1: %\documentclass[aps,prc,preprint,showpacs,nobibnotes,final]{revtex}
2: \documentclass[12pt]{article}
3: \usepackage{graphicx}
4: %\documentclass{elsart}
5: %\usepackage{graphicx}
6: %\usepackage{bm}
7: \textwidth 16.cm
8: \textheight 23.2cm
9: \leftmargin -2.5cm
10: \evensidemargin .0cm
11: \oddsidemargin .0cm
12: \topmargin -2.cm
13: %\hoffset -1.5cm
14: %\documentstyle[prc,preprint,aps,epsfig]{revtex}
15: \begin{document}
16: \bibliographystyle{num}
17: \baselineskip=1.5 \baselineskip
18: %\draft
19: \title{Short-range correlations in asymmetric nuclear matter}
20: \baselineskip=1. \baselineskip
21:
22: %\author[INP]{Piotr Bo\.zek}
23: %\address[INP]{Institute of Nuclear Physics, \\
24: % Polish Academy of Sciences, PL-31342 Krak\'ow, Poland}
25: \author{ P. Bo\.{z}ek\footnote{Electronic
26: address~:
27: piotr.bozek@ifj.edu.pl}\\
28: Institute of Nuclear Physics Polish Academy of Sciences,\\
29: PL-31-342 Cracow, Poland}
30:
31: \date{\today}
32:
33: \maketitle
34:
35:
36: \vskip .3cm
37:
38: %\keywords
39:
40:
41: \vskip .3cm
42:
43: \begin{abstract}
44: The spectral function of protons in the asymmetric nuclear matter is
45: calculated
46: in the self-consistent $T$-matrix approach. The spectral function
47: {\it per proton} increases with increasing asymmetry.
48: This effect and the density
49: dependence of the spectral function partially
50: explain the observed
51: increase of the spectral function with the mass number of the target
52: nuclei
53: in electron scattering experiments.
54: %{ Keywords :}{sum rules, vertex corrections, nuclear matter}
55: %Nuclear matter, superfluidity, spectral function}
56: \end{abstract}
57:
58: %\keywords{ {superfluidity, nuclear matter% saturation point, thermodynamic properties,}
59: {short-range correlations, electron scattering, spectral function}
60: \vskip .4cm
61:
62: %\pacs
63: {\bf 21.65.+f, 24.10.Cn, 25.30.-c}
64:
65: \vskip .4cm
66:
67:
68:
69: The hard core in the free nucleon-nucleon potential induces strong
70: short-range correlations in the
71: nuclear medium. The inclusion of these
72: correlations in the modeling of the nuclear medium is crucial
73: \cite{brugam}.
74: Variational \cite{vcs1,vcs2,fabrocini}, Brueckner-Hartree-Fock
75: \cite{EOSBHF,Mahaux,jlm,bhf,Baldoetal92}, and self-consistent $T$-matrix
76: \cite{Dickhoff:1999yi,Bozek:1998su,Dewulf:2003nj,Frick:2003sd} nuclear matter
77: calculations
78: take this effect into account. As a result of the
79: scattering in the medium nucleonic excitations get dressed.
80: A measure of such medium modifications
81: is given by the spectral
82: function, which can be observed in electron scattering experiments. The
83: extraction of the spectral function is relatively straightforward in the
84: Plane Wave Impulse Approximation but important final state
85: rescattering effects complicate the analysis.
86: The knowledge of the spectral function
87: sheds light on the origin of the nuclear binding energy
88: \cite{Bozek:2001tz}
89: and gives the
90: nucleon momentum distribution.
91:
92:
93:
94:
95: Several calculation of the spectral function exists,
96: both for finite systems \cite{benharfinite,gfmuther} and for nuclear
97: matter \cite{fabrocini1,Baldoetal92,fabrocini,Baldo:2001ec,Bozek:2002em}.
98: At high momentum and high removal energy the spectral function is
99: dominated by short-range correlations which can be studied in
100: the homogeneous nuclear matter. Existing calculations
101: are restricted to symmetric or pure neutron nuclear matter. On the
102: other hand electron scattering experiments are performed on nuclei
103: with a range of values of the neutron to proton ratio $N/Z$.
104: The scaled spectral
105: function,
106: i.e. the spectral function divided
107: by the number of protons, was compared for different nuclei and
108: a significant increase with the mass number was observed \cite{rohe}.
109: This is interpreted as an indication of strong short-range correlations due to
110: neutron-proton scattering which populates the spectral function at
111: high removal energy \cite{ryckebush}.
112: In this work we present the first calculation of the proton spectral
113: function in the asymmetric nuclear matter. We discuss the effect of
114: the $N/Z$ ratio on the
115: scaled spectral function for different atomic number of the
116: target nuclei.
117:
118: The calculation is performed in the self-consistent $T$-matrix
119: \cite{KadanoffBaym}
120: approach using fermion propagators dressed in the self-consistent
121: self-energy. The scheme is thermodynamically consistent and the
122: obtained single particle properties, i.e. the self-energy and the spectral
123: function are consistent with the global properties such as the
124: binding energy \cite{Bozek:2001tz}. In the Brueckner approach the
125: spectral function can be reliably calculated only after inclusion of
126: the rearrangement terms \cite{Baldo:2001ec}.
127: The self-consistent in medium $T$-matrix
128: \cite{di1,Bozek:1998su,Dickhoff:1999yi,Dewulf:2000jg,Bozek:2001tz} is
129: \begin{equation}
130: T=V+ VGGT
131: \end{equation}
132: where the Green's functions $G^{-1}= {\omega-p^2/2m -\Sigma}$
133: in the ladder propagator
134: are dressed
135: by the self-consistent self-energy
136: \begin{equation}
137: i\Sigma= Tr[TG] \ .
138: \end{equation}
139: The details of the calculation can be found in Refs.
140: \cite{Bozek:2002em,Bozek:2002tz}.
141: The same retarded self-energy $\Sigma$ is used to construct the
142: spectral function
143: \begin{eqnarray}
144: A(p,\omega)&=&-2 {\rm Im} G(p,\omega) \nonumber \\
145: &=&\frac{-2{\rm Im}\Sigma(p,\omega)}{
146: (\omega-p^2/2 m-{\rm Re} \Sigma(p,\omega)+\mu)^2+{\rm Im}
147: \Sigma(p,\omega)^2 } \ .
148: \label{normalspec}
149: \end{eqnarray}
150: The calculation is done for a range of densities
151: and asymmetries
152: % between $0.2$ and $1$
153: %normal nuclear density $\rho_0=0.16$fm$^{-3}$
154: using the CD-Bonn
155: potential.
156: %The neutron-proton
157: %asymmetry ranges from $Z/N=1$ to $0.7$.
158: The hole spectral function $A^h(p,E)=A(p,-E)$ is shown in Fig.
159: \ref{specas} as a function of the missing energy for several values of
160: the momentum. The spectral function at normal nuclear
161: density is presented for a symmetric nuclear matter and for
162: $Z/N=0.7$. The proton spectral function
163: is larger for the symmetric nuclear matter,
164: % which is not surprising
165: %since the proton density is a factor $1.25$ larger.
166: but at large
167: missing energy the two curves almost coincide.
168: Since in the asymmetric medium a lower number of p-p collisions is
169: compensated by a more frequent n-p collisions contribution,
170: tensor interaction would
171: lead to a higher scattering rate for high momentum on-shell protons in
172: the asymmetric medium. A far off-shell proton however is
173: scattered in a similar manner in the symmetric and
174: asymmetric nuclear matter. In fact $|Im \Sigma(p,\omega)|$ for protons
175: far off-shell ($\omega<\mu$, $p>p_F$)
176: is even slightly smaller in the asymmetric than in
177: the symmetric nuclear matter. Far off-shell the
178: value of the
179: spectral function is determined by the imaginary part of the self-energy in
180: the numerator of Eq. \ref{normalspec}, and leads to almost no
181: variation of the hole spectral function with asymmetry.
182: Only for energies closer to the quasi-particle
183: pole ($p>p_F$, $\omega>\mu$) is the scattering of protons larger in the
184: asymmetric nuclear matter, giving a higher on shell width for high
185: momentum protons in the neutron rich nuclear matter.
186:
187: When comparing different proton densities in the asymmetric nuclear matter
188: the scaled
189: spectral function $\frac{N+Z}{2Z} A^h(p,\omega)$ is used, which is a
190: measure of the spectral function per proton.
191: We see that the high energy
192: and
193: high momentum part of the scaled hole spectral function is larger in the
194: asymmetric nuclear matter. The increase of the far off-shell
195: correlations { per proton} compensates the slight decrease of the proton
196: off-shell scattering rate.
197:
198: The real-part of the self-energy and the quasiparticle poles
199: depend on the neutron to proton ratio.
200: Accordingly the proton Fermi momentum depends on the proton density,
201: which changes with the proton content. In Fig. \ref{nk} is plotted the
202: proton momentum distribution
203: \begin{equation}
204: n(p)=\int \frac{d E}{2\pi} A^h(p,E) \ .
205: \end{equation}
206: in nuclear matter at normal density for
207: different $Z/N$ ratios. The depletion of the occupation number inside the
208: Fermi sphere and the high momentum component in the distribution are
209: given by short-range correlations in the medium. These effects to
210: within a few percent are the same for the proton to neutron ratio changing
211: from $1$ to $0.7$. The change in the proton density with asymmetry
212: is accommodated by a
213: shift in the proton Fermi momentum.
214:
215: Experiments with electron scattering on finite nuclei are available
216: for several
217: target masses (C, Al, Fe and Au) \cite{rohe}. A strong dependence on the
218: target of the scaled proton spectral function
219: was interpreted partly as a signal
220: of strong p-n correlations. The increase of the off-shell hole
221: spectral function per proton when going from C to Au target is about a
222: factor $2$.
223: % in the region outside of the quasiparticle peak or the
224: % region where $\Delta$ contributes.
225: The spectral function at high missing energy and momentum can be
226: calculated using
227: the local density approximation
228: \begin{equation}
229: S(p,E)=\frac{2}{(2\pi)^4}\int d^3 r A^h(p,E,\rho(r)) \ .
230: \end{equation}
231: In Fig. \ref{sp} is plotted the spectral function divided by the
232: number of protons for several nuclei. The spectral function depends on
233: the mass number of the target. Part of the increase of the spectral
234: function at high missing energy is due to the different proton to
235: neutron ratio. We have
236: \begin{equation}
237: S(p,E) \propto {\rm Volume} \ A_h(p,E) =\frac{Z}{\bar
238: {\rho}_p}
239: A_h(p,E)
240: \end{equation}
241: where $\bar{\rho}_p$ is the mean proton density.
242: The scaled spectral function is
243: \begin{equation}
244: \label{ssca}
245: \frac{S(p,E)}{Z} \propto \frac{1}{\bar
246: {\rho}_p}A_h(p,E) = \frac{1}{\bar{\rho}} \frac{N+Z}{Z} A_h(p,E) \ .
247: \end{equation}
248: Since the hole spectral functions $A_h(p,E)$ at different proton
249: densities are
250: very similar in the considered region of energy and momentum
251: (Fig. \ref{specas}) we see from Eq. \ref{ssca} that the scaled proton
252: spectral function $S(p,E)/Z$ increases with the asymmetry for nuclei with
253: the same average density $\bar{\rho}$.
254: This effect however is not sufficient to explain quantitatively the
255: observed dependence on the
256: target mass.
257:
258: The upper curves in
259: Fig. \ref{sp} are the spectral functions without dividing by
260: $Z$, i.e. the lower curves multiplied by $12 Z/A$. In a homogeneous
261: matter this rescaling should bring the curves back onto each other as
262: in Fig \ref{specas}. The remaining difference visible in
263: Fig. \ref{sp}
264: is due to the density
265: dependence of the spectral function. Heavier nuclei have a larger
266: mean density which gives rise to stronger short-range correlations.
267: %In fact the proton to neutron ratio is almost the same in Al and C nuclei.
268: Qualitatively the same effect is seen in the data \cite{rohe}, but
269: the strongest increase of the proton spectral function happens between
270: Fe and Au targets, and the effect is much more pronounced, especially
271: in the region where the $\Delta$ resonance starts to be visible.
272:
273:
274:
275:
276: The proton spectral function in the asymmetric nuclear matter is
277: calculated. In the far off-shell region the spectral function does
278: not depend strongly on the proton-neutron asymmetry. It means that the
279: spectral function scaled by the proton number is approximately
280: inversely proportional to the proton density (\ref{ssca}).
281: This effect together with
282: density dependence of the spectral function leads to an increase of
283: the scaled proton spectral function with increasing mass number of
284: the target. The experimentally observed increase of the spectral
285: function for heavy target nuclei is stronger than our estimate, especially for
286: the case of gold. Larger
287: frequency of neutron-proton interactions in asymmetric matter
288: leads to a stronger
289: scattering of proton excitation on-shell, but
290: in the off-shell region ($p>p_F$, $\omega<\mu$) we
291: find that the scattering width $2|Im\Sigma(p,\omega)|$ decreases
292: slightly with the asymmetry.
293:
294:
295:
296:
297:
298:
299:
300: {\bf Acknowledgments}
301: \vskip .3cm
302: This work was partly supported by the KBN
303: under Grant No. 2P03B05925. The author thanks the organizers of the
304: ECT$^\star$ Workshop on ``Contributions of Short and Long-range
305: correlations
306: to Nuclear Binding and Saturation'' in Trento for a fruitful
307: atmosphere and Daniela Rohe for an illuminating discussion.
308:
309: \bibliography{../mojbib}
310:
311:
312: %\newpage
313:
314: \begin{figure}
315: \centering
316: \includegraphics*[width=0.95\textwidth]{specas.eps}
317: \caption{The hole spectral function in the asymmetric nuclear matter at
318: normal nuclear density. The lines correspond from top to bottom to
319: $p=255, 330, 410, 500, 570, 650$ MeV. The solid lines are for $N=Z$ and
320: the dashed lines for $Z/N=0.7$. The dotted lines denote the proton
321: spectral function scaled by the mass number
322: to proton ratio $\frac{N+Z}{2Z}$, giving a
323: measure of the occupancy at a missing energy and momentum {\it per proton}.}
324: \label{specas}
325: \end{figure}
326:
327: \begin{figure}
328: \centering
329: \includegraphics*[width=0.5\textwidth]{nk.eps}
330: \caption{The momentum distribution of protons in the nuclear matter at
331: normal density. The solid line is for $N=Z$ and
332: the dashed line for $Z/N=0.7$ }
333: \label{nk}
334: \end{figure}
335:
336: \begin{figure}
337: \centering
338: \includegraphics*[width=0.95\textwidth]{spec.eps}
339: \caption{The hole spectral function scaled by the number of protons for
340: Au, Fe, Al and C nuclei; solid, dashed, dotted, and dashed-dotted lines,
341: respectively (lower curves). The upper curves are multiplied by $\frac{12
342: Z}{A}$. The points represent the data from Ref. \cite{rohe} in the
343: region below the $\Delta$ resonance.}
344:
345: \label{sp}
346: \end{figure}
347:
348:
349:
350:
351:
352: \end{document}
353:
354:
355:
356:
357:
358:
359:
360:
361:
362:
363:
364:
365:
366:
367:
368:
369:
370:
371:
372:
373:
374:
375:
376:
377: