1: %---------------------------- HIPh-template.tex --------------------------
2: %
3: \documentstyle[hip-artc]{article}
4: % -----------------------------------------------------------------------%|
5: % Template TeX file for %|
6: % %|
7: % Acta Physica Hungarica, N.S. %|
8: % %|
9: % Heavy Ion Physics %|
10: % %|
11: % Please, keep this header when composing your own TeX source. %|
12: % %|
13: \volnumber{15} \edyear{2002} \frompage{000} \topage{000} %|
14: \recrevdate{15 November 2002} %|
15: %________________________________________________________________________%|
16: \def\rightmark{Wigner Functions in High Energy Physics}
17: \def\leftmark{T. Cs\"org\H{o}}
18: \newcommand{\fsp}[2]{\epsfysize=#1 \epsfbox{#2}}
19: \title{Wigner Functions in High Energy Physics}
20: \authors{\twerm
21: %
22: {T. Cs\"org\H{o}$^1$ %
23: \index{{\tt csorgo@sunserv.kfki.hu} .
24: \rm Dedicated to the memories of Gy. Marx and E. P. Wigner}
25: }\\[2.812mm]
26: {\normalsize
27: \hspace*{-8pt}$^1$ MTA KFKI RMKI, \\
28: H - 1525 Budapest 114, POBox 49, Hungary\\[0.2ex]
29: %
30: }}
31:
32: \abstract{Recent developments are (meta)reviewed in the applications of
33: Wigner functions to describe the observed single particle spectra and
34: two-particle Bose-Einstein (or Hanbury Brown -- Twiss) correlations
35: in high energy particle and nuclear physics, with examples from
36: hadron-proton and Pb + Pb collisions at CERN SPS.
37: }
38: \keyword{particle correlations, elementary particle and heavy ion
39: induced reactions, quantum statistics}
40: \PACS{12.40.Ee, 13.38.Be, 12.38.Mh, 25.75.Gz, 25.75.Nq}
41:
42: \makeindex
43: \begin{document}
44:
45: \maketitle
46: %\setcounter{page}{1}
47:
48: \section{Introduction}\label{intro}
49: High energy physics attempts to determine what are the most basic constituents
50: of matter and how these most elementary forms of matter interact
51: with each other. The method to achieve this goal is to build
52: accelerators at the highest awailable energies. High energy particle physics
53: studies the collisions of elementary particles and attempts to determine
54: the interaction between as few particles as possible.
55: High energy heavy ion physics attempts to create a new medium with the
56: highest currently available volumes and energy densities so that
57: the in-medium interactions of the elementary particles could be
58: determined. These studies can be utilized to learn about the
59: form of matter in the first few microseconds of the early Universe
60: as well as about the behaviour of matter in the center of dense (neutron)
61: stars.
62:
63: Why are Wigner functions applied in high energy physics?
64: Wigner functions are quantum analogies of the classical
65: phase-space distributions.
66: In conventional field theory, e.g. perturbative QCD,
67: the calculation of the momentum distributions of the observable
68: multi-particle final state can be performed in momentum space only.
69: Usually, a description using Wigner functions
70: can be equivalently rewritten into a calculation in momentum space, too.
71: In some cases, the properties the phase space description becomes important
72: in high energy physics. Currently, such important topics are
73: the search for new states of matter in high energy heavy
74: ion collisions using correlation techniques~\cite{panitkin-rev},
75: and the precise determination
76: of the mass of the W-boson in $e^+e^-$ annihilation at LEP~\cite{leif}.
77: In the first case, a new state of strongly
78: interacting matter is searched for, where quarks and gluons
79: are deconfined, not bound into the usual hardonic states. Theoretical
80: calculations suggest~\cite{fodor-katz} that a new phase of matter can
81: be reached if the temperature, or, the energy density can be
82: sufficiently high, ($T \ge 170$) MeV, at the currently reached finite net
83: baryon densities. The temperature, the energy and the baryon density
84: are local variables, they depend on the phase space evolution of the
85: matter (and of course on the applicability of statistical and
86: thermodynamical concepts in high energy heavy ion collisions).
87: In case of the $W$-mass reconstruction in $e^+e^-$ collisions at LEP2,
88: the aim is to decrease the error on the estimate that comes from the
89: invariant mass estimates of 4-jet decays. However, Bose-Einstein
90: symmetrization effects may introduce a non-perturbative ``cross-talk"
91: between the jets\cite{leif}. Hence pions that come from the decay of the $W^+$
92: may prefer to appear with momenta close to that of another like-charged
93: pion from the decay of the $W^-$, due to the bosonic nature of the pions.
94: Calculations suggested that this modification of the momentum distribution
95: may result is a systematic error as big as 100 MeV in the reconstructed
96: $W$ mass, which is the biggest systematic error on this observable and
97: should be reduced to reach the expected level~\cite{kittel-prev}.
98: However, the most recent paper by the L3 collaboration finds no evidence for
99: inter-W Bose-Einstein correlation effect in fully hadronic W decays
100: at LEP2~\cite{L3-interW}.
101:
102: Quantum-statistical correlations are observed
103: in high energy particle physics in all kind of particle reactions
104: ranging from the ``most elementary" $e^+ e^-$ reactions, see e.g.\cite{epem}
105: through hadron-proton reactions, see e.g.~\cite{hp},
106: to the ``most complex" heavy ion reactions, (see ref.~\cite{AA}
107: for a recent summary of the data),
108: essentially in all experimentally accessible energy regions.
109: These quantum-statistical correlations are correlations of
110: intensities of particles, and they are attributed to either the
111: Bose-Einstein statistics of meson pairs, or, to the Fermi-Dirac statistics
112: of the baryons. These statistics are dependent, in turn, on the
113: phase-space densities of particles, so it is not a surprise,
114: that Wigner functions turn out to be fundamental when one attemts
115: to describe the experimentally measured two-, three- or higher order
116: intensity correlations. As this note is very brief and attempts only
117: to create a narrow bridge between the current quantum optical studies
118: and the theory and experiment dealing with quantum statistical correlations
119: and Wigner functions in high energy physics, let us quote some of
120: the more detailed recent reviews in the
121: field~\cite{AA,kittel-prev,cs-rev,weiner,uli-urs,lorstad,zajc}.
122:
123: %\section{Basic concepts}\label{techno}
124:
125:
126:
127: \begin{figure}[htb]
128: \begin{center}
129: \fbox{\ \fsp{3.6in}{summ-s4.eps} }
130: \caption[summ-s3.eps]{This figure shows some structures in the Wigner function $S(x,k)$
131: when integrated over the momentum, and plotted as a function of the $(t,r_z)$ temporal and
132: longitudinal as well as in the $(r_x, r_y)$ transverse coordinates.
133: Till now, non-Gaussian structure of Wigner functions
134: has been reconstructed in the transverse distribution
135: of hadron-proton reactions at CERN SPS energies only, ref.~\cite{cs-rev}.}
136: \label{summ-s3.eps}
137: \end{center}
138: \vspace*{-1.0cm}
139: \end{figure}
140:
141: %\section{Conclusions}\label{concl}
142: Thus Wigner functions have a broad application in the theory and experiment
143: of high energy physics, as they provide a natural tool to model these
144: reactions in terms of phase space distritubutions.
145: In particular, they are very popular in describing quantum statistical
146: correlations (Bose-Einstein or Fermi-Dirac correlations) of the emitted
147: particles. Currently, Gaussian models dominate~\cite{uli-urs}, and the coupling
148: between the coordinate space and the momentum space distributions
149: is frequently modelled with the help of hydrodynamics~\cite{cs-rev}.
150: State of art
151: results attempt to quantify and to characterize the deviations from Gaussian
152: structure.
153: Shell of fire type of structures have been reconstructed
154: in the transverse coordinate distribution in hadron-proton
155: reactions~\cite{cs-rev},
156: and significant non-Gaussian correlation functions were found in $e^+ e^-$ and
157: hadron-proton reactions~\cite{kittel-prev}. Till now, non-Gaussian structure
158: of the Wigner-function has been reconstructed in $h+p$ reactions
159: only,~\cite{cs-rev}.
160: The current analysis of correlation data in high energy
161: heavy ion physics is confined to the Gaussian approximation, possible
162: more detailed structures (e.g. binary sources~\cite{binary}) have not
163: yet been searched for, in this branch.
164:
165: The Wigner function formalism has been extended
166: not only to thermal, or, in the quantum statistical sense, chaotic
167: sources, but also to coherent particle emitting sources, for example,
168: the pion laser model~\cite{plaser}. In discussions of in-medium hadron
169: mass modification, two-mode squeezed states of hadrons were studied
170: in terms of Wigner functions, both for bosons~\cite{bbc} and
171: for fermions~\cite{fbbc}. In principle, squeezing
172: appears in these papers due to sudden disintegration of a medium
173: where particles propagate with modified mass, so the situation
174: is very similar to the one considered in quantum optics
175: in ref.~\cite{Adam-Janszky}. The only essential difference is that
176: the field theoretical formulation results in two-mode squeezed states,
177: hence quanta with opposite momenta and opposite quantum numbers will
178: be correlated. Wigner functions appear in the formalism because the
179: strenght and the width of these back-to-back correlations
180: depends on the phase-space distribution of quanta in the
181: mass-modified medium~\cite{bbc,fbbc}.
182:
183:
184:
185: From a broader perspective, it seems that Wigner functions will be
186: indispensable tools in high energy physics as long as
187: effects sensitive to the phase-space evolution of these reactions
188: will be investigated.
189:
190:
191: %\section*{Acknowledgement(s)}
192: This work was partially
193: supported by an
194: by OTKA grants T038406, T034269 and T029158
195: and by the {MTA-OTKA-NSF} grant {INT0098462}.
196:
197: %\section*{Notes}
198: \begin{notes}
199: \item[a]
200: E-mail: csorgo@sunserv.kfki.hu
201: \item[b]
202: Dedicated to the memories of Gy. Marx and E. P. Wigner.
203: \end{notes}
204:
205:
206: \begin{thebibliography}{99}
207: \bibitem{panitkin-rev}
208: S.~Y.~Panitkin,
209: %``HBT and fluctuations: Recent results,''
210: {\it Nucl.\ Phys.\ A} {\bf 698} (2002) 323
211: %[arXiv:nucl-ex/0106018].
212: %%CITATION = NUCL-EX 0106018;%%
213:
214: \bibitem{leif}
215: %\cite{Lonnblad:1995mr}
216: %\bibitem{Lonnblad:1995mr}
217: L.~L\"onnblad and T.~Sj\"ostrand,
218: %``Bose-Einstein effects and W mass determinations,''
219: {\it Phys.\ Lett.\ B} {\bf 351} (1995) 293.\\
220: %%CITATION = PHLTA,B351,293;%%
221: %\cite{Lonnblad:1997kk}
222: %\bibitem{Lonnblad:1997kk}
223: L.~L\"onnblad and T.~Sj\"ostrand,
224: %``Modelling Bose-Einstein correlations at LEP 2,''
225: {\it Eur.\ Phys.\ J.\ C }{\bf 2} (1998) 165
226: %%[arXiv:hep-ph/9711460].
227: %%CITATION = HEP-PH 9711460;%%
228:
229: \bibitem{fodor-katz}
230: Z.~Fodor and S.~D.~Katz,
231: %``Lattice determination of the critical point of QCD at finite T and mu,''
232: {\it JHEP} {\bf 0203} (2002) 014
233: %%[arXiv:hep-lat/0106002].
234: %%CITATION = HEP-LAT 0106002;%%
235:
236: \bibitem{kittel-prev}
237: W. Kittel, %[arXiv:hep-ph/9905394] \\
238: W.~Kittel,
239: %``Bose-Einstein correlations in Z fragmentation and other reactions,''
240: {\it Acta Phys.\ Polon.\ B }{\bf 32} (2001) 3927
241: %[arXiv:hep-ph/0110088].
242: %%CITATION = HEP-PH 0110088;%%
243:
244: \bibitem{cs-rev}
245: T. Cs\"org\H{o},
246: {\it Heavy Ion Phys.} {\bf 15} (2002) 1-80
247: %[arXiv:hep-ph/0001233]
248:
249: \bibitem{weiner}
250: R.~M.~Weiner,
251: %``Boson interferometry in high energy physics,''
252: {\it Phys.\ Rept. } {\bf 327} (2000) 249
253: %[arXiv:hep-ph/9904389].
254: %%CITATION = HEP-PH 9904389;%%
255:
256: \bibitem{uli-urs}
257: U.~A.~Wiedemann and U.~W.~Heinz,
258: %``Particle interferometry for relativistic heavy-ion collisions,''
259: {\it Phys.\ Rept.\ }{\bf 319} (1999) 145
260: %[arXiv:nucl-th/9901094].
261: %%CITATION = NUCL-TH 9901094;%%
262:
263: \bibitem{lorstad}
264: B.~L\"orstad,
265: %``Boson Interferometry - A Review Of High-Energy Data And Its Interpretation,''
266: {\it Int.\ J.\ Mod.\ Phys.\ A} {\bf 4} (1989) 2861.
267: %%CITATION = IMPAE,A4,2861;%%
268:
269: \bibitem{zajc}
270: W.~A.~Zajc,
271: %``A Pedestrian's Guide To Interferometry,''
272: %\href{http://www.slac.stanford.edu/spires/find/hep/www?irn=4036085}{SPIRES entry}
273: {\it Proc. NATO Advanced Study Institute on Particle Production in Highly Excited Matter, Castelvecchio Pascoli, Italy, 12-24 Jul 1992}
274:
275: \bibitem{binary}
276: T. Cs\"org\H{o},
277: %``Particle interferometry, binary sources and oscillations in two-particle correlations,''
278: Nucl.\ Phys.\ Proc.\ Suppl.\ {\bf 92} (2001) 223
279: [arXiv:hep-ph/0011320].
280: %%CITATION = HEP-PH 0011320;%%
281:
282: \bibitem{L3-interW}
283: P. Achard et al, L3 Collaboration, {\it Phys. Lett}
284: {\bf B547} (2002) 139-150
285:
286: \bibitem{epem}
287: P.~Abreu {\it et al.} [DELPHI Collaboration],
288: %``Two-dimensional analysis of the Bose-Einstein correlations in e+ e- annihilation at the Z0 peak,''
289: {\it Phys.\ Lett.\ B} {\bf 471} (2000) 460.
290: %%CITATION = PHLTA,B471,460;%%
291:
292: \bibitem{hp}
293: N.~M.~Agababian {\it et al.} [NA22 Collaboration],
294: %``Estimation of hydrodynamical model parameters from the invariant spectrum and the Bose-Einstein correlations of pi- mesons produced in (pi+/K+) p interactions at 250-GeV/c,''
295: {\it Phys.\ Lett.\ B} {\bf 422} (1998) 359
296: %[arXiv:hep-ex/9711009].
297: %%CITATION = HEP-EX 9711009;%%
298:
299: \bibitem{AA}
300: B.~Tomasik and U.~A.~Wiedemann,
301: %``Central and non-central HBT from AGS to RHIC,''
302: arXiv:hep-ph/0210250.
303: %%CITATION = HEP-PH 0210250;%%
304:
305: \bibitem{plaser}
306: S.~Pratt,
307: %``Pion Lasers From High-Energy Collisions,''
308: {\it Phys.\ Lett.\ B} {\bf 301} (1993) 159.
309: %%CITATION = PHLTA,B301,159;%%
310:
311: \bibitem{cstjz}
312: T.~Cs\"org\H{o} and J.~Zim\'anyi,
313: %``Analytic solution of the pion-laser model,''
314: {\it Phys.\ Rev.\ Lett.\ } {\bf 80} (1998) 916
315: %[arXiv:hep-ph/9705433].
316: %%CITATION = HEP-PH 9705433;%%
317:
318: \bibitem{jzcst}
319: J.~Zim\'anyi and T.~Cs\"org\H{o},
320: %``Multi-boson correlations using wave-packets. I: Exact results,''
321: {\it Heavy Ion Phys.\ } {\bf 9} (1999) 241
322: %[arXiv:hep-ph/9705432].
323: %%CITATION = HEP-PH 9705432;%%
324:
325: \bibitem{tau}
326: T.~Cs\"org\H{o} and J.~Zim\'anyi,
327: %``Pion Interferometry For Strongly Correlated Space-Time And Momentum Space,''
328: {\it Nucl.\ Phys.\ A }{\bf 517} (1990) 588.
329: %%CITATION = NUPHA,A517,588;%%
330:
331: \bibitem{bbc}
332: M.~Asakawa, T.~Cs\"org\H{o} and M.~Gyulassy,
333: %``Squeezed correlations and spectra for mass-shifted bosons,''
334: {\it Phys.\ Rev.\ Lett.\ } {\bf 83} (1999) 4013
335: %[arXiv:nucl-th/9810034].
336: %%CITATION = NUCL-TH 9810034;%%
337:
338: M.~Asakawa, T.~Cs\"org\H{o} and M.~Gyulassy,
339: %``Back-to-back correlations for bosons modified by medium,''
340: {\it Nucl.\ Phys.\ A} {\bf 661} (1999) 423
341: %[arXiv:nucl-th/9907089].
342: %%CITATION = NUCL-TH 9907089;%%
343:
344:
345: \bibitem{fbbc}
346: P. K. Panda, {\it et al.}
347: % T.~Cs\"org\H{o}, Y.~Hama, G.~Krein and S.~S.~Padula,
348: %``Squeezed fermions at relativistic heavy ion collider,''
349: {\it Phys.\ Lett.\ B} {\bf 512} (2001) 49
350: %[arXiv:hep-ph/0006048].
351: %%CITATION = HEP-PH 0006048;%%
352:
353:
354: \bibitem{Adam-Janszky}
355: P. \'Ad\'am and J. Janszky,
356: {\it Phys. Rev.} {\bf A50} (1994) 3548-3550 \\
357: P. \'Ad\'am and J. Janszky,
358: {\it Phys. Rev.} {\bf A46} (1992) 6091-6092.
359:
360: \end{thebibliography}
361: \vfill\eject
362: \end{document}
363: Experimentally, one can observe the type and number distribution of particles,
364: the distribution of particles in momentum space, and the correlations between
365: these particles.
366: $
367: <a_1^ +a_2^+ a_2 a_1> = <11><22> + <12><21> \\
368: <12> = Wigner function!
369: $
370:
371: Various views: Wilson loops, event generators, hydrodynamical models.
372:
373: Show some fit results
374:
375: Some density and spectra
376:
377: Calculate Wigner functions for the hydro parameterizations!
378:
379: