1: %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%% LaTeX twice %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%
2: \documentstyle[12pt]{article}
3:
4: \font\eightrm=cmr8
5:
6: \bibliographystyle{unsrt} %for BibTeX - sorted numerical labels by
7: %order of first citation.
8:
9: \arraycolsep1.5pt
10:
11: % A useful Journal macro
12: \def\Journal#1#2#3#4{{#1} {\bf #2}, #3 (#4)}
13:
14: % Some useful journal names
15: \def\NCA{\em Nuovo Cimento}
16: \def\NIM{\em Nucl. Instrum. Methods}
17: \def\NIMA{{\em Nucl. Instrum. Methods} A}
18: \def\NPB{{\em Nucl. Phys.} B}
19: \def\PLB{{\em Phys. Lett.} B}
20: \def\PRL{\em Phys. Rev. Lett.}
21: \def\PRD{{\em Phys. Rev.} D}
22: \def\ZPC{{\em Z. Phys.} C}
23:
24: % Some other macros used in the sample text
25: \def\st{\scriptstyle}
26: \def\sst{\scriptscriptstyle}
27: \def\mco{\multicolumn}
28: \def\epp{\epsilon^{\prime}}
29: \def\vep{\varepsilon}
30: \def\ra{\rightarrow}
31: \def\ppg{\pi^+\pi^-\gamma}
32: \def\vp{{\bf p}}
33: \def\ko{K^0}
34: \def\kb{\bar{K^0}}
35: \def\al{\alpha}
36: \def\ab{\bar{\alpha}}
37: \def\be{\begin{equation}}
38: \def\ee{\end{equation}}
39: \def\bea{\begin{eqnarray}}
40: \def\eea{\end{eqnarray}}
41: \def\CPbar{\hbox{{\rm CP}\hskip-1.80em{/}}}%temp replacemt due to no font
42:
43: %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%
44: %%BEGINNING OF TEXT
45: %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%
46:
47: \begin{document}
48:
49: \centerline{\bf SYMMETRIES AND STAGGERING EFFECTS}
50:
51: \centerline{\bf IN NUCLEAR ROTATIONAL SPECTRA}
52:
53: \bigskip
54: \centerline{NIKOLAY MINKOV, S. B. DRENSKA, P. P. RAYCHEV, R. P. ROUSSEV}
55:
56: \centerline{Institute for Nuclear Research and Nuclear Energy}
57:
58: \centerline{72 Tzarigrad Road, 1784 Sofia, Bulgaria}
59:
60: \medskip
61: \centerline{DENNIS BONATSOS}
62:
63: \centerline{Institute of Nuclear Physics, N.C.S.R. ``Demokritos''}
64:
65: \centerline{GR-15310 Aghia Paraskevi, Attiki, Greece}
66:
67: \bigskip
68:
69: \centerline{\bf Abstract}
70:
71: We study the fine structure of nuclear
72: rotational spectra on the basis of both dynamical and discrete
73: symmetry approaches. In this framework we show that the odd--even
74: ($\Delta I=1$) staggering effects observed in various rotational
75: bands carry detailed information about the collective band-mixing
76: interactions and the collective shape properties of heavy nuclei.
77:
78: \section{Introduction}
79:
80: The odd--even staggering effect is known as a zigzagging behavior
81: of the nuclear inertial parameter between the odd and the even
82: angular momentum states of a rotational band. It due to a
83: relative displacement of the odd angular momentum levels with
84: respect to the even ones \cite{BM75}. The analysis and the
85: interpretation of this effect are of current interest since it
86: carries detailed information about the fine properties of nuclear
87: collective dynamics in different regions of nuclear chart.
88:
89: We study the odd--even staggering effects in nuclear spectra in
90: terms of an appropriately defined quantity
91: \begin{equation}
92: \mbox{Stg}(I)= 6\Delta E(I)-4\Delta E(I-1)-4\Delta E(I+1)+ \Delta
93: E(I+2)+\Delta E(I-2) \ , \label{stag}
94: \end{equation}
95: which is the discrete approximation of the fourth derivative of
96: the function $\Delta E(I)=E(I+1)-E(I)$, i.e. the fifth derivative
97: of the rotational band energy $E(I)$. In the present paper it
98: will be shown that the above quantity is very sensitive to the
99: fine structure of rotational spectra and provides spectacular
100: $\Delta I=1$ staggering patterns (zigzagging behavior of the
101: function $Stg(I)$ with clearly defined zero reference) in various
102: rotational bands. On this basis we propose relevant theoretical
103: analysis of the $\Delta I=1$ staggering effects in collective
104: $\gamma$ rotational bands and nuclear octupole bands in reference
105: to the underlying symmetries of nuclear collective interactions.
106:
107: \section{SU(3) dynamical symmetry and
108: $\Delta I =1$ staggering in heavy deformed nuclei}
109:
110: We have found \cite{MDRRB00} that Eq.~(\ref{stag}) provides well
111: developed staggering patterns in the $\gamma$ bands of the nuclei
112: $^{156}$Gd, $^{156,160,162}$Dy, $^{162-166}$Er, $^{170}$Yb and
113: $^{228,232}$Th. We demonstrated that the observed effect can be
114: interpreted as the result of the interaction of the $\gamma$ band
115: with the ground band in the framework of a Vector Boson Model
116: with SU(3) dynamical symmetry \cite{MDRRBSU3}. In this model the
117: two bands are coupled into the same SU(3) multiplet, which
118: provides the following $\gamma$- band energy expression
119: \cite{MDRRB00}:
120: \begin{eqnarray}
121: E^{\gamma}(I)&=&2B+AI(I+1)
122: +B[\sqrt{1+aI(I+1)+bI^{2}(I+1)^{2}} \nonumber \\
123: &-&\left. CI(I+1)-1\right] \left(\frac{1+(-1)^I}{2}\right) \ ,
124: \label{Egamma}
125: \end{eqnarray}
126: where the quantities $A$, $B$, $C$ , $a$ and $b$ are determined by
127: the effective model interaction. Eq.~(\ref{Egamma}) reproduces
128: successfully the $\Delta I =1$ effect in all considered nuclei. In
129: Fig. 1(a) the experimental and the theoretical staggering patterns
130: obtained for the $\gamma$ band of $^{166}$Er are illustrated.
131:
132: Our theoretical analysis of the staggering patterns observed in
133: rare earth nuclei provide detailed information about the fine
134: behavior of the ground--$\gamma$ band mixing interaction in
135: dependence on the nuclear shell structure in rotational regions.
136: In addition, it suggests a detailed test and relevant comparison
137: of the different kinds of dynamical symmetry schemes.
138:
139: \section{Octahedron point symmetry and $\Delta I =1$ staggering
140: in octupole bands}
141:
142: We propose a study of the fine structure of collective rotational
143: bands with a presence of octupole degrees of freedom through the
144: formalism of the octahedron $(O)$ point symmetry group. Based on
145: the irreducible representations (irreps) of this group
146: \cite{Ham91}, we have constructed a collective Hamiltonian of a
147: system with octupole correlations: $
148: \hat{H}_{oct}=\hat{H}_{A_{2}}+
149: \sum_{r=1}^{2}\sum_{i=1}^{3}\hat{H}_{F_{r}(i)}$ with
150: \begin{eqnarray}
151: \hat{H}_{A_{2}}&=&{a}_{2}\frac{1}{4}
152: [(\hat{I}_x\hat{I}_y+\hat{I}_y\hat{I}_x)\hat{I}_z+
153: \hat{I}_z(\hat{I}_x\hat{I}_y+\hat{I}_y\hat{I}_x)] \ ,
154: \label{HA} \\
155: \hat{H}_{F_{1}(1)}&=&\frac{1}{2}{f}_{11}
156: \hat{I}_z(5\hat{I}_z^{2}-3\hat{I}^{2}) \ ,
157: \label{HF11} \\
158: \hat{H}_{F_{1}(2)}&=&\frac{1}{2}{f}_{12}
159: (5\hat{I}_x^{3}-3\hat{I}_x\hat{I}^{2}) \ ,
160: \label{HF12} \\
161: \hat{H}_{F_{1}(3)}&=&\frac{1}{2}{f}_{13}
162: (5\hat{I}_y^{3}-3\hat{I}_y\hat{I}^{2}) \ ,
163: \label{HF13} \\
164: \hat{H}_{F_{2}(1)}&=&{f}_{21}\frac{1}{2}
165: [\hat{I}_z(\hat{I}_x^{2}-\hat{I}_y^{2})+
166: (\hat{I}_x^{2}-\hat{I}_y^{2})\hat{I}_z] \ ,
167: \label{HF21} \\
168: \hat{H}_{F_2(2)}&=&{f}_{22} (\hat{I}_x\hat{I}^{2}-\hat{I}_x^{3}-
169: \hat{I}_x\hat{I}_z^{2}-\hat{I}_z^{2}\hat{I}_x) \ ,
170: \label{HF22} \\
171: \hat{H}_{F_2(3)}&=&{f}_{23}
172: (\hat{I}_y\hat{I}_z^{2}+\hat{I}_z^{2}\hat{I}_y+
173: \hat{I}_y^{3}-\hat{I}_y\hat{I}^{2})\ . \label{HF23}
174: \end{eqnarray}
175: Here, the first term $\hat{H}_{A_{2}}$ belongs to the
176: one-dimensional irrep $A_{2}$ of the octahedron group $O$, while
177: the terms $\hat{H}_{F_{1}(i)}$ and $\hat{H}_{F_{2}(i)}$ ($i=1$,
178: 2, 3) belong to its three-dimensional irreps $F_{1}$ and $F_{2}$
179: respectively, with ${a}_{2}$ and ${f}_{r\, i}$ ($r=1,2$;
180: $i=1,2,3$) being the Hamiltonian parameters.
181:
182: After taking into account the simultaneous presence of quadrupole
183: degrees of freedom as well as the high order quadrupole--octupole
184: interaction we applied the above Hamiltonian to obtain the
185: rotational spectrum of the system by minimizing subsequently its
186: energy with respect to the third angular momentum projection $K$
187: for each given value of the angular momentum $I$.
188:
189: We found that the so obtained energy bands after being used in
190: Eq.~(\ref{stag}) exhibit various staggering patterns in dependence
191: on the model parameters. Several schematic examples are
192: demonstrated in Fig.~1(b)-(d). On this basis we suppose that the
193: model can be applied to reproduce the staggering effects in
194: nuclear octupole bands \cite{DBoct00} as well as in some
195: rotational negative parity bands built on octupole vibrations .
196:
197: \section{Conclusion}
198:
199: The approaches suggested give a rather general prescription for
200: analysis of various fine characteristics of rotational motion in
201: quantum mechanical systems. They allow a detailed comparison of
202: the effects of the collective interactions and shapes in
203: different regions of nuclei. We propose a systematic study of the
204: symmetries associated with these effects and suggest that it
205: could provide a relevant guide in the revealing of some general
206: properties of collective motion in the less studied regions, such
207: as the exotic nuclei.
208:
209: \section*{Acknowledgments}
210:
211: This work has been supported by BNSF contract no MU--F--02/98.
212:
213: %Bulgarian National Fund for Scientific Research under contract no
214: %MU--F--02/98.
215:
216: %\section*{References}
217:
218: \begin{thebibliography}{99}
219: \bibitem{BM75} A. Bohr and B. R. Mottelson, {\it Nuclear
220: Stucture} vol. II (Benjamin, New York, 1975).
221:
222: \bibitem{MDRRB00} N. Minkov, S. Drenska, P. Raychev, R. Roussev and
223: D. Bonatsos, Phys. Rev. C, {\bf 61}, 064301 (2000).
224:
225: \bibitem{MDRRBSU3} N. Minkov, S. Drenska, P. Raychev, R. Roussev
226: and D. Bonatsos, Phys. Rev. C {\bf 55}, 2345 (1997); Phys.
227: Rev. C {\bf 60}, 034305 (1999).
228:
229: \bibitem{Ham91} I. Hamamoto, X. Z. Zhang and H. Xie, Phys. Lett. B
230: {\bf 257}, 1 (1991).
231:
232: \bibitem{DBoct00}
233: D. Bonatsos, C. Daskaloyannis, S. B. Drenska, N. Karoussos, N.
234: Minkov, P. P. Raychev and R. P. Roussev, Phys. Rev. C (2000) in
235: press.
236:
237: \end{thebibliography}
238:
239: \bigskip\bigskip
240:
241: \centerline{\bf Figure captions}
242:
243: {\bf Fig. 1} $\Delta I =1$
244: staggering patterns: (a)for the $\gamma$ band of $^{166}$Er
245: (theory and experiment); (b)--(d) for the schematic spectra
246: obtained by the octahedron Hamiltonian
247: [Eqs~(\protect\ref{HA})--(\protect\ref{HF23}), theory].
248:
249: \end{document}
250:
251: