hep-ph0607033/nnlo.tex
1: %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%
2: %% ws-procs9x6.tex   :   20-9-2004
3: %% Text file for Proceedings Trim Size [9in x 6in] written in Latex2E.
4: %% The content, structure, format and layout of this style file is the 
5: %% property of World Scientific Publishing Co. Pte. Ltd. 
6: %% Copyright 1995, 2002 by World Scientific Publishing Co. 
7: %% All rights are reserved.
8: %%
9: %% Proceedings Trim Size: 9in x 6in
10: %% Text Area: 7.35in (include runningheads) x 4.5in
11: %% Main Text is 10/13pt					  
12: %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%
13: 
14: %% Use \tbl{...} command for table caption i.e. to fit table width.
15: %% Use \caption{...} command for figure caption.
16: %\documentclass[draft]{ws-procs9x6}  
17: \documentclass{ws-procs9x6}
18: 
19: \begin{document}
20: 
21: \title{Cross sections at NNLO}
22: 
23: \author{V. DEL~DUCA\footnote{\uppercase{R}apporteur at 
24: \uppercase{D}\uppercase{I}\uppercase{S}06}}
25: 
26: \address{INFN, sez. di Torino,\\  
27: via P. Giuria, 1 - 10125 Torino, Italy\\
28: E-mail: delduca@to.infn.it}
29: 
30: \author{G. SOMOGYI AND Z. TR\'OCS\'ANYI}
31: 
32: \address{Institute of Nuclear Research of  
33: the Hungarian Academy of Sciences\\ and  
34: University of Debrecen,\\ H-4001 Debrecen, PO Box 51, Hungary\\
35: E-mail: z.trocsanyi@atomki.hu and somogyga@dragon.unideb.hu}
36: 
37: \maketitle
38: 
39: \abstracts{
40: In this talk we report on the state of the art on the calculation
41: of cross section at next-to-next-to-leading (NNLO) accuracy.}
42: 
43: \section{Higher-order calculations}
44: 
45: Next year, the LHC will start operating, ushering particle physics
46: into a completely unchartered energy realm. The LHC is a proton-proton
47: collider, thus in its use as a research tool it will be essential
48: to have the best possible theoretical understanding of QCD,
49: the  theory  of  the strong  interactions within the Standard Model. 
50: Because QCD is asymptotically free, at high $Q^2$ any cross section
51: can be expressed as a series expansion in $\alpha_S$. For most processes,
52: it suffices to evaluate the series at next-to-leading (NLO) accuracy,
53: which has several desirable features:
54: $a)$ the jet structure. At leading order it is trivial because each 
55: parton becomes a jet, 
56: at NLO the final-state collinear radiation allows up to two partons to
57: enter a jet; $b)$ a more refined p.d.f. evolution through the initial-state
58: collinear radiation; $c)$ the opening of new channels, through the inclusion
59: of parton sub-processes which are not allowed at leading order; $d)$ a
60: reduced sensitivity to the renormalisation and factorisation scales,
61: which are fictitious input scales,
62: allows to predict the normalisation of physical observables, which
63: is usually not accurate at leading order. That is the first step toward
64: precision measurements in general, and in particular toward an accurate
65: estimate of signal and background for Higgs and New Physics at the LHC;
66: $e)$ finally, the matching with a parton-shower MC generator, like
67: MC@NLO, which allows for a reliable normalisation of the event,
68: while generating a realistic event set up through showering and hadronisation.
69: 
70: \section{The NNLO world}
71: 
72: The NLO corrections, though, might be not accurate enough.  
73: For instance, $i)$ in the extraction of $\alpha_S$ from the data, where   
74: in order to avoid that the main source of uncertainty be due to the   
75: NLO evaluation of some production rates, like the event shapes of jet  
76: production in $e^+e^-$ collisions, only observables evaluated at
77: NNLO accuracy are considered~\cite{Bethke:2004uy};   
78: $ii)$ in open $b$-quark production at the Tevatron,  
79: where the NLO uncertainty bands are too large to test the   
80: theory~\cite{Cacciari:2003uh} {\it vs.} the data~\cite{Acosta:2004yw};  
81: $iii)$ in Higgs production from gluon fusion in hadron collisions, 
82: where it is known  
83: that the NLO corrections are large~\cite{Graudenz:1992pv,Spira:1995rr},  
84: while the NNLO   
85: corrections~\cite{Harlander:2002wh,Anastasiou:2002yz,Ravindran:2003um},   
86: which have been evaluated in the large-$m_t$ limit,  
87: display a modest increase, of the order of less than 20\%, with respect to   
88: the NLO evaluation; $iv)$
89: in Drell-Yan productions of $W$ and $Z$ vector bosons at the LHC,  
90: which can be used as ``standard candles'' to measure the parton luminosity  
91: at the LHC~\cite{Dittmar:1997md,Khoze:2000db,Giele:2001ms,Frixione:2004us}.  
92: 
93: In some cases, most notably in Higgs production from gluon fusion,
94: the central value of a prediction may change when going from NLO to NNLO.
95: However, the main benefit is in the
96: reduction of the theory uncertainty band, due to the lesser
97: sensitivity of the NNLO calculations to the $\mu_R, \mu_F$ scales. 
98: In addition, up to three partons make up the jet structure.
99: Thus, a lot of theoretical activity has been directed in the
100: last years toward the calculation of cross sections at NNLO 
101: accuracy~\footnote{For consistency, also the p.d.f. evolution 
102: has been computed to the same accuracy\cite{Moch:2004pa}}.
103: The total cross section~\cite{Harlander:2002wh,Hamberg:1990np}, the
104: rapidity distribution~\cite{Anastasiou:2003yy,Anastasiou:2003ds}
105: and the differential cross section~\cite{Melnikov:2006di} for Drell-Yan $W, Z$ 
106: production are known at NNLO accuracy. So are the total cross 
107: section~\cite{Harlander:2002wh,Anastasiou:2002yz,Ravindran:2003um}, 
108: the rapidity and the differential distributions~\cite{Anastasiou:2004xq}
109: for Higgs production via gluon-gluon
110: fusion, in the large-$m_t$ limit. However, only the calculations of
111: Ref.~\cite{Anastasiou:2004xq}, which has been extended to include the
112: di-photon background~\cite{Anastasiou:2005qj}, and Ref.~\cite{Melnikov:2006di}
113: allow the use of arbitrary selection cuts.
114: 
115: There are essentially three ways of computing the NNLO corrections: 
116: 
117: \noindent $a)$ Analytic integration, which is the first method to have been 
118: used~\cite{Hamberg:1990np}, and may include a limited
119: class of acceptance cuts by modelling cuts as 
120: ``propagators''~\cite{Anastasiou:2003yy,Anastasiou:2002wq}.
121: Besides total cross sections, it has 
122: been used to produce the Drell-Yan rapidity 
123: distribution~\cite{Anastasiou:2003yy,Anastasiou:2003ds}.
124: 
125: \noindent $b)$ Sector decomposition, which is flexible enough to include any
126: acceptance 
127: cuts~\cite{Roth:1996pd,Binoth:2000ps,Heinrich:2002rc,Anastasiou:2003gr}, 
128: and has been used to produce the NNLO differential rates of 
129: Refs.~\cite{Melnikov:2006di,Anastasiou:2004xq,Anastasiou:2005qj}
130: and of $e^+e^-\to 2$~jets~\cite{Anastasiou:2004qd}.
131: The cancellation of the IR divergences is performed numerically.
132: 
133: \noindent $c)$ Subtraction, for which the cancellation of the divergences is  
134: organised in a process-independent way by exploiting the universal  
135: structure of the IR divergences.
136: However, the cancellation of the IR divergences at NNLO is very 
137: intricate~\cite{Kosower:2002su,Weinzierl:2003fx,Gehrmann-DeRidder:2003bm,Gehrmann-DeRidder:2004tv,Gehrmann-DeRidder:2005hi,Frixione:2004is,Somogyi:2005xz,Gehrmann-DeRidder:2005cm,Weinzierl:2006ij}, and except for test cases
138: like $e^+e^-\to 2$~jets~\cite{Gehrmann-DeRidder:2004tv,Weinzierl:2006ij} and 
139: for parts of $e^+e^-\to 3$~jets~\cite{Gehrmann-DeRidder:2005cm}, 
140: no NNLO numerical code has been devised yet.
141: The standard approach of subtraction to NNLO relies on defining approximate  
142: cross sections which match the singular behaviour of the QCD cross  
143: sections in all the relevant unresolved limits.   
144: For processes without coloured partons in the initial state,
145: in Ref.~\cite{Somogyi:2005xz}
146: we disentangled the various kinematical singularities of the squared matrix 
147: element in all singly- and doubly-unresolved parts of the phase space, 
148: which allows for the definition of subtraction terms for processes with any 
149: number of final-state coloured partons.
150: 
151: \section*{Acknowledgments}
152: VDD thanks the organizers of DIS06 for their kind hospitality and support.
153: 
154: \begin{thebibliography}{0}
155: 
156: \bibitem{Bethke:2004uy}  
157: S.~Bethke,  
158: %``alpha(s) at Zinnowitz 2004,''  
159: {\it Nucl.\ Phys.\ Proc.\ Suppl.}  {\bf 135}, 345 (2004) 
160: [hep-ex/0407021].  
161: %%CITATION = HEP-EX 0407021;%%
162:   
163: \bibitem{Cacciari:2003uh}  
164: M.~Cacciari, S.~Frixione, M.~L.~Mangano, P.~Nason and G.~Ridolfi,  
165: %``QCD analysis of first b cross section data at 1.96-TeV,''  
166: {\it JHEP} {\bf 0407}, 033 (2004) 
167: [hep-ph/0312132].  
168: %%CITATION = HEP-PH 0312132;%% 
169:  
170: \bibitem{Acosta:2004yw}  
171: D.~Acosta {\it et al.}  [CDF Collaboration],  
172: %``Measurement of the J/psi meson and b-hadron production cross sections  in p  
173: %anti-p collisions at s**(1/2) = 1960-GeV,''  
174: {\it Phys.\ Rev.} {\bf D71}, 032001 (2005)
175: [hep-ex/0412071].  
176: %%CITATION = HEP-EX 0412071;%%  
177: 
178: \bibitem{Graudenz:1992pv}  
179: D.~Graudenz, M.~Spira and P.~M.~Zerwas,  
180: %``QCD corrections to Higgs boson production at proton proton colliders,''  
181: {\it Phys.\ Rev.\ Lett.} {\bf 70}, 1372 (1993).  
182: %%CITATION = PRLTA,70,1372;%%
183:   
184: \bibitem{Spira:1995rr}  
185: M.~Spira, A.~Djouadi, D.~Graudenz and P.~M.~Zerwas,  
186: %``Higgs boson production at the LHC,''  
187: {\it Nucl.\ Phys.} {\bf B453}, 17 (1995)
188: [hep-ph/9504378].  
189: %%CITATION = HEP-PH 9504378;%%  
190: 
191: \bibitem{Harlander:2002wh}  
192: R.~V.~Harlander and W.~B.~Kilgore,  
193: %``Next-to-next-to-leading order Higgs production at hadron colliders,''  
194: {\it Phys.\ Rev.\ Lett.}  {\bf 88}, 201801 (2002)
195: [hep-ph/0201206].  
196: %%CITATION = HEP-PH 0201206;%%  
197: 
198: \bibitem{Anastasiou:2002yz}  
199: C.~Anastasiou and K.~Melnikov,  
200: %``Higgs boson production at hadron colliders in NNLO QCD,''  
201: {\it Nucl.\ Phys.} {\bf B646}, 220 (2002)
202: [hep-ph/0207004].  
203: %%CITATION = HEP-PH 0207004;%%  
204: 
205: \bibitem{Ravindran:2003um}  
206: V.~Ravindran, J.~Smith and W.~L.~van Neerven,  
207: %``NNLO corrections to the total cross section for Higgs boson production  in  
208: %hadron hadron collisions,''  
209: {\it Nucl.\ Phys.} {\bf B665}, 325 (2003)
210: [hep-ph/0302135].  
211: %%CITATION = HEP-PH 0302135;%% 
212:  
213: \bibitem{Dittmar:1997md}  
214: M.~Dittmar, F.~Pauss and D.~Zurcher,  
215: %``Towards a precise parton luminosity determination at the CERN LHC,''  
216: {\it Phys.\ Rev.} {\bf D56}, 7284 (1997)
217: [hep-ex/9705004].  
218: %%CITATION = HEP-EX 9705004;%%  
219: 
220: \bibitem{Khoze:2000db}  
221: V.~A.~Khoze, A.~D.~Martin, R.~Orava and M.~G.~Ryskin,  
222: %``Luminosity monitors at the LHC,''  
223: {\it Eur.\ Phys.\ J.} {\bf C19}, 313 (2001)
224: [hep-ph/0010163].  
225: %%CITATION = HEP-PH 0010163;%%  
226: 
227: \bibitem{Giele:2001ms}  
228: W.~T.~Giele and S.~A.~Keller,  
229: %``Hard scattering based luminosity measurement at hadron colliders,''  
230: hep-ph/0104053.  
231: %%CITATION = HEP-PH 0104053;%%  
232: 
233: \bibitem{Frixione:2004us}  
234: S.~Frixione and M.~L.~Mangano,  
235: %``How accurately can we measure the W cross section?,''  
236: {\it JHEP} {\bf 0405}, 056 (2004)
237: [hep-ph/0405130].  
238: %%CITATION = HEP-PH 0405130;%%
239: 
240: %\cite{Moch:2004pa}
241: \bibitem{Moch:2004pa}
242: S.~Moch, J.~A.~M.~Vermaseren and A.~Vogt,
243: %``The three-loop splitting functions in QCD: The non-singlet case,''
244: {\it Nucl.\ Phys.} {\bf B688}, 101 (2004)
245: [hep-ph/0403192];
246: %%CITATION = HEP-PH 0403192;%%
247: %\cite{Vogt:2004mw}
248: %\bibitem{Vogt:2004mw}
249: %A.~Vogt, S.~Moch and J.~A.~M.~Vermaseren,
250: %``The three-loop splitting functions in QCD: The singlet case,''
251: {\it Nucl.\ Phys.} {\bf B691}, 129 (2004)
252: [hep-ph/0404111].
253: %%CITATION = HEP-PH 0404111;%%
254: 
255: %\cite{Hamberg:1990np}
256: \bibitem{Hamberg:1990np}
257: R.~Hamberg, W.~L.~van Neerven and T.~Matsuura,
258: %``A Complete Calculation Of The Order Alpha-S**2 Correction To The Drell-Yan K
259: %Factor,''
260: {\it Nucl.\ Phys.} {\bf B359}, 343 (1991)
261: [Erratum-ibid.\ {\bf B644}, 403 (2002)].
262: %%CITATION = NUPHA,B359,343;%%
263: 
264: %\cite{Anastasiou:2003yy}
265: \bibitem{Anastasiou:2003yy}
266:   C.~Anastasiou, L.~J.~Dixon, K.~Melnikov and F.~Petriello,
267:   %``Dilepton rapidity distribution in the Drell-Yan process at NNLO in QCD,''
268:  {\it Phys.\ Rev.\ Lett.}  {\bf 91}, 182002 (2003)
269:   [hep-ph/0306192].
270:   %%CITATION = HEP-PH 0306192;%%
271: 
272: %\cite{Anastasiou:2003ds}
273: \bibitem{Anastasiou:2003ds}
274: C.~Anastasiou, L.~J.~Dixon, K.~Melnikov and F.~Petriello,
275: %``High-precision QCD at hadron colliders: Electroweak gauge boson  rapidity
276: %distributions at NNLO,''
277: {\it Phys.\ Rev.} {\bf D69}, 094008 (2004)
278: [hep-ph/0312266].
279: %%CITATION = HEP-PH 0312266;%%
280: 
281: %\cite{Melnikov:2006di}
282: \bibitem{Melnikov:2006di}
283:   K.~Melnikov and F.~Petriello,
284:   %``The W boson production cross section at the LHC through O(alpha(s)**2),''
285:   hep-ph/0603182.
286:   %%CITATION = HEP-PH 0603182;%%
287: 
288: %\cite{Anastasiou:2004xq}
289: \bibitem{Anastasiou:2004xq}
290:   C.~Anastasiou, K.~Melnikov and F.~Petriello,
291:   %``Higgs boson production at hadron colliders: Differential cross sections
292:   %through next-to-next-to-leading order,''
293:  {\it  Phys.\ Rev.\ Lett.}  {\bf 93}, 262002 (2004)
294:   [hep-ph/0409088].
295:   %%CITATION = HEP-PH 0409088;%%
296: 
297: %\cite{Anastasiou:2005qj}
298: \bibitem{Anastasiou:2005qj}
299:   C.~Anastasiou, K.~Melnikov and F.~Petriello,
300:   %``Fully differential Higgs boson production and the di-photon signal  through
301:   %next-to-next-to-leading order,''
302:  {\it Nucl.\ Phys.} {\bf B724}, 197 (2005)
303:   [hep-ph/0501130].
304:   %%CITATION = HEP-PH 0501130;%%
305: 
306: %\cite{Anastasiou:2002wq}
307: \bibitem{Anastasiou:2002wq}
308:   C.~Anastasiou and K.~Melnikov,
309:   %``Pseudoscalar Higgs boson production at hadron colliders in NNLO QCD,''
310:  {\it Phys.\ Rev.} {\bf D67}, 037501 (2003)
311:   [hep-ph/0208115].
312:   %%CITATION = HEP-PH 0208115;%%
313: 
314: %\cite{Roth:1996pd}
315: \bibitem{Roth:1996pd}
316:   M.~Roth and A.~Denner,
317:   %``High-energy approximation of one-loop Feynman integrals,''
318:  {\it Nucl.\ Phys.} {\bf B479}, 495 (1996)
319:   [hep-ph/9605420].
320:   %%CITATION = HEP-PH 9605420;%%
321: 
322: %\cite{Binoth:2000ps}
323: \bibitem{Binoth:2000ps}
324:   T.~Binoth and G.~Heinrich,
325:   %``An automatized algorithm to compute infrared divergent multi-loop
326:   %integrals,''
327:  {\it Nucl.\ Phys.} {\bf B585}, 741 (2000)
328:   [hep-ph/0004013];
329:   %%CITATION = HEP-PH 0004013;%%
330: %\cite{Binoth:2004jv}
331: %\bibitem{Binoth:2004jv}
332: %  T.~Binoth and G.~Heinrich,
333:   %``Numerical evaluation of phase space integrals by sector decomposition,''
334:  {\it Nucl.\ Phys.} {\bf B693}, 134 (2004)
335:   [hep-ph/0402265].
336:   %%CITATION = HEP-PH 0402265;%%
337: 
338: %\cite{Heinrich:2002rc}
339: \bibitem{Heinrich:2002rc}  
340: G.~Heinrich,  
341: %``A numerical method for NNLO calculations,''  
342: {\it Nucl.\ Phys.\ Proc.\ Suppl.} {\bf 116}, 368 (2003) 
343: [hep-ph/0211144];
344: %%CITATION = HEP-PH 0211144;%%  
345: %\cite{Heinrich:2006sw}
346: %\bibitem{Heinrich:2006sw}
347: %  G.~Heinrich,
348:   %``Towards e+ e- $\to$ 3jets at NNLO by sector decomposition,''
349:   hep-ph/0601062.
350:   %%CITATION = HEP-PH 0601062;%%
351: 
352: %\cite{Anastasiou:2003gr}
353: \bibitem{Anastasiou:2003gr}
354:   C.~Anastasiou, K.~Melnikov and F.~Petriello,
355:   %``A new method for real radiation at NNLO,''
356:  {\it Phys.\ Rev.} {\bf D69}, 076010 (2004)
357:   [hep-ph/0311311].
358:   %%CITATION = HEP-PH 0311311;%%
359: 
360: %\cite{Anastasiou:2004qd}
361: \bibitem{Anastasiou:2004qd}
362:   C.~Anastasiou, K.~Melnikov and F.~Petriello,
363:   %``Real radiation at NNLO: e+ e- $\to$ 2jets through O(alpha(s)**2),''
364:  {\it Phys.\ Rev.\ Lett.}  {\bf 93}, 032002 (2004)
365:   [hep-ph/0402280].
366:   %%CITATION = HEP-PH 0402280;%%
367: 
368: %\cite{Kosower:2002su}
369: \bibitem{Kosower:2002su}
370:   D.~A.~Kosower,
371:   %``Multiple singular emission in gauge theories,''
372:  {\it Phys.\ Rev.} {\bf D67}, 116003 (2003)
373:   [hep-ph/0212097];
374:   %%CITATION = HEP-PH 0212097;%%
375: %\cite{Kosower:2003cz}
376: %\bibitem{Kosower:2003cz}
377: %  D.~A.~Kosower,
378:   %``All-orders singular emission in gauge theories,''
379:  {\it Phys.\ Rev.\ Lett.}  {\bf 91}, 061602 (2003)
380:   [hep-ph/0301069];
381:   %%CITATION = HEP-PH 0301069;%%
382: %\cite{Kosower:2003bh}
383: %\bibitem{Kosower:2003bh}
384: %  D.~A.~Kosower,
385:   %``Antenna factorization in strongly-ordered limits,''
386:  {\it Phys.\ Rev.} {\bf D71}, 045016 (2005)
387:   [hep-ph/0311272].
388:   %%CITATION = HEP-PH 0311272;%%
389: 
390: %\cite{Weinzierl:2003fx}
391: \bibitem{Weinzierl:2003fx}
392: S.~Weinzierl,
393: %``Subtraction terms at NNLO,''
394: {\it JHEP} {\bf 0303}, 062 (2003)
395: [hep-ph/0302180];
396: %%CITATION = HEP-PH 0302180;%%
397: %\cite{Weinzierl:2003ra}
398: %\bibitem{Weinzierl:2003ra}
399: %S.~Weinzierl,
400: %``Subtraction terms for one-loop amplitudes with one unresolved parton,''
401: {\it JHEP} {\bf 0307}, 052 (2003)
402: [hep-ph/0306248].
403: %%CITATION = HEP-PH 0306248;%%
404: 
405: %\cite{Gehrmann-DeRidder:2003bm}
406: \bibitem{Gehrmann-DeRidder:2003bm}
407: A.~Gehrmann-De Ridder, T.~Gehrmann and G.~Heinrich,
408: %``Four-particle phase space integrals in massless QCD,''
409: {\it Nucl.\ Phys.} {\bf B682}, 265 (2004)
410: [hep-ph/0311276].
411: %%CITATION = HEP-PH 0311276;%%
412: 
413: %\cite{Gehrmann-DeRidder:2004tv}
414: \bibitem{Gehrmann-DeRidder:2004tv}
415:   A.~Gehrmann-De Ridder, T.~Gehrmann and E.~W.~N.~Glover,
416:   %``Infrared structure of e+ e- $\to$ 2jets at NNLO,''
417:  {\it Nucl.\ Phys.} {\bf B691}, 195 (2004)
418:   [hep-ph/0403057].
419:   %%CITATION = HEP-PH 0403057;%%
420: 
421: %\cite{Gehrmann-DeRidder:2005hi}
422: \bibitem{Gehrmann-DeRidder:2005hi}
423:   A.~Gehrmann-De Ridder, T.~Gehrmann and E.~W.~N.~Glover,
424:   %``Quark-gluon antenna functions from neutralino decay,''
425:  {\it Phys.\ Lett.} {\bf B612}, 36 (2005)
426:   [hep-ph/0501291];
427:   %%CITATION = HEP-PH 0501291;%%
428: %\cite{Gehrmann-DeRidder:2005aw}
429: %\bibitem{Gehrmann-DeRidder:2005aw}
430: %  A.~Gehrmann-De Ridder, T.~Gehrmann and E.~W.~N.~Glover,
431:   %``Gluon gluon antenna functions from Higgs boson decay,''
432:  {\it Phys.\ Lett.} {\bf B612}, 49 (2005)
433:   [hep-ph/0502110].
434:   %%CITATION = HEP-PH 0502110;%%
435: 
436: %\cite{Frixione:2004is}
437: \bibitem{Frixione:2004is}
438:   S.~Frixione and M.~Grazzini,
439:   %``Subtraction at NNLO,''
440:  {\it JHEP} {\bf 0506}, 010 (2005)
441:   [hep-ph/0411399].
442:   %%CITATION = HEP-PH 0411399;%%
443: 
444: %\cite{Somogyi:2005xz}
445: \bibitem{Somogyi:2005xz}
446:   G.~Somogyi, Z.~Trocsanyi and V.~Del Duca,
447:   %``Matching of singly- and doubly-unresolved limits of tree-level QCD  squared
448:   %matrix elements,''
449:  {\it JHEP} {\bf 0506}, 024 (2005)
450:   [hep-ph/0502226].
451:   %%CITATION = HEP-PH 0502226;%%
452: 
453: %\cite{Gehrmann-DeRidder:2005cm}
454: \bibitem{Gehrmann-DeRidder:2005cm}
455:   A.~Gehrmann-De Ridder, T.~Gehrmann and E.~W.~N.~Glover,
456:   %``Antenna subtraction at NNLO,''
457:  {\it JHEP} {\bf 0509}, 056 (2005)
458:   [hep-ph/0505111].
459:   %%CITATION = HEP-PH 0505111;%%
460: 
461: %\cite{Weinzierl:2006ij}
462: \bibitem{Weinzierl:2006ij}
463:   S.~Weinzierl,
464:   %``NNLO corrections to 2-jet observables in electron positron annihilation,''
465:   hep-ph/0606008.
466:   %%CITATION = HEP-PH 0606008;%%
467: 
468: \end{thebibliography}
469: 
470: \end{document}
471: