^2$, and the space integral is regulated as usual by 

202: introducing a sharp three-momentum cutoff $\Lambda$. The inverse 

203: fermion propagator $M$ is a $48\times 48$ matrix in Nambu-Gorkov, 

204: Dirac, color and flavor spaces, and can be conveniently written as 

205: \begin{equation} 

206: \label{M} 

207: M=\left(\begin{array}{cc} 

208: M^+& 0\\ 

209: 0& M^- 

210: \end{array}\right)\ , 

211: \qquad M^- = - {M^+}^\dagger \ , 

212: \end{equation} 

213: with 

214: \begin{widetext} 

215: \begin{equation} 

216: \label{S+} 

217: M^+ \ = \ \left(\begin{array}{cccccc} 

218: (G^+_{0r})^{-1}& 0& 0& 0& -\Delta_b'& \Delta_g'\\ 

219: 0& (G^+_{0g})^{-1}& 0& \Delta_b'& 0& -\Delta_r'\\ 

220: 0& 0& (G^+_{0b})^{-1}& -\Delta_g'& \Delta_r'& 0\\ 

221: 0& \Delta_b'& -\Delta_g'& (G^-_{0r})^{-1}& 0& 0\\ 

222: -\Delta_b'& 0& \Delta_r'& 0& (G^-_{0g})^{-1}& 0\\ 

223: \Delta_g'& -\Delta_r'& 0& 0& 0& (G^-_{0b})^{-1} 

224: \end{array}\right)~, 

225: \end{equation} 

226: \end{widetext} 

227: where $\Delta_{\alpha}'=i\gamma_5 \Delta_{\alpha}$ and 

228: $(G^\pm_{0\alpha})^{-1}= -[(p_4 \mp i\mu_{\alpha})\gamma_4 

229: +\vec{p}\cdot \vec{\gamma}]$ are $4\times 4$ matrices in Dirac 

230: space. After some algebra, it is seen that the determinant can be 

231: cast into the form 

232: \begin{equation} 

233: {\rm det}\; M = (\; S^+\; S^-\,)^4\ , 

234: \end{equation} 

235: where 

236: \begin{eqnarray} 

237: S^{\pm} &=& |C_r^{\pm} C_g^{\pm} C_b^{\pm}|^2 

238: + |C_r^{\pm} \Delta_r^2 + C_g^{\pm} \Delta_g^2 + C_b^{\pm} \Delta_b^2|^2 

239:  \nonumber\\ 

240: && \hspace{-.8cm} 

241: + \ 2 \!\left[ |C_r^{\pm}|^2 \, {\rm Re}\,({C_g^{\pm}}^\ast 

242: C_b^{\pm}) \; \Delta_r^2 + {\rm cycl. perm. \{{\it rgb}\}}\right] 

243: \! , 

244: \label{ese} 

245: \end{eqnarray} 

246: with 

247: \[ 

248: C_{\alpha}^\pm = \mu_{\alpha}\; \pm \; |\vec p\,| \; + \; i\,p_4 \ . 

249: \] 

250: With this general expression at hand we can investigate the 

251: problem of finding the most favored state under the constraint of 

252: the color neutrality, i.e. $Q_3=Q_8=0$.

253:  

254: Since the expression in Eq.(\ref{ese}) is totally symmetric under cyclic 

255: permutations of the three color indices, a cubic symmetry is expected in 

256: the three-dimensional space spanned by the three color directions along 

257: which the magnitudes of the colored diquark condensates are the 

258: coordinates. In the standard Cartesian representation, the condensate 

259: vector in color space is given by 

260: \begin{equation} 

261: \vec{\Delta}=\Delta_r~ \vec{\rm e}_r 

262: +\Delta_g~ \vec{\rm e}_g +\Delta_b~ \vec{\rm e}_b~. 

263: \end{equation} 

264: Due to the above mentioned symmetry, in what follows we will 

265: restrict our discussion to the sector defined by nonnegative 

266: values of the Cartesian coordinates $\Delta_\alpha$. In this 

267: representation, the 2SC-$b$ state is given by $\vec{\Delta}_{{\rm 

268: 2SC-}b}=(0, 0, \Delta_b)$, whereas the color symmetric state is 

269: $\vec{\Delta}_{\rm 2SC-s}=(\Delta_s, \Delta_s, \Delta_s)$, i.e.\ a 

270: vector pointing from the center to one of the edges of a cube in 

271: color space. For the 2SC-s state color neutrality is achieved with 

272: $\mu_8=\mu_3=0$, while everywhere else color symmetry is broken, 

273: entailing that either $\mu_8$, $\mu_3$ or both have to be 

274: different from zero in order to fulfill the color neutrality 

275: constraint. 

276:  

277: The observation made in \cite{hjz} stating that a 2SC-$b$ state 

278: defines a saddle point of the thermodynamical potential 

279: (\ref{OmegaMFA}) in the order parameter space, being a minimum in 

280: the blue direction but a maximum in the red and green ones, leads 

281: to the important fact that the 2SC-$b$ state widely considered in 

282: the literature is not the true ground state of quark matter in the 

283: 2SC phase. Now the problem is to find the true 2SC ground state, 

284: which should be thermodynamically more favorable not only by a 

285: lower energy but also by its stability with respect to 

286: fluctuations in the amplitude and the orientation of the 

287: condensate. 

288: %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%% 

289: \begin{figure}[htb] 

290: %\centering \includegraphics[width=2.2in]{u81.eps}% 

291: %\hspace{0.5in}% 

292: %\includegraphics[width=0.5\textwidth]{dif-mub-fin.eps} 

293: \includegraphics[width=0.4\textwidth]{mub.eps} 

294: %\includegraphics[width=0.5\textwidth]{O-K-mub.eps} 

295: \caption{Upper panel: Difference between the thermodynamical 

296: potentials of two color neutral states, namely the standard one 

297: --with broken color symmetry-- and the new color symmetric one, as 

298: functions of the baryon chemical potential $\mu_B$ at temperature 

299: $T=0$. Lower panel: Eigenvalues $k_1$, $k_2=k_3$ of the curvature 

300: tensor obtained from the thermodynamical potential at the 

301: color-symmetric minimum. Strict positivity proves the stability 

302: w.r.t.\ arbitrary small amplitude fluctuations. Color neutrality 

303: has been imposed, but not electric charge neutrality.} 

304: \label{fig1} 

305: \end{figure} 

306: %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%% 

307: We show here that the 2SC-s state proposed in this paper fulfills 

308: these conditions. To do this, we perform a numerical analysis 

309: taking a phenomenologically acceptable set of model parameters, 

310: namely $\Lambda = 653$ MeV, $G_S\Lambda^2=2.14$~\cite{klev}, 

311: together with $G_D=\frac34 G_S$. First, we show that the 

312: difference between the thermodynamical potentials of the 2SC-$b$ and 

313: 2SC-s states is positive along the relevant range of baryochemical 

314: potentials, say $350\ {\rm MeV}\le \mu_B/3\le 600\ {\rm MeV}$. The 

315: corresponding curve is plotted in the upper panel of Fig.\ 1. 

316: Second, in the lower panel of Fig.\ 1 we prove the stability of 

317: the 2SC-s solution by showing the strict positivity of the 

318: eigenvalues $k_1$, $k_2$, $k_3$ of the curvature tensor 

319: \begin{equation} 

320: K_{ij}=\frac{1}{2} \frac{\partial \Omega^\mf}{\partial 

321: \Delta_i \partial \Delta_j}\bigg|_{\rm 2SC-s} 

322: \end{equation} 

323: derived from the thermodynamical potential in the 2SC-s state. 

324: Interestingly, the largest eigenvalue $k_1$ corresponds to 

325: fluctuations in the ``radial'' direction $(1,1,1)$, while the two 

326: eigenvalues denoting the curvature in the orthogonal ``angular'' 

327: directions are found to be degenerate ($k_2=k_3$). 

328:  

329: Note that a special situation occurs at a chemical potential 

330: $\mu_B/3\simeq 550$ MeV, where the 2SC-s state becomes 

331: energetically degenerate with the 2SC-$b$ state and simultaneously 

332: the curvature in the angular directions vanishes. This implies 

333: that all orientations of the condensate vector $\vec \Delta$ are 

334: equivalent to each other, i.e.\ the cubic symmetry degenerates to 

335: a spherical one and the preference of the 2SC-s state gets lost 

336: (one has in this case $\Delta_b = \sqrt3\Delta_s$). In contrast, 

337: for all other values of $\mu_B$ the 2SC-s state is preferred, 

338: owing to the penalty introduced for all other states which need 

339: finite color chemical potentials to achieve color neutrality. 

340: %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%% 

341: \begin{figure}[htb] 

342: %\centering \includegraphics[width=2.2in]{u82.eps}% 

343: \includegraphics[width=0.45\textwidth]{surf.eps} 

344: \caption{The penalty for the thermodynamical potential, $\delta 

345: \Omega = \Omega^{MFA} - \Omega^{MFA}_{{\rm 2SC-}s}$, induced by 

346: the color neutrality constraint in the plane of the order 

347: parameters $\Delta_b$ and $\Delta_r=\Delta_g$ for $\mu_B=1200$ 

348: MeV. Since $\mu_3=0$, the penalty is a function of $\mu_8$ and 

349: both vanish in the 2SC-s state where 

350: $\Delta_r=\Delta_g=\Delta_b$.} \label{fig2} 

351: \end{figure} 

352: %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%% 

353: 

354: The behavior of this penalty $\delta \Omega$ in the condensate state 

355: space is illustrated by the contour plot shown in Fig.\ 2 for a

356: baryochemical potential $\mu_B=1200$~MeV chosen such that a maximal

357: effect can be demonstrated, see Fig. 1. In this plot 

358: we consider for simplicity the plane spanned by the axes 

359: $\Delta_r=\Delta_g$ and $\Delta_b$, so that red and green colors 

360: are degenerate and one has $\mu_3=0$. The penalty, arising from 

361: color symmetry breaking, is a function of $\mu_8$ and vanish in 

362: the 2SC-s state for which $\Delta_r=\Delta_g=\Delta_b$ and 

363: $\mu_8=0$. This figure strongly suggests that the 2SC-s state is, 

364: in fact, the absolute minimum of the mean field thermodynamical 

365: potential. 

366:   

367: Another important feature of the 2SC-s state concerns the corresponding 

368: 12 quasiparticle modes. It turns out that for this state the dispersion 

369: relations and degeneracy factors are given by 

370: \begin{eqnarray} 

371: E_0^\pm & = & |\vec p\,| \pm \mu_B/3 \qquad\qquad\qquad\;\;\, 

372: [\,\times 2\,]\ ,  \\ 

373: E_\Delta^\pm & = & \sqrt{(|\vec p\,| \pm \mu_B/3)^2 + \Delta^2} 

374: \qquad [\,\times 4\,]\ , 

375: \end{eqnarray} 

376: where $\Delta = \sqrt{3} \Delta_s$. This means that the system 

377: contains two gapless modes, just like in the case of the conventional 

378: 2SC-$b$ state. However, in 

379: the present case the gapless modes cannot be identified with the 

380: original $u$ and $d$ quarks of ``blue'' (unpaired) color in the 

381: original $\{r,g,b\}$ color basis but arise as a combination of all 

382: three color states. 

383:  

384: In summary, we have shown in this letter that in the case of color 

385: neutrality the ground state of 2SC quark matter should be 

386: constructed in a ``democratic'' way, so that color symmetry is not 

387: broken by the choice of the orientation of the condensate vector 

388: in color space. For this state, the condition of color neutrality 

389: is fulfilled in a trivial way, since the penalty induced by 

390: otherwise necessary color chemical potentials is avoided. We have 

391: shown that this 2SC-s ground state is stable against fluctuations, 

392: thus the problem observed in \cite{hjz} is solved. The 2SC-s state 

393: can serve as a starting point for considering hadronic 

394: correlations on the superconducting QCD vacuum, where due to the 

395: entanglement of the quark color states in the new basis color 

396: neutral quark and diquark excitations arise along the radial 

397: direction besides colored excitations in the tangential plane. The 

398: conclusions drawn so far should not be qualitatively altered when 

399: the additional constraint of electrical neutrality is imposed, 

400: which is important for applications in compact stars. Flavor 

401: asymmetry induced by this constraint could possibly inhibit the 

402: formation of the 2SC state in regions of the neutron star matter 

403: phase diagram. However, provided that a phase transition to 2SC 

404: quark matter is accomplished, it should be described by the 2SC-s 

405: state introduced in this paper. This issue, together with other 

406: extensions of the present work, will be explicitly discussed in 

407: forthcoming publications. 

408:  

409: {\bf Acknowledgements. } D.B.~acknowledges discussions with 

410: Michael Buballa and the inspiring Color Superconductivity seminar 

411: of the Virtual Institute held at Frankfurt and Darmstadt. This 

412: work has been supported in part by CONICET and ANPCyT (Argentina), 

413: under grants PIP 02368, PICT00-03-08580 and PICT02-03-10718, and 

414: by a scientist exchange program between Germany and Argentina 

415: funded jointly by DAAD under grant No.~DE/04/27956 and ANTORCHAS 

416: under grant No.~4248-6. 

417:  

418:  

419: \begin{thebibliography}{99} 

420:  

421: \bibitem{cscreview} 

422: For reviews, see K.~Rajagopal, F.~Wilczek, hep-ph/0011333; 

423: M.~Alford, Ann.\ Rev.\ Nucl.\ Part.\ Sci.\ {\bf 51}, 131 (2001); 

424: T.\ Sch\"afer, hep-ph/0304281; M.\ Buballa, Phys.\ Rep.\ {\bf 

425: 407}, 205 (2005). 

426:  

427: \bibitem{cscstars} 

428: D.\ Blaschke, T.\ Kl\"ahn, D.N.\ Voskresensky, Astrophys.\ J.\ (2000); 

429: D.\ Blaschke, H.\ Grigorian, D.N.\ Voskresensky, Astron.\ \& Astrophys.\ 

430: {\bf 368}, 561 (2001); 

431: D.M.\ Sedrakian, D.\ Blaschke, K.M.\ Shahabasian, D.N.\ Voskresensky, 

432: Astrofiz.\ {\bf 44}, 443 (2001); Phys.\ Part.\ Nucl.\ {\bf 33}, S100 (2002); 

433: H.\ Grigorian, D.\ Blaschke, D.N.\ Voskresensky, Phys.\ Rev.\ {\bf C 71}, 045801 

434: (2005); H.\ Grigorian, D.\ Blaschke, D.N.\ Aguilera, Phys.\ Rev.\ {\bf C 69}, 

435: 065802 (2004); D.N.\ Aguilera, D.\ Blaschke, H.\ Grigorian, 

436: Astron.\ \& Astrophys.\ {\bf 416}, 991 (2004); 

437: Nucl.\ Phys.\ {\bf A }, in press (2005), hep-ph/0412266. 

438:  

439: \bibitem{cschic} 

440: M.\ Kitazawa, T.\ Koide, T.\ Kunihiro, Y.\ Nemoto, 

441: Phys.\ Rev.\ {\bf D 65}, 091504 (2002); 

442: Nucl.\ Phys.\ {\bf A 721}, 285 (2003); 

443: Phys.\ Rev.\ {\bf D 70}, 056003 (2004). 

444:  

445: %\cite{Ruster:2005jc}

446: \bibitem{Ruster:2005jc}

447: S.~B.~R\"uster, V.~Werth, M.~Buballa, I.~A.~Shovkovy and D.~H.~Rischke,

448: %``The phase diagram of neutral quark matter: Self-consistent treatment of 

449: %quark masses,''

450: arXiv:hep-ph/0503184.

451: %%CITATION = HEP-PH 0503184;%%

452: 

453: %\cite{Blaschke:2005uj}

454: \bibitem{Blaschke:2005uj}

455: D.~Blaschke, S.~Fredriksson, H.~Grigorian, A.~M.~Oztas and F.~Sandin,

456: %``The phase diagram of three-flavor quark matter under compact star

457: %constraints,''

458: arXiv:hep-ph/0503194.

459: %%CITATION = HEP-PH 0503194;%%

460: 

461: 

462: \bibitem{cahill} 

463: R.T.\ Cahill, C.D.\ Roberts, J.\ Praschifka, Austral.\ J.\ Phys.\ 

464: {\bf 42}, 129 (1989); 

465: H.\ Reinhardt, Phys.\ Lett.\ {\bf B 244}, 316 (1990). 

466:  

467: \bibitem{Blaschke:2004cc} 

468: D.~Blaschke, H.~Grigorian, A.~Khalatyan, D.N.~Voskresensky, 

469: %``Exploring the QCD phase diagram with compact stars,'' 

470: Nucl.\ Phys.\ Proc.\ Suppl.\ {\bf 141}, 137 (2005); 

471: %[arXiv:hep-ph/0409116]. 

472: R.S.~Duhau, A.G.~Grunfeld, N.N.~Scoccola, 

473: AIP Conf.\ Proc.\ {\bf 739}, 428 (2005); 

474: Phys.\ Rev.\ D {\bf 70}, 074026 (2004). 

475:  

476: \bibitem{Rapp:1997zu} 

477: R.~Rapp, T.~Sch\"afer, E.V.~Shuryak, M.~Velkovsky, 

478: %``Diquark Bose condensates in high density matter and instantons,'' 

479: Phys.\ Rev.\ Lett.\ {\bf 81}, 53 (1998); 

480: %[arXiv:hep-ph/9711396]. 

481: M.G.~Alford, K.~Rajagopal, F.Wilczek, 

482: %``QCD at finite baryon density: Nucleon droplets and color 

483: %superconductivity,'' 

484: Phys.\ Lett.\ B {\bf 422}, 247 (1998). 

485: %[arXiv:hep-ph/9711395]. 

486: %%CITATION = HEP-PH 9711395;%% 

487:  

488: \bibitem{Huang:2002zd} 

489: M.~Huang, P.f.~Zhuang, W.q.~Chao, 

490: %``Charge neutrality effects on 2-flavor color superconductivity,'' 

491: Phys.\ Rev.\ D {\bf 67}, 065015 (2003); 

492: %[arXiv:hep-ph/0207008]. 

493: %%CITATION = HEP-PH 0207008;%% 

494: M.\ Huang, P.f.\ Zhuang, W.q.\ Chao, Phys.\ Rev.\ {\bf D65}, 

495: 076012 (2002); 

496: A.W.~Steiner, S.~Reddy, M.~Prakash, 

497: %``Color-neutral superconducting quark matter,'' 

498: Phys.\ Rev.\ D {\bf 66}, 094007 (2002). 

499: %[arXiv:hep-ph/0205201]. 

500:  

501: \bibitem{hjz} L.\ He, M.\ Jin, P.\ Zhuang, hep-ph/0505061. 

502:  

503: \bibitem{njl} Y.\ Nambu, G.\ Jona-lasinio, Phys.\ Rev.\ {\bf 

504: 122}, 345 (1961); {\bf 124}, 246 (1961). 

505:  

506: \bibitem{njlquark} See, for reviews, U.\ Vogl, W.\ Weise, Prog.\ 

507: Part.\ Nucl.\ Phys.\ {\bf 27}, 195 (1991); M.K.\ Volkov, Phys.\ 

508: Part.\ Nucl.\ {\bf 24}, 35 (1993); T.\ Hatsuda, T.\ Kunihiro, 

509: Phys.\ Rep.\ {\bf 247}, 338 (1994); M.Buballa, Phys.\ Rept.\ {\bf 

510: 407}, 205 (2005). 

511:  

512: \bibitem{klev} S.P.\ Klevansky, Rev.\ Mod.\ Phys.\ {\bf 64}, 649(1992). 

513:  

514: \end{thebibliography} 

515: \end{document} 

516: