1: % ads.tex
2: \documentclass[12pt]{article}
3: \input{epsf.sty}
4: %\input{psfig.sty}
5: %\usepackage{color}
6:
7: %\documentstyle[aps,preprint]{revtex}
8: %\documentstyle[12pt,twoside,psfig]{article}
9:
10: \def\mydate{21 Feb 2000}
11: \def\ignore#1{{}}
12:
13: \tolerance=10000
14: \pagenumbering{arabic}
15: \textheight 23.cm
16: \textwidth 16.2 cm
17: \oddsidemargin 0.5cm
18: \evensidemargin 0.5cm
19: \topmargin=-1.cm
20: \hoffset -0.5cm
21:
22:
23: \renewcommand{\baselinestretch}{1.25}
24: \renewcommand{\thetable}{\Roman{table}}
25: \renewcommand{\thefootnote}{\fnsymbol{footnote}}
26: \newcommand{\de}[1]{\mbox{#1$^\circ$}}
27: \newcommand{\lfill}{\hspace*{\fill}\linebreak}
28: \newcommand{\emet}{\it {et al.}}
29: \newcommand{\upri}{u^{\prime}}
30: \newcommand{\wpri}{w^{\prime}}
31:
32: \newcommand{\myhead}{{\normalsize \mytitle \hfill \thepage}}
33:
34: \newcommand{\beeq}{\begin{equation}}
35: \newcommand{\eneq}{\end{equation}}
36: \newcommand{\beqn}{\begin{eqnarray}}
37: \newcommand{\eeqn}{\end{eqnarray}}
38:
39: \def\green#1{{\color{green}#1}}
40: \def\blue#1{{\color{blue}#1}}
41: \def\magenta#1{{\color{magenta}#1}}
42: \def\red#1{{\color{red}#1}}
43:
44: \def\bsize{\displaystyle \strut }
45: \def\mybig{\displaystyle \strut }
46: \def\mbig{\displaystyle }
47: \def\dd{\partial}
48: \def\la{\raise.16ex\hbox{$\langle$}\lower.16ex\hbox{} }
49: \def\ra{\, \raise.16ex\hbox{$\rangle$}\lower.16ex\hbox{} }
50: \def\go{\rightarrow}
51: \def\yield{\Longrightarrow}
52: \def\next{{~~~,~~~}}
53: \def\onehalf{ \hbox{${1\over 2}$} }
54: \def\onethird{ \hbox{${1\over 3}$} }
55: \def\psibar{ \psi \kern-.65em\raise.6em\hbox{$-$} \lower.6em\hbox{} }
56: \def\psibaralpha{ \psi^{(\alpha)} \kern-1.9em\raise.6em\hbox{$-$}
57: \kern+1.2em\hbox{}}
58: \def\psibara{ \psi^{(a)} \kern-1.9em\raise.6em\hbox{$-$}\kern+1.2em\hbox{}}
59:
60: \def\eff{{\rm eff}}
61: \def\vphi{\varphi}
62: \def\ep{\epsilon}
63: \def\hx{\hat x}
64:
65: \def\myfrac#1#2{{\mybig #1\over \mybig #2}}
66: \def\here{\bigskip ****** ~ up to this point. ~ \mydate ~ ****** \bigskip}
67:
68:
69: \def\justbox#1{$\vcenter{\hrule\hbox{\vrule\kern0pt
70: \vbox{\kern0pt\hbox{#1}\kern0pt}\kern0pt\vrule}\hrule}$}
71: \def\boxit#1{$\vcenter{\hrule\hbox{\vrule\kern3pt
72: \vbox{\kern3pt\hbox{#1}\kern3pt}\kern3pt\vrule}\hrule}$}
73: \def\bigbox#1{$\vcenter{\hrule\hbox{\vrule\kern5pt
74: \vbox{\kern5pt\hbox{#1}\kern5pt}\kern5pt\vrule}\hrule}$}
75: \def\Bigbox#1{$\vcenter{\hrule\hbox{\vrule\kern7pt
76: \vbox{\kern7pt\hbox{#1}\kern7pt}\kern7pt\vrule}\hrule}$}
77: \def\hugebox#1{$\vcenter{\hrule\hbox{\vrule\kern9pt
78: \vbox{\kern9pt\hbox{#1}\kern9pt}\kern9pt\vrule}\hrule}$}
79: \def\Hugebox#1{$\vcenter{\hrule\hbox{\vrule\kern20pt
80: \vbox{\kern20pt\hbox{#1}\kern20pt}\kern20pt\vrule}\hrule}$}
81: \def\thinbox#1{$\vcenter{\hrule\hbox{\vrule\kern1pt
82: \vbox{\kern1pt\hbox{#1}\kern1pt}\kern1pt\vrule}\hrule}$}
83: \def\verythinbox#1{$\vcenter{\hrule\hbox{\vrule\kern.2pt
84: \vbox{\kern.2pt\hbox{#1}\kern.2pt}\kern.2pt\vrule}\hrule}$}
85: \def\thickbox#1{\verythinbox{\verythinbox{\verythinbox{\hugebox{#1}}}}}
86:
87:
88:
89: \begin{document}
90:
91: \thispagestyle{empty}
92:
93:
94: \baselineskip=16pt plus 1pt minus 1pt
95:
96: \vskip 3cm
97:
98: \begin{center}
99:
100:
101: {\Large\bf Solitons in the false vacuum\footnote{\it To appear in
102: the Proceedings of the YITP workshop ``Fundamental Problems and
103: Applications of Quantum Field Theory'', Kyoto, December 20 - 22,
104: 2000.}}\\
105:
106:
107: \vspace{.5cm}
108:
109: {\large Yutaka Hosotani}\\
110: \vspace{.1cm}
111: {\it \small Department of Physics, Osaka University, Toyonaka, Osaka
112: 560-0043}\\
113: \end{center}
114:
115: %\vskip .2cm
116:
117: \begin{abstract}
118: \small
119: \baselineskip=12pt
120: When a potential for a scalar field has two local minima , there arises
121: structure of spherical shells due to gravitational interactions.
122: \end{abstract}
123:
124: \vskip .2cm
125:
126:
127: \baselineskip=14pt plus 1pt minus 1pt
128:
129:
130: Gravitational interactions, inherently attractive for ordinary
131: matter, can produce soliton-like objects even when such things
132: are strictly forbidden in flat space. They become possible as
133: a consequence of the balance between repulsive and attractive forces.
134: One such example is a monopole or dyon solution in the pure
135: Einstein-Yang-Mills theory in the asymptotically anti-de Sitter
136: space.\cite{Hosotani1} In this talk I report a new shell
137: structure in a simple real scalar field theory.
138:
139: In a scalar field theory given by
140: \beeq
141: {\cal L} =
142: {1\over 16\pi G} ~ R
143: + {1\over 2} \phi_{;\mu} \phi^{;\mu} - V[\phi]
144: \eneq
145: we seek a static, spherically symmetric spacetime for which
146: the metric can be written as
147: \beeq
148: ds^2 =
149: \frac{H(r)}{p^2(r)}dt^2 - \frac{dr^2}{H(r)} -r^2 d\Omega^2 ~.
150: \label{metric1}
151: \eneq
152: We suppose that the potential $V(\phi)$ has
153: two minima at $f_1$ and $f_2$ separated by a barrier. Einstein equations
154: and matter equation reduce to
155: \beqn
156: &&\hskip -.8cm
157: \phi''(r) + \Gamma_\eff (r) \phi'(r) = {1\over H} ~ V'[\phi]
158: ~~,~~ \Gamma_\eff= {2\over r} + 4\pi G r \phi'^2 + {H'\over H} ~~,
159: \label{matter1} \\
160: &&\hskip -.8cm
161: H = 1 - {2GM\over r}
162: ~~,~~
163: M(r) =\int_0^r 4\pi r^2 dr \, \left\{ {1\over 2} H \phi'^2
164: +V[\phi] \right\} ~~.
165: \label{metric2}
166: \eeqn
167:
168: \vskip .5cm
169:
170: \noindent
171: \bigbox{I. ~False vacuum black hole}
172: \vskip .3cm
173:
174: Suppose that $V(f_1) = \ep >0$ and $V(f_2) =0$. See figure 1(a).
175: $\phi= f_1$ and
176: $\phi= f_2$ correspond to the false and true vacuum, respectively. If the
177: universe is in the false vacuum, a bubble of the true vacuum is created
178: by quantum tunneling which expands with accelerated velocity. The
179: configuration is called a bounce.\cite{Coleman} The bounce is
180: a Minkowski bubble in de Sitter.
181:
182: Let us flip the configuration.\cite{Hosotani2} The universe is in the
183: true vacuum and the inside of a sphere is excited to the false vacuum.
184: Is such a de Sitter lump in Minkowski possible? If the lump is too
185: small, then it would be totally unstable. The energy localized inside
186: the lump can dissipate to space infinity. If the lump is big enough,
187: the Schwarzschild radius becomes larger than the lump radius, i.e.\
188: the lump is inside a black hole. The energy cannot escape to infinity.
189: It looks like a soliton in the Minkowski space. However, as being
190: a black hole, it is a dynamic object. The configuration is
191: essentially time-dependent.
192:
193: The critical configuration of size $R$ carries interesting numbers.
194: The transition region located around $R$ is approximated by a thin wall.
195: The inside is a de Sitter space with $H = 1 - (r/a)^2$, $a^2 = 3/8\pi
196: G \ep$. The outside is described by the Schwarzschild metric with $H
197: = 1-(r_S/r)$, $r_S = 2G M = R^3/a^2$. At the critical radius
198: $R_c=r_S=a=(3/8\pi G \ep)^{1/2}$; the Schwarzschild radius and
199: cosmological horizon coincide. If the energy scale, $\ep^{1/4}$, is
200: at the GUT scale ($10^{15}$GeV), then
201: $R_c \sim 10^{27}\,$m and $M_c \sim 1$ kg.
202: If $\ep^{1/4} \sim 1 \,$GeV, then $R_c \sim 1 \,$km and
203: $M_c \sim 10^5 \cdot M_{\rm sun}$, a typical mass of a black hole
204: located near the center of each galaxy.
205: If $\ep^{1/4} = 2.4\,$meV as suggested from the estimated value of the
206: present cosmological constant, then $R_c \sim 5.5$ Gpc.
207:
208:
209: \vskip .5cm
210:
211: \noindent
212: \bigbox{II. ~Spherical shells}
213: \vskip .3cm
214:
215:
216: The above false-vacuum-black-hole configuration does not solve
217: Eq.\ (\ref{matter1}) at the horizon. Let us look for nontrivial
218: static solutions to Eqs.\ (\ref{matter1}) and (\ref{metric2}) which are
219: regular everywhere. I show that such
220: solutions exist, if the energy scale determined by the scalar
221: potential is sufficinetly small compared with
222: the Planck scale.\cite{Hosotani3,Dymnikova} An explicit
223: example is given when $V(f_1)=\ep > 0$ and $V(f_2)=0$. The latter
224: condition
225: $V(f_2)=0$ can be relaxed.
226:
227:
228:
229: \vskip -1.2cm
230: \begin{figure}[h]
231: \centering \leavevmode
232: \mbox{
233: \epsfxsize=16.cm
234: \epsfbox{figures.eps}}
235: \caption{\baselineskip=10pt
236: Spherical shells in the de Sitter space. (a) Scalar potential.
237: (b) Potential, $U[\phi]=- V[\phi]$, in the particle analogy.
238: (c) $H(r)$ in the metric.
239: (d) Schematic behavior of $\phi(r)$. In the solutions $w/R \ll 1$.}
240: \label{fig1}
241: \end{figure}
242: \vskip .2cm
243:
244: To see how such solutions become possible, we interpret Eq.\
245: (\ref{matter1}) as an equation for a particle with a coordinate
246: $\phi$ and time $r$. Except for a factor $1/H$ a particle
247: is in a potential $U[\phi]=-V[\phi]$. The coefficient $\Gamma_\eff(r)$
248: represents time-dependent friction. We are looking for
249: a solution which starts at $\phi \sim f_1$, moves to $\sim f_2$, and
250: comes back to $f_1$ at $r=\infty$. It is impossible in flat space,
251: as $\Gamma_\eff$ is positive definite so that the particle loses
252: an energy and cannot climb back to the original starting point.
253:
254:
255: In the presence of gravity the situation changes. The non-vanishing
256: energy density can make $H$ decrease as $r$, and $\Gamma_\eff$ can
257: become negative. The lost energy of the particle during the
258: initial rolling can be regained on the return path by `negative
259: friction', or by thrust. Indeed, this happens.
260:
261: The schematic behavior of a solution is displayed in figure 1.
262: Take, as an example, a quartic potential $V[\phi]$ with
263: $|f_1|, |f_2| \sim 10^{-3} M_{\rm pl}$, and
264: $\ep/V_0 \sim 10^{-3}$ where $V_0$ is the barrier hight.
265: In the solution $\phi$ starts at $\sim f_1$ and makes a transition
266: to $\sim f_2$ at $R \sim 10^7 \, l_{\rm pl}$. The transition width
267: is about $w/R \sim 10^{-3}$. [figure 1(d)]~ $H(r)$ in the metric
268: drops at $\sim R$. [figure 1(c)]
269:
270: Why or how can such a configuration become possible? First of all
271: I remark that there is no static regular solution which starts
272: at $\phi(0) \sim f_1$ and ends at $\phi(\infty) = f_2$. In this
273: configuration there is a single transition from one minimum, $f_1$,
274: to the other, $f_2$, or one shell (wall). Such a configuration is
275: unstable. The shell collapses.
276:
277: In the configuration depicted in figure 1, however, $\phi$ makes
278: two transitions; $f_1 \go f_2 \go f_1$. It defines two shells.
279: The energy density between the two shells is higher
280: than $\ep$, which gives rise to an attractive force between the shells.
281: There also is an intrinsic repulsive force between two domain
282: walls.\cite{Vilenkin} Apparently these two forces balance each other
283: out to form static structure. Yet, it is not clear how the
284: configuration is stabilized against shrinkage.
285:
286: The shell structure disappears as the energy scale of the scalar
287: potential becomes larger and approaches the Planck scale. When
288: the energy scale, instead, becomes smaller, a new type of structure
289: with four or six shells emerges.
290:
291: The global structure of the configuration is noteworthy.
292: In the metric of the $R^1 \times S^3$ type, a mirror of
293: shells appear in the other hemisphere of $S^3$. As the universe
294: shrinks and expands, the intrinsic scale of the shells remain
295: constant.
296:
297: Detailed analysis will be given in ref.\ \cite{Hosotani3}.
298:
299:
300: \vskip 1cm
301:
302:
303: % A useful Journal macro
304: \def\jnl#1#2#3#4{{#1}{\bf #2} (#4) #3}
305: %\def\jnl#1#2#3#4{{#1}{\bf #2} #3 (#4)}
306: \def\PRL{\em Phys.\ Rev.\ Lett. }
307: \def\PRB{{\em Phys.\ Rev.} B}
308: \def\PRD{{\em Phys.\ Rev.} D}
309: \def\PLB{{\em Phys.\ Lett.} B}
310:
311:
312: \leftline{\bf References}
313:
314: \renewenvironment{thebibliography}[1]
315: {\begin{list}{[$\,$\arabic{enumi}$\,$]} % {\arabic{enumi}.}
316: {\usecounter{enumi}\setlength{\parsep}{0pt}
317: \setlength{\itemsep}{0pt} \renewcommand{\baselinestretch}{1.2}
318: \settowidth
319: {\labelwidth}{#1 ~ ~}\sloppy}}{\end{list}}
320:
321: \begin{thebibliography}{99}
322: \small
323: \baselineskip=14pt
324:
325: \bibitem{Hosotani1}
326: J.\ Bjoraker and Y.\ Hosotani, \jnl{\PRL}{84}{1853}{2000};
327:
328: J.\ Bjoraker and Y.\ Hosotani, \jnl{\PRD}{62}{43513}{2000};
329:
330: Y.\ Hosotani, gr-qc/0103069.
331:
332: \bibitem{Coleman}
333: % S.\ Coleman, \jnl{\PRD}{15}{2929}{1977};
334: S.\ Coleman and F.\ De Luccia, \jnl{\PRD}{21}{3305}{1980}.
335:
336: \bibitem{Hosotani2}
337: R.G. Daghigh, J.I. Kapusta, and Y. Hosotani, gr-qc/0008006;
338:
339: D.V.\ Gal'tsov and J.P.S.\ Lemos, gr-qc/0008076.
340:
341: \bibitem{Hosotani3}
342: Y. Hosotani and T. Nakajima, in preparation.
343:
344: \bibitem{Dymnikova}
345: I.G.\ Dymnikova, \jnl{\PLB}{472}{33}{2000};
346: gr-qc/0010016.
347:
348: \bibitem{Vilenkin}
349: A.\ Vilenkin, \jnl{\PRD}{23}{852}{1981}.
350:
351:
352: \end{thebibliography}
353: \end{document}
354:
355:
356:
357:
358:
359: