1:
2:
3: \documentclass[twocolumn,10pt]{article}
4: \setlength{\paperwidth}{8.5in}
5: \setlength{\textwidth}{7in}
6:
7: \setlength{\paperheight}{11in}
8: \setlength{\textheight}{9in}
9: \setlength{\topmargin}{-0.21in}
10:
11: \setlength{\oddsidemargin}{6mm}
12: \setlength{\evensidemargin}{6mm}
13:
14: \setlength{\columnsep}{0.54in}
15: \hoffset=-1.5cm
16:
17:
18:
19: \usepackage{amssymb,color,graphicx}
20:
21:
22:
23:
24:
25: \begin{document}
26:
27:
28: \twocolumn[
29: \begin{center}
30: {\large \textbf{IS PSEUDOSCIENCE THE SOLUTION TO SCIENCE LITERACY?}}\\
31:
32: \vspace{5mm}
33:
34: C.J. Efthimiou
35: and
36: R.A. Llewellyn\\
37: Physics Department\\
38: University of Central Florida\\
39: Orlando, FL 32816
40: \end{center}
41: ]
42:
43:
44: \begin{abstract}
45: In EISTA03 the authors described an ambitious project they have
46: embarked upon at the University of Central Florida to help improve
47: public understanding of the basic principles of physical science,
48: topics often included in the general education program at many
49: colleges and universities. After the pilot course was very
50: successful, the authors were motivated to work harder on the
51: course and explore new directions. They thus decided to create
52: versions of the course, nicknamed flavors, whereby each flavor
53: used a particular genre or theme of movies: Action/Adventure,
54: SciFi, Modern Physics, Superheroes, Astronomy, Pseudoscience.
55:
56: Among all flavors, the Pseudoscience flavor was especially praised
57: by the students. Contrary to passive attendance in the traditional
58: course, the class was full of passionate discussions driven by
59: scenes in popular movies such as \textsf{Sixth Sense}, \textsf{The
60: Others}, and \textsf{Dragonfly}. Almost every single person in the
61: class (of 90 students) would participate in the discussions and
62: defend his/her positions. These discussions often were passionate
63: and quite `heated'. Eventually, scientific analysis was presented
64: by the instructors who always maintained a skeptic attitude on any
65: extraordinary topic requiring extraordinary proof, thus explaining
66: how the scientific method works and what is acceptable and what
67: unacceptable in science. Amazingly, a fraction of the students
68: (not always the same students in all topics) did not always agree
69: with the rational explanations; often their decisions were
70: influenced by personal fears and biases or emotions. Their
71: thinking at times revealed the introduction of arbitrary
72: assumptions and acceptance of anecdotal statements.
73:
74: Many reasons have been put forward by scientists why they do not
75: want to be involved in a fight against Pseudoscience. For example:
76: pseudoscientific beliefs are irrational and therefore it is
77: impossible to fight them with rational arguments; by even agreeing
78: to discuss Pseudoscience we accept it as an established
79: discipline; Pseudoscience is a background noise that does not harm
80: science. All these (and many other) reasons may contain pieces of
81: the truth, but they are not necessarily true. However,
82: Pseudoscience posses a continuous and, in fact, increasing threat
83: to our society. It is impossible to estimate exactly the
84: irreversible harm that will do in the future. It is the
85: scientists' duty to act now to eliminate or, at least, contain
86: this danger. Therefore, in a time when the science literacy of the
87: public has declined and the threat of pseudoscience has increased,
88: revising the traditional science course to present science through
89: the window of Pseudoscience might offer not only a way to restore
90: science literacy, but also a way to help society by eliminating
91: misconceptions and attacking growing trends (astrology, remote
92: viewing, psychic readings, etc) that might harm (financially or
93: otherwise) innocent and trusting citizens.
94: \end{abstract}
95:
96:
97: {\small \textbf{Keywords:} Physics, Physical Science, Films,
98: General Education, Science Literacy, Pseudoscience, Multimedia}
99:
100:
101:
102:
103:
104: \section{\textsf{Physics in Films}}
105:
106: In \cite{EL} the authors have described an ambitious project
107: embarked upon at the University of Central Florida to help improve
108: public understanding of the basic principles of physical science,
109: topics often included in the general education program at many
110: colleges and universities. The project is built around the use of
111: a wide range of popular films to illustrate and serve as the basis
112: for discussions of physical science concepts. One or two brief
113: clips are shown each day, augmented by live demonstrations and
114: other visual aids. (The complete films are viewed by the students
115: at home as a part of their homework.) While still a young project
116: (about 24 months old at this writing), it quickly became a success
117: \cite{success} and a topic of student conversation
118: \cite{UCFFuture}.
119:
120:
121:
122:
123:
124: Student interest and performance in the \textsf{Physical Science}
125: course have both increased dramatically compared with the
126: traditional teaching mode, which we still use in some sections.
127:
128:
129:
130:
131: %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%
132: \section{The Idea of Flavors}
133:
134: After the pilot course was very successfully tested in four
135: sections (with total enrollment of 800 students), the authors were
136: motivated to develop the course further and to explore new
137: directions. The original pilot course included movies that were
138: selected to span the entire topical range of the standard Physical
139: Science course. In the selection of the movies no attention was
140: paid to the genre or the theme of the movie; eventually all the
141: movies used were action, adventure, and science fiction films.
142: Encouraged by the enthusiasm of the students, the authors decided
143: to take the project to the next level by considering possible
144: extensions of the course that would accommodate the curiosity of
145: every student and would satisfy the needs of every instructor.
146: Thus, we decided to create versions (packages)---nicknamed
147: \textit{flavors}---of the course whereby each flavor used a
148: particular genre or theme of movies. As a result, plans were
149: developed to create the following flavors, each using a different
150: film genre:
151: \begin{itemize}
152: \item {\bfseries Action/Adventure} that would use action and adventure
153: movies;
154: \item {\bfseries SciFi} -- science fiction movies;
155: \item {\bfseries Superhero} -- superhero movies;
156: \item {\bfseries Modern Physics}-- movies that enable the teaching of topics from Modern Physics;
157: \item {\bfseries Astronomy} -- movies that contain
158: topics related to astronomy;
159: \item {\bfseries Pseudoscience} -- movies that
160: include pseudoscientific topics;
161: \item {\bfseries Metaphysics} -- movies that touch on
162: questions of metaphysical content.
163: \end{itemize}
164: The reader will immediately recognize the instructors’ intent to
165: break out of the traditional constraints and to teach the concepts
166: of \textsf{Physical Science} using media aids and illustrative
167: examples that not only go far beyond the usual approach, but also
168: have already been accepted by the students as a part of their
169: everyday experience.
170:
171:
172:
173:
174:
175:
176:
177:
178:
179:
180:
181:
182:
183:
184:
185:
186:
187:
188: %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%
189: \section{Pseudoscience Flavor}
190:
191: An idea is named pseudoscientific if it contradicts accepted
192: scientific data, yet it is presented as scientific. We hasten to
193: avoid a possible misunderstanding. A mistake or error in the
194: presentation of a scientific fact does not signal pseudoscience;
195: in these cases the source of the mistake or error is limited or
196: due to incomplete knowledge and is not an intentional act. The
197: borderline of pseudoscience starts when misrepresentation of facts
198: or promotion of unverified claims are intentional. When it comes
199: down to movies, it is very hard to accuse the industry of
200: promoting pseudoscience in the guise of artistic freedom.
201: However, due to the great influence movies have on the
202: scientifically unsophisticated, we shall label (with our apologies
203: to the directors) movies that deal with topics that contradict
204: scientific facts as pseudoscientific.
205:
206: %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%
207: %%%% PSEUDOSCIENCE
208: %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%
209: \begin{figure}[h!]
210: \begin{center}
211: \includegraphics[width=1.5cm,height=2cm]{craft.eps}
212: \includegraphics[width=1.5cm,height=2cm]{signs.eps}
213: \includegraphics[width=1.5cm,height=2cm]{6thsense.eps}
214: \includegraphics[width=1.5cm,height=2cm]{dragonfly.eps}\\[1mm]
215: \includegraphics[width=1.5cm,height=2cm]{others.eps}
216: \includegraphics[width=1.5cm,height=2cm]{id.eps}
217: \includegraphics[width=1.5cm,height=2cm]{unbreakable.eps}
218: \includegraphics[width=1.5cm,height=2cm]{clockstoppers.eps}\\[1mm]
219: \includegraphics[width=1.5cm,height=2cm]{ring.eps}
220: \includegraphics[width=1.5cm,height=2cm]{dracula2000.eps}
221: \end{center}
222: \caption{Some of the films that are used in the
223: \textit{Pseudoscience} flavor of the course.}
224: \end{figure}
225: %
226:
227:
228: There are numerous examples of pseudoscience that may be discussed
229: in a class. However, within the schedule of a normal course only
230: a limited selection of topics is possible. In Summer 2003 we
231: taught a \textsf{Physical Science} class using the Pseudoscience
232: flavor and we chose topics that---we thought---the students would
233: find exciting and stimulating. The topics included:
234:
235: \begin{itemize}
236: \item intelligent life in the universe, alien visitors on Earth,
237: alien abductions;
238: \item fundamental interactions, ghosts;
239: \item universality of the physical laws, magic;
240: \item strength of materials, unbreakability;
241: \item time, time reversal, time stopping;
242: \item chemical reactions, zombies;
243: \item physiology of human body, crossing to afterlife.
244: \end{itemize}
245:
246:
247:
248: The instructors used clips from many Hollywood movies and
249: scientific documentaries. However, the required movies were:
250: \textsf{Clockstoppers}, \textsf{The Craft}, \textsf{Dragonfly},
251: \textsf{Independence Day}, \textsf{The Others}, \textsf{Signs},
252: \textsf{The Sixth Sense}, and \textsf{Unbreakable}.
253:
254: The texts for this course were a selection of popular readings
255: \cite{popular} in pseudoscience: \textsf{The Demon-Haunted World},
256: \textsf{Did Adam and Eve Have Navels}, \textsf{Fads \& Fallacies},
257: \textsf{Why People Believe Weird Things} and one book that
258: describes how science works \textsf{The Scientific Endeavor}
259: \cite{Lee}.
260:
261:
262: %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%
263: \begin{figure}[h!]
264: \begin{center}
265: \includegraphics[width=1.5cm,height=2cm]{SEndeavor.eps}
266: \includegraphics[width=1.5cm,height=2cm]{sagan.eps}
267: \includegraphics[width=1.5cm,height=2cm]{gardner1.eps}
268: \includegraphics[width=1.5cm,height=2cm]{gardner2.eps}\\[1mm]
269: \includegraphics[width=1.5cm,height=2cm]{shermer.eps}
270: \includegraphics[width=1.5cm,height=2cm]{charpak.eps}
271: \includegraphics[width=1.5cm,height=2cm]{darrow.eps}
272: \includegraphics[width=1.5cm,height=2cm]{hines.eps}\\[1mm]
273: \includegraphics[width=1.5cm,height=2cm]{stiebing.eps}
274: \includegraphics[width=1.5cm,height=2cm]{rothman.eps}
275: \end{center}
276: \caption{Books which have been used or will be used
277: as texts in the
278: \textit{Pseudoscience} flavor of the course.}
279: \end{figure}
280: %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%
281:
282: This summer we will teach the Pseudoscience flavor again (by the
283: time this conference is taking place, the class will be close to
284: its ending). \textsf{Dracula 2000} and \textsf{The Ring} will be
285: added to the required movies and several new texts \cite{texts2}
286: will be used and tested for their usefulness.
287:
288:
289:
290: \vspace{5mm}
291: \hrule \hrule
292:
293: \vspace{1mm}
294:
295: %\begin{center}
296: %\begin{minipage}{12cm}
297: \small
298: \noindent {\bfseries EXAMPLE}: Among the topics discussed in physical science
299: is the concept of temperature. Included are related topics of
300: heat transfer via conduction, convection, and radiation. The film
301: \textsf{The Sixth Sense} provides a background against which
302: temperature and heat transfer may be effectively discussed.
303:
304: \textsf{The Sixth Sense} is a film
305: concerned with ghosts. The movie consistently tells the viewer that ghosts
306: like low temperatures, although why that should be is not explained.
307: In \textit{Chapter 26: Someone's in the kitchen}, the scene
308: clearly shows a sudden drop in the room temperature, so one
309: expects the appearance of a ghost, and indeed one appears.
310:
311: \begin{figure}[h!]
312: \begin{center}
313: \includegraphics[width=5cm]{6thsense-pic1.eps}
314: \end{center}
315: \caption{In \textsf{The Sixth Sense}, the room temperature drops
316: before the appearance of a ghost. In this picture taken from the
317: motion picture, we see that the room thermostat has been set to
318: about $72^oF$ but the room temperature has dropped to $56^oF$.}
319: \end{figure}
320:
321: To get a hint concerning the possibility that the appearance of
322: ghosts is heralded by a sudden drop in temperature, we shall look
323: at a case studied by scientists.
324:
325: \begin{figure}[h!]
326: \begin{center}
327: \includegraphics[width=6cm]{Hampton-Court-Palace.eps}
328: \end{center}
329: \caption{Hampton Court Palace. The picture is borrowed from the
330: official site \cite{HCP}.}
331: \end{figure}
332:
333: In Hampton Court Palace \cite{HCP} near London, UK, there is a
334: well-known Haunted Gallery. It is said that the Gallery is stalked
335: by the spirit of Catherine Howard. Catherine Howard was the fifth
336: wife of King Henry VIII. King Henry executed her on February 13,
337: 1542 for her indecent life. Many visitors to the room have
338: described strange phenomena in the gallery such as hearing screams
339: and seeing apparitions. Due to many reports of such occurrences, a
340: team of psychologists, led by Richard Wiseman of Hertfordshire
341: University was called to investigate the claims
342: \cite{news1,news2}. The team installed in the Gallery thermal
343: cameras and air movement detectors. Then about 400 palace visitors
344: were asked if they could feel a ``presence" in the gallery. The
345: response was extraordinary: \textit{more than half reported sudden
346: drops in temperature and some said they sensed a ghostly presence.
347: Several people claimed to have seen Elizabethan figures}. The team
348: however discovered that the experiences could be simply explained
349: by the gallery's numerous old, concealed doors. These exits are
350: far from draught-proof and the combination of air currents which
351: they admit cause sudden changes in the room's temperature. In two
352: particular spots, the temperature of the gallery plummeted down to
353: $36^o F$.
354: %
355: \begin{figure}[h!]
356: \begin{center}
357: \includegraphics[width=6cm]{convectioncurrents.eps}
358: \end{center}
359: \caption{Convection currents are created in any fluid which is
360: kept in a non-uniform temperature. The greater the non-uniformity,
361: the stronger the currents. The picture is borrowed from
362: \cite{Bolemon}.}
363: \end{figure}
364: %
365: ``You do, literally, walk into a column of cold air sometimes,"
366: said Dr Wiseman. Convection is one of the three ways heat
367: propagates; the other two are conduction and radiation.
368: Convection appears in fluids that have a non-uniform distribution
369: of temperature. As a result, currents inside the fluid will be
370: such as to attempt to restore a uniform temperature. These
371: currents are stronger when the non-uniformity is greater. In the
372: case of the gallery rooms, the convection currents would be felt
373: as cold drafts, similar to those experienced by someone who opens
374: the door of a refrigerator a hot day in summer.
375:
376: Wiseman and his team have investigated other haunted places
377: besides Hampton Court Palace with similar results \cite{news2}.
378: Although, self-identified `psychics' claim that what people
379: experience is evidence of supernatural phenomena, physicists are
380: using Occham's razor to eliminate the possibility of anything
381: supernatural.
382:
383:
384:
385:
386: \normalsize
387: %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%
388:
389:
390: \vspace{1mm} \hrule \hrule
391:
392:
393: \vspace{5mm}
394:
395: The previous example describes the interweaving of supernatural
396: claims and physics briefly, but demonstrates how such topics may
397: be related to physics concepts. In the example, the common belief
398: that ghosts live in cold places provides the opportunity to
399: discuss temperature and heat transfer (among other physics
400: topics). Besides educating students about physics, the course
401: offers a unique opportunity to attack widely held
402: misunderstandings and misconceptions. We will report on the topic
403: of pseudoscience more thoroughly in the future.
404:
405:
406: \section{Scientists vs Pseudoscience}
407:
408: The majority of mainstream scientists avoid or ignore dealing with
409: pseudoscience. Some of the reasons used to explain this attitude
410: are tabulated by Friedman \cite{Friedman}:
411: \begin{itemize}
412: \item For whatever reason, people want to believe in pseudoscience;
413: therefore it is essentially a religion, and it is not the
414: business of science to criticize religious beliefs.
415: \item Pseudoscience is irrational; rational argument cannot counter it
416: successfully.
417: \item There might be something in the mass of
418: pseudoscience that is correct but at present unknown to science.
419: We would be foolish to attack pseudoscience, if even a tiny part of
420: it proves out.
421: \item Unlike creationism, astrology does not attack
422: science itself. Live and let live.
423: \item We have enough to do communicating science; there is no time to
424: attack false science or correct inaccurate perceptions about
425: the personalities of scientists.
426: \item We would dignify pseudoscience by mentioning it at all.
427: \end{itemize}
428: However, as scientists we have a moral obligation to society not
429: only to promote science for the well-being of humanity but also
430: for the well-being of the individual members of the society, too.
431: The following passage from Park (page 212 in \cite{Park})
432: summarizes this position well\footnote{Words printed in italics
433: may be replaced by those in the brackets.}:
434: \begin{center}
435: \begin{minipage}{2.8in}
436: \emph{Voodoo science} [pseudoscience] is a sort of background noise,
437: annoying, but rarely rising to a level that seriously interferes
438: with genuine scientific discourse... The more serious threat is to
439: the public, which is not often in a position to judge which claims
440: are real and which are \emph{voodoo} [not real]. Those who are
441: fortunate enough to have chosen science as a career have an
442: obligation to \emph{inform the public about voodoo science} [help
443: the public make the distinction].
444: \end{minipage}
445: \end{center}
446: Belief in pseudoscience indicates, besides lack of understanding
447: for the scientific method, lack of critical thinking and this is
448: dangerous for the science policy in the nations, dangerous for the
449: democracy, and dangerous for the believer. Who can forget the
450: bodies of the 39 cult members in Rancho Santa Fe, California who
451: committed suicide in the belief that a UFO shielded behind the
452: Halle-Bopp comet would take them to heaven?
453:
454: The question `who is responsible?' is hard to be answered. The
455: cause of this is quite complex and if we were to try to study it
456: carefully and thoroughly, we would be lost in a labyrinth of
457: intricate social, political, and economic factors. However, we
458: believe that the media, and in particular, the entertainment
459: industry, may be at least partially responsible for the large
460: numbers of people who believe in pseudoscience. There has been a
461: large number of very successful Hollywood films that have
462: glorified pseudoscientific topics such as astrology, extrasensory
463: perception, alien invasions and alien abductions, ancient
464: interstellar travellers, ghosts, etc. Unfortunately not everyone
465: perceives such films as entertaining fiction and often many people
466: have extrapolated the ideas to the everyday life. This, combined
467: with the passive attitude of the scientists described above, has
468: magnified the problem and the public science illiteracy seems to
469: grow.
470:
471: \textsf{Physics in Films} is a course that exactly attacks this
472: problem: the entertainment industry cannot present its ideas
473: unchallenged any more. Even more, the pseudoscientific topics are
474: paid special attention and a great effort is invested to help the
475: public make the distinction between science and pseudoscience.
476:
477:
478: \section{Student Perception}
479:
480: How do the students perceive the Pseudoscience flavor of the
481: \textsf{Physics in Films} course?
482: The instructors made
483: use in class of an electronic personal response system whereby
484: each student could respond immediately to questions posted by the
485: instructors, their responses being automatically recorded and
486: tabulated by an in-class computer. This system, besides its
487: pedagogical value for giving quizzes with immediate feedback and
488: scores, was used to obtain data on the student's feelings and
489: reactions to the course and to record attendance. The results for
490: few course-evaluation questions are shown in Tables
491: \ref{table:data1} through \ref{table:data3}. The notation in those
492: tables are as follows: SA=strongly agree, S=agree, NO=no opinion,
493: D=disagree, SD=strongly disagree.
494:
495:
496: %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%
497: % TOPICS FROM FILMS WERE WELL-CHOSEN
498: %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%
499: \begin{table}[h!]
500: \begin{center}
501: \begin{tabular}{|c|c|c|c|c|}\hline
502: %\multicolumn{5}{|c|}{PSEUDOSCIENCE CLASS} \\ \hline
503: SA & A & NO & D & SD \\ \hline
504: 42\% & 42\% & 16\% & 0\% & 0\% \\ \hline
505: \end{tabular}
506: \end{center}
507: \caption{Data on the question ``The topics selected from the
508: movies for physics analysis were interesting".}
509: \label{table:data1}
510: \end{table}
511: %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%
512:
513:
514:
515:
516:
517: %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%
518: % DATA FOR INSTRUCTORS SHOULD DEVELOP THE COURSE
519: %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%
520: \begin{table}[h!]
521: \begin{center}
522: \begin{tabular}{|c|c|c|c|c|}\hline
523: %\multicolumn{5}{|c|}{PSEUDOSCIENCE CLASS} \\ \hline
524: SA & A & NO & D & SD \\ \hline
525: 75\% & 20\% & 2\% & 0\% & 4\% \\ \hline
526: \end{tabular}
527: \end{center}
528: \caption{Data on the question ``The instructors should develop
529: this course further since it is more interesting than the standard
530: physical science course".}
531: \end{table}
532: %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%
533:
534:
535: %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%
536: % DATA FOR RECOMMENDING THE COURSE
537: %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%
538: \begin{table}[h!]
539: \begin{center}
540: \begin{tabular}{|c|c|c|c|c|}\hline
541: %\multicolumn{5}{|c|}{PSEUDOSCIENCE CLASS} \\ \hline
542: SA & A & NO & D & SD \\ \hline
543: 68\% & 25\% & 5\% & 2\% & 0\% \\ \hline
544: \end{tabular}
545: \end{center}
546: \caption{Data on the question ``I would recommend to my friends
547: that they take this course".}
548: \label{table:data3}
549: \end{table}
550: %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%
551:
552:
553:
554:
555:
556:
557:
558:
559:
560: %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%
561: \section{Where do we go from here?}
562:
563: Since we have been teaching \textsf{Physics in Films}, we have
564: made progress in improving student perceptions of physical
565: science: students no longer consider \textsf{Physical Science} to
566: be a waste of their time; they now feel that they learn something.
567: Their opinions are tabulated in Table \ref{table:data4}.
568:
569: %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%
570: \begin{table}[h!]
571: \begin{center}
572: \begin{tabular}{|c|c|c|c|c|}\hline
573: %\multicolumn{5}{|c|}{SUPERHERO CLASS} \\ \hline
574: SA & A & NO & D & SD \\ \hline
575: 60\% & 32\% & 5\% & 1\% & 2\% \\ \hline
576: \end{tabular}
577: \end{center}
578:
579: \caption{Data on the question ``I think I learned something from
580: this course".}
581: \label{table:data4}
582: \end{table}
583: %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%
584:
585: However, changing the public's overall perception of science is
586: not easy. More and longer term effort is necessary. Fear and
587: unreasonable dislike for science is deeply-rooted in the minds of
588: the students, as Table \ref{table:data5} illustrates.
589:
590: %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%
591: \begin{table}[h!]
592: \begin{center}
593: \begin{tabular}{|c|c|c|c|c|}\hline
594: %\multicolumn{5}{|c|}{SUPERHERO CLASS} \\ \hline
595: SA & A & NO & D & SD \\ \hline
596: 25\% & 26\% & 8\% & 18\% & 23\% \\ \hline
597: \end{tabular}
598: \end{center}
599:
600: \caption{Data on the question ``I do not like science and I do not
601: want to read anything on science once I am done with this course".}
602: \label{table:data5}
603: \end{table}
604: %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%
605:
606: On the strength of the positive results from the course
607: \textsf{Physics in Films} we believe we may have found a way to
608: address the problem of low scientific literacy among the public,
609: in general, and the abysmally low interest in physical science
610: among college non-science majors, in particular. Among all
611: flavors, the \textsf{Pseudoscience} is distinctly viewed by the
612: students as by far the most exciting and it thus presents a unique
613: tool to facilitate science literacy. We plan to continue to
614: develop the course, explore its application to other science
615: disciplines, and find ways to disseminate it to interested
616: instructors throughout the nation.
617:
618:
619: %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%
620: \begin{thebibliography}{10}
621: %\small
622: \bibitem{EL}
623: \textit{Physics in Films: A New Approach to Teaching Science},
624: \textsc{C.E. Efthimiou, R. Llewellyn}, in the proceedings of
625: EISTA '03.
626: %An updated and slightly expanded version will appear
627: %in Volume 2, Issue 1 of the \textit{Journal of Systemics, Cybernetics
628: %and Informatics}.
629: See also, \textit{Physical Science: a revitalization of the traditional
630: course by avatars of Hollywood in the physics classroom},
631: \textsc{C.E. Efthimiou, R. Llewellyn},
632: \texttt{http://www.arXiv.org/physics/0303005}.
633:
634: \bibitem{success}
635: \textsc{Lee Chow},
636: \textit{Cinema as Physics Lesson},
637: Phys. Today {\bfseries 56} (2003) 15;
638: \texttt{http://www.physicstoday.org/vol-56/iss-5/}
639: \texttt{p15a.html}.
640: \textit{Physics In Films},
641: in the March 2003 APS News;
642: \texttt{http://www.aps.org/apsnews/0303/030306.h}
643: \texttt{tml}.
644: \textsc{B. Dume},
645: \textit{Physics Goes to Hollywood},
646: \texttt{http://www.ioppublishing.com/news/739}.
647: \textsc{A. Witze},
648: \textit{Physics lessons with impact: Using movies to teach concepts reduces
649: fear factor, professors find},
650: \textsf{Dallas Morning News}, issue of 5/10/04;
651: \texttt{http://www.dallasnews.com/sharedcontent/}
652: \texttt{dws/fea/texasliving/stories/051004dnliv}
653: \texttt{physicsfilms.18dfb.html}.
654:
655:
656: \bibitem{UCFFuture}
657: \textsf{Alexis Graham},
658: \textit{A little bit of Hollywood, a lot of Physics},
659: \textsf{The Central Florida Future}, issue of 10/3/2002;
660: \texttt{http://www.ucffuture.com/main.cfm?includ}
661: \texttt{e=detail\&storyid=328832}.
662: \textsc{Trina Priore},
663: \textit{With Great Power Comes a Physical Explanation: action films teach students the laws
664: of physics},
665: \textsf{The Central Florida Future}, issue of 5/21/2003;
666: \texttt{http://www.ucffuture.com/news/436180.html}
667: \texttt{\&mkey=724230}.
668: \textsc{Cary Grayson},
669: \textit{Students play games, watch movies, raise grades},
670: \textsf{The Central Florida Future}, issue of 11/21/2002;
671: \texttt{http://www.ucffuture.com/news/436180.html}
672: \texttt{\&mkey=724230}.
673:
674:
675: \bibitem{popular}
676: \textsc{Carl Sagan}, \textsf{The Demon-Haunted World},
677: Ballantine books 1997.
678: \textsc{Martin Gardner}, \textsf{Did Adam and Eve Have Navels?},
679: W.W. Norton 2000.
680: \textsc{Martin Gardner}, \textsf{Fads \& Fallacies},
681: Dover 1957.
682: \textsc{Michael Shermer}, \textsf{Why People Believe Weird Things},
683: Owl Books 2002.
684:
685: \bibitem{Lee}
686: \textsc{Jeffrey A. Lee}, \textsf{The Scientific Endeavor},
687: Benjamin/Cummings 2000.
688:
689: \bibitem{texts2}
690: \textsc{Terence Hines}, \textsf{Pseudoscience and the
691: Paranormal}, 2nd ed,
692: Prometheus Books 2003.
693: \textsc{Milton Rothman}, \textsf{A Physicists' Guide to Skepticism},
694: Prometheus Books 1988.
695: \textsc{Georges Charpak, Henri Broch}, \textsf{Debunked}
696: Johns Hopkins University Press 2004.
697: \textsc{William Stiebing}, \textsf{Ancient Astronauts, Cosmic Collisions},
698: Prometheus Books 1984.
699: \textsc{Clarence Darrow}, \textsf{Why I am an Agnostic}
700: Prometheus Books 1994.
701:
702: \bibitem{HCP}
703: \texttt{http://www.hrp.org.uk/webcode/hampton\_hom}
704: \texttt{e.asp}
705: \bibitem{news1}
706: \texttt{http://www.ananova.com/news/story/sm\_258}
707: \texttt{288.html}
708: \bibitem{news2}
709: \textsc{A. Frood}, \textit{Ghosts 'all in the mind'}, BBC
710: News,\\
711: \texttt{http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/sci/tech/3044}
712: \texttt{607.stm}
713:
714: \bibitem{Bolemon}
715: \textsc{Jay Bolemon}, \textsf{A Window to Our World},
716: McGraw-Hill 2002.
717:
718: \bibitem{Friedman}
719: \textsc{Alan J. Friedman}, \textsf{The Influence of
720: Pseudoscience, Parascience and Science Fiction},
721: in \textsf{Communicating Science to the Public},
722: Ciba Foundation Conference Proceedings, Wiley 1987.
723:
724: \bibitem{Park}
725: \textsc{Robert Park}, \textsf{Voodoo Science: the Road
726: from Foolishness to Fraud}, Oxford Universiy Press 2001.
727:
728: \end{thebibliography}
729:
730:
731: \end{document}
732: